You are here
News Feeds
WIN: California Voters Reject Proposition 43 to Keep Citizen-Led Tax Measures Accessible
UPDATE: Californians rejected Proposition 43 at the ballot boxes, with 57.5% of voters saying NO.
Proposition 43 would make it much more difficult for Bay Area communities to fund the things we need to thrive: measures to build affordable housing, to protect our open spaces, and to fund the transit systems that keep our region moving, by raising the threshold for citizen-initiated local special tax measures from a simple majority to two-thirds. Greenbelt Alliance strongly opposed Prop 43. Learn more about the campaign here.
Under Prop 43, passing these measures would require a whopping 66.67% supermajority of the vote instead of the regular 50% + 1. A minority of voters could block investments that most of their neighbors support, including efforts to conserve open space, protect farmland, and expand our public transit systems, among others.
Recent examples show the importance of keeping special tax measures accessible. Consider Measure D in Santa Clara County, for example, which funds the protection and restoration of waterways and open spaces. Or, the regional transit measure, Connect Bay Area, or Measure H in San Francisco, which funds MUNI, and the recently approved Sonoma-Marin transit measure. In each case, people took funding for the places and services they rely on directly to the ballot.
California already has significant voter protections around local taxes. We should not make it even harder for communities to fund the parks, trails, and open spaces they value or the affordable housing, transit systems, and safer streets they need. If a majority of voters support a locally proposed measure, a minority should not be able to veto it.
Local voters should have the power to decide how to invest in their communities. Greenbelt Alliance celebrates that voters in California said NO to Prop 43.
Updated on November 12, 2026. Originally published on September 24, 2026.
The post WIN: California Voters Reject Proposition 43 to Keep Citizen-Led Tax Measures Accessible appeared first on Greenbelt Alliance.
Push for ocean roadmap that informs next global stocktake grows at COP31
A coalition of small island states, African countries, the European Union and other G20 nations is leading a push at COP31 in Antalya for a process that can deliver stronger ocean mandates in a key review of climate policies in 2028.
The group of countries is seeking to anchor the sprawling ocean agenda — which ranges from decarbonising transport and energy, adaptation of tourism and fisheries, and loss and damage — into the formal UN negotiations.
This year’s COP31 offers them a prime opportunity, experts say, as the Turkish and Australian co-presidency has signaled its intention to put oceans high in the summit’s agenda.
The ocean is the world’s largest carbon sink and it has absorbed 93% of excess heat in the atmosphere. An extreme El Niño event this year has led to record-breaking temperatures of over 30℃ in some parts of the Pacific, placing coastal communities and fisheries at risk.
While some initiatives have emerged to strengthen the ocean’s role in national climate plans, at formal UN negotiations it has been sidelined to a voluntary dialogue with no negotiated agreements.
Strong backing for ocean outcome in AntalyaA key battleground is whether to kickstart a process at COP31 that would seek a strong reference to oceans in the next global stocktake of climate policies in 2028.
The Ocean Dialogue, established in 2021 and made annual in 2023, is currently the only space within the UN climate process that takes stock on ocean issues. Delegates met in June in Bonn, and also called for more integration of the ocean into climate talks.
On Wednesday at an UN-organised side event to mark the wrap up of this year’s Ocean Dialogue, there was a clearer consensus on the idea of linking this technical space with the broader process.
Speaking on behalf of the AOSIS group of 39 island states, Carlos Varela, Cabo Verde’s environment minister, asked for a “multi-year plan” that would “connect the outcomes of the dialogue with the Paris Agreement ambition cycle, including the second Global Stocktake.”
Indonesia, Niue on behalf of Pacific island states, the European Union, Indonesia and and Ghana on behalf of the African Group of Negotiators (AGN) all explicitly supported a multi-year roadmap aligned with the Paris Agreement, and Brazil stated that they “saw value” in this idea. No country in the room spoke against it.
Marine Lecerf, head of International Policy at the Ocean & Climate Platform, told Climate Home she could “see this land in the cover decision”, this year’s main negotiated agreement.
She said a proposal for an ocean roadmap linked to the next global stocktake is the one that “received the most consensus”, but that, if the cover decision becomes a “Christmas list”, there is a risk that the presidency decides to leave it out.
However, Lecerf said this is a more promising year, and explained that some heads of delegations have already told the COP31 presidency that the ocean is a priority for them, and both Türkiye and Australia seem on board.
Sea weed is grown or farmed in the shallow waters of the Indian Ocean, off Wasini Island, Kenya, with plants tied to ropes in the water. (Photo: Anthony Onyango / Climate Visuals) Strengthening ‘blue’ climate plansAnother initiative mentioned as part of the ocean dialogue is for countries to “enhance climate ambition through ocean-based priorities in NDCs”, which is currently not a mandate they must follow.
France and Brazil have led a voluntary initiative called the Blue NDC Challenge seeking to incentivise more countries to include ‘blue plans’ in their nationally determined contributions (NDCs). Seventeen countries have joined the initiative so far.
In the push to make NDCs more blue, “some countries are arguing that it is too prescriptive to include a specific sector or specific type of ecosystem,” Lecerf said. “It’s a minority, but it’s something we’ve been hearing.”
90% of island and coastal nations include at least one ocean action in their latest round of NDCs, up from 73% in the previous round, which shows movement in the right direction, said Jonathan Baines, ocean programme manager at the World Resources Institute (WRI).
But these are very focused on climate impacts to coastal communities and on managing protected areas, but only 12% of commitments were related to offshore energy, shipping and aquatic food systems, the WRI analysis shows.
Still, this was a rise from the previous round, and “a very welcome broadening of those mitigation efforts, with maritime transport emerging alongside marine conservation as a major priority for cutting emissions,” he explained.
Other proposals mentioned at the UN event included focusing on ramping up blue finance, as well as steering the Green Climate Fund (GCF) towards and increased focus on ocean projects.
‘Blue COP31’ set to spotlight need for ocean protections amid record heat
Fossil fuels still the elephant in the roomNo country has made pledges to phase out offshore oil and gas, which Colombia’s former environment minister Irene Vélez Torres pointed as a key omission.
“COP31 can’t have a credible ocean agenda while ignoring what is being drilled and mined beneath the waves,” she told Climate Home News.
Offshore extraction dominates fossil fuel growth, with 85% of new discoveries and 71% of new projects found at sea. “COP31 should make the ocean a frontline of the transition away from fossil fuels, not a new frontier for their expansion,” said Vélez.
Mona Ainu’u, minister for Natural Resources from the Pacific island of Niue, told Climate Home News that the increased fossil fuel production and scarce climate finance is devastating for small island states like hers.
A November report by Zero Carbon Analytics found that barely 2% of the nearly $550 bn needed for the blue economy is reaching the ocean.
“I left my home four days ago to be here,” Ainu’u said. “El Niño did a really bad job this year, and everything is just dying.”
Speaking on behalf of Pacific island states at the event, she explained that access to finance is lacking for “large ocean states” that want to implement solutions.
“We can’t just be waiting because all this talk and it’s all positive and it’s all good and it’s all nice and theory-like”, said Ainu’u. “But eventually, when we leave COP, we wait for years to receive any support.”
The post Push for ocean roadmap that informs next global stocktake grows at COP31 appeared first on Climate Home News.
WIN: San Francisco Passes Measure H To Keep Muni Going Strong
UPDATE: Measure H in San Francisco passed with 74% of the votes, well above the 50% required threshold. This is a huge win for transit and climate advocates!
Measure H, or Stronger Muni for All, is focused on providing financial support for public transit in San Francisco and preventing a once-in-a-generation funding crisis. The Measure will address Muni’s major annual deficit of over $300 million and ensure that the agency is safe, reliable, and affordable. Not that voters have approved it, Measure H will establish a fair tiered parcel tax that charges 95% of single-family residences a flat $129 annual fee. Larger homes would pay progressively more, and the largest commercial properties would pay up to $400,000 annually. This ensures that average San Franciscans are not burdened by higher taxes while the largest properties pay the most.
Greenbelt Alliance recommended that voters say YES to Measure H and joined a coalition of organizations such as Transform, SF Transit Riders, and the Sierra Club. Because a healthy, resilient, interconnected, and sustainable future necessitates a strong public transit system.
This ballot measure was complementary to the also successful Regional Transit Measure (RTM)‘s goals and will support the region by significantly reducing traffic congestion, reducing greenhouse gas emissions, and protecting downtown and citywide economic recovery.
Updated on November 12, 2026. Originally published on September 24, 2026.
Photo: L Taraval shuttle bus during Twin Peaks Tunnel construction. By Pi.1415926535 – Own work, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=69525140
The post WIN: San Francisco Passes Measure H To Keep Muni Going Strong appeared first on Greenbelt Alliance.
WIN: Voters Says YES to Measure U and To More Homes in Walnut Creek
Update: Measure U in Walnut Creek is well on its way to victory. While we await official results, Measure U passed with over 70% of the votes, showing strong support for the measure.
Measure U proposes updating zoning in Downtown Walnut Creek to allow for more than 200 high-quality senior homes on a transit-oriented site near the Walnut Creek BART station. The rezoning will create an opportunity to address the city’s growing need for senior housing while allowing residents to remain close to family, friends, healthcare, shopping, and other community services as they age.
Learn more about the Measure U campaign here.
The initiative would also support a mixed-use approach with community-serving retail and food-oriented businesses, creating a more vibrant and walkable downtown while supporting local businesses. By directing new housing to an area already served by BART, the initiative advances smart, sustainable growth and makes it easier for seniors to maintain mobility and independence without relying solely on a car. Greenbelt Alliance is joined by East Bay YIMBY and Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California in endorsing YES on the measure.
As an organization whose mission is to educate, advocate, and collaborate to ensure the Bay Area’s lands and communities are resilient to a changing climate, we know that infill development is critical to achieving this vision. Measure U advances the kind of sustainable, transit-oriented development that makes the Bay Area livable for everyone. Supporting senior housing in downtown Walnut Creek means a more vibrant community and a healthier environment.
We encouraged voters to say YES on Measure U to create a more vibrant and walkable downtown in Walnut Creek, and they showed up!
Updated on November 12, 2026. Originally published on September 28, 2026.
The post WIN: Voters Says YES to Measure U and To More Homes in Walnut Creek appeared first on Greenbelt Alliance.
Around 400 onshore wind projects await DOD action, official tells court
Assistant Secretary of Defense Dale Marks told a federal court that the Pentagon doesn’t have enough staff to review permits. A coalition suing DOD says the process ground “to a halt” after Marks was confirmed.
Community Leaders Speak Out Against BAAJA Permitting Bill
The Senate voted Monday (25-73) to start debate on a bill that violates Tribal sovereignty and robs communities of their right to have a voice in what happens to the land, air, and water in their homes. This bill is a last-ditch effort to trade away our basic rights and environmental protections before the new Congress is sworn in.
The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) fast-tracks mining, fossil fuel, and Big Tech projects while gutting local public input, environmental reviews, and Tribal consultation rights. It also gives away unlimited public lands to mining companies for waste dumps and infrastructure.
EMAIL YOUR SENATORS NOWPeople living on the frontlines of oil, gas, petrochemical, and mining pollution in this country need protections, not concessions. This bill would cause real and lasting harm and make it harder to defend families, the environment, and sacred places in the United States.
Community leaders speak out against BAAJAEarthworks asked leaders on the frontlines of mining, oil, and gas projects to share what BAAJA would mean for their communities.
Daranda Hinkey, Fort McDermitt Paiute Shoshone, People of Red Mountain“The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 will minimize tribal sovereignty and jeopardize our aboriginal land and cultural resources. This bill does not serve our people, so I strongly oppose it.”
Diane Wilson, San Antonio Bay Estuarine Waterkeeper“Industrial activity in Calhoun County is robbing commercial fishermen, shrimpers, and oystermen of our income, traditions, heritages and ways of life. BAAJA will make it worse. We are surrounded by massive petrochemical complexes that pollute waterways with chemicals and plastic. We are facing a floating LNG terminal in the Gulf that was approved before residents could have a say. BAAJA would make it impossible to litigate or have a future president reverse these shoddy decisions. Our deep roots in the Gulf should mean more than fossil fuel billionaires’ pocketbooks.”
Brittany McWhorter, Turtle Island Restoration Network“Here on the Texas Gulf Coast we have had a front row seat to the harm our oceans have experienced at the hands of destructive industries. Especially here in Galveston where our coastal communities and wildlife have already experienced an unfair share of harm from oil and gas exploitation, pollution, and environmental degradation.
“This bill provides an accelerated pathway to the destruction of our oceans and prioritizes short-term profit over the health of our planet and our people.”
“This bill provides an accelerated pathway to the destruction of our oceans and prioritizes short-term profit over the health of our planet and our people.”
Brittany McWhorter Leslie Fry Sonné, Citizens to Protect Smith Valley“Smith Valley, Nevada is slated to have one of the largest open-pit copper mines in the United States on our public land. The project may significantly impact our aquifer. We want an open, transparent process with robust environmental review, ample opportunity for public input, and the ability to challenge decisions if our technical experts have data that a project will harm our community.
“We are not opposed to mining if it is done right. We do oppose any permitting bill that gives industry the green light to keep us out of the conversation and decision-making process. Our representatives should push for more transparency and community involvement, not less.”
Fermina Stevens, Western Shoshone Defense Project“In protection of our future and in defense of the 1863 Ruby Valley Treaty, the Western Shoshone Defense Project opposes the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. Indigenous lands are taking the brunt of extraction for the energy transition and to feed the war machine that will likely target other Indigenous Peoples around the world. I often question if the morals of man exist when those who claim to be doing God’s work make laws to destroy the Earth for profit.”
John Beard Jr., Port Arthur Community Action Network“This bill’s not really about permitting reform. It’s about giving free rein to the oil and gas industry to push their projects through unheeded and unimpeded. And that is not reform. That is simply wiping out the democratic process that gives people such as BIPOC communities and also Indigenous communities a voice in these matters. They deserve to be heard because they are being affected. And they’re willing to sit at the table.
“Environmental justice, in terms of this bill, looks like the EJ for All Act that is inclusive, comprehensive, it brings everyone to the table who is involved, and these things can be worked out. But I find it funny, as you should too, that these are things that aren’t taken into account. They exclude the very people that are being affected. That is not a good bill. That is not a fair or democratic bill. It is at the worst authoritarian and even fascist because it eliminates the very people who are supposed to be designed to protect and remove those protections that are already there. Improvements can be made.
“But the problem does not lie in permitting itself. The problem lies in the things that are trying to be done in ways that go against the needs of people who are going to be affected.”
Ka’ila Farrell-Smith (enrolled Klamath Tribal member), Artist, Plaintiff in Farrell-Smith vs Oregon, People of Red Mountain“Limiting the government to government consultation process required by the National Historic Preservation Act Section 106 strips the ability of Tribal Nations to participate in federal decisions affecting our remaining cultural resources.
“Oregon communities were successful in stopping the Jordan Cove Energy Projects through public commenting processes upholding the Clean Water and Air Act. The Mining and Regulatory Clarity Act [included in BAAJA] reverses the ‘Rosemont’ decision out of the Ninth Circuit that interpreted the 1872 Mining Act as limiting where mining companies could construct infrastructure, process ore and dump mine tailings. This will allow for a larger total footprint for mining operations on public lands, escalating negative impacts from mining in the McDermitt Caldera.
“The protection of our ancestral homelands, sacred places, and treaty reserved resources must not be compromised in the interest of accelerating federal permitting processes.”
“The protection of our ancestral homelands, sacred places, and treaty reserved resources must not be compromised in the interest of accelerating federal permitting processes.”
Ka’ila Farrell-Smith Ava Curtis, Multicultural Alliance for a Safe Environment“New Mexico has long been exploited by the mining industry, with mining disasters, pollution, and health effects common around the state. That is why we are so disappointed to see our Senator, Senator Martin Heinrich, co-sponsoring the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. This bill would limit public engagement in the mine permitting process, allow companies to claim nearly unlimited public lands for any use associated with a mine, and amend the National Historic Preservation Act to essentially make Tribal consultation discretionary.
“New Mexico has 23 federally recognized Tribes and pueblos who have stewarded these lands for generations and deserve a guarantee of Tribal consultation.”
Organizational Statement, Protect Music Valley“The people are not separate from the environment. Weakening of our environmental protections is an attack on us, the people of the United States. Desert residents will not stand for the destruction of the protections that have been rightfully ours by law in this nation for generations.”
The post Community Leaders Speak Out Against BAAJA Permitting Bill appeared first on Earthworks.
Data centers could lower your electricity bill. Will utilities let them?
When sales increase more than costs, rates should decline. But some utilities are using lower historical sales data with updated cost assumptions to try and “lock in” higher rates, writes Edward Burgess of Current Energy Group.
Multilateralism, food security and agroecology: Daunting obstacles and moments of hope
NNU demands return home of Professor Lawani, thousands of immigrants unlawfully held in ICE detention
This battery runs on vitamin B12
In the search for a sustainable alternative to today’s lithium-ion batteries, researchers often look to materials found readily in nature. And in the latest such advance, researchers in Spain have made a rechargeable battery that uses vitamin B12 as a catalyst.
Vitamin B12 is an essential nutrient that the body needs for making red blood cells and maintaining the nervous system. The human body doesn’t naturally produce vitamin B12, and it is usually obtained from animal products such as fish, meat, and dairy. The food and drug industry cultivate bacteria that produce vitamin B12 for supplements and additives.
The team from the University of Cordoba decided to put the vitamin to use in zinc-air batteries. Metal-air batteries are more sustainable than lithium-ion batteries, which rely on expensive critical minerals that are mined with an environmental and ethical cost.
Metal–air batteries consist of a negative electrode made of pure metal such as lithium, magnesium, aluminum, or zinc. The positive electrode has a porous structure that lets in oxygen from the air, and a catalyst at the electrode triggers electrochemical reactions with the oxygen. “Precisely because it uses atmospheric oxygen, one of the battery’s active materials is not located inside the battery itself, thus significantly reducing its weight,” the researchers write in a paper published in the Journal of Materials Chemistry A.
So metal–air batteries can pack much more energy by weight than conventional lithium-ion batteries. This makes them promising for applications where light weight is crucial, such as drones or medical devices. Indeed, small zinc-air batteries, the most practical among the different types of metal–air batteries, are used widely for hearing aids. But those medical device batteries are not rechargeable.
.IRPP_ruby , .IRPP_ruby .postImageUrl , .IRPP_ruby .centered-text-area {height: auto;position: relative;}.IRPP_ruby , .IRPP_ruby:hover , .IRPP_ruby:visited , .IRPP_ruby:active {border:0!important;}.IRPP_ruby .clearfix:after {content: "";display: table;clear: both;}.IRPP_ruby {display: block;transition: background-color 250ms;webkit-transition: background-color 250ms;width: 100%;opacity: 1;transition: opacity 250ms;webkit-transition: opacity 250ms;background-color: #eaeaea;}.IRPP_ruby:active , .IRPP_ruby:hover {opacity: 1;transition: opacity 250ms;webkit-transition: opacity 250ms;background-color: inherit;}.IRPP_ruby .postImageUrl {background-position: center;background-size: cover;float: left;margin: 0;padding: 0;width: 31.59%;position: absolute;top: 0;bottom: 0;}.IRPP_ruby .centered-text-area {float: right;width: 65.65%;padding:0;margin:0;}.IRPP_ruby .centered-text {display: table;height: 130px;left: 0;top: 0;padding:0;margin:0;padding-top: 20px;padding-bottom: 20px;}.IRPP_ruby .IRPP_ruby-content {display: table-cell;margin: 0;padding: 0 74px 0 0px;position: relative;vertical-align: middle;width: 100%;}.IRPP_ruby .ctaText {border-bottom: 0 solid #fff;color: #0099cc;font-size: 14px;font-weight: bold;letter-spacing: normal;margin: 0;padding: 0;font-family:'Arial';}.IRPP_ruby .postTitle {color: #000000;font-size: 16px;font-weight: 600;letter-spacing: normal;margin: 0;padding: 0;font-family:'Arial';}.IRPP_ruby .ctaButton {background: url(https://www.anthropocenemagazine.org/wp-content/plugins/intelly-related-posts-pro/assets/images/next-arrow.png)no-repeat;background-color: #afb4b6;background-position: center;display: inline-block;height: 100%;width: 54px;margin-left: 10px;position: absolute;bottom:0;right: 0;top: 0;}.IRPP_ruby:after {content: "";display: block;clear: both;}Recommended Reading:This concrete could turn your house into a battery
The Cordoba team wanted to make a rechargeable battery using a biomolecule. They have previously made batteries with the protein hemoglobin and the enzyme catalase, which contain iron. This time they chose vitamin B12, also called cobalamin. The vitamin contains cobalt (III) at its core, which would be essential for electrochemical reactions.
Vitamin B12 is a highly soluble vitamin. To make it stable inside a battery that operates with water-based electrolytes, the team fixed it to the surface of carbon nanotubes, which are microscopic tubes made of carbon atoms. Then the researchers incorporated the nanotubes into the air electrode of alkaline zinc-air batteries.
The electrodes reached a specific capacity of 199.4 mAh of energy per gram, giving rechargeable batteries with high performance. And the electrodes worked in a cyclic fashion, allowing for a battery that could be recharged for up to 250 cycles. The performance is far from what is needed for practical applications right now, but the work highlights biomolecular platforms as “a high-performance and sustainable frontier for next-generation rechargeable batteries,” writes the team.
Source: Valentín García-Caballero et al., A vitamin B12-based air electrode for high-performance rechargeable zinc–air batteries, Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2026.
Image: ©Anthropocene Magazine
Envision Energy’s new AI-powered system can help mining companies decarbonise
Envision Energy’s new system combines wind, solar, batteries and AI to help remote Australian mines cut diesel use, emissions and electricity costs.
The post Envision Energy’s new AI-powered system can help mining companies decarbonise appeared first on Renew Economy.
Who Pays for Waste-to-Energy? Debt, Put-or-Pay Contracts and Climate Finance
The biggest disadvantages of waste-to-energy are financial as well as environmental. Incinerators are the most expensive way to manage waste, they are frequently built with public loans and subsidies, and many come with “put-or-pay” contracts that force cities to keep supplying waste for decades — or pay for waste they never deliver.
It’s also a climate finance problem. As governments negotiate climate finance at COP31 in Antalya, incinerators are competing for the same money as proven zero waste solutions: nearly USD 4 billion has gone into waste incineration projects, capturing 94% of waste-sector methane finance, while barely 1% reaches organic waste management and food rescue. In October, GAIA and allied groups demanded an end to public financing for incineration. Our new research, The Burn Book, documents twenty incinerators and incinerator proposals around the world. Together they have racked up nearly $7 billion in investment, with a portion coming directly from taxpayers through government subsidies and municipal borrowing.
What is a put-or-pay contract?A put-or-pay contract — sometimes called a minimum tonnage guarantee — requires a city to deliver a minimum amount of waste to an incinerator every year. If the city sends less, for example because of robust recycling and composting programs, it still pays as if it had delivered the full amount. In practice, this turns waste reduction into a financial penalty.
Under a put-or-pay contract, cities pay financial penalties for reducing waste-burning through ecological techniques like recycling or composting.
The Burn Book shows how common these clauses are:
- Hempstead, New York (USA): a long-term put-or-pay contract requires payment for at least 381,000 metric tons of waste a year through 2034.
- Surabaya, Indonesia: the Benowo plant’s operator is guaranteed payment for at least 1,000 metric tons a day even when the city delivers less, and the national utility buys its electricity at a preferential tariff of $0.1335 per kWh.
- Harare, Zimbabwe: the planned Pomona incinerator sits at the center of a $344 million, 30-year concession that requires the city to pay for minimum quantities of waste whether or not they are delivered.
- Moerdijk, Netherlands: contracts requiring 510,000 metric tons of waste a year led to financial disputes once better waste separation reduced municipal deliveries.
Incinerators are often presented as private investments, but much of the money comes from the public — through development banks, national grants, municipal borrowing and guaranteed electricity prices:
- Copenhagen, Denmark: Amager Bakke (CopenHill) was financed with about $682 million in publicly backed borrowing. When local waste volumes came in lower than expected, its owner municipalities loosened restrictions on imported waste.
- Paris, France: Isséane cost about $836 million, largely through public financing.
- Kwinana, Australia: the project received $16.3 million in federal grants and up to $63.8 million in debt financing from the government-owned Clean Energy Finance Corporation, while councils signed 20-year waste-supply agreements.
- Rome, Italy: the nearly $1.12 billion Santa Palomba incinerator will bind the city to a 33-year concession, even as Rome plans to raise separate collection to 70% by 2035.
- Prachinburi, Thailand: three industrial incinerators are part of a 12-plant project backed by more than $500 million in debt financing arranged by the Asian Development Bank, with lenders including the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank.
The risk is greatest where cities have the fewest resources to absorb it. GAIA Asia Pacific’s Citizens’ Atlas on False Climate and Circularity Solutions assessed 59 World Bank Group projects from January 2015 to August 2026. It found that 42 of them support waste incineration — including waste-to-energy, pyrolysis and gasification — across US$35.89 billion in total approved project amounts. Only 15 of the 59 projects mention or include plans to address waste workers’ concerns.
In Africa, GAIA’s new report Africa’s Waste Crisis Is Attracting the Wrong Solution examines 15 waste-to-energy projects and proposals across 10 countries. Ethiopia’s Reppie plant shows what can go wrong. The government spent about $120 million on a facility designed to burn 1,400 metric tons a day, but it processes only around 396–650 tons. It costs about $6.09 million a year to operate, Addis Ababa pays more than $1.83 million a year in compensation for power-generation shortfalls, and waste pickers interviewed reported an average 50% drop in income after the incinerator opened.
Overcapacity: when there isn’t enough waste to burnBig incinerators are designed around big waste volumes. When cities succeed at recycling and composting, those plants run short — and someone has to cover the gap. Europe already has around 65 million tonnes of incineration overcapacity, according to a 2026 data update from Zero Waste Europe, which calls for a moratorium on new capacity and for EU law to treat incineration as disposal, not recovery.
Oversizing is still happening. Brampton’s Emerald facility in Canada is approved to expand from about 182,000 to 912,000 metric tons a year, and the planned plant in Barueri, Brazil, has roughly three times the capacity of the residual waste the city itself generated in 2024.
7 questions to ask before your city signs an incinerator contract- What kind of waste will the plant burn, and where will it come from — household waste, recyclables, organics, plastics, or waste imported from other cities?
- Is there a minimum tonnage or put-or-pay clause — and what happens to the bill if we recycle and compost more?
- How long is the contract, and what would it cost to exit early?
- Who carries the debt if the plant underperforms or waste volumes fall?
- Are electricity prices, tipping fees or subsidies guaranteed with public money?
- Will emissions, including dioxins and particulate matter, be continuously monitored and published?
- How will waste pickers and informal recyclers be affected, and what is the plan to protect their livelihoods?
GAIA’s Waste-Burning 101 toolkit helps communities and organizers work through these questions, challenge proposed facilities and engage in waste planning decisions. For organizing strategies, read How Communities Can Refuse Incineration and Win.
Zero waste costs less — and should get the climate financeThe alternative is cheaper, and it is where climate finance agreed at COP31 should go. In Bandung, Indonesia, decentralized community systems save the local government up to USD 1.7 million a year in avoided transport and tipping fees. Over 550 municipalities around the world are already taking steps toward zero waste. And over GAIA’s 25 years, more than 375 incinerators have been shut down — proof that communities can win against incinerators.
Frequently asked questions about the costs of waste-to-energy What are the disadvantages of waste-to-energy?Waste-to-energy incinerators are expensive to build and run, often rely on public money and long-term contracts that require a steady waste supply, emit greenhouse gases and toxic pollutants, and produce toxic ash. The twenty incinerators in GAIA’s Burn Book produced at least 1.7 million tons of toxic ash per year.
What is a put-or-pay contract in waste management?A put-or-pay contract obliges a city to deliver a minimum quantity of waste to a facility or pay for the shortfall. It discourages recycling and composting, because reducing waste doesn’t reduce the bill.
Who finances waste-to-energy incinerators?Often the public. Funding comes from development banks such as the World Bank Group, the Asian Development Bank and the European Investment Bank, as well as government grants, municipal borrowing and guaranteed electricity tariffs.
Is waste-to-energy cheaper than recycling and composting?No. Incineration is the most expensive form of waste management. Community-based zero waste systems — separation, collection, composting and recycling — are sustained at a fraction of the cost of building an incinerator.
Can communities stop an incinerator?Yes. More than 375 incinerators have been shut down over GAIA’s 25 years, and 2026 victories include Skalica in Slovakia, Pavlikeni in Bulgaria and Mapo-gu in South Korea.
Read the full Burn Book, download the World Bank fact sheet, and if your community is fighting an incinerator, put your campaign on the map.
The post Who Pays for Waste-to-Energy? Debt, Put-or-Pay Contracts and Climate Finance first appeared on GAIA.
COP31’s electrification pledge wins support, with caveats on clean power and finance
More than a dozen countries, including Germany, South Korea, Pakistan and several small island states, have publicly backed the Turkish COP31 presidency’s flagship electrification pledge.
The voluntary pledge aims to raise electricity’s share of global final energy consumption to 35% by 2035, from 23% currently, but does not specify how that electricity should be generated.
The COP31 presidency is not expected to publish a full list of backers until next week, as it continues to rally support. But at least 14 countries have publicly endorsed the pledge, according to a Climate Home News analysis of speeches and official statements.
Alongside COP31 co-host Australia and COP32 host Ethiopia, they include Germany, Norway, Finland, South Korea, Pakistan, Zimbabwe, Eswatini, Togo and Liechtenstein, as well as the small island states of Palau, Seychelles and the Solomon Islands.
The European Union is widely expected to join the pledge this week, although member states still need to formally approve the decision, Politico reported. On Wednesday, President Ursula von der Leyen supported the pledge in her personal capacity and encouraged others to do the same.
Major economies still on the fenceOther major economies have welcomed COP31’s focus on electrification while stopping short of endorsing the pledge.
British Prime Minister Andy Burham said on Thursday that he was proud to support the summit’s focus on electrification. He said it matters for energy security, for creating good jobs in clean energy and manufacturing, and for lowering people’s bills.
Brazil’s environment minister João Paulo Capobianco ssaid on Thursday that electrification was “an important front” in climate action, but warned it should not be pursued “for the sake of it”. It should instead serve as a means of improving efficiency and cutting emissions. He said Brazil would work with the Turkish proposal and suggest adjustments to allow “specific solutions” that reduce emissions, without giving details.
Saudi Arabia was more openly sceptical. Energy minister Prince Abdulaziz bin Salman told the leaders’ summit that emissions reduction is “what unites us”, “not necessarily the track to achieving it”. “The expansion of electrification does not necessarily mean cutting emissions, so long as we do not consider the sources of its production,” he said, adding that countries’ choices must be respected.
Clean power strings attachedMany of the nations formally backing the initiative have attached some strings to their support. At a high-level roundtable on Wednesday, the low-lying Pacific island nation of Palau said it would sign on to the pledge. But it added that electrification “must not become a substitute or a distraction” from the chief goal of transitioning away from fossil fuels.
Seychelles also endorsed the pledge but added that it must be connected with cleaner electricity. “Electrifying more activities while continuing to burn fossil fuels will not deliver the full economic or climate benefits,” the country’s representative told the roundtable.
COP31 co-president Murat Kurum and Chris Bowen from Turkiye and Australia. (Photo: COP31/Flickr) COP31 co-president Murat Kurum and Chris Bowen from Turkiye and Australia. (Photo: COP31/Flickr)Australia’s climate and energy minister Chris Bowen, whose country is co-leading the pledge with Türkiye, has defended its design. “Electrification is almost always a good thing,” he told the Outrage and Optimism podcast recently. He argued that switching to an electric car cuts emissions by 60% even on a coal-fired grid, and by 90% when powered by solar.
Doug Arent, senior fellow at the WRI Polsky Center for the Global Energy Transition, said the most important thing “is that there is significant support for the concept of electrification”. He expects more countries to “recognise their pathway to be behind the 35 by 35” in the coming years.
Calls for financeOther developing countries backing the pledge have underlined the critical importance of access to finance. Pakistan’s Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif showed off his country’s people-led boom in rooftop solar and growing rollout of electric vehicles. But he added that “momentum without finance cannot be sustained,” and said the burden of new technologies cannot fall on countries already in debt.
Zimbabwe backed the pledge but warned of the high capital costs and financial bottlenecks facing developing countries. Its representative proposed a global electrification investment facility that would provide first-loss guarantees for projects under Mission 300, an initiative to connect 300 million people in Sub-Saharan Africa to electricity by 2030.
The Solomon Islands, another supporter of the pledge, asked for a dedicated finance access window for small island nations and least developed countries (LDCs).
Tuesday saw the launch of a global finance coalition backed by COP31 host Türkiye and COP32 host Ethiopia aimed at supporting clean electrification in developing countries.
Closing the roundtable, Türkiye’s energy minister Alparslan Bayraktar, who chaired the session, claimed the 35×35 pledge had found broad support worldwide. He called for a “smart” energy transition that draws on all available technologies, including carbon capture, use and storage.
The post COP31’s electrification pledge wins support, with caveats on clean power and finance appeared first on Climate Home News.
Power Shift: State Election Wins Open Path for Climate Progress
In the U.S. midterm elections, Democrats won control of governorships and state legislatures across the country. At a time of public outcry over data centers and rising electricity costs, incoming leaders will have a mandate to rein in polluters, constrain utilities, and advance clean energy.
France: The brass band and the revolution
For the third time in a week, on Tuesday, November 10, France saw major strikes in education, and mass demonstrations across the country. Well over...
The post France: The brass band and the revolution first appeared on Spring.
Budget 2026: Indigenous Investment in the Shadow of a New Economy
MARK CARNEY’S second budget as Prime Minister was released last week, on November 5th. Titled Masters of Our Destiny, the budget offers $400 billion in spending over six years. For Indigenous people, the budget allocates a significant $26.6 billion over the next five fiscal years, and nearly $50 billion in total over the next ten.
This is the largest total investment in Indigenous communities in any Budget since I started accounting in 2021, and more than five times the 2025 Budget allocation of $9.29 billion.
While much of the whopping $50 billion is spread out over ten years, as opposed to the typical five or six (this, in some ways, is a reminder of Justin Trudeau’s budgets), and there are some notable asterisks on some of the funding decisions, there is still no denying that this budget is incredibly significant and will hopefully facilitate much-needed improvements in the socio-economic lives of Indigenous people.
Despite this significant increase in Indigenous-specific funding, however, Budget 2026 has some shortcomings. In particular, this Budget is based on a logic of debt.
In other words, the Carney government intends to pay for this new spending and it plans to build Indigenous economic sovereignty through big bets on industry tax breaks and incentives designed to bring Indigenous people into major resource extraction projects.In this context, there are reasons for concern.
But first, a breakdown of the funding allocated for Indigenous communities.
Carney’s 2026 Indigenous BudgetFig 1. Indigenous Budget Allocation Breakdown
New funding in 2026 is divided among four major areas: Housing and Infrastructure, Education, Children and Families, and Health and Safety. Together, these four areas make up 98.2% of total Indigenous funding, and the largest share comes from the $32 billion investment over ten years for Indigenous housing and infrastructure.
Housing and Infrastructure
While most of that $32 billion in infrastructure money will go to First Nations housing — specifically on-reserve housing — almost $1 billion is split between the Atlantic First Nations Water Authority and three programs meant to bolster Indigenous-led construction and housing financing.
Given that one of the federal government’s big ambitions in this Budget is to eliminate homelessness within ten years, it is not surprising that Carney was forced to invest heavily in Indigenous housing. According to the 2021 census, over one-third of people experiencing homelessness across the country identified as Indigenous, despite comprising only 5% of the total population. Still, the AFN estimates the First Nations infrastructure gap alone at more than $376 billion. So, in the bigger picture, it’s unclear how far this investment can stretch.
The investment in the Atlantic First Nations Water Authority also builds on the federal government’s promise (again) to lift all on-reserve boil water advisories. The government had already announced $4.6 billion in June 2026 to achieve this end.
Education
In education, almost all of the $6.25 billion goes to on-reserve schooling, with just under $450 million for Indigenous post-secondary education — $10 million of which goes to the Dechinta Centre for Research and Learning.
Children and Families
Here, the government is allocating $6.75 billion across three areas. $6 billion over six years for Jordan’s Principle, and another $575 million over five years to renew the Inuit Child First Initiative and support its transition into a new program called Pirutsiagutiit — co-developed with Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami and the four Inuit Treaty Organizations. Finally, $806.7 million over five years renews funding to implement An Act respecting First Nations, Inuit and Métis children, youth and families.
Health and Safety
Regarding health and safety, about 86% of the total $3.35 billion funds the NIHB Program (Non-Insured Health Benefits). The rest is broken down into smaller funding amounts for initiatives and services like supporting Indigenous youth in sport, the Red Dress Alert pilot, community-led safety initiatives, and public health efforts in Indigenous communities.
Land and Miscellaneous
Just under $200 million covers what might be described as Land and Law, including funding Indigenous-led justice initiatives, supporting Canada’s land registry responsibilities, resolving Indigenous litigation, pursuing additions to reserve and self-government processes, and working on modern treaty and Section 35 rights agreements.
The remaining one percent or so of Indigenous-specific spending covers funding for a range of programs and initiatives, including the First Nations Financial Management Board, the First Nations Tax Commission and the First Nations Infrastructure Institute, funding Indigenous media initiatives, developing a new Partnerships for Indigenous Workforce Readiness Fund, creating a Northern Shelf Bioregion Reconciliation Framework Agreement, and providing additional funding for the National Centre for Truth and Reconciliation and the RCMP’s National Centre for Missing Persons and Unidentified Remains.
There is also a section of funding items that are not directly allocated to Indigenous communities but will benefit us. Something we might think of as “+Indigenous.” This includes funding proposals which, while they might not be directed at Indigenous people specifically or exclusively, they stand to benefit Indigenous people by virtue of servicing regions with a high Indigenous population, generally (housing, economic development, emergency management, etc.).
Too Good to be True? Readying the Red FlagsThere are some promising new funding items here, and it’s a relief that this budget also renews funding for several Trudeau-era programs the 2025 budget ignored — which worried several Indigenous leaders about scaled-back or disappearing support for important initiatives. Still, these commitments must be viewed in the context of the budget as a whole. This is where the red flags emerge.
In general, this budget makes clear that Mark Carney and his Liberal government believe big tech, resource extraction, and other potentially dangerous industry sectors will be the pillars of this country’s economy — with social spending happening in the shadow of these sectors’ proliferation.We see this ethos throughout the entire budget, including in Carney’s economic incentives for Indigenous people. For example, Budget 2026 highlights an offer to 128 Indigenous groups in Alberta and British Columbia the sale of a 15 percent stake in Trans Mountain Corporation. It also offers a minimum 10 percent ownership interest in Pacific Link, Canada’s new West Coast oil pipeline. Lastly, contentious Indigenous investments are showcased within the budget, such as the nuclear power generation venture involving the Williams’ Treaty First Nations.
To this end, the budget also lists advancing Bill C-39, Building Canada Strong, as a key measure in the game plan to make Canada more competitive and economically sovereign. By highlighting initiatives under Bill C-39, such as creating a Crown Consultation Hub to coordinate consultations with Indigenous Peoples, Carney tries to sell the idea that the bill is unquestionably good for Indigenous people.
This, despite the fact that dozens of Indigenous leaders have publicly denounced the omnibus bill as harmful and a violation of their rights to free, prior, and informed consent. Protests against the bill have already started across the country, and some experts question whether it is so problematic that it might spur a renewed Idle No More-esque movement.
In short, Budget 2026 gave me whiplash: improved housing on your land, but those lands should be open for business when it comes to mining, oil, and forestry. It invests in clean water, but gives tax breaks that will keep major AI data centres being built across the country, gobbling up thousands of litres of energy and water a day.
To me, this budget forces us to consider: can we really celebrate investments that improve basic needs when those improvements come against the backdrop of accelerating environmental degradation, expanding industry wealth, and a government that seems more than willing to trample our collective rights to get there? Is this a destiny worth mastering?
See the attached PDF for the full appendix.
Citation:
Yesno, Riley. “Budget 2026: Indigenous Investment in the Shadow of a New Economy” Yellowhead Institute. Nov 12 2026. https://yellowheadinstitute.org/2026/budget-2026-indigenous-investment-in-the-shadow-of-a-new-economy
The post Budget 2026: Indigenous Investment in the Shadow of a New Economy appeared first on Yellowhead Institute.
Pipeline Promises, Climate Risks
This surprise cost could derail your heat pump or EV charger installation. Here’s how to avoid it.
“Electrify everything” has become a mantra in the fight against climate change. Switching a home’s heating, cooling, and other energy-intensive loads from fossil fuels to electricity could drastically reduce planet-warming emissions. But electrification has often run into a major, and expensive, hurdle: upgrading a home’s electric capacity.
A home’s connection to the grid is rated by amperage, or amps, which caps the amount of current it can safely draw at once. The standard for houses built in the last few decades is generally 200 amps. Many older residences, however, have a lower limit because they were constructed when electricity powered little more than the lights, refrigerator, microwave, and perhaps the dryer. Research from Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory found that roughly a third of homes in the United States have panel capacity of 100 amps or less. In the Northeast, that share rises to closer to half.
As people install heat pumps, induction stoves, and EV chargers, they can run into a couple of potential issues. Their electric panel may simply run out of slots to install more circuit breakers, in which case the relatively easy fix of adding a subpanel often does the trick. But sometimes homeowners run into a bigger problem, where an electrician says all the new loads will push them past their home’s peak power limits.
Upgrading an electrical service can start at a few thousand dollars and quickly skyrocket, particularly in rural areas or places where power lines run underground. “We’ve seen estimates of $10,000 to $20,000,” said AJ Rossman, an electrical engineer with VEIC, a contractor that runs much of Efficiency Vermont’s state program.
The exact scope of the problem is unclear. There is scant data on how many service upgrades are done each year, let alone those that may have been recommended and never made due to the cost. But the Lawrence Berkeley research suggests there may be thousands, if not millions, of homeowners who are told they need to upsize their service as they electrify.
The good news is, there are workarounds — if you or your electrician know where to look. It’s a lesson my wife and I recently learned.
When we moved into our Burlington, Vermont, home, natural gas powered the furnace, stove, and dryer. We knew we’d eventually want to electrify, so I had our service increased from 150 amps to 200. Because we needed the upgrade as part of other work, the bill wasn’t horrible.
The change allowed us to install an EV charger, switch to heat pumps, get an induction stove, and plan for an electric dryer. We were happy to have a home largely free of fossil fuels.
Then we decided to build an addition.
Our plan for an extra 800 square feet would require two more small heat pumps along with lighting, outlets, and ditching our gas dryer. None of this was much of a concern until our electrician did the math. He determined that the laundry room swap alone would push our theoretical load to around 192 amps. Upgrading to 300 or 400 amp service would require trenching a new underground line and possibly even overhauling the transformer serving our block. It could cost us well over $10,000.
Read Next They thought getting their home off fossil fuels would be straightforward. Chaos ensued. Tik RootI panicked and started digging for answers. I had heard about a growing array of products designed to help people in my situation. For example, a friend had installed a smart panel that monitors how much electricity each circuit is using to ensure demand does not exceed the home’s capacity. If things get close, the panel shuts off lower-priority breakers as needed, then turns them back on when it’s safe.
This was appealing, but expensive. Converting my panel would have cost around $4,000 in materials alone. Even options that control a few circuits starts at about $2,000. With labor, the outlay seemed almost as staggering as a service upgrade.
I came across a cheaper category of devices called load-sharing switches, or smart splitters. They allow two high-demand appliances to share the same circuit, with just one running at a time. That means only the heavier load counts in a home’s demand calculation. Each switch cost around $800, depending on the brand. The issue was that we would probably need at least two to bring our calculated load below 200 amps. That was certainly an improvement, but it still wasn’t cheap and it left little wiggle room for the future.
There must be a better option, I thought. So, as a last-ditch effort, I called my utility provider, who I assumed may have other customers in a similar position. An advisor immediately asked me a question I had taken for granted: Is your electrician sure you need an upgrade?
When my electrician had calculated how much power my house would need, it appears he used the National Electrical Code’s standard method. Simply put, this approach uses the rated loads of all the electrical items in a home to calculate its theoretical load. Using one of the many online calculators to replicate his work, I arrived at the same conclusion: I was already taking up about 187 amps and the addition would push me to around 227 — beyond the panel’s 220-amp limit.
But Burlington Electric told me there was a lesser-known section of the code that could give me a very different answer. Commonly referred to as Section 220.87, even though it was recently moved to section 120.87, this method uses a year’s worth of utility data to identify a home’s actual peak demand instead of relying on hypothetical usage. Like 73 percent of residences around the country, my home has a smart meter, so it was relatively easy to request that information from my utility. A spreadsheet arrived the next day.
The file was thousands of rows long, so I put it into TrueLoadapp.com, a tool electricians can use to evaluate a customer’s load using this alternative method. It parsed the data to find my peak, which came on January 20, when my home topped out at just under 62 amps. The code mandates a 25 percent buffer when calculating usage, which bumped me about 77 amps.
Even then I was using less than 40 percent of my service and less than half what the standard method calculated. I then added my new loads the traditional way, and discovered there was more than enough capacity without upgrading my service. I had just saved thousands of dollars
“My mission is to get anybody who is considering any sort of electrification to do this first,” said Jake Marin, the founder of TrueLoad. “There are many, many, many situations where there is nothing wrong with your panel.”
Electricians work on a home’s electrical panel. Roughly a third of U.S. homes have 100-amp service or less, but research suggests only a small fraction may actually need an upgrade as they electrify. Jessica Rinaldi / Boston Globe via Getty ImagesMarin used to work at the VEIC, where he was involved in dozens of panel upgrades and started to wonder whether there was a better approach to the problem. That’s when he found 220.87 and built TrueLoad. “It tends to show that you have a lot more headroom than you actually thought,” he said. “People are spending $10,000 or more that they don’t need to.”
This aligns with the Lawrence Berkely research, which found that only a small fraction of homes actually need an upgrade, especially when using 220.87. “Most electrical panels have headroom for additional load,” said lead author Sean Murphy in a webinar earlier this year. Efficiency Vermont also looked into this issue, with similar results.
“We’re finding it really depends on the electrician,” said Rossman, who co-authored the white paper on the topic. It found that many electricians use rules of thumb in evaluating headroom, and few of those surveyed were aware of 220.87. Even homes with smaller services may have more capacity remaining than homeowners or electricians realize. “For a reasonable household, we are not seeing anything that comes close with the 200 amps,” said Rossman, noting that even fully electric homes utilize a fraction of that. “And it’s rare where you need something with more than 100 amps.”
Whether a load calculation is accepted ultimately rests with local inspectors. Some don’t even require one. Those who do shouldn’t have a problem with 220.87 because it’s been around for decades, said Dean Austin, a senior electrical specialist at National Fire Protection Association. Master electrician Johnathan Quong, who owns New England Electric, has been turning to it for years, when the traditional calculation suggests a home lacks capacity.
“We’ve been able to keep tons of people on 100 amp panels,” said Quong, who added that he’s never had an inspector reject a 220.87 project. The bigger obstacle, he said, may be getting electricians to adopt it. At an industry conference this year where the topic came up, he said he sensed skepticism from colleagues accustomed to traditional calculations.
“It didn’t sound like they knew about it, or didn’t feel like that was acceptable, and they still felt like it was their responsibility to make sure that it was 100 percent safe,” he said. “In my mind, there shouldn’t be any resistance.”
One caveat is that homeowners must get usage data from their utility, and Marin said access varies widely. Some utilities print a home’s peak load on the monthly bill, and TrueLoad has a feature for helping users make requests, but customers can still end up having to dig for that data — and navigating the system isn’t easy even for experts.
“I don’t even know how I would get that data from my own smartmeter,” said Ric O’Connell, executive director of GridLab, a nonprofit focused on supporting a clean grid. A few days later he emailed to say that after “a long time” and a battle with a “really poor” user interface, he obtained his data from Pacific Gas and Electric Company in California. It showed that his home peaked at just 65 amps.
For those who can’t access data, there are a few options. Another section of the code, 220.83 (recently changed to 120.83), allows some loads to be discounted based on the assumption that not everything in a home will be running simultaneously. In certain situations, that method may produce an even lower calculated demand than 220.87, said Jenny Low, director of panel optimization work and electrical reassessments for Build It Green, a nonprofit working to create equitable, healthy, and regenerative neighborhoods. At the very least, she said, it should be more forgiving than the standard method.
If I had used that option, my addition would likely have squeaked in under 198 amps, which would not have left enough margin to make me comfortable. The 220.87 route was clearly the smarter move. The 2026 version of the code expands the options by allowing both demand data and load discounting, although adoption may vary depending upon which version of the code a jurisdiction currently uses. The bigger challenge is making sure electricians and homeowners know about it.
For anyone who is short on capacity after using these approaches, load-management options like smart panels and switches are often the cheapest path to electrification. “There are,” said Low, “lots of ways to avoid a panel upgrade.”
As for me, contractors broke ground on the addition last week. If all goes to plan, I will spend a grand total of zero dollars on an electrification project that could have cost me well over $10,000.
This story was originally published by Grist with the headline This surprise cost could derail your heat pump or EV charger installation. Here’s how to avoid it. on Nov 12, 2026.
Uncommon “Common Sense”: Spain, China, and a “Great Politics” for the 21st Century
Spain’s progressive government hasn’t been blind to the risks of Europe’s growing trade imbalance with China, but has chosen openness and cooperation over confrontation with Beijing. This course puts Madrid at odds with Europe’s increasingly defensive posture towards China. Whether this proves a winning strategy or a doomed gamble is still up for debate. But it shouldn’t be read in isolation: it is part of Spain’s attempt to chart a new vision for Europe beyond permanent crisis management.
This article will feature in the Green European Journal’s winter 2026 print edition Far West: Europe in the “Chinese Century”. Subscribe now and be among the first to receive a copy in December.
Under Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez, Spain has emerged as an exception to the worldwide drift towards conservative and reactionary politics. In matters of energy, climate change, social rights, and international diplomacy, among many others, Spain has reclaimed the enduring relevance of a progressive response to the global polycrisis – almost single-handedly at times. On more than one occasion, this trailblazing effort has helped shape and lend credibility to an emerging consensus. On issues such as Gaza, EU energy market reform, and the need to bolster state resources in the face of unprecedented crises, Spain has punched above its weight. In retrospect, it is generally seen as having been early rather than wrong.
On China, however, Spain’s distinctive approach diverges from the European mainstream in certain key respects. Since 2023, Sánchez has visited China four times, highlighting opportunities for bilateral cooperation and investment. Meanwhile, the Franco-German consensus – and therefore that of the EU – has become increasingly confrontational towards Beijing, stressing the threat posed by unfair competition and industrial overcapacity to European jobs and economic stability. In this context, is Spain’s position doomed to marginalisation?
Spain’s stance on ChinaThe Sánchez government’s approach to China is fully situated within the European framework, which characterises the country simultaneously as a partner, an economic competitor, and a systemic rival.[1] It has repeatedly argued for the need to balance the EU-China trade deficit, initially calling it “significant”[2] and later “unsustainable”[3] and “unacceptable”.[4] All of this falls well within the contours of the European consensus.
Where divergence is visible is in Spain’s preference for engagement over confrontation with Beijing, whether on trade imbalances, investment, or security. Spain has been less inclined to support protectionist or punitive measures against China, as Sánchez has highlighted during his frequent visits there. On electric vehicles, renewable energies, and other frontier technologies, Spain has welcomed Chinese investment, with the proviso that it meet the requirements expected of development strategies. These include local value added, high-quality employment, and technology transfer.[5] Recent examples of this kind of development-oriented investment deal, which benefits both countries, include the revival of the Nissan factory in Barcelona[6] and the construction of the CATL-Stellantis battery gigafactory in Zaragoza.[7]
Spain has also been more tolerant of Chinese investment in security-critical areas such as surveillance and communications infrastructure. While the Spanish government cancelled a fibre-optic service contract with Telefónica over the use of Huawei gear in April 2025,[8] it did not introduce an outright ban on the Chinese tech giant, which the European Commission is planning to exclude from European telecoms networks.[9] In July of the same year, it awarded the company a multi-million-euro contract for the storage of judicial wiretaps.[10] Finally, Spain has been less vocal about China’s role in materially supporting Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, favouring what it considers pragmatic engagement over a more hawkish position.
In these respects, Spain’s approach to China does deviate somewhat from the majority opinion in the EU, especially insofar as it favours dialogue and engagement over confrontation to resolve friction. The question, then, is whether this tactical divergence is reasonable and how it fits within Spain’s broader political strategy.
End of the vacationPerhaps the largest elephant in the room is China’s overwhelming industrial dominance. The list of sectors in which China is a leading player is long, but in some of them, such as the so-called “new energy” sector (the group of technologies focused on clean and low-carbon alternatives to fossil fuels), the gap with the rest of the world is staggering. In 2024, China accounted for three-quarters of global clean-tech investment,[11] controlling over 70 per cent of manufacturing capacity in almost every sector tracked by BloombergNEF. In some of those sectors, its dominance reaches monopolistic levels. These include rare earth refining (91 per cent),[12] solar cells (92 per cent),[13] and battery anode materials (97 per cent).[14] This reality makes it impossible to achieve the global and regional decarbonisation targets proposed by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) or set by the EU itself without relying on China’s manufacturing might.
Spain’s approach to China can be seen as part of the answer to a much larger question: What does Spain want Europe to be?
China is also seeking to dominate other sectors it has identified as strategic and “emerging” or “future” in its latest Five-Year Plan,[15] including new materials, aerospace, AI, quantum computing, and biomanufacturing. To make this achievable, China can count on its continent-sized resources and population, guided by Beijing’s capacity to provide strong direction to both public and private companies – a form of indicative planning with sharp teeth. It is this industrial dominance that brings Sánchez to state that “China is rebuilding its greatness” and that it is destined, as in past centuries, “to play an essential role in the future of the world”.[16]
The European Union is no stranger to dealing with a much larger, more integrated, and more industrially capable partner. The entire history of European integration, beginning in the early 1950s, can be seen as a process of learning to live and thrive in the shadow of the United States. The key difference, in that case, was that this relationship of subordination was as much chosen by Europe as imposed on it. The “vacation from power” that Europeans enjoyed until very recently, to use a phrase coined by Dutch political philosopher Luuk van Middelaar, imposed severe limitations upon Europe but allowed it to see itself as a continental market with regulatory powers that did not need to bother with the nuisances of hard power.
Now that this understanding of Europe is collapsing, demolished by the very ally upon which it depended, the essential question for EU member states is how to survive, if not thrive, in that brave new world. Spain’s approach to China, then, can be seen as part of the answer to a much larger question: What does Spain want Europe to be?
The Europe Spain wantsThe key to this question can be found in Spain’s repeated calls for further European integration and a significant expansion of its capabilities. Now that Europe must deal with “great powers” that might not have its best interests at heart, and without the ability to outsource its security, what counts as a “realistic” position is up for debate.
In 2025, in a speech to the Spanish Congress of Deputies, Sánchez advocated for a federal Europe and said it was unrealistic “to pretend to compete with great powers like the United States, like China, like India, without deepening our European integration”.[17] Without hard capabilities in industry, defence, digital technologies, and finance, to name just a few, it is impossible to gain sufficient leverage on the global stage. And without that leverage, a hawkish stance on China would end up being a convoluted suicide mission – mere verbal bluster without substance. Europe must be strong enough to work with others to deliver global public goods that guarantee the continuation of human civilisation as we know it, such as climate stability or some kind of rules-based international order.
Even in matters of defence, where Spain has often been singled out for not toeing the line on the 5 per cent target pushed by Trump, Sánchez has repeatedly called for the creation of a European army,[18] favouring the pooling of resources, the coordination of procurement, and the integration of operational structures over the wasteful expansion of 27 separate national armies.[19]
Spain’s preference for a more open form of strategic autonomy, informed by an awareness of current limitations, can be traced back to its recent history. Spain was one of the last countries in Western Europe to join the European Communities, having spent the so-called “golden years” of capitalism (1945-1975) as an underdeveloped fascist dictatorship. One of the country’s few national consensuses is support for further European integration and development, driven by Spaniards’ enduring memory of what it means to be cut off from their neighbours and Europe’s institutions.
Unlike Spain, many other EU member states thrived under the post-World War II order and fear they have much to lose from its unravelling. They cling to the fantasy of defeating China through an unlikely combination of confrontation at the negotiating table and austerity at home. Spain, by contrast, has been one of the most persistent member states in calling for greater European fiscal muscle to allow us to do what we must as a Union. This is demonstrated by both its proposals in 2020 and its even more ambitious initiatives in 2025-2026 advocating a permanent fiscal capacity and a European safe asset.
In adopting this stance, has Sánchez once again “skate[d] to where the puck is going to be, not where it has been”, a direction that everyone else will eventually travel in? While Mario Draghi’s 2024 report – commissioned by Ursula von der Leyen to identify solutions to the “dwarf among giants” challenge – uses the more liberal-coded language of competitiveness and economic stagnation, it shares clear similarities with Sánchez’s discourse. These include advocating deeper integration as the only real solution Europe has at its disposal and acknowledging the need for public investment and industrial policy.[20]
Although the extent to which Draghi’s recommendations have become EU policy is contested, they carry significant weight, making it more difficult to dismiss Sánchez’s approach as mere folly. Instead, it can be seen as an attempt to present a green and progressive alternative that goes where the Draghi plan cannot – or will not. A simple anecdote speaks volumes about the self-imposed limits of the current consensus: Draghi himself once remarked, seemingly in passing, that “as much as I love this concept [of joint European debt], it is not the main thing in the report.”[21]
A new “great politics”Europe today seems firmly embarked on a doomed course of action that offers nothing but an imaginary solution to a very real set of problems. Whether driven by conviction or by catastrophic opportunism, the new political majority in the European institutions is determined to curb immigration within an ageing continent, slash public budgets although new capabilities are desperately needed, and cling to dreams of absolute national sovereignty when only an authentic European sovereignty – however messy and incomplete – has any chance of succeeding.
The fact that Spain – in historical terms an unlikely candidate – has offered the most coherent and realistic alternative to this path underlines the urgency of articulating a new political centre. This must acknowledge the present threats and enjoy sufficient support to begin delivering solutions at scale. Perhaps we must first endure various attempts to solve new problems with old solutions – in the form of all possible combinations of conservative and nationalist “small politics”.[22] It is important to note that these are by no means the exclusive domain of right-wing parties.
Spain’s preference for a more open form of strategic autonomy can be traced back to its recent history.
The silver lining to the highly volatile era in which we live, characterised by weak and shifting loyalties, is that enough people may begin to demand real solutions to their increasingly severe problems. When that moment of acute crisis arises, the ability to offer a “great politics” that offers solutions to the defining issues of the century – from the climate crisis to soaring inequality, technological destabilisation, and the obsolescence of the post-war social contract – will prove crucial.
It is possible that no such force will assemble to counter Europe’s decline, leaving us poorer, fragmented, and subjugated. But if it does, accompanied by a new great politics that can help forge a social contract fit for the current context, then Spain’s first coalition governments since the Second Republic of the 1930s – personified internationally by Sánchez but made up of a number of political actors – might be seen in retrospect as an early laboratory for a “new common sense”.[23]
If such a politics emerged, it would no doubt choose openness and multilateralism over closed borders and transactionalism. Here, the perspective of those who have themselves been migrants, or of younger generations who are further removed in time from imperial nostalgia, might prove crucial.
A new European great politics would also choose scale and ambition over austerity and stagnation, since the major problems we face can only be addressed with major solutions. Humanity’s powers of creation and destruction are immense; they must be used for the better good. The alternative – dreaming of a future in which they simply vanish without first laying waste to our societies – is futile.
The way forward is more clean energy, more liveable cities, improved production practices, and the expansion of democracy into more spheres of life. The astounding productivity gains of recent decades must be diffused throughout society. Progressive forces need to remember that only the most repressive social contracts can prevent this from happening in the long run. Those battles should not be conceded before they are even fought, and here it does not matter whether we are talking about the energy transition, digitalisation, or AI.
Finally, if a great politics of the 21st century did emerge, it would understand that the new social majority is much more diverse, with distinct interests that must be respected. This would, of course, include those fighting for social rights but might also include those concerned about issues that are traditionally coded as conservative but are being abandoned by the reactionary bloc, such as regulatory stability or international competitiveness.
“Uncommon” senseSpain’s strategy towards China – and its broader vision for Europe – is characterised by an exceptionally uncommon common sense and may be an early glimpse of such a “great politics”. But even under the most optimistic scenarios, this vision for Europe would not be the only one. Any plausible new European consensus would also have to accommodate those who favour more coercive and defensive postures – such as the recent Franco-German agreement on the need for a “kill switch” to cut off European single market access for countries such as China[24] – and those constrained by the ever-present demands of domestic politics, a limitation that Sánchez knows very well.
Whether the Spanish approach is wiped out from the commanding heights of European politics – either as a temporary setback or the definitive end of a doomed gamble – is a question for Europe’s citizens. On Europe, China, and beyond, the legacy of the Spanish experiment should not belong to Spaniards alone. It is up to us all to decide its fate.
[1] European Commission & the High Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy (2019). Joint Communication to the European Parliament, the European Council and the Council: EU-China – A Strategic Outlook (JOIN/2019/5 final). 12 March 2019. Available at <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:52019JC0005>.
[2] President of the Government of Spain (2025). “Comparecencia ante los medios de comunicación del presidente del Gobierno, Pedro Sánchez, tras su viaje a Vietnam y China”. 11 April 2025. Available at <https://bit.ly/4jBVnf9>.
[3] President of the Government of Spain (2026). “Lecture by the President of the Government of Spain, Pedro Sánchez, at Tsinghua University”. La Moncloa. 13 April 2026. Available at <https://bit.ly/4jy6bed>.
[4] President of the Government of Spain (2026). “Joint press appearance by the President of the Government of Spain, Pedro Sánchez, and the President of the French Republic, Emmanuel Macron: Speech by the President of the Government of Spain, Pedro Sánchez”. 30 September 2026. Available at <https://bit.ly/4BkrrdK>.
[5] La Moncloa (2026). “Spain and China sign three agreements to strengthen economic cooperation and open new trade opportunities”. 14 April 2026. Available at <https://bit.ly/4yHltRQ>.
[6] Invest in Spain (2026). “Ebro Motors pone en marcha una nueva línea de producción en Barcelona”. 2 July 2026. Available at <https://www.investinspain.org/es/noticias-main/2026/ebro>.
[7] Stellantis (2025). “Contemporary Star Energy, S.L. inicia la construcción de su giga factoría en Zaragoza”. 26 November 2025. Available at <https://bit.ly/48fB6Vu>.
[8] Reuters (2025). “Spanish government cancels contract with Telefonica for using Huawei gear”. 29 August 2025. Available at <https://bit.ly/3WqM1sR>.
[9] Sam Clark (2026). “Huawei ban to cost the EU up to €40 billion, says industry”. Politico Europe. 22 July 2026. Available at <https://www.politico.eu/article/telecom-industry-estimates-huawei-ban-cost-europe-40-billion/>.
[10] Tomorrow’s Affairs (2025). “Huawei at the centre of Spanish security—will Madrid pay the price of trust?”. 13 July 2025. Available at <https://tomorrowsaffairs.com/huawei-at-the-centre-of-spanish-securitywill-madrid-pay-the-price-of-trust>.
[11] Oktavia Catsaros (2025). “China Dominates Clean Technology Manufacturing Investment as Tariffs Begin to Reshape Trade Flows: BloombergNEF”. BloombergNEF. 28 April 2025. Available at <https://bit.ly/3UDIQ0u>.
[12] International Energy Agency (2026). “Rare Earth Elements: Executive summary”. 8 April 2026. Available at <https://www.iea.org/reports/rare-earth-elements/executive-summary>.
[13] Clean Investment Monitor (2026). “Tracking Global Clean Technology Investment: Key findings”. 18 March 2026. Available at <https://www.cleaninvestmentmonitor.org/reports/global-clean-investment-2025>.
[14] International Energy Agency (2026). “Energy Technology Perspectives 2026: Supply chain risks and industrial competitiveness”. 26 March 2026. Available at <https://bit.ly/3UeKndi>.
[15] Xinhua (2025). “Key recommendations document outlines priorities in China’s next five-year blueprint”. The State Council of the People’s Republic of China. 25 October 2025. Available at <https://english.www.gov.cn/news/202510/25/content_WS68fc10abc6d00ca5f9a0703e.html>.
[16] President of the Government of Spain (2026). “Lecture by the President of the Government of Spain, Pedro Sánchez, at Tsinghua University”. La Moncloa. 13 April 2026. Available at <https://bit.ly/4jy6bed>.
[17] President of the Government of Spain (2025). “Comparecencia del presidente del Gobierno para informar sobre el nuevo escenario geopolítico de la Unión Europea y las conclusiones del Consejo Europeo celebrado el pasado 20 de marzo en Bruselas”. La Moncloa. 26 March 2025. Available at <https://bit.ly/4BibQvr>.
[18] EuroEFE (2025). “Sánchez abre la puerta a crear un «verdadero» ejército europeo”. 26 March 2025. Available at <https://efe.com/euro-efe/2025-03-26/sanchez-europa-seguridad/>.
[19] President of the Government of Spain (2025). “Declaración institucional del presidente del Gobierno sobre el acuerdo con la OTAN”. La Moncloa. 22 June 2025. Available at <https://bit.ly/4snkDbe>.
[20] Mario Draghi (2025). The Future of European Competitiveness. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union. Available at <https://commission.europa.eu/topics/competitiveness/draghi-report_en>.
[21] Thomas Moller-Nielsen (2024). “Common debt not ‘essential’ for EU competitiveness, says Draghi”. Euractiv. 30 September 2024. Available at <https://www.rapporteur.com/news/common-debt-not-essential-for-eu-competitiveness-says-draghi/>.
[22] A term coined by Italian Marxist philosopher Antonio Gramsci. La piccola politica (“small politics”) focuses on routine political tasks and the maintenance of power. By contrast, la grande politica (“great politics”) is characterised by transformational change. See Quaderni del carcere (“Prison Notebooks”), first published in 1947.
[23] For Gramsci, “common sense” refers to an uncritical and unquestioned body of assumptions. A “new common sense” represents a transformed, counter-hegemonic worldview. Ibid.
[24] Finbarr Bermingham & Xiaofei Xu (2026). “France, Germany call for new weapon allowing ‘immediate cut off’ of China from EU market”. South China Morning Post. 5 October 2026. Available at <https://bit.ly/3UJpNBV>.
Climate progressives won the midterms without saying ‘climate’
On October 20, the two candidates running to represent Michigan in the U.S. Senate, Abdul El-Sayed and Mike Rogers, took questions for an hour at the Detroit Economic Club. El-Sayed, the Democrat who had previously run for governor, made a name for himself years ago by connecting public health to the climate crisis. He published a fierce defense of the Green New Deal at the time, touting its economic, health, and planetary benefits. But last month at the Detroit Economic Club, El-Sayed didn’t mention the Green New Deal at all.
Instead, the only mentions of such a plan came from his opponent, who used it as an attack on El-Sayed and the Democratic party as a whole. “We need to make sure we don’t have the largest tax increase in the history of the country,” Rogers said, “which is, that’s what the other team is talking about doing.”
A vote for El-Sayed would ring in an era of “big government, government control, more rules, more regulation, another Green New Deal,” Rogers continued. It’s become a common refrain since President Donald Trump’s effort to rebrand the climate movement’s push for widescale public investment in renewable energy as a “Green New Scam.”
Two weeks later, El-Sayed handily won the race.
Even though many of the newly elected Democrats did not talk about the Green New Deal by name, the think tank Climate and Community Institute describes El-Sayed as belonging to a new class of green economic populists who are running for public office (and winning) by connecting the need for climate action to soaring utility bills and the hoarding of wealth by a handful of individuals and companies.
El-Sayed “clearly gets it,” said Patrick Bigger, research director at Climate and Community Institute, or CCI. The senator-elect’s platform, which proposes stricter regulations on data centers and energy companies, is “really exciting,” he said. These are promising climate agenda items — even if Democrats don’t explicitly call them that. For example, voters may oppose data centers in their backyard for any number of reasons, but some number of them are required for our digitalized reality and progressives now have an opportunity to take the companies behind them to task and get them to commit to reducing their strain on the local environment. Likewise, where voters came out in support of lowering utility bills, electeds now can talk further about investing in cheaper renewable energy systems like solar and wind power.
Bigger led a recent analysis that scored candidates in this year’s primary and midterm elections based on three questions: Is the candidate pushing for renewable energy or other climate actions? Do they name the rising cost of living as a voter issue, and have a plan to lower those costs? Do they articulate a populist vision by blaming wealthy corporations and powerful individuals for both the climate and affordability crises? CCI argues that candidates like El-Sayed who check all three boxes are the climate champions of the moment.
Other progressives named in the report include Will Lawrence, a co-founder of the Sunrise Movement, the climate group that first sounded the alarm for a Green New Deal in 2018. Lawrence, who will represent Michigan’s 7th District in the next Congress, points to his history of climate organizing on his website: “I will be among the most knowledgeable and dedicated members of Congress on water, climate and energy policy,” he writes. “I will fight for investment to secure the climate we depend on, adapt to the changes we can’t prevent, and finally drive our electric bills down.”
These “new folks headed to the House and the Senate who are really on board with a robust transformative approach to climate,” said Bigger, represent “a major shift.”
Read Next How the midterms could unleash a new era for clean energy in these 3 states Jake BittleBut not all climate progressives heading to Washington next year are so allergic to calling it the Green New Deal: Representatives-elect Claire Valdez and Darializa Avila Chevalier in New York City name it specifically on their campaign websites and in the press. Still, this new wave of climate leaders may feel it’s time for the decarbonization agenda to get a refresh; Valdez and Avila Chevalier’s websites also include mentions of “a livable planet for all” and “a livable world for everyone,” respectively. In part, this diversity of messaging tactics reflects the fractured nature of the climate movement since Trump retook office with a checklist of Biden-era environmental regulations to roll back.
If progressive Democrats’ messaging on climate has shifted, said Aru Shiney-Ajay, executive director of the Sunrise Movement, it’s because the terrain they’re fighting in has changed, too. “I think, as the climate crisis gets worse and worse, it’s becoming increasingly clear that the strategy, policy-wise, needs to be incorporating climate change into every single aspect of what we’re doing,” she said. In other words, climate policy should not be framed as a separate issue from the economy, infrastructure improvements, or foreign policy. “It should be the defining framework within which we have to think about how we run our society,” said Shiney-Ajay.
In 2018, the Sunrise Movement burst onto the national stage by protesting outside House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi’s office — with the Green New Deal as their top priority. Just seven years later, members of the Sunrise Movement voted to reorganize around the priority of fighting authoritarianism and, in particular, the second Trump administration. Shiney-Ajay acknowledged that the climate movement has suffered in recent years.
But that doesn’t mean that the public has become disengaged from the climate crisis. In fact, voters across the political spectrum are more attuned to it than ever. “People are actually really hungry for something to do about climate change,” said Shiney-Ajay. “I think we will actually see a lot of momentum around stopping the climate crisis. And I certainly hope to build a movement that makes that possible.”
Wherever climate progressives or so-called “green economic populists,” are in office, the CCI report says, now is the time to govern. (It’s worth noting that a petition launched this week asking Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who famously joined Sunrise members in the protest outside of Pelosi’s office, to run in the 2028 presidential race.) It will, of course, take more than the next two years, or the next presidential term, to solve the climate crisis.
toolTips('.classtoolTips4','The process of reducing the emission of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases that drive climate change, most often by deprioritizing the use of fossil fuels like oil and gas in favor of renewable sources of energy.');This story was originally published by Grist with the headline Climate progressives won the midterms without saying ‘climate’ on Nov 12, 2026.
Pages
The Fine Print I:
Disclaimer: The views expressed on this site are not the official position of the IWW (or even the IWW’s EUC) unless otherwise indicated and do not necessarily represent the views of anyone but the author’s, nor should it be assumed that any of these authors automatically support the IWW or endorse any of its positions.
Further: the inclusion of a link on our site (other than the link to the main IWW site) does not imply endorsement by or an alliance with the IWW. These sites have been chosen by our members due to their perceived relevance to the IWW EUC and are included here for informational purposes only. If you have any suggestions or comments on any of the links included (or not included) above, please contact us.
The Fine Print II:
Fair Use Notice: The material on this site is provided for educational and informational purposes. It may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. It is being made available in an effort to advance the understanding of scientific, environmental, economic, social justice and human rights issues etc.
It is believed that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have an interest in using the included information for research and educational purposes. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. The information on this site does not constitute legal or technical advice.




