You are here
G1. Progressive Green
Cracks in dangerous “permitting reform” overhaul widen with Jeffries opposition statement
Yesterday, House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries made public his opposition to the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA, S. 5653), “raising concerns about the legislation’s proposed changes to bedrock environmental laws and protections for Tribal sovereignty.” Despite Democrats gaining strong majorities in both chambers of Congress beginning in 2027, Sen. Heinrich and other bill sponsors have refused to delay a Senate vote on the bill currently scheduled for Monday, Nov. 9. A manager’s amendment to the 417-page bill is expected to be released Nov. 8, giving senators less than 24 hours to understand what they are voting on.
“We’re grateful Leader Jeffries made a wise move to listen to the full range of interests in the Democratic caucus, avoid a bloody factional fight mere days after a historic political victory, and not hand President Trump a policy win he would weaponize to harm public lands, waters and wildlife, and communities in the western U.S.,” said Erik Schlenker-Goodrich, executive director of the Western Environmental Law Center. “We hope Leader Schumer does the same. There is a constructive conversation to be had in the 120th Congress to build out renewables infrastructure and deliver on the promise of affordability, while respecting people and place. That conversation should proceed through regular order to bring new ideas to the table and ensure that all voices are heard.”
BAAJA would enact the most severe environmental and community protection rollback in American history, affecting Tribal sovereignty, the National Environmental Policy Act, Endangered Species Act, Clean Water Act, and National Historic Preservation Act. Read our analysis here.These rollbacks would fast-track an array of Trump’s vanity projects such as the “triumphal arch” and White House “ballroom,” remove barriers to unwanted, cruel, and wasteful immigrant detention centers, and supercharge the buildout of AI data centers over community opposition.
A coalition of 29 groups in Sen. Heinrich’s home state of New Mexico with diverse focus areas including Indigenous, faith, children’s wellbeing, clean water, conservation, climate, and community issues sent him a letter opposing the bill last week.
Contacts:
Erik Schlenker-Goodrich, Western Environmental Law Center, 575-751-0351, eriksg@westernlaw.org
Marlyn Twitchell, Western Environmental Law Center, 541-485-2471, ext. 144, twitchell@westernlaw.org
The post Cracks in dangerous “permitting reform” overhaul widen with Jeffries opposition statement appeared first on Western Environmental Law Center.
In Their Own Words: The Senior Reform and Tory Figures Who Have Lauded Trump
U.S. President Donald Trump suffered a spectacular setback in the country’s midterm elections this week, with Democrats taking control of Congress and the Republicans losing races in their traditional heartlands.
The election was a rebuke to Trump’s increasingly unpopular presidency. Voters expressed frustration with the cost of living and the economy, while the U.S.-Israeli war with Iran – which has driven up fuel prices – has proven to be a major political liability.
Trump’s political fortunes have also been damaged by his administration’s aggressive immigration enforcement. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), the agency at the centre of his mass deportation drive, has become a flashpoint and an emblem of Trump’s autocratic rule.
Yet, across the Atlantic, some of the UK’s most senior right-wing politicians have spent recent years enthusiastically praising Trump, celebrating his political leadership, and seeking to emulate his policies.
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage has repeatedly presented himself as one of Trump’s most enthusiastic international allies. At a Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) event in February 2025, he declared that Trump is “the bravest man I know”.
Farage also described the president’s 2024 election victory as a source of inspiration for his own political ambitions. “This is all going to blow back and help us. We are now topping every opinion poll in Britain, and we are going to win the next general election,” he said.
With Reform falling in the polls and the party facing police and parliamentary investigations, that prospect now seems increasingly unlikely.
Subscribe to Desmog Email Address Sign Up Send me intelligence from: All US/Global team UK/Europe team Sign Up --> (function($){ $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-us').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619D07B21962C5AFE16D3A2145673C82A3CEE9D9F1ADDABE965ACB3CE39939D42AC9012C6272FD52BFCA0790F0FB77C6442'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-vdrirr-vdrirr'); }); $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-uk').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619BD43AA6813AF1B0FFE26D8282EC254E3ED0237BA72BEFBE922037EE4F1B325C6DA4918F8E044E022C7D333A43FD72429'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-ijkidr-ijkidr'); }); })(jQuery);Meanwhile, Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch has similarly celebrated Trump’s return to office and his second term agenda.
At the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship (ARC) conference in February 2025, Badenoch referenced her party’s defeat at the 2024 general election and her subsequent election as Tory leader, saying: “People ask me what difference new leadership will make? Well, take a look at President Trump.”
She continued: “He’s showing that sometimes you need that first stint in government to spot the problems, but it’s the second time around when you really know how to fix them.”
And this enthusiasm has extended beyond rhetoric. Reform and Conservative politicians have embraced Trump’s calls for expanded fossil fuel extraction, praised his drive to slash the state, and proposed British versions of his immigration enforcement operation.
Meanwhile, as revealed by DeSmog, influential right-wing Westminster pressure groups have accepted $20 million from U.S. sources, including major Trump donors, over the past decade – while MPs have received more than £300,000 for attending Trump-aligned events since the 2024 UK general election.
‘Drill, Baby, Drill’Few policy areas illustrate the ideological alignment between Trump and Britain’s right-wing parties more clearly than oil and gas.
Trump began his second presidency by demanding that Britain abandon restrictions on North Sea extraction. On 3 January 2025, he posted on Truth Social: “The UK is making a very big mistake. Open up the North Sea. Get rid of Windmills!”
And his administration has made expanding domestic fossil fuel production a central policy objective, encapsulated by the slogan “drill, baby, drill”.
The Conservatives and Reform have both echoed that mantra, arguing that Britain should maximise extraction from its dwindling North Sea reserves rather than pursue a transition away from fossil fuels.
In September 2025, Badenoch met Trump at the White House. Afterwards, she made clear that the North Sea had featured prominently in their discussions.
The Conservative leader wrote on the social media platform X: “Not surprised Trump was so emphatic. It’s all we spoke about last night. We have to get our oil and gas out of the North Sea.”
She added: “We have to make the most of our natural resources. It’s mad to leave billions of £ in there.”
The comments reflected Badenoch’s commitment to maximising fossil fuel extraction at the expense of the UK’s climate commitments – pledging to scrap the 2050 net zero emissions target that the Conservative Party introduced in office.
U.S. Vice President JD Vance and Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch.Credit: JD Vance / X
Reform has gone even further in adopting Trump’s pro-oil language.
Speaking at a fundraiser for the Heartland Institute – a U.S. climate science denial group – in September 2024, Farage urged the country to re-elect Trump so the Republican could enact his “drill, baby, drill” agenda.
Reform has pursued an anti-climate manifesto modelled on Trump’s policies – pledging to remove the ban on fracking for shale gas, open new coal plants, and scrap subsidies for renewable energy.
In summer 2025, Reform’s mayor of Greater Lincolnshire Andrea Jenkyns met representatives of oil and gas company Egdon Resources, owned by Texas-based Heyco Energy, and promised to echo the Trump administration’s approach to drilling.
“Donald [Trump] is wise,” she said. “We value our oil and gas industries and know that they are essential for Britain’s energy security and to fuel our homes.”
Jenkyns has been a vocal supporter of fracking, saying: “I want to turn the countryside into Swiss cheese and just go for it.”
Egdon claims it has discovered huge deposits of natural gas in the Gainsborough Trough basin in Lincolnshire, which it would extract through fracking – a practice banned in the UK due to its environmental and health impacts.
As revealed by DeSmog, George Yates, who owns Egdon and Heyco, is a Trump donor.
Like Trump – who has called climate change the “greatest con job ever perpetrated on the world” – Farage has frequently spread climate science denial. Speaking at the 2025 ARC conference, he claimed it’s “absolutely nuts” for carbon dioxide to be considered a pollutant.
In fact, the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the world’s foremost climate science body, has stated that carbon dioxide “is responsible for most of global warming” since the late 19th century, which has increased the “severity and frequency of weather and climate extremes, like heat waves, heavy rains, and drought”.
‘A British DOGE’Trump’s drive to slash federal spending, overseen initially by Elon Musk through the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), has been another major source of inspiration for Britain’s right.
The initiative was a central feature of Trump’s early second-term agenda, promising to reduce the size of the federal government. It also drew widespread controversy over mass redundancies, the accessing of private data, the dismantling of international aid programmes, and the extent of Musk’s unprecedented influence over the administration.
However, both Badenoch and Farage have explicitly endorsed the idea of importing DOGE to Britain.
In February 2025, Badenoch told The Telegraph’s Daily T podcast that Britain needed a similar scheme.
Asked whether the UK needed its own version of DOGE, she replied: “I think so” – adding: “If you remember in my campaign launch speech, I said that we need to reboot [and] rewire the state. This is what we have to do.”
Badenoch added: “We have to do something like DOGE … We have to have a revolution on this.”
Farage was equally enthusiastic. At Reform’s March 2025 local elections campaign launch, he told supporters: “Frankly folks, what we need in this country to pay for the cuts that people deserve and need, we need a British form of DOGE, as Elon Musk has got in America. Let’s have a British DOGE.”
Reform deputy leader Richard Tice called for: “a sort of county-by-county equivalent of a DOGE” at the same event, asking supporters: “Do you want to make Britain great again?”
Billionaire and DOGE lead Elon Musk at CPAC 2025. Credit: Zach RobertsAnd the party has attempted to implement this agenda in local government.
In June 2025, Reform announced the creation of a DOGE team intended to identify and cut spending in its local councils.
The initiative was presented as a direct counterpart to Musk’s American project. Reform’s then-chair, Zia Yusuf, said: “For too long British people have been British taxpayers have watched their money vanish into a black hole.”
He continued: “As promised, we have created a UK DOGE to identify and cut wasteful spending of taxpayer money. Our team will use cutting-edge technology and deliver real value for voters.”
Yusuf also lauded Musk – a far-right tech baron – as “the ideal person” to lead Trump’s DOGE agency.
Despite Reform’s strong language, its local DOGE operation hasn’t achieved dramatic “cost savings” for taxpayers. In February, Paul Chamberlain, a Reform cabinet member responsible for Kent Council’s DOGE agenda, told the Financial Times: “We made some assumptions that we would come in here and find some of the craziness that DOGE found in America and that was wrong, we didn’t find any of that.”
ICE and Mass DeportationsImmigration enforcement has been another area where British right-wing politicians have sought to emulate Trump.
In August 2025, Farage unveiled plans to detain and deport migrants who have entered Britain through irregular routes. Yusuf outlined the proposed system for implementing the policy, including a dedicated deportation force – modelled on ICE – and a data-sharing system connecting government agencies.
He said: “We will pair this legislative reset with a UK deportation command – that is a dedicated force to identifying, detaining and deporting illegal migrants at scale.”
Yusuf added: “We’ll create a cutting edge data fusion centre that will automatically share data between the police, the Home Office, the NHS, the DVLA, HMRC and banks.”
In September 2026, Farage even said he wanted to “hijack” Trump’s ICE advisor, Tom Homan, and bring him to Britain “to secure our borders”.
The Conservatives have also explicitly drawn on the U.S. model. In October 2025, Badenoch announced plans for a new ‘Removals Force’ modelled on ICE, with powers to identify, detain and deport people without legal immigration status.
The proposals included facial recognition and a requirement for police to check people against biometric border data.
When Badenoch was asked whether Trump would approve of the policy, she replied: “I wouldn’t be surprised if he loved it.”
The Iran WarThe Iran war has proven to be politically disastrous for Trump and the Republican Party – a fact now acknowledged by U.S. Vice President JD Vance – but senior right-wing figures in the UK were quick to support the president’s military intervention.
Badenoch was among the most vocal Conservative supporters of the bombing campaign – saying in January 2026, amid protests against Iran’s government, that she would support American intervention if it took place “with a broad coalition of countries”.
Asked whether the U.S. and its allies should help remove the Iranian regime, Badenoch replied: “I think that given the threat that we’re seeing to the people, I think that would be right”.
She qualified her position by insisting that any intervention had to be judged against Britain’s national interest.
When Trump and Israel launched their attacks in February, Badenoch supported their actions and criticised Prime Minister Keir Starmer for refusing to join the initial offensive.
She argued that Britain should “do more than catch arrows” and “take out” Iranian missile launchers.
Explaining her position, she said: “When missiles are being fired, the launchers which are kept deep underground come out. If you take out the capacity, that means that they will stop sending missiles over. So don’t just catch the arrows. Stop the archer.”
Badenoch has subsequently denied that she had called for Britain to join the offensive strikes, claiming: “I said that we support their actions. I never said we should join.”
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage.Credit:
House of Commons (CC BY-3.0)
The calls for British intervention were particularly pronounced among Reform’s senior figures, including Tice and former Conservative chancellor Nadhim Zahawi, who defected to Reform in January 2026.
Zahawi told The Sun that Britain should participate in the U.S.-Israeli operation. “Whatever the U.S. needs we should make all of our assets available,” he said. “That means bases, hardware, logistics. We should join the bombing if needed.”
He subsequently told Times Radio that Britain should “make everything available to our greatest ally, the United States of America”.
Tice was similarly explicit. Appearing on Saudi broadcaster Al Arabiya in March, Farage’s deputy said that a Reform government: “would be helping the Americans and the Israelis in any way they saw appropriate” and would be “pleased to help” with offensive missions if asked.
Andrea Jenkyns went further, refusing to rule out British troops being deployed on the ground. Asked on Sky News whether she wanted to see British forces in Iran, she said: “Ideally not at this stage”, but added: “you can’t rule anything out. Look, it’s too hostile and we don’t know the direction it’s going in. But should we be using more of our weapons and should the [HMS] Dragon be there already? Most certainly.”
They were following Farage’s lead. On 28 February, the Reform leader tweeted: “The Prime Minister needs to change his mind on the use of our military bases and back the Americans in this vital fight against Iran!”
A few days later, he said the UK’s “inaction” in failing to join the war was “frankly pathetic”.
Gaza and VenezuelaBeyond Iran, senior figures on the British right have repeatedly applauded Trump’s willingness to remake the international order – even when his interventions have provoked widespread condemnation.
In February 2025, Farage welcomed Trump’s proposal to take control of Gaza and relocate its population.
He said: “I love that notion. The thought of a wealthy, wonderful thriving place with well-paid jobs, casinos, nightlife … it all sounds very appealing to me.”
Farage added: “I’m not here to answer for everything the Trump administration has to say.”
But he also praised Trump’s early presidency more broadly: “promises made, promises kept, quite extraordinary” he said – adding: “So without being specific on Gaza, I would just say I think he’s off the most incredible start.”
Farage also described Trump’s use of tariffs – some of which have been imposed on the UK – as a “transactional tool” which the president uses “amazingly effectively”. These tariffs are now blamed for creating high costs in working class areas of America that rely on manufacturing.
Meanwhile, Badenoch was also supportive of Trump’s intervention in Venezuela where, in January, the U.S. captured President Nicholás Maduro.
“Venezuela was a brutal regime,” Badenoch said – adding: “I think what’s happened is quite extraordinary. But I understand why America has done it.”
Asked whether the intervention was morally justified, Badenoch replied: “Morally, yes.”
The MAGA ModelThe relationship between Trump and Britain’s right extends beyond individual endorsements of his policies, encompassing a wider network of political organisations, ideological allies, and campaign groups.
Few British political figures have embraced Trump’s project as enthusiastically as Liz Truss, who has reinvented herself as a MAGA evangelist since leaving Downing Street.
Truss was even spotted at Trump’s Florida Mar-a-Lago estate on the night of the midterm elections, giving her a front-row seat to the electoral hammering inflicted on the Republicans.
Yet Truss has championed the very policies that underpinned the disastrous results.
Speaking at CPAC in February 2025, the former prime minister declared: “We want a Trump revolution in Britain.” She called for Musk and his “nerd army of Muskrats” to examine the British “deep state”, and said the UK should participate in what she described as the “second American revolution”.
“We see President Trump in the executive, in the Oval Office signing off executive orders, and we want some of that in Britain,” Truss told the conference. “We want drill, baby, drill. We want men banned from women’s bathrooms and women’s sports. We want illegal immigrants deported. We want taxes to be cut. We want a Trump revolution in Britain.”
Truss has since become the chair of CPAC UK, bringing the pro-Trump jamboree to Britain. The event, hosted in July, was addressed by Farage – despite the Reform leader suggesting beforehand that he would be “steering well clear” of the summit.
Former Conservative prime minister Liz Truss.Credit:
Simon Dawson / No 10 Downing Street (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)
Andrew Griffith, the Conservative Party’s shadow chancellor, also addressed the event and has developed close ties to Trump’s MAGA network.
Meanwhile, Farage has helped to import an influential U.S. climate science denial group, the Heartland Institute, to the UK. The Reform leader was the keynote speaker at the launch of the Heartland Institute’s UK-EU branch in December 2024, months after urging the group to set up a satellite in Europe.
Heartland Institute UK-EU director Lois Perry claims to be advising the party on its climate agenda and is the strategy director of Reform Friends of Israel – a lobbying group within the party.
And Farage has been forging ties with Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) – a powerful legal advocacy group that led the campaign to overturn Roe v Wade, the landmark ruling that protected the constitutional right to abortion in the United States.
ADF’s UK branch spent over £1.4 million on its activities in 2025, more than three times higher than in 2020. Farage has not only appeared on promotional materials put out by the ADF, but according to the New York Times the group orchestrated a visit by Reform’s leader to Washington DC in September 2025, during which he testified to Congress.
ADF has also reportedly arranged backroom meetings between Farage and State Department officials on their visits to London.
“President Trump’s victory represents the rejection of open borders, socialist economics, woke ideology, net zero fanaticism and [diversity, equity, and inclusion schemes] by right thinking people in America,” Zia Yusuf posted after the president’s election victory in November 2024, adding: “The UK is next.”
Two years on, the American electorate is rejecting the Trump project. His increasingly unpopular presidency, and Reform’s own faltering fortunes, suggest the MAGA model may be losing its appeal on both sides of the Atlantic.
The post In Their Own Words: The Senior Reform and Tory Figures Who Have Lauded Trump appeared first on DeSmog.
Respect the Rot
If a tree falls in the woods and no one is around to see it, did it happen?
To the mycelium and the worms, yes.
To the birds that create nests and the insects that burrow deep, yes.
For the mammals and amphibians that make it their home, yes.
For the water that finds refuge, yes.
Industries have distorted our view of the world. Industries have made us think that the only value in forests is paper, pellets, and timber. But the value of standing forests is much more. There’s even value in dead and dying parts of the forest. There’s a big difference between tree plantations and biodiverse natural forests.
Why are tree plantations bad?A tree plantation is a crop. They’re even often called treefarms. Tree plantations are where people plant rows upon rows of one kind of tree. They’re often quick-growing and non-native. In tree plantations, even birdsong is hard to come by.
Tree plantations are worse than natural forests at providing:
- carbon storage
- water retention
- habitat for biodiverse species
Plus, tree plantations are more susceptible to forest fires. They’re a terrible replacement for natural forests. We should be pouring resources into saving our natural forests.
The circle of lifeThe cycles of nature are all inherently valuable.
When a tree falls, it begins something remarkable. After being a small part of a giant ecosystem, it becomes an ecosystem in itself. Naturally fallen trees become home to all the life-giving forces of nature. From the predators to the prey, from the worms to the fungi, from decay to life. It all happens in a hollowing log. The rot is home to much more than we’ll ever understand.
Woodpeckers nest and find food in rotting trees and logsWe often think of rot as bad news in our modern human lives. Rotting fruit in our homes means money lost. It means new food waste for our landfills. Rot in our gardens means our neighborhood beautification project is at risk. Rot in the wood of our homes or furniture is costly to repair.
But rot isn’t just essential. It’s inevitable. Nature and life are synonymous with rot. To grow fruit, seeds, saplings, and vegetables, the soil must be nutrient rich. That happens in part because of rot.
Some plants can take root in a way they couldn’t on a healthy standing tree. Some animals make their homes in dead trees. For decomposers to do their best work, they need rot and decay. Rot makes forests healthier.
The value of rotTo fully value nature we have to value all parts of it. Even those that are separate from our daily lives. By respecting the rot of nature, we can be better stewards of Mother Earth. We can’t create policies that don’t consider nature. Policies like that hurt nature, but they hurt us, too. We’re a part of nature. We must develop policies that account for the holistic functions of entire ecosystems.
We live in an era of devastation and forest destruction. We’re facing increasingly harsh impacts of climate change. It’s time for a different kind of forest advocacy. One that’s uncompromising in its love for all parts of nature. One that recognizes the big picture and doesn’t need a price tag or a pitch on its ROI.
Dogwood Alliance is a proud advocate for the trees, the forests, the rot, and the have-nots. Communities who are dismissed, undervalued, and over-polluted. Forests that suffer from our dismal track record of conservation, protection, and stewardship. We value all the parts that make us whole.
Together let’s fight for a better world. One with greater love for human and nonhuman life on this beautiful floating rock we call home. May we all find that love for ourselves, for one another, and for the forests.
Join the MovementThe post Respect the Rot appeared first on Dogwood Alliance.
Dirty Dozen™ food chemicals: Potassium bromate
Avoid or limit foods containing potassium bromate.
Potassium bromate has been classified as a possible carcinogen by the World Health Organization’s cancer research agency, based on evidence of kidney and thyroid tumors in animals. Potassium bromate is intended to convert to potassium bromide during baking, but some residual potassium bromate may remain in finished products.
What is potassium bromate?Potassium bromate is used as a dough strengthener, flour treating agent and oxidizing agent. It strengthens gluten, improves dough elasticity and helps bread rise more consistently, producing a higher-volume loaf.
Which foods contain potassium bromate?Potassium bromate is added to some flour and dough used to make bread products, including hamburger buns, sandwich bread, rolls, tortillas, pastries and crackers.
Look for potassium bromate in product ingredient lists, usually below or next to the Nutrition Facts panel, on the back of the package. It may also appear as “bromated flour” on ingredient labels.
How is potassium bromate regulated?The Food and Drug Administration is responsible for overseeing food additives and other ingredients. Potassium bromate entered the U.S. food supply before the 1958 Food Additives Amendment established the modern additive approval process, so it was never required to undergo full premarket safety review.
It remains permitted in bread, rolls and buns at up to 75 parts per million of flour weight. In 2024, the FDA identified potassium bromate as a priority additive for safety reassessment.
The WHO cancer research agency has classified potassium bromate as possibly carcinogenic to humans. It has been banned from food in the EU, U.K., Canada, Brazil, China, South Korea and many other countries.
Since 1990, potassium bromate has been on California’s Proposition 65 list of chemicals known to cause cancer. The state will prohibit potassium bromate in food starting in 2027. Arkansas enacted a ban in 2025, which will go into effect in 2028. New York has passed legislation, which awaits the governor’s signature, and numerous other states have introduced similar bills.
Potassium bromate is prohibited in certified organic foods under Agriculture Department organic standards, which bar synthetic substances.
What does the science say about potassium bromate?When bread bakes, heat is supposed to convert potassium bromate into potassium bromide, a less-harmful compound. But if baking times are too short, temperatures too low, or dough too thick, that conversion is incomplete – leaving residual potassium bromate in the finished product.
The kidney is the primary vulnerable organ: Long-term animal studies found significant increases in kidney tumors in rats, along with other tumors in the lining of the abdomen and, in some studies, the thyroid gland.
Laboratory and animal studies show that potassium bromate can cause oxidative stress – a buildup of reactive molecules that can damage cells – as well as DNA breaks and chromosomal damage.
Research has also found that potassium bromate can damage DNA through a distinct mechanism, generating reactive intermediates that cause specific DNA lesions. Those lesions can contribute to mutations.
Direct evidence of harm in humans is limited, and research about exactly how potassium bromate causes cancer is ongoing.
Find out moreLearn more about recommendations relating to potassium bromate – and the full EWG Dirty Dozen™ list of food chemicals – on EWG’s research page.
EWG’s Food Scores provides ratings for more than 150,000 foods and drinks based on nutrition, ingredients and processing concerns, and flags unhealthy ultra-processed foods to help you identify alternatives.
EWG’s Skin Deep® cosmetic database helps to identify harmful chemicals in personal care and beauty products. EWG Verified® products meet the strictest criteria for transparency and health.
And the Healthy Living™ app lets you take these tools with you on the go.
Areas of Focus Food & Water Food Ultra-Processed Foods Toxic Chemicals Food Chemicals Authors Sarah Reinhardt, MPH, RDN November 5, 2026Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ found in tap water of 197M Americans
WASHINGTON – About 197 million people in the U.S. drink drinking water contaminated with the toxic “forever chemicals” known as PFAS, according to test data released by the Environmental Protection Agency and recent state test results.
That’s 23 million more Americans exposed to PFAS in drinking water than the EPA found in previous tests.
The number aligns with findings from a 2020 paper by Environmental Working Group scientists that estimated PFAS was in the water of 200 million Americans.
The new EPA findings mark the last installment of tests of the nation’s drinking water supply conducted as part of the Fifth Unregulated Contaminant Monitoring Rule, or UCMR 5, the regulation that required U.S. water utilities to test drinking water for 29 individual PFAS compounds.
The UCMR 5 data reveal 3,595 sites with detectable levels of PFAS, bringing the total number of known PFAS-contaminated sites to 13,459.
“The new data confirms what we feared: PFAS contamination of tap water is as widespread as our study estimated in 2020,” said David Andrews, Ph.D., EWG’s chief science officer.
Protections under threatThe EPA results come against a backdrop of increasing environmental deregulation. The agency is in the final stages of rolling back limits on four PFAS chemicals.
The agency is retaining first-time drinking water standards for the two most notorious PFAS – PFOA and PFOS. And the EPA set a health goal of zero for these two chemicals because it has identified no level in tap water that is without health risk.
“We already know PFAS exposure has been linked to a variety of health harms and can be harmful in extremely small amounts. Delaying, weakening or abandoning PFAS limits would be detrimental to public health.” Andrews added.
In 2024, the Biden EPA finalized first-time limits on six PFAS in drinking water. The limits, called maximum contaminant levels, or MCLs, set enforceable standards for the amount of contaminants allowed in drinking water.
In a reversal last year, Trump’s EPA announced plans to leave four PFAS unregulated – GenX, PFBS, PFNA and PFHxS.
The agency plans to retain the PFOA and PFOS standards at 4 parts per trillion. But it also wants to extend the compliance deadline for meeting those standards to 2031.
The EPA’s plan to reverse the four MCLs also likely contradicts an anti-backsliding provision in the Safe Drinking Water Act. That law requires any revision to a federal drinking water standard to “maintain, or provide for greater, protection of the health of persons.”
“This isn’t just a regulatory change, it’s a public health betrayal. These rollbacks will expose American families to chemicals linked to cancer and other serious health issues,” said Scott Faber, EWG’s vice president for government affairs.
“The EPA is abandoning science-based protections at the exact moment its own tests prove we need them most,” he added.
Widespread PFAS pollutionEven if the limits for PFOA and PFOS remain in force, scrapping the four other limits will make it harder to hold polluters responsible for endangering millions of Americans by releasing toxic forever chemicals into U.S. waterways.
The EPA’s toxicity assessments of GenX and PFHxS – replacement chemicals for PFOA and PFOS – found that exposure to even extremely small doses could pose similarly serious health risks. Finalizing the rollback means the agency wouldn’t enforce limits on GenX and PFHxS in tap water.
EWG estimates nearly 30,000 industrial polluters could be discharging PFAS into the environment, including into sources of drinking water. Restrictions on industrial discharges would lower the amount of PFAS ending up in drinking water sources.
Other organizations have found similarly concerning levels of PFAS contamination as EWG’s estimates. A recent report from Environment America found that PFAS was detected in 83% of rivers, lakes, streams and other surface waters between 2022 and 2024.
“It’s time to turn off the tap and address drinking water contamination at the source. For PFAS, that’s chemical plants, industrial sites and any manufacturers unnecessarily using these chemicals,” said Faber.
Health risks of PFAS exposurePFAS are known as “forever chemicals” because once released into the environment, they do not break down, and they can build up in the body. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has detected PFAS in the blood of 99% of Americans, including newborn babies.
Very low doses of PFAS have been linked to suppression of the immune system. Studies show exposure to PFAS can also increase the risk of cancer, harm fetal development and reduce vaccine effectiveness.
“Consumers shouldn’t have to worry about the safety of the water that comes from their tap,” Andrews said. “With 197 million people exposed to PFAS in their drinking water, government regulators must hold polluters accountable and ensure utilities have the resources to remove these toxic forever chemicals.”
While the cost of removing PFAS from drinking water should not fall on consumers, numerous home filter options can help,” he added.
For people who know of or suspect the presence of PFAS in their tap water, a home filtration system is the most efficient way to reduce exposure. Reverse osmosis and activated carbon water filters can effectively remove these chemicals. But consumers should make sure to change their filters as recommended.
In 2023, EWG researchers tested the performance of 10 popular water filters to evaluate how well each reduced PFAS levels detected in home tap water.
###
The Environmental Working Group is a nonprofit, non-partisan organization that empowers people to live healthier lives in a healthier environment. Through research, advocacy and unique education tools, EWG drives consumer choice and civic action. Visit www.ewg.org for more information.
Areas of Focus Water Toxic Chemicals PFAS Chemicals EPA, state PFAS data confirm EWG’s 2020 estimate as Trump moves to scrap protections Press Contact JR Culpepper jr.culpepper@ewg.org (202) 779-9990 November 5, 2026The Clock is Ticking for TFFF: Will COP31 Deliver Where COP30 Failed?
This article was originally published by Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung
By Valentina Figuera Martínez and Oli Munnion
The re-election of Lula da Silva in Brazil’s presidential race is a huge victory for progressive politics in Latin America, narrowly avoiding descent once more into the chaos of the far-right Bolsonaro dynasty. Lula’s decisive win is also a victory against U.S. interventionism, and the Trump Administration’s efforts to impose its political, neocolonial and military dominance across the region.
However, one consequence of the result is that a lifeline has been thrown to the Tropical Forest Forever Facility (TFFF), a new and highly controversial forest finance scheme championed by the Brazilian government. A Bolsonaro victory would undoubtedly have been the final nail in the coffin for TFFF, a silver lining to an otherwise very big, dark cloud.
The TFFF is still on life support though—it has until the end of the year to secure USD 10 billion in initial funding, which it has so far failed to do, or face key investors such as the Norwegian government pulling out, regardless of whether Lula or Bolsonaro sit in the presidential chair.
This makes COP31 make or break for TFFF. Although not on the formal agenda of the UN climate negotiations, the scheme’s backers will be desperately seeking additional pledges in the corridors of the Antalya conference centre.
Alongside the failure of COP30 in Belém, Brazil, to establish a binding roadmap to end deforestation, the TFFF also fell short of its promise to secure the “future of tropical forests”. Brazil’s flagship financing scheme had attracted only USD 6.7 billion in sponsor capital, well below the USD 25 billion initially required to operate at a full scale.
What it did attract was widespread opposition from civil society and Indigenous Peoples’ organisations. Messaging against TFFF featured prominently in demonstrations in Belém, and a statement rejecting TFFF and defending forest rights was signed by 205 organisations, many of which were participating in counter-mobilisations.1
The plan had been to use the USD 25 billion in sponsor capital to issue up to USD 100 billion of “senior market debt” (low interest rate, high repayment priority loans and bonds), at a one to four leverage, to build a total investment fund of USD 125 billion.
This sum would then be invested by the fund at a higher rate of return in order to generate an anticipated revenue of USD four billion per year, which would be paid to tropical forest countries in exchange for conserving one billion hectares of standing tropical forests.
In Belém, sponsor capital pledges from the Global North included Norway’s USD 3 billion, Germany’s €1 billion (USD 1.15 billion), and France’s €500 million (USD 577 million), totalling USD 4.7 billion, all with specific conditions and strings attached.
So far, more than a quarter of TFFF funds come from countries that are supposed to be its main beneficiaries
Brazil and Indonesia, which are two of the three largest tropical forest countries, committed USD one billion each in sponsor capital. That means that so far, more than a quarter of TFFF funds come from countries that are supposed to be its main beneficiaries.
In addition to these five countries, very small pledges from the Netherlands (USD 5 million), Portugal (USD 1 million), and the Minderoo Foundation (USD 10 million) brought the total to USD 6.7 billion, although this sum isn’t available immediately due to several of the conditions imposed.2
Since then, other pledges have trickled in, such as the UK’s £400 million (approximately USD 534 million), and another USD 500 million from the Netherlands post-election, taking the total to USD 7.8 billion. At the same time though, Europe’s steady march to the right and cooling of climate commitments has put some pledges in doubt. A member of the German Chancellor’s CDU budget committee has argued that Germany’s €1bn investment is hard to justify and should be removed from the 2027 national budget.
A “once-in-a-generation initiative (…) via an innovative financing mechanism” was promised, but what is the financial logic behind the TFFF and will it tackle the underlying drivers of deforestation? Let’s start at the beginning.
Whose Proposal Is It?The Brazilian government claims that the TFFF is led by Global South tropical forest countries. In reality, it is a proposal written by bankers for bankers, and was conceived of in the Global North under the leadership of the World Bank.
One of its earliest iterations was a set of four papers published in 2018 by the Center for Global Development (CGD) under the title “Creating a Multilateral Wealth Fund for a Global Public Good: A Proposal for a Tropical Forest Finance Facility”. Among the authors is Kenneth Lay, former vice president and treasurer of the World Bank from 2006 to 2010. Other Global North contributors are cited, as well as officials from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank.
However, there is no mention of Brazil, Indonesia or the Democratic Republic of the Congo in this initial documentation, and the participation of these tropical forest countries and the subsequent leadership of the Brazilian government have come later, giving legitimacy to the scheme.
A Neo-Colonial Economic Model Underlies the TFFFAccording to the 2018 version of the scheme,
“TFFF is a proposal to mobilise significant low-cost resources which can be invested in private markets to generate a financial return for rewarding successful actions that contribute to achieving a global goal, reduced deforestation. (…) Utilising primarily public funds to generate investment profits from the private sector that in turn provide international finance for public goods could serve to move beyond the finite borders of overseas development aid.”
From its inception, the intention was clear: the TFFF was designed to use limited public funds to leverage much larger private investments in order to generate profit for wealthy investors and claim to contribute to “halting deforestation”. A convenient formula for limiting public contributions and maximising private returns, while claiming deforestation benefits in the Global South.
This original 2018 financial logic has been revived in the three concept notes subsequently presented by the Brazilian government3, which hinge on: 1) converting money borrowed from wealthy investor countries and companies into profit that can be used to “drive change in developing countries”; and 2) distributing these funds using a results-based aid approach once pre-agreed measurable outcomes are achieved.
In essence, it reproduces a neo-colonial and technocratic dynamic.
In essence, it reproduces a neo-colonial and technocratic dynamic that privileges “measurable outcomes” over lived realities, reducing complex social, cultural, and ecological factors to narrow metrics. What is easy to measure tends to be prioritised over what matters most, sidelining gender justice, Indigenous governance systems, collective rights, structural drivers of inequality and other forms of environmental harm beyond deforestation.
TFFF is presented as a “country-led” approach, but reinforces a paternalistic mindset in which donors and Global North actors “drive change” in the Global South, rather than addressing historical responsibility for climate breakdown, ecological harm, colonial crimes, and debt injustices.
The TFFF is seen by its proponents as a unique opportunity to kill two birds with one stone, allowing private investors to make money and secure corporate greenwashing by reporting their alleged “contributions” to ‘Net Zero commitments’ and ‘nature positive finance’, such as the Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures (TNFD)4. All of which have been denounced by civil society as controversial schemes to perpetuate corporate abuses, human rights violations and environmental crimes.
Who is Really Funding the Fund?One of the most concerning aspects of the scheme is its heavy reliance on bond markets for Global South debt. In essence, the money used to “protect” tropical forests will be largely paid for by countries in the Global South, through debt servicing and payments to wealthy international investors. As the Third World Network has warned, the real financing will come from “developing countries themselves, disguised by the international capital markets as ‘natural’ return on investments”.
This reflects a perverse money-machine logic: the TFFF will borrow billions of dollars from sponsors and wealthy investors at a lower interest rate, and then invest those resources heavily in emerging market bonds, issued, for example, by highly indebted Global South countries or companies driving deforestation that need immediate liquidity, at a higher rate of return. These emerging market bonds are issued at higher interest rates as they are judged to involve higher risk for the lender (in this case, the TFFF), as it is assumed, for example, that Global South borrowers are more likely to default.
The TFIF will make its money through deepening the debt crisis and insolvency in the Global South.
The profit generated through this difference in interest rates (and often unjust assessment of risk) will then be used primarily to repay lenders, cover World Bank fees, and service interest on sponsor capital. Only if there are profits left over following these transactions would any funds actually be transferred to tropical forest countries. Therefore, the TFIF will make its money through deepening the debt crisis and insolvency in the Global South, at a time when debt levels are already unprecedented.
Merel van der Mark, Forests and Finance Coalition Coordinator and an expert on financial mechanisms, has made the link between a failure of the Global North to pay what is owed when it comes to climate and biodiversity finance, and the shift towards private finance to make up the shortfall.
In an interview given for this article, she explains how
“for years and years, tropical forest countries have asked for support from richer countries, for the protection of their forests. But rich countries have failed to mobilise the amounts that are needed to achieve real forest protection.”
“So the TFFF seems to me a sad acknowledgement that rich countries are not doing their part, and that the only way to mobilise them to allocate money to forest protection is if they get their money back, with interest. So in that sense, I think that TFFF does not mobilise finance in an equitable way.”
Deforestation as a Market FailureThe TFFF’s rationale is that by valuing standing tropical forests, the fund will address a “market failure” by assigning a value to, and paying for, the “ecosystem services” provided by tropical forests, thereby incentivising their protection over their destruction or degradation. The financialisation of nature is therefore the proposal’s driving force, where forests are turned into a market value that can generate returns, prioritising capital accumulation above human rights, ecosystem integrity, and all other considerations.
This poses a profound contradiction: the dominant economic system that turns nature into a financial asset is destroying the cultures, practices, rights and relationships to territories of Indigenous Peoples, local communities, women, and youth—the commodification of nature is therefore not compatible with respecting the interdependent complexities that make up an ecosystem.5
The structural drivers of deforestation are precisely the same commodity supply chains and industrial processes that fuel the current economic system.
Aligning an economic and financial system designed to extract wealth from nature and forest-dependent peoples with the protection of tropical forests is a paradox in itself. The structural drivers of deforestation are precisely the same commodity supply chains and industrial processes that fuel the current economic system: agribusiness, intensive livestock farming, mining, fossil fuel extraction, infrastructure development, logging for pulp and paper and biomass energy, among other economic sectors.
The same financial system that will sustain the TFFF generates vast profits from companies driving deforestation. It’s like deliberately fighting a losing battle, just to ensure profits for wealthy investors.
The Propaganda Trap: IPLC “Advice” Is Not the Same as Decision-Making PowerA key pillar of the TFFF is that tropical forest countries will allocate a minimum of 20% of payments they receive to supporting Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities (IPLCs). This means that if a tropical forest country receives USD four per hectare of standing forest, 80 cents would have to be allocated to IPLCs.
Subsequently, the most recent TFFF proposal (Concept Note 3.1) developed “Guiding Principles for the Allocation to Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities”, and established a “Technical and Scientific Advisory Panel” and an “IPLCs Advisory Council”. Primarily composed of 10 IPLC representatives, the IPLCs Advisory Council will only advise the TFFF Board, and will have no access to decision-making over mobilising and managing the fund’s overall resources. Moreover, the members of the IPLCs Advisory Council will need to be approved by the TFFF Board.
The really important decisions will be taken by the Board of the Tropical Forest Investment Fund (TFIF), which is the “financial heart” of the fund and responsible for managing the capital (discussed in more detail below). As the World Rainforest Movement (WRM) points out in its analysis of the scheme, it is a mechanism steeped in colonial rationale. Giving IPLCs an advisory role and the power to decide how a fraction of the leftover resources are spent is not the same as giving them full access to decision-making and participation in the fund’s governance structure.
Chief Ninawa Huni Kui, an Indigenous leader from the Brazilian Amazon and president of the Federation of the Huni Kui Indigenous People in Acre, Brazil, is highly skeptical of the scheme. In an interview given for this article, he said:
“I don’t believe we will have positive results with those actions. The Tropical Forest Forever Facility is just another propaganda trap that will generate huge profits [for wealthy investors]. From a critical perspective, it is a form of co-optation: involving Indigenous Peoples without letting them make the decisions. It’s another deception. The fund’s decisions will not respond to the real desires and needs of all peoples. This ends up weakening the Indigenous movement, rather than strengthening it”.
In addition to concerns about decision-making, the Huni Kui leader also sees the TFFF’s speculative nature as a contradiction to the cosmovision of Indigenous Peoples. “A capitalist fund is very contrary to the spiritual worldviews of Indigenous Peoples, to the relationship between bem viver6 and territories. Financial resources cannot be confused with bem viver. ‘I’ll give them some money and they’ll have a better relationship with nature.’ It’s not about that. We’re talking about a deeper notion; it’s about reverence and recognition of nature,” he said.
On top of this, the fund’s stated commitment to equity, rights and inclusion—expressed through the introduction of “funding access modalities” for IPLCs and tropical forest countries—is not guaranteed in the event of market stress, liquidity pressure, drawdowns or default. Even if the financial architecture of the fund remains intact, tropical forest countries, and therefore IPLCs, may receive no payments, as priority would be given to repaying investors.
TFIF: the Real Decision-Making PlayerThe governance structure of the TFFF involves two independent entities: the Tropical Forest Investment Fund (TFIF) and the Tropical Forest Forever Facility (“the Facility” or TFFF).
The TFIF will be responsible for mobilising and managing financial resources, and will take important decisions through the TFIF Board, a central institution in the scheme. The TFIF will have its own governance structure and the freedom to make “market-driven decisions”, which will inevitably mean prioritising economic interests over rights. The TFFF will be limited to “oversee[ing] the forest cover rewards system, including eligibility criteria, monitoring methodologies, and disbursement rules”.
The TFFF Board will include eighteen member countries: nine sponsor countries and nine non-sponsor tropical forest countries that meet the criteria set out in the Facility Charter, the fund’s institutional governance framework, which will guide implementation arrangements, eligibility criteria, and other foundational considerations. All sponsor countries contributing at least USD one billion to the TFFF will be granted a seat on the TFFF Board, until the total number reaches nine.
The Technical and Scientific Advisory Panel and the IPLCs Advisory Council will function under the supervision of the TFFF Board, which limits their decision-making power in key areas such as conflict resolution, enforcement action, defining indicators, and setting baselines. This contradicts principles of Free, Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC) and weakens democratic control.
On the other hand, the TFIF Board will consist of “professionals” with the required “expertise”, and will be nominated and appointed by the “Sovereign Sponsors” (national governments providing sponsor capital) from an “independent committee’s recommendation”.
The Role of the World BankThe World Bank will be the scheme’s trustee and host the TFFF Secretariat, and may also “provide certain Treasury Management services to TFIF”. Its reputation has been discredited in the Global South as it has been widely recognised for sinking countries in debt, imposing unjust conditions on loans, shaping economies to benefit big corporations instead of people, and even backing military dictatorships.
The TFFF will therefore be hosted by and benefit an organisation responsible for promoting policies that exacerbate inequalities and ecological impacts in the Global South7, which could prove even more problematic in times of global crisis and financial instability.
The payment hierarchy that the World Bank will oversee will be determined according to the revenues of the TFIF, and will be prioritised in the following way:
- Bond-holders, including “debt service and fees payments” to those who lent their money to the TFFF and World Bank fees;
- Other Private investors;
- Sovereign sponsors, which are mainly state loans;
- In last place, eligible tropical forest countries that have a deforestation rate lower than 0,5 percent.
If revenues decline, payments to tropical forest countries will be the first to be postponed, and if things get even worse, the TFIF will “commence an orderly liquidation”.
This payment hierarchy matters: in years when returns are low, forest-based payments would be reduced before investor returns are affected. In extreme market downturns, forest-related payments might pause altogether. Next in line would be reductions in payments to sovereign sponsors, further protecting the interests of private investors.
Payments to IPLCs will therefore be the lowest priority, while the interests of sponsors and wealthy private investors will be protected through the fund’s investment strategy. Trying to align profit-making with environmental outcomes in this way could therefore put more pressure on forest-dependent communities, as it is ultimately they that will bear the greatest risk burden from market volatility, potential liquidation, and penalties.
Will the TFFF Incentivise Investments that Harm Forests?Although the TFFF’s concept note 3.1 states that investments in deforestation, coal, peat, oil, and gas will be excluded, the fund’s unclear investment exclusion criteria are a serious concern. Questions remain unanswered about whether and how the criteria would effectively prohibit investments in sectors that cause deforestation, and ensure that companies that are linked to harmful biodiversity impacts would not benefit from the scheme.
Van der Mark points out that there are many more industrial sectors that have “impacts on biodiversity, like the use of agrotoxics and intensive water use, that are for now not excluded. And here lies a tension, because if the exclusion criteria are too strict, they will exclude too many activities and the fund won’t be able to generate the returns it needs to make the payments to forest countries.”
Generating profits from speculative financial markets while relying on exclusion criteria to avoid investing in biodiversity-destroying activities reveals a fundamental contradiction at the fund’s core. What’s the point in creating a scheme that could lead to social and environmental harms if safeguards are not developed and strictly enforced?
The TFFF also claims that it will have strict criteria to ensure that payments to tropical forest countries will be reduced significantly if their deforestation rates increase. However, as van der Mark explains, there is a risk of leakage to other biomes if TFFF-related payments mean that commodity production just expands into areas not covered by the scheme.
Furthermore, “there is also the risk that intensification of production on already converted areas, through the use of more fertilisers and pesticides, will harm nature in other ways than through deforestation.” The TFFF’s criteria are not able to mitigate either of these risks.
The TFFF may become another tool to instrumentalise finance for destruction
Civil society organisations have long warned about the urgent need to halt destructive finance that is directed towards activities that harm forests and biodiversity. Ironically, by its design, the TFFF may become another tool to instrumentalise finance for destruction, displace forest loss into other biomes within eligible tropical forest countries, and detract from efforts to fundamentally change how international finance flows.
The current climate and biodiversity finance architecture—designed to support the goals of the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC)—is subservient to the extractive economic model. The barriers to accessing funding by Global South countries, such as power asymmetries, debt injustices and challenges in resource mobilisation are not going to be overcome with debt-driven conservation schemes like the TFFF.
“As much as it’s important to mobilise finance for nature protection, as TFFF is trying to do, it is even far more important to regulate harmful finance. If destructive finance is not halted, it’s like mopping the floor with the tap still open,”
explains van der Mark.
“To really halt destructive finance, we must address the core problem: our economic system built on extractivism and a structural dependence on perpetual growth. This growth imperative drives ecological overshoot, social inequity, and financial practices that externalise harm while privatising gains. We need to shift to an economic system that operates within planetary boundaries, that restores ecosystems, and prioritises sufficiency over accumulation.”
Real Solutions: Addressing the Root Causes of Deforestation and Biodiversity LossMarket-based approaches to climate change and biodiversity loss are constantly embroiled in scandals and facing serious questions over integrity.8 Concerns over human rights violations and poor performance records demand alternative approaches rooted in human rights, traditional knowledge, and gender justice.
An effective funding mechanism must aim to address the root causes of deforestation, climate change and biodiversity loss, as well as transform dominant economic and financial structures to prioritise nature and social equity over private interests. While common but differentiated responsibilities among countries are a crucial foundation to build strong finance architecture around, the TFFF design has major flaws and won’t be able to mobilise resources in a sustained, gender-responsive, equitable and predictable manner for tropical forest countries. Instead, the TFFF is a speculative financial mechanism that will feed off Global South debt and gamble on volatile financial markets amid geopolitical instability.
The much-lauded 20 percent direct access to funds for IPLCs is a trap designed to buy support from Indigenous groups: having a say over the leftovers is not the same as having full governance power over the fund. Indigenous Peoples, local communities, women and youth must have full access to decision-making in the entire governance structure of any fund that truly wants to be effective.
An effective fund must ensure continuous capacity-building, legal protection, and strong regulations to protect land rights, alongside a robust grievance mechanism. It must also actively support efforts to dismantle the financial incentives that drive deforestation, while strengthening legal systems to address the high levels of risk faced by environmental defenders when protecting their territories.9
An effective fund must ensure continuous capacity-building, legal protection, and strong regulations to protect land rights
Moreover, institutional arrangements and policy decisions that genuinely aim to enable transformative change must address underlying structural constraints, including:
Debt restructuring and cancellation10, and tax justice: priority must be given to relieving the fiscal pressures on Global South countries to expand commodity production and dependence on destructive activities. Public sources of funding must be increased to fund social and environmental priorities, rather than perpetuating the debt crisis. In this context, taxing the super-rich and extractive sectors is an urgent conversation to design an efficient fund capable of addressing the root causes of deforestation and biodiversity loss.
Recognition of ecological debt: Global North countries are historically responsible for the majority of biodiversity destruction and ecological degradation, but they continue to evade their responsibilities. Only two countries have contributed their share of USD 20 billion per year agreed under the Kunming–Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework (KMGBF)11. An effective fund must ensure not only human rights-based and gender-responsive approaches, but also recognise the colonial legacies of nature depletion and its implications for societies, economies, traditional cultures, and ecosystems.
Increasing public finance for biodiversity and climate action while lessening the fiscal pressures that push Global South countries toward biodiversity-harming activities is essential to achieving meaningful and lasting outcomes.
In Conclusion: The Ecological Collapse Caused by Capitalism will not be Solved with More CapitalismGenuine efforts to curb deforestation demand moving away from market-based approaches that perpetuate wealth accumulation and greenwashing, and instead support inclusive decision-making while confronting the structural drivers of forest loss. The TFFF cannot meaningfully challenge agribusiness, extractive industries, illegal logging, false solutions, and perverse incentives that sustain destructive activities.
Forest protection requires robust, rights-based public financing mechanisms.
At its core, the TFFF is a leveraged bet on risky emerging market debt12 that embodies contradictory approaches to forest conservation and diverts attention from the urgent need to halt the expansion of extractive sectors. It also obscures the role of state policies—often shaped by pressures from the international financial system—that render extractivism a perceived necessity for maintaining financial stability.
Forest protection requires robust, rights-based public financing mechanisms that place ecosystem integrity and the rights of Indigenous Peoples and local communities at the center, rather than market-driven schemes that demand regulation, investment screening, and social and environmental safeguards.
Real solutions are already being built on the ground, and we must work towards ensuring that the right financial resources, as well as political, social and economic conditions, are in place to allow them to flourish. These alternatives need to be strengthened, policies must be coherent, and key conditions such as land rights must be guaranteed.
Recognising that forests and biodiversity cannot be treated as commodities or financial assets is essential. Fundamentally, the ecological collapse caused by capitalism will not be solved with more capitalism.
- 1“NO to TFFF, YES to Forest Rights. Statement from Civil Society Organisations on the Launch of the Tropical Forests Forever Fund (TFFF)”, Global Forest Coalition (GFC), November 2025, https://globalforestcoalition.org/no-to-tfff-yes-to-forest-rights/.
- 2See “Investment Tracker,” TFFF Watch, https://tfffwatch.org/investment-tracker/Norway.
- 3The first Concept Note was published by the Brazilian government in July 2024, the second one in February 2025, the third one in August 2025, and the fourth one (Version 3.1) was released in October 2025.
- 4The TNFD is a voluntary initiative for corporate greenwashing made up of a group of large corporations–including many with a terrible track record in environmental issues. It is based on the core claim that more self-reporting by corporations on their nature-related impacts is key to solving the biodiversity crisis. This taskforce has been developing a framework on what a business should report on. To learn more see “The TNFD: What it is, who’s behind it and why it’s a major greenwashing risk,” Global Forest Coalition (GFC), December 2022. The TFFF will allow corporations profiting off environmental abuse to report “compliance”with the TNFD, and apply “financial products” that supposedly “support nature” to greenwash their polluting activities.
- 5For an analysis on commodifying nature and avoiding a real change see “Marketing the planet: The financialization of nature”, by Helena Paul, Radical Ecological Democracy, January 2022, https://www.cbd.int/cms/ui/forums/attachment.aspx?id=417&exp=639052793791354386&uid=1&key=07baea2208edfad639fb5530f97da407.
- 6South American Indigenous philosophy that favors deep relationships between humans and nature over individualistic material and consumerist development. See Alberto Acosta, The Dictionary of Radical Alternatives, https://dictionaryofradicalalternatives.org/Concepts:Buen_Vivir/Alberto_Acosta/English; and Eduardo Gudynas and Alberto Acosta, “La renovación de la crítica al desarrollo y el buen vivir como alternativa”, Utopía y Praxis Latinoamericana, 2011, https://www.redalyc.org/pdf/279/27919220007.pdf.
- 7See also The World Bank: A Critical History (2023), by Éric Toussaint, https://www.plutobooks.com/product/the-world-bank-a-critical-history/.
- 8“Rise in legal challenges over carbon credit schemes”, The Guardian, June 25, 2025, https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2025/jun/25/courts-corporate-carbon-offsetting-claims-lse-report; Souparna Lahiri and Valentina Figuera Martínez, Biodiversity Offsetting: A corporate social license to perpetuate biodiversity destruction and gender inequality, Global Forest Coalition (GFC), October 2024, https://globalforestcoalition.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/EN_Biodiversity-Offsetting-Briefer.pdf.
- 9For an investigation on the struggles of environmental defenders see “Collective Power: The Struggle for Protection for Land and Environmental Defeders” September 16, 2026, Global Witness, https://globalwitness.org/en/campaigns/land-and-environmental-defenders/collective-power/.
- 10For an analysis of the key reasons why debt is relevant to biodiversity protection and should remain on the agenda of international policy processes, see Jessica Dempsey and Audrey Irvine-Broque, “Addressing debt is critical to halting biodiversity loss”, March 2022, Third World Network, https://www.twn.my/title2/briefing_papers/twn/Debt%20biodiversity%20TWNBP%20Mar%202022%20Dempsey.pdf.
- 11Pettinotti, L., Cao, Y., Kamninga, T. and Colenbrander, S. (2024) A fair share of biodiversity finance? Apportioning responsibility for the $20 billion target by 2025. ODI Working Paper. London: ODI (https://odi.org/en/about/our-work/a-fair-share-of-biodiversity-finance)
- 12See Max Alexander Matthey and Aidan Hollis, “The Tropical Forest Forever Facility (TFFF): Brazil’s $125bn Rainforest Gamble,” Substack, September 2025, https://substack.com/home/post/p-174014902.
Nearly 7M U.S. school students may be exposed to pesticides used to treat crop fields
Nearly 20,000 U.S. public elementary and middle schools sit within a quarter-mile of crop fields where harmful pesticides may be sprayed, a new EWG analysis finds. Almost 7 million students attend those schools and could be exposed, including more than 575,000 at schools within 200 feet of a field.
Pesticide applications could be putting children, families and school staff at risk because they lack basic protections such as buffer zones and warnings.
INTERACTIVE MAP U.S. elementary and middle schools near crop fieldsThis map shows the number and percentage of elementary and middle schools within a quarter mile, 1,000 feet and 200 feet of what the Department of Agriculture considers to be a crop field. These schools have the potential to be in the “spray zone” of pesticides that may be used on these fields. Pesticides sprayed on crop land can harm children who attend schools nearby.
View hereChildren face higher risks of the potential health harms linked to pesticides because their developing bodies and nervous systems are more vulnerable to chemical toxicity. Two hundred feet is close enough for harmful drift to reach classrooms and playgrounds. In addition to students, thousands of teachers and other school staff are at risk.
EWG’s new map allows users to see how many schools in their state, county, congressional district or state legislative district are at risk. It does not account for public high schools or private schools. Nor does it include the thousands of public parks, playgrounds and ball fields where children live and play that may also be sprayed with pesticides. Schools were considered if they contained at least one grade that is K-8.
Research shows that pesticides are often detected inside homes as far as a half-mile from spraying. EWG found 1,932 public elementary and middle schools within just 200 feet of application and 19,208 within a quarter-mile of a crop field that could be treated with pesticides – one out of every four schools in America.
And it doesn’t matter where kids go to school – this is a nationwide issue:
- In New York, over 550 schools are within a quarter-mile of a crop field, totaling over 200,000 students.
- In Ohio, almost 1,000 schools and 400,000 children are within a quarter-mile of a crop field.
- In Florida, over 270 schools and almost 150,000 children.
- In Colorado, 340 schools and over 100,000 children.
- In Vermont, more than 71% of schools in the state are within a quarter-mile of a crop field.
But families lack key information about these commercial pesticide applications. Parents and caregivers deserve the certainty of knowing their children are not being exposed to harmful pesticides when they are at school. They have the right to know when pesticides are being applied near their schools, who is applying them, what is being applied and what precautions are being taken to protect children.
EWG’s map makes it clear that Congress must do more to protect consumers and kids at schools from commercial applications of toxic chemicals.
That’s why EWG and Consumer Reports are urging Congress to reject any new pesticide laws unless they include the Consumer Pesticide Safety Bill of Rights – a road map for making the food Americans eat and the communities they live in safer. It addresses long-running gaps in pesticide protection, and it includes a call for Congress to ensure that children are safe from pesticide exposure while at school.
What are the health risks of pesticide exposure?Studies show that living near pesticide spraying is linked to harm to the respiratory system, increased risk of cancer and harm to the developing fetus, such as low birth weight and reduced IQ.
According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, children are especially susceptible to potential health problems stemming from pesticide exposure, such as neurological and behavioral development, endocrine disruption and cancer.
Spraying creates dangers not just for kids at schools close to fields where pesticides are used but also for those in more distant neighborhoods, where chemicals may drift.
Pesticide air monitoring has shown some pesticides can travel miles from the application site. Evidence suggests health harms such as pediatric cancers may be associated with pesticide applications up to 2.5 miles away.
How is pesticide use regulated near schools?Many states, cities and counties have adopted legal standards to restrict pesticide spraying near schools, citing the risks it poses to children, whose bodies and brains are still developing. But these protections vary from state to state.
More than 40 states – including Georgia, Illinois, New York, North Carolina and Texas – have restricted how and when pesticides can be sprayed near schools.
Alabama and North Carolina, for example, ban crop dusting near schools. Many other states – including Arizona, Louisiana, Maine, Michigan and New Hampshire – have placed buffer zones that restrict pesticide spraying around schools.
Illinois and other states require that alerts be posted on school grounds to tell students before or after spraying.
Some states, including Kentucky, Minnesota and Nevada, require that parents be notified. Others, like Louisiana and Pennsylvania, require schools to track students who are sensitive to pesticides.
Other states, including Georgia and New Mexico, limit the hours when pesticides can be sprayed near schools. California prohibits pesticide applications within a quarter-mile of public schools during the hours when children are most likely to be present. The state also requires additional notifications, reporting and training,
What should the Environmental Protection Agency and Congress do?State regulations and laws are inconsistent, and many help parents and students only after they have been exposed to toxic chemicals or when it is too late.
The standards also always assume pesticides will be applied without error by the applicator – something that isn’t always done.
Instead, the federal government should set a minimum standard for buffer zones around schools, and ensure states’ ability to go further. Even though the people who spread the chemicals on farm fields may already be required to wear special protective gear, communities nearby remain unprotected.
Congress and the EPA can also ensure proper notifications are sent if pesticides are applied near schools, as many states already require.
Parents and families should not have to track down a government registry, pay a fee or require a doctor’s note to be notified of pesticide applications that could expose them, their children or their pets to toxics. Families deserve to know whether someone living or working near their home has applied pesticides that can make people sick.
As with some state programs, the EPA and states should work together to proactively notify people of commercial pesticide applications near their homes and schools. This would give parents more information to potentially lower their kids’ exposure risk.
Pesticide companies, including Bayer’s Monsanto and ChemChina’s Syngenta, are actively trying to hide pesticide application information from consumers. These companies are trying to boost pesticide sales and hide the risks from industrial chemical use.
Now, they’re trying to push Congress to quickly reauthorize a pesticide law, the Pesticide Registration Improvement Act, without making any changes to protect the public.
Congress might consider renewing the Pesticide Registration Improvement Act as early as December. The current law, through which the chemical industry negotiates fees that fund the EPA’s pesticide reviews, is set to expire next September.
Lawmakers shouldn’t support any new pesticide law that fails to protect consumers and kids at school. Any such legislation should adopt EWG and Consumer Reports’ Consumer Pesticide Safety Bill of Rights – making clear that consumers deserve to be protected from toxic chemicals.
Food was on the table. Now Congress should deliver.
Food was on the table during the election – and voters are hungry for change.
While many issues mattered to voters, polling shows that food issues like rising food inflation, food safety and how food affects our health were as important as health care and other concerns.
For starters, voters want Congress to do more to make sure that our food is safe. In particular, Congress should make sure the chemicals added to our food meet tough safety standards. Congress should also do more to keep our food free from pathogens and contaminants like the “forever chemicals” known as PFAS.
When farmers offer to adopt regenerative practices like cover crops, Congress should make sure they get financial support.
Voters also want Congress to do more to ensure consumers have access to healthy food. In particular, Congress should require that our schools offer healthier options, and some states have already acted to phase out harmful ultra-processed foods.
Voters also want Congress to restore funding cuts to anti-hunger programs and take steps to address rising food prices. Reducing tariffs on food imports and breaking up monopolies would be good places to start.
Until the election, few of these issues got the attention we deserve. Now that the voters have spoken, it’s time for Congress to deliver a recipe for success.
Here are seven steps the new Congress can take right away to provide consumers with more safe, healthy, and affordable food:
- The new Congress should require that all new food chemicals are reviewed for safety before they are added to our food. Right now, 99% of new food chemicals are reviewed for safety by the chemical companies, not the safety experts at the Food and Drug Administration.
- The new Congress should require that pesticide residues found on the fruits and vegetables most commonly eaten by our kids meet the toughest safety standards, and that safety experts at the Environmental Protection Agency quickly review pesticides when they are banned by other nations.
- The new Congress should define ultra processed foods and require a disclosure on food labels so we can find healthier options when we shop.
- The new Congress should make sure that food safety experts carefully track pathogens and regularly inspect food manufacturing plants and fruit and vegetable farms to reduce the risk posed by pathogens like cyclospora.
- The new Congress should direct food safety experts to set limits on the amount of toxic PFAS in our food and ban PFAS in cookware.
- The new Congress should triple spending on regenerative farming practices like cover crops to help address water pollution in places like Iowa. Right now, three out of four farmers are turned away when they seek help to adopt regenerative farming practices.
- The new Congress should rescind the cuts to anti-hunger programs that have increased hunger at a time of rising food prices. Everyone should have enough to eat.
Food is a kitchen table issue. There’s much more Congress should do to make our food a priority. These seven steps are a good place to start.
Areas of Focus Food Ultra-Processed Foods Food Chemicals Authors Scott Faber November 4, 2026Historic midterms deliver clear message to Congress: Prioritize people’s health and well-being
WASHINGTON – The American people have sent a powerful message with the historic midterm elections: They demand a government that works for them, not a government corrupted by the power of polluters and corporate interests.
The sweeping rejection of the Trump administration’s policies presents Congress’ incoming Democratic majority with both an opportunity and an obligation to deliver on the issues that matter most to families.
The Environmental Working Group says the next Congress should pursue efforts to provide safe, healthy food and clean drinking water, strengthen protections against toxic chemicals and pesticides, and support affordable clean energy.
The following is a statement from EWG President and Co-founder Ken Cook:
This historic election is a celebration of American pluralism – and a reminder that, to paraphrase Benjamin Franklin’s warning, we have a republic, if we can keep it.
Last night’s results offer us a reason for optimism and a renewed confidence that progress is possible. By listening to voters and putting people first, we can begin to restore trust in government, and build a healthier, safer and more hopeful future for generations to come.
The results are also a resounding rejection of President Donald Trump’s agenda and a powerful affirmation of the values that make America stronger: opportunity, accountability and the fundamental promise that government should work for the people, not powerful corporate interests.
The people are fed up with policies that cater to polluters and corrupt corporate interests ahead of the health, safety and economic well-being of millions of Americans.
Democrats now have an opportunity – and an obligation – to deliver on a different vision, one grounded in the kitchen-table issues that matter to families every day. That means fighting for clean, safe, healthy food free from harmful pesticides and toxic additives; drinking water free from dangerous contaminants; and affordable, clean energy.
It means holding polluters accountable, restoring the government’s ability to protect public health and the environment, and rejecting the playbook of the last two years of putting Big Food, Big Ag and Big Pesticides ahead of the public interest.
Democrats must also begin to repair the damage inflicted by the most stridently anti-environmental, anti-science administration in our history, and rebuild the federal government’s capacity to protect Americans.
That means restoring and strengthening critical agencies, including the EPA, the FDA and the CDC. It means restoring and strengthening science-based safeguards against pesticide exposure and toxic chemicals; protecting drinking water from contamination; and ensuring that public health, not corporate influence, drives regulatory decisions.
EWG stands ready to work with Congress – and all stakeholders – to make it happen and to turn this electoral mandate into real action.
We have an ambitious agenda and concrete opportunities to make progress. We look forward to working with incoming members of Congress and continuing our work to reform our food chemical safety system, strengthen pesticide protection and help farmers lead the transition to regenerative agriculture.
###
The Environmental Working Group (EWG) is a nonprofit, non-partisan organization that empowers people to live healthier lives in a healthier environment. Through research, advocacy and unique education tools, EWG drives consumer choice and civic action.
Press Contact Alex Formuzis alex@ewg.org (202) 667-6982 November 4, 2026“There’s no hardened opposition”: A Q&A with Katherine Matos Meza on geothermal in Western Canada
On Oct. 21, Cascade Institute researcher Katherine Matos Meza and Carlos Gorraez Meraz presented the findings of their report Deep Listening: Assessing the social acceptance of geothermal energy during a webinar and roundtable discussion hosted by ACET (Accelerating Community Energy Transformation). ACET Executive Director Curran Crawford moderated, Matos Meza and Gorraez Meraz presented their work, and a panel of experts discussed the findings: Cascade Institute’s Geothermal Policy Lead Emily Smejkal; Dr. Amel Barich, founder and CEO of Geoscience Research and Communications; and Clean Air Task Force Super Hot Rock Geothermal Policy Manager Ann Garth.
We caught up with report author Katherine Matos Meza after the event to discuss her findings.
Q: This was the first study of geothermal’s social acceptance in Alberta and British Columbia. What did you find?
KMM: The main result was that the audience is unfamiliar with geothermal energy, but despite the low level of familiarity, the general social acceptance of geothermal is moderate, and there’s no tangible opposition.
It was interesting to see how these findings are similar across Alberta and British Columbia, as we were expecting to find a different level of progressiveness in these two provinces.
Basically, that makes us think that we are really in a good moment to start informing people about geothermal and building the social acceptance. It’s important to help the general audience understand how geothermal works, and its potential for their communities, especially in Canada where we have cold winters. We are already seeing an increase in energy demand, and we need reliable sources of clean energy, especially in winter.
Op-ed
Drilling down: How Canadians feel about geothermal energy
Katherine Matos Meza and Simone Philpot unpack the Deep Listening findings in Canada’s National Observer.
Q: You polled people in British Columbia and in Alberta – which province was more supportive of geothermal?
KMM: Talking about numbers, on a scale from 1 to 5, Alberta’s social acceptance level was 3.07, and British Columbia’s was 2.97. So, they were close. I would say that acceptance is moderate in both provinces. We didn’t find any substantial differences between them.
Q: How would you define “moderate”?
KMM: A moderate level of social acceptance suggests that attitudes toward geothermal energy are generally neutral to mildly positive, indicating that people do not yet hold strongly positive or strongly negative views. This leaves room for perceptions to evolve as familiarity increases.
Perceptions around technologies can change really fast. When familiarity with technology is low, but acceptance is moderate, there is a significant opportunity to build social acceptance, as people have not yet developed strong positive or negative views about it.
There’s no hardened opposition to geothermal in these provinces. In some industries, we can already see opposition, especially in oil and gas. In the U.S., there are some spillovers from oil and gas opposition that are going to affect geothermal, but we don’t see that here in Canada. Maybe that’s because Albertans feel comfortable with drilling, because they are an oil and gas producer. They understand what drilling is, and how it has impacts, but also that it can be well managed.
It’s important to start building trust in geothermal before other actors come into the picture. But we need to do this in a transparent and technical way. A lack of accurate information from a project can contribute to negative public perceptions and undermine social acceptance. In this study, we examined the level of trust in a range of organizations and groups. Utility companies, oil and gas companies, and mainstream media were among the least trusted sources. Scientists and universities, on the other hand, were the most trusted messengers, which suggests that people want accurate, evidence-based information.
Q: Who else are seen as trusted messengers on geothermal?
KMM: The most trusted messengers are scientists and universities, but also environmental NGOs and renewable energy companies. This data suggests that people want technical information. This is interesting, because that means that people are open to listening to renewable energy companies, and geothermal is within the renewable domain. That’s our top tier of trusted messengers. The government—municipal, provincial and federal—are in the middle of the list. Among the least-trusted were oil and gas companies, and mainstream media.
Q: According to the survey, support for geothermal is strong compared to other energy options. What does that mean?
KMM: We asked people to what extent they support geothermal compared to other energy options. It was a direct question comparing geothermal across different energy sources currently available in British Columbia and Alberta. The results show that geothermal has positive signs of support. We didn’t find that there’s any tangible opposition to geothermal compared to other energy options, particularly renewable energies—this further reinforces that there is moderate acceptance of geothermal from people who are unfamiliar with the industry.
Q: Acceptance of geothermal energy was higher among men than women, according to the study. Why is that?
KMM: On average, research shows women tend to be a bit more cautious, and men tend to perceive lower risk and be more willing to take risks. So, these results might be a reflection of that. It may also reflect women’s lower involvement in the energy sector.
That’s also the reason why the communication strategy could be tailored according to the different demographic profiles. In the report, we present two audience personas that illustrate that and how the report results can be translated into engagement approaches.
Table 1 from the Deep Listening report: audience personas for ultradeep geothermal in Alberta and British Columbia.Q: You mention a “window of opportunity” for geothermal energy, and you point out that there are things that could close that window of opportunity. What specific factors could lower support for geothermal development?
KMM: A lot of things can change people’s perceptions around geothermal projects. When topics become politicized, you can see misinformation start spreading. There are a lot of factors that can ignite opposition, not only a bad project or a misleading company giving bad information. It’s hard to anticipate where this might come from, how it could evolve, or how fast this can happen.
This is where our window of opportunity matters: if we have informed the public about the benefits of geothermal, we make it a little harder for misinformation to spread. We can work to build positive perceptions of the industry with technical information. It’s really important to build social trust, build social acceptance, while also looking at how these conversations will evolve across Canada and in the U.S., because what happens there tends to overlap in Canada.
Q: What should geothermal energy advocates learn from your work?
KMM: The study asks what people care about when they think about energy sources, and the results are telling us that people want affordable energy, they want reliable energy, and they want safe energy. Those were the top priorities. If geothermal can provide those benefits, we need to lead with what people value the most and show how geothermal can bring these benefits to their communities.
Read the full report: Deep Listening: Assessing the social acceptance of geothermal energy
The post “There’s no hardened opposition”: A Q&A with Katherine Matos Meza on geothermal in Western Canada appeared first on Cascade Institute.
New study: Neonic pesticides found in semen and urine, linked to lower sperm concentration
- A study of 179 men at a fertility clinic tested urine and semen for neonicotinoids, or neonics, and linked higher neonic exposure in semen to lower sperm concentration.
- Eleven neonics or their breakdown products were found in more than 75% of urine samples, and four were found in more than 75% of semen samples.
- A proposed settlement would give the Environmental Protection Agency until April 30, 2027, to decide on revoking legal limits for residues of five neonics on food.
Neonicotinoid insecticides, notorious for their role in the collapse of bee populations, are turning up in human semen and may be linked to lower sperm count, a new peer-reviewed study finds.
Researchers found these pesticides, also known as neonics, and their breakdown products – the compounds the chemicals become in the body – in nearly every study participant.
In urine, 11 neonics or their breakdown products were found in more than 75% of samples, and acetamiprid, one of the most widely used neonics, was found in every one. In semen, four were found in more than 75% of samples, and one, a breakdown product of the neonic dinotefuran, was detected in more than 99%.
It’s just one study of 179 men in China, and the findings are preliminary. The men were partners in couples seeking fertility treatment and they provided samples once. A stronger study would include a comparison group from the general population. But the finding of an association between neonic exposure and semen quality adds to a growing set of studies showing wide human exposure to neonics.
Beyond this study, concerns have also emerged about how that exposure may harm human reproduction and development.
Delay on deciding neonics petitionThe prevalence of neonics in humans, combined with the building case for potential health concerns linked to exposure, comes as the Environmental Protection Agency may face a legal deadline for deciding whether to keep allowing five neonics’ residue on food.
In August 2026, the EPA agreed to a proposed settlement with the Natural Resources Defense Council that would set a binding April 30, 2027, deadline to respond to the group’s neonics petition.
That petition asked the agency to revoke tolerances – the maximum allowable amount of a pesticide on food – for five neonics: acetamiprid, clothianidin, dinotefuran, imidacloprid and thiamethoxam.
The study’s findings point to issues the NRDC flagged in its petition: The EPA ignored evidence that harm may occur at low exposure levels, the compounds neonics become can be more toxic than the original chemicals, and people are exposed to several neonics at once.
What did the new study find?Published in the journal Frontiers in Endocrinology in September 2026, the study was led by researchers at a Chinese fertility clinic and a medical university.
The authors collected urine from 179 men and semen from 173, with 146 men providing both. After testing for 18 neonics and their breakdown products, the researchers detected at least one neonic in almost every sample, though how often each compound turned up varied by neonic and sample type.
Some compounds were found at higher levels in semen than in urine. And levels in urine were a poor predictor of levels in semen, suggesting urine tests alone may miss what’s in semen.
Most previous pesticide exposure studies rely on testing urine. The study’s authors suggest semen may be “a potentially informative matrix for reproductive risk assessment” – meaning it could give a clearer picture of how neonic exposure affects reproductive health.
Two breakdown products in semen were linked to lower sperm concentration, a key measure of sperm quality and male fertility. Looking at the combined effect of all the neonics in semen, higher overall exposure was also associated with lower sperm concentration but not to lower total sperm count, movement or shape.
Why are neonics a concern?Some human health studies suggest exposure to neonics may harm children and the developing fetus. Biomonitoring studies show that exposure is widespread in children and pregnant people around the world.
In federal biomonitoring from 2015-2016, a neonic breakdown product was detected in the urine of half of kids ages 3 to 5, and their diet may be a primary route of exposure.
The EPA continues to allow the use of these insecticides. But some states are taking action to limit their use, in an effort to protect pollinators.
California’s Department of Pesticide Regulation moved to limit outdoor uses of imidacloprid, clothianidin, dinotefuran and thiamethoxam on most food and feed crops that are attractive to bees and other pollinators. Several other states, including Maine and New Jersey, regulate the use of neonics.
But the U.S. has lagged far behind these states in taking action on neonics, even though bee colony collapse has caused severe economic losses for American beekeepers.
It has also harmed others who rely on bees and other pollinators. For instance, they’re essential for U.S. farmers who grow squash, melon, cantaloupe, apples, almonds and many other crops that need pollination to bear fruit.
Other studies show the extensive use of neonics may not be necessary.
Research published in the journal PNAS in 2021 found that on farms growing corn and watermelon together, integrated pest management – treatment of crops only when pests reach damaging levels – cut insecticide use by 95% while maintaining corn yields and increasing watermelon yields.
EWG and more than 120,000 of our supporters have written to the EPA urging it to ban all unnecessary uses of neonic insecticides in the U.S.
How can I reduce my exposure to neonics?Because neonics are absorbed into plants, washing produce can’t get rid of their residue on produce entirely. But EWG still recommends washing your produce to potentially reduce the amount of pesticide residue on it.
Other steps you can take to reduce your exposure to these chemicals:
- Check EWG’s Shopper’s Guide to Pesticides in Produce™. The guide identifies the Dirty Dozen™ list of non-organic fruit and vegetables with the most pesticide residues. Neonics can be found on some U.S. produce, including blackberries.
- Choose organic when you can, especially for the produce on the Dirty Dozen. Synthetic neonics aren’t permitted in organic farming.
- Keep eating fruits and vegetables. The health benefits of a diet rich in produce outweigh the risks of pesticide exposure. If organic isn’t available or affordable, non-organic produce is still far better than none.
- Skip neonics at home. Many lawn, garden and pet flea products contain imidacloprid and other neonics. Check labels before you buy, and skip products with neonics.
AI Needed to Produce More Gas to Power More AI, Tech Firm Cohere Says
Oil and gas companies need to integrate AI into their operations so that they can extract more fossil fuels—which can then be used to power more AI.
That is the pitch that Canada’s leading AI company, Cohere, is making to the oil and gas industry, even as its CEO Aidan Gomez argues publicly that it is important for the tech industry to be aligned with “environmental goals.”
“As energy demand surges globally, driven in part by the explosive growth of AI data centers, oil and gas companies face significantly new operational, market, and environmental pressures,” explains a Cohere e-book from 2025 that advertises the AI company’s services to the fossil fuel sector. “AI has the potential to change the industry’s trajectory quickly, thereby better equipping it to address the growing supply-demand imbalance.”
An X post from the Toronto-based Cohere in early 2025 claimed that “AI-driven analytics optimize drilling, leading to more efficient resource extraction,” while predicting that “the oil and gas market for AI & ML [machine learning] is projected to surpass $4.9 billion by 2034, with GenAI playing a pivotal role in this growth.”
Using AI to increase the production of fossil fuels, which are then used to power the explosive growth of AI data centres, might seem like a strategy designed mostly to increase profits for fossil fuel and tech companies.
But that’s not the way Gomez is pitching Cohere to Canadians. He promises his company will deliver huge societal benefits, including bringing “down the cost of living for the average Canadian” and developing “cures for different diseases and ailments.”
Variations of Cohere’s fossil fuel-forward business model have been adopted across the industry by Amazon, Microsoft, Google, and other tech giants, according to Paris Marx, tech critic and author of the new book Hyperscale: The Ambition and Excess of Big Tech’s Data Empires.
“It feels like another example of just how intertwined the fossil fuel industry and the tech industry have become since the advent of generative AI taking off,” Marx told DeSmog in an interview. “There were relationships between them in the past, but now it’s just fully out in the open how simpatico their interests are, because more data centres means more fossil fuel demand”.
Cohere did not respond to DeSmog’s request for comment.
Subscribe to Desmog Email Address Sign Up Send me intelligence from: All US/Global team UK/Europe team Sign Up --> (function($){ $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-us').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619D07B21962C5AFE16D3A2145673C82A3CEE9D9F1ADDABE965ACB3CE39939D42AC9012C6272FD52BFCA0790F0FB77C6442'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-vdrirr-vdrirr'); }); $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-uk').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619BD43AA6813AF1B0FFE26D8282EC254E3ED0237BA72BEFBE922037EE4F1B325C6DA4918F8E044E022C7D333A43FD72429'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-ijkidr-ijkidr'); }); })(jQuery); ‘Playbook for Oil and Gas’In mid-September, 10,000 people gathered in Montréal for Canada’s largest AI conference. One of the most anticipated speakers that day was Gomez, who in 2023 was named by Time as one of the 100 most influential people in the world working in AI.
Cohere, the company he co-founded in 2019, recently received a funding commitment of $1.6 billion from Mark Carney’s Liberal government, helping bring its valuation to nearly $36 billion, and making it Canada’s most valuable AI firm and a significant player in the global industry. Gomez spoke on multiple occasions at the ALL IN conference from September 16-17, where he described AI as a nation-building technology for Canada.
“I think Canadians are strategic. And if we look at where we are right now in our geopolitical situation, we need to gain leverage on the world stage. That is frankly the project for our country. If we want to remain sovereign, if we want remain an independent country, we need leverage on a global stage. This is a place where we can win,” he said.
Gomez also assured attendees that data centres “can be completely in line with environmental goals,” adding that “with the type of energy that goes into these data centres, we need to make sure that it’s clean.”
Cohere CEO Aidan Gomez at the ALL IN conference in Montréal, September 2026. Credit: Mary StuartCohere has in some cases prioritized renewable energy for its computing power, as it will be operating its AI models through a Bell data centre in Merritt, BC, that is powered by hydroelectricity.
Nevertheless, the vast majority of new data centres proposals in Canada involve fossil fuels. Canada’s federal government has previously identified 15.5 gigawatts of new gas capacity planned for data centres, which could cause an increase of somewhere between 33 to 63 megatonnes of annual greenhouse gas emissions.
While Gomez promoted the use of clean energy on stage, his company is trying to secure contracts with fossil fuel companies, including to help boost their production and refining capacity.
Cohere’s 2025 e-book makes the case for “creating an AI-empowered oil and gas company”. It details “how energy sector leaders can harness generative AI— including agentic AI systems — to transform the oil and gas value chain, spanning upstream exploration and production to midstream logistics, downstream refining, and services.”
Examples include helping to “identify the ideal drilling locations”, supporting pipeline monitoring and leak detection, and taking care of transportation logistics. The book offers the example of Shell using AI to improve efficiency in deep-sea exploration, “boosting offshore oil output”.
DeSmog recently reported on a new study that found AI could increase global energy-related carbon dioxide emissions by between 1.2 and 4.8 percent, largely from improving productivity in fossil fuel production. Large fossil fuel companies, like Chevron, Equinor, ExxonMobil, and Shell are already integrating AI into their operations.
Cohere argues in its e-book that fossil fuel companies are well-positioned to meet the massive electricity requirements of new data centres. “AI offers a transformative leap — a way to help the sector meet surging energy demand,” it argues.
The explosive growth of AI data centre proposals can in turn “provide markets” for the oil and gas industry, according to an internal strategy document prepared for the Clerk of the Privy Council, one of the top advisors to Prime Minister Carney.
Global AI PlayerGomez isn’t the only Canadian CEO attempting to portray AI as environmentally sustainable. Mirko Bibic, CEO of Bell Canada, said at the ALL IN conference that his company is developing AI with “Canadian environmental stewardship”. Bibic explained that Bell’s data centres will use closed loop cooling systems, and that the company is going to “use best-in-class building practices to minimize the emissions”.
The conference took place on the heels of Bell’s announcement to expand an AI hub in Saskatchewan by 900 megawatts, which will be powered by gas.
“Bell is committed to building AI infrastructure responsibly,” the company said in response to questions from DeSmog, adding that the Saskatchewan proposal “will be subject to the provincial environmental impact assessment process.”
Cohere is the only Canadian company that develops large language models (LLMs), which it does for governments, companies, and other enterprise users rather than consumers.
The company recently finalized a merger with German AI company Aleph Alpha, a move that Cohere says will allow it to compete directly with OpenAI and other tech giants in certain markets. “We are now the largest AI company outside the United States and China,” Gomez said in late October, following the news of the company’s $36 billion valuation.
“We need this technology,” Prime Minister Carney said in announcing his government’s investment in Cohere’s latest funding round. “That’s why this company’s growth has been so extraordinary. It is in all our interests for Cohere to succeed, and now all Canadians will have a share in that success.”
But Cohere’s products will specifically create “greater profitability” for the oil and gas industry—at least according to the AI company’s promotional materials.
“The question is no longer if generative and agentic AI will reshape the oil and gas sector, but rather how quickly organizations will position themselves to benefit,” Cohere’s e-book argues.
The publication ends with a quote from Vicki Hollub, CEO of the U.S. oil company Occidental Petroleum: “Technologies … like AI will determine whether we stagnate — or surge forward.”
The post AI Needed to Produce More Gas to Power More AI, Tech Firm Cohere Says appeared first on DeSmog.
Millions of Dollars Pouring into UK Democracy from Trump’s America
MPs and leading UK think tanks have received major sums from U.S. benefactors – often with ties to U.S. President Donald Trump – since the 2024 general election, DeSmog can reveal.
Six MPs, including Reform UK leader Nigel Farage and Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch, have collectively accepted £335,000 for attending official Trump events and donor meetings, or gatherings held by right-wing U.S. groups.
Meanwhile, seven conservative policy groups in the UK have received at least $3 million (£2.3 million) from U.S. sources since 2024, and $20.4 million (£15.2 million) since 2016, the year of Trump’s first presidential election.
These revelations come as Trump’s Republican Party faces an uphill battle in today’s Midterm elections, with the Democrats vying to win control of both the House of Representatives and the Senate. Trump’s poll numbers have hit new lows with more than two-thirds of U.S. voters disapproving of the president’s handling of the cost of living amid a surge in gas prices due to the U.S.-Israeli war with Iran.
Trump is also unpopular in the UK and across Europe, with 85 percent of Brits saying they have an unfavourable view of the U.S. president.
Yet his administration has been openly attempting to fund its allies in Europe. According to The Guardian, the State Department has allocated $15 million (£11.2 million) to three conservative groups in the UK. These grants form part of a “slush fund” to boost likeminded organisations across Europe, with up to $3 million (£2.2 million) reportedly available to those focused on “developing civilizational bonds” and “defending rule of law”.
DeSmog’s analysis has found that, in addition to these planned donations by the Trump administration, millions have been poured into UK democracy by U.S. donors in recent years.
Right-wing think tanks to have received funding from U.S. donors since 2024 have included Policy Exchange ($1.1 million), the Henry Jackson Society ($955,000), the Institute of Economic Affairs ($609,000), the Global Warming Policy Foundation ($222,000), the Adam Smith Institute ($51,000), and the Academy of Ideas ($5,000).
The Prosperity Institute, formerly known as the Legatum Institute, also received $137,000 from two U.S. foundations, with the donations listed in charity filings covering the period to April 2024, though the group told DeSmog that these payments were received in 2023 and covered “work on the U.S. Prosperity Index project, so had no bearing on the domestic work of the think tank”.
In 2024, the Adam Smith Institute and Academy of Ideas received £50,000 and £4,965 respectively from the Prometheus Institute – a philanthropic foundation founded by Carl Barney, who donated over $1.6 million to Republican and pro-Trump campaigns during the 2024 election, including more than $900,000 to the Trump 47 Committee – making him one of California’s top pro-Trump donors during the race.
Six MPs have also received substantial payments from prominent U.S. conservative groups.
Farage has received £69,126 in income and £153,101 in expenses for attending 10 events – including over £32,000 to campaign for Trump during the 2024 presidential election campaign, and £27,000 to attend events during Trump’s inauguration in January 2025. Both trips were funded by crypto billionaire Christopher Harborne, who has financial ties to the White House.
Reform MP Suella Braverman, who defected to the party in January, has received £23,664 in expenses for attending four U.S. events, including delivering a speech in January 2025 at the Heritage Foundation – the group behind Project 2025, the radical right-wing blueprint for Trump’s second term. Braverman attended these events while she was a Conservative MP.
Farage, who is the only MP to have accepted speaking fees for some of the U.S. events, has come under intense pressure for his relationship with Trump. The Reform leader has labelled the president the “single most resilient and bravest person I’ve ever met in my life”, and has frequently called for Trump’s policies to be replicated in the UK – including the mass expansion of domestic fossil fuel production, the creation of a new immigration deportation agency, and unleashing the crypto industry.
“The continuing influx of overseas funding for UK think tanks, especially through opaque transatlantic networks, poses urgent questions for the government over how to safeguard our democracy against the risks of foreign interference,” said Tim Picton, senior advocacy advisor at Spotlight on Corruption,
“This funding can have a significant influence on our political discourse, but largely falls outside of the regulated sphere we currently have in place.”
All the MPs and think tanks named in this article were approached for comment.
The MPsA number of Conservative MPs have also been paid to attend right-wing U.S. events in recent years.
Shadow Foreign Secretary Tom Tugendhat, who was appointed to the role in August, has received £49,000 in flights and accommodation since April 2025 to attend several meetings organised by the Hudson Institute, a conservative group based in Washington DC, at which he is a ‘distinguished fellow’.
Badenoch also received over £23,000 in expenses to speak at the Hoover Institution at Stanford University in October 2025. The Tory leader has regularly praised Trump – claiming in February 2025 that he was “fixing” America’s problems. Like Reform, the Conservatives have proposed introducing an immigration ‘Removals Force’ modelled on the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency, while Badenoch supported Trump’s bombing campaign in Iran.
The three groups already allocated money through the Trump administration’s European slush fund are also run by high-profile Conservatives.
The Guardian reported in July that $7 million (£5.2 million) had been allocated to 878, which describes itself as a new “leading British and American think tank” devoted to “the rediscovery of our ancient culture” and “ending mass immigration”. The group lists its founding directors as Jacob Rees-Mogg, the former Conservative MP and Cabinet minister, and his former adviser Radomir Tylecote.
Former Conservative MP and Cabinet minister Jacob Rees-Mogg.Credit:
Simon Dawson / No 10 Downing Street (CC BY-2.0)
A reported $5 million has also been set aside for Free Speech Union International – the global offshoot of the Free Speech Union (FSU), a legal advocacy group run by Conservative peer Toby Young, who told The Guardian that its international branch had “expressed interest in applying for grant funding from the U.S. State Department” but that it had not yet been awarded the money.
Young reiterated this claim when approached by DeSmog.
The FSU is also already known to have received funding from U.S. sources. As first reported by Democracy for Sale, its now-defunct U.S. arm received money from a charity linked to a prominent anti-abortion lawyer.
An additional $3 million allocation from the State Department slush fund has reportedly been made to the Jobs Foundation for a programme called ‘Countering Overregulation to Advance American Investment’. Conservative peer Matthew Elliott, who led the official Vote Leave Brexit campaign, is the president of the Jobs Foundation, which is a pro-business advocacy group.
“If this money is being used to fulfill a specific direction from the U.S. State Department, there is a legal obligation for these organisations to declare this to the Home Office’s Foreign Influence Registration Scheme under national security laws,” Picton said.
The Think TanksSignificant payments have also been made from U.S. donors to UK think tanks in recent years.
DeSmog’s analysis has found that right-wing think tanks have accepted over $20.4 million from U.S. benefactors since 2016, often via their American fundraising wings, and $3 million since 2024.
Much of this money flows from U.S.-based donor advised funds (DAFs) – entities that keep the original source of funding hidden from public view. DAFs such as the Vanguard Charitable Endowment Programme, the National Philanthropic Trust, and Donor Advised Charitable Giving have been used to give money to right-wing UK think tanks in recent years – which has obscured the identities of some donors.
However, some are publicly disclosed. For example, the New York-based Achelis and Bodman Foundation gave $75,000 (£56,000) to the American Friends of the GWPF in 2024 – the entity that accepts donations from U.S. sources on behalf of the Global Warming Policy Foundation, one of the UK’s principal climate science denial groups. The Achelis and Bodman Foundation also donates to the likes of the Heritage Foundation and the Hudson Institute.
Several UK conservative think tanks use ‘friends of’ groups to channel donations across the Atlantic. Last year, American Friends of Policy Exchange, belonging to the influential Westminster think tank, accepted $50,000 (£37,000) from the Florida-based Swordspoint Foundation, which is run by Trump donor Robert Bishop.
55 Tufton Street. Credit: R4vi, CC-BY-SA-2.0In 2024, the IEA accepted up to $189,000 (£141,000) for research and study programmes from the Cherish Freedom Foundation – a group historically funded by Robert Mercer, a major donor to right-wing groups and campaigns whose family gave $25.5 million to Trump’s 2016 presidential campaign. The Institute of Economic Affairs has previously received money from fossil fuel majors including BP, ExxonMobil, and Shell, as well as from the U.S.-Australian media mogul Rupert Murdoch.
The IEA told DeSmog that it does not accept money from government sources and that it does not take donations “in exchange for research”.
These groups have also frequently echoed Trump’s narratives. The campaign director of Net Zero Watch, the lobbying arm of the GWPF, appeared on Murdoch-owned TalkTV in March and declared that “Trump is absolutely right to say that windmills [sic], and our mad policies on North Sea oil and gas, are making our energy more expensive.”
Meanwhile, in February 2024, Policy Exchange senior fellow Edward Stringer wrote an opinion piece for The Telegraph entitled: “Trump is right. Defenceless Europe can no longer freeload off America”.
Almost all of these UK groups belong to the Tufton Street network, a right-wing alliance based in Westminster that lobbies to dismantle state services and privatise public bodies. Its members share an opposition to climate action, and they have spent decades attempting to undermine policies designed to reduce emissions. As revealed by Democracy for Sale, the U.S. funding to some of these groups has increased by 29 percent from 2024 to 2025.
Tufton Street donors also closely overlap with the Conservative Party. As reported by DeSmog and Democracy for Sale in June 2024, Tory benefactors had gifted over £6.8 million to Tufton Street think tanks since 2019.
The Atlantic BridgeThere has also been a concerted attempt in recent years to build transatlantic right-wing networks to share policies, campaign strategies, and narratives.
One of the most prominent has been the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship (ARC), which holds an annual conference in London featuring thousands of attendees.
ARC is fronted by conservative commentator Jordan Peterson and run by Baroness Philippa Stroud, a Conservative member of the House of Lords. It’s the brainchild of the Legatum Group, a Dubai-based investment firm, and the hedge fund manager Paul Marshall – the co-owners of the radical right-wing broadcaster GB News, which employs Farage as a presenter.
Marshall is also a key funder of ARC, having given £3 million to the group since its creation in 2023. As revealed by DeSmog and Unearthed, this year’s conference was sponsored by Reform mega-donor and crypto billionaire Ben Delo, Tory and Reform donor Anthony Bamford, and a number of U.S. funders – including fossil fuel companies and executives – that have donated to Trump and the Republican Party.
Speakers at the conference included senior U.S. politicians – notably Trump’s energy secretary Chris Wright, U.S. House Speaker Mike Johnson, and Sarah Rogers, who is overseeing the State Department’s European slush fund. They spoke alongside UK figures who have been forging close ties, both financial and political, to Trump’s America – including Farage, Badenoch, Elliott, and Young.
President Donald Trump and Reform UK leader Nigel Farage at CPAC in 2018.Credit:
Shealah Craighead / White House (Public domain)
Among the attendees were dozens of parliamentarians, corporate executives, and right-wing think tanks including the Heritage Foundation, Adam Smith Institute, TaxPayers’ Alliance, and Prosperity Institute.
A key theme of the conference is criticism of global climate policies, with Marshall claiming in his 2025 ARC speech that the world has been infected by a “climate derangement syndrome”. He claimed that “our economic prosperity and our people’s livelihoods” are being sacrificed “all for the sake of making some fractional changes to the level of CO2 in the atmosphere”.
Also in attendance at this year’s ARC event was Samuel Samson of the State Department, who has reportedly been “at the forefront” of the Trump administration’s “effort to reshape America’s relationship with Europe”.
MPs have registered complimentary tickets to ARC worth at least £6,900 since 2024. The FSU has also reportedly received funding from ARC and Reform donor Delo, who owns a venue in Westminster that serves as a hub for various right-wing groups and content creators.
Another influential pro-Trump network has also been imported into the UK in recent months: the Conservative Political Action Committee (CPAC), which hosted its inaugural London event in July.
CPAC GB is chaired by former Conservative prime minister Liz Truss, while the event was headlined by Farage – despite the Reform leader suggesting beforehand that he would be “steering well clear” of the summit.
CPAC GB promised to bring together “global heavyweights” of the international right, and featured Young, Rees-Mogg, Tylecote, The Telegraph’s Allison Pearson, Reform’s Matthew Goodwin, broadcaster Mike Graham, and U.S. activist Jack Posobiec.
Farage has also helped to import an influential U.S. climate science denial group, the Heartland Institute, to the UK. The Reform leader was the keynote speaker at the launch of the Heartland Institute’s UK-EU branch in December 2024, months after advising the group to set up a satellite in Europe.
Heartland Institute UK-EU director Lois Perry claims to be advising the party on its climate agenda and is the strategy director of Reform Friends of Israel – a lobbying group within the party.
Farage has also been forging ties with Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) – a powerful legal advocacy group that led the campaign to overturn Roe v Wade, the landmark ruling that protected the constitutional right to abortion in the United States.
ADF’s UK branch spent over £1.4 million on its activities in 2025, more than three times higher than in 2020. Farage has not only appeared on promotional materials put out by the ADF, but according to the New York Times the group orchestrated a visit by Reform’s leader to Washington DC in September 2025, during which he testified to Congress.
ADF has also reportedly arranged backroom meetings between Farage and State Department officials on their visits to London, and as recently reported by the iPaper, the Reform leader has accepted more than £83,000 in earnings, accommodation, and flights from groups that support the anti-abortion movement, many of which are featured above.
The post Millions of Dollars Pouring into UK Democracy from Trump’s America appeared first on DeSmog.
Dirty Dozen™ food chemicals: propyl paraben
Avoid or limit foods containing propyl paraben.
Propyl paraben is a synthetic preservative shown in studies to mimic the hormone estrogen, raising concerns about its potential to disrupt hormonal processes.
Several studies have linked propyl paraben exposure to reproductive health effects. These effects include changes in sperm quality and testosterone levels in males and associations with egg quality and quantity and pregnancy outcomes in females.
What is propyl paraben?Propyl paraben, part of the paraben family, is a synthetic preservative used to prevent the growth of bacteria, mold and yeast in food, personal care products, cosmetics and some pharmaceuticals, extending their shelf life.
Which foods contain propyl paraben?Propyl paraben is typically added to baked goods such as tortillas, cookies, cakes and packaged snacks like chips and trail mix.
Look for propyl paraben in product ingredient lists, usually below or next to the Nutrition Facts panel, on the back of the package.
How is propyl paraben regulated?The Food and Drug Administration oversees food additives and other ingredients. The FDA has permitted propyl paraben as a food additive since 1977, classifying it as “generally recognized as safe” under thresholds of 0.1 percent.
In 2024, the FDA added propyl paraben to its list of chemicals under post-market safety reassessment.
The European Union banned propyl paraben from food in 2006, citing the EU’s food safety arm finding that it caused reproductive harm and hormone disruption in young rats at all doses tested – meaning no safe daily intake could be established.
Several U.S. states have acted to restrict or ban propyl paraben in food. In 2023, California passed a law to prohibit it in food sold in the state beginning in 2027. West Virginia and Arkansas passed similar restrictions in 2025. Numerous other states have proposed legislation to ban propyl paraben.
Propyl paraben is prohibited in certified organic foods under Agriculture Department organic standards, which bar synthetic substances.
What does the science say about propyl paraben?Multiple studies have confirmed that even at low doses, propyl paraben can mimic the hormone estrogen in the body, potentially disrupting hormone-sensitive processes like reproduction, development and cell growth.
In laboratory experiments, propyl paraben activated genes linked to tumor growth. It also encouraged the growth of breast cancer cells that respond to estrogen.
These findings suggest propyl paraben may play a role in breast cancer progression.
Studies in humans and animals have linked propyl paraben to reproductive harm. Research found associations between higher levels of propyl paraben in urine and reduced egg count in women.
In men, propyl paraben exposure has been associated with reduced sperm count and quality and decreased testosterone levels. A 2026 study of mother-infant pairs found prenatal propyl paraben exposure was associated with fetal distress and adverse pregnancy outcomes.
Animal studies show propyl paraben can affect multiple generations: Prenatal exposure has been linked to reduced egg count across generations, while long-term low-dose exposure has been shown to promote mammary tumor growth.
In mouse embryos, propyl paraben triggered oxidative stress, DNA damage and mitochondrial dysfunction, interfering with early embryo development.
Because people are exposed to propyl paraben both through food and personal care products, determining the long-term impact of dietary exposure alone is an area of ongoing research.
Find out moreLearn more about recommendations relating to propyl paraben – and the full EWG Dirty Dozen™ list of food chemicals – on EWG’s research page.
EWG’s Food Scores provides ratings for more than 150,000 foods and drinks based on nutrition, ingredients and processing concerns, and flags unhealthy ultra-processed foods to help you identify alternatives.
Propyl paraben is also added to cosmetic products as a preservative. EWG’s Skin Deep® cosmetic database helps to identify harmful chemicals in personal care and beauty products. EWG Verified® products meet the strictest criteria for transparency and health.
And the Healthy Living™ app lets you take these tools with you on the go.
Authors Sarah Reinhardt, MPH, RDN November 3, 2026Revealed: Pro-AI Data Center Group Spending At Least $2.54M on TV Ads to Influence Ohio Election
A pro-AI data center group purchased at least $2.54 million worth of television ads that ran recently in Ohio, a new DeSmog analysis reveals. The group, Build American AI, is linked to Leading the Future, a major AI industry super PAC backed by Silicon Valley billionaires.
The ads extolled the economic benefits of Ohio’s data center boom, one of the hottest issues in the state’s Senate election, but did not endorse either candidate in the race: Trump-aligned Republican incumbent Jon Husted, who was appointed by Governor Mike DeWine to serve out Vice President J.D. Vance’s term, and former three-term Democratic Senator Sherrod Brown.
“When some people hear data centers they picture computers and servers,” says one Build American AI ad. “But we see something different: electricians, engineers, manufacturers.” The ad states that data centers have brought more than $40 billion in investments and created over 95,000 jobs in Ohio.
“The future won’t be built by politicians or special interests,” states the ad, “It’ll be built by American workers right here in Ohio.”
The ads appeared on at least 16 Ohio television stations between September 7 and October 21, according to Build American AI’s filings with the Federal Communications Commission, which described them as “non-candidate issue ads.”
A still from one of Building American AI’s pro-data-center ad campaign in Ohio during the race for Senate between Republican Jon Husted and Democrat Sherrod Brown. Credit: Via Google Ads Transparency Center.Build American AI ordered at least $2.5 million in ads in Ohio, $1.5 million in ads in Wisconsin and $1.1 million in Kansas between September 7 and October 24, according to DeSmog’s analysis. Jesse Hunt, the group’s head of communications, confirmed that the group is spending over $5 million in the three states, but did not comment on the exact amounts.
Build American AI has been described by Politico as a “subsidiary” of Leading the Future, a super PAC which was formed last year to promote AI industry interests. Leading the Future has emerged as a major player in 2026 election cycle — backing both Democratic and Republican candidates in primary races earlier this year.
The super PAC has received about $125.79 million in contributions during the 2026 midterm election cycle as of October 29, according to Federal Election Commission (FEC) filings. Most of that came from a handful of donors: $25 million each in individual contributions from tech venture capitalists Marc Andreessen and Ben Horowitz, $50 million from their venture fund Andreessen Horowitz, also called a16z, and $12.5 million each from OpenAI co-founder and president Greg Brockman and his wife Anna Brockman.
OpenAI is part of a joint venture with SoftBank, Nvidia, the U.S. Department of Energy, and other partners to build a mammoth data center complex on federal land in Pike County, Ohio. The project would include an on-site gas-fired power plant designed to produce 9.1 gigawatts of power — larger than any gas-fired power plant currently operating worldwide, and enough to power about 7 million homes.
OpenAI’s investors include the Andreessen Horowitz venture capital fund. OpenAI’s energy chief is John McCarrick, who as an energy official in Trump’s first administration promoted exports of U.S. liquefied natural gas to Europe following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, and advocated for Asian countries to invest in natural gas.
Andreessen Horowitz did not respond to a request for comment.
OpenAI did not respond to DeSmog’s request for comment on the Brockmans’ personal donations to Leading the Future, or its stance on using gas-fired power for its data centers.
In August 2025, OpenAI co-founder and president Greg Brockman posted on X that he and his wife, Anna Brockman, were “supporting” the Leading the Future superPac to advocate for “a balanced view” of AI policy, “which we think of as optimistic realism, towards achieving AI’s benefits.” Credit: @gdb account on XMarc Andreessen is also a board member of tech giant Meta, which is building “Prometheus,” a massive data center in New Albany, Ohio, about 15 miles northeast of state capital Columbus. The partially-built computing complex runs on natural-gas turbines — and is designed to scale to one gigawatt, enough to power about 800,000 homes.
These projects are among dozens of proposed data center projects in Ohio, which is strategically positioned atop part of the Marcellus Shale, the biggest gas field in the U.S.
The AI boom is on track to worsen the climate crisis, which is on the verge of passing the key 1.5 degree Celsius (2.7 degrees Fahrenheit) limit on global heating that nations set in the 2015 Paris Agreement.
Based on current trends, the energy demand of new U.S. data centers could increase the nation’s carbon emissions by 24 to 44 million metric tons a year between 2024 and 2030, according to a recent study published in the journal Nature Sustainability — equivalent to the tailpipe emissions from an additional 5 to 10 million additional gasoline-burning cars.
Marc Andreessen recently called the climate crisis “over” in a post on X, and has praised fracking as an “incredibly positive outcome” of energy industry research and development.
“Energy should be in an upward spiral,” wrote Andreessen in his “Techno-Optimist Manifesto” in 2023. “The more energy we have, the more people we can have, and the better everyone’s lives can be.”
Both he and Horowitz have each contributed at least $3,500 to Husted’s re-election campaign since late 2025, according to FEC filings.
Mark Andreessen responded sarcastically in June to an X post by French economist Thomas Piketty about unequal wealth and the climate crisis: “SMH the climate crisis is over, Greta has pivoted to Palestine, and the rest of us are panicking over data centers. Do keep up.” Credit: @pmarca account on X.Build American AI’s ads appeared after Sherrod Brown’s campaign ran a series of ads branding Husted “the face of data centers in Ohio” and lambasted him for supporting multi-billion-dollar, greenhouse-gas spewing data center developments as well as for handing out tax breaks for data center developers.
Brown’s campaign spent $2.4 million on ads criticizing Husted’s support for data centers as of late August, according to political ad spending tracker AdImpact.
The ads caught the attention of the National Republican Senatorial Committee, which sent out a memo in mid-August to “interested parties” about “Ohio’s data center risk,” as first reported by Axios. The memo warned that Brown’s opposition to data centers had turned the issue into “the anchor hanging around Husted’s neck” that could get him voted out of office. “The companies that need these projects built have to fix how Ohioans see them: who benefits, who pays, and why a community should want one,” the memo stated — the themes of Build American AI’s TV ad campaign.
Sixty-three percent of Ohioans oppose AI data centers, according to a recent poll by The New York Times. As of September, the state has over 125 local data center moratoriums in place, as well as 21 ballot measures across 16 counties targeting data center construction, the most of any state. “People who would wave at their neighbors that they’ve seen for 10 years but never have spent the time on their porches” are “looking past partisan differences to fight for their communities,” Nick Owens, an attorney in rural Ohio, told DeSmog. Owens, who said he is a Republican, volunteers with the campaign Conserve Ohio, which is seeking to ban large-scale data centers in the state.
Looking ahead, local community groups in Ohio are attempting to gather 413,000 signatures needed to put a statewide data center moratorium on the ballot in 2027.
“Grassroots people who frankly have one hundredth the level of funds [of tech leaders] are battling these fights,” said Owens. “It’s really David versus Goliath, but the righteous people in this case, I believe, will prevail: the people who live in their communities.”
The post Revealed: Pro-AI Data Center Group Spending At Least $2.54M on TV Ads to Influence Ohio Election appeared first on DeSmog.
State food chemical laws don’t create chaos. They make food safer for everyone.
More than a dozen states have now passed laws restricting certain chemicals from food. Most apply to food served in schools, and a few may apply to food sold in stores.
Companies have argued that differing state laws make food manufacturing and distribution systems less efficient – and that this “patchwork” of requirements could make food more expensive. Major industry groups have even backed a draft bill in Congress to block them.
But the industry argument doesn’t hold up.
What usually happens instead: When one state raises the bar for consumer safety by passing a new law saying what can and can’t be in products, companies often change their products nationwide, extending the new law’s benefits to everyone.
These are just a few examples of “patchwork” state laws that made consumer products safer for all of us: removing toxic flame retardants from furniture, bisphenol A, or BPA, from baby bottles and higher-risk ingredients from food.
How did California get toxic flame retardants out of furniture?Before 2013, most furniture sold in the U.S. contained toxic flame retardant chemicals in its upholstery foam. The foam helped furniture pass product safety tests.
But research linked these chemicals – also commonly used in baby products like strollers, car seats and nursing pillows – to multiple health risks, including cancer, hormone disruption and deficits in attention and learning in children, without providing meaningful fire safety.
As a result, California began updating its testing standards and phasing flame retardants out of products sold in the state.
The effort faced fierce industry opposition. Chemical corporations spent millions lobbying to keep the old standard in place. One such company, Chemtura, sued California to overturn the new rules. The company lost, and the new standards took full effect in 2015.
In 2020, Congress adopted these same standards as a federal requirement through the Safer Occupancy Furniture Flammability Act – helping all states switch to product safety tests that kept chemical flame retardants out of furniture.
How does state policy protect infants from BPA in baby bottles?In 2009, Minnesota became the first state to make baby bottles free of BPA, a synthetic estrogen linked to early puberty, impaired immune function and other developmental harms.
Ten more states followed with their own policies restricting BPA in children’s products. Most laws targeted baby bottles, sippy cups and infant formula containers.
Under pressure from state lawmakers and attorneys general, major manufacturers took BPA out of products nationwide, regardless of which states those items were sold in.
By 2012, so many manufacturers had already dropped BPA from baby bottles and sippy cups that the FDA formally ended its use in those products.
The Food and Drug Administration in 2013 also ended the use of BPA in formula packaging.
What has been the California Food Safety Act impact?The California Food Safety Act banned four food additives – Red Dye No. 3, brominated vegetable oil, potassium bromate and propylparaben – from food sold in the state starting in 2027.
Food companies pushed back. The Consumer Brands Association and other industry groups together opposed the bill. The National Confectioners Association called the legislation part of a “patchwork of inconsistent state requirements created by legislative fiat that will increase food costs.”
But by 2024, multiple states had introduced similar bans.
In early 2025, the FDA revoked authorization of Red 3 in food. That same year, major manufacturers, such as Kraft Heinz and General Mills, began announcing plans to reformulate products without artificial colors.
No company has announced planned price increases associated with the changes.
What would the FRESH Act do to state food chemical laws?The food industry’s “patchwork” argument isn’t just a talking point – it’s the basis of a draft bill.
The FRESH Act would block state bans or restrictions of food additives, or even mandatory warnings. The bill was proposed by Rep. Kat Cammack (R-Fla.).
If enacted, it would push groundbreaking state laws like California’s off the table – laws that have helped rid consumer products nationwide of chemicals like Red 3.
History is clear: When states act, companies change their products for everyone, for the better. The chaos predicted by food companies never actually occurs.
States aren’t the problem in our food safety system. Until the FDA adopts stricter regulations to help protect people from toxic chemicals, states are filling the gap.
What can you do?Tell your members of Congress to oppose any federal bill that strips states of the power to protect their residents from harmful food chemicals.
In the meantime, you can check what’s in your groceries using EWG’s Food Scores database, which provides ratings of more than 150,000 food products based on ingredients of concern, nutrition and processing.
Areas of Focus Food Food Chemicals Authors Sarah Reinhardt, MPH, RDN Scott Faber November 2, 2026Ohio Denies Evidence of Fracking Waste in Drinking Water. Its Own Records Show Otherwise.
This story was co-published with Rolling Stone.
In Ohio’s rural southeastern corner, Marietta College geology professor David Jeffrey was among the residents worried that industry activity in America’s booming natural gas region could be polluting their drinking water. That’s “the biggest fear,” he said at an August meeting with top Ohio officials.
When Jeffrey and residents from advocacy groups Buckeye Environmental Network and Washington County for Safe Drinking Water met with Ohio officials, those state officials repeatedly assured residents that despite the up to 1.4 billion gallons of oil and gas wastewater injected in underground wells in their county and across Ohio each year, the state was unaware of any resulting drinking water contamination there.
“We would have heard about it,” Mary Mertz, director of the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR), which oversees both aspects of Ohio’s environment and its oil and gas industry, told residents in the August 17 virtual meeting.
“No one has called us that I’m aware of,” said Eric Vendel, ODNR’s oil and gas division chief. “We have a water investigation form that can be filled out and we would have my team down there and investigate the water.”
What officials did not tell the group that day is that five years earlier, the state did receive a call and, on Vendel’s orders, investigated a drinking water well for oil and gas wastewater contaminants in eastern Ohio, roughly 80 miles away from Washington County. Independent experts say the results are consistent with fracking wastewater contamination. Despite that and the water well’s location near two oil and gas wastewater injection wells, ODNR concluded fracking wastewater was not to blame, according to documents DeSmog and Rolling Stone obtained via public records request.
Subscribe to Desmog Email Address Sign Up Send me intelligence from: All US/Global team UK/Europe team Sign Up --> (function($){ $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-us').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619D07B21962C5AFE16D3A2145673C82A3CEE9D9F1ADDABE965ACB3CE39939D42AC9012C6272FD52BFCA0790F0FB77C6442'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-vdrirr-vdrirr'); }); $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-uk').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619BD43AA6813AF1B0FFE26D8282EC254E3ED0237BA72BEFBE922037EE4F1B325C6DA4918F8E044E022C7D333A43FD72429'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-ijkidr-ijkidr'); }); })(jQuery);ODNR spokesperson Andy Chow told DeSmog and Rolling Stone: “When administrators were meeting with representatives in Washington County, they were discussing matters related to injection wells located in Washington County. ODNR stands by the comments made by its administrators.”
Concerns over polluted drinking water cross political and social divides, perhaps nowhere more so than rural Washington County. As intensely salty wastewater pushed below ground resurfaces, residents and officials have injected the issue into the already bitterly divided Ohio governor’s race. Susan Vessels, a Republican official in Washington County, recently appeared alongside Democratic gubernatorial candidate Dr. Amy Acton because of Acton’s pledge to pause new wastewater wells in this densely drilled area. “We have a chance to prevent the worst from happening, and we need to act now,” Acton told DeSmog and Rolling Stone.
“Drinking water is not political and it is my hope Ohioans will come together across party lines on this issue.”
Susan Vessels, Marietta City Council PresidentOhio ranks in the top 10 nationally for both oil and gas production. Fracking can occur within 100 feet of a school or rural home, and operators have been able to tap the gas-rich Marcellus and Utica formations by drilling directly beneath water reservoirs and state parks. But in order to maintain that production, the industry has to offload the tidal wave of toxic wastewater — rich in salts, carcinogens, heavy metals, and radioactive elements — that surfaces in the weeks and years that follow drilling an oil or gas well.
That wastewater gets pumped into injection wells deep below ground, where impermeable geological layers are supposed to keep it from leaking into oil and gas wells or drinking water supplies. Washington County, whose 19 injection wells outnumber all of Pennsylvania, has received complaints of this wastewater, or brine, flooding nearby oil and gas wells, according to the New York Times.
Now, an hour and a half drive north, in the town of Coshocton, Ohio, records show evidence of a family’s drinking water polluted by high levels of the same types of salts found in fracking wastewater.
“This is different”In early November 2021, Bill Burgan, an eastern Ohio water well driller, called ODNR to complain about water from a 360-foot well he had drilled in 2017 for the Fisher family in Coshocton, according to ODNR documents. At the beginning of 2021, their water had become salty and corrosive. Not only did it leave a salty taste in the mouth, but it caused their hot water tanks to rust out prematurely. The couple had replaced two tanks in four years. Within weeks, the newest one became coated in an unidentifiable white precipitate.
“Sometimes we drill through pockets of salt,” said Burgan, president of American Drilling and Pump Service, in an interview with DeSmog and Rolling Stone this summer outside his Stone Creek, Ohio, shop. “But this is different, it’s fracking waste.”
Burgan told DeSmog and Rolling Stone, and, separately, ODNR according to public records, that he expressed concern that the Fishers’ drinking water well became impacted by an oil and gas wastewater injection well located less than two miles from the family’s home and operated by a Texas-based company called Buckeye Brine. The local community vigorously opposed Buckeye Brine’s installment of the injection well, where since 2014 the company has injected over 400 million gallons of waste.
After receiving Burgan’s complaint, ODNR swiftly launched an investigation that agency geologist Tamara Richards said “will focus solely on contaminants associated with oil and natural gas exploration and production,” according to public records.
The state’s results indicate signatures of possible drinking water pollution from oil and gas wastewater, according to independent experts who reviewed the findings. Ohio’s final report on the incident, completed in January 2022, found two separate indicators of potential fracking wastewater contamination — total dissolved solids, and chloride — in the Fisher family’s water. Both tested at more than five times the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) limits. ODNR also tested for sodium, which lacks a formal EPA limit but has a threshold, as high levels can cause unpleasant taste and health problems for diabetics. In the Fishers’ water, sodium was 17 times the EPA threshold.
According to Jeffrey, the Marietta College geologist, high levels of total dissolved solids, chloride, and sodium also are found in the sea of fracking wastewater pumped into injection wells like the one operated by Buckeye Brine.
However, ODNR concluded there was “no evidence of an oilfield related impact” and pinned the cause of the contamination on a sandstone layer called the “Big Injun” that the agency, without providing any data, stated “appears to be” naturally salty and surrounded part of the family’s water well.
But Jeffrey said testing done by the state did not look at enough parameters to determine that the contamination was natural and not from fracking wastewater. “It seems ODNR is either stonewalling, misdirecting, or just doesn’t know what they are doing,” he told DeSmog and Rolling Stone.
In a separate case that would unfold over a year after ODNR tested the Fishers’ water, the agency was considering whether leaking injection wells or else the “Big Injun” sandstone formation might be contaminating conventional oil and gas wells in Athens County, just west of Washington County. This time, ODNR concluded the impacts “cannot be plausibly explained” by the sandstone formation due to its unique brine signature, citing a “June 2, 2020 technical analysis prepared by ALL Consulting.” The agency added that impacts from this natural layer would have been consistent from the start, and “it is unlikely” they would have appeared only after the injection well operator began working. ODNR ultimately suspended the permit for a set of three injection wells that were eventually shut in for leaking fracking wastewater. ODNR has not yet replied to questions regarding this case.
When asked about the state’s findings in Coshocton and their scientific evidence, Burgan was dismissive. “They are covering it up,” he said, “because they are making too much money off of this.”
Oil and gas companies pay Ohio five cents a barrel to dispose of in-state wastewater, and 20 cents for wastewater imported from other states. Much of the waste injected comes from neighboring West Virginia and Pennsylvania. With at least a billion gallons of waste injected every year, that income translates to an average of $2.4 million annually for state coffers, according to state documents.
“The ODNR Division of Oil and Gas Resources Management uses evidence and facts, testing, and the latest technologies to evaluate complaints of brine migration” and “stands by the results of its investigation,” said ODNR spokesperson Chow.
The entrance to Buckeye Brine’s injection well facility in Coshocton, Ohio. Credit: Justin Nobel/DeSmogBut ODNR did not investigate the Buckeye Brine injection well, subject of the original complaint, or any other injection wells. It did investigate “producing oil and gas wells within a one-half mile radius” of the family’s home.
After Burgan’s company reached out, we “contacted ODNR and ODNR was not interested in any further efforts on the matter,” said Susie Patterson, the manager at Buckeye Brine, by email. Patterson said groundwater monitoring wells installed in 2019 and sampled quarterly showed “no indication of contamination by oilfield substances,” or that “the water was not fit for consumption due to contaminants,” and pinned issues with the Fishers’ well on the water well driller.
“The wells were drilled much deeper than surrounding wells producing good drinking water,” said Patterson. “It is Buckeye’s opinion that the driller was trying to justify to the well owner the bad wells.”
The Fishers declined to participate in the story.
The Oil and Gas Industry’s Trillion-Gallon ProblemAcross America, over one trillion gallons of oil and gas wastewater are generated every year — enough to fill a line of waste barrels to the moon and back 28 times. Nearly all of this waste — 96 percent — will be injected deep into the earth at disposal injection wells.
Given the oil and gas industry’s reliance on injection wells as a critical means of disposal for a dangerous waste stream, analysts have referred to injection wells as a linchpin to the sound operation of the entire oil and gas industry. Disposal of oil and gas wastewater is the industry’s “Achilles’ heel,” said Ted Auch, a researcher at the oil and gas industry watchdog Fieldnotes. A 2021 Rice University Center for Energy Studies report stated that if the industry did not have injection wells to rely on for waste disposal, the “resulting economic impacts would be profound — and likely, existential.”
The United States has more than 181,400 oil and gas wastewater injection wells, but as industry leaders testified at the Texas state capitol in August, lack of space to store this toxic brine already is threatening to curtain oil and gas production in Texas’ productive Permian Basin. Even where it has been stored, increasing evidence shows the wastewater is not always staying put.
Injection has proven particularly problematic in Ohio, where state regulators have halted operations at over half a dozen injection wells, citing concerns that fracking wastewater has leaked and has traveled up to five miles underground to contaminate conventional oil and gas wells. ODNR noted in a 2023 letter to DeepRock Disposal Solutions, a southeast Ohio company formerly run by the chair of the state senate’s energy committee, that such incidents pose a risk to public health and drinking water too.
In Texas, wastewater shot down injection wells has burst back to the surface at old oil and gas wells, at times generating 100-foot geysers of brine in the desert, and Inside Climate News reported that oilfield waste has contaminated drinking water sources in the heart of West Texas oil country. Reporting by ProPublica revealed the situation is similar in neighboring Oklahoma, where regulators have clashed over how far to rein in the injection industry, despite state evidence showing drinking water sources polluted with contaminants consistent with oilfield waste.
Independent scientists raise the question of whether other oil and gas states may be facing similar problems.
“We have always been concerned as environmental scientists and geologists in this area that there is no underground containment in these [injection] wells,” said Jen Bowman, a water chemistry expert and the director of environmental programs at Ohio University, in Athens. “What so many folks in this area don’t understand, our underground layers are just rock layers so there is no magic underground lake where you are getting water from, and there is no magic underground storage container where the waste is going.” Injecting millions of gallons of waste at high pressure means contamination miles from the site of injection is inevitable, she said.
“This is not a good plan or disposal mechanism for potentially dangerous materials,” Bowman told DeSmog and Rolling Stone, “especially given that people rely on groundwater in so much of rural Ohio.”
The concern about drinking water in Washington County is exactly what motivates Susan Vessels, the Republican president of the Marietta City Council. She has led the council in writing a resolution, passed last October, urging Ohio state legislators to introduce legislation imposing a three-year moratorium on new wastewater injection wells in Washington County. More recently she has crossed the political aisle when Amy Acton, the former state health director, came to Marietta last month as part of her gubernatorial campaign. Acton supports Vessels’ proposed moratorium and is facing an ugly, expensive race against billionaire Vivek Ramaswamy.
Acton told DeSmog and Rolling Stone that the fight over injection wells and drinking water contamination comes down to ensuring a better future for Marietta and all of Ohio.
“That is why I am committing to a three-year moratorium on wastewater injection wells in Washington County,” said Acton. “I’m fighting against the corruption in our Statehouse and the cost of that corruption that we pay for. We must act to protect our resources and our drinking water.” Ramaswamy’s campaign has not replied to questions.
“Drinking water is not political,” said Vessels, “and it is my hope Ohioans will come together across party lines on this issue.”
In an op-ed, she took to task the GOP contender Ramaswamy, who called people “whiners” for raising concerns about clean water, energy use, and other issues as proposals for AI data centers arrive in Ohio.
“I think they are full of shit, and that is point-blank my opinion.”
Phillip Johnson, Washington County water well drillerWashington County water well driller Phillip Johnson said he has drilled hundreds of private water wells in the region. He disagreed with the state’s conclusion that brine from the sandstone formation caused the Fisher family well’s contamination.
“I think they are full of shit, and that is point-blank my opinion,” he said.
Johnson said that if the sandstone formation was the cause of the salt contamination in the Fishers’ drinking water, then the salty taste should have been there from the beginning, and not strengthened over time as the couple reported, according to ODNR documents.
“Just because you drill 1,000 wells and everything works fine, it just takes one well to not work right for there to be a problem,” said Johnson. “It is nature, if you pump something down under pressure, the path of least resistance is up.”
“I am all for drilling oil and gas,” he added, “but fresh natural water is the most essential natural resource there is, in this country, the state, anywhere in the world, and if you contaminate it, you essentially ruin everything.”
Dominic DiGiulio, a retired EPA scientist with a doctorate in geoscience and decades of experience investigating the movement of underground fluids, provided another assessment of the state’s conclusions in the Coshocton case.
“The ODNR’s logic for stating that the domestic well is partially screened in the Big Injun formation is flawed,” said DiGiulio, who also previously consulted for government agencies and NGOs. “ODNR does not provide compelling evidence.”
The post Ohio Denies Evidence of Fracking Waste in Drinking Water. Its Own Records Show Otherwise. appeared first on DeSmog.
President Trump Unveils EPA’s New Contradictory Methane Proposal at Campaign Rally
At a Tuesday campaign rally for Republican Senate candidate Ken Paxton in Lubbock, Texas, President Trump announced the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) proposal to roll back a Biden-era methane rule, setting up a likely future showdown in how the agency oversees climate pollution under the Clean Air Act.
The proposal marks a break from the agency’s previous approaches to greenhouse gas regulation by maintaining that — for now — the EPA still has the authority to regulate climate pollution from the oil and gas industry, though it might revisit this decision later. With affordability top of mind for many midterm voters, however, the President framed the move in economic terms.
“Tonight I’m officially terminating Biden’s expensive and unnecessary methane regulations,” Trump announced to the crowd, located near the oil-rich Permian Basin. The new plan would loosen federal requirements for oil and gas operators to detect and repair leaks, ease restrictions on gas flaring, and eliminate the Super Emitter Program, a third-party monitoring and reporting system designed to identify major releases of methane, known as a climate super pollutant.
Trump said the proposal, which addressed a 2024 rule known as OOOOb/c, would “save consumers and energy producers $45 billion in costs, unlock vast quantities of Texas natural gas, and produce 210 million barrels of oil.” Under President Biden, the EPA estimated the rule would prevent the release of 58 million tons of methane and 16 million tons of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), leading to major public health and climate benefits. Climate change already is raising costs for American households by an estimated $400 to $900 annually, according to a 2025 Brookings report.
Trump’s Lubbock announcement follows a series of sweeping deregulatory moves by the EPA in which the agency has stated it does not have the authority to regulate the greenhouse gas emissions that cause climate change under the Clean Air Act. EPA’s most notable decision came in February when the agency rescinded the 2009 endangerment finding, the U.S. government’s scientific finding that greenhouse gases harm human health and the environment and the legal basis for its rules addressing climate change. More recently, the EPA stated in September that it would no longer limit climate pollution for power plants, a move which would likely extend the lifespan of coal-fired power plants.
In the wake of these decisions, however, legal experts and environmental advocates say that the EPA is attempting to assert power unevenly. On the one hand, the agency says it lacks the legal authority to regulate greenhouse gas emissions from cars, trucks, power plants, and industrial sources under the Clean Air Act. On the other, the latest EPA proposal relies on, in some cases in the same section of, the Clean Air Act to regulate methane, a greenhouse gas, from the oil and gas industry.
In its latest proposed rule, the EPA addresses this tension, acknowledging that “stakeholders have also raised concerns” about the agency’s authority to regulate the oil and gas sector’s greenhouse gas emissions under the landmark air pollution law. Depending on the agency’s final handling of the issue with fossil fuel-fired power plants, the EPA states it could then use a “future rulemaking” to resolve the issue in the oil and gas sector. (The EPA is accepting public comments on its proposed repeal of its authority to regulate greenhouse gas emissions for fossil fuel-fired power plants until Nov. 2.)
Subscribe to Desmog
Email Address Sign Up Send me intelligence from: All US/Global team UK/Europe team Sign Up --> (function($){ $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-us').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619D07B21962C5AFE16D3A2145673C82A3CEE9D9F1ADDABE965ACB3CE39939D42AC9012C6272FD52BFCA0790F0FB77C6442'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-vdrirr-vdrirr'); }); $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-uk').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619BD43AA6813AF1B0FFE26D8282EC254E3ED0237BA72BEFBE922037EE4F1B325C6DA4918F8E044E022C7D333A43FD72429'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-ijkidr-ijkidr'); }); })(jQuery); Attacking EPA’s ‘flawed legal basis’In 1999, the oil and gas industry’s largest trade group, the American Petroleum Institute (API), organized a meeting over whether it should “coordinate a multi-industry, trade group response” to the threat of what it called EPA’s “flawed legal basis” for regulating greenhouse gas pollution, including carbon dioxide and methane, under the Clean Air Act. In 2024, the API filed a legal challenge over the OOOOb/c rule, which was eventually consolidated into a lawsuit with states and other industry trade groups. That suit has been paused while the agency reconsiders the rule.
Parts of the oil and gas industry have flagged this distinction in how the Trump EPA is handling two different greenhouse gases under the same law. Shortly after the EPA repealed the endangerment finding, the Domestic Energy Producers Alliance (DEPA), an oil and gas trade association founded by fracking magnate and Trump donor Harold Hamm, wrote a letter to the EPA, thanking the agency for “restoring the rule of law.” The group called out “methane and other greenhouse gas emission requirements for the oil and gas sector” among its examples of “major regulations based on the Endangerment Finding.”
A flare burns over oilfield infrastructure in West Texas’ Permian Basin in 2020. Credit: Justin Hamel/DeSmogA few months later, after the agency published an update on its proposed reconsideration of the OOOOb/c methane rule, DEPA wrote in an internal newsletter that EPA “does not explain its legal reasoning for continuing to regulate methane emissions when it has found that it does not have the authority to regulate carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from vehicles and has proposed it does not have the authority to regulate power plants’ CO2 emissions.”
On Tuesday in Corpus Christi, the president called out Hamm by name at another midterms rally shortly before the one announcing the methane rule rollback. “Harold Hamm is here, the great oilman,” said Trump, looking around the audience. “Hi, Harold.”
‘The Very Definition of Arbitary’Legal experts and environmental advocates say the EPA’s inconsistency leaves unresolved important legal questions about the federal government’s authority to regulate climate pollution, potentially keeping the door open to upend federal methane regulation entirely.
“Treating similar pollutants under the same statute differently, with no stated reason or evidence, is the very definition of arbitrary and capricious decision making,” said Alejandro Camacho, a law professor at the University of California, Los Angeles.
Camacho argues that if the EPA adopts a broad theory limiting its authority over greenhouse gases, it must explain why that theory doesn’t also undermine its authority to regulate methane. “States have already sued over the power plant repeal, as have health and environmental groups, and they can and should attack this inconsistency too,” he added.
A lone pumpjack in Loving County, Texas, in the Permian Basin. Credit: Justin Hamel/DeSmogThe EPA’s proposal nods to the industry’s questioning of its authority and points to the agency’s history of handling the oil and gas sector separately, “but the agency hasn’t explained how it will navigate it,” said Rosalie Winn, senior director and lead counsel on methane and clean air policy for the Environmental Defense Fund.
Mary Sasso, an attorney for the Clean Air Task Force, said the agency’s decision to defer the question could leave the future of methane regulation uncertain. “I think that there’s very real concerns that we could see changes to EPA’s interpretation of its own authority finalized in some type of regulation that would be really damaging for public health and the environment,” she said.
Camacho agrees, and warned that the deferral could foreshadow future agency backtracking. “The deferral is less a reasoned distinction than a placeholder for the next rollback,” he said.
The administration also argues that the proposed changes will reduce regulatory costs, encourage domestic energy production, and help lower prices for consumers. “Since day one, President Trump has been putting real money back into the hands of American people by putting American energy back in the hands of the American workers, businesses, and communities,” said Interior Secretary Doug Burgum in a press statement about the proposal.
Consumer savings uncertainAlthough the EPA estimates that the proposed rollback to the methane rule would save consumers tens of billions of dollars, the relationship between domestic production and consumer prices is more complicated, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration. In an emailed response to DeSmog, the EPA said its estimate reflected the anticipated cost oil and gas operators would save by not having to comply with regulations, their excess profits, and consumer savings. The proposed rule reflects this calculation in its Regulatory Impact Analysis section, but does not provide further details on how the agency determined these figures. These figures are not independently established consumer savings.
“As much as it would be easy to paint oil executives as cartoonish villains hiking prices while families suffer, individuals have little to no control over benchmark oil prices,” said Kelly Mitchell, the executive director of the oil and gas watchdog Fieldnotes.
“The administration may claim that new rules will incentivize new production, bringing online supply to counter the barrels trapped behind the Strait of Hormuz,” Mitchell said. “However, these new rules are primarily designed to help operators of marginal wells — wells that produce fewer than 15 barrels per day.”
Flaring methane gas in the Permian Basin, Texas. Credit: Justin Hamel/DeSmogMitchell questioned whether the benefits of the rollback would reach consumers, arguing that changes would primarily reduce costs for oil and gas operators without guaranteeing lower prices at the pump. “We’re left with an outcome where oil companies get to war profiteer, avoid using any of those profits to clean up a major pollution source, and fail to reduce prices. Now they have the gall to look us in the eyes and tell us this is a gift to the American consumer.”
Since rescinding the endangerment finding, the EPA no longer accounts for the cost of harms from additional climate pollution — only the economic harms — which does not figure into the new rule’s estimated savings. Meanwhile, in a study recapping the last decade of climate-induced health harms, the Lancet reported a record high of 710,000 heat-related deaths in 2023 — and almost 72 percent of them caused by climate change.
The proposed rule places particular emphasis on a class of low-producing facilities known as marginal wells, which typically produce relatively small amounts of oil and gas. The Trump administration alleges that regulations established under the previous administration stymied these wells. “Under crooked Joe Biden, ‘Dumocrats’ crushed the small oil and gas operators,” Trump said during the rally Tuesday. “There are small operators, they’re great operators too, I know so many of them — with crippling regulations and methane that caused prices to skyrocket.”
The EPA says many of these wells are family-owned operations that struggle with the costs of complying with Biden-era standards, but an Environmental Defense analysis found that nearly half of all marginal wells are owned by just 93 corporations.
The proposed methane rule reconsideration is the latest development in a broader campaign to weaken federal methane protections under the purview of Aaron Szabo, a former registered lobbyist for a member of a major trade group pushing for these rollbacks. Earlier this month, Szabo stepped down as the head of the EPA Office of Air and Radiation. Last month, DeSmog reported that members of the oil and gas industry had simultaneously voiced public support for federal methane rules while covertly working to “eviscerate”them during the second Trump administration, according to an investigation published by Fieldnotes.
The proposed changes to the OOOOb/c methane rule are not yet final. The EPA says it will provide at least 45 days for public commentafter publication in the Federal Register, including a public hearing.
The post President Trump Unveils EPA’s New Contradictory Methane Proposal at Campaign Rally appeared first on DeSmog.
Two GB News Directors Have Investments in Oil Companies Behind Rosebank and Jackdaw
Two directors of GB News, which has loudly advocated for the new Rosebank and Jackdaw oil and gas fields, hold shares in the firms behind the projects.
Sir Paul Marshall, a millionaire hedge fund boss who also owns The Spectator magazine, and Lord (Theodore) Agnew of Oulton, a Conservative peer and donor, sit on the board of All Perspectives Ltd, the holding company of GB News.
Marshall is also one of its two principal funders, pumping money into the loss-making right-wing outlet.
GB News – which employs Reform UK leader Nigel Farage and former Tory Cabinet minister Jacob Rees-Mogg – has strongly supported new North Sea drilling, with presenters recently calling Rosebank “a no-brainer” that should be approved “instantly”.
The Labour government last week approved the development of the Jackdaw gas field near Aberdeen and is expected to make a decision on Rosebank soon.
Rosebank would create an estimated 250 million tonnes of carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions over its 10-year lifetime, roughly 70 percent of the UK’s total annual emissions. The oil and gas field near the Shetland Islands is 80 percent owned by Adura, an “independent joint venture” by the fossil fuel giants Equinor and Shell that also owns the Jackdaw site.
At the end of June, Marshall’s hedge fund Marshall Wace held $16.3 million (around £12.3 million) of stock in Shell, according to its latest filings to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.
Meanwhile, Lord Agnew is a shareholder in Equinor, owning a stake in the company worth at least £100,000 according to his parliamentary register.
DeSmog first revealed Marshall Wace’s huge fossil fuel portfolio in 2023, which increased to $2.8 billion (£2.1 billion) in the first quarter of this year.
One of Marshall Wace’s biggest backers, U.S. private equity giant KKR, is itself a major investor in fossil fuels.
Subscribe to Desmog Email Address Sign Up Send me intelligence from: All US/Global team UK/Europe team Sign Up --> (function($){ $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-us').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619D07B21962C5AFE16D3A2145673C82A3CEE9D9F1ADDABE965ACB3CE39939D42AC9012C6272FD52BFCA0790F0FB77C6442'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-vdrirr-vdrirr'); }); $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-uk').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619BD43AA6813AF1B0FFE26D8282EC254E3ED0237BA72BEFBE922037EE4F1B325C6DA4918F8E044E022C7D333A43FD72429'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-ijkidr-ijkidr'); }); })(jQuery);“GB News has gone way beyond just covering the Rosebank decision. Presenters repeatedly attacked the energy secretary for considering rejecting it, and demanded that the government ‘drill baby drill’,” said Richard Wilson, director of the campaign group Stop Funding Heat.
“The public deserves to know when the people overseeing a TV station have a financial stake in the outcome it’s pushing for”.
Wilson also pointed out that media regulator Ofcom requires “due impartiality” from broadcasters on live policy decisions, potentially including the approval of specific oil fields.
“It’s time for Ofcom to take action,” he said. “In the meantime, it’s vital that advertisers continue to steer clear of GB News”.
Paul Marshall and Marshall Wace declined to comment. GB News and Lord Agnew were approached for comment.
GB News’s ‘Rosebank-tinted’ CoveragePresenters and guests on GB News have vocally backed the Rosebank and Jackdaw projects.
On 26 October, Rees-Mogg, who lost his seat at the 2024 general election, was asked for his view on Rosebank, replying: “Oh, drill, baby drill. We should get on with it as fast as possible,” adding that the UK should also overturn its ban on fracking for shale gas.
On 19 August, GB News presenter Andrew Pierce interviewed Reform’s deputy leader Richard Tice about the two projects, saying: “If both of them were given the go-ahead, wouldn’t that instantly create some of the extra fuel security, energy security we need, apart from the revenue for the Exchequer?”
Tice replied, “Of course. Both should be given the go-ahead instantly,” adding that the government should grant new North Sea exploration licences, which would break its 2024 manifesto commitment.
On 22 October, Pierce himself called Jackdaw “brilliant” and said it was “madness” for Labour MPs to oppose Rosebank.
GB News political editor Christopher Hope has also made the case for Rosebank, remarking on 26 October: “We’re buying in the oil and gas we would take from Rosebank. Anyway, why not make it in [the UK] and get tax revenue from that asset?”
A few days earlier, on 16 October, he said: “It seems like a no-brainer to many, but not on the left of politics.”
GB News presenter and former Conservative MP Jacob Rees-Mogg.Credit: GB News / YouTube
Last week, the GB News website ran an opinion article by Russell Borthwick, the chief executive of Aberdeen and Grampian Chamber of Commerce, headlined: “Jackdaw approval is a victory for common sense. Now it’s Rosebank’s turn.”
As DeSmog has documented, GB News has long backed new fossil fuels and attacked climate action. It has also given a platform to climate science deniers, including from the Global Warming Policy Foundation (GWPF), a pressure group that says more CO2 emissions would be a “benefit to the planet”.
Marshall has also personally criticised policies designed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, claiming in a speech to the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship (ARC) conference in February 2025 that the world has been infected by a “climate derangement syndrome”. He said “our economic prosperity and our people’s livelihoods” are being sacrificed “all for the sake of making some fractional changes to the level of CO2 in the atmosphere”.
In reality, reaching net zero emissions is predicted to cost only a fraction of UK GDP, while the extreme weather events caused by climate change could have a dramatic impact on the global economy.
Marshall’s Spectator magazine, edited by former Conservative Cabinet minister Michael Gove, has also strongly supported new North Sea drilling.
A piece last week by anti-net zero columnist Ross Clark hailed Jackdaw as “a small victory for common sense” but lamented that Labour will not approve Rosebank so long as the UK keeps its net zero targets.
The Spectator’s “gossip columnist” Steerpike also last week accused Labour MPs of “throwing a tantrum over Jackdaw”, and concluded: “It has taken years, and so much time has been wasted, but at least the most obvious decision facing the country has finally been made. The question is whether Burnham will be brave enough to approve Rosebank as well.”
The Spectator was approached for comment.
The post Two GB News Directors Have Investments in Oil Companies Behind Rosebank and Jackdaw appeared first on DeSmog.
How the Far-Right Uses Climate Disasters to Build Political Power
Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor’s End Times Fascism and the Fight for the Living World is critical reading for anyone seeking to understand and push back against the far-right coalitions wielding considerable state and corporate power around the world.
Klein and Taylor posit that today’s fascists believe that end times have arrived, and have made it their mission to profit from cascading global crises, while hunkering down and protecting themselves as the world burns around them.
The book details three factions of end times fascists, united by their shared apocalypticism. The religious fundamentalists believe end times are upon us, but they will be saved by their messiah. The Silicon Valley technologists are building technologies they say could be world-ending, that in the meantime are killing jobs, consuming vast resources, and polluting communities. The ethno-nationalists espouse conspiratorial ideas about cultural replacement and treat immigration as an existential threat.
DeSmog Canada editor/reporter Mary Stuart spoke with Astra Taylor about how climate change fits into end times fascism, the importance of AI data centre fights, and how we can understand Canadian Prime Minister Carney’s neoliberal moves in response to U.S. President Donald Trump.
Taylor is a writer, documentarian, and activist. She co-founded the Debt Collective, a membership-based union for debtors, and is the author of several books, including The Age of Insecurity and Democracy May Not Exist But We’ll Miss It When It is Gone.
This interview was conducted by phone and has been edited for length and clarity.
Mary Stuart: I want to start by asking how your book can help us understand some recent elections. Jair Bolsonaro’s son Flávio won the first round of voting in Brazil’s election and nearly became president. The far-right AfD recently won in Saxony-Anhalt. How do these wins fit into your analysis of end times fascism?
Astra Taylor: One phenomena we describe in End Times Fascism relevant here is the role of Pentecostal religious communities in turning out the vote. To paraphrase reporting from Brazil, a voter said “my heart’s with Lula, but my pastor told me to vote for Flávio”.
The incredibly difficult conditions that we’re living under created fertile terrain for prophecy and religion, for kinds of pentecostalism, a faith that is focused on prosperity, individual advancement and banking on the idea that life is suffering here on earth, but you will be rewarded in the afterlife.
There’s also interference from Tech oligarchs. We don’t know the half of it at this moment, but the way the platform [Meta] refused to run ads for Lula’s party and beyond is certainly a factor. And the Trump regime [is playing a role] as well.
AfD is a similar. Naomi and I wrote a piece in the Financial Times and we open with the images that went viral this summer of the Danube River drying, and Nazi warships emerging. Hundreds of Nazi warships sank during WWII, and as the river receded, this paraphernalia was coming out of the mud. We thought it was a powerful metaphor for today. What’s really striking is the riverbed— the fact that it’s drying because of climate change. Our point is that fascism always emerges from crises. And we cannot separate the ecological and economic crises people are facing.
People are really struggling with affordability. People are feeling that they don’t have a future. And actually quite strikingly, rates of immigration are quite low, right? So [Saxony-Anhalt is] one of the places with the least immigration, but [the AfD] step in and say “the problem is the immigrants, it’s not a larger economic system.” This is a classic fascist move that we describe throughout the book.
MS: What role do climate change and climate denial play in end times fascism?
AT: Naomi and I are insistent that the planet is a player in our politics. Fascism always surges in moments of crisis.
We are in a world that is being roiled by disasters and shocks. We’ve reached a point where the consequences [of climate change] are undeniable. You cannot deny a heat dome when you’re inside it. You cannot deny a hurricane when it’s blowing the roof off your house. Of course, you can still deny why the storm is coming. You can embrace a Marjorie Taylor Greene perspective and say that it’s due to space lasers or you can say “the climate has always changed, this is nothing new, we don’t know if it’s human causing it.”
The far-right is adapting to circumstances … where ecological catastrophes are the norm, people can’t pay their property insurance bills anymore because the rates have been jacked up or because the insurers have pulled out, or where people have to pay the cost of fixing their homes or moving because of disasters.
The far-right is having to acknowledge that there are fires, there are storms, that people are suffering. They’re responding by deflecting, by saying, “don’t blame the fossil fuel companies and the politicians who take their money, blame the globalists in the EU and their climate policies, or blame the immigrants”.
We saw this really vividly after Hurricane Helene, a tropical storm that hit Appalachia. Trump and Elon Musk were going around saying “FEMA has no money for you because the Democrats spent it on immigrants.” So they use the hurricane to advance the Great Replacement Conspiracy. It’s an amazing pivot to go from a storm destroying tens of thousands of houses to say, “the problem is the globalists are importing immigrants to replace you”. But it’s working.
People have been warning for many years about ecofascism being the consequence of climate change. Ecofascism is the consequence of decades of denial, not just from the far-right, but by liberals who insisted that we could address this crisis through market policies that were doomed to fail.
It’s absolutely criminally irresponsible to not talk about climate change right now because that will create a vacuum for this pivot from the real arsonists to the immigrant victims. And we need to insist on robust climate policies. Not just renewables. It’s investments in care work and in all sorts of low carbon important initiatives. It needs to be at the centre of our politics.
There was a time when liberals could think people will stop denying climate change when they experience it firsthand. We’re seeing that is not true. People in that state of vulnerability and shock are more susceptible to strongmen and scapegoating, and we need to be right there with a different plan and a different story.
MS: In the book you talk about a number of site fights and bright spots, one of them being the AI data centre backlash. What is the importance of AI data centre fights in defeating end times fascism? Can these fights be sites of expansion for movements to touch on other issues as well?
AT: The data centre fight is an amazing opportunity to weave together all of these issues that we know are interconnected. People aren’t fighting data centres in their backyard for just one reason. They are fighting them because they care about their air and water, because they don’t want a future where all the jobs are gone and every bit of economically valuable work, as OpenAI calls it, is performed by robots. It’s also a democracy fight. These data centres are coming in under the cover of non-disclosure agreements, often with little input from even the city council and no input from the community.
But it’s more than that. There’s such intensive capital expenditure, like borrowing on capital markets right now. That’s part of why interest rates are being jacked up around the world, which increases the cost of borrowing for ordinary people. Rates are going up, it’s making homes more unaffordable. The fact that the population is buried by debt is a huge part of what drove Flávio Bolsonaro’s surge in recent months.
All of these factors are compounding, and so it would be foolish for environmentalists not to intervene and try to connect those those dots. The data centre fight has to be connected to affordability.
MS: In Canada, our Prime Minister Mark Carney is a former investment banker who Naomi recently referred to as the ‘paragon of liberalism’. He’s privatizing key pieces of Canadian infrastructure, doubling down on fossil fuels, other extractive projects, and AI, while using the language of standing up to Trump. His approval ratings are incredibly high. How are we to understand this?
AT: Naomi might call him a paragon of liberalism. I call him Sir banks a lot. I don’t trust bankers, especially those who are committed to the kind of neoliberalism and financialization that he’s proposing.
It’s dangerous to say “peer into the window, asset managers of the world. Canada has lots of resources that you can purchase and we have a healthcare system that can still be privatized and higher education system that still has some public funding that we could siphon off to the private sector.”
These are the policies and conditions that created fertile terrain for the far-right. Carney does not seem to have learned that lesson. It was striking when he gave that speech at Davos, about there being a rupture. The world was so ready for Canada to lead, and to project onto that speech that he was actually standing up for true universalism and for international law.
Instead he’s doing this nostalgic hyper-nationalist neoliberalism that isn’t really nationalist, because it was reported by the the Toronto Star that the amount of money going to [the] American tech sector from the Department of National Defense has doubled in the last year. He’s spending Canadian money to enrich the very companies that are behind Trump. You cannot fight oligarchy with oligarchy. You definitely can’t fight fascism with oligarchy. You fight it with solidarity and with democratic socialism, with addressing the root crises.
People want to believe that this figure can protect them when the truth is protection is in building collective power and insisting on a deep economic and political transformation. What he’s doing is incredibly dangerous. And the fact that he’s rolling back already weak climate policies when Canada’s main export is wildfire smoke, is just incredibly insulting and incredibly dangerous. The world needs Canada to stand firm against fascism.
MS: You talk about the power of stories, and detail the stories that the end times fascists are telling. What’s a counter story that’s been missing?
AT: In the book we talk about how we need to tell stories not of end times but of better times. We are entering a period where there are going to be roiling crises. We need to figure out how to live together well under these conditions.
I think we need stories that just remind us of how critical this fight is and that ground us in a love of this world. Naomi and I want stories that connect people to that, that remind people that we do live in a planetary paradise. It’s worth defending.
Ultimately, the organizer in me says we need more than stories. I think it’s incumbent on all of us to try to find a political home, to face the fact that fascism is not something that we can fight alone, we can only fight it together. If there’s not something for you to join, where you live, then start something … It takes not just stories, but actions, however imperfect, however small, however inadequate, but when we all take them, it adds up.
End Times Fascism and the Fight for the Living World can be ordered in Canada, the U.S. And UK.
The post How the Far-Right Uses Climate Disasters to Build Political Power appeared first on DeSmog.
Pages
The Fine Print I:
Disclaimer: The views expressed on this site are not the official position of the IWW (or even the IWW’s EUC) unless otherwise indicated and do not necessarily represent the views of anyone but the author’s, nor should it be assumed that any of these authors automatically support the IWW or endorse any of its positions.
Further: the inclusion of a link on our site (other than the link to the main IWW site) does not imply endorsement by or an alliance with the IWW. These sites have been chosen by our members due to their perceived relevance to the IWW EUC and are included here for informational purposes only. If you have any suggestions or comments on any of the links included (or not included) above, please contact us.
The Fine Print II:
Fair Use Notice: The material on this site is provided for educational and informational purposes. It may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. It is being made available in an effort to advance the understanding of scientific, environmental, economic, social justice and human rights issues etc.
It is believed that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have an interest in using the included information for research and educational purposes. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. The information on this site does not constitute legal or technical advice.




