You are here

G1. Progressive Green

In Pictures: ‘Armageddon’ at Europe’s Swim Spots Linked to Climate Change and Factory Farm Pollution

DeSmogBlog - Wed, 10/21/2026 - 23:00

Across Brittany, tractors can be seen trundling onto beaches to remove truckloads of foul-smelling algae ahead of the tourist rush. 

Situated below steep cliffs and ancient forests, these once pristine beaches have been devastated by algal blooms – the rapid growth of toxic seaweed which kills off fish and plant life. This sea lettuce algae can also release a toxic gas that can cause humans dizziness, chest pain, breathing problems, and even cardiac arrest.

The French peninsula is not alone. Fed by harmful pollution from agriculture, and fuelled by seas warmed by climate change, lurid green blooms are increasingly appearing on beaches and lakes across Europe – prompting hundreds of swimming bans across the continent this summer. 

Subscribe to Desmog Email Address Sign Up Send me intelligence from: All US/Global team UK/Europe team Sign Up --> (function($){ $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-us').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619D07B21962C5AFE16D3A2145673C82A3CEE9D9F1ADDABE965ACB3CE39939D42AC9012C6272FD52BFCA0790F0FB77C6442'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-vdrirr-vdrirr'); }); $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-uk').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619BD43AA6813AF1B0FFE26D8282EC254E3ED0237BA72BEFBE922037EE4F1B325C6DA4918F8E044E022C7D333A43FD72429'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-ijkidr-ijkidr'); }); })(jQuery);

Scientists are clear on the cause: for decades, chemicals including nitrogen and phosphorus have leached into waterways from human sewage, as well as fertilisers and excess manure fuelled by the rapid growth of Europe’s factory farms. 

These ‘nutrients’ are vital for plant growth – but in large quantities they destroy the delicate balance of ecosystems, allowing certain plants, including algae, to multiply at the expense of animals and other species.

Green algae on Plage du Yar, Plestin-le-Grèves, in Brittany, France. Agricultural run-off carries the algae down the river Yar and into the sea. Credit: Selene Magnolia Gatti

DeSmog visited some of the worst impacted spots in Europe, speaking to fishers, swimmers, and business owners whose livelihoods and wellbeing depend on healthy waters.

This article was published in partnership with Euronews and Climatica

On the shores of lakes and beaches across France, Spain, Germany and Northern Ireland, we heard accounts of plummeting fish and insect numbers, swimming bans, and beach closures. 

The risks of algal growth have been known for decades, but higher temperatures and longer summers mean these dangerous blooms are growing larger and lasting longer in many of the continent’s most iconic waterways. 

“I remember our beautiful beach before the pollution,” says Brittany resident Jean Hascoet, who leads local campaign group Baie de Douarnenez Environnement. “Now, with thousands of pigs near our town, everything is different.”

Brittany resident and environmental campaigner Jean Hascoet, pictured here in Douarnenez Bay, France, says the surge in intensive farming in the region has devastated local beaches. Credit: Selene Magnolia Gatti

‘Spain’s Sacrificial Zone’

“You’ll never see me swimming in that water again,” Fina says. 

The 84-year-old from Murcia in southeastern Spain lives with her husband Francisco on the beachfront at Los Urrutias, on the west coast of the Mar Menor, Europe’s largest saltwater lagoon. Rotting seaweed piles up on the shore, giving off a foul stench. 

“This used to be paradise. The sea was teeming with seahorses,” Fina says. 

Brittany resident and environmental campaigner Jean Hascoet, pictured here in Douarnenez Bay, France, says the surge in intensive farming in the region has devastated local beaches. Credit: Selene Magnolia Gatti

The last decade has seen a sharp increase in algae growth in the Mar Menor – a hotspot for Spanish and international tourists. Cyanobacteria, also known as blue-green algae, is reliant on nutrients such as nitrogen and phosphorus to grow, and in this region, intensive farming has provided a ready supply. 

Spain is the EU’s largest producer of pork, accounting for a quarter of the bloc’s production. In the Mar Menor catchment area, according to latest government figures, 305 pig farms house nearly 700,000 animals – producing vast amounts of manure and slurry, a liquid mixture containing faeces and urine. When it rains, the nutrient-rich mixtures flow from fields into rivers feeding the lagoon.

Algae piled up on one of the Mar Menor’s 22 beaches, Los Urrutias, near Murcia, Spain, due to excess nitrogen from industrial agriculture and livestock farming. Credit: Santi Donaire

“The land can’t accommodate it all,” says Pedro Luengo, a biologist and spokesperson for the campaign group Ecologistas en Acción in Murcia. “We’re a sacrificial zone.”

Tourists now steer clear of the area closest to the farmland – the western region where Fina lives, which was once an idyllic family holiday spot. 

Instead, on other beaches, such as La Manga in the east, bathers enjoy an artificial paradise thanks to local authorities who, as in France, remove the algae daily over the summer months. In the first three months of 2026, they collected more than 4,000 tonnes from Mar Menor’s shores and nearby water– roughly the weight of 1,000 elephants.

Algae piles up in skips after being collected by municipal workers in Los Urrutias, Murcia, southeastern Spain. During peak season, cleaning crews remove the algae blooming in the saltwater lagoon on a daily basis. Credit: Santi Donaire

Authorities say these clean-ups help protect human health and allow essential sunlight to reach sea life, which would otherwise be blocked by the blooms. But it has not shielded those who rely on the lagoon for their livelihood.

“We used to catch far more gilthead seabream and prawns. Now the catch is much smaller,” says Rubén Albaladejo, a fisherman from Lo Pagán. “The Mar Menor is a drain into which everyone dumps their rubbish and waste.” 

Algal blooms endanger aquatic life by consuming vast amounts of oxygen, meaning fish, seahorses, and crustaceans can suffocate. They also produce toxins that attack the nervous and respiratory systems of sea life. 

Alongside nutrient pollution, water temperatures rose sharply this year amid record-breaking heatwaves across the continent. “We’ve reached 30 degrees – something we’ve never seen before.” Albaladejo says that in these conditions, species such as gilthead seabream struggle to reproduce.

Scientists warned in August that human-caused climate change was driving record temperatures in the continent’s seas, with a 2C temperature rise registered in the Mediterranean, and around 1.4C in ​Western European seas.

Rubén Albaladejo mends nets on his fishing boat, moored at the fishermen’s guild in San Pedro del Pinatar, Murcia, Spain. Credit: Santi Donaire ‘The Lough Is Dead’

Albaladejo shares his worries with fishers across Europe. Around 2,000 kilometres away in Northern Ireland, Declan Coney has also seen Lough Neagh – the UK’s largest lake – devastated by blue-green algae every summer since 2023. 

“Fishing is instilled in me – generation after generation,” Coney says. “This year has been the worst ever for fishing. The Lough is dead.”

Coney has been working on the lake since 1975. He used to go out with his father and sometimes caught £1,000 worth of fish in a day, he says. But now the cost of the diesel required to boat to his nets can be greater than the value of the catch. 

Trout and eel numbers have fallen in recent years, in part thanks to the oxygen-hogging blue-green algae, whose weight also forces Coney’s fishing nets shut, so fish can’t swim inside. 

Since the 2000s, the lough has also been besieged by the invasive zebra mussel species. These consume large amounts of phytoplankton, depriving other species of these microscopic plant-like organisms, a vital food source, as well as attaching to fishing nets and ripping them. 

“There’s no money [in it],” Coney says. “It’s not a livelihood anymore.”

Declan Coney has fished on Lough Neagh in Northern Ireland for decades, but plummeting catch numbers have made it impossible to make a living.
Credit: Joe Laverty

As in Spain, Lough Neagh’s algal blooms are the result of decades of nutrient pollution. Northern Ireland’s livestock sector has grown rapidly, supported by government expansion plans since 2013: poultry numbers have risen by a third, and pigs by 74 percent. 

Earlier this year, investigative outlet Watershed and The Guardian found evidence of cattle, pig and human faeces in samples of water from the lough, which spans nearly 400 square kilometres and provides 40 percent of Northern Ireland’s drinking water. 

Mary O’Hagan lives on the north-west of the lake. During the Covid-19 pandemic, she set up a wild swimming group, and found that the cold water had huge benefits – from improving mental health to relieving chronic pain.  

“In my 30s, I didn’t have much of a life, I wasn’t looking after myself. Swimming in Lough Neagh changed my life completely,” O’Hagan says. “We had a community.”

But after the second year of the blooms, she felt forced to shut the swimming group down. 

“I couldn’t in all good conscience organise swims where people would be exposed to bacteria, algae, or god knows what else.” 

“The first year… was awful. It was like Armageddon. To see the shores covered as far as the eye can see in pea green sludge, was horrendous,” she says.

Campaigner Mary O’Hagan was forced to shut her swimming group due to harmful pollution in Lough Neagh, Northern Ireland. Credit: Joe Laverty

O’Hagan’s concerns are shared by swimmers and local authorities elsewhere in Europe. In Germany, dozens of lakes are also routinely devastated by algal blooms, triggering a spate of temporary swimming bans this summer. 

“The water used to be clear, you could see your own feet,” says Oland Stephan, who has run a kiosk at Sander lake in northern Germany for 18 years. Once a popular bathing spot, the lake has been off-bounds for swimmers for the last few years because of the blue-green algae – which can cause vomiting, diarrhea, and skin irritation, among other issues. 

“I could make a living back then, but not anymore,” Stephan says. “I have bankruptcy papers at home.”

Peter Bünting, a lifeguard at the lake, says the cloudiness of the water from the algae makes search and rescue operations challenging. “You might have a casualty in front of you but you just can’t see.”

Sander lake in Lower Saxony, Germany. The lake is frequently closed to swimmers due to harmful blue-green algae pollution. Credit: Selene Magnolia Gatti ‘More Animals Than People’

Certain types of algae have been linked to fatalities. When sea lettuce and blue-green algaes break down, they can produce hydrogen sulfide, a lethal gas that smells like rotten eggs and causes  blocked airways and fluid to build up in the lungs if inhaled in large quantities. 

Since the 1980s, sea lettuce algae has been linked to as many as six deaths on Brittany’s beaches. 

Locals here are clear about the cause of the algae growth. Near the tourist town of Saint-Brieuc, “the pigs” has been scribbled across an official sign warning about the danger and symptoms of inhaling toxic gas from the algae. 

“We have many more animals than people,” environmental author Yves-Marie Le Lay told DeSmog. Although the peninsula covers just five percent of France’s surface, its 6.8 million pigs account for 58 percent of the country’s total population. “We have a manure problem, it all ends up in the rivers.”

Author and campaigner Yves Marie Le Lay demonstrates the use of a gas mask on the Plage du Fond de la Baie, in Locquirec, Brittany, France. He uses the device when algae blooms appear, to avoid inhaling any toxic gas. Credit: Selene Magnolia Gatti

For environmental activist Fabrice Hamon, who lives near the Penfoul beach in Western Brittany, bacteria such as E. coli and salmonella from manure run-off have also become a daily concern – washed by rain from farmland down to the sea. 

Since official tests in the summer of 2025 identified E. coli on Penfoul, the beach has been under a partial swimming ban, and is at risk of being closed permanently. 

Red signs warn swimmers and dogs against spending time on the algae-strewn Penfoul beach in Western Brittany. Credit: Selene Magnolia Gatti

Hamon says these bacteria are “super dangerous” if they are swallowed or come into contact with areas like the eyes and nose – and can cause infections, such as conjunctivitis, urinary tract infections, and gastro-intestinal infections that lead to diarrhea and vomiting.

Hamon is uneasy about the coming months. This summer’s droughts meant that fewer harmful excess nutrients were washed into the waterways from fields treated with manure, but instead are stored in the soil until it rains. Europe, the fastest-warming continent in the world, is seeing more intense and unpredictable bouts of extreme weather, including increased downpours and flooding.

“Right now there’s a build-up of bacteria in the fields,” Hamon says. “All it takes is a heavy downpour and bingo. It’s a slow-acting poison: little by little, ecosystems are being degraded by the build-up of pollution linked to intensive farming.”

Environmental activist Fabrice Hamon with the device he is using to test water in the River Foul in Brittany, France. He also regularly collects water samples to test for E. coli. Credit: Selene Magnolia Gatti Warming Seas

As climate change accelerates, warming temperatures are also exacerbating the algal blooms. Algae grows quicker and lasts longer in warm waters, as higher temperatures allow it to digest and reproduce at a faster rate. 

Jürgen Leicher, deputy chairman for the German environmental group BUND in the state of Schleswig-Holstein, has been sailing on the Baltic Sea for 40 years, and says this year’s algal blooms were the worst he’s ever seen. 

Temperatures in Germany broke records for three consecutive days in June, reaching almost 42C. Satellite images of the Baltic in August show vast algal blooms swirling towards the coast.“You feel really afraid when you sail for hundreds of miles through a yellow-brown dirty sea,” says Leicher. “All the way through this algae, the sea was dead. You see no birds, no mammals, no fish. It’s so empty.”

Agriculture is the biggest source of the problem: the intergovernmental body HELCOM estimates it accounts for up to 90 per cent of nitrogen and up to 80 per cent of phosphorus in diffuse nutrient run-off into the Baltic. 

Despite decades of intergovernmental efforts to reduce nutrient pollution, the Baltic is struggling to recover from the environmental damage combined with rising temperatures. Each year, when algae dies it sinks to the seabed, taking large amounts of phosphorus with it. That phosphorus is released back into the ocean in future years — a dangerous feedback loop that picks up speed as the sea warms.

Satellite image of algal blooms in the Baltic Sea, August 2026. Credit: Dávid D. Kovács, Jan Musial, Jędrzej Bojanowski, Dennis Clarijs, Jurry de la Mar, and András Zlinszk / Copernicus Data Space Ecosystem Seeking Solutions

In the face of these huge challenges, residents, campaigners and scientists are united in their determination to find solutions. 

Leicher thinks that better monitoring could help track the profound environmental disruption taking place in the Baltic Sea. His colleagues at BUND Schleswig-Holstein have launched a citizen science project, which will see volunteers collect water samples twice a month from local rivers. By analysing the samples in a laboratory, the organisation hopes to pinpoint sources of pollution and help efforts to cut nutrients.

In Brittany, Fabrice Hamon has designed an app – La Météo Bacterio – which helps monitor for bacteria in the 20 odd rivers that flow onto local beaches, meaning tourists and residents can check for warnings before they swim.

Others are focusing their efforts on political and legal action. In recent years, campaigners and residents have won a raft of legal victories – including persuading the Spanish government in 2022 to bestow ‘legal personhood’ on Mar Menor, providing the lagoon with rights to protection and restoration.

Residents and campaigners stage a protest at Playa de Los Espejos in Los Alcázares against the pollution of Spain’s Mar Menor, September 2026. Credit: Santi Donaire


Ultimately, though, scientists say that nutrient pollution must be slashed to limit the recurrent harmful algae growth – and that means transforming agricultural practices. 

“The science is clear on what needs to be done,” says Professor Friedhelm Taube from Kiel University (CAU), who spent 12 years advising Germany’s Ministry of Agriculture. Governments should support farmers to use less nitrates-heavy fertiliser, plant catch crops like grass clover that absorb some of the excess nutrients from soils before they run into rivers, lakes and sea, and reduce the number of animals farmed on limited land, he says.

“Farming animals can be fine,” Taube says, but to keep nutrient run-off within safe limits, numbers should be reduced to just one ‘livestock unit’ per hectare – a technical term that translates to just one dairy cow or around three pigs. That means far fewer animals in regions where they are intensively farmed, he adds. 

Campaigners in Spain also face a stark choice. “Either we wreck the Mar Menor,” says Pedro Luengo from Ecologistas en Accion, “or we transform the agricultural model”.

In Northern Ireland, Mary O’Hagan is determined to continue to fight for change. “I credit getting into Lough Neagh for the lovely active life I lead,” she says. “It’s one of the reasons I fight back in the way I do.” 

It’s a long fight, but Mary is hopeful. “I’d like to see improvements in my children’s lifetimes – to see it restored to how it was.”

Additional research by Joey Grostern and Louis Bontemps

Editing by Phoebe Cooke and Clare Carlile

The post In Pictures: ‘Armageddon’ at Europe’s Swim Spots Linked to Climate Change and Factory Farm Pollution appeared first on DeSmog.

Categories: G1. Progressive Green

Armenia reconsiders nuclear future as Rosatom offers replacement for aging Soviet reactor

Bellona.org - Wed, 10/21/2026 - 16:10

Armenia is reconsidering its plans for a new nuclear power plant after a fresh proposal from Russia’s state nuclear corporation Rosatom and a sharp revision of the country’s future electricity needs, potentially opening the door to decades of continued dependence on Russian nuclear technology.

The discussions come as Armenia works to extend the operating life of its aging Metsamor nuclear power plant, whose sole functioning reactor was commissioned in 1980 and is now expected to remain in service until at least 2036.

During a September 29 meeting in Yerevan, Rosatom Director General Alexey Likhachev presented Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan with proposals for new nuclear generating capacity, including a Russian-designed VVER-1000 reactor capable of producing approximately 1,000 megawatts of electricity.

The proposal is one of several under consideration by Armenia, which has also explored nuclear cooperation with the United States, France, South Korea and China.

Pashinyan emphasized that no decision had been made and that the government would evaluate competing proposals on economic and technical grounds, including their cost, safety, construction schedules and guarantees.

But according to Bellona nuclear expert Alexander Nikitin Armenia’s eventual decision will be shaped as much by geopolitics as by its electricity requirements.

A changing calculation

Until recently, Armenia had favored replacing Metsamor with one or more small modular reactors, whose relatively modest generating capacity appeared better suited to the country’s limited electricity market.

But on October 1, Pashinyan acknowledged that the government’s calculations had changed.

According to the prime minister, new investment projects, including facilities associated with artificial intelligence, have substantially increased Armenia’s anticipated electricity requirements.

Just over a year ago, he said, Armenia had an electricity surplus. Now, investment commitments have created the prospect of a deficit.

“I have said dozens of times before that we need nothing more than a modular nuclear power plant,” Pashinyan said. “But now, due to this change, we have to understand that, most likely, a modular plant will not be enough for us.”

He suggested that a reactor with a capacity of 1,000 megawatts might prove a more practical alternative, although experts are still examining the question.

The shift could improve Rosatom’s prospects. Unlike many proposed small modular reactor designs, Russia’s conventional VVER technology has an established operating history, something Moscow has emphasized in promoting its nuclear exports.

Yet a large reactor would also present challenges for Armenia’s relatively small electricity grid, requiring careful consideration of how the country would manage the sudden loss of such a substantial generating unit.

Nikitin, however, believes Armenia should continue exploring smaller reactors rather than concentrating its future nuclear generating capacity in one large facility.

“Given Armenia’s heightened seismic activity, I believe the country would be better served by establishing several power-generation centers using small modular reactors based on designs currently being offered by nuclear companies from the United States, South Korea, France or even China,” he said.

He also suggested that Armenia could establish an international consortium to develop small modular reactors, potentially including Rosatom, since cooperation with the Russian corporation will remain necessary as long as Metsamor continues operating.

Keeping Metsamor running

Meanwhile, Armenia remains dependent on its existing nuclear plant.

Metsamor’s second reactor, a Soviet-designed VVER-440 unit, began operating in 1980. Both of the plant’s reactors were shut down following the devastating 1988 Armenian earthquake, but the second was restarted in 1995 amid severe electricity shortages.

Today, it supplies a substantial share of Armenia’s electricity, estimated by Nikitin at approximately 30 to 40 percent.

Rosatom is participating in a modernization program intended to extend the reactor’s operation until 2036, when it will have been in service for 56 years, excluding its period of shutdown.

Likhachev has said he sees no technical obstacles to reaching that target. He also disclosed that Armenian officials are examining the possibility of a further extension until 2046.

Such an undertaking would require extensive additional investment in safety systems, equipment modernization and spent-fuel storage. Likhachev acknowledged that the necessary expenditures could substantially increase the cost of electricity generated by the plant.

Nikitin describes the extension as an interim measure driven by Armenia’s difficult energy circumstances rather than a desirable long-term solution.

“Extending the operating lives of nuclear power plants has become common practice in virtually every country. There is nothing unusual about it in itself, although aging equipment can certainly be expected to cause problems, particularly when subjected to external stresses such as earthquakes,” he said.

He warned that Armenia’s seismic conditions and the limitations of Metsamor’s original Soviet-era design make replacing the plant particularly important.

“The sooner Armenia develops a new nuclear power infrastructure, the less likely it will be to encounter problems with a plant built to an outdated design that did not incorporate many of today’s safety requirements,” Nikitin said.

A decision with lasting consequences

For Armenia, choosing a replacement reactor involves more than selecting generating capacity.

In recent years, Pashinyan’s government has moved toward closer relations with the European Union while effectively freezing its participation in the Russian-led Collective Security Treaty Organization. Armenia has also discussed the possibility of withdrawing from the Eurasian Economic Union.

Nikitin argues that Moscow views these developments with concern and regards nuclear cooperation as one means of maintaining its influence over Armenia.

“Russia is doing everything it can to preserve the country’s dependence on Rosatom, pursuing various initiatives and offering proposals through the nuclear corporation that appear attractive at first glance,” he said.

In Nikitin’s assessment, the strategic purpose of these offers is to discourage Armenia from moving further away from Russian-led institutions and toward the European Union.

Russia already supplies Metsamor’s nuclear fuel and provides technical services. Awarding Rosatom the contract for a replacement plant could preserve that relationship for decades through fuel deliveries, maintenance, specialized equipment, personnel training and nuclear safety support.

“If Armenia agrees to build another Russian nuclear power plant, it will effectively become dependent on Rosatom — and therefore Russia — for nearly a century,” Nikitin warned.

He pointed out that the long-term relationship between a nuclear plant and its technology supplier extends well beyond construction, encompassing fuel supplies, spent-fuel management and the maintenance of specialized equipment.

Choosing a Western or Asian supplier could diversify Armenia’s nuclear partnerships, although alternative technologies would bring their own financing, licensing and construction challenges. Pashinyan has said Armenia expects to select its new reactor technology by the end of 2027, perhaps sooner.

With construction likely to take many years, the government faces a narrowing window in which to replace Metsamor before its planned retirement. For Nikitin, the choice goes to the heart of Armenia’s relationship with Russia.

“The decision to build a new nuclear power plant in Armenia will undoubtedly be driven more by politics than by energy considerations,” he said.

The post Armenia reconsiders nuclear future as Rosatom offers replacement for aging Soviet reactor appeared first on Bellona.org.

Categories: G1. Progressive Green

Best bang for your buck: Halloween edition

Environmental Working Group - Wed, 10/21/2026 - 07:36
Best bang for your buck: Halloween edition JR Culpepper October 21, 2026

.has--background.block-content--type-curated-block-list { padding-top: 3rem; padding-bottom: 3rem; }

Finding the perfect finishing touch for your Halloween costume can be tricky, especially when you have to worry about spooky ingredients hiding in makeup and personal care products.

To make Halloween shopping a little simpler for you and your kids, we’ve rounded up lower-hazard options for eyeliner, mascara, hair gel and body art products, including fake blood, glitter and face paint. And what’s more, they’re all $20 or less.

Each product listed rates green on our Skin Deep® database, which identifies ingredients and potential health hazards in personal care products.

Some of the products below are EWG Verified®, which means they have been reviewed by our scientists to ensure they meet strict health and transparency standards and avoid EWG’s ingredients of concern.

Looking for even more options? Use our Healthy Living™ app on the go to scan any product and find out its hazard rating on Skin Deep. Or look for our EWG Verified mark on products at your favorite shop and online.

Mascara ATTITUDE Oceanly Mascara + Serum, Blue

EWG Verified. Available for $20.58 on Amazon.

PURCHASE ON AMAZON

View details Maia's Mineral Galaxy Natural Mascara, Brown

EWG Verified. Available for $20.99 on Maia's Mineral Galaxy.

PURCHASE HERE

View details The Honest Company Extreme Volume + Bold Lash Primer

EWG Verified. Available for $19.99 on Amazon.

PURCHASE ON AMAZON

View details Well People Expressionist Pro Mascara, Pro Black

EWG Verified. Available for $20 on Well People.

PURCHASE HERE

View Details Eyeliner Rejuva Minerals Eye & Brow Pencil, Black Sapphire

EWG Verified. Available for $18.95 on Rejuva Minerals.

PURCHASE HERE

View Details The Honest Company Vibeliner Pencil Eyeliner, Grounded

EWG Verified. Available for $15 on Amazon.

PURCHASE ON AMAZON

View Details Well People Fresh Lines Liquid Eyeliner, Black

EWG Verified. Available for $12.60 on Amazon.

PURCHASE ON AMAZON

View Details Maia's Mineral Galaxy Mineral Eye Liner, Twilight Green

EWG Verified. Available for $15.49 on Maias Mineral Galaxy.

PURCHASE HERE

View Details Hair Gel Fresh Monster Hair Styling Gel, Medium Hold

Rated 1. Available for $13.98 on Amazon.

PURCHASE ON AMAZON

View Details Jozi Curls, Strong Hold Styling Gel, Style

Rated 1. Available for $5.99 on Jozi Curls.

PURCHASE HERE

View Details Original Sprout Natural Styling Balm

Rated 1. Available for $16.99 on Amazon.

PURCHASE ON AMAZON

View Details Made For Locs Vegan Retwisting Firm Hold Styling Hair Gel

Rated 1. Available for $9.97 on Amazon.

PURCHASE HERE

View Details Miscellaneous Black Moon Cosmetics Moon Diamond, Emerald Eclipse

Rated 1. Available for $17 on Emerald Eclipse.

PURCHASE HERE

View Details Jovy Eyeshadow/Blush, Capri Gold

EWG Verified. Available for $12 on Jovy.

PURCHASE HERE

View Details Areas of Focus Personal Care Products Cosmetics Guest Authors Aspen Rosner, Communications intern October 21, 2026
Categories: G1. Progressive Green

Oil Industry Consultant Joins Climate Denial Group Run by Tory Peer

DeSmogBlog - Wed, 10/21/2026 - 06:51

Kathryn Porter, a consultant to the fossil fuel industry and a prominent critic of emissions reduction policies, has joined the UK’s foremost climate science denial group.

Porter appears frequently in the media as an “independent” expert on energy issues and has been interviewed on the BBC, LBC, GB News, and TalkTV, while her research is often covered in conservative media.

She also writes a column for The Telegraph, and in recent weeks she spoke on energy panels at both Labour and Conservative party conferences.

Porter’s consultancy Watt-Logic advises the oil and gas industry. Its website states that she works for “businesses with projects across the electricity, gas and oil industries”, including “clients with conventional energy assets including gas-fired power stations, gas storage, upstream oil and gas production and [Liquefied Natural Gas]”.

On 16 October, Porter joined the board of the Global Warming Policy Foundation (GWPF), a lobby group set up by Conservative peer and former chancellor Lord Nigel Lawson in 2008 to counter the growing consensus on the need to address man-made climate change.

The group, which is currently led by Tory peer Lord Craig Mackinlay, has said CO2 has been “mercilessly demonised” when it is a “benefit to the planet” – claiming that the atmosphere’s CO2 concentration should be “two or three times” higher than it is now. The group does not publicly declare its funding.

Subscribe to Desmog Email Address Sign Up Send me intelligence from: All US/Global team UK/Europe team Sign Up --> (function($){ $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-us').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619D07B21962C5AFE16D3A2145673C82A3CEE9D9F1ADDABE965ACB3CE39939D42AC9012C6272FD52BFCA0790F0FB77C6442'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-vdrirr-vdrirr'); }); $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-uk').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619BD43AA6813AF1B0FFE26D8282EC254E3ED0237BA72BEFBE922037EE4F1B325C6DA4918F8E044E022C7D333A43FD72429'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-ijkidr-ijkidr'); }); })(jQuery);

In a statement on the GWPF website, Porter said: “I am delighted to be joining the Board of Trustees. Nigel Lawson understood the importance of open debate, rigorous analysis and challenging conventional wisdom, and I look forward to helping build on that legacy.”

Porter has authored two reports for the GWPF, and one for its campaign arm Net Zero Watch, since 2023.

She will sit on the board alongside The Telegraph’s chief interviewer Allison Pearson, and Labour MP Graham Stringer.

Porter has publicly criticised climate policies. In a post on X in January 2025, Porter attacked what she called an “excessive focus on CO2” in energy policy, and in February she suggested the UK’s landmark Climate Change Act should be repealed.

As DeSmog revealed in July 2023, Porter has written blogs that contradict basic climate science. In a 2017 post, she wrote that “climate models overstate global warming”. In fact, climate models have accurately predicted global temperature rises, with observed warming reflecting scientific forecasts.

The UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the world’s foremost climate science body, has stated that it is “unequivocal that human influence has warmed the atmosphere, ocean and land”.

It has also stated that carbon dioxide “is responsible for most of global warming” since the late 19th century, which has increased the “severity and frequency of weather and climate extremes, like heat waves, heavy rains, and drought”.

While Porter and the GWPF claim that reaching net zero emissions by 2050 is unaffordable, a succession of heatwaves during the British summer led to mass school closures, public transport disruption, and a “disaster” harvest – ultimately costing the economy an estimated £4.4 billion.

The Climate Change Committee, an independent government advisory body, has estimated that reaching net zero will cost 0.2 percent of GDP per year – and that its total cost will be less than one fossil fuel price shock.

Porter and the GWPF were approached for comment.

Conservative Connections

Porter and the GWPF have several connections to the Conservative Party.

In January, Clare Coutinho, the then Tory shadow energy secretary, helped to launch a paper written by Porter claiming that renewable energy development could cause blackouts – a claim rejected as “nonsense scaremongering” by the government.

Coutinho had previously suggested that the Labour government should hire Porter to vet its energy policies.

The Conservative Party under Kemi Badenoch has ditched its past support for climate action, declaring it would be “impossible” to reach net zero by 2050, and vowing to repeal the Climate Change Act. Badenoch has banned any Tory candidate from supporting net zero.

Earlier this month, Porter spoke at the Conservative Party’s conference in Birmingham on a panel entitled ‘Solving Britain’s Energy Crisis’ alongside newly-appointed shadow energy secretary Andrew Bowie, head of policy at Octopus Energy Jack Pardoe, and Liam Halligan, a former GB News presenter and the director of the Centre for Policy Studies think tank.

Porter also spoke on a GWPF panel at last year’s Tory conference entitled ‘Can Britain survive Ed Miliband?’, where she called for net zero to be scrapped and for increased fossil fuel extraction. 

As DeSmog revealed in September 2024, GWPF donors have given more than £7 million to the Conservatives over the past two decades.

At this year’s Labour Party conference in Liverpool, Porter also spoke on an energy panel organised by the oil exploration company EnQuest, whose CEO Amjad Bseisu is a Conservative Party donor.

Speaking alongside Bseisu, GMB general secretary Gary Smith, and Labour donor Dale Vince, Porter called for taxes to be reduced on the fossil fuel industry and for the UK to expand its North Sea drilling. 

The post Oil Industry Consultant Joins Climate Denial Group Run by Tory Peer appeared first on DeSmog.

Categories: G1. Progressive Green

Five problems with the FDA’s proposed food chemicals rule

Environmental Working Group - Wed, 10/21/2026 - 05:23
Five problems with the FDA’s proposed food chemicals rule Anthony Lacey October 21, 2026

A new EWG analysis finds a Food and Drug Administration proposed food chemicals rule update may represent more bark than bite – its “requirements” could be mandatory in name only, and worse, may weaken the current rule. 

The FDA in August proposed to narrow a legal loophole in a food chemicals approval process that’s currently shrouded in mystery. 

The food chemicals fall into the category of “generally recognized as safe,” or GRAS. 

The GRAS loophole allows food and chemical companies, rather than the FDA, to greenlight new food chemicals or new uses of those chemicals – often in secret. Since 2000, the food and chemical industry has greenlighted nearly 99% of food chemicals introduced onto the market without federal safety review, a 2025 EWG analysis found.

Under current law, a company gets to decide for itself whether to notify the FDA after deciding a food chemical is GRAS. Many choose not to inform the agency, leaving it – and consumers – in the dark about what’s in their food. 

EWG has identified over 100 of these so-called “secret GRAS” chemicals used in thousands of products. The FDA estimates in the proposed rule that there could be thousands of these secret ingredients. 

The FDA rule purports to take the secrecy out of GRAS by mandating companies tell it when they determine a new chemical or use is safe. But EWG’s analysis suggests the proposed rule is toothless and may weaken some existing requirements. 

Here are five major problems with the FDA’s proposal. 

1. Potentially unsafe chemicals can still go into food before FDA review 

The FDA has said its proposed rule will end so-called secret GRAS notifications by requiring companies to notify it when they introduce a new ingredient. 

But buried in the rule is a remarkable admission: “a company may reach a GRAS conclusion about a new use of a substance and introduce the substance into interstate commerce before submitting a GRAS notice.” 

Worse, there’s no deadline for notifying the FDA. A chemical could be on the market indefinitely before the FDA gets involved. And it’s allowed to remain on the market while the FDA completes its review. 

So even if the FDA decides in the end a chemical is not safe, consumers may have already been exposed for years. 

2. No incentive to comply

What happens to a company that ignores the notification requirement? Not much, according to the rule. 

It states that non-compliance is merely “a factor in FDA’s prioritization of food substances for post-market review.” It doesn’t lead to civil penalties or any requirement to pull the product from shelves.

The FDA’s post-market review program is chronically underfunded and notoriously slow. It took the FDA nearly 35 years to ban Red Dye No. 3 after determining in 1990 the dye causes cancer. The FDA banned brominated vegetable oil 50 years after first raising concerns about its safety. And petitions calling on the FDA to address potentially dangerous chemicals often languish for years.

With the agency sometimes taking decades to work its way through its watchlist, if it ever does, the threat of landing on that list is not a meaningful deterrent.

3. No data? No problem! 

The proposed rule streamlines the review process for potentially thousands of chemicals and uses currently on the market. These are chemicals companies have secretly decided should be considered GRAS and never told the FDA about. 

To qualify for this process, a company must submit basic information only, including, in addition to its name and its uses, details about how much of it was being used and proof it was being sold in food before the rule took effect. 

What isn’t required: safety data. Scientific justification. Not even a short summary of why the company thinks the substance is safe. 

The proposed rule states the FDA will post these submissions on a public list, but it also says appearing on the list “does not mean that the FDA has reviewed the GRAS status of the substance.” 

How many secret GRAS chemicals or uses could benefit from this “streamlined” process? No one knows, but the FDA estimates it could receive more than 2,400 submissions from more than 900 companies through this track alone. 

Some new substances – or new uses of substances already in our food – have never been reviewed by the FDA for safety. And under this rule, they wouldn’t have to be. They’d simply be registered. 

This approach contrasts starkly with current law. 

Today, when a company submits a notice to the FDA, it must include a list of all the data it relied on to conclude the chemical was safe. All that information must be of the “same quantity and quality of scientific evidence” as would be required by the more rigorous pre-market review process for food additives. 

4. Creates perverse incentives to rush potentially unsafe ingredients onto store shelves

Any substance in the food supply before the rule’s effective date can use the streamlined no-safety-data process up to one year after the rule is finalized. 

Finalizing a proposed rule can take years. The last time the FDA updated its GRAS process, through a rule proposed in 1997, it took the agency 19 years to finalize. 

Now there’s a window when companies can introduce new chemicals – or use chemicals in new ways – by taking advantage of the shorter process.  

The proposed rule effectively rewards companies for getting their product on the market quickly, before oversight begins. It gives companies a financial incentive to move quickly, skipping review rather than taking  the time for careful scrutiny. 

A rule intended to rein in the secret GRAS loophole process may accelerate the very behavior it was meant to stop.

5. Creates a major new loophole for minor amounts of new chemicals 

The proposal also expands a fairly obscure exemption, as the Guardian recently reported.  

Until recently, the “threshold of regulation” loophole applied only to food contact materials that might leach into food in tiny amounts – 0.5 parts per billion. Any chemical whose dietary exposure falls below that threshold and does not cause cancer is able to evade the normal review process. 

Companies have exploited the rules to let some chemicals into the food supply. Perchlorate, a rocket fuel chemical that could harm children’s brain development, can be used in dry food packaging through the loophole.

The proposed rule would extend this exemption to substances added directly to food. That’s a major change. 

The FDA’s cancer-centered approach to risk also ignores other important kinds of potential harm. For example, hormone-disrupting chemicals can cause damage at very low doses. So can chemicals that affect fetal development, harm the nervous system or suppress immune function. 

The proposed loophole extension also fails to consider the total risk that might come from exposure to the same chemicals from other foods or from non-food sources like personal care products. 

This new exemption could allow substances like flavor ingredients, enzymes, solvents, processing aids and fermentation byproducts to skip FDA review altogether. 

What we need instead

The FDA’s proposal will not fix the problems with our food chemical review system. Congress can still step in to make our food safer. 

Rep. Frank Pallone (D-N.J.) and Sens. Ed Markey (D-Mass.) and Cory Booker (D-N.J.) have introduced legislation that would go much further than the proposed rule. It would require pre-market review of new GRAS substances, mandate disclosure of important safety data, and give the FDA the resources it needs to complete the job. 

These bills represent the kind of structural reform the GRAS system needs. EWG urges Congress to move the bills forward and calls on the FDA to strengthen its proposed rule.

States stepping up

In the meantime, states have stepped in to fill the FDA’s regulatory gaps. More than 30 states have introduced legislation to make our food safer. Food companies have responded by reformulating products.

New York recently passed a bill requiring companies to disclose their use of GRAS substances, which is awaiting the governor’s signature. Any federal action on food chemicals must preserve these important state protections. 

EWG will continue to push for a food safety system that puts consumer health first – not one that creates the appearance of oversight while leaving the door open to unreviewed chemicals.

Areas of Focus Food Authors Melanie Benesh October 21, 2026
Categories: G1. Progressive Green

Samadua’s Nutmeg, Beutong Ateuh’s Candlenut, and the Shadow of Expanding Mining Frontiers in Aceh

Yes to Life no to Mining - Wed, 10/21/2026 - 01:03
Samadua's Nutmeg, Beutong Ateuh's Candlenut, and the Shadow of Expanding Mining Frontiers in Aceh

A campaign essay by Yayasan APEL Green Aceh

See Yayasan APEL Green Aceh's campaigns here Summary

Plans for metal mineral mining in Samadua Subdistrict, South Aceh, and Beutong Ateuh Banggalang Subdistrict, Nagan Raya, have triggered agrarian conflict in Aceh. This essay reads the two cases as manifestations of a structural problem: part of the expansion of the extractive frontier into the landscapes of smallholder spice cultivation. In Samadua, nutmeg (Myristica fragrans) has been the backbone of family economies since long before the district existed. In Beutong Ateuh, kemili (the Gayo-Acehnese name for candlenut, Aleurites moluccana) grows alongside areca nut, coffee, cacao, rice, and durian on slopes that form the headwaters of the Meureubo River and part of the Leuser–Ulu Masen Ecosystem corridor. The argument is simple. What is at stake in these mining plans is not merely a stand of forest or a plot for spice production, but the moral economy of farmer-stewards of the landscape, tested over countless generations. Once dismantled by a mining permit, that ecosystem cannot be restored by any amount of compensation.

Reading Two Subdistricts as One Event

 There is a temptation to treat Samadua and Beutong Ateuh, two subdistricts in the Indonesian province of Aceh, as separate cases. Samadua lies on Aceh’s southwest coast, where nutmeg trees descend the slopes toward the sea. Beutong Ateuh lies in Aceh’s inland highlands, where candlenut and coffee fill the gaps between mountain valleys. Yet reading them separately is a serious analytical mistake. They share at least three things: (1) remaining stands of Sumatran tropical rainforest that regulate the hydrology of the wider landscape; (2) smallholder spice-farming systems that have sustained families for decades to centuries; and (3) a new wave of metal mining business permits (IUP) issued or renewed in 2025–2026, without meaningful consultation with affected communities.

In the framework of political ecology, what we see in both areas is a local manifestation of a global process that some thinkers call accumulation by dispossession: the accumulation of capital not through productive innovation but through the seizure of living space. That living space is not empty land waiting to be priced. It is a web of local institutions, agroecological knowledge, collective memory, and spiritual relationships that make a piece of landscape irreplaceable.

The essay proceeds in four steps. First, it situates Samadua and Beutong Ateuh within the political ecology of post-conflict, post-tsunami Aceh. Second, it reads the nutmeg and candlenut economies as production systems that are more than commodities. Third, it examines the mining permit regime now operating in both areas, with particular attention to Supreme Court Decision No. 91.K/TUN/LH/2020 and how a series of new IUPs appears to circumvent it. Fourth, it reads the November 2025 Sumatra flash floods as a hydrological warning that must not be ignored in spatial planning decisions.

 

 

Beutong Ateuh agroforestry ecosystem and buffer zone to the Leuser-Ulu Masen Ecosystem, home to Sumatran tiger, Rhino, orangutan and countless other species

Samadua – A Subdistrict Built on the Scent of Nutmeg

 South Aceh is often called the heart of Indonesia’s nutmeg production. This is not rhetoric. For more than a century, household economies along the western Bukit Barisan, from Meukek, Sawang, and Samadua to Tapaktuan, have depended on nutmeg trees planted in mixed gardens alongside durian, clove, patchouli, chili, and jengkol. These gardens are not monocultures. They are agroforestry systems that ecologically mimic the structure of secondary forest, store water, protect soil from erosion, and support biodiversity that will never appear in conventional economic accounts.

The Samadua nutmeg economy is a textbook example of what the agrarian literature calls smallholder resilience. Farming families have great harvesting flexibility. Nutmeg can be picked year-round and sold as mace, seed, or fruit flesh for candied preserves; market risk is spread out; and productive assets can be passed across generations without being divided into worthless fragments. This system was not a gift from the state. Farmers built it, with knowledge handed down and renewed from one generation to the next, season after season. Even when white root rot (Rigidoporus microporus) struck nutmeg gardens in the past decade, the community’s response, supported by the Aceh Nutmeg Forum, led to the recovery of hundreds of hectares of smallholder gardens and to a more disease-resistant improved variety, “Sambutan.” This is a community able to look after itself, so long as its living space is not taken from under its feet.

This is where mining becomes dangerous. According to reporting by the Aceh Civil Society Coalition, two companies hold exploration IUPs in the Samadua area, totaling about 1,491.4 hectares: PT Bersama Sukses Mining (PT BSM) with 752.4 hectares and PT Mineral Mega Sentosa (PT MMS) with 739 hectares. The figure looks modest on paper, but projected onto maps of villages and smallholder gardens, it becomes a threat to water sources, to slope fertility, and to the ecological connection between nutmeg gardens and the forest stands on hilltops that hold back rainwater.

Even more troubling is the permitting process itself. In an open “love letter” issued by the Samadua Student Association (IMPS) on the 69th anniversary of South Aceh in November 2025, it is clear that residents experienced what is technically called procedural dispossession: their inherited land was placed on the Mining Business License Area (WIUP) map without outreach, without the knowledge of landowners, and without meaningful consultation. When the principle of Free, Prior, and Informed Consent (FPIC) is reduced to a perfunctory signature or skipped entirely, the permit that results is no longer an instrument of spatial planning. It becomes what the Aceh Civil Society Coalition called “a blank check for companies to enter and take control of people’s living space.”

On the night of Saturday, 15 August 2026, after the Isya prayer, hundreds of Samadua residents signed a petition against the mine at the Al-Munawarah Mosque in Gampong Kota Baru. A similar action had earlier been held by the Samadua South Aceh Kinship Association (IKSAS) in Subulussalam. This was not an impulsive act but a collective decision by a community that had carefully weighed how great the risk of losing water sources from the hills around their gardens would be, how long mining compensation could make up for lost in nutmeg income across generations, and how many agrarian conflicts would flare if the permits were forced through.

Samadua and its centuries old nutmeg agroforestry ecosystem

Beutong Ateuh – Candlenut, Rivers, and a Bloody History

About two hundred kilometers to the north, in the highlands of Nagan Raya, Beutong Ateuh Banggalang occupies a geographic position that may be even more ecologically strategic. The least populous subdistrict in Nagan Raya (about 2,026 people according to the latest data), it sits at roughly 556 meters above sea level, at the meeting point of two of Sumatra’s most important ecosystem landscapes: the Leuser Ecosystem (KEL) and the Ulu Masen Ecosystem. Beutong Ateuh’s forests are a living bridge, a corridor, between the two landscapes, allowing large wildlife such as orangutans, tigers, and Sumatran elephants to move, interbreed, and survive.

On the slopes of that corridor grows what Acehnese and Gayo people call kemili, alongside Robusta coffee. According to mapping by Syiah Kuala University, the land area for both covers 4,379 hectares, more than 61% of the potential coffee plantation area of Nagan Raya Regency. Together with paddy rice, areca nut, cacao, and durian, these commodities form a livelihood system as old, and as moral, as the Samadua nutmeg system.

But this landscape carries wounds. In Aceh’s contemporary history, the name Beutong Ateuh is tied to two events that must not be overlooked. The first is the 1999 human tragedy, when armed violence took the lives of Teungku Bantaqiah and dozens of his students, an event that made this land, in collective memory, tanoh (land) of the martyrs. The second, more recent, is the flash flood and landslide of 26 November 2025, which destroyed at least 200 homes and nearly erased Kuta Teungoh Village from the map. The Meureubo River, which rises in the Leuser forest and empties into the Indian Ocean, overflowed with an intensity not recorded in even the oldest residents’ memory. Months after the disaster, residents are still living in temporary shelters, and to this day the clean water crisis has not fully recovered.

It is in this context that the metal mineral mining permit regime has been reactivated. Through Decree of the Head of the Aceh Investment and One-Stop Integrated Services Agency No. 540/DPMPTSP/05/IUP-Eks./2026, PT Alam Cempaka Wangi (ACW) obtained an Exploration IUP for metal minerals (copper) in Beutong Ateuh Banggalang covering 1,820 hectares. PT Hasil Bumi Sembada (HBS) also holds an exploration permit. Taken together, the eight companies holding IUPs in Nagan Raya, including CV Blang Leumak Raya, PT Hikmah Beutong Raya, PT Mozika Karian Meutuah, PT Nagan Mineral Murni, and two coal companies, point to one thing: the state is viewing this landscape not as an ecological buffer but as a mineral reserve waiting to be extracted.

What makes this configuration ethically and legally problematic is the existence of Supreme Court Decision No. 91.K/TUN/LH/2020. That decision revoked the permit of PT Emas Mineral Murni (PT EMM) over a 10,000-hectare concession in Beutong Ateuh, on the grounds that the concession could damage the Leuser Ecosystem and environmental functions, and that it lay in an area prone to floods, landslides, drought, and earthquakes of VII–XII on the Modified Mercalli Intensity scale. In other words, the decision is a legal instrument that positions Beutong Ateuh as an area that should be free of any extractive activity. The reappearance of new IUPs after that ruling violates the spirit of the law set by Indonesia’s highest court.

Dried Candlenuts from the agroforests of Beutong Ateuh

The Permit Regime as Structural Violence

Let us pause to reflect on what is actually happening. When a mining business permit is issued without FPIC, without meaningful consultation, and without mapping its overlap with people’s productive land, what is taking place is not mere administrative negligence but a form of structural violence: violence that works through procedure, through stamps and signatures, through maps drawn in comfortable rooms hundreds of kilometers from the gardens where nutmeg and candlenut trees grow.

This violence operates on several levels at once. At the first level, it delegitimizes people’s rights over their own land, which has been managed for generations but which, in the eyes of the permit regime, lacks a “formal certificate.” At the second level, it alters power relations within the community: some residents, promised jobs or financial rewards, support the mine, while most oppose it. This creates horizontal conflict that did not previously exist, and companies often exploit it to justify claims that “the local community supports” the project. At the third level, it hands long-term risks such as hydrological damage, heavy metal contamination, and further deforestation to the communities least able to bear them, while profits are siphoned off to centers of capital far beyond Aceh’s borders.

In contemporary political-ecological analysis, this configuration is not an anomaly but a pattern. It recurs in Halmahera, in Southeast Sulawesi, in Central Kalimantan, wherever the extractive frontier pushes into areas previously regarded as “peripheral.” What makes the Aceh case especially urgent is the Leuser Ecosystem, the only place in the world where orangutans, tigers, elephants, and Sumatran rhinos still share a single landscape, a biogeographic fact that makes any decision to allow mining in its buffer zone a decision with consequences beyond the jurisdiction of the Republic of Indonesia.

Nutmeg from the agroforests of Samadua

The November 2025 Disaster: A Warning Not to Be Missed 

As a result of the Sumatra flash floods of 25 November 2025, around 85 percent of the villages in Beutong Ateuh were lost. Beutong Ateuh, long known as a fertile farming region, was severely damaged. A day before the flood hit Beutong Ateuh on 26 November 2025, APEL Green Aceh found about 30 cubic meters of logs piled up in an area bordering protected forest in Babah Suak Village, the link between the Leuser forest and the Ulu Masen forest in Aceh Province. Forest Watch Indonesia (FWI) recorded that Aceh Province lost around 177 thousand hectares of forest, 2.5 times the area of Singapore, in just seven years. In a single year alone, the Land of the Veranda of Mecca lost around 16 thousand hectares of natural forest.

Treating the November 2025 disaster as a lesson is a moral and scientific imperative. When upstream forests are cleared or torn open by extractive activity, the water cycle is disrupted. Extreme rainfall, whose frequency and intensity are rising with climate change, can no longer be absorbed gradually into the soil and aquifers. Water moves as surface runoff carrying mud, rocks, and tree trunks down the slopes with devastating force. If we allow mineral mining to operate on the slopes of Beutong Ateuh, just hit by flash floods, or in the hills of Samadua that feed the water sources of smallholder nutmeg gardens, we are not only defying the wisdom of spatial planning but actively preparing the next disaster.

Ecological Resistance from Below

Perhaps the most remarkable thing about these two cases is not the threat but the response. In Samadua, the protest against the mine is led not by a single figure but by a web of actors: students, community leaders, mosque imams, and mothers and fathers who sign petitions after the Isya prayer. In Beutong Ateuh, resistance continues from generation to generation, from Teungku Diwa Laksana, Abu Kamil, and the Beutong Ateuh community, who openly rejected PT EMM’s exploitation in September 2018, to today’s rejection of PT Bumi Sempada and PT Alam Cempaka Wangi. An official letter rejecting the mine was sent to the President of the Republic of Indonesia in May 2026, signed by the Pawang Uteun community, Yayasan APEL Green Aceh, and 99 local, national, and global civil society organizations.

This resistance is not merely a reaction. It is a positive statement about the kind of development people want. When Rusli, Secretary of Babah Suak Village, says “This Beutong land is not for sale,” he is articulating a political theory: that land is not a commodity, and that the value of a landscape cannot be reduced to rupiah per hectare. When a resident of Beutong Ateuh says “if it’s farming, it’s certain the residents benefit and nature is preserved,” he is advancing an entirely sensible political-economic proposition: that smallholder agriculture, which spreads benefits widely and preserves ecological function, is a more rational form of development than extractive mining that concentrates profit at the center and leaves costs on the periphery.

This resistance moves within legal, moral, and ecological frameworks at once. It reminds the state of Supreme Court Decision 91.K/TUN/LH/2020. It reminds all of us of the agrarian understanding that land is a trust across generations. It reminds science that a landscape that has shown its vulnerability to disaster must not be opened up further.

The process of drying candlenuts in Beutong Ateuh

Aceh’s Nature Is Not a Legacy to Be Used Up

When we place Samadua and Beutong Ateuh side by side, we see more than two mining conflicts. We see a historic choice facing Aceh: will this landscape be managed as an ecological buffer and a stage for a sustainable smallholder spice economy, or will it be handed over to an extractive regime that has repeatedly proven it leaves behind holes, mud, and wounds?

That choice is not hypothetical. It is being made today, through every IUP issued, every WIUP map drawn, every consultation skipped, and every resident’s voice left unheard. Yayasan APEL Green Aceh, Selamatkan Hutan Hujan, Yes to Life No to Mining, Pawang Uteun, Lanskap Hijau Sumatera, and the entire civil society network state their position clearly: (1) a comprehensive evaluation of all IUPs in Samadua and Beutong Ateuh; (2) full application of the FPIC principle; (3) public disclosure of permitting information; and (4) a halt to mining activities that could trigger agrarian conflict and environmental damage until land rights, community participation, and ecological impacts are resolved openly.

Samadua’s nutmeg has fed families for more than a hundred years. Beutong Ateuh’s candlenut has grown alongside Aceh’s long history of resistance. The rivers flowing from both areas give life to millions of people downstream. The November 2025 disaster has warned us what happens when this landscape is weakened. The 2020 Supreme Court decision has declared what legally must not be done. The voices from the villages have said plainly what they want. What remains is for the state to find the courage to listen. Aceh’s nature is not a legacy to be used up.

Yayasan APEL Green Aceh, for the forests, water, and living space of the people of Aceh.

Is your community, organization, or network interested in becoming a YLNM member? Would you like to know more about us? Please send an email enquiry to membership[at]yestolifenotomining.org

Subscribe to our bi-monthly newsletter Suscríbase a nuestro boletín

Yes to Life No to Mining global solidarity network since 2012 | Contact Us

The post Samadua’s Nutmeg, Beutong Ateuh’s Candlenut, and the Shadow of Expanding Mining Frontiers in Aceh appeared first on Yes to Life No to Mining.

Categories: G1. Progressive Green

How Big Pharma Tried to Weaken the Rules of the UN’s Nature Fund

DeSmogBlog - Tue, 10/20/2026 - 21:30

As the COP17 nature summit gets underway in Armenia, evidence has emerged of lobbying by a leading international pharmaceuticals group to weaken the terms of a flagship fund for nature.

Documents analysed by DeSmog show that the International Federation of Pharmaceutical Manufacturers and Associations (IFPMA) called for a “radical rethink” of the rationale for the landmark Cali Fund – the first mechanism built to take voluntary payments from large companies that profit from genetic sequence data.

The IFPMA states that the “modalities of the decision” to establish the Fund – which was ratified by 196 countries in 2024 at the COP16 summit of the UN Convention on Biological Diversity in Colombia – should be “significantly reviewed, revised and clarified”.

In the consultation submission, the trade group – which represents the pharmaceutical sector at the UN – also challenged the indicative rates at which companies were invited to contribute to the Fund, agreed at COP16 as 0.1 percent of revenue or 1 percent of profit.

The IFPMA labelled these indicative rates as “premature”, set “without any rational analysis”, and “commercially unrealistic”, suggesting instead that companies be allowed to contribute to the voluntary fund at a level of their choosing. 

Other demands from the IFPMA included a guarantee that any contribution would explicitly substitute payments for digital sequence information required under national or international laws.

Despite contributions to the Cali Fund already being voluntary, following a fierce lobbying push at the last summit, the IFPMA also seeks a guarantee they will remain so, stating that “there are elements in the decision that do not go far enough in creating a truly voluntary mechanism”.

Responses from other sectors, such as biotechnology and cosmetics – which are listed alongside pharma and artificial intelligence firms in the treaty text as industries that should contribute – echo some of the IFPMA’s objections, and appear to be reluctant to support the Fund as it is currently conceived. 

The UK Bioindustry Association (UK BIA), which has 600 biotech and life sciences companies among its members, says the CBD’s expectations for what the Fund can raise are currently set “unrealistically high”, in its consultation response dated March 2025. 

UK BIA states that “for the Fund to succeed in the long term”, questions over its design and operationalisation must be addressed, and “clear incentives” created. 

The revelations come as negotiators gather for the UN biodiversity summit in Armenia this week, with just $10,000 pledged by companies to the Cali Fund. 

It falls far short of the $1 billion to $10 billion that the UN had hoped the Fund could draw in every year, half of which is mandated to flow directly to the Indigenous and local communities that steward biodiversity.

“The tiny amounts contributed to the Cali Fund so far, combined with continued delays from industry, send a clear signal: voluntary contributions are simply not delivering,” An Lambrechts, a biodiversity politics expert at Greenpeace International, told DeSmog. 

The latest UN report shows that the world is off track on all but one of 23 targets aimed at reversing catastrophic nature loss, with the total funds raised to date from both private and public bodies falling far short of what is needed to close a $200 billion “biodiversity finance gap”.

“Big multinational corporations are turning massive profits by exploiting nature,” Lambrechts says, “while leaving people all over the world to face the impacts of the biodiversity crisis.”

Subscribe to Desmog Email Address Sign Up Send me intelligence from: All US/Global team UK/Europe team Sign Up --> (function($){ $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-us').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619D07B21962C5AFE16D3A2145673C82A3CEE9D9F1ADDABE965ACB3CE39939D42AC9012C6272FD52BFCA0790F0FB77C6442'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-vdrirr-vdrirr'); }); $('.newsletter-container .ijkidr-uk').click(function() { $('.js-cm-form').attr('data-id', '2BE4EF332AA2E32596E38B640E905619BD43AA6813AF1B0FFE26D8282EC254E3ED0237BA72BEFBE922037EE4F1B325C6DA4918F8E044E022C7D333A43FD72429'); $('.js-cm-email-input').attr('name', 'cm-ijkidr-ijkidr'); }); })(jQuery);

A spokesperson for the UN Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) Secretariat admits that the sums in the Fund “sit well below the scenarios that were discussed in Cali”, but puts this down to the evolving “operational infrastructure” and its low profile.

“Substantive decisions expected at COP17 are expected to give in-scope companies more solid ground to commit,” they said.

“I do believe companies have legitimate concerns, but there’s also a sense in which they don’t want to pay,” said a source close to the negotiations, who preferred to remain anonymous. “If these industries were really supportive then someone would have put the money in by now, even just as a token, a show of good faith.”

Guilherme Cintra, Director, Innovation Policy at IFPMA wrote in an email that the group had “long supported the goals of the Convention on Biological Diversity and continues to deliver against the targets set out in the Global Biodiversity Framework”.

He added: “The level of participation in the Cali Fund reflects ongoing questions about the design and implementation of the mechanism, rather than a lack of commitment to biodiversity. Governments should use COP17 to rethink the Cali Fund to attract broader participation and ensure it supports biodiversity and preserves scientific openness.” 

UK BIA declined to comment on the record. 

“It’s concerning that, nearly two years after the agreements reached at COP16 in Cali, funding for biodiversity protection remains an unfulfilled promise,” Juan Bay, leader of the indigenous Waorani nation of Ecuador told DeSmog.

“This reflects a situation we have been denouncing for years: Indigenous peoples protect some of the most biodiverse territories on the planet, yet we continue to face enormous difficulties in directly accessing the funding needed to protect them.”

History of Pushback

When the Cali Fund was launched in February last year, the UN hailed it as the beginning of “a new era for biodiversity finance”.

The new financial instrument aimed to address a new reality: that genetic data, known as digital sequence information, or DSI, is now available online. This allows companies, or researchers, to access material from plants, animals, bacteria and fungi without ever setting foot in the country of origin – and bypass rules that require payment. 

As a result, the genetic code that underpins a range of lucrative products – everything from sweeteners to the vast majority of cancer drugs – is available with few rules to limit access. 

The Cali Fund, Carbon Brief writes, was aimed at “closing this loophole”. It was agreed that 50 percent of funds would go to Indigenous communities and local communities that steward fragile ecosystems, with the rest going to Global South countries and scientific research.

At the COP16 summit where the Fund was agreed, the business lobby reached a record high, including from sectors that the mechanism was built around: pharmaceuticals, biotechnology, cosmetics, and information services associated with DSI, including artificial intelligence.

An Indigenous delegate taking part in UN talks in Colombia two years ago, when the Cali Fund was first agreed. Half of any funds raised are ear-marked for Indigenous and local communities that care for fragile ecosystems. Credit: Photographer: Fernando Vergara / Associated Press /Alamy

A Global South government push at the UN talks for the Fund to be a mandatory mechanism was defeated in the wake of a strong lobbying effort by the pharma, agritech and biotech industry, which dubbed the proposed levy a ‘global tax’.

In the lead up to the summit, UK-based pharma giant AstraZeneca, which posted $12.4 billion in profits last year, had warned the British government it “might cut jobs” if a levy were introduced, according to The Guardian. An AstraZeneca spokesperson denied the comments. 

Another pharma giant, GSK, also pushed back against the Fund, which it called “disproportionate”, telling the UK government it could “hinder the development of new medicines and vaccines”, in emails obtained by Carbon Brief.

A spokesperson from GSK told DeSmog it had set ambitious targets and was investing in nature protection. “We support the intent behind the Cali Fund and will make a decision regarding voluntary contributions when there is more information about how the Cali Fund will work alongside other national and multilateral Access and Benefit Sharing mechanisms,” they said. 

“As a company, we are committed to advancing our research and development in response to the needs of patients,” an AstraZeneca spokesperson said in an email. “An assessment of the full impact on our operations will be conducted once there is more clarity from governments on the implementation of the DSI MLM [Cali Fund].”

Since 2024, the pharmaceutical industry’s global lobby group the IFPMA appears to have continued to focus its energy on weakening the rules that were agreed in Colombia.

The COP16 agreement established key elements of the Fund: contribution rates, a list of sectors that should contribute, and set thresholds to ensure large companies were expected to give to the fund, defining qualifying entities as those that exceeded two of three financial thresholds: $20 million in assets, $50 million in sales, or $5 million in profit.

However, rates and thresholds were marked as ‘indicative’ and set to be finalised at the current talks in Armenia. 

Cali Fund Push Back 

To build on what had been agreed in Cali, Colombia, the CBD sought to engage industry over how to make the Fund operational – inviting responses on what sectors should contribute and how.

DeSmog analysed 22 responses, which were submitted by 14 groups in response to stakeholder consultations issued by the Convention of Biological Diversity secretariat, along with available public statements from industry groups that have engaged publicly with the Fund.

In their submissions, industry groups pushed back on a range of fronts. The IFPMA, which claims to represent over 90 percent of the world’s leading research-based pharmaceutical companies, emerges as the Fund’s most outspoken critic.

It called for a “radical rethink” of the Fund’s rationale, and states that the MLM (multilateral mechanism that gives rise to the Cali Fund) does not “effectively advance biodiversity goals”. 

The group criticised everything from contribution levels, a lack of clarity “on how funds will be allocated or guarantees that funds will directly support conservation efforts”, and proposed that the treaty decision text be “significantly reviewed, revised and clarified”.

’A Tax on Innovation’

The IFPMA states that the MLM “essentially imposes a financial burden on the free exchange of scientific data, which is critical for medical, environmental and other societal research”. It adds that: “by taxing DSI use, the MLM risks creating disincentives for global scientific cooperation, slowing the pace of innovation”.

The IFPMA also stated that it is “critical” that indicative contribution rates (0.1 percent of revenue or 1 percent of profit) be “reconsidered”.

“Establishing indicative contribution rates in Decision 16/2 was premature and the rates themselves are commercially unrealistic, are not based on the underlying value that DSI brings, lack scientific justification, do not take into account sector-specific differences, and serve as a disincentive to participation,” it wrote. 

The IFPMA’s view that setting indicative rates was “premature” is echoed in the submission from the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC). 

The ICC was approached for comment. In its consultation submission, it states that the ICC is seeking “clarity, certainty and enabling conditions that are essential to incentivise businesses to actively engage”.

“Not Voluntary Enough”

The IFPMA goes on to suggest that the size of any contribution should be left to companies’ discretion, writing that “the expectation of contribution as well as the level of contribution must both be voluntary”.

While IFPMA recognises that payments into the Fund are already “voluntary in principle”, it argues that the wording of the treaty decision does “not go far enough in creating a truly voluntary mechanism” – taking issue with a clause that invites signatories to the CBD treaty to enact laws that incentivise company contributions.

The IFPMA goes on to add: “Given that the indicative rates were chosen without any rational analysis – as acknowledged by the decision itself, which calls for a study to propose replacement realistic rates – it is critical that these placeholder rates are truly indicative.”

In 2026, the UN’s CBD secretariat produced a study, in which it modelled the impact of contribution rates on the competitiveness of eligible companies, and found “the direct cost burden […] to be modest, relative to sector margins”. The IFPMA disputed these findings too, stating that “even modest reductions in expected returns can be enough to delay, scale back or halt a project”.

“Obligation Stacking”

The CBD negotiating text (Decision 16/2), which established the Fund, stated that the treaty would not override national “benefit-sharing” laws that already exist in at least 20 countries – which require companies to pay, or otherwise compensate, communities for their use of digital genetic data.

The IFPMA and BIA trade groups both expressed their concern at what they call “obligation stacking”, in consultation documents analysed by DeSmog. The IFPMA said that any payment into the Cali Fund should rule out paying governments for DSI again under any national laws, and both ask for “legal certainty”.

In response to a request for comment, Guilherme Cintra, IFPMA’s director of innovation policy, said: “The current mechanism overlaps with existing law, relies on inaccurate assumptions about how data is used in the discovery of medicines, and asks companies to hand over a share of their total revenue whether ‘digital sequence information’ was used to develop a medicine or not.”

‘Artful Arguments’

Dr Siva Thambisetty, associate professor of law at the London School of Economics (LSE), describes industry’s core arguments as “artful”.

She explains that the Fund decision to base contributions on revenue or profit, was an attempt aimed at securing “oversight and transparency” in the absence of comparable publicly available data from companies on how they use DSI.

“I think it’s interesting that the very companies that wanted a voluntary mechanism are now claiming that there is no legal certainty,” says Thambisetty. “We have to be careful that national ABS [access and benefit-sharing] laws are not damaged for a system that not many users appear to have any intention of paying into”.

She suggests that industry objections raised touch the fund’s viability and the terms already agreed, rather than how it should be rolled out. “It’s the operational clarity that the negotiations in Armenia should ideally focus on, rather than reopening the basis for the normative clarity, and multilateral will – which is clearly set out in CBD decisions,” she said.  

A paper released on the eve of the summit by the Common Initiative think tank acknowledges that the fund is empty due to structural problems, not just to low company ambition. 

It highlights a lack of consensus on how to define DSI, no clear mechanism for counting contributions, and a lack of harmonization between national governments’ implementation.

But these structural problems are not “bad luck,” they write. Rather, “it is what happens when a mechanism designed to extract money from some of the most profitable industries on earth is built on the assumption that those industries will simply volunteer to pay it.”

Indigenous Agency

Finalising the Cali Fund will be top of the agenda at the upcoming Cop17 talks in the Armenian capital Yerevan, which will run from 19-30 October. 

Parties are expected to pin down the details on disbursement of the fund between Global South countries, thresholds for company participation and fund governance, as well as measuring countries’ progress against targets to protect 30 percent of land and seas and restore the earth’s degraded ecosystems.

For June Rubis, an Indigenous representative who sits on the Cali Fund Steering Committee, the question of where money ends up has great importance. “I would like to see Indigenous communities be given meaningful agency over priorities, access and delivery,” she tells DeSmog.

The final Cali Fund text agreed at COP16 stated that half of any funds raised would go to Indigenous and local community stewards for self-defined projects that support biodiversity protection like forest restoration, or the transfer of ecological knowledge between generations.

Indigenous communities manage, or have rights over, around 37 percent of the earth’s natural areas, despite making up just 6 percent of the global population.

“What I want to avoid is a situation in which money is nominally allocated for Indigenous Peoples and local communities, but the project priorities are determined elsewhere or communities have to pass through an institution they did not identify,” says Rubis.

Rubis believes it’s important to take the time to build a financial mechanism that works for company contributors, countries, and Indigenous peoples and local communities alike. “Of course,” she adds, “for all this to apply, we also need to have the money coming in.”

More Action From States

Although businesses are expected to pay into the Cali Fund, national governments have the power to negotiate, agree and enforce decisions reached through the CBD process – and bear the responsibility to ensure funds are raised. 

To date, governments have played a mixed role. Some Global North countries, including the EU bloc and UK, appear to have lobbied alongside industry to push for the Cali Fund to be non-binding and voluntary.

However since then, through the Friends of the Cali Fund – which is chaired by the UK and Chile and includes Norway and Armenia – both the UK and the EU are now working to incentivise contributions.

Other countries such as Switzerland, where pharmaceutical companies make up 7 percent of GDP, as well as Japan and Korea, have continued to push back on key elements of the fund architecture.   

“I have been surprised to see industry arguments amplified by some Global North governments,” says Nithin Ramakrishnan from the nonprofit Third World Network,

“Including on areas – such as the relationship with national laws – that appear to go against the text that was agreed in Cali.”

For her part, Thambisetty tells DeSmog she would like to see “more coordinated action” on the part of countries where most of these large firms are situated. 

Thambisetty suggests a global push is needed to frame contributions as a moral responsibility for companies and investors: “a good public narrative about why these payments are necessary”. 

Learning By Doing

So far, the Cali Fund has raised no money from large firms. The only companies to contribute are Prozomix, a small UK-based biotech company that paid in July this year, and UK technology start-up TierraViva AI which contributed in November 2025.

The smaller outfits are encouraging others to follow suit. The first, TierraViva AI, which deposited $1,000, called on companies to embrace “learning by doing”, in an open letter penned last November. 

A second company, the biotech firm Prozomix, which handed over $5,000 in July, states on its website: “We feel companies of our size, and at any and all stages of development, should pay for the privilege of exploiting public DSI”.

Business for Nature, an alliance of more than 100 progressive businesses, has encouraged contributions from its members, pointing out they depend on healthy ecosystems to maintain their business model. It writes in an August briefing that “companies do not need to wait for the final rules to engage”.

It’s a sentiment echoed by the CBD executive secretary Schomaker, who called on companies to commit, ahead of this week’s summit. 

“Maybe if you think it’s too new for you, make a gesture and start paying, and increase over time,” she told environmental news site Mongabay.

“It’s frankly not good enough for a company to say, ‘We have many questions,’ and just sit there and wait.”

With editing by Emma Howard

The post How Big Pharma Tried to Weaken the Rules of the UN’s Nature Fund appeared first on DeSmog.

Categories: G1. Progressive Green

PART 3 TRAINING NOV 10 AT 6PM ET: People’s Assemblies and The Revolutionary Potential of Grassroots Power

Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund - Sun, 10/18/2026 - 22:17

Back by request! CELDF is hosting Part 3 of People's Assemblies & The Revolutionary Potential of Grassroots Power on Nov 10 at 6:00 PM ET. Registration required.

The post PART 3 TRAINING NOV 10 AT 6PM ET: People’s Assemblies and The Revolutionary Potential of Grassroots Power appeared first on CELDF - Community Rights Pioneers - Protecting Nature and Communities.

Categories: G1. Progressive Green

IPCC-65 suspended without agreement on key decisions, DCJ calls for urgency and equity in climate science

Demand Climate Justice - Fri, 10/16/2026 - 22:36

Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 17 October 2026- The 65th session of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has been suspended without agreement on the timeline for its Seventh Assessment Report (AR7) or the budget for 2027.

At the heart of the disagreement is when the IPCC’s next major climate assessment should be completed. Many developed countries, Small Island Developing States (SIDS) and some Least Developed Countries(LDCs) want the AR7 working Group reports completed by 2028, in time for the next Global Stocktake of the Paris Agreement. Many other developing countries have emphasised the need for a timeline that allows meaningful participation and rigorous scientific review. Discussions on the budget are also linked to decisions on the timeline.

Demand Climate Justice (DCJ) emphasised the importance of both timely scientific assessments and an inclusive, transparent and member-driven process for reaching decisions.

‘Scientific urgency and equity must go hand in hand. Meaningful inclusion is not simply about funding an additional delegate to attend IPCC meetings. Developing countries must also have sufficient time and resources to engage with scientific literature, review the assessments and contribute meaningfully to the process. Without this, the inequalities in participation that already exist risk being perpetuated,” said Meena Raman, Deputy Director, Third World Network.

DCJ also reiterated its call for a rapid and equitable phase-out of fossil fuels, emphasising that urgent climate action cannot wait for the next IPCC assessment. 

“The urgency of climate action has not changed. We need climate science that is both timely and inclusive, and a process that gives developing countries a meaningful voice. The science is already clear on the need for rapid emissions reduction. Equity and historical responsibility require developed countries to do their fair share of global mitigation efforts by moving first and fastest in cutting emissions, while providing finance, technology and capacity-building support to developing countries,” said Rachitaa Gupta, Global Coordinator, Demand Climate Justice.

Media enquiries and updates

For media enquiries, interview requests or further information, contact the Global Campaign to Demand Climate Justice (DCJ) at dcj.comms@demandclimatejustice.org.

For the latest statements, analysis and updates on climate justice and COP31, visit demandclimatejustice.org or follow DCJ on X, Instagram, LinkedIn and Facebook.

The post IPCC-65 suspended without agreement on key decisions, DCJ calls for urgency and equity in climate science appeared first on Global Campaign to Demand Climate Justice.

Categories: G1. Progressive Green

Pages

The Fine Print I:

Disclaimer: The views expressed on this site are not the official position of the IWW (or even the IWW’s EUC) unless otherwise indicated and do not necessarily represent the views of anyone but the author’s, nor should it be assumed that any of these authors automatically support the IWW or endorse any of its positions.

Further: the inclusion of a link on our site (other than the link to the main IWW site) does not imply endorsement by or an alliance with the IWW. These sites have been chosen by our members due to their perceived relevance to the IWW EUC and are included here for informational purposes only. If you have any suggestions or comments on any of the links included (or not included) above, please contact us.

The Fine Print II:

Fair Use Notice: The material on this site is provided for educational and informational purposes. It may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. It is being made available in an effort to advance the understanding of scientific, environmental, economic, social justice and human rights issues etc.

It is believed that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have an interest in using the included information for research and educational purposes. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. The information on this site does not constitute legal or technical advice.