You are here
News Feeds
After the blue tsunami
The voters of the United States have spoken. They have delivered Donald Trump and the Republican Party one of the worst electoral defeats in modern U.S. history, one that rivals the defeat of the GOP after Nixon’s impeachment. To capture its enormity, pundits have grasped for ever more dramatic metaphors from wipeout to earthquake, tsunami, and deluge.
The damage done to Trump, MAGA, and the Republican Party is hard to exaggerate. None other than outgoing Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis described it as “an extinction level event…. To call it a wave, I don’t think would be fully accurate. It’s the political equivalent of a meteor strike that went all around the United States, blue states, red states, everything in between.” He predicted it might take a decade for his party to recover.
As the results continue to pour in, the Democrats have swept Congress, winning as many as 260 seats in the House and potentially 56 in the Senate. And they now hold the majority of governors’offices throughout the country. All the Republican gains from 2024 have been erased.
The mass, cross-class resistance is responsible for this defeat ofTrump and the Republican Party. For the last two years, millions of people have protested, defended their communities, and fought for basic democratic rights in the face of the administration’s massive, violent, and sometimes murderous repression. This resistance and the broader radicalization against Trump turned people out in record numbers to kick out his cronies and replace them with Democrats.
On the one hand, this massive vote reflects enormous anger and disgust with Trump, his billionaire backers, and the capitalist system that has impoverished workers and brutalized our communities. That rage opens new horizons for building class and social struggle.
On the other hand, the turn back towards the Democratic Party and the Left’s predominant electoral strategy inside of it risks derailing the movement. We’ve all seen the devastating consequences of this strategy many times before; outraged by Republicans, insurgents voted for the Democrats, but then sat back waiting for change, only to have their hopes betrayed, opening the door for the Republicans to pose as the only alternative and return to power.
To break this cycle, the Left, unions, and social movements must abandon this strategy and, instead, carry out a two-front battle. First, we must continue to defend ourselves against the Trump administration, which remains a clear and present danger. It appears to be doubling down on a program of racist, reactionary nationalism, as reflected in the promotion of white supremacist Stephen Miller as his new chief of staff.
Second, we must force the Democrats both to enact immediate reforms, like the restoration of Medicaid funding, and to fight for much more radical ones like Medicare for All and the abolition of ICE. In the process of this independent struggle, we must set our sights on building a new party of our own, a workers’ party.
Rage against the Trump machineThe meteor that hit the Republican Party in the midterms was none other than Donald Trump. He told voters to pretend he was on the ballot. And they did, voting against him in every corner of the country from north to south and east to west. As one voter said, “I would crawl on my belly over broken glass to vote against that awful man.”
Usually, the midterm electorate is older, wealthier, and whiter. This year, it was more multiracial, more working class, and younger. And these voters came out against Trump in unprecedented numbers and opposed him on every major issue.
Remember, Trump had promised to end the forever wars, bring down the cost of living, and stop mass migration. He instead launched the deeply unpopular war on Iran, which, in combination with tariffs, spiked prices on everything from groceries to gas.
On the issue of immigration, he transformed what had been a source of popularity into a liability. People were repulsed by his deployments of ICE, construction of concentration camps, and mass deportation, especially after his goons murdered Alex Pretti and Renée Good in Minneapolis.
Every single demographic swung against Trump and the Republicans, in particular Latinos and young men. The electorate voted against ICE, the Iran War, the tech oligarchs’ AI data centers, class and social inequality, corruption, and greed. And they sent a clear message: they want reforms that address and improve their lives.
This blue wave was not just in traditional Democratic Party strongholds, but in the heartlands of the so-called red states. The Democrats took Lindsey Graham’s seat in South Carolina, swept Texas, won a Senate seat in Kansas for the first time in 94 years, and, at the time of writing, were poised to win Senate seats in Mississippi and Alaska. The Republicans’ iron grip on the red states, including the old Confederacy, has cracked.
And, in the face of psychotic redbaiting and racism, a slew of candidates in the Democratic Socialists of America won local, state, and congressional elections. This is a sign of the radicalization to the Left, especially among young people. In a stunning development, one-third of young voters nationally considered themselves socialists, more than three times the number that identified as MAGA.
Even in DeSantis Land, aka Florida, DSA member Angie Nixon—with no support from the DNC—came within three percentage points of winning a Senate seat. Some pundits contend that if she had been a moderate, she would have won. But that misses the point that in a deep red state, a Black woman and member of DSA came close to victory.
Trump’s failure to derail democracyThe people defied Trump’s attempt to subvert democracy. After the Supreme Court’s gutting of the Voting Rights Act, Black voters turned out in mass numbers, asserting their rights and voting against Republicans everywhere.
Trump’s campaign to rig the election by getting state Republicans to gerrymander Congressional districts blew up in his face. With results still coming in, his GOP candidates lost in at least ten of the fifteen districts. Meanwhile, Democrats picked up five redistricted seats in California and one in Utah.
And the courts ruled against Trump’s more extreme plans to interfere with the vote. They blocked his attempt to seize voter rolls and rejected his attempt to prevent the certification of the Senate election in Alaska.
His attempt to buy the election, by promising to pay each voter $5,000 if the Republicans held on to the House and Senate, also backfired. So did Musk’s obscene spending spree. He wasted nearly half a billion dollars in a fruitless effort to boost GOP candidates.
On election day, Trump refrained from following through on his threat to deploy ICE at the polls. In the face of his racist authoritarianism, Latinos turned out in record numbers to protest the Republicans’ escalation of the war on immigrants.
In the end, the blue tsunami was so enormous that, in contrast to 2020, Trump could not question the results, let alone organize a mob against them. Demoralized and resentful in his White House bunker, he initially vacillated between promising to work with the Democrats and threatening to veto everything and rule through executive decree.
Shattering the MAGA coalitionTrump’s MAGA electoral coalition now lies in tatters. Only two years ago, armed with an authoritarian nationalist program, he had united the tech oligarchs, small businesspeople, and sections of the demoralized working class to win back the White House.
While Trump delivered tax cuts and deregulation for the rich, his administration screwed everyone else. Its wars and tariffs drove up prices for small business owners and cut into the living standards of workers. And Trump’s bigotry and scapegoating drove sections of oppressed people, particularly those Latinos who had, out of despair, fallen for his spell, back to the Democrats.
No amount of scapegoating of immigrants, trans people, Muslims, and socialists could cover up his corrupt enrichment of his own family or his naked service to a narrow section of the capitalist class. Bigotry simply does not compensate for spiking prices that threaten people’s ability to pay their bills and buy health insurance.
His policies demoralized even his hard-core supporters like some of the so-called Front Row Joes who stopped turning out to his election rallies. His increasingly bizarre speeches, combining comments about candidates’ asses, various vanity construction projects, and stale laugh lines from the past, evoked declining enthusiasm from even the most faithful.
And his candidate selection was a disaster. He confused politics with a mobster’s patronage system, backing people loyal to him but with no hope of winning, like the comically corrupt Ken Paxton in Texas and Darline Graham, the unqualified sister of the late Lindsey Graham in South Carolina. They, among many others, were so bad that one of his campaign organizers mocked them, saying, “I have seen the enemy and it is us.”
Republican voters either did not turn out or broke from Trump to vote Democrat. The bulk of the capitalist class had already begun to turn against him, diverting their donations back to the Democrats. And, after the election, the stock market surged in the biggest single-day gain in over a year and the largest post-election increase in 44 years in hopes for the restoration of capitalist and imperialist stability.
The next day, however, they woke up, realizing the Democrats’ threat of regulation of AI data centers would undercut the sole source of growth in the U.S. economy, and panicked, reversing all the gains of the previous day. Now all the oligarchs are plotting new strategies to seduce the Democrats’ establishment and neutralize its Left.
As a result of the crack-up of Trump’s cross-class coalition, the Republican Party faces an existential crisis. Trump had transformed it from the main party of big business into a party of the far right, and then his policies and perceived betrayals tore it apart, dooming it to a truly historic defeat.
Already the wolves are circling around their pack leader. JD Vance blamed the Iran War— which he claims to have opposed—for the Republican defeat. DeSantis is sharpening his executioner’s ax. And many are now fleeing the sinking ship. For instance, the current House Speaker, Mike Johnson, has promised to step down from leadership and will not be the party’s minority leader, while he presumably waits for the rapture to rescue him from the Democrat’s coming inquisition.
The Democrats’ victory and its contradictionsThe beneficiary of Trump’s crisis is the Democratic Party. Its candidates won their races across the country, with very few exceptions. Most of the victors, particularly in the red states, are pro-capitalist centrists, many of whom hold reactionary positions on key issues like abortion, trans rights, and immigration.
They denounced Trump’s extremes while promising to address the affordability crisis. Neither they nor their establishment backers, however, lifted a finger to oppose the wave of anti-trans referendums across the nation. Even worse, Josh Turek, the centrist victor in the Iowa Senate race, came out against transgender athletes participating in youth sports.
A minority of the victors are pro-capitalist progressives. The most significant of these is Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan. After the Democratic Party establishment, along with AIPAC, tried to block his victory in the primary, he secured the nomination, overcame Mike Rogers’ Islamophobic campaign of hate and bigotry, withstood the defection of his primary opponent, Haley Stevens, and won the election to become the first Muslim to secure a Senate seat.
Democratic Socialists also scored victories across the country. These were mainly in traditional Democratic Party heartlands like New York City. Nonetheless, many of the candidates aligned with DSA were new “members” whose affiliation to the socialist movement may have more to do with a perceived path to electoral success than any principled commitment to Marxism. Indeed, many, like Angie Nixon in Florida, distanced themselves from socialism, and others like the newly elected LA Mayor Nithya Raman, who was backed by a hedge fund manager, declared herself pro-capitalist.
These progressives and Democratic Socialists, as establishment analysts have pointed out, underperformed compared to the centrists. They won by narrower margins and in some cases lost. In Vermont, for instance, voters split their ticket. They voted for establishment Democrats, who swept the state, and for the incumbent Eisenhower Republican, Phil Scott, who attacked progressive Amanda Janoo’s campaign platform as “unrealistic.”
[P]rogressives and socialists who did win will be a minority in a party dominated by the capitalist establishment. All of this means that the Democrats’ massive victory in the midterms will largely prevent progressives from advancing their agenda.Significantly, progressives and socialists who did win will be a minority in a party dominated by the capitalist establishment. All of this means that the Democrats’ massive victory in the midterms will largely prevent progressives from advancing their agenda. The establishment doesn’t have to rely on them as a voting bloc to rule and pass legislation. So, the progressives will not be able to use normal parliamentary means to pressure the party into advancing reforms like Medicare for All.
By contrast, the enormous centrist bloc will likely ensure the reelection of the establishment’s Congressional leadership. It will take not only petitions, but also mass protests to prevent Hakeem Jeffries from becoming House Speaker and Chuck Schumer Senate Majority Leader. Both are corporate and AIPAC bagmen.
Mistakenly, left-wing stalwarts like Mamdani, AOC, and El-Sayed have pledged support to Jeffries, preemptively undercutting the possibility of dethroning him. This is a dead-end tactic of parliamentary horse-trading with the establishment in the vain hope of winning their support for a more progressive platform.
It will not work. The establishment’s program will at best promise to restore the wretched status quo ante with some mild reforms that pale in comparison to what’s desperately needed. For instance, on immigration, they will not legalize all migrants nor grant them equal rights, but will conduct a “kinder, gentler” border enforcement and enact “saner” immigration policy that under Obama and Biden, led to as many, if not more, deportations than under Trump.
And the establishment will certainly not abolish ICE; they are just as likely to increase funding, as they already have done, to pay for so-called reforms like training and body cameras. We can expect the same centrist nonsense from them on gender, reproductive, and trans rights as well as policing. Even supposedly socialist stalwarts like AOC have dismissed radical demands for equality with quips like “woke 1.0 was crazyyyyy.”
By contrast, what capital demands of the establishment, they will deliver. And that is to restore order in the state bureaucracy, rebuild its damaged sections, especially its military brass, push for an end to the Iran War, reverse Trump’s idiotic protectionism, and repair the damage done to U.S. imperialism’s network of allies.
No doubt, they will demand a pound of flesh from the Trump regime; they will investigate all the corruption, including Elon Musk’s dubiously constitutional DOGE operations, and they will likely impeach the incompetent, testosterone-addled “War” Secretary Pete Hegseth, among other underlings.
Incoming Democratic Party House oversight chair Robert Garcia has already warned the Trump cabinet to “lawyer up.” But Jeffries and Schumer have announced that they will not focus on investigations, impeachment, and convictions. Instead, they have promised to address the affordability crisis.
Even assuming they had the political will to reign in the rapacious billionaire donor class and reshape this new gilded age of capitalism – which they do not – their ability to do so is constrained by their lack of a veto-proof majority. So, barring mass pressure from below, they can only win what Trump will agree to and sign into law. And he will likely veto almost everything they propose.
The battle for 2028That reality will set up the battle for the 2028 presidential election, which has already begun. The Democrats smell blood in the Republican waters. All the party’s factions will prepare their candidates to fight for the nomination with confidence that the victor will win the presidency.
The battle will be between the capitalist establishment and the progressive wing as it has been for the last several cycles. The establishment, party bureaucracy, and their ruling-class donors will cohere around a centrist with a restorationist program and some mildly liberal planks that address the affordability crisis. Already, progressives and the DSA are rallying to push AOC to follow Bernie Sanders’ example and run for the nomination.
Even if the DSA’s electoral strategy inside the Democratic Party increases the number of elected politicians, they will remain stuck in a quadruple trap. They remain within a hostile capitalist party, disciplined by a capitalist state mired in a growing fiscal crisis, and a global capitalist system already in a slump and headed for a recession when the AI boom ends, and the stock bubble pops. All of this leaves them, and the voters they lead, no closer to breaking and forming a party of their own.
[D]espite waves of class and social struggle over the last two decades, the balance of class forces still favors the ruling class. Socialist sentiment is not yet organized as a force at work sites and in the community, where our real power lies. As a result, we have not managed to build sustained, insurgent movements with the power to scare the ruling class enough to force them to deliver reforms.
Moreover, despite waves of class and social struggle over the last two decades, the balance of class forces still favors the ruling class. Socialist sentiment is not yet organized as a force at work sites and in the community, where our real power lies.
As a result, we have not managed to build sustained, insurgent movements with the power to scare the ruling class enough to force them to deliver reforms. The capitalist state, and the power of the global system have contained and neutralized all progressives elected on the Democratic Party ballot line to executive office, from Seattle’s Katie Wilson to Chicago’s Brandon Johnson, and Zohran Mamdani, and it will do the same to Nithya Rahman in LA.
As a result, the Democratic establishment will probably have an easier path to secure the nomination of one of their anointed centrists against AOC or some other insurgent this time than they had against Sanders, whom they struggled against the first time but trounced in the second contest.
Lame duck, angry duck, or tyrannical fowl?One unpredictable variable over the next two years is Trump himself. Will he go silently into the dark night or rage, rage against the dying of his light? He is a discredited lame duck facing his own mortality. His authoritarian personality disorder, however, could turn him into, in Chris Christie’s words, an “angry duck.”
But it is hard to see what he can do now. He faces a population that despises him, his regime, and all of his policies. The Democratic-controlled Congress will both bog him down in investigation and demand that he enact modest reforms.
His party is in shambles. More cabinet members will look to flee the sinking ship, and perhaps, as one of his pollsters joked, find “asylum in Israel.” Others eager to salvage their lucrative careers will turn on their master, charting a new course to try and rebuild the GOP.
Nevertheless, this angry duck could buck the constitutional order, something he did with his failed coup on January 6, 2021, but not since. This gives the lie to the liberal panic, and lazy leftist hyperbole, that Trump is a fascist. He’s not; he’s an authoritarian nationalist fighting in our degenerating electoral system of competitive authoritarianism.
He could nevertheless morph into a fascist. But, given the widespread demoralization of even his most loyal base and the decomposition of the various far-right militias, he lacks the forces to break the constitutional order.
With Trump, however, nothing can be ruled out. His decision to replace Susie Wiles with Stephen Miller as his Chief of Staff is an ominous signal that, whatever wobbles in the dark of election night, he might be planning to re-galvanize his MAGA base behind an escalated war on immigrants and intensification of Trump’s Donroe Doctrine in Latin America and the Caribbean.
As the New York Times reports, Miller is the most authoritarian and racist figure in the regime. He advocated the “separation of migrant families at the border; the 2017 Muslim travel ban; directing the government to stifle critics of Mr. Trump; the ending of nearly all U.S. refugee programs; the widespread pressure campaign against U.S.universities; extrajudicial boat strikes that have killed hundreds; and purges of officials deemed insufficiently loyal to Mr. Trump.”
But, the Times continue, “Miller’s most wide-reaching influence can be seen in Mr. Trump’s mass deportation campaign, which Mr. Miller has overseen. Mr. Miller helped set in motion militarized operations on the streets of American cities, pitting masked, heavily armed immigration agents against residents of cities like Minneapolis and Chicago.”
Miller is also one of the fiercest advocates of U.S dominance in the Western Hemisphere. When Trump was threatening the annexation of Greenland, he infamously told CNN’s Jake Tapper, “We live in a world in which you can talk all you want about international niceties and everything else. But we live in a world, in the real world, Jake, that is governed by strength, that is governed by force, that is governed by power. These are the iron laws of the world since the beginning of time.”
With this racist thug at the helm, Trump could morph from an angry duck into a tyrannical fowl. Whether he can carry out Miller’s sociopathic America First program in his dramatically weakened position remains to be seen. The resistance cannot wait to find out. We must stand ready to organize mass protests and mass direct action to stop him in his tracks.
The global tsunamiRegardless of what Trump does, his defeat will have enormous international repercussions. It is the latest setback the right has suffered from the defeat of Hungary’s Viktor Orbán to Serbia’s Aleksandar Vučić and Brazil’s Flávio Bolsonaro.
This string of losses fits the pattern of mass popular opposition to any party in power. This has created sharp whiplashes as voters alternately toss out the capitalist establishment, reformists, and the far right.
None have been able to address global capitalism’s multiple crises that have wrecked the lives of the vast majority. So, people have swung from various false and failing alternatives, desperately seeking a solution that’s not on offer.
Nonetheless, Trump’s defeat should inspire everyone around the world to rise up against the authoritarian nationalist right. It will boost the confidence of people to organize and defeat the AFD in Germany, Marine Le Pen in France, Narendra Modi in India, and Vladimir Putin in Russia, to name just a few.
The wipeout of the Republicans will also further weaken the hand of U.S. imperialism against its rivals. Until 2028, there will be no new helmsperson on the empire’s tiller. This will have contradictory effects.
On the positive side, it may impede Trump from carrying out the worst of imperialist plots. Despite his and Miller’s demonic fantasies, the administration will face more constraints on further gunboat diplomacy in Latin America, including against Cuba.
It is likely that Trump will also be forced to cut some kind of deal to end the Iran War, open up the Strait of Hormuz, restore shipments of fossil fuels and petrochemicals, and relieve those economies that the war has wrecked. Such a deal will be a setback for Israel’s Benjamin Netanyahu and his decades-long ambitions to escalate the ongoing genocide in Palestine into yet more regional war.
The zionists are thus panicking. As one Israeli journalist close to Netanyahu wailed, “What happened in America last night is a catastrophe. Take AIPAC’s worst nightmares, double them, and you still don’t get close.”
Furthermore, Trump’s defeat should help undermine the transactional pact of Ukrainian blood for Russian oil that his administration has struck with Putin. Ukraine will more readily be able to secure weapons from Washington, D.C. to defend itself from Russian imperialism and its state terrorism against civilians and civilian infrastructure.
Lastly, Trump’s plan for a summit with Xi Jinping and Putin at the upcoming APEC summit, where the three powers would divide up today’s world into imperial spheres of influence like Roosevelt, Churchill, and Stalin did at Yalta after World War Two, is likely off the table. Xi and Putin will now regard the administration as a weak, caretaker regime and start planning for how to deal with the Democrats in 2029.
On the negative side, the U.S. ruling class will be determined to restore its imperial position in the wake of a second Trump administration that has further exacerbated its relative decline against its rivals in global capitalism. They will turn to the Democrats to carry out that project, especially against China, their main economic and geopolitical rival.
Without struggle there is no progressAmidst all these contradictions, the most positive impact of Trump’s defeat is the mass popular sense of victory against a regime that had inflicted class war and vicious scapegoating on the majority of the country’s population. Our collective expectation of change has been raised.
But, and this is no surprise to most people, the Democratic Party is not a vehicle for the working class and the oppressed either to stop Trump or to advance our demands for reform. Therefore, the resistance must remain vigilant against Trump’s authoritarian threat and stand ready to stage mass, disruptive protests and strikes, including a general strike planned for May Day 2028, to protect our democratic rights and communities.
At the same time, we must organize and force the Democrats to enact immediate reforms. We should demand that they reverse the looming Medicaid cuts, restore funds for the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), and reinstate the 760,000 people kicked off Obamacare.
To win more thoroughgoing reforms, we will need to build independent mass class and social struggle from below. Without that, the Democrats will block substantial demands from Medicare for All to the Green New Deal, the abolition of ICE, and, yes, the defunding of the police.
Amidst this moment of raised expectation, the Left, social movements, and unions have an opportunity and responsibility to fight for such demands over opposition from the Democrats. Snide dismissals notwithstanding, Howard Zinn was right: “What matters most is not who is sitting in the White House, but ‘who is sitting in’—and who is marching outside the White House, pushing for change.”
Two years of resistance have brought Trump to his knees. The worst mistake we could make is to sit back and wait for the Democrats to deliver now or in two years.Two years of resistance have brought Trump to his knees. The worst mistake we could make is to sit back and wait for the Democrats to deliver now or in two years. That will only provide the decimated far right an opening to regroup, rebuild, and exploit disappointment in the Democrats to return to power in the future.
We have to break our epoch’s international pattern of whiplashing back and forth between the parties of the capitalist establishment and the far right. To do that, we need to build an organized and confident Left, with a growing and stronger revolutionary socialist wing, at the heart of a reenergized resistance. We should take lessons and confidence from what our siblings are doing in the wave of uprisings from France to India, Kenya, Albania, and beyond.
We have to adopt a new strategy of building independent class and social struggles, fighting for our demands rather than accepting the establishment’s inadequate reforms, and rebuilding the democratic structures of unions and movements. In that process, we can cohere a new militant minority and build a party of our own, a workers’party, that can challenge the Democrats and Republicans in a contest for state power.
With the Trump era appearing to come to an end, we can see the flickering light of a new day on the horizon. But to usher it into being, we cannot rest in the afterglow of the contradictory results of this midterm election nor wait with folded arms for the 2028 presidential election. Keep your marching shoes on, grab a picket sign, and commit to the long struggle for a society that puts people and planet first. A new world is possible, but we have to fight for it.
Opinions expressed in signed articles do not necessarily represent the views of the editors or the Tempest Collective. For more information, see “About Tempest Collective.”
Featured Image credit: Antonioaesparza, RRC1701, Office of Senator Jon Ossoff, Sikis2021, Stimpus1, Leoniceno, ArenLeBrun, Conlan Houston, The Trump White House; modified by Tempest.
The post After the blue tsunami appeared first on Tempest.
Landfill Methane at COP31: Why Zero Waste Is a Climate Action
For years, zero waste solutions have quietly formed the backbone of community-led climate resilience. Yet, they have historically been sidelined in global climate discussions and storytelling. COP31 changes that. Türkiye, the host country, has placed zero waste and circular economy planning at the very top of its priority themes. For the first time in the history of UN climate summits, a host presidency is elevating waste-derived emissions to a leading position on the climate action agenda and the international stage.
Methane from landfills is created when food scraps, garden waste and other organic materials rot without oxygen in dumps and landfills. It is a short-lived but extremely powerful climate pollutant, so cutting it is one of the fastest ways to slow warming this decade — and the quickest, cheapest way to do that is to keep organic waste out of landfills through food waste prevention, source separation and composting, not by burning it in incinerators.
The COP31 presidency has made “Zero Waste and Methane Reduction” one of its headline themes, treating waste as a climate issue rather than only a municipal service. That is good news — at COP31, the UN climate conference taking place in Antalya, Türkiye, from 9 to 20 November 2026, our message is clear: zero waste is a proven climate action when it tackles waste at source and is rooted in justice — and the climate finance that follows must go to proven zero waste solutions, not to so-called “waste-to-energy” incinerators.
What is landfill methane?When organic waste is buried in a landfill or piled in an open dump, it breaks down without oxygen. That process, called anaerobic decomposition, releases methane — a greenhouse gas that traps far more heat than carbon dioxide in the short term. The more food and garden waste a city sends to disposal, the more methane its landfills produce.
The science is clear. Organic waste is the largest part of the problem. In Asia, organic matter — mainly discarded food and agricultural material — makes up 50% to 70% of municipal solid waste, as delegates highlighted at GAIA Asia Pacific’s Second Regional Congress on Organics and Climate. Citing studies that attribute around 30% of current global warming to methane, the COP31 presidency has argued that waste prevention and better management of organic waste can deliver rapid climate benefits.
Landfill methane is also a public safety issue. The same rotting waste that generates methane fuels landfill fires and collapses. In recent months, a series of landfill fires and landslides across Asia blanketed cities in toxic fumes and claimed residents’ lives, many of them waste pickers.
“When communities prevent food waste and sort organics at the source, we win twice: we cut methane emissions at the source and eliminate the toxic landfill fires choking our neighborhoods.” — Froilan Grate, Regional Coordinator, GAIA Asia Pacific
Why incineration is not a solutionProven solutions exist, and scaling them in the next five years is crucial. Incinerator companies often pitch “waste-to-energy” as a way to avoid landfill methane. But burning organic waste simply swaps one climate pollutant for another: the carbon in food scraps and paper is released as CO2 right away, alongside the fossil carbon in burned plastics. Waste-to-energy is the most carbon-intensive way to manage waste and releases more greenhouse gases than any other type of energy facility — 1.7 times as much as coal-fired power plants.
GAIA’s new Burn Book analysis of twenty incinerators and incinerator proposals found that the eleven facilities with available data release a combined 5.5 million metric tons of CO2e every year — the equivalent of 1.3 million passenger cars. And because incinerators need a steady supply of waste to stay financially viable, they compete directly with the composting and food waste programs that stop methane at the source.
Burning wet organic waste also makes little sense. In Mauritius, communities stopped a proposed 300,000-tonne waste-to-energy plant by pointing out a simple mismatch: roughly 70% of the island’s waste is green and kitchen waste. It’s one of the inspiring victories against incinerators GAIA members shared during the Global Week of Action.
Follow the money: climate finance is going to the wrong solutionsThe biggest obstacle to cutting waste methane isn’t technology — it’s finance. Delegates at the Organics Congress highlighted a stark imbalance: nearly USD 4 billion has gone into capital-intensive waste incineration projects, capturing 94% of waste-sector methane finance, while barely 1% reaches organic waste management and food rescue systems.
The Jakarta Declaration, adopted at the Congress in September 2026, sets out a roadmap to fix that. It calls on national governments and financing institutions to halt funding for incinerators and redirect climate finance into low-cost, decentralized, and proven locally led organic waste systems and food loss and waste reduction.
Cities already cutting methane with zero wasteCommunity-led organic waste systems are not a pilot idea. They are working at scale today:
- Florianópolis, Brazil: the city’s Capital Lixo Zero program more than quadrupled food waste composting, from 1,175 tonnes in 2020 to 5,126 tonnes in 2024.
- Valparaíso, Chile: waste pickers from Chile’s national movement ANARCH began managing organic waste in September 2026, in a region where around 70% of municipal waste is organic.
- Pune, India: SWaCH’s 4,000 door-to-door waste pickers enforce source segregation across 1 million households and divert 25 tonnes of organic waste a day.
- Bandung, Indonesia: a Climate Policy Initiative analysis found decentralized community systems save the local government up to IDR 30 billion (about USD 1.7 million) a year in avoided transport and tipping fees.
- Barangay Potrero, Malabon City, Philippines: by integrating 80 waste workers into its system, this community of 43,000 residents diverts more than 100,000 kg of organic waste a year.
- Durban, South Africa: groundWork and eThekwini Municipality turned 586 tonnes of organic waste from three municipal markets into 190 tonnes of compost for city parks and community food gardens, avoiding an estimated 133 tonnes of methane. A cost-benefit analysis found market composting delivers a net benefit of R18 million (about USD 1.09 million) over ten years, while landfilling the same waste would cost R32 million.
- Dar es Salaam, Tanzania: Nipe Fagio’s community-based model collects waste from 4,500 households and diverts virtually 100% of their organic waste from disposal, avoiding about 16.4 tonnes of methane emissions a year.
- Accra, Ghana: the Green Africa Youth Organization (GAYO) has formally integrated more than 600 informal waste workers into a decentralized organic waste model that won the 2024 Earthshot Prize.
These results come from places with limited budgets. They show that the most cost-effective climate infrastructure is often people — waste workers, residents and local officials — backed by clear policy. Learn how Bandung, Durban and Valparaíso are financing inclusive organic waste systems, and meet the five Global South cities the UN recognized for zero waste. Explore more zero waste solutions and how GAIA members are building zero incineration cities.
What COP31 negotiators should do about waste methaneAs negotiations continue in Antalya, GAIA members are calling on:
- Policymakers to prioritize waste prevention, reuse, source separation, and organics management in climate policies and national climate plans (NDCs), with targets for composting and food waste prevention, while keeping incineration and other polluting technologies out of zero waste solutions.
- Financiers to direct accessible climate and methane finance towards proven, locally led zero waste systems that cut emissions, strengthen communities, and avoid polluting infrastructure, including decentralized organic waste systems, food rescue and direct support for municipalities, and to stop treating incineration as a methane solution.
- Governments and decision-makers to cut waste methane and black carbon at the source, reduce plastic production and fossil fuel dependence, back city-level commitments like the Cities Methane Pledge, and protect and formally integrate waste pickers and workers through a just transition.
Landfills produce methane when organic waste such as food scraps, garden waste and paper breaks down without oxygen. Keeping organics out of landfills through prevention, separation and composting stops that methane at the source.
Does composting reduce methane?Yes. Well-managed composting breaks organic waste down with oxygen, which largely avoids the methane that forms in landfills, and turns the waste into a soil amendment.
Is incineration better than landfill for the climate?No. Incineration releases the carbon in waste as CO2 immediately, and waste-to-energy emits more greenhouse gases than any other type of energy facility. The climate-friendly alternative to both is zero waste: preventing waste, composting organics and recycling.
When and where is COP31?COP31 takes place in Antalya, Türkiye, from 9 to 20 November 2026. The COP31 presidency has made zero waste and methane reduction one of its key themes.
What is the Jakarta Declaration?The Jakarta Declaration was adopted in September 2026 at GAIA Asia Pacific’s Second Regional Congress on Organics and Climate. It calls on governments and financiers to stop funding incinerators and redirect climate finance into decentralized organic waste management and food waste reduction.
Take action during COP31Zero waste is a climate action, but only when it tackles waste at source and is rooted in justice. Methane from waste is one of the most solvable parts of the climate crisis. Read the Jakarta Declaration, share this article with your local officials, learn more about GAIA’s engagement at COP31 and sign up for GAIA’s updates to follow our work at COP31 and beyond.
The post Landfill Methane at COP31: Why Zero Waste Is a Climate Action first appeared on GAIA.
Utilities should consider ‘taking a breather’ from rate cases: Minnesota PUC vice chair
“Filing rate cases right now is really painful,” Joseph Sullivan told Utility Dive in an interview where he also discussed his concerns with overly complex data center cost allocation and an erosion of public trust in institutions.
Can These 4 Tips Transform Climate Communication At COP31 And Beyond?
A version of this piece was featured in Food Tank’s newsletter, released weekly on Thursdays. To make sure it lands straight in your inbox and to be among the first to receive it, subscribe now by clicking here.
Greetings from Antalya, Türkiye!
I’m here for COP31, the United Nations’ annual climate conference, which kicks off today. And I’m doing something a little different this year.
In addition to moderating a panel with the Earth Day Network and other organizations and visiting the Republic of Bati Akdeniz Agricultural Research Institute, I’ll be spending more time in the audience. Listening. Learning. Asking questions. And hopefully hearing some new ideas about how we can finally move from promises to action.
Because, frankly, I’m getting a little tired of all the talk.
Don’t get me wrong. I’ve attended these conferences for years, and I know important progress happens here. I’ve met extraordinary farmers, scientists, advocates, policymakers, and young people who are working every day to make our food and climate systems more resilient.
But this is COP31. We’ve been having these conversations for more than three decades. And we’re still not acting nearly fast enough.
More than a decade after the Paris Agreement, we’re facing the very real prospect of exceeding the 1.5°C warming threshold that countries pledged to avoid. In September, the U.N. Environment Programme warned that temporarily crossing that threshold is now all but inevitable.
That’s devastating. And it should make all of us angry.
But it doesn’t mean we give up. It means we need to do things differently—and one place to start is by changing how we talk about climate change in the first place.
I think about this a lot in my work at Food Tank. We know that food and agriculture can be powerful climate solutions. Farmers are restoring soil, protecting biodiversity, reducing waste, and helping communities adapt to extreme weather.
Yet, according to the U.N. Food and Agriculture Organization, agrifood systems receive less than 8 percent of global climate finance.
How is that possible?
We have solutions. We have evidence. We have people doing remarkable work on the ground. But we’re still not investing in them at the scale we need.
And I wonder whether part of the problem is that we’re not telling these stories in ways that resonate with people.
That’s why I was particularly interested in a new report from Potential Energy Coalition, commissioned by The Rockefeller Foundation. Researchers analyzed more than 83,000 survey responses to better understand how we can communicate about climate change in ways that actually inspire people to act.
Four findings stood out to me.
First, don’t be afraid to talk about climate change. We’re often told to avoid those words altogether and talk instead about jobs or economic development. But the research suggests that being direct about the consequences of climate change can be much more effective. People deserve to know what’s at stake.
Second, talk about what we can gain, not just what we might lose. Nobody wants to hear only about sacrifice, restrictions, and everything they must give up. Let’s talk about cleaner air, healthier communities, affordable energy, and better food systems. Let’s give people something to work toward.
Third, make it personal. Climate change isn’t some distant problem for future generations. It’s already affecting what we eat, what we pay for groceries, our health, and the livelihoods of farmers and food workers. Those connections matter. And so do the stories of real people experiencing these changes.
And fourth, please, let’s stop using so much jargon! Terms like “net zero” and “green transition” might make sense to those of us who work in this space every day, but they don’t necessarily mean much to everyone else. We need language that’s clear, accessible, and, most importantly, connected to solutions people can understand.
None of this means watering down the science or pretending the climate crisis isn’t serious.
Quite the opposite: It means taking people seriously enough to communicate with them in ways that are honest, useful, and hopeful.
One of the things I’ve learned from spending time with farmers around the world is that they don’t always talk about climate change in the language we hear at international conferences. They talk about unpredictable rains, declining yields, the cost of inputs, or whether their children will want to keep farming.
And they’re often the people doing the most innovative work to adapt.
We need to listen to them.
The report also offers four approaches to telling more effective climate stories, and I hope communicators, advocates, and policymakers will take a look.
Because we can’t keep doing the same things and expecting different results.
I’m heading into COP31 with some frustration, yes. But also with hope. Recent elections have reminded us that people care deeply about their communities, their health, their food, and their futures. There’s an opportunity to connect those concerns to meaningful climate action.
And I’m looking forward to seeing what happens here in Antalya. This year at COP, I’ll be listening closely, meeting with people working on solutions, and looking for stories that deserve more attention. We’ll continue sharing reporting, analysis, and reflections at FoodTank.com, both during the conference and afterward.
Articles like the one you just read are made possible through the generosity of Food Tank members. Can we please count on you to be part of our growing movement? Become a member today by clicking here.
Photo courtesy of Conservation Commons, Unsplash
The post Can These 4 Tips Transform Climate Communication At COP31 And Beyond? appeared first on Food Tank.
“We are the union”: Ontario Amazon workers launch unionization fight
On November 4, 2026, Ontario Amazon workers publicly launched a campaign to unionize their workplace. The announcement was made in partnership with Unifor — Canada’s...
The post “We are the union”: Ontario Amazon workers launch unionization fight first appeared on Spring.
As U.N. Climate Negotiations Begin, Report Warns That Warming Is Gaining Pace
Heat is accumulating in Earth’s systems at an accelerating rate, the U.N.’s weather agency has reported as the COP31 climate change summit begins in Turkey, with 2026 on track to be one of the four warmest years on record.
The Cybertruck era is over, but America’s electric truck experiment isn’t
After barely three years on the road, Tesla is planning to kick the Cybertruck to the curb after flagging sales. Elon Musk announced on Friday that the company would wind down production next year to make room for the production of Cybercabs, the robot taxis Tesla hopes will reshape transportation.
In its short lifespan, the Cybertruck managed to become a top candidate for the most polarizing vehicle on the road — ever. Critics called it a “MAGA hat on wheels” and compared it to a dumpster — a resemblance that may have fooled some hungry raccoons that once chewed on the vehicle’s rear vault. It’s already being declared “one of the greatest flops in automotive history,” on par with Ford’s 1957 Edsel. But the polygonal, supposedly bulletproof truck did appeal to a certain demographic.
“It’s the kind of vehicle, as a kid, you imagine for the future,” said Dan Krassner, executive director of the American EV Jobs Alliance, an advocacy organization working to end the partisan divide over electric vehicles. He’s a Republican and a wrestling fan, and noted that some of his favorite pro wrestlers drove Cybertrucks, including the married WWE superstars Seth Rollins and Becky Lynch, along with The Miz and Liv Morgan (though the latter has said it was the “worst investment” she ever made).
Weeks before the Cybertruck rolled out in late 2023, Musk told investors that Tesla would sell 250,000 vehicles a year. But it never came close: Last year, it sold just over 20,000. It’s the latest sign that the attempt to make EVs macho is falling flat, after Ford announced last December that its F-150 Lightning pickup truck, the all-electric version of the country’s most popular vehicle, would be discontinued since it was a money-loser. Sales of Rivian’s electric pickup have been sliding downward each year since 2023; they have also dropped sharply for GMC’s Hummer EV, which was dubbed “the worst-selling pickup truck of 2026.”
Automakers have long tried to shed the saintly, environmentally friendly image of the Toyota Prius, and this shift to big, aggressive electric trucks was an effort to appeal to traditional American pickup buyers. But they not only had to contend with conservatives’ hesitations about EVs, they also had to persuade a public increasingly worried about the cost of living to overcome sticker shock, to fork over thousands, if not tens of thousands, more to buy an electric pickup instead of a gas-powered one. A comparable gas-powered Ford pickup starts at $52,000, about $11,000 less than the Lightning did before Ford discontinued it.
“The first electric trucks weren’t priced for the people who buy trucks, and buyers still have fair questions about charging and towing,” Krassner said. “You know, macho advertising can’t fix the monthly payment.”
The starting price for the 2026 Tesla Cybertruck was just raised to $92,500, and the cheapest Hummer EV is $97,200. Full-size electric pickup trucks need very large batteries to deliver the range and towing capabilities that truck buyers want, leading to higher prices, Krassner said.
But cheaper models are on the way. Ford’s upcoming electric pickup truck coming next year, the Fathom, will be priced starting at $28,400 — well below the price of the average gas-powered pickup. Meanwhile, now that the F-150 Lightning is out of production, with used models going for 50 percent off the sticker price, it’s “selling like hotcakes,” according to the transportation news site Electrek.
“As the electric trucks are more comparable in price to gas trucks, we expect them to be a superior product and be popular with Americans,” Krassner said.
Read Next The market for used EVs ‘is so hot’ right now Tik RootThere’s still a large partisan divide on electric vehicles: Roughly half of all new EV registrations in the U.S. from 2012 to 2023 went to the 10 percent most Democratic counties, according to a study from the MIT Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research. Because electric trucks performed better in Republican-leaning areas — though not as well as Tesla and Ford had hoped — the researchers suggested they could still be a way to broaden EV adoption. And some of Republicans’ resistance to electric vehicles has begun to ease, Krassner said. The share of Republicans who agree that EVs are “for people who see the world differently than I do” fell from 59 percent in November 2023 to 49 percent in November 2025, according to polling from EVs for All America.
As the Cybertruck’s production comes to a close, Alexander Edwards, president of the research consultancy Strategic Vision, was cautious about declaring the electric pickup experiment a failure. He sees the F-150 Lightning as a lesson in making sure that trucks can perform the jobs their owners bought them to do — including towing a camper across several states without worrying about range and charging access. The Cybertruck, on the other hand, appealed to a sense of individuality, innovation, excitement, but only a relatively small group of people were willing to pay for that experience at a high price point, especially as Tesla became a political target thanks to Musk’s involvement with DOGE.
“I think price, product frustrations, Musk’s politics, and the changing meaning of owning one all need to be part of the discussion,” Edwards said.
High gas prices sparked by the war in Iran, which have stuck around for months, are prompting people to purchase hybrids, though sales of electric vehicles have declined after the Trump administration’s elimination of federal tax credits last year. Krassner is also bullish on a new generation of range-extended electric trucks — EVs with a gas-powered generator — which could ease drivers’ range anxiety.
In other words, America’s experiment with electrified pickup trucks isn’t over yet. “I’d say round one went to the gas truck,” Krassner said. “Round two hasn’t started yet.”
This story was originally published by Grist with the headline The Cybertruck era is over, but America’s electric truck experiment isn’t on Nov 10, 2026.
COP31 outcome needs to prioritise transition away from fossil fuels
Stientje van Veldhoven is Minister of Climate and Green Growth for the Netherlands.
When we co-hosted the first-ever conference on transitioning away from fossil fuels (TAFF) this April, the world was reeling from the volatility in oil and gas prices due to the Hormuz blockade. Fossil fuels moved to the centre of the debate as country leaders scrambled to secure supplies for their people.
We saw the very opposite in Santa Marta. Nearly 60 nations came together with 2,600-plus participants from civil society and community organisations, businesses and scientists to discuss concrete solutions on how governments can shift away from fossil fuels. Together, we defined the ‘Santa Marta process’ to serve as an extra engine for the broader process of the UNFCCC.
The Santa Marta process will see expert groups and committed countries develop national roadmaps, chart pathways to overcome financial constraints, and drive economic transformation. We made a multi-year commitment to take this process forward. With Tuvalu and Ireland taking over as co-chairs for 2027, transitioning away from fossil fuels is now moving from words to action.
European nations signal support for fossil fuel roadmap, says COP30 president
Work gets underwayAt the opening of the Santa Marta conference, my co-chair Colombia’s then energy minister Irene Veléz Torres and I repeatedly stressed one thing: that the forum was not a space for negotiations, but a forum for countries and other partners to discuss practical steps to move away from fossil fuels.
Since then, we have seen three roadmaps already submitted: by France, Germany and our own. Pacific Island ministers also recently announced their intention to develop a regional roadmap to transition away from fossil fuels. And I called on the European Commission to do the same for the European Union.
On top of this, numerous countries are already working on parts of the transition, such as phasing out coal or ending fossil fuel subsidies. More countries are expected to follow soon.
Workstreams were launched in early August, followed by sign-ups from countries willing to take a larger role and lead on organising different activities. Each workstream has an assigned lead organisation (or madrina). Each has its own working structure.
Workstream 1 focuses on supporting countries in developing and implementing flexible, country-owned national roadmaps. It operates as an open, collaborative hub that coordinates partner institutions to provide tailored technical, financial and policy support directly aligned with each country’s specific needs and existing frameworks. The consortium, which functions as a hub, currently consists of the NDC Partnership, the Powering Past Coal Alliance, the World Resources Institute and the newly established Science Panel on the Global Energy Transition.
Workstream 2 focuses on mobilising collective coalition power to tackle national and international financial constraints, debt-related barriers and macroeconomic dependencies that hinder the transition away from fossil fuels. Starting with a scoping phase, it will deliver transparent, actionable recommendations and reform solutions to support countries’ structural fiscal needs at global fora. Its madrinas are the International Institute for Sustainable Development and Transforma, a Latin American think-and-do-tank.
Workstream 3 focuses on driving economic transformation by mapping green partnership potential, decarbonising trade balances and building competitive, mutually beneficial clean markets. It aims to help countries, especially producers, diversify their economies, scale domestic value creation, and unlock collective trade opportunities. The madrina is the Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development working together with the South Centre.
Incorporating Santa Marta into COPWhat was abundantly clear in Santa Marta is that our coalition’s efforts are a strong support to, rather than a replacement for, the COP process. Over the past decade or so, the focus at COPs was on setting goals. Now we must focus on implementation. The COP31 presidencies have previously indicated their willingness to incorporate elements of the Santa Marta process into COP31 outcomes. We look forward to seeing how we can achieve this together.
The Brazilian COP30 Presidency delivered its global roadmap on the transition away from fossil fuels – a voluntary toolkit for countries that want to move ahead – just before the COP started in Antalya on Monday. During the coming two weeks, it’s critical that we see more concrete, actionable roadmaps for the fossil fuel phase-out. These documents can be crucial for a strong second Global Stocktake of national climate plans in two years’ time.
Brazil’s fossil fuel roadmap sketches out first global timetable
At COP31, a variety of TAFF-related events will be hosted, focusing on next steps within the Santa Marta workstreams. We welcome any leader and expert from around the world to take part as they work to develop their roadmaps, identify the fossil fuel subsidies they need to phase out, or establish green/clean markets at home.
Only by reducing fossil fuel demand and replacing it with clean electricity to run our economies can we all become more economically resilient and sharply cut the pace of climate change.
The post COP31 outcome needs to prioritise transition away from fossil fuels appeared first on Climate Home News.
How Germany Can Fight the AfD
The far-right Alternative für Deutschland (AfD), a party with openly anti-democratic positions, has become the strongest force in nationwide polls, particularly in eastern Germany. Jana Hensel, author of Es war einmal ein Land (“Once There Was a Country”), argues that although the AfD’s rise fits a broader European trend, it can be truly understood and defeated only by grasping the experience of East Germans and responding to their grievances. To mount a successful challenge, pro-democratic parties cannot carry on with business as usual.
Konrad Bleyer-Simon: In the international press, East Germany is often portrayed as the problematic part of the country. Earlier, it was described as being stuck in the past; now, as driving the shift to the far right. What does East Germany mean to you?
Jana Hensel: I have been studying East Germany for over 20 years. I have published many books on the subject and, of course, the East is my home. I come from Leipzig and participated in the Monday demonstrations with my mother in 1989. For me, that remains one of the most significant experiences of my life. So, East Germany means a great deal to me. It is my social, personal and political home. I feel a strong connection to the people of East Germany and am, of course, very saddened by what has become of the East.
But you say that there is no such thing as an East German identity.
I no longer work with the concept of identity. The word does not appear in my new book, because identities are fluid and change depending on who you are dealing with. I am from Leipzig, but I am now also a Berliner. I am German and occasionally become an East German, but I can also adopt a West German perspective. So, the concept of identity cannot get us anywhere; instead, I am concerned with the question of experience. In the book, I attempt to recount a political history of East German society from 1990 to the present day and to answer the question of how it came about that significant sections of East German society – as I believe – have turned their backs on democracy.
When did it dawn on you that German reunification might not, after all, be an unambiguous success story?
That is a difficult question, because I have always tried to describe, from an East German perspective, the things that, in my view, did not go well. We have a wide economic and social divide, high levels of emigration, and a truly inadequate representation of East Germans in leadership positions. So, we have many problems. I have always tried to talk about them, in the hope that we would resolve these issues democratically. But now we find ourselves in a situation where many of these unresolved socio-political problems are translating into support for the AfD and leading not to the improvement of our shared democratic system, but to its destruction. I find this deeply tragic, because I can see that the AfD is seizing upon many of the issues raised by myself and others, and is using them to justify its destructive policies. When the AfD’s lead candidate in Saxony-Anhalt, Ulrich Siegmund, says “We are taking our country back”, the feeling of being second-class citizens naturally resonates.
We have a wide economic and social divide, high levels of emigration and a truly inadequate representation of East Germans in leadership positions.
The Monday demonstrations of 1989 were a sign of East Germans’ quest for freedom and democracy. What exactly did the citizens of East Germany mean by democracy back then?
There were two aspects to this. People took to the streets to demand civil liberties. They also achieved successes in this regard, for example, in the freedom to vote, freedom of the press, freedom of expression, freedom of assembly, and, of course, freedom of movement. These were very important, central demands in 1989. However, looking at the post-war history of the German Federal Republic [West Germany], democracy naturally also appeared as a promise of growing prosperity.
And this is precisely where the experiences of East and West diverge. Democracy was fought for by the East Germans themselves and, from the very beginning, led to major social and economic upheavals for many of them. By the end of 1991, for instance, three million East Germans had already lost their jobs, and 85 per cent of them changed jobs during this process of transformation. These are experiences that West German society is unfamiliar with.
I believe East Germans were holding out for a long time, but at some point, because prosperity was not materialising to the same extent, they began to turn away from democracy.
People rally behind the AfD to create a moment of disruption – to undermine a system in which they no longer place much hope
The AfD started out as a neoliberal party and remains the antithesis of a welfare party. So why do many people think it can be an answer to citizens’ economic concerns?
That is truly contradictory. Let’s just look at Saxony-Anhalt, which is currently the most concrete example. If we examine the election, we see that the vast majority of people who voted for the AfD did so because of social, economic, and financial problems. It is clear that people on low incomes in rural areas, in particular, no longer have any confidence in democratic parties.
But does the AfD solve these problems? Of course not. It is a highly ideologically driven party that is becoming increasingly radicalised and advocates extreme approaches to education, culture, migration, and media policy. We can already see that there is a wide gulf between the motivations of voters in eastern Germany and the AfD’s promises. That is precisely where the opportunity lies to defeat the AfD, because it is the political centre that must resolve the real problems faced by a large proportion of the people in Saxony-Anhalt. People rally behind the AfD to create a moment of disruption – to undermine a system in which they no longer place much hope.
You write that Hartz IV, a social reform introduced by the red-green coalition government in 2005 which tightened the conditions for receiving welfare payouts, marked a decisive turning point in East Germans’ loss of trust. Could you explain why?
Up until 2013, East Germans voted more heavily for left-wing parties than West Germans in every federal election. This means we are dealing with a society that still carries a certain post-socialist legacy. This was not immediately obvious, because in 1990 they had voted for [Christian-democratic leader] Helmut Kohl, who promised rapid reunification.
East German society is characterised by its working-class roots. This is actually a typical voter base for left-wing parties – for the Social Democrats, for Die Linke, and perhaps to some extent for the Greens as well. Furthermore, up until 2013, East Germans consistently voted for the Greens in significant numbers.
Most commentators assume East Germans began to turn their back on democracy in 2015, with Merkel’s refugee policy and the rise of the extreme-right Pegida movement and the AfD. However, if one looks very closely at the figures, it becomes clear that the first major turning point coincided with the introduction of Hartz IV – the biggest reform of the social security system in the history of the Federal Republic. Hartz IV was ill-suited to the East German labour market, which was already characterised by extreme unemployment at the time. Nevertheless, it was pushed through by the red-green coalition. We can clearly see that voter turnout in the East declined significantly afterwards.
Meanwhile, the AfD is trying to give the impression that it stands for true democracy or a genuine desire for freedom. Yes, that is what its voters believe. They do that the same way as other groups want to believe that we are a resilient democracy – although I am no longer at all sure whether we still are. For years, we have been debating proceedings to ban the AfD, but we are getting nowhere. The result is that people in Germany can currently, through free democratic elections, vote for an anti-democratic, racist, and extreme-right party, which then enters parliament. We have now seen this in Saxony-Anhalt: whilst this party was legitimised through democratic means, it does not stand for democratic politics. We are, however, familiar with this experience from many other countries – be it Hungary or the US. It is an experience that is now also becoming a reality in Germany, or rather in eastern Germany.
Does that mean the AfD is not an East German or German phenomenon? After all, the rise of the far right is a trend we are seeing across Europe and worldwide.
It is certainly part of a global trend, but it has an East German DNA. I believe that in every country, we need to look closely to understand what has happened there. Orbán’s rise in Hungary must be explained from a Hungarian perspective, and Trump is also part of American history.
The AfD is certainly part of a global trend, but it has an East German DNA
I am not turning this into an East German problem, but I am trying to explain it from an East German perspective. After all, we must acknowledge that the AfD is twice as strong across the board in the East as it is in western Germany. A week after the election in Saxony-Anhalt, in which the AfD received 43.6 per cent of the vote, local elections took place in Lower Saxony (one of the Western states), where the AfD achieved 15.9 per cent. We must explain this enormous gap, as this is the only way we can bridge it. I am firmly convinced of this. If we look at the AfD as a pan-German phenomenon, we are failing to tackle its various roots.
What about the AfD’s growing strength across Germany, though? Can we still say its DNA is East German?
I do not believe that the party itself has East German roots, but rather that its success in East Germany stems from East German factors. In the West, we can see that the party has only recently begun to grow and has, above all, gained a lot of ground under the current Chancellor, Friedrich Merz. However, this massive growth in the West simply comes on top of many years of gradual growth in the East. That is why we now find ourselves at one of the darkest moments in Germany’s post-war and reunification history. And yet I have the feeling that the more closely we look, the more precisely we can identify solutions. I am not at all sceptical on that point.
The results in Saxony-Anhalt in particular provide us with a clear roadmap for action, including how we can combat the AfD. However, this is the exact opposite of what Friedrich Merz and certain sections of the CDU are doing, as they are adopting the AfD’s policies as their own. Instead, we need concrete policies for the ageing, depopulated, and in many respects less prosperous East, which holds different views from the West on many socio-political issues. This was the case during the migration crisis, with the Covid-19 pandemic, and also with regard to Russia’s war of aggression against Ukraine.
As a society, we have drastically narrowed the scope of public debate. This makes it difficult for me to adopt the perspectives of those who do not support Angela Merkel’s refugee policy. I do not share the views of anti-vaxxers. But we must clearly admit that, in Germany, over the last ten years, we have primarily turned material issues into matters of principle. We have made decisions largely on that basis, rather than recognising that there are sections of the population who view migration and even war through a material lens.
Does this also have to do with the fact that, apart from the leftist party Die Linke, the main forces standing for election over the last three decades were those that originated in the former GDR?
For a long time, Die Linke’s predecessor, the Party of Democratic Socialism (PDS), was the party of the East. And you can see very clearly that the moment it tried to become a pan-German party – namely in the years after 2007 – it ceased to be successful in the East. In 2007, it merged with the Labour & Social Justice – The Electoral Alternative (WASG) party to form Die Linke. The AfD has, to some extent, taken its place.
So, can we say that the AfD is currently the only “East German party”?
You could say that the AfD is the only East German party with the strength of a mainstream party, because it now achieves poll ratings of 35 to 40 per cent in all the East German federal states. But at the same time, we naturally have strong Minister-Presidents in all the East German federal states. Michael Kretschmer (CDU, Saxony) defeated the AfD. Manuela Schwesig (SPD, Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania) and Dietmar Woidke (SPD, Brandenburg) have also managed to do so. These individuals are each propelling their respective parties forward. Sometimes it’s the SPD, sometimes the CDU/CSU. However, if we look at which party still enjoys widespread support across the board, it is the AfD.
Does that make it an East German party? I am not so sure about that. It may well be that the AfD is repeating the same mistakes in the East as the other parties. It is possible that the AfD is merely using East Germans to roll out its radical, racist, and nationalist agenda, without paying any heed to the interests of the voters.
It will take a few more years to see whether these voters actually remain with the AfD or whether they have formed a coalition of convenience in the election to disrupt the system and will subsequently fall apart again.
Die Linke successfully increased its appeal to voters in Berlin. But even there, many complain that it is an anti-democratic and antisemitic party. Should we be concerned about this?
This is one of the most absurd debates we are currently witnessing in Germany. I am stunned by how many people think it is a good idea to equate Die Linke with the AfD. Not so long ago, the Minister-President of Rhineland-Palatinate, Gordon Schnieder (CDU), called for a ban on Die Linke to be considered. We are heading down a spiral of escalation here.
It is true that the Left Party does have a problem with antisemitism in some quarters, and it must resolve this. But we can see very clearly that the majority of voters – especially young people in Berlin – voted for the party for social reasons. I think it would be disastrous to now lump all these people together with an extremist faction. Friedrich Merz is fuelling this trend.
It will take a few more years to see whether these voters actually remain with the AfD or whether they have formed a coalition of convenience in the election to disrupt the system
The Greens have managed to stay relevant in East German state elections this year, in Saxony-Anhalt and Mecklenburg-Vorpommern. What would it take for them to become stronger in East Germany as well?
Socio-economically and demographically, the East remains a tough nut to crack for the Greens. Rural areas in particular lack academic communities and higher-income earners [among whom the Greens typically enjoy strong support]. However, we have seen in every election that the Greens can be successful in urban areas where, like in the West, the socio-economic structure, the average age, and the density of institutions are high. This was the case in Dresden, Leipzig, Potsdam, Greifswald, and other cities.
People rally behind the AfD to create a moment of disruption – to undermine a system in which they no longer place much hope.
It is also interesting that the Greens achieved a strong result in Saxony-Anhalt – with a very strong lead candidate, Susan Sziborra-Seidlitz. In terms of her background, she is not a typical Green. She is a trained nurse, has worked in the care sector for many years, and originally comes from the Left. With just under 9 per cent, she naturally also benefited from a massive second-vote campaign. However, I believe she also won people over as a person. This shows that the Greens can be surprisingly strong when they field compelling figures who do not primarily represent the academic milieu.
I have never been one of those people who make sweeping claims that the Greens do not understand the East. That is simply not true, because there have always been very committed Greens in the eastern German states. The Greens have their roots in East Germany, as is reflected in their name, Alliance 90/The Greens [Alliance 90 was an alliance of opposition groups in the GDR], and for a long time I haven’t felt that they are unaware of these roots. Robert Habeck and Annalena Baerbock, for instance, travelled throughout the East during their time in office and tried to see things from that perspective. As a party that draws on the revolutionary legacy of 1989, it plays a very important role in the East. This remains true even if they only achieve 6 per cent of the vote in the East, and it holds all the more true the more successful they are.
In 2027, five state elections will take place in West German states. What are your expectations?
I am already looking at North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW) with great concern. There is a stable red-green coalition there, but we can see that the AfD is very strong in the regions affected by economic transitions. One can only hope that the AfD does not achieve a significant symbolic success in NRW now, and will not exceed 15 per cent in the West.
What would be a good strategy to defeat the AfD, beyond banning it or erecting a firewall against it?
In Saxony-Anhalt, the Gordian knot has been cut, as Sahra Wagenknecht’s BSW has emerged as a second political player on the scene that also wants to pursue disruptive politics.1 Nevertheless, I believe the firewall policy could succeed if it involved more than symbolic distancing from a very radical party. That is what we have seen over the last ten years. All of us – myself included – have erected this firewall whilst at the same time clinging to the status quo. But we have done far too little to understand what these voters actually want.
Fortunately, it is clear that we are finally beginning to do so. Following last year’s local elections in NRW, we saw that the proportion of blue-collar workers amongst AfD voters is very high. Suddenly, we have linked the social issue to the AfD. In the East, we have seen over the past ten years that the proportion of workers voting for the AfD has been rising steadily, and yet we have failed to address the social issue. This is the crucial issue, because 36 years after reunification, the East has still not reached the standard of living enjoyed in West Germany – neither in terms of wages, nor in terms of income or economic strength. We must begin to tackle the differing levels of prosperity between the two societies politically as well. Every chancellor since Helmut Kohl has failed in this regard, because the East has always been co-administered from a West German perspective.
We need a policy that actively works with these differences and examines them closely; one that scrutinises every measure and every law carefully to see how they affect East and West German states. The prosperity gap between East and West is structural. It will not disappear on its own and remains clearly visible. That is why different approaches are needed.
- After the election in Saxony-Anhalt, the BSW agreed to talks and cooperation with the AfD on specific parliamentary votes, effectively ending the firewall against the far-right party. In a secret ballot, some CDU lawmakers also likely voted for the far-right AfD candidate for parliamentary speaker. ︎
Chile podría ahorrar US$27 mil millones en importaciones de combustible acelerando la adopción de vehículos eléctricos
Un nuevo análisis de Carbon Tracker concluye que una adopción más rápida de vehículos eléctricos podría reducir la dependencia de Chile de las importaciones de petróleo y los costos de transporte, en momentos en que el país debate la siguiente fase de sus estándares de eficiencia vehicular.
Santiago, 10 de noviembre – Chile podría ahorrar aproximadamente US$27 mil millones en costos acumulados de importación de combustible hasta 2050 si acelera su transición desde vehículos a bencina y diésel hacia vehículos eléctricos a batería (BEV), según un nuevo informe del think tank financiero Carbon Tracker, publicado en asociación con el Centro de Movilidad Sostenible (CMS).
El informe, El salto a la electricidad: Los beneficios económicos de una política de promoción de vehículos eléctricos en Chile, concluye que seguir dependiendo de los vehículos con motor de combustión interna (ICE) encerraría al país en décadas adicionales de demanda de combustible y de exposición a la volatilidad de los precios internacionales del petróleo. Chile importa casi la totalidad de su petróleo crudo, y el transporte representa el 57% del consumo nacional de petróleo.
En un escenario sin cambios de políticas (business-as-usual), los costos acumulados de importación de combustible para el transporte terrestre podrían alcanzar casi US120 mil millones hasta 2050. Una transición acelerada hacia los vehículos eléctricos permitiría a Chile ahorrarse más de 27 mil millones en el mismo período. Hacia 2050, los costos anuales de importación de combustible para el transporte de Chile podrían reducirse hasta en un 56% mediante una transición acelerada hacia el transporte eléctrico terrestre, en comparación con un escenario sin cambios de políticas.
Los hallazgos se dan en momentos en que Chile implementa su Estrategia Nacional de Electromovilidad, actualizada en junio de 2026, que introdujo una meta de 20% de ventas de cero emisiones para vehículos livianos y medianos al año 2030. En la próxima sesión del Consejo de Ministros por la Sustentabilidad y el Cambio Climático, los ministros decidirán, antes de fin de año, sobre la Fase 2 de la Ley de Eficiencia Energética (Ley N° 21.305).
El informe pide mantener la Fase 2 de los estándares de eficiencia vehicular establecidos en la Ley de Eficiencia Energética de Chile, que debe entrar en vigencia en 2027. La siguiente fase eleva el rendimiento promedio exigido para los vehículos livianos nuevos de 18,8 a 22,8 kilómetros por litro de gasolina equivalente para el período 2027-2029.
La recomendación surge en medio de las inquietudes planteadas por representantes de la industria automotriz sobre el posible impacto de los estándares más estrictos en los precios y las ventas de vehículos. Carbon Tracker sostiene que mantener el calendario ayudaría a evitar que vehículos de combustión interna menos eficientes sean desviados hacia Chile a medida que otros mercados endurecen sus regulaciones, a la vez que incentivaría a los fabricantes a ofrecer más modelos eficientes y eléctricos.
A pesar de los avances de Chile en la electrificación del transporte público, en particular en Santiago, los vehículos eléctricos representaron solo alrededor del 3,5% de las ventas de vehículos livianos y medianos nuevos en los primeros siete meses de 2026.
Chile cuenta con importantes ventajas para acelerar la adopción. Casi dos tercios de su electricidad proviene de fuentes renovables, y su posición como uno de los principales productores de cobre y litio le otorga un papel estratégico en las cadenas de suministro globales de vehículos eléctricos.
El informe también concluye que, según sus supuestos de precios de combustible y de carga, operar un vehículo eléctrico cuesta aproximadamente un 50% menos por kilómetro que un auto a bencina y un 20% menos que uno a diésel. Una transición acelerada también podría generar cerca de US$493 millones en beneficios económicos acumulados asociados a la salud hasta 2050, gracias a la reducción de la contaminación del aire.
Ben Scott, autor del informe y Jefe de Demanda de Energía de Carbon Tracker, declaró:
“Cada vehículo nuevo a bencina o diésel que se vende hoy fija por años una demanda de combustible importado, dejando a Chile expuesto a los precios internacionales del petróleo. Mantener la Fase 2 de los estándares de eficiencia ayudaría a mejorar la eficiencia de los vehículos que ingresan al mercado chileno. La idea de que los estándares de eficiencia de la flota encarecen automáticamente todos los autos malinterpreta cómo funcionan estas regulaciones. A los fabricantes se les evalúa según la eficiencia promedio de los vehículos que venden, lo que les da flexibilidad para cumplir la meta ofreciendo modelos más eficientes y eléctricos, en lugar de exigir que todos los vehículos cumplan el mismo estándar.”
A partir de las experiencias de electrificación vehicular en economías emergentes como Etiopía, Nepal y Vietnam, el informe recomienda mantener la Fase 2 de los estándares de eficiencia vehicular vigentes en Chile, junto con regulaciones vinculantes del lado de la oferta para reducir progresivamente la venta de vehículos de combustión interna, incentivos fiscales focalizados para mejorar la asequibilidad de los BEV e inversión coordinada en infraestructura de carga, especialmente fuera de Santiago y a lo largo de los principales corredores de carga.
En conjunto, estas medidas podrían respaldar la transición de Chile hacia sus metas de ventas de vehículos de cero emisiones para 2035 y 2045, al tiempo que reducirían los costos futuros de importación de combustible y entregarían mayor certidumbre a inversionistas y proveedores de vehículos.
Lea el informe completo
Leapfrog to Electric: Chile – Los beneficios económicos de las políticas a favor de los vehículos eléctricos en Chile ( partir del 10 de noviembre)
Notas para los editores
• El informe fue elaborado por Carbon Tracker en asociación con el Centro de Movilidad Sostenible (CMS).
• La cifra de US$27 mil millones representa el ahorro acumulado en importaciones de combustible hasta 2050 bajo el escenario de Transición Acelerada a BEV de Carbon Tracker, en comparación con un escenario sin cambios de políticas basado en las políticas existentes.
• El análisis abarca automóviles de pasajeros, buses y vehículos de carga medianos y pesados.
• El informe es el tercero de la serie Leapfrog to Electric de Carbon Tracker, que examina los beneficios económicos y financieros de acelerar la adopción de vehículos eléctricos en economías emergentes. Los informes anteriores se centraron en Brasil y Colombia, y estimaron ahorros acumulados potenciales en importaciones de combustible hasta 2050 de hasta US250 mil millones y aproximadamente US40 mil millones, respectivamente. En conjunto, los tres estudios muestran cómo los países de América Latina podrían reducir los costos económicos de la dependencia de combustibles importados para el transporte, y el papel que puede desempeñar la política pública para acelerar la electrificación.
• La Fase 2 de los estándares de eficiencia de vehículos livianos de Chile abarca el período 2027-2029, con una meta promedio de flota de 22,8 km/Lge, frente a 18,8 km/Lge durante 2024-2026. Estos estándares evalúan la eficiencia promedio de los vehículos en las ventas de un importador, en lugar de aplicar el mismo mínimo a cada modelo individual.
Voceros:
Ben Scott, Jefe de Demanda de Energía, Carbon Tracker;
Nicolás González-Jiménez, Analista Energético, Carbon Tracker
Para consultas de prensa y entrevistas
Valentina Rojas: valentina.rojas@gsccnetwork.org
Alessandra Moscadelli / Sally Palmer: media@tracker-group.org
Acerca de Carbon Tracker
Carbon Tracker es un think tank financiero independiente, ubicado en Reino Unidp, que examina el impacto de la transición energética en los mercados de capitales y los riesgos financieros asociados a la continua dependencia de los combustibles fósiles.
The post Chile podría ahorrar US$27 mil millones en importaciones de combustible acelerando la adopción de vehículos eléctricos appeared first on Carbon Tracker Initiative.
Chile could save US$27 billion in fuel imports by accelerating electric vehicle adoption
Despite progress in electrifying public transport, private EV adoption remains low, even as electric vehicles offer lower running costs and Chile’s electricity supply becomes increasingly renewable.
London, 10 November – Chile could save approximately US$27 billion in cumulative fuel import costs by 2050 through an accelerated transition to battery electric vehicles (BEVs), according to a new report from Carbon Tracker.
The research finds that continued reliance on petrol and diesel vehicles would leave Chile exposed to decades of additional fuel demand and international oil-price volatility. Chile imports almost all its crude oil, while transport accounts for 57% of national oil consumption.
Under a business-as-usual scenario, cumulative road transport fuel import costs could reach almost US$120 billion by 2050. An accelerated transition to BEV could also reduce Chile’s annual transport fuel import costs by as much as 56% in 2050, compared with business as usual, while avoiding approximately 600 million barrels of oil equivalent in cumulative fossil-fuel consumption.
The report, Leapfrog to Electric: Chile, also finds that BEVs cost approximately 50% less per kilometre to operate than petrol cars and 20% less than diesel cars, based on its fuel-price and charging assumptions. Reducing vehicle-related air pollution could generate a further US$493 million in cumulative health-related economic benefits by 2050.
Chile’s electrification opportunity
Chile has several advantages that could support faster adoption. Almost two-thirds of its electricity comes from renewable sources, while its position as the world’s largest copper producer and second-largest lithium producer gives it an important role in global EV supply chains.
The country has also made considerable progress in electrifying public transport, particularly in Santiago. Yet BEVs accounted for only around 3.5% of new light- and medium-duty vehicle sales in the first seven months of 2026.
Ben Scott, report author and Head of Energy Demand at Carbon Tracker, said:
“Much of the discussion around electric vehicles focuses on their upfront cost. But governments also need to consider the long-term economic costs of every additional petrol or diesel vehicle sold, from imported fuel demand to the wider health and climate impacts. Chile has the renewable electricity resources and industrial advantages to move faster. The challenge is to create the market conditions that will allow more households and businesses to benefit from electrification.”
Closing the gap between policy targets and market adoption
Chile’s National Electromobility Strategy, updated in June 2026, introduced an interim target of 20% zero-emission sales for light- and medium-duty vehicles by 2030, alongside its ambition to reach 100% by 2035. The Council of Ministers for Sustainability and Climate Change is expected to decide on Phase 2 of Chile’s vehicle efficiency standards before the end of 2026.
The report identifies maintaining Phase 2 of Chile’s Energy Efficiency Law as an immediate policy priority. Scheduled for 2027-2029, the next phase increases the average fuel efficiency standard for new light-duty vehicles from 18.8 to 22.8 kilometres per litre of gasoline equivalent.
Unlike a standard applied uniformly to individual vehicle models, the regulation assesses fleet-wide averages, giving manufacturers flexibility to meet the target through a mix of more efficient petrol, hybrid and electric vehicles. Automotive industry representatives have raised concerns about the potential impact of the tighter standards on vehicle prices and sales. Carbon Tracker argues that maintaining the timetable would help prevent less efficient ICE vehicles from being redirected to Chile as other markets strengthen their regulations, while encouraging manufacturers to supply more efficient and electric models.
Beyond maintaining existing standards, the report argues that achieving these targets will require stronger measures to accelerate adoption and encourage investment. Drawing on experiences in Ethiopia, Nepal and Vietnam, it recommends binding supply-side regulations to progressively phase down internal combustion engine vehicle sales, targeted fiscal incentives to improve BEV affordability, and coordinated investment in charging infrastructure, particularly outside Santiago and along major freight corridors.
These measures could help Chile reduce future fuel-import costs while supporting its energy security and climate objectives.
A wider economic opportunity for Latin America
The Chile study is the third in Carbon Tracker’s Leapfrog to Electric series, which assesses the economic and financial benefits of accelerating vehicle electrification in emerging economies.
Earlier reports found that Brazil [LINK] could avoid up to US$250 billion in cumulative fuel import costs by 2050, while Colombia [LINK] could save approximately US$40 billion.
Together, the three studies point to a broader economic case for transport electrification across Latin America. Although Brazil, Colombia and Chile have different automotive markets and policy frameworks, reducing dependence on imported fuels and accelerating EV adoption through targeted government policies should be priorities across the region.
Leapfrog to Electric: Chile was published in association with Centro de Movilidad Sostenible (CMS).
Explore the research
Chile: Leapfrog to Electric: Chile – The Economic Benefits of Pro-Electric Vehicle Policy
[Download the Chile report – English]
[Download the Chile report – Spanish]
Previous reports in the series:
Colombia: Leapfrog to Electric
Notes to editors
The US$27 billion figure represents cumulative modelled fuel import savings to 2050 under Carbon Tracker’s Accelerated BEV Transition scenario, compared with a business-as-usual scenario based on existing policies.
The analysis covers passenger cars, buses, and medium- and heavy-duty vehicles.
Spokesperson: Ben Scott, Head of Energy Demand, Carbon Tracker.
For media enquiries and interviews, contact media@tracker-group.org.
The post Chile could save US$27 billion in fuel imports by accelerating electric vehicle adoption appeared first on Carbon Tracker Initiative.
Battery boost: State pours $15 million into portable vanadium electrolyte manufacturing
WA backs development of a high-capacity, relocatable manufacturing facility that produces on-site electrolyte for large-scale vanadium flow battery storage projects.
The post Battery boost: State pours $15 million into portable vanadium electrolyte manufacturing appeared first on Renew Economy.
2026 | October News Wrap: Updates from LVC Members Worldwide
The struggles of our member organisations across the world never stop, and neither do the stories of resistance, solidarity and collective action that emerge from them!
The post 2026 | October News Wrap: Updates from LVC Members Worldwide appeared first on La Via Campesina - EN.
Trump’s obsession with GDP rebuked by voters
Five ways countries stymie climate negotiations without actually saying ‘no’
When the government won’t do enough about collapse, can the church step in?
The factory occupation constructing new futures
The five-year struggle over the GKN Florence factory is more than a labour issue, argues Lorenzo Feltrin. It’s a strategy of green conversion and resistance to the far-right
The post The factory occupation constructing new futures appeared first on Red Pepper.
Climate risk is increasingly understood as business risk. COP31 needs to link opportunity with climate action
Business leaders who dismiss COP31 as a diplomatic exercise risk missing signals that will shape future investment, regulation and competitiveness.
The post Climate risk is increasingly understood as business risk. COP31 needs to link opportunity with climate action appeared first on Renew Economy.
'I really do mean abolish Westminster'
2 years after Mexico relocated their climate-ravaged community, residents struggle to adapt
It’s 3 a.m. and the beach in El Bosque, in southeast Mexico, is humming with small talk and laughter as Viviana Velázquez eases out of her hammock and dashes to the shoreline to greet a boat returning with the night’s catch. Velázquez, 38, and her 13-year-old daughter, Marlene, help the tired fishermen unload the ice boxes and heave a plastic crate full of bonito to the cooperative to be weighed.
The captain pays Velázquez for her help in fish. She saves a couple to fry for breakfast and cashes in the rest for 50 pesos, the equivalent of about $3, and heads back to her hammock, where some friends are eating pastries while catching up on the past week’s dramas.
This work is known locally as garrulear. For decades it was an important source of income, food, and bonding for women in El Bosque, a small fishing community in the state of Tabasco located on a narrow peninsula sandwiched between the Gulf of Mexico and the Usumacinta River. It is one of the things that Velázquez misses most since sea level rise forced residents to leave.
“In El Bosque I would garrulear every day, but then the sea took everything,” said Velázquez, as she settled back into a hammock. “Now I’m stuck inside most of the time; it’s too far to come here often.”
El Bosque became the first community in Mexico to be recognized as displaced by climate change in 2023. By then, coastal erosion and flooding from storm surge had already damaged or swept away more than half of the hundred or so homes in the area. After a high-profile media campaign and several administrative claims by a coalition of environmental justice organizations working with residents of El Bosque, President Andrés Manuel López Obrador pledged to relocate them.
In November 2024, a new neighborhood called Nuevo Bosque, or New Forest, was inaugurated 7.5 miles inland on the outskirts of the city of Frontera. Fifty-one families received identical purpose-built houses in Nuevo Bosque.
The El Bosque relocation was seen as a huge win for the residents and a success story for the government. Yet two years on, the community is now also struggling to adapt to economic, social, and cultural losses caused by moving away from the sea. Meanwhile, the residents who were excluded from the relocation still don’t know why.
Velázquez was among the lucky ones to be rehoused, but she doesn’t feel settled. “I am trying to adapt to my new life, but I can’t sleep, I cry all the time, my heart beats a thousand times a minute,” she told Drilled. “We’re constantly worrying about money. I eat and eat and eat to calm my nerves. I’ve put on 29 pounds.
“We are grateful, but I am still grieving,” she said. “I miss everything about El Bosque: the cool breeze, my friends, our whole life.”
Fishing wasn’t just a job for the people of El Bosque. It was a core part of who they were, both as individuals and as a community. They wanted to be relocated closer to the coast so they could still fish every day, but the authorities said that they’d likely be flooded out again within a few years. Here, they should be safe from flooding for 30 years or so.
Fishers help to unload the boats in El Bosque, work locally known as garrulear.Daniele Volpe
The grief is not over yet. A taxi ride from Nuevo Bosque to El Bosque and back costs 240 pesos (equivalent to around $14), which is why Velázquez and her friends only go back once a week or so even during the height of the fishing season. But even these precious few nights spent garruleando, helping the fishermen and bonding with friends, are numbered.
“At the rate things are going, a few sandy islands are all that will soon be left of El Bosque,” said Lilia Gama, an ecologist and expert in coastal erosion from the Juarez Autonomous University of Tabasco. “The river and the sea will likely join up within a decade, and the entire community will be under water.”
According to Gama, the river and sea in El Bosque would have eventually joined anyway, due to the natural dynamics of the waters, but climate change has turbocharged the process.
Rising sea level is primarily caused by global heating driven by the greenhouse gas emissions released from burning fossil fuels. Ice caps, ice sheets, and glaciers that flow into the oceans are melting, increasing the volume of oceans across the globe. The oceans are also expanding due to warmer waters, which are not only making seas rise further but also causing storms to grow stronger and more destructive. Powerful tidal waves, storm surges, and other events that create extremely high sea levels, which historically occurred once every century, could become annual phenomena by 2100.
Globally, the rate of sea level rise has more than doubled over the past three decades. It will rise a further 15 to 30 centimeters (4 to 12 inches) on average by 2050, according to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, endangering close to a billion people currently living in low-lying coastal areas.
It could leave up to half the entire state of Tabasco, home to about 2.5 million people, uninhabitable or highly vulnerable by the end of the century, according to modeling by Climate Central.
Under international law, states have a duty to protect their communities and guarantee human rights, which includes transitioning away from fossil fuels and implementing climate adaptation measures to minimize harm.
“If displacement cannot be prevented, communities have the right to be consulted, the right to information, and to provide input so they co-shape the decision on how and where they will be relocated,” said Veronika Fikfak, a professor of international human rights law at University College London.
From El Bosque to Nuevo BosqueEl Bosque was founded in the early 1980s by landless people from the neighboring state of Veracruz who saw an opportunity to lift their families out of poverty. Back then the peninsula was covered in mangroves and thick vegetation — hence the name El Bosque, which means “the forest.”
Velázquez was just six months old when her family moved to El Bosque. The family didn’t get rich, but they did alright. There was an abundance of fish that sold to restaurants and markets in the capital, Mexico City, and then locally as El Bosque became a popular spot for local tourists to eat crab tamales, ceviche, and fish empanadas.
Velázquez married a local fisherman, Javier Rodriguez, and they had two children.
In February 2022, the sea flooded their home during a storm, and the family moved into another house slightly farther inland. When that house flooded in November 2022, they were evacuated to Frontera. By then, an entire row of houses in El Bosque was fully submerged under water, and the kindergarten and primary school their children attended had been abandoned.
Viviana Velázquez and her husband, Javier Rodriguez, at their new house in Nuevo Bosque. They stayed in El Bosque with their children as long as they could, through the collapse of two houses, before finally leaving in December 2024. Daniele VolpeBefore being evacuated, “the children were crying all the time, scared by the sound of the waves crashing into the house,” Velázquez said. “But we came back to El Bosque so my husband, Javier, could keep fishing.” They stayed in a makeshift house cobbled together from sticks and metal sheeting, even after the power was cut off due to storm damage. “I couldn’t bear to leave.”
The family finally left El Bosque for good on New Year’s Eve 2024, a month after getting the keys to their new house in Nuevo Bosque.
Nuevo Bosque consists of four rows of identical single-story, two-bedroom houses, each with a back and front yard that are too small for the chickens and ducks many raised in El Bosque. There’s a playground, a basketball court, and some benches — the town’s only gathering place, where teenagers make out and community meetings are held.
The town was inaugurated without running water or a primary school. A narrow laminate static trailer parked at the community entrance currently serves as a makeshift classroom. There’s no bathroom, so the kids run home if they need the toilet.
One day in late May when Drilled visited the school in Nuevo Bosque, the morning began with children helping to sweep rainwater from an overnight storm out of the trailer. With no AC and just four fans (one of them broken), soon it was baking hot inside. Tabasco has always been hot and humid, but climate change is driving temperatures higher, and the state education department had just instructed schools to close at 11:30 a.m. for the rest of the term because of the heat.
“The kids get irritable and sleepy. It’s so hot, it’s hard even for me,” said teacher Isabel Mayo Cerino. “This was supposedly a planned relocation, and yet nobody thought about education. A community without a school isn’t a proper community.”
The state education department has promised to build a proper classroom when the community finds some suitable land. But the children have been without a proper school for almost six years now, ever since a tidal wave flooded their old school in El Bosque in late 2020.
Natali Segura, 28, moved her 11-year-old son to a school in Frontera because he could barely read or write. “The kids lost 5 or 6 years of school,” said Segura. “They are so behind.”
The community is relieved to be away from the threat of the rising sea, and close proximity to the city has brought benefits. A hospital is nearby, and there’s good internet and phone service, which the teenagers love.
But multiple residents told Drilled that they feel isolated and less healthy. Drilled met many adults and children who, like Velázquez, said they had put on significant amounts of weight since relocating away from the coast. Their life in the city is far more sedentary. Fish is no longer a mainstay of their diet, and fast food is a lot easier to find. Residents have gotten into the habit of ordering snacks and big bottles of sugary, fizzy drinks for home delivery.
At the same time, money is tighter, and for the first time mothers don’t always know where the next meal for their kids is coming from.
Nuevo Bosque, a new community of 51 row houses, was built on the outskirts of the city of Frontera in the state of Tabasco, for fisher families displaced by coastal erosion. It was inaugurated in November 2024. Daniele Volpe“It might look like we’re better off in these new houses, but we’re not,” said Áurea Sánchez, 44, who spends hours each day at her evangelical church praying for the community to be blessed. “No one was rich in El Bosque, but no one ever went hungry. Now, life is more precarious. We’re fishers, we can’t change overnight.”
In 2024, Sánchez and her eldest daughter, Yesenia, were among hundreds of people from frontline communities in Latin America and the Caribbean who testified at a landmark hearing on climate displacement convened by the Inter American Court of Human Rights, or IACHR, in Manaus, Brazil. “I realized that we’re not alone, that we have rights, and that many communities are suffering because we haven’t looked after what God gave us,” Sanchez told Drilled.
El Bosque has become an emblematic case of climate displacement, helping clarify international law and setting in motion a wave of policy reforms in Mexico. It was cited in a historic opinion published by the IACHR in May 2025.
“States are obligated to adopt measures to prevent … migration and forced displacement resulting directly and indirectly from disasters and other impacts of climate change,” according to the IACHR advisory opinion on human rights and climate change. In other words, the highest court in the Americas says that under existing international law, states are duty bound to develop and finance public policies on climate adaptation and displacement.
Where oil production and displacement convergeInternational climate negotiations are often cast in terms of those who have contributed the most to climate change and those who will suffer the worst consequences. Mexico is one of the few countries that straddles both categories.
Mexico is one of the top 20 largest historic contributors to greenhouse gas emissions. Industrialized countries that benefited most from fossil fuels are legally and morally bound to help lead the way in transitioning away from fossil fuel under international law and U.N. climate treaties like the 2015 Paris Agreement.
Yet Mexico is the 11th largest oil producer in the world, according to the International Energy Agency’s most recent data. It is also highly vulnerable to climate breakdown. If current climate trends continue, Mexico could see at least 3 million people internally displaced by 2050 as a result of sea level rise, drought, desertification, extreme heat, and other sudden and slow onset climate disasters, according to one study by the World Bank.
This paradox is particularly stark in Tabasco, the state where El Bosque is located, which is also the home state of former president Andrés Manuel López Obrador, whose six-year term from 2018 to 2024 saw Mexico’s transition to renewable energy sources go backward.
Tabasco is one of the biggest oil-producing states in Mexico, and fossil fuel companies have built refineries, pipelines, and other polluting infrastructure along its eroding coastline, as well as roads, schools, hospitals, and entire neighborhoods for their workers. Sea level rise and air pollution from oil operations threaten them all, underlying the harm caused by fossil fuels at every stage of their life cycle — from toxic pollution and industrial accidents when they are extracted and refined, to the global heating driven by the release of greenhouse gases when they are burned.
Mexico’s national oil company, Pemex, was founded by President Lázaro Cárdenas in 1938. A symbol of the country’s nationalism and sovereignty, it’s now ranked as the biggest corporate polluter in Latin America and among the most indebted fossil companies globally.
The shoreline is eroding rapidly along the coast of Tabasco, one of Mexico’s biggest oil-producing states and also one of the most vulnerable to climate change.Daniele Volpe
Tabasco is tightly intertwined with Pemex, which has installations in 80 percent of the state’s municipalities — including the Dos Bocas oil refinery, which opened in 2022 about 60 miles west of El Bosque, and only meters away from a primary school in the neighborhood Lázaro Cárdenas del Río, more colloquially known as La Petrolera (the oil company), because so many residents work for Pemex.
The refinery has suffered floods, fatal fires, and massive oil leaks, while acute respiratory problems, panic attacks, headaches, and vomiting have surged among residents. The neighborhood is dotted with empty houses, all that’s left of the families displaced by the pollution, or who moved away in fear of further industrial disasters.
A huge gas flare is visible from the local hospital near La Petrolera, which is owned and operated by Pemex for its workers and their families, where Cindy Barjau rushed her daughter two years ago after she passed out, overcome by the fumes from the refinery.
“Children can’t play outside anymore; we keep our windows shut,” Barjau told Drilled. “It’s inhumane. Our quality of life has gone. We want to leave, too, but where would we go?”
Pemex has acknowledged a rise in air pollution but has repeatedly claimed that there is no risk to nearby communities. The gravity of the air pollution is difficult to determine, however, because the government has classified its air monitoring data as secret until 2030.
Documents obtained by local media suggest that Pemex began building the facility before completing an environmental impact assessment or a drainage system.
In March, amid growing public pressure following a fire that left five workers dead, President Claudia Sheinbaum asked Pemex to help relocate the school, where enrollment has plummeted.
A 2025 study by Amnesty International revealed that at least 2 billion people — a quarter of the world’s population — live within 3 miles of operational oil, gas, and coal projects, which have turned nearby communities and critical ecosystems into so-called sacrifice zones.
“The fossil fuel industry impacts people’s bodies, their health, their land, and the environment, polluting the surroundings and compromising the ability to sustain life in the short and medium term — and the long term, due to its climate impacts,” said Juan Manuel Orozco, a project officer at the nonprofit group Conexiones Climáticas, which has worked with residents in Dos Bocas and El Bosque. “In the southeast of Mexico, the situation is particularly dramatic. It’s as if all the monsters of our times have converged here.”
International law advancesIn July 2025, a historic advisory opinion by the International Court of Justice, or ICJ, confirmed that all states, whether they are signatories to the Paris Agreement or not, have a duty to take action to achieve “deep, rapid and sustained” cuts in greenhouse gas emissions, which includes regulating private corporations. The continued expansion of fossil fuels would amount to a legal wrong under customary international law, which could trigger an obligation to provide full reparations, the ICJ wrote.
The opinions — along with the El Bosque case — have generated political momentum in Mexico, and there has been more ambition on climate since President Claudia Sheinbaum took office in 2024.
As a signatory to the Paris Agreement, Mexico must submit an updated climate action plan (called a Nationally Determined Contribution) to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change every five years. Mexico’s 2025 update set a greenhouse gas target for the first time, implying that it would begin to take steps to lower its emissions.
However, plans are afoot to expand fossil fuel exploration, production, and use, while Mexico’s target timeline for shifting to renewable energy sources is way too slow, according to Climate Action Tracker.
Read Next In a rare show of global unity, countries adopt landmark climate ruling Naveena Sadasivam & Te Aniwaniwa PatersonThe IACHR and ICJ opinions also helped clarify that states have a duty to safeguard human rights in the context of climate change and put in place adaptation measures to reduce foreseeable harms (which could include things like infrastructure damage and forced displacement). When climate impacts are so advanced that harms have become unavoidable, the courts direct states to cooperate on “loss and damage” claims, including for financial compensation.
Mexico’s updated climate action plan acknowledged, also for the first time, that climate change is already causing loss and damage, which will require reparations to some communities.
Mexico could also end up facing loss and damage claims from other states over its failures to regulate fossil fuel and other polluting corporations and reduce emissions fast enough. But first the government must face domestic lawsuits for failing to protect its own people from foreseeable harms caused by climate change.
Loss and damageThe specific duties states have under international law to tackle sea level rise — and deal with consequences like lost livelihoods and displacement — are still undergoing legal clarification, and El Bosque has been a test case in many ways. In Mexico, the experience, good and bad, is likely to inform future climate policy, while a new lawsuit by El Bosque residents who were excluded from the relocation could help clarify the government’s statutory duties to climate-displaced communities.
Mexico, like dozens of other countries, still has no climate adaptation plan that sets out how it will both protect and prepare its own communities from climate breakdown. This is expected to include measures to prevent or minimize the risk of forced displacement, such as coastal restoration, reforestation, water-capture systems, and flood walls.
Read Next For Puerto Rico’s fishers, climate change isn’t the only challenge — being left to adapt alone is another Ayurella Horn-MullerIn El Bosque, the state failed to implement adaptation measures such as mangrove restoration that could have slowed down the erosion, according to Nora Cabrera, founder of the Mexico City-based law firm Nuestro Futuro, which is representing the residents.
The relocation, while well intentioned, was poorly planned and led to a decline in living standards for many residents, Cabrera said.
“The community has been made more vulnerable by the relocation — a level of regression that speaks to the process of climate injustice,” said Cabrera. “The El Bosque case is clearly one of loss and damage, because conditions for adaptation were never created. This amounts to an omission on the part of the Mexican state … regarding its citizens, its people.”
The first house in El Bosque to be completely destroyed by the waves belonged to fisherman Pablo Cardoza, who lived on the seafront with his wife and three children. In September 2019, a strong northerly wind caused a storm surge, flooding the house with sea water, dead trees, and trash. So Cardoza and his family moved to a rental in Frontera, and he took up open-water line fishing, which requires spending several nights on the water to catch sea bream, amberjack, and red snapper.
The catch is more reliable out at sea, but Cardoza still worries about making rent each month. Fish stocks are down due to warmer ocean temperatures, acidification, coastal erosion, and pollution from Pemex’s offshore oil rigs.
Once the government accepted responsibility for relocating residents, officials conducted a census, held meetings, and collected documents. In the end, 51 families were selected to receive new homes. However, the criteria for inclusion — or exclusion — have never been shared, and residents left out, like Cardoza, have never been told why.
“I missed some meetings because I was out at sea, but it feels really unfair. We were the first to lose our home and livelihoods,” Cardoza said. “I haven’t given up. I hope one day they correct this injustice.”
In July, Nuestro Futuro filed a lawsuit on behalf of Cardoza and six other residents of El Bosque who were not relocated without any explanation. This case, Cabrera said, could end up in the Mexican Supreme Court and prompt a ruling on what obligations the state has to climate-displaced communities.
The Mexican government is worried about the pending surge in climate displacement, which would inevitably add pressure on urban hubs like Mexico City, Monterrey, and Guadalajara, where extreme heat and water shortages are already getting worse. A new national policy is in the works for grappling with climate displacement, although it’s unclear when it will be finished, and the Mexican department of environment and natural resources is holding consultations with a wide range of experts on issues such as migration and gender for the separate climate adaptation plan.
If the displacement policy reflects recommendations submitted by residents of El Bosque and climate justice experts, it should make relocation a last resort, and something that is well planned, less traumatic, and more just for the next El Bosque, and the one after that.
In September, the government acknowledged that the vast majority of states and municipalities currently depend on data that is “three to four years out of date” to assess the risk from earthquakes, hurricanes, sea level rise, and other disasters. Funds have been allocated to help all 31 states and Mexico City identify new risks and update prevention efforts, said Laura Velázquez, Mexico’s national coordinator for civil protection.
Urgency is rising to get plans, policies, and financing in place, as climate breakdown accelerates faster than models predicted. “It’s too late for us, but we need a law or a policy to help others,” said Sanchez, the Nuevo Bosque resident who testified at the IACHR hearing in Brazil. “We were the first but we won’t be the last.”
toolTips('.classtoolTips3','Carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, and other gases that prevent heat from escaping Earth’s atmosphere. Together, they act as a blanket to keep the planet at a liveable temperature in what is known as the “greenhouse effect.” Too many of these gases, however, can cause excessive warming, disrupting fragile climates and ecosystems.');This story was originally published by Grist with the headline 2 years after Mexico relocated their climate-ravaged community, residents struggle to adapt on Nov 10, 2026.
Pages
The Fine Print I:
Disclaimer: The views expressed on this site are not the official position of the IWW (or even the IWW’s EUC) unless otherwise indicated and do not necessarily represent the views of anyone but the author’s, nor should it be assumed that any of these authors automatically support the IWW or endorse any of its positions.
Further: the inclusion of a link on our site (other than the link to the main IWW site) does not imply endorsement by or an alliance with the IWW. These sites have been chosen by our members due to their perceived relevance to the IWW EUC and are included here for informational purposes only. If you have any suggestions or comments on any of the links included (or not included) above, please contact us.
The Fine Print II:
Fair Use Notice: The material on this site is provided for educational and informational purposes. It may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. It is being made available in an effort to advance the understanding of scientific, environmental, economic, social justice and human rights issues etc.
It is believed that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have an interest in using the included information for research and educational purposes. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. The information on this site does not constitute legal or technical advice.




