You are here

News Feeds

Interactive: Tracking negotiating texts at the COP31 climate summit

The Carbon Brief - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 06:13
Print article Share

The centrepiece of every UN climate summit is for countries to negotiate the wording of a large number of legal agreements – and COP31 in the Turkish city of Antalya is no different.

These texts are hashed out behind closed doors in the “blue zone” at the COP, where diplomats from nearly 200 nations – not including the US – will be haggling over each individual verb.

Over the course of the two-week summit, negotiators will be trying to reach consensus on more than 100 separate agreements – but, first, they must agree which issues are on the agenda.

The complexity of this process can make it challenging to keep track of what countries are fighting about and how negotiations are progressing.

Carbon Brief’s real-time text tracker, below, offers a helping hand by decoding the agenda and keeping a searchable record of every document for each part of the negotiations.

The first column of the interactive tracker lists the topic of each agenda item, with further columns including dates, page counts and links to the original PDFs.

The table is searchable via the interactive text box and can be sorted using the arrow icons.

(() => { const iframe = document.getElementById('cop31-text-tracker'); const iframeOrigin = new URL(iframe.src).origin; window.addEventListener('message', (event) => { if (event.origin !== iframeOrigin || event.source !== iframe.contentWindow) { return; } const message = event.data; if ( !message || message.type !== 'cop31-text-tracker:resize' || !Number.isFinite(message.height) || message.height < 0 ) { return; } iframe.style.height = `${Math.ceil(message.height)}px`; }); })();

This year’s talks come with a twist: Turkey holds the presidency and is hosting COP31, but Australia is jointly running the show as “president of negotiations”.

The pair have already announced their intention to produce a “cover text” – an overarching political document summarising key negotiated outcomes, along with issues not on the official agenda.

This could include a recognition that warming is set to “overshoot” the 1.5C limit and the impacts this is already causing. It may also include potential solutions, such as the Turkish presidency’s “electrification” target, for 35% of global final energy to come from electricity by 2035.

While the summit is not seen as a banner year for the negotiations, falling half-way between two “global stocktakes” of progress, there are still plenty of major topics up for discussion.

These include efforts to finalise the “global goal on adaptation” and whether to continue a contested process on how to cut emissions, known as the “mitigation work programme”.

Negotiators will also be trying to agree on the details of a new “just transition mechanism”, also referred to as the “Belém-Antalya mechanism for global just transitions” (BAM).

While most of the items on the agenda are agreed in advance, parties can suggest late additions. These must be signed off before negotiations can begin, often resulting in an “agenda fight”.

COP30 agreed to put two new items on the agenda for future summits.

These are the provision of climate finance by developed countries, under Article 9.1 of the Paris Agreement, and making global “finance flows” consistent with the treaty, under Article 2.1c.

Ahead of COP31, the African group of nations filed a request to add climate-related trade tariffs to the agenda. COP30 had agreed to annual “dialogues” on this matter at the Bonn climate talks.

The African group also wants further items added, on tripling adaptation finance and on funding for the Green Climate Fund, a flagship UN body designed to support climate action.

Ahead of the opening of the summit, Carbon Brief’s text tracker counts 104 substantive items on the agenda, not including procedural matters, such as the election of COP officials.

The figure below illustrates the status of the COP31 negotiations overall, in a traffic-light format. Each agenda item is colour-coded according to its current status.

(() => { const iframe = document.getElementById('cop31-text-chart'); const iframeOrigin = new URL(iframe.src).origin; window.addEventListener('message', (event) => { if (event.origin !== iframeOrigin || event.source !== iframe.contentWindow) { return; } const message = event.data; if ( !message || message.type !== 'cop31-text-chart:resize' || !Number.isFinite(message.height) || message.height < 0 ) { return; } iframe.style.height = `${Math.ceil(message.height)}px`; }); })();

For topics shown in red, negotiators have not yet managed to put anything down on paper, perhaps because parties have fundamentally different views on how they should proceed.

For items in orange, negotiators are working on an “informal text”, which is an early draft setting out the views of different parties, but not yet expressed in formal legal language.

Once a draft legal agreement becomes available, topics will be colour-coded yellow. At this point, areas of remaining disagreement will be denoted in the text with [square brackets] and “options”.

As such, texts with many square brackets or options tend to be an indicator of a high level of disagreement between parties. For this reason, the tracker table above counts and displays the number of outstanding brackets and options in each document.

During the course of the summit, negotiators may work through many iterations of texts on each agenda item. These documents may include “bridging text”, designed to resolve differences of opinion and to find a “landing zone” that all groups can agree on.

Agreement is reached on a given topic once all brackets and options have been resolved, at which point the item will be coloured green in Carbon Brief’s traffic-light chart.

Where agreement cannot be reached, discussions may be subject to “rule 16”, meaning negotiations are postponed until the next session. These topics are colour-coded grey.

The figure below gives an at-a-glance overview of the status of the main topics up for negotiation.

(() => { const iframe = document.getElementById('cop31-agenda-status'); const iframeOrigin = new URL(iframe.src).origin; window.addEventListener('message', (event) => { if (event.origin !== iframeOrigin || event.source !== iframe.contentWindow) { return; } const message = event.data; if ( !message || message.type !== 'cop31-agenda-status:resize' || !Number.isFinite(message.height) || message.height < 0 ) { return; } iframe.style.height = `${Math.ceil(message.height)}px`; }); })();

As parties narrow down the options and brackets towards the end of each summit, they start to generate “clean” texts, which contain no areas of disagreement and can be converted into “draft decisions” that are ready for formal adoption at the closing plenary of the meeting.

Finally, at the closing plenary, each draft decision must be gavelled through by the COP president, signifying its formal adoption as a legal agreement and outcome of the summit.

This last step is usually a formality, but dramatic exceptions are possible.

During the closing plenary at COP29, the president of the meeting failed to adopt a deal relating to the “global stocktake” from 2023, which had called for “transitioning away” from fossil fuels.

Carbon Brief also ran text trackers for COP28, COP29 and COP30.

Words by Simon Evans. Tracker maintained by Ho Woo Nam.

Interactive: Who wants what at the COP31 climate change summit 02.11.2026 COP31 Antalya Experts: What China wants from the COP31 climate talks 29.10.2026 China policy Interview: COP31 president says electrification is ‘surest way to protect citizens’ 10.07.2026 COP31 Antalya Bonn climate talks: Key outcomes from the June 2026 UN climate conference 19.06.2026 Adaptation

The post Interactive: Tracking negotiating texts at the COP31 climate summit appeared first on Carbon Brief.

Categories: I. Climate Science

COP31 Briefing: What to expect from the Antalya climate summit?

Climate Change News - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 06:09

Here’s an overview of issues to watch as governments, businesses and civil society head to the Turkish seaside resort of Antalya for two weeks of negotiations, leaders’ speeches, panel discussions and initiative launches. 

This is the first COP to be staring an almost certain overshoot of the 1.5C warming limit in the face, even as countries squabble over when the next UN science reports should be delivered. 

The geopolitical mood ahead of the annual talks, from November 9-20, has been sweetened somewhat by Lula’s surprise re-election in Brazil and American voters delivering a thumbs down to climate change-sceptic Donald Trump in the US midterms this week.

Still, neither of those things will make the talks much easier in practice, as fossil fuel-producing emerging economies are unlikely to want to make compromises on issues such as the energy transition and donor nations aren’t expected to turn up with much additional money for helping developing countries deal with worsening climate impacts.

With government budgets squeezed by ongoing conflicts and oil prices riding high after the Strait of Hormuz crisis, there will be a focus on the national benefits of boosting renewables, from a security and cost perspective. This advances the cause of the voluntary electrification goal proposed by Türkiye – which could be one of the biggest headlines from this COP.

Around the venue at COP31 (Photo: UNFCCC/Kiara Worth) How did we get here?

In terms of the mechanics of how COP31 will work, all eyes are on the relationship between the co-hosts Türkiye and Australia. This unusual splitting of the presidency roles wasn’t born out of love, despite the friendly demeanour the country’s two environment ministers displayed at the pre-COP in Fiji.

The deal, for Türkiye to host the COP on its soil and run the non-negotiated Action Agenda side of things while Australia manages the formal negotiations, was reached last year after Ankara steadfastly refused to back down in the face of greater support for its rival. It’s all smiles for now, with Australia backing the Turkish-championed electrification goal and early signalling in Fiji that both COP31 teams will work on producing a COP cover decision, summarising key outcomes and setting the political direction for the year ahead.

Türkiye says it has “final decision” at COP31 despite Australia running negotiations

But what if they disagree on how things are going? That’s where it could get awkward. As we have reported, Türkiye is adamant it will have the final say over what happens in Antalya. Ahead of the COP, the government of President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has been criticised by rights campaigners for cracking down on civil liberties in the country, while COP31 attendees have been warned not to interfere in Türkiye’s internal affairs. Apparently government approval for the traditional COP climate protest due to take place on Saturday is still pending.

The view from Climate Home News

With the opening plenary scheduled for Monday, Australia is doing its best to try to avoid an agenda fight at the start. African countries have submitted requests for additional items including on adaptation finance and trade.

Nepal, which is still struggling with the aftermath of August’s huge flash flood, has also thrown its hat into the ring, requesting an agenda item to kick off a formal work programme on mountains and climate change. A row over what to discuss even before the talks start is never a good look, but it’s unclear how Australia is going to settle this ahead of time.

Later in the week – on November 11 and 12 – the leaders’ segment takes place. The early speaking list shows a relatively low-key turnout, with the few big hitters including Brazil’s Lula, the UK’s Andy Burnham and Spain’s Pedro Sanchez. India and China aren’t sending their top men. We’ll be listening out for whether leaders commit to the electrification goal, national plans for transitioning away from fossil fuels and cutting deforestation, and/or any new pledges of climate finance.

Early speakers’ list suggests few powerful leaders will attend COP31

On the last of these, it’s likely to be slim pickings, with the EU saying it’s coming empty-handed. The Adaptation Fund will be seeking contributions from donor governments as will the new Pacific Resilience Facility. African and other developing countries will push for a number to be put on last year’s vague goal to triple adaptation finance by 2035, as well as talks on how to get there. If rich nations refuse to budge at all, we expect fireworks.

Towards the end of the talks, all eyes will be on the cover decision – what goes into it and what doesn’t. Key elements that could be in there, according to Australia, include some wording on the 1.5C overshoot, the electrification goal, cutting methane emissions, early warning systems, improved access to finance for climate-vulnerable countries and nature-based solutions including more action to protect forests and oceans.

The elephants in the room will be whether and how to incorporate the new global roadmap on transitioning away from fossil fuels into the formal COP outcome and any specification – wanted by the EU, for example – that the new electrification goal should be achieved using largely clean sources of power.

Fossil fuel transition and how to cut emissions

Having seemingly emerged from nowhere, the idea of a global fossil fuel roadmap became a flashpoint at last year’s summit in Belém. After countries fought bitterly over it in the formal negotiations, with only around half of countries in favour, COP30 president André Corrêa do Lago saved the day by promising to produce a voluntary roadmap.

Unveiled on November 3, the 182-page document sets out a voluntary three-stage timetable to 2033. Countries are advised to draw up national transition plans by 2028, in time for the next Global Stocktake, then prioritise building up clean energy in 2029–30, with the main push to cut fossil fuel production coming only from 2030 onwards.

The EU has made clear that the extension of the work programme is one of its priorities for the summit. 

It remains to be seen how the blueprint will be followed up. Brazilian officials have emphasised that it is not a formal document that needs to be negotiated.

But some governments, especially Europe and small island states, might lead a charge to try and include references to it in the COP31 cover decision, expected to be the summit’s main negotiated outcome. Fossil fuel-producing nations, meanwhile, have already made it clear that’s a no-no for them. 

In the formal negotiations, the hottest ticket is the mitigation work programme (MWP) – the dedicated track for discussing emission-cutting measures that’s barely made progress over the years, primarily due to stonewalling from fossil fuel producers like Saudi Arabia and Russia. 

After failing to agree on minimal conclusions last June in Bonn, countries now need to decide in Antalya whether this forum should continue to exist and, if so, in what form. 

The Least Developed Countries (LDCs) and small island developing states want the MWP to continue with a stronger mandate more closely linked with efforts to deliver on the outcomes of the Global Stocktake, which in 2023 called for the transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems. Emerging economies like Saudi Arabia, India and China are likely to fiercely oppose that framing. 

Science row set to rumble on

While it’s not on the negotiating table, climate science could carve out a more prominent place than at recent COPs. The context is stark: the UN now accepts that overshooting warming of 1.5C is unavoidable, and even its most optimistic scenario sees it peak at 1.7C–1.8C around mid-century before falling back again.

Some countries may push for COP31’s headline outcomes to acknowledge the overshoot and call for stronger efforts to limit it. Others may point to it as evidence that the world should abandon 1.5C altogether.

A bigger fight over science has been rumbling on elsewhere, at the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), but it is likely to cast a long shadow over proceedings in Antalya. The UN panel’s last meeting a few weeks ago was suspended after governments failed, for the sixth time, to agree on a timeline for its next flagship assessment. 

A majority of countries want the AR7 set of IPCC reports ready in time for the second global stocktake (GST) of climate action, due to end in November 2028. But a smaller group of developing nations, led by Saudi Arabia, India and Russia, have pushed back claiming this schedule would make it harder for developing-country scientists to contribute. While governments will continue discussions online at an extraordinary IPCC meeting in early December, some might push for the COP31 to send a signal.

One option floated by scientists and policy experts is for the COP31 cover decision to call on the IPCC to deliver its inputs to the GST in good time. And with the dispute now more political than technical, the presidency could use the presence of world leaders and ministers in Antalya to try to broker a deal that has so far eluded their more junior colleagues at the IPCC.

The “Friends of Science” press conference at UN climate talks in Bonn on June 17, 2026. Photo: Marie Jacquemine/Greenpeace) Electrification goal – a bright spot?

­COP31’s flagship initiative to accelerate the electrification of the world’s economy – which is part of the Action Agenda being led by Türkiye – has been criticised for failing to include a commitment to produce the power from clean energy. 

Governments that sign onto the voluntary pledge in Antalya will commit to increasing electricity’s share of total energy consumption to 35% globally by 2035 in line “with pathways consistent with keeping 1.5C alive”, the text put together by the Turkish presidency says.  

The pledge’s text says the electricity goal should be supported by “diverse and sustainable energy sources”, but stops short of explaining what these sources are. The goal is “complementary to efforts to expand renewable energy and improve energy efficiency”, but the “use of clean electricity” will vary according to national circumstances, it adds.

COP31 president Murat Kurum has said that the push to make electrification more “widespread” – through measures like the rollout of electric vehicles and heat pumps –  will “automatically” lead to a reduction in the use of fossil fuels. But many campaigners disagree, criticising the proposed pledge for failing to give an explicit signal on the fossil fuel transition. 

    On Energy Day, on November 10, the Turkish presidency is expected to formally launch its flagship electrification pledge, revealing which countries have signed up. So far, Australia is on the list, and European countries are also likely to back it. India could well be a no, and China’s a maybe. 

    Meanwhile, there are concerns over whether and how the world can meet the goal. Currently electricity’s share of final energy consumption is around 23-24% and to reach the target that will need to grow by around one percentage point a year. But based on current policies, it’s only set to reach 28% by 2035, according to a new analysis by Climate Action Tracker, with transport falling far behind despite rising sales of electric vehicles. 

    Experts highlight the urgency of investing in bolstering grids and storage, especially in developing countries, which have not kept pace with fast-growing renewables capacity.

    A new mechanism for just transition

    A new mechanism to help countries transition to a cleaner world while reducing inequality is set to be one of the main deliverables from the climate summit, as stated by Australia. Civil society groups – which were pivotal in winning last year’s agreement in Brazil to set up a mechanism – want to see it established in Antalya and take shape over the coming year.

    At the mid-year talks in Bonn, countries discussed the design features of the mechanism – including its scope, governance arrangements, structures and functions. The outcome was an informal preliminary note compiling a range of views and possible options. 

    Exactly what the mechanism should cover, and what it should not, remain a contentious subject for governments. For example, the Like-Minded Developing Countries – a bloc of more than 20 low- and middle-income nations including China and India – and the Arab Group oppose it being used to push them to transition away from fossil fuels (TAFF). 

    That contrasts with some Latin American and small island states who want to see the mechanism used as a way of furthering global commitments already made in 2023 on TAFF and tripling renewable energy by 2030. Developed countries, for their part, insist the mechanism should not put responsibility on them to provide new financial support. 

    From Belém to Antalya – gains, gaps and challenges for a new Just Transition Mechanism 

    Some experts want the new Just Transition Mechanism to lay out actions across different parts of the economy – not just to protect workers in the energy sector but also in agriculture and heavy industries. Others say it should be wider-ranging, making sure vulnerable people get a fair share of benefits from the green economy and efforts to build resilience.

    Campaigners, who have nicknamed it the “Belém-Antalya Mechanism” (BAM), have come up with a proposal to keep the thorny issue of how to finance just transitions on the agenda while assuaging concerns that yet another UN fund will be set up and need to be filled at a rather barren time for climate finance. 

    Climate Action Network International is pushing for a “resource mobilisation group” to be created under the BAM, which could explore and develop ways to boost the quantity, quality and governance of finance for just transition around the world, which is currently not well defined or tracked.

    Campaigners call for a Belem Action Mechanism for a just transition (Photo: IISD ENB/Mike Muzurakis) Hunt for more adaptation cash amid surging impacts

    As intensifying climate disasters, including floods, heatwaves and drought, continue to hit poor countries the hardest, calls for funding to help them cope have become central to their demands at the climate talks – and COP31 seems set for a new round of fights on  adaptation issues. 

    In a new letter sent to the UNFCCC, African negotiators have asked for three new items, including adaptation finance, to be added into the formal negotiating agenda. 

    At last year’s COP30, governments agreed to at least triple adaptation finance by a deadline of 2035 but without clarity on the baseline year for tripling, the amount to be delivered, who will pay and the mode of delivery. Countries also agreed to a set of indicators aimed at tracking national efforts to strengthen climate resilience, although these were weakened and cut down from an initial list of 100 to 59 indicators at the last minute. 

    Last week, the chair of the African group, Antwi-Boasiako Amoah, told a media briefing that “nobody is even sure of the [tripling] baseline and then there’s no clarity on the pathways, and so it’s important for us to be able to get some visibility and some credibility in that aspect”.

    Comment: COP31 must deliver finance for Africa or there will be no implementation

    At the mid-year talks in Bonn in June, developed countries, mostly European governments, refused to include a target to triple adaptation finance by 2035 in the decision text for the Global Goal on Adaptation (GGA), casting doubt on their commitment to the goal.

    And on Wednesday, a United Nations report found that, even if developed countries do triple adaptation finance by 2035, it would only meet about a third of developing countries’ needs.

    Other issues up for negotiation on adaptation include deciding on how to put the GGA indicators into practice and where the Adaptation Fund sits within the UN climate architecture, as it needs to be given a mandate to serve the Paris Agreement and receive the proceeds of a 5% levy on UN carbon markets.

    China and Africa keen to talk trade

    China has made clear it wants COP31 to tackle the thorny issue of trade measures that prevent the free flow of cleantech equipment. As the world’s dominant manufacturer of clean energy technologies, this may be unsurprising. How far China is willing to push the issue in Antalya and what it hopes to achieve are less clear, however. 

    The issue is poised to re-surface tensions about the use of tariffs and export controls to regulate the trade of both cleantech and emissions-intensive goods. 

    Tensions set to flare over trade at COP31 as China makes it a priority

    At COP30 in Brazil last year, trade became one of the talks’ most contentious issues after China and large emerging economies lobbied to get “unilateral trade measures” on the agenda – a move mostly targeting the EU’s carbon border levy on high-emission imports. 

    Brazil proposed containing the discussions to a series of dialogues adjacent to the formal negotiations, with initial meetings taking place in Bonn in June. But these have yet to yield practical solutions on a way forward. 

    Once again, observers anticipate trade to surface as one of the most prominent and challenging issues of the talks. The African Group of Negotiators has already requested an agenda item on trade in an effort to tie the ongoing trade dialogues to the formal negotiation process in the next two years, which is bound to get pushback from European countries. 

    Ghanaian diplomat Antwi-Boasiako Amoah is the chair of the African Group. Photo: IISD/ENB – Kiara Worth Support for green industrialisation

    Expanding clean technology manufacturing and decarbonising dirty industries has been creeping up the agenda of UN climate summits and has a prominent place on COP31’s non-negotiated Action Agenda.

    Host Türkiye – which boasts a large industrial economy – made the issue a central pillar of its push to accelerate global emissions cuts to 2035.  

    This includes the launch of a Green Industrialisation Facilitation Mechanism, which aims to help Least Developed Countries (LDCs) capitalise on rapidly expanding renewable energy and cleantech value chains to create jobs and spur economic growth.

    The mechanism isn’t a new financing scheme but aims to help countries turn their industrial priorities into viable projects and connect them with technical expertise and existing finance.

    Separately, an initiative to promote collaboration and exchange between governments, industry and financial institutions on cleantech production and industrial decarbonisation will be launched in Antalya. 

    The Global Green Industrialization Agenda builds on a declaration endorsed by 19 countries in Belém last year, which called for a mechanism to support industrial strategies that are just, sustainable and provide economic opportunities in developing countries. It will be hosted by the UN Industrial Development Organization.  

    Oceans emerge as top nature concern

    With a super El Niño event shattering temperature records beneath the waves and weakening the planet’s largest carbon sink, protecting the ocean is an issue Türkiye and Australia seem to align on.

    The Turkish presidency has ranked it high up its Action Agenda and is preparing a declaration on the topic, while Australia has signalled that a mention of ocean-based climate measures could be included in a cover decision. 

    In the lead-up to COP, a coalition of over 100 nations, including Brazil, the EU and the group of African countries, has called for a strong ocean outcome at COP31. Unlike previous decisions that merely “recognise”  the ocean’s importance, they argue Antalya should deliver a plan for implementation of ocean measures.

    Pacific islands have pushed strongly for this too, and as part of the pre-COP in Fiji, they also launched their own declaration calling for elevating the role of oceans in reducing emissions. Some countries have called for a longer-term process that culminates in the second Global Stocktake.

    Pacific leaders rail at climate finance failures after pre-COP trip to Tuvalu

    Veteran US negotiator Sue Biniaz said the outlook is relatively positive, with strong support from both presidencies and little pushback. Countries should now commit to ocean conservation measures as part of their climate plans, she said, which is something championed by the Blue NDC initiative outside of the formal talks.

    Ilana Seid, the chair of the AOSIS group of small island states, said “the best way we can alleviate stress on the ocean is to transition away from fossil fuels”, which is something the Arab group of nations has warned against discussing in the context of ocean negotiations.

    Unlike last year’s Amazon COP in Belém, action on deforestation has been almost entirely cut out of Türkiye’s Action Agenda. Still, some work has continued towards meeting a global goal of halting deforestation by 2030, including a COP30 presidency roadmap launched on November 3 by Brazilian officials. 

    It outlines a menu of policies – including on protecting standing trees, channeling new finance and planting new forests – to reach the global goal, agreed three years ago in Dubai. Brazilian officials told the roadmap’s launch that it is up to countries to decide how they adopt these recommendations.


    ­

    The post COP31 Briefing: What to expect from the Antalya climate summit? appeared first on Climate Home News.

    Categories: H. Green News

    ECVC and Assembly of the Poor stand together against EU-Thai Free Trade Agreement

    Farmers from Thailand and Europe met to exchange on the dangers of the EU-Thailand Free Trade Agreement, which threatens to be concluded by the end of the year.

    The post ECVC and Assembly of the Poor stand together against EU-Thai Free Trade Agreement appeared first on La Via Campesina - EN.

    Rooted in Territory: How Agroecology and Regenerative Communities Build Resilience

    Navdanya International - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 05:43

    From seed sovereignty to international cooperation, from farms to public spaces: on October 24, a gathering organized by Navdanya International brought grassroots initiatives and institutions into conversation, opening up new possibilities for regenerating the land.

    Food system resilience is now at the heart of the international debate. The climate crisis, biodiversity loss, and growing corporate concentration in the food sector make it urgent to build systems that can not only withstand shocks but also transform. The issue was central to the 54th session of the UN Committee on World Food Security (CFS), held at FAO headquarters in Rome from October 19 to 23, and it will continue to shape discussions in the lead-up to COP31, the UN climate conference taking place in Turkey this November. But how can these policy directions be turned into concrete practice? And what role can communities play?

    These questions gave rise to “Agroecology and Regenerative Communities: Networks of Resilience Among Youth, Schools, Farmers, and Institutions,” an event organized by Navdanya International on October 24 at the Chiostro degli Agostiniani in Bracciano, under the patronage of the Bracciano-Martignano Regional Nature Park Authority. Farmers, researchers, schools, associations, and institutions all came together around a shared principle: resilience grows out of relationships, not isolated efforts.

    The discussion, moderated by Navdanya International’s director Ruchi Shroff, centered on concrete proposals. These included turning public spaces into community hubs, following the example of Officine Municipali, where cultural events on regeneration and resilience could be held and locally grown agroecological products distributed; experimenting with cultures of resilience on public land to create new circular economy supply chains; and launching a digital platform where organizations belonging to the Sustainable Development Forum can share their activities and proposals.

    The event was also an opportunity for Bracciano’s mayor, Marco Crocicchi, to make two important announcements. The first was the opening of a youth center in the same building that houses Officine Municipali. The second was that the process to twin Bracciano with Tubas, a city in the West Bank, is nearly complete, with plans to launch international cooperation projects focused on agroecology.

    One key point emerged from the discussion: the agroecological transition cannot rest on the choices of individual farmers or consumers alone. It requires economic, social, and institutional conditions that make those choices possible. Access to land, support for local economies, valuing local knowledge, and giving communities a say in decisions about their own territory are all deeply interconnected. Building resilience therefore also means strengthening people’s collective capacity to organize, work together, and influence the policies and resources that will shape the future of their territories.

    Seeds, Biodiversity, and Community Self-Reliance

    For agricultural geneticist Salvatore Ceccarelli, protecting biodiversity is the foundation of any path toward regeneration and resilience. In his talk, he traced the shift from systems in which farmers selected, saved, and exchanged their own seeds to an industrial model built on uniform varieties and an increasingly concentrated market. “Uniformity breeds vulnerability,” he said: genetically uniform crops are more exposed to disease and unpredictable weather, and they can require more external inputs.

    Evolutionary populations and participatory plant breeding point to another way forward: giving farmers back an active role in managing seeds and cultivating diversity that can adapt over time. Seed sovereignty is also an economic and democratic issue.

    The link between diversity and self-reliance also came through in the remarks of Caterina Batello, president of the Italian Association of Agroecology (AIDA), who drew attention to the disappearance of small farms and the growing concentration of agricultural activity. The agroecological transition, she argued, means putting farmers back at the center by bringing together research, practical knowledge, fair incomes, and the protection of ecosystems.

    Local Networks, Public Spaces, and Policy

    But transforming food systems takes more than changing farming practices. It also requires building relationships among farmers, citizens, schools, and institutions, and creating the spaces and tools that can sustain community initiatives over time.

    In Bracciano, this approach is taking shape through Terrae Vivae, Navdanya International’s program developed in collaboration with Ecologia – Unione Buddhista Italiana, which weaves together ecological education, agroecology, and community participation. The program brings together schools, farmers, associations, and institutions, creating concrete opportunities for learning and collaboration across the territory.

    This work is already producing tangible results: ecological education workshops in schools, training programs that take students to visit local farms firsthand, initiatives with farmers on biodiversity and the agroecological transition, and forums where farmers, citizens, and institutions can exchange ideas. Officine Municipali marks a further step in this direction, providing a physical space where these relationships can grow stronger and give rise to new shared initiatives.

    Silvia Francescon, of the Italian Buddhist Union spoke about interdependence as the foundation of an ecological vision that recognizes the deep connections between people, nature, and communities. She highlighted the value of the work built up over time, partly through the ability to bring very different groups together, and the importance of shared spaces as places to cultivate relationships, self-reliance, and new possibilities for collective action. She recalled how hard it had been, at the outset, to imagine a network that would one day include government ministries, the municipality, farmers, schools, and associations. As this network grows, she observed, the way public spaces are used and shared matters too: they can become places that build bonds, self-reliance, and new opportunities to act together.

    Bracciano’s mayor, Marco Crocicchi, who has supported Navdanya International’s work in the territory from the start, also reflected on this vision. He described collaboration between the town administration and civil society as an essential way to make the most of the community’s resources.

    For Crocicchi, institutions play a vital role precisely when they recognize that they cannot be the only players. Their task, he said, is to foster connections between different actors, make spaces available, and create the conditions for initiatives to grow on their own and deliver concrete results.

    Officine Municipali in Bracciano is a good example of this collaboration. The town administration restored the public building and opened it to the community, and Navdanya International now serves as its managing partner through a project co-funded by the European Union under the Lazio Region’s 2021-2027 European Social Fund program. With free coworking, cultural events, training, and public meetings, it is fast becoming a hub for participatory planning.

    The mayor stressed that restoring the building would not have been enough on its own. It was the associations and groups that bring it to life that turned it into a space open to everyone. He also announced that new funding will allow a youth center to open on the upper floor, creating more opportunities for people to meet and strengthening the connections between the activities already based there.

    The network also reaches other cultural projects in the territory, including a partnership with the Bracciano International Film Festival. Organized by GASP and the Papermoon collective, the festival brings together different art forms, community participation, and dialogue.

    Mara Cossu and Tiziana Occhino of Italy’s Ministry of Environment and Energy Security (MASE) explored the role institutions can play in building these connections.

    Youth and Territories: Building a Network for Ecological Regeneration

    The discussion with MASE picked up where the morning session left off. That session, a round table titled “Youth and Territories: Collaborative Networks for Ecological Regeneration,” was led by Fernanda Marfil and Lorenzo Maggi of Navdanya International as part of the Ministry-co-funded project “RiGenerAzione Ecologica: Cittadinanza e Partecipazione” (Ecological Regeneration: Citizenship and Participation). Alongside the MASE representatives, participants included FELCOS Umbria, AIESEC Italy, CIMA Foundation, Una Mano per l’Ambiente, Cosmofauna, CRAS, the Bracciano Scout group, and FICS, who together laid the groundwork for a network meant to last well beyond the event. Lorenzo Maggi called the Ministry’s presence “essential,” because it helped the associations understand how to engage with institutions.

    The organizations work at very different scales, but they share a common need: better connections between local initiatives and wider networks. Groups deeply rooted in their territories want more visibility and new partnerships, while those working at the national, international, or institutional level want closer ties with local communities.

    This led to the idea of a shared digital platform, designed to build relationships rather than simply raise visibility. It will be a place to co-design projects, share skills and resources, organize collective training, and keep a common calendar of events and initiatives, while keeping the voices, experiences, and needs of young people and local communities at its heart. Navdanya International has committed to creating and running the platform, and to setting its priorities and ground rules together with the network’s member organizations.

    How can these proposals be sustained beyond individual projects? Ruchi Shroff put this question to the Ministry representatives. Cossu pointed to the value of the work it takes to connect people, institutions, and expertise, work that often goes unrecognized. This ability to build relationships, she noted, is one of the cornerstones of Italy’s National Strategy for Sustainable Development, which funds the project. Institutions, she stressed, must learn to “build spaces and bridges,” creating opportunities for communities to come together and develop a shared vision for their territory.

    Tiziana Occhino stressed the importance of giving these experiences continuity, above all by recognizing the younger generation’s role as stewards of change. Young people, she reminded the audience, “are the present,” and they must be directly involved in shaping social and ecological change. Part of the role of institutions, she added, is to “keep sowing, and help those who are sowing carry the seeds ever farther,” so that local initiatives can take root and become a shared legacy.

    On the agricultural policy front, Silvia Canali of the Ministry of Agriculture, Food Sovereignty and Forestry (MASAF) highlighted the value of territorial processes that bring together farmers, institutions, and citizens. Drawing on the experience of Bio-districts, she underlined the need to move “beyond a purely business-driven, purely production-focused mindset” and build richer forms of collaboration. These districts, she explained, “form networks precisely because of their diversity,” and the wide range of actors involved can become a strength, deepening cooperation and fostering shared paths of territorial development.

    From Farms to Local Supply Chains 

    One of the main reasons for building these networks is the need to support farming and strengthen the local economy. The farmers who shared their experiences showed that the agroecological transition is already a reality on the ground, even as it faces economic, regulatory, and cultural obstacles.

    Elena Carone Fabiani of Fattoria Biologica Le Bricchiette spoke about almost thirty years of organic farming built on seasonality, direct sales, and respect for the territory, and about how the farm is now grappling with the disruption climate change has caused to growing cycles.

    Mariana Donnola of Azienda Agricola La Argentina showed how rotational grazing can help regenerate ecosystems. She also stressed how hard it is to get consumers to appreciate the time, labor, and value that go into food produced this way.

    Andrea Cippitelli of Fattoria Faraoni in Sutri described the farm’s conversion from conventional livestock farming to a pasture-based system. According to the farm’s own data, regenerative management has tripled pasture productivity and raised soil organic matter by two percentage points. Yet in an area dominated by hazelnut monoculture, economic and regulatory hurdles still stand in the way of these practices spreading more widely.

    Showing that a different kind of agriculture is possible, then, is not enough. It also has to be economically viable and linked to distribution models that guarantee fair prices for farmers and access to good-quality food for everyone.

    The Anguillara Solidarity Purchasing Group (GAS), active since 2009, is working toward exactly that. It has built direct relationships with farmers and has since expanded its commitment by founding a Renewable and Solidarity Energy Community, a clear example of how networks built around food can help create new forms of solidarity economy and shared management of resources.

    The day itself made this connection between farmers and consumers tangible. Throughout the event, produce from the territory’s agroecological farms was served in the cloister, offering a real taste of the short supply chains that local networks can help strengthen.

    Education, Culture, and Youth Stewardship 

    Keeping these initiatives going over time also depends on involving the younger generation. Schools are an essential part of the network, bringing together knowledge, professional skills, and the territory’s farms and businesses.

    Through Terrae Vivae, ecological education programs and school-to-work training take students out into the fields and onto farms, linking classroom learning with hands-on experience. Alessio Fiorucci of the Salvo D’Acquisto agricultural high school in Bracciano spoke about the value of the activities carried out with local farms and how the work will continue with a new program focused on seeds and biodiversity.

    The arts high school at IIS Luca Paciolo contributed “Ars non dat Panem,” an installation exploring bread as food, memory, and cultural heritage. Professor Ravaioli presented the project she developed with her students and fellow teacher Patrizia Santoro, while Professor Giuseppina Tessitore, the school’s site coordinator, spoke about schools’ educational responsibility to encourage informed choices.

    From Bracciano to Tubas: Resilience as Solidarity

    Relationships built at the local level can also lay the groundwork for new forms of international cooperation, linking communities that are geographically distant but share the need to defend their territories and resources.

    With this in mind, Mayor Marco Crocicchi announced that Italy’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs has given its approval for the twinning of Bracciano with Tubas, a Palestinian city in the West Bank. The project grew out of the Cantiere di Pace (Peace Workshop), one of the participatory initiatives run by the town administration, and aims to build a lasting relationship between the two communities, potentially including collaboration on farming and agroecology.

    Giacomo Rossetti of GASP (Gruppo di Assistenza e Solidarietà Popolare) described how local associations have helped drive the initiative and keep public attention on the conditions facing the Palestinian population. Access to land and water, the ability to keep farming, and the chance to build cooperative ties are all crucial to daily life in Tubas.

    In this context, Ceccarelli also emphasized the importance of seed sovereignty: taking a community’s seeds away strikes at its memory, its identity, and its future. He also raised the possibility of recovering Palestinian varieties preserved in germplasm collections. In this way, cooperation between territories can bring together solidarity, the defense of rights, and ecological regeneration.

    From Dialogue to Action

    The event set out to do more than compare experiences: it aimed to launch a shared program of work. The proposals that emerged point to a few concrete priorities: strengthening direct relationships between farmers and citizens, experimenting with agroecological practices and local supply chains, making public spaces into places for participation, and keeping young people involved in decisions that affect their territory.

    Spaces, production, and markets are not three separate initiatives. They can become parts of a single circular economy strategy, one that creates new opportunities, regenerates ecosystems, and strengthens the territory’s resilience.

    The challenge now is to turn these ideas into collective action, working with everyone involved to identify priorities, the resources needed, and shared responsibilities. The work begun through Terrae Vivae and Officine Municipali offers a solid starting point. The aim is not to replace the initiatives already active in the territory, but to bring them into closer connection with one another.

    Lucio Cavazzoni, president of the Bio-district of the Bolognese Apennines, also sent a message to the gathering. Cavazzoni is one of the founders of Terra Comune: terra non guerra (Common Land: Land, Not War), an alliance that brings together farming, environmental, and social organizations, bio-districts, trade unions, and Solidarity Purchasing Groups. He called for collaboration that is “more concrete, more hands-on, and without borders,” building cooperation “not on the land or against the land, but with the land,” and urged the mayors present to promote large bio-districts open to everyone’s participation.

    As Ruchi Shroff emphasized, “the real future of food begins in our territories,” through processes that connect farmers, schools, young people, associations, and institutions. Stig Tanzmann of the German organization Brot für die Welt (Bread for the World), who joined the event after taking part in the CFS sessions at FAO, also drew this link between the local and the global: “States must listen to voices from the grassroots, from the territories.” Community experiences must be able to help shape international policy, and commitments made in negotiations must translate into tools that genuinely support the agroecological transition.

    Photo Credits: Navdanya International – Photos 5 and 7: Gabriele Albarello

    Categories: A3. Agroecology

    France’s student strikes

    Tempest Magazine - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 05:00

    French students have been protesting in the largest numbers since the historic May 1968 Paris uprising. Protests began last month in Paris’s northern suburbs, where students have struggled to learn in crumbling, pest-infested schools with too few teachers. Students say the government’s latest budget isn’t enough to fix the school system’s failings, and they are demanding more. Public anger over the budget and abysmal school conditions has spread—and so have the protests; students have been blocking high schools and protesting in the streets in the thousands. The government’s response has been heavy-handed and violent; there have been many recorded incidents of police brutality against young and vulnerable high school students. On Saturday, Oct 17th, 550,000 students, parents, educators, and trade unionists across the country flooded the streets to demand drastic, immediate improvements to the school system.

    Laurent (pseudonym) is a 35-year-old Information Technology teacher in a public school located in a city in Brittany, France. The students at his school are not currently on strike, but have held a few small rallies in solidarity with striking students across the country. I spoke with him to get his impressions as a public educator witnessing student protests from inside the country.

    Danielle Bullock: What is currently happening in your school? Are students on strike?

     

    Laurent: I work in a school near the city of Rennes, and there’s not a lot of protest here (in my school) for basically two reasons. One being that most of our students come from a sort of wealthier background, and they are not that involved in politics because they don’t have to be. So we just have a smaller number of students who are really involved in politics.

    And one other factor is most students come in with the bus. So when they arrive, it’s just two minutes before classes begin. So you can’t quite block your high school if you don’t arrive one hour before. So what we have, what the director of (my) school said is, it’s okay to protest in front of the building, but everyone who wants to come in has to be able to come in. So what we had the first few days (of the student strike) was one to two hundred students in front of the high school protesting. But my high school has 1,200 students. So mid-range in terms of size.

    Starting the second day, most of the students were still back in school because parents had to write a note saying their kid was on strike. They had to justify why the kids were not at school. And so we had one or two days with sort of a bigger protest in front of the high school, and ever since, almost nothing. The fact that students come to our school by bus is really a huge factor. In the nearby city (Rennes), there are a lot more protests at the high schools, and those schools are completely blocked. And there’s also quite a bit of vandalism. Because it’s a city where, historically, whenever there is a protest, there is a lot of stuff that is destroyed and vandalized. So with this high school movement, it sort of follows the same trends.

    DB: And the university students in Rennes, are they on strike in solidarity?

     

    L: We have two big universities in Rennes. Big for France —they’re not the same size as American universities. There’s one (university) for science and one more for literature and politics and everything.

    And the one that teaches literature and foreign languages is always on strike whenever there’s something. So this time as well, they blocked the university. I didn’t hear much about the scientific one, the scientific university. Also, because the campus is really large, it’s really hard to block anything. There are dozens of buildings, smaller buildings. So I didn’t hear much from them, but I know that at the literature one, the students went on strike as well.

    DB: What do you think is the main reason why the students are on strike?

     

    L: It’s quite difficult, actually, because it started as really a local thing because there are some high schools, especially near Paris, that are in really complete disrepair. And their first ask was: we want to be able to study in good conditions. For example, we want classrooms that aren’t 8 degrees Celsius (40º F) in the winter and 40 degrees Celsius (104º F) in the summer. We want teachers because when teachers are absent, or there are vacancies, there are no substitutes. We want chairs for everyone. We want tables for everyone, which is not quite the case in all of these (schools).

    Some high schools, especially near Paris, are in really complete disrepair. And [the student strikers’] first ask was: we want to be able to study in good conditions.

    But it’s quite a small number of high schools that have these sorts of issues. And these demands, I’ve been hearing about them for years now. And so the students started to do a bit of protesting. This time it went directly to blocking the high school because, back in my days as a high school student, first it was a protest in the street, and then, if nothing happened, we blocked the high school. This time they went with blocking first.

    With social media, there have been some videos of bins burning in front of high schools. Also, one big factor was that the political answer [to the strikers’ actions] was to send the police, and heavily armored police, directly. This really escalated the protests from the start. There have also been some videos of police violence against (what are) basically kids, and this is over social media, so it’s really spread rather quickly, which inspired other students who saw the videos and said, okay, we want to be part of that as well, and began to protest.

     

    DB: And what are the consequences of students not going to school if they were on strike?

     

    L: Where I am, there are no consequences. I mean, since most students go to class, the main consequence is that they don’t attend, so they fall a bit behind. But as far as I know, in my high school, the director is really more into dialogue. So he will let them speak if they want to speak. And if they want to protest, they can, as long as they don’t destroy anything. So where I am, the strategy is really not escalation at all. It’s just, okay, you want to protest? We will give you a place where to protest. They’re in dialogue with the director to talk about any issues, but the thing is, most of the demands are at a country level. So the director, he can’t do anything about these demands.

    When there’s no dialogue, of course, tension is building. And at some point, it has to burst.

     

    DB: Why did it have to come to this point where people are so angry? Students are so angry.

     

    L: The thing is that the students from the first high schools near Paris, they said we have been asking nicely for years, and we’re only heard when we start burning stuff. The current president has been ignoring what people in the streets have to say from the beginning. He’s never tried to discuss what people depend on. And even François Hollande before him, whenever there was a huge protest, he would send the police and just try to intimidate as much as possible.

    So basically, there is no dialogue between what people ask for and the government, and it’s been the case for ten to fifteen years now. That’s basically why everything’s coming to this point, because when there’s no dialogue, of course, tension is building. And at some point, it has to burst.

     

    DB: What is the general opinion of teachers about what’s going on with the strikes?

     

    L: I’ve been talking with colleagues. I mean, teachers, as everyone, have different political opinions. And people who are more on the right, to the far-right side, they support the police and (they think) all these kids should go back to school. [They say] they’re ridiculous, their demands are childish, and they should go back home or go back to school.

    From a more left point of view, I mean, of course, we support what they ask for. Because basically what they want is better conditions to work in. So the demands are not quite localized [some demands are more generalized and appeal to wider layers]. For example, there are also huge school days, 8 a.m. to 6 p.m., with big gaps in the middle, so really exhausting for students. Some of them have a one-hour drive to go to school and the same to go back home, and they are completely exhausted.

    Another thing is, after high school, there is a system, a platform (Parcoursup), where you register if you want to go on to higher education. And since the supply for higher education in France is not enough to meet the demand, there’s a lot of frustration about that system and that platform. And we can understand that this platform creates a lot of stress because it looks at old school reports for the entire high school [career]. So every bad grade, even two or three years before the end of high school, can mean that you have a worse report and mean that you cannot really get into the school [college] you want. So it’s a lot of pressure for a long time for the students, and that we can empathize with. So we support the demands.

    Then there are basically two categories of teachers. Some who say, we’re in France, and in France, if you want to get something, you really never get anything unless you break stuff first. So we’re really, yeah, there’s some vandalism, but that’s France; that’s how it is. And some others who are like, yeah, we support the demands, but it would be really better if there weren’t that much vandalism. So basically, you have the two opinions from what I’ve been seeing around me, my colleagues.

     

    DB: Have any of the teachers’ unions made statements in support of student strikes?

     

    L: You have unions that are more on the right side and many of them that are more on the left side, but there’s the one big one and a lot of smaller ones, which are still quite big.

    And we have the choice every couple of years. There are some elections to see which are the bigger unions and how they should be taken into account with the secretary of education. [This determines which union] will have a bigger voice speaking with the secretary of education. So in France, teachers can go on strike if a union calls for it. And almost instantaneously, they all said, okay, starting now, you can go on strike. We cover you.

     

    DB: So—teachers can go on strike as well as students?

     

    L: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

     

    DB: When you say the union will “cover you”, what do you mean?

     

    L: They [the union] have to say, “We declare that there is a strike starting now. So that if we don’t go to work, it will be considered as participating in that strike instead of just, oh, I decided I don’t want to go to work.

     

    DB: Right, but teachers—there will be no other consequences for teachers?

     

    L: Right, so you won’t get paid, but you won’t lose your job, or you won’t have any kind of penalty. That’s how strikes work in France. You need the union that will say, ” Okay, as a union, we decided to go on strike.” And then every worker is included in that; we don’t have to provide proof that we are part of that union. We can just participate in that strike.

     

    DB: What are the teachers’ main complaints? If teachers had to say what the worst thing about French schools is, what do you think they would say?

     

    L: Oh, there’s a lot. Because the first strike for us this year was a week before the student strike started. Because basically, the prime minister announced his plan for next year’s budget. And in that budget, it was said that the pay would remain exactly the same. So basically, it means that we lose money because of inflation. And it’s been the case for basically years now. It started in the 80s. This difference between what we’re actually paid and inflation doesn’t follow exactly. And it means 20 to 30 percent pay cuts compared to what it was in the 80s. So it’s quite huge. That’s basically one major grievance—that teachers in France are quite underpaid. And so much so that there are a lot of problems recruiting new teachers.

     

    DB: In comparison to how much they pay police, do teachers make more or less?

     

    L: Yeah. The thing is, there’s one major difference that will make comparison quite hard—the level of qualification is really not the same. So if you were a teacher in France until recently, you needed five years of education, a master’s degree. And to become a police officer, you just need to have finished high school. So the bar is really lower. I would say police officers get slightly higher pay.  I don’t know quite all the details, but at least in the beginning, their pay is better.

     

    DB: So less qualifications, better pay.

     

    L: There’s probably way more teachers than there are police officers in France, because almost everything is public. I think there are 800,000 teachers in France. So it’s quite huge. So if you want to raise their pay, it’s billions [of dollars]. Even if the increase isn’t really high, it’s billions instantly. It’s in this context that the state doesn’t have much money; it’s quite hard [for the state] to increase our pay. And the unions, they say, we will not negotiate a pay increase without also negotiating working conditions. Because what we had a couple of years ago, our secretary said, ” Yeah, so we will give you a pay increase.”  But what he did basically was create another way for us to do extra hours, which would then get paid, which is not quite the same as, okay, you’re getting a pay increase. No, it’s an increase in labor too.

    And then a lot of things go with that. Since the pay is not quite good, we have trouble recruiting. So in many places, there aren’t enough teachers. So basically, in these places, in the places where people don’t want to go, there aren’t many teachers. And there aren’t many substitute teachers who are real [credentialed] teachers.  There were some posts on eBay, yeah, we need a teacher. You need 15 minutes in front of someone who will say, ” Okay, you’re good. You can go in front of students,” and that is the whole process. That’s how the substitute teachers are recruited in some places. So the quality is really, it can be good because some of them can be good, but there’s no guarantee that the people who are in front of the students are any good at all. But many substitute teachers aren’t being hired right now. They’re not putting them in a classroom.

     

    DB: So what happens to a class when there’s no teacher?

     

    L: If the teacher gets sick, the class is canceled. There are two things. If the teacher is away for less than two weeks, they won’t even search for a replacement because it’s too difficult. If the teacher is away long enough and substitute teachers are available, you can ask for one.

     

    DB: So if somebody just gets sick, you get the flu, and you are out for five days, there’s no class. So what do students do when there’s no class?

     

    L: Yeah, usually in high school, they have some rooms where they can sort of relax and/or work if they want to. But if the high school is in a really bad state, maybe those rooms are quite horrible, or they don’t exist. So the inequalities are there as well. And no work for the students is provided.

     

    DB: How many students do you have at the most in a class?

     

    L: Classes go up to 35, 36, and that’s one of the reasons why I have a lot of students. The demand is that, okay, when we are having a full class all together, 35, 36 is way too many for one teacher to teach properly, so we want smaller groups.

    Because the state says teachers cost too much and cut the number of teachers, this led to bigger classes, even though the number of kids was rising at the time. Now we have the opportunity [to correct this] because people are having fewer kids, and the number of students in middle school and high school is slowly decreasing. And so basically there are two options. Either you keep the number of teachers the same, and you have smaller classes, or you decrease the number of teachers to follow the decrease in students.

    And there’s a big issue about how much we want to spend on education in France. That’s basically the one thing: what place we want to give education in our spending. And the politics that have been in France for many years is—we try to not invest much in public stuff.

    And yeah, probably private will develop. Oh, we’ll see. And that’s [true] for teaching, that’s [true] for health, that’s for most of the justice as well; it’s been underfunded for years now. All the public sector, except maybe police because there’s always money for police, and the army. But other than that, all the public sector, it’s been quite underfunded for years now. But that’s a choice that we have to make as a society.

     

    DB: How do you think the student strikes will be resolved?

     

    L: Unfortunately, after the riots last Saturday, I don’t have much hope for a happy ending. The videos of vandalism are everywhere to be seen, and they completely eclipsed the legitimate claims from the students. In the news, it feels like it sparked a bigger movement, and we’ll see if the students can keep their own strikes without huge interference from anyone else. In case of interference, the political right asks for a lot more police repression (against protesters).

    Opinions expressed in signed articles do not necessarily represent the views of the editors or the Tempest Collective. For more information, see “About Tempest Collective.”
    Featured Image credit: FreCha; modified by Tempest.

    The post France’s student strikes appeared first on Tempest.

    Categories: D2. Socialism

    Sewage bacteria generate electricity while destroying antibiotics

    Anthropocene Magazine - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 05:00

    Sewage is full of organic matter that can be a source of energy. But it also carries harmful chemicals as well as leftover medicines that conventional treatment methods can’t remove easily.

    Researchers now report a technology that can solve three sewage-related problems at the same time. Their new device uses bacteria in wastewater to generate electricity while breaking down a hard-to-degrade antibiotic and producing a valuable industrial chemical. The team published their results in Journal of Power Sources.

    There have been plenty of research efforts to harness microbes for treating wastewater while producing renewable energy. The approach uses microbial fuel cells, which are battery-like devices with two electrodes.

    In microbial fuel cells, bacteria grow on an electrode and devour organic matter, converting chemical energy into electrons, which flow in an external circuit to produce electricity. Then those electrons meet oxygen at the other electrode to create water.

    Turns out that microbial fuel cells usually generate very small amounts of electricity. “So we asked a different question: What else could those electrons do when they arrive?,” writes the team from the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research-Advanced Materials and Processes Research Institute in Science X Dialog.

     

    .IRPP_ruby , .IRPP_ruby .postImageUrl , .IRPP_ruby .centered-text-area {height: auto;position: relative;}.IRPP_ruby , .IRPP_ruby:hover , .IRPP_ruby:visited , .IRPP_ruby:active {border:0!important;}.IRPP_ruby .clearfix:after {content: "";display: table;clear: both;}.IRPP_ruby {display: block;transition: background-color 250ms;webkit-transition: background-color 250ms;width: 100%;opacity: 1;transition: opacity 250ms;webkit-transition: opacity 250ms;background-color: #eaeaea;}.IRPP_ruby:active , .IRPP_ruby:hover {opacity: 1;transition: opacity 250ms;webkit-transition: opacity 250ms;background-color: inherit;}.IRPP_ruby .postImageUrl {background-position: center;background-size: cover;float: left;margin: 0;padding: 0;width: 31.59%;position: absolute;top: 0;bottom: 0;}.IRPP_ruby .centered-text-area {float: right;width: 65.65%;padding:0;margin:0;}.IRPP_ruby .centered-text {display: table;height: 130px;left: 0;top: 0;padding:0;margin:0;padding-top: 20px;padding-bottom: 20px;}.IRPP_ruby .IRPP_ruby-content {display: table-cell;margin: 0;padding: 0 74px 0 0px;position: relative;vertical-align: middle;width: 100%;}.IRPP_ruby .ctaText {border-bottom: 0 solid #fff;color: #0099cc;font-size: 14px;font-weight: bold;letter-spacing: normal;margin: 0;padding: 0;font-family:'Arial';}.IRPP_ruby .postTitle {color: #000000;font-size: 16px;font-weight: 600;letter-spacing: normal;margin: 0;padding: 0;font-family:'Arial';}.IRPP_ruby .ctaButton {background: url(https://www.anthropocenemagazine.org/wp-content/plugins/intelly-related-posts-pro/assets/images/next-arrow.png)no-repeat;background-color: #afb4b6;background-position: center;display: inline-block;height: 100%;width: 54px;margin-left: 10px;position: absolute;bottom:0;right: 0;top: 0;}.IRPP_ruby:after {content: "";display: block;clear: both;}Recommended Reading:Designer bacteria clean wastewater and generate power—at the same time

     

    If all the electrons don’t combine with oxygen and hydrogen at the second electrode, the product is hydrogen peroxide instead of water. Hydrogen peroxide is a household chemical used for disinfection and bleaching. It is also used widely in chemical manufacturing. The chemical industry makes it today using an energy- and chemical-intensive process in large plants.

    To get the right reaction in the microbial fuel cell, the researchers designed a new electrode. They embedded iron and nickel oxides on a flexible carbon fiber cloth. When they heated the cloth in the presence of acetylene at 800°C, a forest of carbon nanofibers grew out of it. “The metal particles rode the growing fibers upward, so every fiber ended with a metal oxide tip,” the researchers say.

    So the electrode has conductive fibers with a catalytic tip. And bacteria cling to this rough conductive surface and form a thick film.

    The team used the same electrodes on both side of the fuel cell. When they ran sewage spiked with the antibiotic chloramphenicol through the cell, it removed 99.99% of the drug while producing hydrogen peroxide in two days.

    “Next, we plan to run it longer, test other drugs, check the toxicity of the breakdown products and link several cells in series to raise the power,” the team writes. “So can dirty water help pay for its own cleanup? Not completely yet. But in two days, our system turned sewage into cleaner water, a useful chemical and a little electricity.”

    Source: Yashmeen Budania et al. In-situ CVD grown FeO & NiO CNF electrode for integrated antibiotic degradation, peroxide production, and bioenergy generation in microbial fuel cells. Journal of Power Sources, 2026.

    Image: ©Anthropocene Magazine (AI-generated)

     

    Burniston pledges to fight Europa fracking appeal

    DRILL OR DROP? - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 04:40

    Councillors in the North Yorkshire village of Burniston said today they would continue to stand by their community in the face of an appeal over gas drilling and lower-volume fracking.

    Extract from joint statement on Europa Oil & Gas appeal.
    Full document at the end of this article

    The company behind the scheme, Europa Oil & Gas, gave notice earlier this week that it would challenge the refusal of its planning application. It informed the stock market yesterday.

    In a joint statement, Burniston Parish Council and the area’s North Yorkshire councillor, Derek Bastiman, said:

    “Although the intention to appeal comes as no surprise, we are somewhat concerned that EOG [Europa Oil & Gas] have not listened in any way to the serious concerns that over 1,600 people expressed during the planning process.

    “If it is possible to find a suitable, safe place for fracking and the underground dumping of chemicals, so close to where people live, we would be very surprised. We can say with great certainty, it is not here.”

    The statement, signed by the parish council chair, Cllr Richard Parsons, and Cllr Bastiman, said the refusal of the planning application by North Yorkshire Council in May 2026 was “clear and absolute”.

    It added:

    “No-one, including Europa Oil and Gas ltd, were left in any doubt as to why the application was refused.”

    North Yorkshire’s planning committee rejected the application on five grounds, despite a recommendation from officials to approve. The grounds for refusal were:

    • Harm to the heritage coast and landscape
    • Proximity to homes and impact on amenity
    • Harm to the setting of the North York Moors
    • Impact on tourism and lack of economic gain
    • Conflict with council climate commitments

    The statement added:

    “The objections to this application were overwhelming and were clearly listened to by the Planning Committee. The words that were submitted were clear, they were accurate and they were precise. Many mistakes and missing information in the application were exposed. The planning committee listened, understood and delivered their decision in the most decisive manner.”

    Cllr Parsons said:

    “Cllr. Bastiman, myself and Burniston Parish Council stand absolutely alongside our community as a whole. We will continue to ensure that the voices of our communities are heard. We will continue to represent those voices. We listen to, understand and agree with the views of our community and the wider community. They reject the application in its entirety for all the right reasons.

    “Nothing has changed, the refused application is still the same, the grounds for refusal remain as valid today, as they were six months ago. We expect the planning inspector, even if the request to hear this appeal is granted, to support the decision of the planning committee.

    “The application was for a fracking process that has been shown to be far from safe. This is the wrong project, at the wrong time, in the wrong place.”

    The statement said the parish council had been notified about the appeal “in what appears to be a rather unconventional manner”:

    “No formal notice appears to have been received, just a laminated card attached to a public noticeboard in Burniston Village, by Europa Oil and Gas Ltd informing of the appeal and requiring ‘representations about this appeal’ by November 25th 2026.”

    The Planning Inspectorate (PINS), which handles planning appeals, told DrillOrDrop that Europa’s notice, was part of a formal procedure, known as DMPO (Development Management Procedure Order) 2015.

    This requires appellants to give 21 days’ notice of the appeal to any owners or tenants of the site.

    The appeal will then be submitted to PINS, where it will be validated.

    PINS will set out a timetable for the appeal process.

    The local planning authority, North Yorkshire Council, must then notify all interested parties about the appeal and give them a deadline in which to submit written representations.

    That date has not been set and is separate from the 21-day deadline mentioned on Europa’s notice.

    261105 Burniston joint press releaseDownload
    Categories: G2. Local Greens

    The Clock is Ticking for TFFF: Will COP31 Deliver Where COP30 Failed?

    Global Forest Coalition - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 04:29
    Lula’s victory has saved the Tropical Forest Forever Facility (TFFF) for now, but its reliance on private investment, Global South debt, and dubious governance means that it is still a false solution for forests, regardless of who is in power in Brazil. 

    This article was originally published by Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung

    By Valentina Figuera Martínez and Oli Munnion

    The re-election of Lula da Silva in Brazil’s presidential race is a huge victory for progressive politics in Latin America, narrowly avoiding descent once more into the chaos of the far-right Bolsonaro dynasty. Lula’s decisive win is also a victory against U.S. interventionism, and the Trump Administration’s efforts to impose its political, neocolonial and military dominance across the region.

    However, one consequence of the result is that a lifeline has been thrown to the Tropical Forest Forever Facility (TFFF), a new and highly controversial forest finance scheme championed by the Brazilian government. A Bolsonaro victory would undoubtedly have been the final nail in the coffin for TFFF, a silver lining to an otherwise very big, dark cloud.

    The TFFF is still on life support though—it has until the end of the year to secure USD 10 billion in initial funding, which it has so far failed to do, or face key investors such as the Norwegian government pulling out, regardless of whether Lula or Bolsonaro sit in the presidential chair.
    This makes COP31 make or break for TFFF. Although not on the formal agenda of the UN climate negotiations, the scheme’s backers will be desperately seeking additional pledges in the corridors of the Antalya conference centre.

    What Went Wrong in Belém?

    Alongside the failure of COP30 in Belém, Brazil, to establish a binding roadmap to end deforestation, the TFFF also fell short of its promise to secure the “future of tropical forests”. Brazil’s flagship financing scheme had attracted only USD 6.7 billion in sponsor capital, well below the USD 25 billion initially required to operate at a full scale.

    What it did attract was widespread opposition from civil society and Indigenous Peoples’ organisations. Messaging against TFFF featured prominently in demonstrations in Belém, and a statement rejecting TFFF and defending forest rights was signed by 205 organisations, many of which were participating in counter-mobilisations.1

    The plan had been to use the USD 25 billion in sponsor capital to issue up to USD 100 billion of “senior market debt” (low interest rate, high repayment priority loans and bonds), at a one to four leverage, to build a total investment fund of USD 125 billion.

    This sum would then be invested by the fund at a higher rate of return in order to generate an anticipated revenue of USD four billion per year, which would be paid to tropical forest countries in exchange for conserving one billion hectares of standing tropical forests.

    In Belém, sponsor capital pledges from the Global North included Norway’s USD 3 billion, Germany’s €1 billion (USD 1.15 billion), and France’s €500 million (USD 577 million), totalling USD 4.7 billion, all with specific conditions and strings attached.

    So far, more than a quarter of TFFF funds come from countries that are supposed to be its main beneficiaries

    Brazil and Indonesia, which are two of the three largest tropical forest countries, committed USD one billion each in sponsor capital. That means that so far, more than a quarter of TFFF funds come from countries that are supposed to be its main beneficiaries.

    In addition to these five countries, very small pledges from the Netherlands (USD 5 million), Portugal (USD 1 million), and the Minderoo Foundation (USD 10 million) brought the total to USD 6.7 billion, although this sum isn’t available immediately due to several of the conditions imposed.2

    Since then, other pledges have trickled in, such as the UK’s £400 million (approximately USD 534 million), and another USD 500 million from the Netherlands post-election, taking the total to USD 7.8 billion. At the same time though, Europe’s steady march to the right and cooling of climate commitments has put some pledges in doubt. A member of the German Chancellor’s CDU budget committee has argued that Germany’s €1bn investment is hard to justify and should be removed from the 2027 national budget.

    A “once-in-a-generation initiative (…) via an innovative financing mechanism” was promised, but what is the financial logic behind the TFFF and will it tackle the underlying drivers of deforestation? Let’s start at the beginning.

    Whose Proposal Is It?

    The Brazilian government claims that the TFFF is led by Global South tropical forest countries. In reality, it is a proposal written by bankers for bankers, and was conceived of in the Global North under the leadership of the World Bank.

    One of its earliest iterations was a set of four papers published in 2018 by the Center for Global Development (CGD) under the title “Creating a Multilateral Wealth Fund for a Global Public Good: A Proposal for a Tropical Forest Finance Facility”. Among the authors is Kenneth Lay, former vice president and treasurer of the World Bank from 2006 to 2010. Other Global North contributors are cited, as well as officials from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank.

    However, there is no mention of Brazil, Indonesia or the Democratic Republic of the Congo in this initial documentation, and the participation of these tropical forest countries and the subsequent leadership of the Brazilian government have come later, giving legitimacy to the scheme.

    A Neo-Colonial Economic Model Underlies the TFFF

    According to the 2018 version of the scheme,

    “TFFF is a proposal to mobilise significant low-cost resources which can be invested in private markets to generate a financial return for rewarding successful actions that contribute to achieving a global goal, reduced deforestation. (…) Utilising primarily public funds to generate investment profits from the private sector that in turn provide international finance for public goods could serve to move beyond the finite borders of overseas development aid.”

    From its inception, the intention was clear: the TFFF was designed to use limited public funds to leverage much larger private investments in order to generate profit for wealthy investors and claim to contribute to “halting deforestation”. A convenient formula for limiting public contributions and maximising private returns, while claiming deforestation benefits in the Global South.

    This original 2018 financial logic has been revived in the three concept notes subsequently presented by the Brazilian government3, which hinge on: 1) converting money borrowed from wealthy investor countries and companies into profit that can be used to “drive change in developing countries”; and 2) distributing these funds using a results-based aid approach once pre-agreed measurable outcomes are achieved.

    In essence, it reproduces a neo-colonial and technocratic dynamic.

    In essence, it reproduces a neo-colonial and technocratic dynamic that privileges “measurable outcomes” over lived realities, reducing complex social, cultural, and ecological factors to narrow metrics. What is easy to measure tends to be prioritised over what matters most, sidelining gender justice, Indigenous governance systems, collective rights, structural drivers of inequality and other forms of environmental harm beyond deforestation.

    TFFF is presented as a “country-led” approach, but reinforces a paternalistic mindset in which donors and Global North actors “drive change” in the Global South, rather than addressing historical responsibility for climate breakdown, ecological harm, colonial crimes, and debt injustices.

    The TFFF is seen by its proponents as a unique opportunity to kill two birds with one stone, allowing private investors to make money and secure corporate greenwashing by reporting their alleged “contributions” to ‘Net Zero commitments’ and ‘nature positive finance’, such as the Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures (TNFD)4. All of which have been denounced by civil society as controversial schemes to perpetuate corporate abuses, human rights violations and environmental crimes.

    Who is Really Funding the Fund?

    One of the most concerning aspects of the scheme is its heavy reliance on bond markets for Global South debt. In essence, the money used to “protect” tropical forests will be largely paid for by countries in the Global South, through debt servicing and payments to wealthy international investors. As the Third World Network has warned, the real financing will come from “developing countries themselves, disguised by the international capital markets as ‘natural’ return on investments”.

    This reflects a perverse money-machine logic: the TFFF will borrow billions of dollars from sponsors and wealthy investors at a lower interest rate, and then invest those resources heavily in emerging market bonds, issued, for example, by highly indebted Global South countries or companies driving deforestation that need immediate liquidity, at a higher rate of return. These emerging market bonds are issued at higher interest rates as they are judged to involve higher risk for the lender (in this case, the TFFF), as it is assumed, for example, that Global South borrowers are more likely to default.

    The TFIF will make its money through deepening the debt crisis and insolvency in the Global South.

    The profit generated through this difference in interest rates (and often unjust assessment of risk) will then be used primarily to repay lenders, cover World Bank fees, and service interest on sponsor capital. Only if there are profits left over following these transactions would any funds actually be transferred to tropical forest countries. Therefore, the TFIF will make its money through deepening the debt crisis and insolvency in the Global South, at a time when debt levels are already unprecedented.

    Merel van der Mark, Forests and Finance Coalition Coordinator and an expert on financial mechanisms, has made the link between a failure of the Global North to pay what is owed when it comes to climate and biodiversity finance, and the shift towards private finance to make up the shortfall.

    In an interview given for this article, she explains how

    “for years and years, tropical forest countries have asked for support from richer countries, for the protection of their forests. But rich countries have failed to mobilise the amounts that are needed to achieve real forest protection.”

    “So the TFFF seems to me a sad acknowledgement that rich countries are not doing their part, and that the only way to mobilise them to allocate money to forest protection is if they get their money back, with interest. So in that sense, I think that TFFF does not mobilise finance in an equitable way.”

    Deforestation as a Market Failure

    The TFFF’s rationale is that by valuing standing tropical forests, the fund will address a “market failure” by assigning a value to, and paying for, the “ecosystem services” provided by tropical forests, thereby incentivising their protection over their destruction or degradation. The financialisation of nature is therefore the proposal’s driving force, where forests are turned into a market value that can generate returns, prioritising capital accumulation above human rights, ecosystem integrity, and all other considerations.

    This poses a profound contradiction: the dominant economic system that turns nature into a financial asset is destroying the cultures, practices, rights and relationships to territories of Indigenous Peoples, local communities, women, and youth—the commodification of nature is therefore not compatible with respecting the interdependent complexities that make up an ecosystem.5

    The structural drivers of deforestation are precisely the same commodity supply chains and industrial processes that fuel the current economic system.

    Aligning an economic and financial system designed to extract wealth from nature and forest-dependent peoples with the protection of tropical forests is a paradox in itself. The structural drivers of deforestation are precisely the same commodity supply chains and industrial processes that fuel the current economic system: agribusiness, intensive livestock farming, mining, fossil fuel extraction, infrastructure development, logging for pulp and paper and biomass energy, among other economic sectors.

    The same financial system that will sustain the TFFF generates vast profits from companies driving deforestation. It’s like deliberately fighting a losing battle, just to ensure profits for wealthy investors.

    The Propaganda Trap: IPLC “Advice” Is Not the Same as Decision-Making Power

    A key pillar of the TFFF is that tropical forest countries will allocate a minimum of 20% of payments they receive to supporting Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities (IPLCs). This means that if a tropical forest country receives USD four per hectare of standing forest, 80 cents would have to be allocated to IPLCs.

    Subsequently, the most recent TFFF proposal (Concept Note 3.1) developed “Guiding Principles for the Allocation to Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities”, and established a “Technical and Scientific Advisory Panel” and an “IPLCs Advisory Council”. Primarily composed of 10 IPLC representatives, the IPLCs Advisory Council will only advise the TFFF Board, and will have no access to decision-making over mobilising and managing the fund’s overall resources. Moreover, the members of the IPLCs Advisory Council will need to be approved by the TFFF Board.

    The really important decisions will be taken by the Board of the Tropical Forest Investment Fund (TFIF), which is the “financial heart” of the fund and responsible for managing the capital (discussed in more detail below). As the World Rainforest Movement (WRM) points out in its analysis of the scheme, it is a mechanism steeped in colonial rationale. Giving IPLCs an advisory role and the power to decide how a fraction of the leftover resources are spent is not the same as giving them full access to decision-making and participation in the fund’s governance structure.

    Chief Ninawa Huni Kui, an Indigenous leader from the Brazilian Amazon and president of the Federation of the Huni Kui Indigenous People in Acre, Brazil, is highly skeptical of the scheme. In an interview given for this article, he said:

    “I don’t believe we will have positive results with those actions. The Tropical Forest Forever Facility is just another propaganda trap that will generate huge profits [for wealthy investors]. From a critical perspective, it is a form of co-optation: involving Indigenous Peoples without letting them make the decisions. It’s another deception. The fund’s decisions will not respond to the real desires and needs of all peoples. This ends up weakening the Indigenous movement, rather than strengthening it”.

    In addition to concerns about decision-making, the Huni Kui leader also sees the TFFF’s speculative nature as a contradiction to the cosmovision of Indigenous Peoples. “A capitalist fund is very contrary to the spiritual worldviews of Indigenous Peoples, to the relationship between bem viver6 and territories. Financial resources cannot be confused with bem viver. ‘I’ll give them some money and they’ll have a better relationship with nature.’ It’s not about that. We’re talking about a deeper notion; it’s about reverence and recognition of nature,” he said.

    On top of this, the fund’s stated commitment to equity, rights and inclusion—expressed through the introduction of “funding access modalities” for IPLCs and tropical forest countries—is not guaranteed in the event of market stress, liquidity pressure, drawdowns or default. Even if the financial architecture of the fund remains intact, tropical forest countries, and therefore IPLCs, may receive no payments, as priority would be given to repaying investors.

    TFIF: the Real Decision-Making Player

    The governance structure of the TFFF involves two independent entities: the Tropical Forest Investment Fund (TFIF) and the Tropical Forest Forever Facility (“the Facility” or TFFF).

    The TFIF will be responsible for mobilising and managing financial resources, and will take important decisions through the TFIF Board, a central institution in the scheme. The TFIF will have its own governance structure and the freedom to make “market-driven decisions”, which will inevitably mean prioritising economic interests over rights. The TFFF will be limited to “oversee[ing] the forest cover rewards system, including eligibility criteria, monitoring methodologies, and disbursement rules”.

    The TFFF Board will include eighteen member countries: nine sponsor countries and nine non-sponsor tropical forest countries that meet the criteria set out in the Facility Charter, the fund’s institutional governance framework, which will guide implementation arrangements, eligibility criteria, and other foundational considerations. All sponsor countries contributing at least USD one billion to the TFFF will be granted a seat on the TFFF Board, until the total number reaches nine.

    The Technical and Scientific Advisory Panel and the IPLCs Advisory Council will function under the supervision of the TFFF Board, which limits their decision-making power in key areas such as conflict resolution, enforcement action, defining indicators, and setting baselines. This contradicts principles of Free, Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC) and weakens democratic control.

    On the other hand, the TFIF Board will consist of “professionals” with the required “expertise”, and will be nominated and appointed by the “Sovereign Sponsors” (national governments providing sponsor capital) from an “independent committee’s recommendation”.

    The Role of the World Bank

    The World Bank will be the scheme’s trustee and host the TFFF Secretariat, and may also “provide certain Treasury Management services to TFIF”. Its reputation has been discredited in the Global South as it has been widely recognised for sinking countries in debt, imposing unjust conditions on loans, shaping economies to benefit big corporations instead of people, and even backing military dictatorships.

    The TFFF will therefore be hosted by and benefit an organisation responsible for promoting policies that exacerbate inequalities and ecological impacts in the Global South7, which could prove even more problematic in times of global crisis and financial instability.

    The payment hierarchy that the World Bank will oversee will be determined according to the revenues of the TFIF, and will be prioritised in the following way:

    1. Bond-holders, including “debt service and fees payments” to those who lent their money to the TFFF and World Bank fees;
    2. Other Private investors;
    3. Sovereign sponsors, which are mainly state loans;
    4. In last place, eligible tropical forest countries that have a deforestation rate lower than 0,5 percent.

    If revenues decline, payments to tropical forest countries will be the first to be postponed, and if things get even worse, the TFIF will “commence an orderly liquidation”.

    This payment hierarchy matters: in years when returns are low, forest-based payments would be reduced before investor returns are affected. In extreme market downturns, forest-related payments might pause altogether. Next in line would be reductions in payments to sovereign sponsors, further protecting the interests of private investors.

    Payments to IPLCs will therefore be the lowest priority, while the interests of sponsors and wealthy private investors will be protected through the fund’s investment strategy. Trying to align profit-making with environmental outcomes in this way could therefore put more pressure on forest-dependent communities, as it is ultimately they that will bear the greatest risk burden from market volatility, potential liquidation, and penalties.

    Will the TFFF Incentivise Investments that Harm Forests?

    Although the TFFF’s concept note 3.1 states that investments in deforestation, coal, peat, oil, and gas will be excluded, the fund’s unclear investment exclusion criteria are a serious concern. Questions remain unanswered about whether and how the criteria would effectively prohibit investments in sectors that cause deforestation, and ensure that companies that are linked to harmful biodiversity impacts would not benefit from the scheme.

    Van der Mark points out that there are many more industrial sectors that have “impacts on biodiversity, like the use of agrotoxics and intensive water use, that are for now not excluded. And here lies a tension, because if the exclusion criteria are too strict, they will exclude too many activities and the fund won’t be able to generate the returns it needs to make the payments to forest countries.”

    Generating profits from speculative financial markets while relying on exclusion criteria to avoid investing in biodiversity-destroying activities reveals a fundamental contradiction at the fund’s core. What’s the point in creating a scheme that could lead to social and environmental harms if safeguards are not developed and strictly enforced?

    The TFFF also claims that it will have strict criteria to ensure that payments to tropical forest countries will be reduced significantly if their deforestation rates increase. However, as van der Mark explains, there is a risk of leakage to other biomes if TFFF-related payments mean that commodity production just expands into areas not covered by the scheme.

    Furthermore, “there is also the risk that intensification of production on already converted areas, through the use of more fertilisers and pesticides, will harm nature in other ways than through deforestation.” The TFFF’s criteria are not able to mitigate either of these risks.

    The TFFF may become another tool to instrumentalise finance for destruction

    Civil society organisations have long warned about the urgent need to halt destructive finance that is directed towards activities that harm forests and biodiversity. Ironically, by its design, the TFFF may become another tool to instrumentalise finance for destruction, displace forest loss into other biomes within eligible tropical forest countries, and detract from efforts to fundamentally change how international finance flows.

    The current climate and biodiversity finance architecture—designed to support the goals of the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC)—is subservient to the extractive economic model. The barriers to accessing funding by Global South countries, such as power asymmetries, debt injustices and challenges in resource mobilisation are not going to be overcome with debt-driven conservation schemes like the TFFF.

    “As much as it’s important to mobilise finance for nature protection, as TFFF is trying to do, it is even far more important to regulate harmful finance. If destructive finance is not halted, it’s like mopping the floor with the tap still open,”

    explains van der Mark.

    “To really halt destructive finance, we must address the core problem: our economic system built on extractivism and a structural dependence on perpetual growth. This growth imperative drives ecological overshoot, social inequity, and financial practices that externalise harm while privatising gains. We need to shift to an economic system that operates within planetary boundaries, that restores ecosystems, and prioritises sufficiency over accumulation.”

    Real Solutions: Addressing the Root Causes of Deforestation and Biodiversity Loss

    Market-based approaches to climate change and biodiversity loss are constantly embroiled in scandals and facing serious questions over integrity.8 Concerns over human rights violations and poor performance records demand alternative approaches rooted in human rights, traditional knowledge, and gender justice.

    An effective funding mechanism must aim to address the root causes of deforestation, climate change and biodiversity loss, as well as transform dominant economic and financial structures to prioritise nature and social equity over private interests. While common but differentiated responsibilities among countries are a crucial foundation to build strong finance architecture around, the TFFF design has major flaws and won’t be able to mobilise resources in a sustained, gender-responsive, equitable and predictable manner for tropical forest countries. Instead, the TFFF is a speculative financial mechanism that will feed off Global South debt and gamble on volatile financial markets amid geopolitical instability.

    The much-lauded 20 percent direct access to funds for IPLCs is a trap designed to buy support from Indigenous groups: having a say over the leftovers is not the same as having full governance power over the fund. Indigenous Peoples, local communities, women and youth must have full access to decision-making in the entire governance structure of any fund that truly wants to be effective.

    An effective fund must ensure continuous capacity-building, legal protection, and strong regulations to protect land rights, alongside a robust grievance mechanism. It must also actively support efforts to dismantle the financial incentives that drive deforestation, while strengthening legal systems to address the high levels of risk faced by environmental defenders when protecting their territories.9

    An effective fund must ensure continuous capacity-building, legal protection, and strong regulations to protect land rights

    Moreover, institutional arrangements and policy decisions that genuinely aim to enable transformative change must address underlying structural constraints, including:

    Debt restructuring and cancellation10, and tax justice: priority must be given to relieving the fiscal pressures on Global South countries to expand commodity production and dependence on destructive activities. Public sources of funding must be increased to fund social and environmental priorities, rather than perpetuating the debt crisis. In this context, taxing the super-rich and extractive sectors is an urgent conversation to design an efficient fund capable of addressing the root causes of deforestation and biodiversity loss.

    Recognition of ecological debt: Global North countries are historically responsible for the majority of biodiversity destruction and ecological degradation, but they continue to evade their responsibilities. Only two countries have contributed their share of USD 20 billion per year agreed under the Kunming–Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework (KMGBF)11. An effective fund must ensure not only human rights-based and gender-responsive approaches, but also recognise the colonial legacies of nature depletion and its implications for societies, economies, traditional cultures, and ecosystems.

    Increasing public finance for biodiversity and climate action while lessening the fiscal pressures that push Global South countries toward biodiversity-harming activities is essential to achieving meaningful and lasting outcomes.

    In Conclusion: The Ecological Collapse Caused by Capitalism will not be Solved with More Capitalism

    Genuine efforts to curb deforestation demand moving away from market-based approaches that perpetuate wealth accumulation and greenwashing, and instead support inclusive decision-making while confronting the structural drivers of forest loss. The TFFF cannot meaningfully challenge agribusiness, extractive industries, illegal logging, false solutions, and perverse incentives that sustain destructive activities.

    Forest protection requires robust, rights-based public financing mechanisms.

    At its core, the TFFF is a leveraged bet on risky emerging market debt12 that embodies contradictory approaches to forest conservation and diverts attention from the urgent need to halt the expansion of extractive sectors. It also obscures the role of state policies—often shaped by pressures from the international financial system—that render extractivism a perceived necessity for maintaining financial stability.

    Forest protection requires robust, rights-based public financing mechanisms that place ecosystem integrity and the rights of Indigenous Peoples and local communities at the center, rather than market-driven schemes that demand regulation, investment screening, and social and environmental safeguards.

    Real solutions are already being built on the ground, and we must work towards ensuring that the right financial resources, as well as political, social and economic conditions, are in place to allow them to flourish. These alternatives need to be strengthened, policies must be coherent, and key conditions such as land rights must be guaranteed.

    Recognising that forests and biodiversity cannot be treated as commodities or financial assets is essential. Fundamentally, the ecological collapse caused by capitalism will not be solved with more capitalism.

    CC-BY-SA 4.0
    Categories: G1. Progressive Green

    Peru: Protection of uncontacted Indigenous people’s territory blocked

    Survival International - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 03:21
    Peruvian government has blocked a proposal to protect the forest of the Mashco Piro — thought to be the largest group of uncontacted Indigenous people in the world.
    Categories: E1. Indigenous

    Governments must embrace Fossil Free Zones as they head to COP31

    Climate Change News - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 03:19

    Irene Vélez Torres is the former Minister of Environment and Sustainable Development (2025-2026) and former Minister of Mines and Energy (2022-2023) of Colombia. Hon. Ralph Regenvanu is Vanuatu’s Minister of Climate Change, Adaptation, Meteorology and Geo-Hazards, and Energy.

    Governments will gather next week in Antalya, Türkiye, for COP31, this year’s United Nations climate summit. Three years ago, at the same summit in Dubai, nearly every country on Earth agreed, for the first time, to work toward transitioning energy systems away from fossil fuels.

    There is still no agreement on how to do it or where to start. One of us governed a fossil fuel producing-country in the Amazon; the other serves a Pacific Island state that has never extracted a barrel of oil. We have both tried to answer that question from inside our governments, and we want to share what we learned with the ministers who will try next.

    Fossil Free zones are an ambitious step

    Neither of our countries is rich. In 2024, fossil fuels still met more than three-quarters of Colombia’s energy demand, and coal and oil revenue help pay for schools and hospitals. In Vanuatu, children in Port Vila are still studying in tents three years after the last cyclone destroyed their classrooms.

    We both took on the just transition challenge from vulnerable positions, with little support from the countries that bear the responsibility to act first and fastest. Still, we chose to lead with ambition.

    This year’s events have made the case to phase out fossil fuels even clearer. When the Strait of Hormuz was effectively closed in February, the world suffered what the head of the International Energy Agency called the largest energy supply shock in history.

    The resultant energy crisis is what pushed countries in Santa Marta – 57 total countries representing nearly half the world’s GDP and approximately 20% of the global fossil fuel supply – to work toward a managed, equitable and just transition away from fossil fuels.

    The ongoing global energy shock has laid bare the limitations of our current system and shown that the persistent reliance on fossil fuels is unsustainable, for both people and planet.

    In this vein, we have been clear on our stance that a healthy forest and a healthy ocean are not assets waiting to be drilled. That is why we have advocated strongly for Fossil Free Zones, or protected places where a government decides that oil, gas, and coal will never be extracted because what lives there is worth more left intact. It turns a vague global promise made in Dubai into a concrete line on the ground, or on the sea.

    Lessons from Colombia and the Pacific

    Colombia’s lesson: start where the numbers are clearest. In August, Colombia declared nearly 500,000 square kilometres of the Amazon, roughly 42 percent of the country, permanently closed to new mining, oil, and gas. It is the largest terrestrial Fossil Free Zone on the planet. 

    Earth Insight found that drilling there would create billions of dollars in stranded assets while doing almost nothing for energy security. The decision was built with Indigenous Peoples, Afro-descendant communities, and campesinos, and backed by the largest investment in the region’s history in forest-based economies. A decision made with communities, rather than for them, grows deep roots.

    Vanuatu’s lesson: replace the fuel, not just refuse to drill. From Vanuatu and the Solomon Islands in the west to Hawaii in the east, no fossil fuels are extracted, though vast reserves may lie beneath the seabed and pressures from industry destroy that grow.

    However, Pacific nations do not want to dig them up – and making renewables the cheapest option, and securing the political commitments to protect these areas, means they will never have to. Vanuatu aims for 100 percent renewable electricity by 2030 and is on track to meet this goal in nearly every sector. Across its islands, small solar and hydro systems are built with public funds, run by local businesses, and welcomed by communities.

    The shared lesson: small countries scale together. Pacific leaders have agreed to pool their efforts on renewable energy across the region. In April, Pacific Climate Ministers adopted the Tassiriki Call for a Fossil Fuel Free Pacific. At the Santa Marta Conference, they proposed the world’s first fossil fuel-free marine zone, an ambition we will carry to the Second Conference on Transitioning Away from Fossil Fuels in Tuvalu next July.

    Building momentum to move past challenges

    We will be honest about the risks. Colombia’s new government has pledged to revive oil and gas exploration, and a ministerial resolution is relatively easy to overturn. Indeed, extractive interests have already driven the incoming government to revoke this Amazon protection just two months after taking office.

    That is why such efforts cannot remain the experiment of a few countries. Vanuatu has championed a “multilateralism from the margins”, which is how it won the International Court of Justice Advisory Opinion confirming that granting fossil fuel licenses can breach states’ legal obligations to protect the climate system. Decisions like ours endure when others make them too. Mexico and Guatemala have already walked similar paths, but more need to follow.

    COP31 is the moment for more countries to join in these commitments, providing pathways toward the change we need. Any government can advance its transition away from fossil fuels by creating a Fossil Free Zone with tools it already holds: protected areas, Indigenous land titles, land and ocean planning, and energy licensing rules.

    The just transition will reshape our forests and oceans either way. The only question is whether nature guides it or pays the price. Colombia and the Pacific Islands have drawn our lines. At COP31, we hope others will draw theirs.

    The post Governments must embrace Fossil Free Zones as they head to COP31 appeared first on Climate Home News.

    Categories: H. Green News

    PIPSC: Time to join the labour movement

    Spring Magazine - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 03:00

    The Professional Institute of the Public Service of Canada (PIPSC) is a union representing 80,000 scientists, researchers, engineers, tax and other professionals. As a professional...

    The post PIPSC: Time to join the labour movement first appeared on Spring.

    Categories: B3. EcoSocialism

    Socialists and AI: No other choice?

    Tempest Magazine - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 02:44

    Thus [the bourgeois economist] saves himself from all further puzzling of the brain, and what is more, implicitly declares his opponent to be stupid enough to contend against, not the capitalistic employment of machinery, but machinery itself.

    —Karl Marx

    As Marxists, we cannot disentangle Artificial Intelligence (AI) from capitalist political economy.

    AI is not, in fact, “intelligence” but rather a system of sophisticated algorithms that do not generate new ideas but can only spit out what it has been fed. How tech companies developed these algorithms was through “data scraping,” taking large amounts of personal and private data to teach its machines.

    AI is also not “artificial.” AI is powered and built by a large force of workers from the Global South, including Kenya, Venezuela, the Philippines, and India, among others.

    Moderators for digital platforms work 18 to 20 hours a day sometimes, at a rate of $1.46-$3.74 per day, looking at incredibly violent and disturbing text passages and images with no breaks.

    Of course, these digital companies offer no support to these workers, with many workers suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder and deep psychological damage.

    Many attempts to organize workers at these digital sweatshops have been crushed. Daniel Montag, a worker in Kenya, told Time that workers at a digital sweatshop subcontracted by Meta were all fired after attempts at unionization.

    Reading these reports is eerily reminiscent of the piecemeal sweatshops that Karl Marx described in Capital: worked to the bone under confined conditions for pennies.

    Digital infrastructure is not immaterial: the virtuality of the digital merely mystifies the grueling labor and extraction that enriches tech companies.

    This is coupled with the intensive fossil fuel and water use that AI data centers require, with AI data center needs exceeding the already heavy burden of other digital services such as Netflix and Zoom.

    Digital infrastructure is not immaterial: the virtuality of the digital merely mystifies the grueling labor and extraction that enriches tech companies.

    However, the moral arguments used to reject generative AI unfortunately often fall flat in the imperial core. Many ask, “Which major industry isn’t fueled by the blood of workers in the Global South?” Or, “Is it possible to be morally pure in a capitalist economy?” Of course not. But, if such arguments are not compelling, I offer here a few different arguments about why organizers on the Left should reject AI as it is being developed under capitalism.

    Community

    Writing, artistic expression, learning, and thinking are social acts. When we write or create art, we do so with the goal of reaching an audience intellectually or emotionally.

    When we read and think, we learn from writers and process what society, past and present, has communicated.

    As I often teach in my own writing courses, a key aspect to becoming a good writer is awareness of your audience and taking the opinions of others into account.

    For organizers, the social aspect is particularly important. As historical materialists, our writing and thinking should be continually developing with and in community. Generative AI takes away this community aspect, and the only interlocutor is the faceless user interface of Claude or ChatGPT.

    What potential organizing opportunities do we miss when we outsource community dialogue to machines? And why would we want to outsource idea-generation to machines that aggregate reactionary views?

    As studies have shown, AI algorithms commonly make decisions based on racial stereotypes.  We should not risk reproducing these same reactionary tendencies in our own organizing by trusting machines that are often designed for surveillance and military applications.

    Also, nothing in the past five years has suggested that those in charge of these large AI companies, such as Mark Zuckerberg and Elon Musk, are interested in fixing the racist and reactionary tendencies of these systems.

    When organizers use AI, whether for writing or graphic design or anything else, we are feeding tech companies that actively seek to thwart our aims.

    The social effects of AI are horrifying: AI psychosis, cognitive decline, heightened surveillance, and militarization. When the U.S. military horrifically bombed a girls school in Iran, strong evidence suggests the target was chosen by an AI algorithm.

    When organizers use AI, whether for writing or graphic design or anything else, we are feeding tech companies that actively seek to thwart our aims.

    Feeding these tech companies our data also gives the surveillance state more ammunition to use against us. Our thoughts and ideas should be ours, not shaped by AI or given to tech companies as another data point to further suppress and surveil socialist organizing.

    Also, AI art is sloppy and ugly, and AI writing tends to be poorly written and formulaic. When restaurants use AI art, does the food not look like it’s infested with worms?

    Relying on AI hurts our ethos as organizers. Earlier this year, Vijay Prashad and Tings Chak were caught using AI to write an article on China and Uyghurs. The deeply problematic politics of their argument aside, the AI article contained several hallucinated sources that detracted from whatever credibility the article and the publication, Monthly Review, had.

    If our goal is to reach the wider community, we should not give the public easy grounds to dismiss us. And if we believe in the power of labor and creativity, our materials should reflect that.

    We can learn how to write and draw together, or at the very least pay competent writers and artists for our materials.

    This belief in community and labor should be centered in our thinking on AI, which leads me to the threat of AI and automation to labor.

    Labor

    Taste is ultimately subjective, and some people do genuinely love AI slop when it generates fingerless hands or worm-infested hamburgers. So, when discussing AI with the broader public, our arguments should center on labor.

    The dream of tech companies is to depress the value of labor power, so the capitalist class can extract more surplus value.

    We are beginning to see AI used in multiple industries: automated grading and teaching to replace educators, digitally generated art and content to replace artists, and vibes coding to replace software developers and engineers.

    The proliferation and development of AI poses a grave threat to workers.

    AI automation is not only targeting jobs of the professional managerial class either. Many companies are building AI-enabled robots to begin replacing jobs in factories and oil refineries. Even gig work is under attack by automation through companies such as Waymo and Starship Technologies.

    The proliferation and development of AI poses a grave threat to workers. According to one tracking tool, roughly 265,000 jobs have already been cut due to AI.

    The specter of AI is used in the way Marx describes automation in Capital, Volume I:

    The instrument of labour, when it takes the form of a machine, immediately becomes a competitor of the workman himself. The self-expansion of capital by means of machinery is thenceforward directly proportional to the number of the workpeople, whose means of livelihood have been destroyed by that machinery. The whole system of capitalist production is based on the fact that the workman sells his labour-power as a commodity. Division of labour specialises this labour-power, by reducing it to skill in handling a particular tool. So soon as the handling of this tool becomes the work of a machine, then, with the use-value, the exchange-value too, of the workman’s labour-power vanishes; the workman becomes unsaleable, like paper money thrown out of currency by legal enactment. That portion of the working-class, thus by machinery rendered superfluous, i.e., no longer immediately necessary for the self-expansion of capital, either goes to the wall in the unequal contest of the old handicrafts and manufactures with machinery, or else floods all the more easily accessible branches of industry, swamps the labour-market, and sinks the price of labour-power below its value.

    In other words, machinery and automation takes away the labor power of the worker, and the only commodity she has—labor—is rendered unnecessary. Workers who are not laid off now must work more as their workday intensifies to compete against machines.

    Machinery and automation takes away the labor power of the worker, and the only commodity she has—labor—is rendered unnecessary.

    Take, for example, an educator. A university begins to lay off instructors as tasks such as grading and curriculum development become automated by AI, and the remaining instructors take on more classes, more students, and ultimately more work to maintain their employment. The quality of education and instruction will decrease across the board for both students and instructors, but the university only sees short term value gains.

    In a capitalist political economy, where the goal is to extract as much value as possible, technology will always trend (with notable exceptions) toward automation, deskilling, and the suppression of the value of labor power.

    Spoiler alert for Park Chan Wook’s No Other Choice

    In Park Chan Wook’s newest film, No Other Choice, the main character, Yoo Man Su (Lee Byung Hun), is laid off from his manufacturing job at a paper factory. A new position at a paper factory opens up, and Man Su decides to eliminate his competition, literally. He kills every other unemployed worker competing for his position, and when Man Su gets the job at the end of the film, he walks into a factory where he is the only person. All other workers have been eliminated, and the only thing for Man Su to do is watch machines make paper. No community, no solidarity. Barely even any work.

    Park Chan Wook’s vision of automation grows ever closer as tech companies, large corporations, and governments promote and fund AI in service of value extraction, war, and surveillance.

    AI is another weapon aimed directly at the global working class, whose precarious conditions of daily living are already close to unbearable.

    Is the time we save outsourcing our creativity and cognition to automated algorithms worth it?

    Opinions expressed in signed articles do not necessarily represent the views of the editors or the Tempest Collective. For more information, see “About Tempest Collective.”
    Featured Image credit: Tang Yau Hoong; modified by Tempest.

    The post Socialists and AI: No other choice? appeared first on Tempest.

    Categories: D2. Socialism

    In the Valley of Reconciliation: Yellowhead Institute & Crown-Indigenous Relations, 2018-2026

    Yellowhead Institute - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 02:21

    IN THE SUMMER of 2018, Yellowhead Institute was just a baby. 

    We launched earlier that year and found ourselves in the midst of a political crisis in Indian Country. Justin Trudeau had been elected and sought sweeping changes to Indigenous policy, including a proposal for an alternative to the Indian Act. We wanted to understand the shape of this alternative to help communities prepare and intervene. Our small 2-3 person team poured over ministerial statements, budgets, new laws and policy; we spoke to dozens of First Nation leaders and activists; and slowly pieced together the vision for the “Rights Framework,” which we then went on to critique in our first ever Special Report in October 2018. It landed. We presented the findings to First Nation political organizations around the country. Then, at the 2018 Assembly of First Nations (AFN) Special Chiefs Assembly, a young Delaware leader named Megan Logan took the stage on behalf of First Nation youth opposed to the Rights Framework, citing our report. Chiefs in Assembly passed a resolution against the Framework. 

    That was the moment we knew Yellowhead had a place in the national dialogue on Indigenous issues; that we could produce rigorous, independent, and critical research and analysis that would support communities in their efforts to make change. 

    Over eight years later, we are still doing that work. In fact, this is the 200th publication of the Yellowhead Brief. Our short-form, argumentative or descriptive research and writing has endured. 200 publications. Of course, Yellowhead does many things: on the research side, we publish four Special Reports every year, multiple special features, and our multi-year Red Paper projects. We run the Yellowhead School with two non-credit programs (the Misko Aki Knowledge Exchange, or MAKE, and Yellowhead Online), AND a degree program, the Public Administration and Indigenous Governance B.A. All of which are designed to provide critical tools, quality research, and transformational education designed to build solidarity and/or practice Native sovereignty.

    But the Brief is the gate-way for most people into the Yellowhead galaxy. So, reaching this milestone is important for our team and it marks an occasion to reflect. As we do, it feels like so much has changed over our near ten-year run, and so much remains the same. There is a new Liberal Government, new proposals to change the collective relationship, and a new generation of young people telling their leaders that something is not quite right. Okiniwak, Walking Forward Together, and Here We Stand are just a few of the Indigenous youth groups based in Ontario organizing across the country, building community, taking stands on contemporary political issues in thoughtful ways, and challenging the rest of us to pay attention. There are many others.

    These groups’ primary concerns revolve around the Carney Government’s Building Canada Strong(er) agenda and the related economic reconciliation framework that seeks to bring Indigenous communities along. Yellowhead has used the Brief to understand and explain the infrastructure being established to “Build Canada Strong” in pieces on Special Economics Zones, Cooperation Agreements, the climate costs of Bill C-39, But there is clearly more work to be done around the new consultation regime, the role of the Major Projects Office, environmental management, the proposed sovereign wealth fund, implementation of the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples and Indigenous rights more generally. 

    Still, we know that Carney is not Trudeau. 

    Where Trudeau sought to overhaul the machinery of government, was open to restitution, and created bilateral negotiations frameworks – all to build trust for a comprehensive approach to a new relationship – Carney is focused on a narrower set of priorities. Trudeau clearly had his critics (myself included), yet he makes Carney look like John A. MacDonald: a Prime Minister set on nation-building where Indigenous people are, more or less, in the way. Carney rarely speaks on Indigenous issues, and when he does, betrays his lack of interest or knowledge. As Cree Minister of Indigenous Services, Mandy Gull-Masty, reports on the Indian Act’s slow death, Carney is apparently unaware and makes a renewed pitch to scrap the legislation. His approach is decidedly unilateral and obtuse.

    Meanwhile, we have hostile provinces. The young people of Here We Stand are pointing to Ontario’s Bills 5 and 140, designed to fast-track development and strip environmental protections in that province. Treaty 8 Chiefs have told Alberta their consultation framework is so weak they’ll meet soon in court (again). Saskatchewan is selling off First Nation lands, Quebec is erasing Indigenous languages through Bill 96, and B.C. just elected a party that campaigned on scrapping the provincial UNDRIP law. 

    ‘Round we go. Reconciliation arrives, does a few laps, and then quietly jogs off – a pattern seen throughout the highs and lows of Canadian history. We see the shift in our day-to-day: reconciliation is no longer an institutional focus, funders are shifting resources to other areas, and renewed racism creeps into our social media pages.

    Still, in our near-decade of work we know that it’s in these times of confrontation that public education and useful, accessible research and analysis matters most. So, as we enter another valley in our collective relationship, Yellowhead will be there.

    Citation:

    King, Hayden. “In the Valley of Reconciliation: Yellowhead Institute & Crown-Indigenous Relations, 2018-2026” Yellowhead Institute. Nov 05 2026. https://yellowheadinstitute.org/2026/in-the-valley-of-reconciliation-yellowhead-institute-crown-indigenous-relations-2018-2026

    Photograph: Round Dance by Stan Williams

     

    The post In the Valley of Reconciliation: Yellowhead Institute & Crown-Indigenous Relations, 2018-2026 appeared first on Yellowhead Institute.

    Categories: E1. Indigenous

    How This Year's Super El Niño Will Worsen Global Hunger

    Yale Environment 360 - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 01:41

    A monster El Niño is nearing its peak, deepening drought in many parts of the world. Coming as countries slash foreign aid and war chokes supplies of energy and fertilizer, the climate phenomenon could leave millions more people in vulnerable countries without enough to eat.

    Read more on E360 →

    Categories: H. Green News

    Shell Accused of Putting LNG Exports First — But Is Santos Throwing Stones from a Very Expensive Glasshouse?

    Royal Dutch Shell Plc .com - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 01:20

    Australia’s gas giants turn on one another over domestic supply, export profits and who should pay for the government’s proposed gas reservation scheme. Behind the corporate accusations lies a more uncomfortable question: why should a major gas-exporting nation struggle to guarantee affordable gas for its own citizens?

    5 November 2026

    By the Donovan–Shell Archive

    There is something wonderfully revealing about the spectacle unfolding in Australia’s liquefied natural gas industry.

    Three enormous gas-exporting businesses are arguing over who should be obliged to supply Australian customers.

    Not whether Australia possesses sufficient gas resources.

    Not whether overseas customers will continue receiving enormous shipments of LNG.

    But which company should shoulder the financial consequences of ensuring Australians can buy some of their own country’s gas.

    The latest confrontation involves Santos, Shell and Origin Energy.

    According to a report published by The Australian on 4 November 2026, Santos has accused its competitors of promoting a regulatory arrangement that would favour their existing operations while imposing disproportionate obligations on Santos’s Gladstone LNG project.

    The accusation is serious.

    It is also extraordinarily ironic.

    Because independent reporting by ABC Australia has previously identified Santos’s own LNG operation as a major contributor to the very domestic gas-market problems the proposed regulations are intended to address.

    The result is a corporate argument in which everyone claims to be defending Australia’s interests.

    And everyone, naturally, would prefer somebody else to pay.

    The latest accusation: Santos turns on Shell and Origin

    The dispute centres on three LNG export developments on Curtis Island, near Gladstone in Queensland.

    Shell operates Queensland Curtis LNG (QCLNG).

    Australia Pacific LNG (APLNG) is associated with Origin Energy and ConocoPhillips.

    Gladstone LNG (GLNG) is operated by Santos.

    All three projects export Australian gas to international customers.

    Their commercial positions, however, are significantly different.

    According to The Australian, Santos objects to proposals supported by QCLNG and APLNG that would recognise exporters’ existing contributions to domestic gas supplies when calculating new reservation obligations.

    Santos argues that this approach could allow its competitors to satisfy regulatory requirements using gas they already supply to Australian customers.

    GLNG, by contrast, could be required to find additional domestic gas while continuing to honour overseas LNG contracts.

    Santos considers that unfair.

    Its competitors might reasonably respond that the greater unfairness would be to disregard their previous contributions while allowing an exporter that historically purchased domestic gas for export to escape additional obligations.

    Welcome to the Australian LNG industry’s interpretation of burden-sharing.

    Santos’s allegations about Shell’s exports

    The November report contains allegations that deserve careful examination.

    Santos claims that uncontracted spot LNG exports by QCLNG and APLNG increased from approximately 75 petajoules in 2021 to 122 petajoules in 2024.

    That would represent an increase of approximately 63%.

    Santos also alleges that domestic gas supplies from those projects declined over the period.

    Separately, it accuses its competitors of seeking domestic gas margins of between 300% and 500%, linked to international LNG pricing.

    These are substantial claims.

    However, the figures are presented here as allegations attributed to Santos. They should not be treated as independently verified findings.

    The distinction between contracted exports, spot sales, gross domestic deliveries and net domestic supply is essential.

    A company might increase spot exports while remaining a net supplier to the domestic market.

    Similarly, a claim about unusually high margins requires scrutiny of the underlying price, production costs, transport costs and contractual terms.

    Without those details, it would be premature to conclude that Shell or Origin engaged in improper pricing.

    Nevertheless, the allegations deserve examination.

    Australian consumers have a legitimate interest in knowing whether gas producers are prioritising export opportunities when domestic buyers face high prices.

    And Shell should not escape scrutiny simply because Santos has its own uncomfortable history.

    The Santos glasshouse

    The strongest reason to investigate Santos’s latest accusations is the extensive independent reporting already available.

    On 8 September 2026, ABC Australia published an investigation examining the role of Queensland’s LNG exporters in Australia’s domestic gas problems.

    Its findings were particularly damaging to the position advanced by Santos.

    The report explained that GLNG had been developed with substantial LNG export capacity but insufficient dedicated gas reserves to meet all its export commitments.

    Consequently, GLNG historically purchased gas from Australia’s domestic market to fulfil overseas contracts.

    Energy analyst Saul Kavonic estimated that the volumes involved over the preceding decade were equivalent to approximately 20% of eastern Australia’s domestic gas demand.

    That is an extraordinary comparison.

    It does not mean Santos literally removed one-fifth of all domestic gas in every year, but it illustrates the cumulative scale of GLNG’s reliance on third-party supplies.

    The ABC contrasted GLNG’s position with QCLNG and APLNG, which had predominantly been net suppliers to Australia’s domestic market.

    In other words, Shell and Origin’s projects had historically contributed gas to domestic customers on a net basis.

    Santos’s GLNG project had historically depended on acquiring gas from that market.

    This is a material distinction.

    It would be neither accurate nor fair to overlook it.

    Shell deserves credit where the evidence supports it

    This archive has documented Shell’s environmental controversies, fossil-fuel expansion, litigation and corporate conduct for decades.

    But criticism should never become a substitute for evidence.

    On this particular issue, Shell’s historical record appears more favourable than Santos’s.

    The ABC investigation reported that QCLNG and APLNG had overwhelmingly been net domestic gas suppliers.

    That does not establish that every Shell pricing decision was reasonable.

    It does not answer Santos’s allegations about recent spot exports.

    And it does not demonstrate that Shell’s preferred reservation model would necessarily produce the best outcome for Australian consumers.

    But it does mean Shell has a legitimate basis for arguing that previous domestic contributions should be considered when designing future obligations.

    A company that has already supplied substantial quantities of gas domestically may reasonably question a system that treats it identically to an exporter that historically drew gas out of the domestic market.

    The difficulty is designing rules that recognise genuine contributions without allowing companies to claim credit for supplies that would have reached domestic customers anyway.

    That is where the regulatory argument becomes particularly important.

    How Australia reached this extraordinary position

    The origins of the dispute lie in the rapid expansion of LNG exports from eastern Australia.

    During the previous decade, enormous investments transformed Queensland’s coal-seam gas industry.

    Three LNG export developments were constructed on Curtis Island.

    They connected eastern Australian gas resources to international energy markets, particularly in Asia.

    The projects promised investment, employment, export earnings and economic growth.

    But the development of a major LNG export industry also exposed domestic customers to competition from overseas buyers.

    Gas that might previously have been sold into the Australian market could now be exported.

    In principle, increased production could satisfy both markets.

    In practice, the availability, location, price and contractual commitments associated with gas supplies created significant complications.

    GLNG’s dependence on third-party domestic supplies became a particularly contentious feature of this system.

    ABC reporting has also examined historical transactions through which gas originally associated with domestic supply arrangements ultimately supported exports.

    For Australian manufacturers requiring reliable gas at internationally competitive prices, these developments were hardly academic.

    Higher gas prices can affect production costs, investment decisions and employment.

    Households are affected directly through energy bills and indirectly through the cost of goods and services.

    The basic policy question is therefore straightforward.

    How can Australia remain a major LNG exporter while ensuring sufficient gas is available to domestic users on reasonable terms?

    The answer has proved considerably less straightforward.

    Canberra’s proposed solution: reserve gas for Australians

    The Albanese government announced a national domestic gas reservation policy in December 2025.

    After consultation and revisions during 2026, the government introduced legislation intended to require LNG exporters to contribute gas to the domestic market.

    The current framework provides for domestic supply obligations of up to 20% of annual LNG export volumes.

    The scheme is scheduled to commence in 2027, with supply obligations beginning on 1 January 2028.

    Importantly, the legislation includes provisions allowing obligations to be adjusted to account for existing export contracts and infrastructure constraints.

    The government argues that the scheme will improve domestic supply security and place downward pressure on gas prices.

    Those outcomes remain policy objectives, not established results.

    The details matter enormously.

    A reservation requirement that produces genuinely additional domestic supply could improve market conditions.

    A scheme that permits exporters merely to reclassify existing supplies, purchase domestic producers or exploit contractual exemptions might achieve considerably less.

    The question is not simply whether 20% sounds like a reassuring number.

    It is whether the legislation will change the actual quantity of gas available to Australian customers.

    The battle over exemptions

    Santos has advocated protections for existing export contracts and changes to the proposed regulatory obligations.

    According to the November reporting, its preferred approach includes recognition of contracts predating the government’s December 2025 announcement, greater flexibility over commercial terms, and circumstances in which reservation requirements could be reduced or suspended.

    Some of these arguments raise legitimate concerns.

    Long-term LNG contracts involve substantial financial commitments.

    Abrupt regulatory changes can create commercial uncertainty and potentially affect investment.

    Australia also has an interest in maintaining reliable relationships with international trading partners.

    But there is another side.

    If existing contracts, contractual extensions and other exemptions are defined too broadly, the companies most responsible for domestic supply pressures could face relatively limited obligations.

    ABC investigations published in October examined precisely this possibility.

    Analysts warned that aspects of the proposed scheme might permit exporters to reduce their exposure through contractual arrangements, acquisitions or accounting mechanisms without necessarily increasing physical gas deliveries.

    These are concerns about potential loopholes, not findings that Santos has unlawfully exploited them.

    Nevertheless, they deserve serious attention before the legislation is finalised.

    A reservation scheme that rewards clever paperwork more generously than additional domestic supply would be a remarkable achievement in regulatory futility.

    The industry’s favourite argument: investment will suffer

    The gas industry has repeatedly warned that intervention could discourage investment.

    That argument should not be dismissed automatically.

    Gas developments require substantial capital, long planning periods and confidence in regulatory stability.

    Poorly designed obligations could make marginal projects less attractive.

    But investment arguments also require context.

    A country’s natural resources are not simply an unrestricted entitlement for exporters.

    Governments have legitimate responsibilities to domestic consumers, industrial competitiveness and energy security.

    The relevant policy challenge is to balance those interests.

    Santos’s warnings about investment should therefore be considered alongside its own commercial incentives.

    Shell and Origin’s proposals should receive the same treatment.

    No company becomes a disinterested public-policy expert merely by submitting a consultation response.

    And no proposal should be accepted simply because its supporters describe it as market-efficient.

    The decisive question is whether the resulting framework delivers more gas to Australian users at prices that support households and industry.

    What about Shell’s shareholders?

    Shell’s major institutional investors include global asset managers such as BlackRock and Vanguard, whose funds have substantial interests in large international energy companies.

    Such investors have an obvious interest in disciplined capital allocation, regulatory predictability and sustainable financial returns.

    But the long-term interests of shareholders are not necessarily served by every opportunity to maximise export revenues.

    Prolonged disputes with governments, public dissatisfaction over energy prices and increasingly restrictive regulation can create significant commercial risks.

    A transparent and workable domestic gas framework may offer greater long-term stability than repeated confrontations over supply obligations.

    For Shell, the challenge is to demonstrate that its Australian operations can deliver competitive returns while maintaining constructive relationships with the country supplying the resource.

    That is not an unreasonable expectation.

    It is the ordinary price of operating a major energy business.

    The environmental contradiction nobody should overlook

    There is another dimension to this argument.

    All three companies are debating how natural gas should be allocated between domestic consumption and overseas exports.

    Yet LNG remains a fossil fuel.

    Its production, processing, liquefaction, transportation and combustion generate greenhouse-gas emissions.

    Methane leakage can add materially to the climate impact.

    The industry’s argument that gas can support energy security and replace higher-emitting fuels in certain circumstances does not eliminate those emissions.

    Nor should a domestic gas reservation scheme be mistaken for an energy-transition strategy.

    The immediate policy objective is to ensure sufficient affordable gas for existing users.

    That may be important for industries that cannot readily electrify.

    But Australia’s longer-term climate and energy objectives also require reducing dependence on fossil fuels where practical.

    Shell’s continued commitment to LNG expansion therefore remains relevant to any broader assessment of its environmental record.

    The current dispute illustrates how difficult it can be to reconcile export-led fossil-fuel growth, domestic energy affordability and climate commitments.

    A dispute in which everyone has something to lose

    The November confrontation is unusual because it exposes divisions within an industry that often presents a united front against government intervention.

    Shell and Origin have reasons to seek recognition for their historical domestic gas contributions.

    Santos has reasons to resist obligations that could increase its costs or complicate existing export arrangements.

    The government wants to improve domestic supply without undermining export earnings and investment.

    Consumers want affordable energy.

    Manufacturers want reliable contracts and predictable prices.

    And environmental advocates want a credible pathway away from continued fossil-fuel dependence.

    These interests overlap in some respects and conflict sharply in others.

    The most important task for policymakers is to ensure that the eventual rules reward genuinely additional domestic supply rather than the most effective corporate lobbying.

    That will require transparency about export volumes, domestic deliveries, contractual exemptions and the basis on which individual obligations are adjusted.

    Without such transparency, the public may struggle to establish whether the scheme has achieved its purpose.

    Conclusion: the gas industry’s remarkable circular firing squad

    Santos accuses Shell and Origin of putting exports first.

    Shell and Origin can point to their historical contributions to Australia’s domestic market.

    Independent analysts have questioned whether Santos’s own LNG development helped create the supply pressures now requiring government intervention.

    Meanwhile, the industry warns that imposing new obligations could discourage investment.

    Each argument contains issues worth examining.

    None should be accepted uncritically.

    The ultimate irony is that a country blessed with enormous gas resources has reached a position in which its major exporters are fighting over responsibility for supplying domestic customers.

    It is an impressive achievement.

    Not necessarily one to celebrate.

    For Shell, this particular controversy does not justify automatic condemnation.

    Its historical domestic supply record deserves recognition.

    But that recognition should not become a blank cheque for its preferred regulatory arrangements or prevent scrutiny of its current export and pricing practices.

    For Santos, the challenge is more uncomfortable.

    Before accusing competitors of pursuing an export agenda, it must contend with independent evidence concerning GLNG’s longstanding reliance on domestic gas purchases to fulfil overseas commitments.

    And for Australia’s government, the challenge is to produce a scheme that changes actual supply rather than merely redistributing obligations on paper.

    Australia’s households and manufacturers do not need another competition in corporate finger-pointing. They need gas they can actually obtain at reasonable prices.

    The LNG industry has become remarkably accomplished at exporting Australia’s natural resources.

    Perhaps its next great technological breakthrough will be ensuring Australians can afford some of them.

    A fictional conversation: Sir Henri Deterding and John Donovan

    The following is an imaginary satirical exchange. Sir Henri Deterding died in 1939. No dialogue is presented as an authentic historical quotation.

    SIR HENRI DETERDING: Donovan! I am informed that Shell is being accused of exporting too much gas.

    JOHN DONOVAN: By Santos, Sir Henri.

    DETERDING: Santos? Another oil and gas company?

    DONOVAN: Indeed. One that has itself been criticised for buying Australian domestic gas to fulfil export commitments.

    DETERDING: Ach! So the exporter accuses the other exporters of exporting?

    DONOVAN: That is a reasonable summary.

    DETERDING: Mein Gott. In my day we called this commerce. Today, apparently, it is a parliamentary inquiry.

    DONOVAN: The Australian government wants exporters to reserve gas for domestic customers.

    DETERDING: Sensible. A nation should not have to beg foreign customers to return its own resources.

    DONOVAN: The companies are arguing over exemptions.

    DETERDING: Naturally. Every industrialist supports regulation, provided it regulates somebody else.

    DONOVAN: Shell may actually have the better historical domestic supply record in this particular dispute.

    DETERDING: You are defending Shell, Donovan?

    DONOVAN: Where the evidence warrants it.

    DETERDING: Ach. Most irritating. I had hoped you were reliably unreasonable.

    DONOVAN: I leave that to the corporate lobbyists.

    DETERDING: Ja. Then perhaps there is hope for you yet.

    Principal sources

    The Australian, 4 November 2026: Santos accuses Shell and Origin Energy of pushing export agenda through gas reservation advocacy — subscription may be required.

    ABC News, 8 September 2026: Gas crisis divides industry amid claims culprit getting away ‘scot-free’

    ABC News, 12 October 2026: Critics say ‘Santos-sized loopholes’ will make gas reservation a joke

    ABC News, 27 October 2026: Warnings gas culprit Santos could slip through reservation net

    Australian Government, updated 30 October 2026: Gas Market Review and reforms

    Australian Government, 10 September 2026: Securing more affordable gas for Australians

    Editorial note and disclaimer

    This article is independent journalism, analysis, opinion and satire based on publicly available reporting and government documentation as of 5 November 2026. It is not financial or investment advice.

    Allegations attributed to Santos concerning Shell, Origin Energy, LNG export volumes and pricing margins are reported as allegations, not established findings. Independent reporting concerning GLNG’s historical domestic gas purchases is distinguished from claims of unlawful conduct. No such unlawful conduct is alleged here.

    The fictional dialogue involving Sir Henri Deterding and John Donovan is entirely imaginary and intended solely as satire.

    The article was prepared with AI-assisted research and drafting. The cited reporting and government material provide the factual basis; no claim is made that the full paywalled article was independently inspected.

    Readers should consult the original sources and relevant company disclosures when assessing disputed commercial or regulatory claims.

    The central factual distinction is supported by ABC’s independent investigation: GLNG historically relied on domestic gas purchases for export, whereas QCLNG and APLNG were predominantly net domestic suppliers. The government’s current framework specifies obligations beginning on 1 January 2028.

    Shell Accused of Putting LNG Exports First — But Is Santos Throwing Stones from a Very Expensive Glasshouse? was first posted on November 5, 2026 at 10:20 am.
    ©2018 "Royal Dutch Shell Plc .com". Use of this feed is for personal non-commercial use only. If you are not reading this article in your feed reader, then the site is guilty of copyright infringement. Please contact me at john@shellnews.net

    Extreme flooding in the Southwest foreshadows a wild El Niño winter

    Grist - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 01:15

    The Southwest just got way too much of a good thing. Last weekend, a ferocious storm inundated communities and killed at least four people. Though precipitation is an essential component of Arizona’s desert climate, the state got two or three months’ worth of it in just a few days — far more than human infrastructure could handle all at once. Since September 20, an astonishing 28.84 inches of rain has fallen on Clovis, New Mexico, compared to its historical average of just 3.3 inches.

    “This weekend was just adding more on the rough times that those communities in Southwest Colorado and Arizona and Utah and New Mexico have been having recently,” said Russ Schumacher, director of the Colorado Climate Center at Colorado State University, who’s also the state climatologist. “I think the El Niño connection is pretty clear.”

    Indeed, that band of warm water in the Pacific could be priming much of the southern United States for a winter of increased precipitation, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s seasonal outlook. “Could an event like this have happened in a non-El Niño year?” asked Michael A. Crimmins, a climatologist at the University of Arizona. “It could have, but it would have been a lot harder to pull all of the ingredients together at the same time, and would have been a lot less likely.”

    .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook{font-family:'Basis Grotesque', 'Basis Grotesque Pro', Arial, sans-serif;color:#3C3830;box-sizing:border-box} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook *{box-sizing:border-box} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook h2.title{font-family:'PolySans', 'PolySans US', Arial, sans-serif;font-weight:500;font-size:25px;line-height:1.15;letter-spacing:-.018em;color:#3C3830;margin:0 0 6px} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook h3.head{font-family:'PolySans', 'PolySans US', Arial, sans-serif;font-weight:500;font-size:19px;line-height:1.2;color:#3C3830;margin:22px 0 8px} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook p.sub{font-size:16px;font-weight:500;line-height:1.4;color:#6B665E;margin:0 0 14px} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;align-items:center;gap:4px 18px;font-size:14px;font-weight:500;line-height:1.2;margin:0 0 12px} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend span{display:inline-flex;align-items:center;gap:7px;padding:2px 0} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend svg{width:13px;height:12px;flex:none;display:block;overflow:visible} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend .k-ec{stroke:#B5B0A7;stroke-width:.8px} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .grist-footer{display:flex;justify-content:space-between;align-items:flex-end;align-items:last baseline;gap:16px;margin:14px 0 0;padding:10px 0 0;border-top:1px solid #E6E3DD} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .grist-footer__lines{display:flex;flex-direction:column;min-width:0} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .grist-footer p{margin:0;font-size:12px;line-height:1.35} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .grist-footer p.grist-footer__note{color:#6B665E;font-style:italic;font-weight:500;margin:0 0 3px} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .grist-footer__source{color:#6B665E;font-weight:500} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .grist-footer p.grist-footer__credit{color:#3C3830;font-style:italic;font-weight:700;margin:3px 0 0} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .grist-footer__logos{display:flex;align-items:last baseline;gap:14px;flex:none} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .grist-footer__logo{display:block;width:46px;height:auto;color:#3C3830;overflow:visible} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .grist-footer__logo path{fill:currentColor} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .grist-footer{border-top:0;padding-top:0} @media (max-width:600px){.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook h2.title{font-size:21px}.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook p.sub{font-size:15px}.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend{font-size:13px}} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map{display:block;width:100%;height:auto;overflow:visible;margin:0;max-width:none} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map path{stroke:none} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map defs path{fill:inherit;stroke:inherit;stroke-width:inherit} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .coast{fill:none;stroke:#A8A39A;stroke-width:1.6px;stroke-linejoin:round} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .land{fill:#FFFFFF} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .band{stroke:#FFFFFF;stroke-width:.5px;stroke-opacity:.6} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .k-wL,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend .k-wL,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .chips .k-wL{fill:#FBD1AB} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .k-wK,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend .k-wK,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .chips .k-wK{fill:#F79E4E} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .k-n,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend .k-n,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .chips .k-n{fill:#D8D4CC} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .k-pL,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend .k-pL,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .chips .k-pL{fill:#A0D9CC} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .k-pK,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend .k-pK,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .chips .k-pK{fill:#1EA585} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .k-dL,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend .k-dL,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .chips .k-dL{fill:#E8B8F9} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .k-dK,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend .k-dK,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .chips .k-dK{fill:#C54DEF} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .k-ec,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend .k-ec,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .chips .k-ec{fill:#FFFFFF} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .k-Worsens,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend .k-Worsens,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .chips .k-Worsens{fill:#8600B4} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .k-Persistence,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend .k-Persistence,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .chips .k-Persistence{fill:#AC00E8} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .k-Development,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend .k-Development,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .chips .k-Development{fill:#CD66F1} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .k-Improvement,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend .k-Improvement,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .chips .k-Improvement{fill:#A0D9CC} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .k-Removal,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .legend .k-Removal,.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook .chips .k-Removal{fill:#12A07F} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .states{fill:none;stroke:#BDB8AF;stroke-width:.7px;stroke-linejoin:round} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map text{font-family:'Basis Grotesque', 'Basis Grotesque Pro', Arial, sans-serif;stroke:none} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .fxlabel{font-weight:700;font-size:17px;fill:#3C3830} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .inset{fill:none;stroke:#C9C5BD;stroke-width:.8px;stroke-dasharray:2 2} .el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .insetlabel{font-weight:500;font-size:12px;fill:#6B665E} @media (max-width:800px){.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .fxlabel{font-size:26px}.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .insetlabel{font-size:18px}} @media (max-width:480px){.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .fxlabel{font-size:38px}.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook svg.map .insetlabel{font-size:24px}} @media (prefers-reduced-motion:reduce){.el-nino-precip-outlook#el-nino-precip-outlook *{transition:none !important}} A wetter winter looks likely across the southern US

    Precipitation outlook through February 2027

    Slightly favors wetterFavors wetterSlightly favors drierFavors drierEqual chancesWetterDrierEqual chancesPuerto Rico, U.S. Virgin Islands @media (min-width:768px){.article-body{container-type:inline-size}.el-nino-precip-outlook-wide{width:min(130cqi, 100vw - 32px)!important;max-width:none!important;margin-left:calc((100cqi - min(130cqi, 100vw - 32px)) / 2)!important;margin-right:calc((100cqi - min(130cqi, 100vw - 32px)) / 2)!important}} @media (min-width:1069px) and (max-width:1439px){.el-nino-precip-outlook-wide{width:min(80cqi, 100vw - 32px)!important;margin-left:calc((100cqi - min(80cqi, 100vw - 32px)) / 2)!important;margin-right:calc((100cqi - min(80cqi, 100vw - 32px)) / 2)!important}} @media (min-width:1440px){.el-nino-precip-outlook-wide{width:min(140cqi, 100vw - 32px)!important;margin-left:calc((100cqi - min(140cqi, 100vw - 32px)) / 2)!important;margin-right:calc((100cqi - min(140cqi, 100vw - 32px)) / 2)!important}}

    The looming problem this winter is heat, oddly enough. The unfolding El Niño is already the strongest on record, and it could get stronger still in the next few months. Although that amounts to just a handful of extra degrees in the Pacific, it injects a tremendous amount of energy into the atmosphere, scrambling weather the world over. The phenomenon is so influential, in fact, that it has helped cancel hurricanes over in the Atlantic, by messing with winds high up in the atmosphere. Accordingly, this year shattered the record for the latest first hurricane in a season by nearly a month. Normally by this time of year we’d have seen six of these cyclones, but 2026 has still only produced one.

    The Southwest, though, gets no such relief from inclement weather. In addition to adding heat to the sky, the warmer waters of El Niño also increase atmospheric moisture. Even beyond the El Niño, temperatures in the Pacific have been running extra hot, which explains why the western part of the ocean has produced 10 hurricanes this season even as the Atlantic has remained quiet. (Overall, more than 90 percent of the excess heat that humans have pumped into the atmosphere has been absorbed by the oceans.)

    All this warm water means more moisture for the weather patterns that have been moving into the Southwest over the last month. A separate system in late October, for instance, became one of the most extreme storms in Colorado’s history, pelting higher elevations with up to 8 inches of rain in four days, causing widespread destruction. “It’s just really extreme amounts of water vapor in the atmosphere that have been aimed into the Southwest in each of those storms,” Schumacher said.

    This autumn precipitation primed Arizona, Colorado, and other Southwestern states for yet more destruction this past week. For one, rivers were already running high, then ran all the higher. And two, if soils are soaked, a follow-up bout of rain will run off and cause flooding. “We get the second storm, just a little bit after the first one, then everything was primed for even worse flooding this time around,” Schumacher said. 

    Read Next California has a plan for El Niño’s torrential rain: Save it for later

    In mountainous terrain, this gets especially dangerous, as the topography funnels rainwater into raging torrents. “If you hike around the Southwest, you’re going to see out-of-place boulders all over the place,” Crimmins said. “Water put it there. Maybe it was 5,000 years ago or something like that, but water moves. We can have really epic flash flooding.”

    The one silver lining here is that any increased precipitation from this El Niño could bring drought relief to much of the southern U.S., according to NOAA’s projections. Climate change is not only exacerbating these ongoing dry spells — hotter temperatures also increase evaporation from reservoirs. At the same time, populations are growing in the Southwest, meaning more people demanding more water. 

    .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook{font-family:'Basis Grotesque', 'Basis Grotesque Pro', Arial, sans-serif;color:#3C3830;box-sizing:border-box} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook *{box-sizing:border-box} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook h2.title{font-family:'PolySans', 'PolySans US', Arial, sans-serif;font-weight:500;font-size:25px;line-height:1.15;letter-spacing:-.018em;color:#3C3830;margin:0 0 6px} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook h3.head{font-family:'PolySans', 'PolySans US', Arial, sans-serif;font-weight:500;font-size:19px;line-height:1.2;color:#3C3830;margin:22px 0 8px} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook p.sub{font-size:16px;font-weight:500;line-height:1.4;color:#6B665E;margin:0 0 14px} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;align-items:center;gap:4px 18px;font-size:14px;font-weight:500;line-height:1.2;margin:0 0 12px} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend span{display:inline-flex;align-items:center;gap:7px;padding:2px 0} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend svg{width:13px;height:12px;flex:none;display:block;overflow:visible} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend .k-ec{stroke:#B5B0A7;stroke-width:.8px} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .grist-footer{display:flex;justify-content:space-between;align-items:flex-end;align-items:last baseline;gap:16px;margin:14px 0 0;padding:10px 0 0;border-top:1px solid #E6E3DD} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .grist-footer__lines{display:flex;flex-direction:column;min-width:0} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .grist-footer p{margin:0;font-size:12px;line-height:1.35} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .grist-footer p.grist-footer__note{color:#6B665E;font-style:italic;font-weight:500;margin:0 0 3px} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .grist-footer__source{color:#6B665E;font-weight:500} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .grist-footer p.grist-footer__credit{color:#3C3830;font-style:italic;font-weight:700;margin:3px 0 0} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .grist-footer__logos{display:flex;align-items:last baseline;gap:14px;flex:none} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .grist-footer__logo{display:block;width:46px;height:auto;color:#3C3830;overflow:visible} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .grist-footer__logo path{fill:currentColor} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .grist-footer{border-top:0;padding-top:0} @media (max-width:600px){.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook h2.title{font-size:21px}.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook p.sub{font-size:15px}.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend{font-size:13px}} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map{display:block;width:100%;height:auto;overflow:visible;margin:0;max-width:none} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map path{stroke:none} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map defs path{fill:inherit;stroke:inherit;stroke-width:inherit} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .coast{fill:none;stroke:#A8A39A;stroke-width:1.6px;stroke-linejoin:round} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .land{fill:#FFFFFF} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .band{stroke:#FFFFFF;stroke-width:.5px;stroke-opacity:.6} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .k-wL,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend .k-wL,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .chips .k-wL{fill:#FBD1AB} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .k-wK,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend .k-wK,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .chips .k-wK{fill:#F79E4E} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .k-n,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend .k-n,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .chips .k-n{fill:#D8D4CC} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .k-pL,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend .k-pL,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .chips .k-pL{fill:#A0D9CC} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .k-pK,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend .k-pK,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .chips .k-pK{fill:#1EA585} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .k-dL,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend .k-dL,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .chips .k-dL{fill:#E8B8F9} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .k-dK,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend .k-dK,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .chips .k-dK{fill:#C54DEF} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .k-ec,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend .k-ec,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .chips .k-ec{fill:#FFFFFF} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .k-Worsens,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend .k-Worsens,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .chips .k-Worsens{fill:#8600B4} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .k-Persistence,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend .k-Persistence,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .chips .k-Persistence{fill:#AC00E8} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .k-Development,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend .k-Development,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .chips .k-Development{fill:#CD66F1} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .k-Improvement,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend .k-Improvement,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .chips .k-Improvement{fill:#A0D9CC} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .k-Removal,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .legend .k-Removal,.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook .chips .k-Removal{fill:#12A07F} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .states{fill:none;stroke:#BDB8AF;stroke-width:.7px;stroke-linejoin:round} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map text{font-family:'Basis Grotesque', 'Basis Grotesque Pro', Arial, sans-serif;stroke:none} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .fxlabel{font-weight:700;font-size:17px;fill:#3C3830} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .inset{fill:none;stroke:#C9C5BD;stroke-width:.8px;stroke-dasharray:2 2} .el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .insetlabel{font-weight:500;font-size:12px;fill:#6B665E} @media (max-width:800px){.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .fxlabel{font-size:26px}.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .insetlabel{font-size:18px}} @media (max-width:480px){.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .fxlabel{font-size:38px}.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook svg.map .insetlabel{font-size:24px}} @media (prefers-reduced-motion:reduce){.el-nino-drought-outlook#el-nino-drought-outlook *{transition:none !important}} Drought could ease across the South this winter

    Seasonal drought outlook through January 31, 2027

    WorseningPersistingDevelopingImprovingEndingPuerto Rico, U.S. Virgin Islands @media (min-width:768px){.article-body{container-type:inline-size}.el-nino-drought-outlook-wide{width:min(130cqi, 100vw - 32px)!important;max-width:none!important;margin-left:calc((100cqi - min(130cqi, 100vw - 32px)) / 2)!important;margin-right:calc((100cqi - min(130cqi, 100vw - 32px)) / 2)!important}} @media (min-width:1069px) and (max-width:1439px){.el-nino-drought-outlook-wide{width:min(80cqi, 100vw - 32px)!important;margin-left:calc((100cqi - min(80cqi, 100vw - 32px)) / 2)!important;margin-right:calc((100cqi - min(80cqi, 100vw - 32px)) / 2)!important}} @media (min-width:1440px){.el-nino-drought-outlook-wide{width:min(140cqi, 100vw - 32px)!important;margin-left:calc((100cqi - min(140cqi, 100vw - 32px)) / 2)!important;margin-right:calc((100cqi - min(140cqi, 100vw - 32px)) / 2)!important}}

    With these factors conspiring, the Colorado River’s two largest reservoirs, Lake Powell and Lake Mead, are approaching the point of collapse. The potential for more rainfall this winter might help fill them, Schumacher said, but it can’t reverse the system’s precipitous decline. “It’s a long way to go to get even back to where we were a year ago,” he said. “Let alone when it was in good condition decades ago.”

    The wildcard this year is snowpack: It’s still too early to tell, Schumacher said, how much snow will fall in Colorado. Whereas rainwater flows quickly into rivers, making it harder to store without overwhelming infrastructure — hence all the destructive flooding of late — snowpack slowly releases water as things thaw in the spring. With a record low snowpack earlier this year, Colorado is in desperate need of bountiful flakes in the months ahead.

    Water agencies can’t change the weather, but they can at least change how they manage precipitation. Down in Arizona, cities like Tucson have been installing green infrastructure — basically dirt spaces that hydrate native plants — which slow down the flow of water, thus preventing flooding. “There’s really cool and clever ways of thinking about stormwater as a resource,” Crimmins said, “rather than a nuisance.”

    This story was originally published by Grist with the headline Extreme flooding in the Southwest foreshadows a wild El Niño winter on Nov 5, 2026.

    Categories: H. Green News

    Cows and cyclones: New push to design solar farms for cattle and climate, but is Australia ready?

    Renew Economy - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 01:01

    Companies are looking again at how to put more farmland under solar without disrupting operations or clashing with conditions, but is social licence pressure high enough in Australia?

    The post Cows and cyclones: New push to design solar farms for cattle and climate, but is Australia ready? appeared first on Renew Economy.

    Well Done, America

    Common Dreams - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 00:34


    Well that was a night. The glad spectacle of a newly sentient America tottering back to its capacious ideals was dubbed Orange Crush, Bluenami, a political earthquake, a wily tweak to Hegseth's coveted public execution and "one of the great acts of defiance in American history." It was both landslide too big to rig or stop and "extinction-level" rout. Above all, it was a thunderous rejection of fear, greed, lies, cruelty, war-mongering, authoritarianism. Tell your kids, urged Abdul El-Sayed, "The bad guys lost."

    Who knew, pundits marveled: Turns out if you keep lying, stealing, abusing children, terrorizing, kidnapping, assaulting neighbors, shooting people in the street, making it impossible to get food, gas, health care or education while gloating about it and lining your fat pockets, everyone hates you. So it was that a "Trump Reckoning" and GOP "Armageddon" beyond even their worst doomsday scenarios arrived wherein Democrats swept "nearly every race that matters” as Americans en masse embraced all the shithole, lunatic, transgender, anti-Semitic, dog-eating, Medicare-wanting Muslim Brotherhood communists they'd been so helpfully warned about, alas, in vain.

    This, of course, despite MAGA's best/worst efforts to re-draw districts, shutter polling places, strong-arm election officials, browbeat brown and black voters, pre-litigate election results they couldn't buy, and launch 1,000 DOJ "polling monitors" into all 50 states in hopes of targeting vulnerable minority districts. And yet, noted Garrett Graff, nothing untoward happened. Instead, voters "gave America another chance." Millions stood up, showed up, voted early, refused to bend the knee or be silenced. Graff said a friend wrote from deep-red Mississippi, where Democrat Scott Colom still had a stunning, razor-thin lead. "My flabbers are gasted,” she wrote. “Be on the lookout for pigs in the sky."

    "So much history was made last night," Graff added, much of it shaped by both the 250 years and then Trump's dark reign of white supremacist politics. The startling result: The most diverse set of newly elected lawmakers the country has ever seen, with one historian writing Dems are winning races "they haven’t won since they were the white supremacist party.” An Atlanta Journal-Constitution story begins, "In 1860, an enslaved man named Sheppard Peek was listed among the possessions of William Peek, a white man in Crawfordville"; Sheppard's value was placed at $1,400. In Georgia on Tuesday, his great-great-granddaughter, Keisha Lance Bottoms, was elected the first Black female governor in the country.

    Bottoms is just one of many historic firsts. Xavier Becerra, the son of Mexican immigrants, became California's first elected Latino governor. Deb Haaland became New Mexico’s first Native governor. Wisconsin and Nevada elected their first Black governors. There are three other first women governors. New Hampshire's Chris Pappas will become the first out gay man in the Senate. A trans woman won a House seat in...Alabama. Colorado elected its first Gen Z woman; she will be one of a record 100 women to serve simultaneously in the House. Democrats gained full control of a record six state governments, Southern voters swung 20 points to Dems, Jon Ossoff was easily re-elected on a platform, essentially, of "I don't like Nazis." Virginia ended Jim Crow after 124 years, and enshrined abortion in its constitution. Nancy LaCore, a former Navy admiral fired by Hegseth, flipped Nancy Mace's seat in South Carolina. The GOP lost all four of its gerrymandered districts in Florida. Egyptian-born Adam Hamaway, 57, will be the first Muslim elected to the House from New Jersey. A Rutgers-educated doctor, he served 8 years as a combat surgeon in the US Army before starting private practice in Princeton; he also volunteered in Gaza, Syria, Lebanon, Sudan, Jordan.

    Beating back a grotesquely Islamophobic campaign, Michigan's Dr. Abdul El-Sayed will become the first Muslim in the Senate.In his victory speech, he thanked "everyone who sent a dollar, made a call, posted a story and most importantly gave us your stake in democracy. You took a chance on the unlikeliest of candidates." Summoning "all the kids who watched and the parents who struggled to explain why the president openly mocked someone for their name or how they pray, let them (know) the bad guys lost...We deserve an America big enough for all our kids - let's go build it." He also cited the "delicious irony" that JD, whose "view of America is small, like him," is constitutionally obligated to swear him in come January.

    In another sweet spot and longtime pipe dream, Talarico took back Texas from the scandal-smeared Paxton in "not just a tsunami, but a bloodbath." Adding to the schadenfreude was the upset win by Gina Hinojosa, the state's first Latina governor-elect, over monstrous Greg Abbott. In a stunning twist, Dems also won every statewide office down to railroad commissioner, along with four Supreme Court seats; the wins prompted an explosion of noisy joy in Austin that "sounded like an Eastern European city that just overthrew a dictator.” The cherry on top: Texas' new Dem Attorney General, who campaigned on investigating Elon Musk after he moved his business there to escape California woke, can now prosecute him for state level crimes without any DOJ interference.

    Musk, who spent half a billion dollars nationwide and lost every race he tried to buy, is among MAGA fat cats, tech bros and grifters who'll likely be targeted by California's (easily reelected) Robert Garcia, set to chair the House Oversight Committee. His blunt message: "Lawyer up." Many others also feel "the only way we want Dems to reach across the aisle is with a subpoena." With an "accountability bill" ready, Dean Blundell argues, "A LOT of people need to go to jail" - Hegseth, the Trump family crypto empire, the DOJ hacks who covered up Epstein crimes, the Rapist-In-Chief, the sadists of ICE once it's been "torn down to the studs." Scores of voters also demanded justice for their victims Renee Good, Alex Pretti and Lorenzo Salgado Araujo by putting "I Voted" stickers on their memorials: "They were on the ballot."

    Over at the presumably ketchup-encrusted White House, Trump remains in his own daft fantasy world, the "lamest of lame ducks." He burbles he "looks forward to working with" the trans jihadists he says are destroying America, but he'll veto everything. He's awash in his "magnificent" ballroom. He insists if he was on the ballot "we'd have won IN A LANDSLIDE," but of course he was and CNN's John King is happy to name all the places he told voters to pretend he was: "They did. They'd had enough." Even his cultists - and ex-cultists - blame him: "The reason isn't them, it's you. You fucked us. We chose Hitler with Down Syndrome, and we lost." Online, meanwhile, the White House posted a desperate "PSA: Trump Is Still Your President." Like we could forget.

    Still, the seismic shift tentatively feels like a new dawn, a path toward redemption, a sliver of hope, the long-ago thing with feathers we can barely remember. Candidates, volunteers, organizers, lawyers stepped up, and vast numbers of Americans showed up to support them. The mood was buoyant. Some said they wished Mitch McConnell was alive to see the Senate results. The Borowitz Report said Mike Johnson begged God to "rapture him up" immediately; tearfully, he said that as a loyal Republican he couldn't bear to be in a "minority" because he hates 'em all. Another report said a bitter Elon Musk put Ken Paxton on eBay; no buyers yet. Also, tragically, two sources say cracks and peeling have again emerged in the Reflecting Pool, but MAGA is on it. Said an Interior spokesperson, "The Reflecting Pool has never looked this beautiful, and it's all thanks to President Donald J. Trump."

    - YouTube www.youtube.com

    - YouTube www.youtube.com

    Categories: F. Left News

    The 2026 Clean Fleet Awards demonstrate $25 million saved annually in fuel costs

    Pembina Institute News - Thu, 11/05/2026 - 00:01
    TORONTO — Winners of this year's Clean Fleet Awards are collectively saving an estimated $25 million annually in fuel costs and reducing oil consumption by approximately 250,000 barrels a year, demonstrating the financial benefits of going electric...

    Oligarchs Have Escaped Democracy. Greens Must Help Bring Them Back

    Green European Journal - Wed, 11/04/2026 - 23:57

    From the Epstein files to offshore tax havens and private islands, the world’s wealthiest are increasingly finding ways to operate beyond the reach of democratic governments. Decades of globalisation and political complicity have allowed oligarchs to carve out spaces where they can ignore laws and escape public accountability. As their power grows, democratic institutions are left increasingly hollowed out. Can the Greens help reverse this democratic retreat by bringing oligarchs back under public control?

    For many years, international headlines have been haunted by the long, ugly shadow of the Epstein files. It has become clear from the revelations in the documents that those given power in the globalised economy are now operating as oligarchs beyond the reach of democratic government.

    These files give a glimpse into just one of the conspiracies between the wealthy and the politicians who serve them. A decade ago, the leaks of financial details of the global elite through the Panama and Paradise Papers painted a similar picture of a corrupt class of citizens of nowhere who manipulate democratic politicians as though from some high-tech Mount Olympus. Far from public scrutiny, they have created spaces where they can live according to their own whims. I call these spaces “lacunae”, places where the oligarchs can ignore the laws framed by elected politicians, avoid paying their taxes, and engage in their unhinged fantasies. This disengagement by the world’s richest and most powerful men is ineluctably destroying the democracy that has prevailed at least in the West since the end of World War II.

    We can trace this subversion of democracy back 30 years, to the process of globalisation that enabled the super-wealthy to escape the democratic compact. It is nearly three decades since protesters were in the streets outside intergovernmental meetings in Seattle, London, Washington, and Melbourne, resisting political attempts to allow corporations to rule the world. And as Greens, we argued that this eventuality would be disastrous for our environment and our society as it would enable spaces beyond democratic control – exactly the sorts of “lacunae” we see now.

    Politicians like Bill Clinton and Tony Blair invented the framework they called the Third Way, seeking to counter the extreme marketisation of Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher but institutionalising corporate globalisation. Legal changes enshrined in agreements like NAFTA (North American Free Trade Agreement), public-private partnerships, and deep financial deregulation were part of a deliberate handing away of power that has since been used to justify performative helplessness in the face of growing corporate power. The devastating consequences of this abnegation of democratic authority are now visible all around us: the question is, what can we, as Greens, do about it?

    This article is based on thinking that I outline more fully in a pamphlet I recently published, where I describe five lacunae: knowledge, moral, legal, tax, and monetary. In this article I will outline in brief the legal and tax lacunae; the others are described in the pamphlet itself.

    Offshore and beyond the law

    Not content with lobbying and bullying politicians to reduce their tax rates and the regulation that constrained their worst excesses, the oligarchs have begun to create worlds altogether beyond the reach of elected politicians, in the offshore secrecy jurisdictions that have always enabled the wealthy to operate beyond the law. Think, for instance, of settlements like Peter Thiel’s Próspera on the island of Roatán in Honduras, or Elon Musk’s drug-fuelled fantasies of off-world colonies on Mars. These are what I call the “legal lacunae”.

    In his seminal book Captive State (2000), George Monbiot lays out many examples of how insidiously corporate domination creeps into government. Monbiot details a series of case studies of local and national governments handing over power to corporations, ranging from the corporate takeover of the British National Health Service (NHS) to the supine acceptance of “genetic engineering” techniques and a series of pro-corporate trade treaties. One of these agreements was especially shocking: the Multilateral Agreement on Investment (MAI), the plan for corporate domination that we have seen play out over the past three decades.

    Negotiated in secret, the draft treaty was leaked in 1997 and was due to be signed in Paris in October 1998. By then, French citizens had seen the threats to laws they valued, like those protecting their food and farming sector and their film industry, and then-prime minister Lionel Jospin withdrew his country from the agreement, leading to the MAI’s ultimate collapse. It is worth noting again that this was being done in secret; without a courageous whistle-blower leaking the draft we would have known nothing about it and politicians would have waved it through.

    On the other side of the Atlantic, Bill Clinton betrayed the trust of the American workers by facilitating the process of globalisation that would destroy their conditions of work and life. Through NAFTA (1994), and then by radically extending the power of the World Trade Organisation so that it could overrule national democratically elected governments, Clinton was a key architect of the legal lacuna within which corporations and oligarchs have thrived. His embrace of trade with Beijing and support for admitting China into the WTO in 2001, with special status as a “developing country” was the final nail in the coffin of employment and environmental standards in the US.

    People were told at the time that only the low-skilled jobs would be offshored, and that those who lost them would be able to retrain for well-paid jobs in service of the new-style, globalised economy. This didn’t happen, and what we see now is the implicit bargain politicians struck with the oligarchs: that we would lose skilled, well paid employment, but in return, we would get cheaper consumer goods, including virtual products. This trade-off was entirely concealed at the time, no doubt for fear it would be rejected. Undoubtedly, politicians of the Left, like Blair and Clinton, felt they were doing their best for working people by bowing to the “inevitable” tide of globalisation and at least guaranteeing an enhanced lifestyle through a wider range of cheap consumer goods. But the implicit trade-off in terms of quality employment was never made explicit and has led to disillusionment amongst voters. The lies now being told around AI are similar: citizens can get computers to run your their while they sit on the sofa spending their income on having food and goods delivered to their door.

    Behind this smokescreen of an interconnected global village with higher living standards and continuing skilled employment, corporations were making use of the global nature of the new markets to evade protective legislation in the national markets where they sold their products by producing them offshore. This critique was made explicitly by many Greens, but we were dismissed as radicals, dreamers, and “conspiracy theorists”. The threats that were clear to many of us nearly 30 years ago have since become a reality. And it is now time to demand politicians who do not sell us out to powerful corporations and oligarchs out of self-interest or sheer laziness.

    Tax haven; democratic hell

    The tax haven is the prototype lacuna. It goes without saying that most ultra-rich people have not amassed their wealth through generosity of spirit and many resent having to contribute any of their assets for the public benefit through taxation. It was the tax haven that taught them how they could evade their responsibility for the social contract and live entirely selfish, self-serving lives. It is also the area I know most about, having spent five years as an MEP trying to build a fair global taxation system.

    The story of the tax haven begins in the era of decolonisation, when rich and powerful Europeans who had literally “owned” other people’s land and operated it as a personal, self-enriching fief were forced to give up this injustice. Their public response was to accept the inevitable with as much grace as they could muster, while out of sight they created lacunae that enabled them to carry on the centuries of exploitation that had made them and their families rich. The UK overseas territories were vital to this process, as the country hung onto various random pieces of land that were so small as to be easily overlooked but where those with enough wealth, power, and connections to make use of them hid their wealth and continued to avoid paying their fair share.

    The Brits also invented that deceitful fiction, the trust. The trust is basically a conjuring trick: money is temporarily placed in limbo, without an apparent owner. For tax and regulatory purposes, it is made to disappear. Money in trusts apparently belongs to nobody and is completely unregulated. The law around trusts plays with the concept of ownership, allowing the wealthy to separate themselves from their assets, which are assigned to trustees. Because the purpose of the trust is to conceal assets, we cannot provide data for the volume of tax evaded through this means. However, the Tax Justice Network (TNJ) has given some particularly extreme examples, such as Sam and Charles Wyly in the United States, who set up a number of offshore trusts to shield more than 1 billion dollars in family wealth. TNJ also mentions the Duke of Westminster in the UK, who managed to inherit an estate of 9 billion pounds held in trust, escaping around 3 billion pounds in tax. There is an obvious answer here: that all governments should be required to create registers listing the beneficial owners of all trusts falling under their jurisdiction, something Greens have argued for in the European Parliament.

    As oligarchs have moved their cash offshore, the tax base has become eroded. As a result, it has become harder and harder for democratic politicians to invest in the sorts of public services and infrastructure that citizens of democratic societies expect. The value that is accrued by the billionaires is sucked out of the bank accounts of citizens, who blame their immiseration on the politicians they chose to protect them. Unless democratic politicians find the courage and strategy to challenge the oligarchy, the future of democracy looks uncertain. Young people in particular are losing faith in democracy and moving to the political extremes, including to parties who idealise street action above democratic engagement.

    During my time as an MEP (2014-20) I sat on a number of tax investigatory committees, all created as Green initiatives. We helped to expose tax avoidance on a massive scale, with the active support of some very brave journalists and employees of the offshore industry who were prepared to risk everything to lift the veil on the secrecy that shields the financial activities of the rich and powerful. Rather like the Epstein files, first the Panama Papers and then the Paradise Papers made public what the oligarchs and their lackeys would rather was kept secret. It bears repeating that what we see here is a mere glimpse of the corruption of global elites – if only a few sets of documents from a handful of companies can implicate this many, what would full transparency achieve?

    So what do we do?

    As a Green politician, I’ve spent most of my life trying to gain power through the ballot box and use it to make life better for people and planet. But what can be done if the power has actually escaped from the democratic system altogether? What should we as Greens do about that? Clearly, we need politicians at national level with the courage to restore the power that politicians had over domestic laws before the process of globalisation, as discussed above. But it is precisely the movement of companies beyond national jurisdiction that is entailed in globalisation that requires a wider response.

    The paradox of our time is that democratic politics is failing just when we need politicians to have the most courage. But the democratic crisis offers an opportunity to those who are genuine democrats and prepared to take on the oligarchs. I see a historic role for Green parties in this moment of crisis. The lacunae I have identified are the direct result of generations of politicians working hand-in-glove with oligarchs and the corporate hierarchy. Voters have grasped this democratic betrayal and their response is to reject “establishment” politicians. For many this means choosing the far right; but Greens are opposed to the establishment too, and just as ready to work for the people, as we have always done.

    The policy proposals needed to bring the oligarchs back within democratic control are obvious but not easy. We cannot expect the problems of the last 30 years to be solved overnight, but we can demand of our politicians that they identify the problem, abandon their posture of learned helplessness, and start working together to solve it. We need to have the courage to explain our political project within this framework: the Greens are already leading the charge against fascism, yet we must go further and build a concerted and practical policy platform to challenge oligarchic power. I am not arguing that we should become populists, proposing simple solutions to complex problems. Quite the reverse, in fact: a populist approach to politics leads to repeated disappointment with failed saviours who are seen to have feet of clay – and ultimately disillusionment with democratic politics itself. Greens can be bold and brave, but we can also be practical. We need to be all three just now.

    A number of specific and detailed legal changes are necessary to close the lacunae but some are particular urgently needed. Perhaps the most important is that all pieces of territory across the globe should be required to either be subject to the UN as independent states or become formally part of territories that are. As we found from the Epstein files, the “overseas territory” always was and still is the apotheosis of the lacunae we are seeking to fill. While we can demand much more from our domestic politics, it is also inevitable when seeking to contain people and companies who deliberately belong nowhere that we need to have international cooperation to bring them back down to earth.

    Because transnational corporations and off-world oligarchs are hard to constrain by democracies that operate at nation-state level, we also need politicians who are still committed to democracy and the rule of law to work together across national boundaries to reclaim their power. It was the escape from nation-state legal systems that turbo-charged the global oligarchy: only transnational cooperation can reclaim our power from them. I label this agreement between countries still committed to democracy and the rule of law a “coalition of the honourable”. Without it, the oligarchs will continue their game of divide-and-conquer – and we will all be the losers.

    A coalition of the honourable

    Canadian prime minister Mark Carney received much praise for the speech he made at the 56th World Economic Forum in Davos, where he argued that “intermediate powers like Canada, are not powerless”. They have the capacity to build a new order that encompasses our values, such as respect for human rights, sustainable development, solidarity, sovereignty and territorial integrity of the various states.

    While his rhetoric was welcome, Carney is wrong to think that capitalism can go through this “rupture” without significant reorganisation of its own structures, and this is where the proposals of green politics are so vital. While posturing as a bastion of sustainability and virtue on the world stage, Canada acts as home base to some of the most destructive mining companies in the world. To be taken seriously, the country would have to sign up to the UN binding treaty1 and bring into line its corporations that have been causing thousands of deaths across the world. In other words, without green politics and green policies, the domination of the oligarchs and the corporations will never be effectively challenged.

    How feasible is this sort of international cooperation at a time of rising nationalism? It would be wrong to suggest that, because many people are choosing nationalist, fascist parties, the majority have given up hope in cooperation between countries: the data shows clearly that the opposite is the case. Earlier this year, the Rockefeller Foundation published a vast 34-country survey asking people about their views on international cooperation: 57 per cent of respondents thought that their country should cooperate to solve global challenges even if it meant compromising on national interests, and this had risen two points from the previous year.

    This idea of an international effort like the coalition of the honourable is supported by 61 per cent of global citizens according to the Rockefeller poll. The fascists are trying to foster the sort of selfish, exclusionary, nationalist politics that leads inevitably to competition, impoverishment, and war, but a majority are resisting this. A survey commissioned by the UN Foundation and conducted by GeoPoll asked 5,000 people in 20 countries (including all 15 members of the Security Council) for their views on international cooperation. They found that nearly nine in ten believed that even the world’s most powerful countries need the international system rather than trying to confront today’s problems on their own. Their conclusion is that disappointment with the way international bodies are performing has not undermined the understanding that such cooperation is vital.

    Greens have been developing politics of social justice and defence of the planet for decades, and we have also developed a pluralist and inclusive style we call “doing politics differently”, where we accept that all parties have something to offer, however difficult this may prove to be in the heated reality of a coalition government. This sort of cooperation is going to be vital to build our strength in challenging the oligarchs, and we will need to accept this reality as we seek to recover from the decades when those who governed our countries ceded power to the Pax Americana and the corporations.

    Trump’s second term has underlined what we should really have known a decade ago: those countries that are still committed to human rights, democracy, and the rule of law need to urgently replumb our social and economic systems that are currently dominated by the very companies that are threatening our future. This means building strategic autonomy in finance and IT, as well as critical minerals and supply chains.

    This proposal is challenging but not unrealistic. Countries that can broadly be considered to still respect democratic values and the rule of law (including the UK, most EU members, Canada, Japan, South Korea, Australia, and New Zealand) together represent nearly a third of the global economy. This is a secure basis on which to build a new world order, and one that feels considerably more dependable than relying on the US or China.

    Revitalising democracy

    We can only expect citizens to share our respect for the rule of law and democratic government if we can demonstrate that it works for them. This means calling out the politicians of centre-left and centre-right who handed power to the oligarchs and making strong, practical proposals for taking that power back. We can see some important steps in that direction being taken; for example, the 890-million-euro fine imposed on Google by the EU for market abuse and the preliminary finding against Meta for addictive design of Instagram and Facebook, both under the Digital Markets Act (DMA).

    It is no accident that the growth of the lacunae has been accompanied by the diminution of our political dialogue and the shrinkage of our public space; nor that some of the leading oligarchs are also the purveyors of rhetorical division and disinformation. The EU democracy shield is a deliberate attempt to counter this, as is the UK’s proposed National Centre for Information Defence. Similarly, the funding for the European Digital Media Observatory and the European Fact-Checking Standards Network are a step in the right direction, as is the UK’s Amplify: The Local Media Action Plan. None of this legislation goes far enough but it does make clear that European lawmakers still consider it their role to regulate the public space, in contrast to the US, where the oligarchs have been handed untrammelled power.

    The fight for truth matters but it is in the arena of political economy that the future of democracy will be won or lost. The detailed platform of tax legislation proposed by Greens in the European Parliament is vital, followed by an agreement by the coalition of honourable countries to implement external tariffs against countries that renege and allow oligarchs to continue their flouting of the social contract. Other necessary steps include introducing legislation requiring proactive rather than retrospective licensing of products – including digital ones – and establishing a reconstructed and democratised global trade body to replace the WTO. Our politicians chose to give away their control and they can and must choose to take it back.

    The hegemonic power of US capitalism and the corporations and oligarchs that comprise it can feel overwhelming, but the Epstein files are the chink in their armour. Just as we pushed through anti-money laundering legislation by leveraging the revelation that financial secrecy had enabled the funding of the 9/11, we should now use the powerful disgust aroused by the filth of the Epstein revelations to mobilise the energy to shut down the lacunae where the oligarchs destroy the life chances of global citizens.

    1. The UN Binding Treaty is a proposed international agreement to require transnational corporations to respect human rights and ensure accountability for abuses linked to their activities. ︎

    Categories: H. Green News

    Pages

    The Fine Print I:

    Disclaimer: The views expressed on this site are not the official position of the IWW (or even the IWW’s EUC) unless otherwise indicated and do not necessarily represent the views of anyone but the author’s, nor should it be assumed that any of these authors automatically support the IWW or endorse any of its positions.

    Further: the inclusion of a link on our site (other than the link to the main IWW site) does not imply endorsement by or an alliance with the IWW. These sites have been chosen by our members due to their perceived relevance to the IWW EUC and are included here for informational purposes only. If you have any suggestions or comments on any of the links included (or not included) above, please contact us.

    The Fine Print II:

    Fair Use Notice: The material on this site is provided for educational and informational purposes. It may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. It is being made available in an effort to advance the understanding of scientific, environmental, economic, social justice and human rights issues etc.

    It is believed that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have an interest in using the included information for research and educational purposes. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. The information on this site does not constitute legal or technical advice.