You are here
News Feeds
Judge denies another Trump administration attempt to meddle with voter data in Common Cause v. DOJ
In a ruling on Nov. 2, Federal District Court for the District of Columbia Judge Sparkle L. Sooknanan denied the DOJ’s motion for a stay pending appeal in Common Cause and individual voters’ ongoing lawsuit challenging the federal agency’s attempts to obtain sensitive voter data and exercise control over states’ election processes. In response, Common Cause and its legal counsel issued the following statement:
“Once again, the Trump administration's efforts to hijack the elections have been stopped by a federal court. As today's decision reaffirms, the executive branch has no business meddling in how states manage their voter rolls—and no legal authority to do so. As they get increasingly desperate, the Trump administration keeps trying new twists on the same plan to meddle in November’s elections, and the courts keep saying ‘no.’ States have the constitutional authority to run elections, not the President.
“In American democracy, voters choose their elected leaders, not the other way around. Today's decision deals yet another blow to the Trump administration's efforts to gerrymander the voter rolls. The Department of Justice has no authority to — and no legitimate purpose for —consolidating voter data.
“Voters can cast their ballots this November with confidence that their personal information is protected.”
View the opinion here.
The Long Journey to Hold Canadian Mining Accountable
By Jan Morrill, Earthworks and Diana Martin, MiningWatch Canada
This month representatives of communities living in the shadows of the Pueblo Viejo gold mine and their allies traveled almost 30,000 kilometres around the world to draw attention to the impacts of its mining on their homes and families. They are calling for action to protect their health, safety, and to defend the rights of their communities. This shouldn’t have to be the case.
These Dominican activists visited Belgium, Panama, and Canada calling for more transparency and accountability from the Canadian company operating the mine, Barrick Mining, better oversight from the Canadian government, and the safe relocation of 450 families who say they are already suffering environmental and health impacts.
Calling out harm in LondonThe trips come on the heels of a complaint filed with the London Bullion Market Association (LBMA), an accreditation authority for gold, silver, and other precious metals. The complaint alleges the company’s public record of human rights violations and environmental harms is incompatible with LBMA’s internal guidelines, and therefore gold from the mine should not be traded on the London Bullion Market. The complaint highlights the pollution, health problems, and impacts on crops in communities around the mine. According to the lead lawyer filing the complaint, “If you sit in London and you set standards but don’t police them — to enable highly profitable metals trading to go on — then you should expect to be held to account.”
Communities search for answersCommunities have raised longstanding concerns about water contamination, air pollution, and other health impacts. One of Latin America’s largest open-pit gold mines, Pueblo Viejo has generated vast quantities of mine waste since commercial operations began. Barrick is now pursuing a major expansion that includes a new facility designed to store hundreds of millions of tonnes of additional mining waste and extend operations for decades.
The Comité Nuevo Renacer (CNR), an organization representing five communities affected by the Pueblo Viejo mine in the Dominican Republic — La Cerca, La Piñita, Las Lagunas, Jobo Claro, and Jurungo — has advocated for years for community relocation in response to the environmental and health problems they associate with living near the mine.
This advocacy includes unsuccessful efforts to obtain essential information from Barrick Mining Corporation regarding the mine’s environmental impacts and tailings facilities. Since 2021, the CNR and its partner organizations have written to Barrick, its CEOs, and to investors, requesting access to information and transparency about the impacts of the mine on communities and families. These requests for information have been ignored or answered with information that is incomplete or not relevant to their requests.
Calls for more transparency in BelgiumDuring the first week of October, Fernando Peña from the National Space for Transparency in Extractive Industries (ENTRE) and the Public Policy Observatory from the Autonomous University of Santo Domingo attended the Extractive Industry Transparency Initiative (EITI) annual meeting. Peña, the official representative for civil society from the Dominican Republic, highlighted the LBMA case and the concerns of local communities during the official event and in other spaces.
Government accountability in PanamaOn October 27, Casilda Lima, resident of Las Lagunas, member of the CNR and plaintiff in the LBMA complaint, presented testimony before the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights. As part of a hearing on the international obligations of Canadian extractive companies and their impact on human rights, Ms. Lima shared her experiences of living less than a kilometer from the tailings dam holding back mine waste for the Pueblo Viejo mine. She testified to the many health problems she is experiencing like headaches, nausea and trouble breathing, the dust that blows from the tailings and covers her house on a daily basis, and the noise from mining operations that keeps her awake at night. She highlighted the community calls for relocation, stating “…they should move us …to a place where we have water, where we have rivers, like what we had before [mining], now we don’t have anything.”
The CNR also presented written testimony as part of the proceedings, calling on the Canadian government to investigate the actions and impacts of Barrick, and to take all necessary measures to remedy the damages. They also asked the Canadian government to work jointly with the Dominican government to implement the resettlement project, which has been on hold for seven years, and urged the Government of Canada to take action to ensure that Canadian companies, including Barrick, comply with international standards and regulations on access to information and transparency, such as the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI), the Global Industry Standard on Tailings Management, and others.
Taking the message to CanadaFrom October 28 through November 4th, Leoncia Ramos, a representative of the CNR and resident of the community of La Piñita, and another plaintiff in the LBMA complaint, traveled to Canada to provide a first-hand account of the impacts of extractive activities on agricultural and rural communities in the Dominican Republic. Her testimony was included in a parliamentary press conference and she brought her concerns to representatives of the Canadian government, who committed to looking further into the issue. The Canadian Network for Corporate Accountability, representing over 40 civil society organizations, invited Ms. Ramos as a speaker at their biannual members meeting.
While Canada expands trade globally, back home the government is narrowing already limited avenues for accountability for abuses by Canadian mining companies abroad. Ms. Ramos leveraged her visit to urge Canadian decision-makers to act on community concerns and address the risks posed by mining expansion. She called on the government to implement due diligence legislation that ensures affected people have meaningful access to accountability and remedy.
Bringing justice homeThere should be measures in place to protect communities from harms associated with mining and ensure they have the information they need to make decisions about what is best for themselves and their families. When communities suffer harm, there should be timely and appropriate remedy taken by companies and national governments. If communities raise concerns, standards setters like the LBMA, and governments where the companies are headquartered should assume responsibility and take action.
The post The Long Journey to Hold Canadian Mining Accountable appeared first on Earthworks.
Will historic protests against ICE shape the midterms?
This article Will historic protests against ICE shape the midterms? was originally published by Waging Nonviolence.
Tomorrow’s midterm elections are widely viewed as a referendum on Trump’s second presidency. Prior studies have found strong associations between protest and U.S. election outcomes, including the 2010 and 2018 midterm elections. Protests can influence popular opinion on policy issues, boost turnout among eligible voters, and shape how candidates set policy priorities.
At the Crowd Counting Consortium, or CCC, we have tallied an extraordinary number of protests since Donald Trump’s second inauguration in January 2025. The majority of protests in Trump’s second term so far have named democracy or the presidency itself as a primary claim — think the nationwide Hands Off and No Kings protests in 2025 and 2026.
But among protests focused on more specific policy domains, one key theme stands out. The administration’s anti-immigration policies and expansive, violent crackdown on immigrants have generated active, grassroots support networks in neighborhoods across the country and fueled a wave of protests in support of immigrants’ rights. During Operation Metro Surge in Minneapolis and St. Paul, protests took place in over 30 percent of counties containing 80 percent of the nation’s population. March 2026 may have been the month with the highest number of pro-immigrant protests in U.S. history. A significant proportion of these protests occurred in counties that Trump won in 2024.
Trends in immigration-related protests since January 20, 2017Of course, the current wave of protest builds on a longer-term foundation of pro-immigrant demonstrations. Since the CCC started collecting data on protest in the United States in 2017, we’ve seen that protests against the federal government’s immigration policies have been a constant feature of the protest landscape across all three presidential administrations — Trump 1, Biden and Trump 2 (see Table 1).
Table 1: Immigration protest events as a share of all left/liberal protests
Little more than a week after Trump’s first inauguration in January 2017, numerous protests took place around the country in response to his Jan. 27 signing of Executive Order 13769, sometimes called the “Muslim Ban,” which restricted citizens of seven majority-Muslim countries from entering the U.S. On Jan. 28 and 29, mass protests occurred in and around airports, where immigrant rights groups and community members assembled to ensure the safe arrival of citizens of those countries who were in transit when the executive order went into effect. Protests against the executive order continued in February 2017 under the slogan “No Ban No Wall.” The Trump administration ultimately revised the executive order to a narrower version that the U.S. Supreme Court upheld as lawful; multiple protests followed on June 26, 2018.
But the biggest jumps in protest participation came on coordinated, nationwide days of action related to the administration’s immigration policies. The first, on June 30, 2018, was a national day of action declaring that “Families Belong Together.” These protests demanded an end to the administration’s “child separation policy” — the practice of separating migrant children from parents and caretakers upon arrival at the U.S.-Mexico border — which was in effect under the Obama administration but escalated under Trump. This protest campaign was highly effective: The pressure placed on the administration led the White House to end the policy through an executive order, though loopholes remained.
#newsletter-block_97e0c2853594db9da80dfd6b8dce8fd9 { background: #ECECEC; color: #000000; } #newsletter-block_97e0c2853594db9da80dfd6b8dce8fd9 #mc_embed_signup_front input#mce-EMAIL { border-color:#000000 !important; color: #000000 !important; } Sign Up for our NewsletterOn Jan. 19, 2019, the third annual Women’s March on Washington represented an additional increase in coordinated nationwide protests in which immigrants’ rights were a core issue. And July 12, 2019 saw the Lights for Liberty day of action, which attempted to pressure elected officials (particularly in the newly Democratic Congress) to close detention centers and adopt more humane immigration policies. Ultimately, congressional Democrats introduced legislation in 2021 to reunite immigrant children with their families. In sum, the first Trump administration saw an impressive range of protests on behalf of immigrants’ rights, some of which had powerful impacts.
Overall, the Biden administration saw a decline in such protests, with about 60 percent fewer than during the first Trump administration (seven percent to 11 percent as a share of overall left/liberal protests, respectively). Notable days of action during the Biden administration included continued protests calling for closure of Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE, detention centers, as well as protests against ongoing family detention and separation practices, and protests against asylum restrictions during a major surge in deportations in 2024.
During the second Trump administration, such protests have seen a breathtaking rise.
Figure 1 provides a comparative view of the number of immigration-related protests under the second Trump administration, compared to the first. The y-axis, showing the cumulative number of immigration-related protests since Trump’s two inaugurations, demonstrates the massive scale and steady climb of protests during his second term so far.
Figure 1: Counts of pro-immigrant protest events during Trump’s first and second terms
Figure 2 shows the frequency of such events on a monthly basis. There have been more protests in support of immigrants in seven of the months since January 2025 than in any of the 48 months of Trump’s first term. In 10 of the first 17 months of the current term, protests against Trump’s immigration policies made up over 20 percent of total protests. Few other protest claims have animated the public with such enduring salience over time.
Figure 2: Pro-immigrant protests in the U.S., January 20, 2017 – May 31, 2026
Figure 2 also shows clear increases in the number of immigration-related protests during nationwide anti-Trump protests. Spikes in activity occurred on April 19, 2025 during the Hands Off protests; on October 18, 2025, when many No Kings protests adopted opposition to ICE and Trump’s mass deportation agenda as a central claim; and on March 28, 2026, when the third No Kings protests again made immigration a primary claim. Our tallies have also documented 170 repeater events (protests that are scheduled to take place daily, weekly or monthly) that specifically mention immigrant rights or opposition to ICE in their stated claims.
In Illinois and Minnesota, protests started local and went nationalTrump’s immigration policies have produced particularly intense local mobilizations in areas that saw escalated ICE deployments, which then diffused to solidarity protests nationwide. For example, from early September to mid-November 2025, ICE launched Operation Midway Blitz targeting immigrants in Chicago. During that period, the CCC documented 3,491 protest events in opposition to Trump’s immigration policies, starting in Chicago and spreading across the country during the No Kings mobilization on Oct. 18, 2025, which named immigration as a central issue.
Operation Metro Surge, the federal immigration enforcement operation in the Minneapolis-St. Paul region, also provoked powerful opposition locally and beyond, with over 4,400 protests taking place between Dec. 2, 2025 and Jan. 31, 2026. Significant numbers of protests responded to specific, publicized government abuses, such as aggressive law enforcement actions against immigrants, the killings of Renée Good and Alex Pretti, and the detention of a 5-year-old child of a Colombian immigrant. Three waves of action stood out: the ICE Out For Good weekend of action on Jan. 10-11; the Day of Truth & Freedom on Jan. 23, which was concentrated in Minnesota; and the National Shutdown and ICE Out of Everywhere actions, which mainly spanned Jan. 30-31, with some events lasting into Feb. 1.
Figure 3 shows the number of counties that saw pro-immigrant protests in Illinois and Minnesota, respectively, after Operation Midway began in Chicago and Operation Metro Surge began in Minneapolis-St. Paul. Overall, these two states saw higher-than-average numbers of counties featuring protests, including among counties far afield from the major cities in which ICE focused its deployments.
Figure 3. Pro-immigrant protests in Illinois and Minnesota during and after ICE operations in Chicago and Minneapolis-St. Paul
Nationwide, the total volume of protest produced during early 2026 is extraordinary.
January 2026 alone featured the fourth-most protest events recorded in all 10 years of CCC data, owing to the massive number of protests in Minnesota and around the country in opposition to Operation Metro Surge and its impacts, and to Trump’s immigration agenda in general.
And the events in Minnesota seem to have been a flashpoint. Anti-ICE protests continued in February and March 2026, and anti-ICE claims were central to the nationwide No Kings mobilization on March 28. March 2026 may have been the month with the highest number of pro-immigrant protests in U.S. history (see Table 2).
Table 2: Top 10 months by total protest events, January 20, 2017 – May 31, 2026
Protests opposing Trump’s immigration policies were reported in 933 counties during Operation Metro Surge, between Dec. 2, 2025 and Feb. 1, 2026 — about 30 percent of all counties in the U.S. These counties were densely populated: Together, they contain more than 80 percent of the U.S. population (see Figure 4). From March 2026 through May 2026, the CCC continued to record thousands of events protesting ICE, with hundreds of distinct civic organizations and hundreds of thousands of people participating.
Figure 4: U.S. immigration protests following ICE deployments to Minneapolis
Nor are protests against ICE operations an exclusively liberal phenomenon. Instead, there has been a stark increase over time in the number of pro-immigrant protests in counties that Trump won in 2024 by at least a 5-point margin (see Figure 5). Among the pro-immigrant protests that occurred in March 2026, about 40 percent of them occurred in such counties.
Figure 5: Pro-immigrant protests in counties Trump won by >5 Points in the 2024 Presidential Election, January 20, 2017 – May 31, 2026
Across the country, a broad range of constituencies using a variety of means have expressed opposition to Trump’s immigration policy. Demonstrations have just been one method. Those activating on behalf of and in support of immigrants include people forming human chains to protect immigrant workers; neighborhoods organizing support networks for affected immigrant families; students engaging in walkouts from schools and protests at college career fairs; people engaging in hunger strikes in support of international and undocumented students; knitters engaging in “craftivism”; people holding encampments outside of ICE facilities or noise demonstrations outside of hotels in which ICE agents were housed; consumers engaging in boycotts and sell-backs at Target and Home Depot; clergy engaging in civil disobedience; communities holding vigils for slain immigrants or those killed while advocating for them; community members building raised beds across thoroughfares to prevent ICE vehicles from accessing facilities, and more. Institutions and employers have raised their voices: Local businesses and business associations have called for the end of ICE operations in their towns, ranchers and farmers have decried treatment of their immigrant employees, and the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops has condemned mistreatment of immigrants as well.
Counter-protest was minimalTrump’s immigration policies have supporters in the country, particularly among Republicans. But few people have rallied or marched in defense of them. Right-leaning protests made up fewer than two percent of all immigration-related protests during the first 14 months of the first Trump administration, and less than 0.7 percent of immigration-related protests during the same stretch of his second administration.
The frequency of pro-immigrant protests during Trump’s second term has eclipsed that of anti-immigration protests by 145 to 1. The vast majority of anti-immigration protests have been counter-protests occurring at demonstrations in support of immigrants and their rights.
However, right-leaning protests have been increasingly characterized by anti-immigrant claims over the past three presidencies. Whereas anti-immigrant protests constituted 1.68 percent of all right-learning protests during Trump’s first term, that proportion has increased sevenfold so far during his second, to 12.43 percent.
Table 3: Anti-immigration protest events as a share of all right/conservative protests
A powerful and growing pro-immigrant constituencyToday’s mass protests in support of immigrants’ rights build on a durable pattern of pro-immigrant and anti-ICE protest in the U.S. To wit, the CCC has documented a prayer protest outside an ICE facility in Broadview, Illinois that has been held every Friday for the past 20 years.
But the recent increase in pro-immigrant protests and their intensity is notable. The breadth and volume of pro-immigrant protests show that committed activists and organizations have succeeded in rallying huge numbers in favor of justice and dignity for immigrants, indicating a durable underlying infrastructure. In this essay, we focused on street protest as one indicator in the overall picture. But community mobilization on behalf of immigrants has meant far more than demonstrations. Mutual aid and neighborly support, observing and documenting ICE operations, litigation, support to immigrants in detention, and direct appeals to public officials have all been central to America’s response to Trump’s immigration policies. The growth of pro-immigrant protests reflects a (potentially growing) constituency willing to take risks to defend a multicultural vision of America, potentially widening its appeal.
#support-block_44025fcb71a2dbca0e27a3e6a63c9963 { background: #000000; color: #ffffff; } Support UsWaging Nonviolence depends on reader support. Make a donation today!
DonateIn short, we see capable organizers and the mass public pushing hard for humane treatment of immigrants for the foreseeable future. Neither political party has figured out how to address immigration in a way that resolves the need for safe and secure borders and the need to treat everyone on U.S. soil with dignity, decency and due process. But the impacts of Trump’s policies on immigrants, their families and their broader communities provide a galvanizing issue for Americans who otherwise agree on little else. For example, some conservative faith communities and various progressive groups increasingly find themselves on the same side when it comes to immigration.
Policymakers often resist turning to activists, civil society organizations and community groups for policy solutions. But the persistence of multi-sectoral immigration activism, as seen through protest alone, also reflects a powerful and growing constituency in favor of just and humane approaches to immigration. Protests reflect and shape the existing moral consensus but also can reorient constituencies in favor of a new consensus. We hope the members of the next Congress pay attention.
This article Will historic protests against ICE shape the midterms? was originally published by Waging Nonviolence.
How Food Is Helping Transform Residential Care in Ukraine
Effective Aid Ukraine, an Irish charity helping the Ukrainian community, is combining farming, cooking, and residential care reform to give young people of Lviv, Ukraine practical skills, confidence, and choice.
The project is based at Rozdil Friends Home, a residential center for boys and young men with disabilities. Residents displaced from eastern Ukraine after Russia’s invasion grow vegetables in a greenhouse, harvest fresh produce throughout the year, and learn how to cook and preserve food for future meals.
“It’s not just about teaching children how to grow food,” Tom McEnaney, Founder of Effective Aid Ukraine, tells Food Tank. “It’s choosing what you’re going to eat and being able to make it yourself,” he says. “That’s what leads to people having more fulfilled lives.”
Growing food also helps stretch the limited budgets of the nonprofit. Vegetables produced on-site reduce food purchases, leaving more money for clothing, repairs, and other daily needs.
Effective Aid Ukraine is now working to rebuild the center’s kitchen. When it is finished, residents will help prepare meals while kitchen staff become teachers instead of cooks. They will learn food safety, meal planning, and cooking skills they can use later in life as a career and to live independently.
The organization hopes their work will serve as a pilot to support a broader shift taking place across Ukraine. McEnaney sees the country moving toward community-based care. Working with the Lviv Regional Authority and its governor, Maksym Kozitzkyy, Effective Aid Ukraine is helping test how food production in residential care facilities can be scaled up and out.
Four years after Russia’s invasion of the country, more than 10 million people are in need of urgent humanitarian assistance in Ukraine and 3.8 million are internally displaced, according to the Office of the U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR). Effective Aid Ukraine sees rebuilding daily routines and pathways toward greater independence as an important part of the country’s broader recovery.
The UNHCR leverages food and cooking as catalysts for recovery across emergency settings and during times of conflict. The World Food Programme, along with UNHCR, call for decisive actions to ensure access to safe and sufficient nutritious food in times of crisis. Initiatives like the one in Rozdil build on those findings by connecting agriculture with everyday independence.
McEnaney believes the lesson of their work is simple: “It’s about giving people purpose, dignity, and fulfillment.”
Articles like the one you just read are made possible through the generosity of Food Tank members. Can we please count on you to be part of our growing movement? Become a member today by clicking here.
Photo courtesy of Effective Aid Ukraine
The post How Food Is Helping Transform Residential Care in Ukraine appeared first on Food Tank.
The Road to Organic Certification
Becoming certified organic is often a way for farmers to communicate their values to customers. It symbolizes a prioritization of environmental practices, especially within pockets of their market that they are unable to connect with face-to-face. With so many farmers already being worn thin with responsibilities, the often career-long decision to get certified can be daunting, especially without full clarity about what benefits await on the other side.
The post The Road to Organic Certification appeared first on RAFI.
Stop the harmful use of tebuthiuron in Taos County
Living in Taos, I have come to appreciate the unique beauty and ecological importance of our land. But now, this precious environment is under threat. The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) Taos Field Office, in collaboration with the U.S. Wildland Fire Service, plans to apply tebuthiuron, a soil-activated herbicide, to about 2,929 acres of public land in northern Taos County. This action, involving the aerial dropping of herbicide pellets onto dense brush, is a practice we must urgently question.
Tebuthiuron specifically targets sagebrush by inhibiting photosynthesis, which may sound like a controlled solution, but the broad-spectrum impact of this herbicide can lead to unintended and severe environmental consequences. Our local flora, including non-target species, could be irreparably harmed, disturbing the complex ecosystems that many wildlife species depend on.
Furthermore, community health stands to be affected. According to the Environmental Protection Agency, exposure to tebuthiuron may have adverse effects on humans and animals, which poses a risk to the residents living nearby who cherish and rely on these lands for recreation and cultural practices. The possibility of contamination of our groundwater is also a concern, as the pellets can leach into the soil and disrupt aquifers that supply our drinking water.
While addressing overgrowth and fire risks is essential, the adoption of safer, more sustainable land management practices is possible. Prioritizing mechanical clearing or controlled burns, involving local restoration ecologists in decision-making, and increasing public consultations can ensure a balanced approach that safeguards our habitat and health.
We cannot allow an indiscriminate solution that jeopardizes our environment and well-being. I urge BLM and the U.S. Wildland Fire Service to re-evaluate the use of tebuthiuron in this operation and seek alternative, eco-friendlier strategies.
Please join me in urging the BLM to reconsider their methods by signing this petition. Together, we can protect Taos County’s land and ensure a healthier environment for generations to come.
Shayna Gladstone Petition StarterTaos County is a very special place & it does not need to be poisoned. The water, people & animals need to come first. There are other ways to get rid of the sage if you must. Please be like Europe & stop using this chemical
Melvina , Nunica, MI, United States.
Sign the Petition https://c.org/9fRRwZsjt6
Why Formal Intervention Matters in the Kentucky Power Audit
At a time when accountability and transparency are especially important for Kentucky Power customers, the Kentucky Public Service Commission’s decision to deny intervention status to the Mountain Association, Appalachian Citizens’ Law Center, and Kentuckians For The Commonwealth in its audit of Kentucky Power is disappointing because it limits how we can contribute to the process.
For nearly a decade, the Mountain Association and our partners have formally intervened in utility cases affecting Eastern Kentucky. We’ve participated because the people we serve are directly affected by the outcomes. From small businesses and nonprofits to local governments, volunteer fire departments, and families struggling with high energy bills, we bring perspectives that might otherwise go unheard.
Intervention in most PSC cases allows stakeholders to formally participate in a case by filing testimony, presenting evidence, conducting discovery, and helping build the official record. Those tools help ensure that decision-makers hear from the customers who live with the consequences of those decisions every day, versus just the utilities or groups like the Kentucky Industrial Utilities Customers who has been increasingly partnering with the Kentucky Attorney General to jointly intervene.
In this case, we wanted to intervene to be able to review the Request For Proposals (RFP) and give our input in scope and selection of an auditor. The audit was called for by the Public Service Commission this July 2026 following their most recent rate increase case.
Kentucky Power serves more than 160,000 customers in far Eastern Kentucky. Their customers face some of the highest electric bills in the state, and many households in the region already struggle with significant energy burdens and low income. Kentucky Power has raised their rates four times in ten years. In that time, residential rates have risen 75% and small commercial rates have risen 35%. An audit of the company’s operations and management is an important opportunity to examine why these repeated, significant rate increases are needed and what the company can do differently to better protect its customers who aren’t able to just take their business elsewhere.
“We appreciate that the PSC has directed the selected auditor to engage with stakeholder groups as part of determining the audit’s scope, but there is an important distinction between being interviewed and being a party to the proceeding,” said Robin Gabbard, President of Mountain Association. “The people who pay those bills should have a meaningful role in that conversation and our role as an intervenor would have centered those voices.”
While we may not have been granted formal intervention, we will continue bringing those voices forward throughout this audit process and in the other cases our Energy Team continues to intervene in on behalf of Eastern Kentuckians.
To learn more about our history of utility intervention, please visit our Policy webpage: https://mtassociation.org/policy
The post Why Formal Intervention Matters in the Kentucky Power Audit appeared first on Mountain Association.
Has the Green Party been Captured by the Left?
Adrian Ramsay, Green MP and former co-leader of the Green Party of England and Wales, has told the BBC, that the party is at a crossroads, on what kind of party it is to be. He cited the ‘Zionism is Racism’ motion adopted at the party’s recent autumn conference, as a break with the traditional philosophy of environmental focus.
Ramsay said "One option is to sort of dig in more down this approach, not only in relation to this motion, but I think that there's a risk it brings with it - a quite divisive, a quite internally focused approach to politics."
Ramsay said this is "perhaps seen from small groups of people on the hard left of politics who go around different parties trying to influence how those parties are run."
As reported by The Guardian, Ramsay went on to say, “There is also a small number of people who have joined, perhaps from the very hard left of politics, who might be more at home in the SWP or with George Galloway or with Your Party. [They] not only want to adopt some very hardline positions on certain issues, but have a very different culture to how they go about it.” Those members were seeking to “seeking to change the direction of the party.”
What is taking place here, is that this is part of an ongoing attempt by the establishment of the party to regain control after Zack Polanski was elected as leader of the party last year. Ramsay, along with Ellie Chowns, another Green MP, stood against Polanski for the leadership, and were endorsed by former leader and former Green MP, Caroline Lucas.
Polanski won with 84% of the vote, a crushing defeat for the party establishment who didn’t want him to become leader, and they were worried about losing their influence in the party. They bided their time and waited for an opportunity to strike back.
The party’s membership shot up from about 60,000 to 230,000 which made it difficult to complain about things not going well, so they needed a cause. Something that would appeal to more traditional type of member and would lead to the newer, suspect members to leave to leave the party.
The ‘Zionism is Racism’ motion passed at autumn conference became the trigger. I think the establishment thought there was a chance it would pass, and started preparing. When the motion did pass, they went into action. What made this an even better vehicle for the fight back was that the Holborn and St Pancras Parliamentary byelection would take place a few days later, where Polanski was the Green party candidate.
On mainstream media, even before the vote was declared, although Lucas probably knew that Labour would retain what is a very safe seat, launched into a speech about how the ‘Zionism is Racism’ motion had cost the party winning the seat. There is no evidence for this, but once she said it, it became a news story in itself for mainstream media. So, the campaign had begun. Ramsay’s latest media intervention is just the campaign moving along.
Mainstream media reports that 18,000 people have left the Green party since Zionism motion was passed. I don’t know if this true, but I have seen a few members saying on social media they have left over the motion, but I’ve also seen some say they left over the pro-nuclear policy passed at the same conference. I’ve also seen some say they have joined the party because of the Zionism motion.
The whole thing has the uncomfortable feeling that this is another right-wing coup, similar to what happened in the Labour party when Jeremy Corbyn was leader. Spread smears about antisemitism, demand expulsions of members on spurious grounds for being antisemitic and creating an atmosphere where the newer members will leave the party.
I’m proud to be a Green Lefty or ecosocialist, as we say, and have been a member of the Green party for over twenty years. Our numbers were fairly small, but now many left-wing people see the Green party as the most viable party to deliver any kind of socialism and anti-neoliberalism.
This minority establishment should stop waging this divisive civil war and realise that the party has moved on. Ecological justice cannot be separated from social justice, because the effective cause of both of our ills is the same, capitalism. If we don’t want to challenge this system, the party will remain on the margins of politics and so be completely irrelevant.
Interactive: Who wants what at the COP31 climate change summit
- Just transition
- Climate finance
- Adaptation and mitigation
- Global stocktake and NDCs
- Action agenda and other issues
Delegates will soon gather in the Turkish resort city of Antalya for UN climate negotiations, against a backdrop of war, energy crisis and climate extremes.
At COP31, nations will try to find agreement on various issues, including climate finance for developing countries and a global “just transition” towards a cleaner economy.
This summit is unusual due to its joint presidency, which means that Australia is leading the negotiations while Turkey hosts the conference.
Outside the formal negotiations, Turkey is also pushing its own priorities as part of a wider “action agenda”, including electrification, oceans and “green industrialisation”.
In order to track parties’ positions on key negotiating points and wider issues at COP31, Carbon Brief has analysed around 100 documents and captured them in the interactive table below.
The first column shows the countries and UN negotiating blocs, the second shows the topics up for debate and the third indicates specific issues within those topics.
The final column indicates the positions that the parties have expressed on each topic. These range from “priority” – meaning the party is likely to be pushing the issue – to “oppose”, meaning it is likely to push against it.
This is a “living document” that will be updated over the course of COP31.
Please get in touch if you would like to offer additions by emailing policy@carbonbrief.org.
Brief explanations of the key issues and jargon-filled language that permeate the talks can be found below the interactive table.
(() => { const iframe = document.getElementById('cop31-who-wants-what'); const iframeOrigin = new URL(iframe.src).origin; window.addEventListener('message', (event) => { if (event.origin !== iframeOrigin || event.source !== iframe.contentWindow) { return; } const message = event.data; if ( !message || message.type !== 'cop31-who-wants-what:resize' || !Number.isFinite(message.height) || message.height < 0 ) { return; } iframe.style.height = `${Math.ceil(message.height)}px`; }); })(); Just transitionAt COP30 in Brazil in 2025, nations agreed to establish a practical mechanism to help drive a “just transition” to a low-carbon economy.
Key aspects of this "Belém-Antalya mechanism" (BAM) – often referred to as the “just transition mechanism” (JTM) – were agreed during the June climate negotiations this year, but many details are missing and dividing lines remain between parties.
Parties have disagreed about the scope of the mechanism and whether it should be tied to the provision of finance.
Nevertheless, following progress in June within the “just transition work programme” (JTWP), civil society groups highlighted that getting the mechanism up and running is a “key expected outcome” from COP31.
Climate financeClimate finance is always a highly contested issue at UN climate negotiations.
Developing countries have successfully pushed for a “work programme” on climate finance to feature on the conference agenda.
These parties see this programme as a way to pressure developed countries into providing more funding from their public coffers, specifically under Article 9.1 of the Paris Agreement. Some are even proposing a “burden sharing” arrangement for climate-finance provision.
This comes against a backdrop of major donors cutting their aid budgets and the Trump administration in the US pressuring multilateral development banks (MDBs) to drop their climate objectives.
Developed countries, which have traditionally been responsible for providing finance, would prefer to keep a broader focus on issues such as improving access to existing finance and broadening the range of donors. Some developing countries, such as small-island states, also support these goals.
Nations have also been discussing Article 2.1c of the Paris Agreement under the “Veredas dialogue”. This focuses on making all global “financial flows” consistent with climate action.
Countries have different views about what this involves, with developing countries again hoping to keep the focus on developed countries’ responsibilities to financially support them.
Adaptation and mitigationAt negotiations in June, parties were unable to agree on the details of a “global goal on adaptation” (GGA), which is intended to drive climate adaptation worldwide.
Having agreed at COP30 on a list of 59 “indicators” – ways to assess progress towards the GGA – nations now need to refine these before COP32 in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. This is a highly technical process that involves a taskforce working out how to use and track these indicators.
Broadly, developing countries stress the importance of finance to fund adaptation efforts, rather than simply to track progress. They also want reassurances about a pledge made last year to “triple adaptation finance”.
At the June climate negotiations, negotiators also failed to make any progress when discussing the mitigation work programme (MWP) – the only formal agenda item that concerns cutting greenhouse gas emissions.
Among other things, parties disagreed on whether the MWP should continue running over the next few years, or simply be brought to a close.
Global stocktake and NDCsBack in 2023, the first “global stocktake” (GST) of the Paris Agreement set out the state of climate action and what needed to be done to set the world on course.
On mitigation, nations agreed to a package of measures, including “transitioning away from fossil fuels”, tripling renewable energy and “halting and reversing deforestation” by 2030.
Some of these outcomes remain contentious among certain parties, particularly large, developing countries and those with economies that rely on fossil-fuel exports.
Developing countries have persistently argued that they need more climate finance to implement the global stocktake outcomes.
Parties were meant to update their climate plans under the Paris Agreement, informed by the first global stocktake, by 2025. These plans, known as nationally determined contributions (NDCs), cover the period out to 2035.
So far, only 150 parties – responsible for three-quarters of global emissions – have submitted new NDCs.
Iran, Vietnam, Egypt and Argentina are among those without new NDCs – and the US has withdrawn its climate plan under the Trump administration.
Some parties, such as the EU, have stressed the need for countries to submit their new NDCs ahead of COP31 – and to ensure they are aligned with the 1.5C temperature limit.
COP31 will also see the launch of the second global stocktake, which will conclude in 2028.
Action agenda and other issuesTurkey will be pushing its “action agenda” priorities at COP31, including global targets for electrification, reducing waste and reducing building-sector emissions.
(The Australian “presidency of negotiations” is intending to pursue a “cover text” decision at COP31 that may capture some of these wider targets, such as the electrification goal.)
The action agenda is meant to provide a complementary track to the formal negotiations, where governments and non-state actors can advance specific, real-world solutions.
A new COP31 presidency effort dubbed the “climate implementation bridge” is also meant to complement these ambitions by turning NDC goals into an “investable project portfolio”
Some parties have explicitly signalled their support for various elements beyond the formal negotiations, in the run-up to COP31.
For example, a joint letter signed by 105 parties called for COP31 to “put the ocean at the heart of climate action” by embedding ocean-based climate action in the UNFCCC architecture.
Interactive: Tracking negotiating texts at the COP31 climate summit 05.11.2026 COP31 Antalya Experts: What China wants from the COP31 climate talks 29.10.2026 China policy Interview: COP31 president says electrification is ‘surest way to protect citizens’ 10.07.2026 COP31 Antalya Bonn climate talks: Key outcomes from the June 2026 UN climate conference 19.06.2026 AdaptationThe post Interactive: Who wants what at the COP31 climate change summit appeared first on Carbon Brief.
More E-Bikes on National Park Trails Is a Bad Idea
The Trump administration is trying to allow more electric bikes onto national park trails, according to Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER). New rules being finalized by the National Park Service (NPS) weaken the environmental reviews required under a successful PEER lawsuit brought during the first Trump term challenging an attempt to allow e-bikes wherever pedal bikes are allowed to travel.
Today marks the end of the public comment period for these proposed new rules. In its public comments, PEER raises concerns that the rules expanding e-bike access to park trails:
- lack any provisions to monitor or prevent injuries and conflicts with other trail users, such as hikers and horseback riders;
- do not address disturbing wildlife or the danger of wildfires caused by overheated e-bike batteries; and
- dramatically reduce public involvement in decisions to expand e-bike access.
“This is yet another example of the Trump administration’s deep aversion to considering consequences before acting,” stated PEER Executive Director Tim Whitehouse, noting that the primary rationale for the rules are executive orders promoting deregulation and reducing environmental reviews. “Safeguards against abuse from e-bikes will depend upon shrinking cadres of park law enforcement rangers trying to cope with ever-growing demands on their time.”
One major issue PEER raises is e-bike access to park wildlands. While e-bikes and other mechanized transportation are not allowed inside congressionally designated wilderness, there are 26 million acres of park backcountry lacking such protection. Several “flagship” parks such as Yellowstone, Glacier, Big Bend, and Grand Canyon, for example, do not have any designated wilderness and are “protected” only by NPS policies that can be waived or changed. The proposed NPS rules open doors for park managers to allow e-bike access to backcountry trails.
“Our concern is that e-bikes could be allowed in the most remote, wild places within the national park system,” added Whitehouse, pointing out that PEER has no objection to e-bike access on paved roads or trails in parks’ developed front-country. “It will become harder to appreciate the wonder of nature above the constant whir of e-bike motors.”
Another complication is that the new NPS rules would not preempt the growing number of state laws governing e-bike equipment and use. As a result, future e-bike restrictions may vary widely from park to park.
###
News Roundup: Fierce debate as California changes course in central water hub
Following two days of public comments opposing the proposal, the State Water Board approved Governor Newsom’s updated Bay-Delta Plan centering voluntary agreements.
As the Los Angeles Times reports, environmental and Tribal representatives condemned the exclusionary framework and lack of transparency surrounding the decision-making process. They criticized “what they described as backroom deals intended to help powerful water suppliers and farming companies” at the expense of the already fragile Delta Estuary and California taxpayers.
The State Water Board’s decision came despite widespread public opposition and limited public access to information. State agencies used confidentiality agreements to restrict access to scientific data and discussions central to the plan’s development. As Shingle Springs Band of Miwok Indians Vice Chair Malissa Tayaba told the board members: “You are on the wrong side of history, and we will prevail.”
The likely next governor of California, Xavier Becerra, will be left to clean up the mess. Implementation of the widely criticized plan faces further uncertainty as the federal government threatens to withdraw from the plan, taking several hundred million dollars in funding with it. As Becerra prepares for the upcoming election and a possible transition into office, the San Francisco Chronicle reports that “environmentalists, tribes and fishing groups have said they will urge him to prevent the Bay Delta Plan from moving forward.”
Read more coverage of the decision below:
- COMMENTARY: Reject the discriminatory, illegitimate, and harmful Voluntary Agreements. Maven’s Notebook.
- RESTORE THE DELTA: Tribes and environmental groups slam State Water Board’s anticipated adoption of updated Bay-Delta Plan, vow further action. Maven’s Notebook.
- Fierce debate as California changes course in central water hub. The Los Angeles Times.
- Has the Trump administration doomed Newsom’s water plan?. CalMatters.
- California regulators adopt major overhaul to state water policy, drawing critics. The San Francisco Chronicle.
- California approves sweeping Bay-Delta water plan as environmentalists push back. Courthouse News Service.
- Newsom races to lock in his water legacy. POLITICO.
Trump appointee has illegal cabin in Idaho national forest
A cabin the U.S. Forest Service ordered removed from Idaho’s Sawtooth National Recreation Area in 2024 is still standing, and the man whose company was told to take it down, Michael Boren, now oversees the agency as U.S. Department of Agriculture undersecretary for natural resources and environment, according to High Country News and Public Domain.
In November 2024, the Forest Service sent a cease-and-desist letter to Galena Mines LLC, then managed by Boren, after finding the cabin had been built nearly a mile north of the company’s mining claims. The letter ordered the cabin removed by July 1, 2025.
Since Boren’s arrival at USDA, the Forest Service has shown no sign of enforcing its order. A USDA spokesperson described the structure as a warming hut built by backcountry skiers “for public use as needed.” When asked about a video posted by American Hunters and Anglers showing the cabin’s door boarded over, the spokesperson said the hut “could be used in the event of a winter emergency.”
The cabin isn’t Boren’s first clash with the Forest Service. He built a 2,500-foot airstrip on his Hell Roaring Ranch inside the national recreation area, and described the work to the Army Corps of Engineers as “pasture improvement to eliminate gopher holes and weeds.” The Forest Service warned him in 2021 against further development, and Boren sued critics of the airstrip for defamation.
Boren’s 2025 ethics agreement and financial disclosure did not list Galena Mines. USDA said his family has had no ownership stake since May 2024, but Idaho business records list Boren as the company’s manager until February 2025, and Forest Service officials discussed the cabin directly with him in November 2024.
Judge orders inquiry into potential DOJ misconduct in D.C. golf course caseDistrict Judge Ana Reyes has ordered an inquiry into potential misconduct by Trump administration officials over President Donald Trump’s plans to redevelop the East Potomac Golf Links in Washington, D.C. The move comes after she learned that the government has been working for weeks to submit the redesign plan to the National Capital Planning Commission, a detail the DOJ lawyers failed to disclose in recent hearings.
Earlier in October, the U.S. Department of the Interior cleared more than 400 trees from the golf course, which the agency described as part of a routine “tree maintenance plan.” Judge Reyes quickly intervened and ordered a halt to the cutting.
Quick hits Powerful House lawmaker raises Tribal concerns with permitting bill Judge orders an inquiry into potential DOJ misconduct in Trump’s golf course caseNPR | New York Times | The Hill
Opinion: Oil and gas leases on public lands Forest Service finalizes transfer of management of Maroon Bells San Juan River now forecast to rise 4 feet higher than 1911 historic flood in Pagosa SpringsColorado Sun | Salt Lake Tribune
International tourists stayed away this summer, and Utah’s Mighty 5 felt it Osage Nation speeds up orphan well cleanup as federal oversight recedes Developer plans $113M housing project on former BLM land near Las Vegas Quote of the dayOur public lands should be managed for their many values, not endlessly kept available for oil and gas leasing until the deal finally becomes discounted enough for a speculator to take advantage of.”
—Angelyn Tabalaba, deputy director for the Nevada Conservation League, Las Vegas Review-Journal
Picture This @usinteriorSt. Croix National Scenic Riverway winds through more than 200 miles of Minnesota and Wisconsin, offering some of the most scenic and least developed landscapes in the Upper Midwest.
Paddle beneath wooded bluffs, camp amid the Northwoods or cast a line surrounded by fall color. Along the way, watch for bald eagles and other wildlife that call the riverway home.
Photo by Craig Blacklock
(Featured image: Sawtooth National Forest near Stanley, Idaho. Katja Schulz, Flickr)
The post Trump appointee has illegal cabin in Idaho national forest appeared first on Center for Western Priorities.
Revealed: Pro-AI Data Center Group Spending At Least $2.54M on TV Ads to Influence Ohio Election
A pro-AI data center group purchased at least $2.54 million worth of television ads that ran recently in Ohio, a new DeSmog analysis reveals. The group, Build American AI, is linked to Leading the Future, a major AI industry super PAC backed by Silicon Valley billionaires.
The ads extolled the economic benefits of Ohio’s data center boom, one of the hottest issues in the state’s Senate election, but did not endorse either candidate in the race: Trump-aligned Republican incumbent Jon Husted, who was appointed by Governor Mike DeWine to serve out Vice President J.D. Vance’s term, and former three-term Democratic Senator Sherrod Brown.
“When some people hear data centers they picture computers and servers,” says one Build American AI ad. “But we see something different: electricians, engineers, manufacturers.” The ad states that data centers have brought more than $40 billion in investments and created over 95,000 jobs in Ohio.
“The future won’t be built by politicians or special interests,” states the ad, “It’ll be built by American workers right here in Ohio.”
The ads appeared on at least 16 Ohio television stations between September 7 and October 21, according to Build American AI’s filings with the Federal Communications Commission, which described them as “non-candidate issue ads.”
A still from one of Building American AI’s pro-data-center ad campaign in Ohio during the race for Senate between Republican Jon Husted and Democrat Sherrod Brown. Credit: Via Google Ads Transparency Center.Build American AI ordered at least $2.5 million in ads in Ohio, $1.5 million in ads in Wisconsin and $1.1 million in Kansas between September 7 and October 24, according to DeSmog’s analysis. Jesse Hunt, the group’s head of communications, confirmed that the group is spending over $5 million in the three states, but did not comment on the exact amounts.
Build American AI has been described by Politico as a “subsidiary” of Leading the Future, a super PAC which was formed last year to promote AI industry interests. Leading the Future has emerged as a major player in 2026 election cycle — backing both Democratic and Republican candidates in primary races earlier this year.
The super PAC has received about $125.79 million in contributions during the 2026 midterm election cycle as of October 29, according to Federal Election Commission (FEC) filings. Most of that came from a handful of donors: $25 million each in individual contributions from tech venture capitalists Marc Andreessen and Ben Horowitz, $50 million from their venture fund Andreessen Horowitz, also called a16z, and $12.5 million each from OpenAI co-founder and president Greg Brockman and his wife Anna Brockman.
OpenAI is part of a joint venture with SoftBank, Nvidia, the U.S. Department of Energy, and other partners to build a mammoth data center complex on federal land in Pike County, Ohio. The project would include an on-site gas-fired power plant designed to produce 9.1 gigawatts of power — larger than any gas-fired power plant currently operating worldwide, and enough to power about 7 million homes.
OpenAI’s investors include the Andreessen Horowitz venture capital fund. OpenAI’s energy chief is John McCarrick, who as an energy official in Trump’s first administration promoted exports of U.S. liquefied natural gas to Europe following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, and advocated for Asian countries to invest in natural gas.
Andreessen Horowitz did not respond to a request for comment.
OpenAI did not respond to DeSmog’s request for comment on the Brockmans’ personal donations to Leading the Future, or its stance on using gas-fired power for its data centers.
In August 2025, OpenAI co-founder and president Greg Brockman posted on X that he and his wife, Anna Brockman, were “supporting” the Leading the Future superPac to advocate for “a balanced view” of AI policy, “which we think of as optimistic realism, towards achieving AI’s benefits.” Credit: @gdb account on XMarc Andreessen is also a board member of tech giant Meta, which is building “Prometheus,” a massive data center in New Albany, Ohio, about 15 miles northeast of state capital Columbus. The partially-built computing complex runs on natural-gas turbines — and is designed to scale to one gigawatt, enough to power about 800,000 homes.
These projects are among dozens of proposed data center projects in Ohio, which is strategically positioned atop part of the Marcellus Shale, the biggest gas field in the U.S.
The AI boom is on track to worsen the climate crisis, which is on the verge of passing the key 1.5 degree Celsius (2.7 degrees Fahrenheit) limit on global heating that nations set in the 2015 Paris Agreement.
Based on current trends, the energy demand of new U.S. data centers could increase the nation’s carbon emissions by 24 to 44 million metric tons a year between 2024 and 2030, according to a recent study published in the journal Nature Sustainability — equivalent to the tailpipe emissions from an additional 5 to 10 million additional gasoline-burning cars.
Marc Andreessen recently called the climate crisis “over” in a post on X, and has praised fracking as an “incredibly positive outcome” of energy industry research and development.
“Energy should be in an upward spiral,” wrote Andreessen in his “Techno-Optimist Manifesto” in 2023. “The more energy we have, the more people we can have, and the better everyone’s lives can be.”
Both he and Horowitz have each contributed at least $3,500 to Husted’s re-election campaign since late 2025, according to FEC filings.
Mark Andreessen responded sarcastically in June to an X post by French economist Thomas Piketty about unequal wealth and the climate crisis: “SMH the climate crisis is over, Greta has pivoted to Palestine, and the rest of us are panicking over data centers. Do keep up.” Credit: @pmarca account on X.Build American AI’s ads appeared after Sherrod Brown’s campaign ran a series of ads branding Husted “the face of data centers in Ohio” and lambasted him for supporting multi-billion-dollar, greenhouse-gas spewing data center developments as well as for handing out tax breaks for data center developers.
Brown’s campaign spent $2.4 million on ads criticizing Husted’s support for data centers as of late August, according to political ad spending tracker AdImpact.
The ads caught the attention of the National Republican Senatorial Committee, which sent out a memo in mid-August to “interested parties” about “Ohio’s data center risk,” as first reported by Axios. The memo warned that Brown’s opposition to data centers had turned the issue into “the anchor hanging around Husted’s neck” that could get him voted out of office. “The companies that need these projects built have to fix how Ohioans see them: who benefits, who pays, and why a community should want one,” the memo stated — the themes of Build American AI’s TV ad campaign.
Sixty-three percent of Ohioans oppose AI data centers, according to a recent poll by The New York Times. As of September, the state has over 125 local data center moratoriums in place, as well as 21 ballot measures across 16 counties targeting data center construction, the most of any state. “People who would wave at their neighbors that they’ve seen for 10 years but never have spent the time on their porches” are “looking past partisan differences to fight for their communities,” Nick Owens, an attorney in rural Ohio, told DeSmog. Owens, who said he is a Republican, volunteers with the campaign Conserve Ohio, which is seeking to ban large-scale data centers in the state.
Looking ahead, local community groups in Ohio are attempting to gather 413,000 signatures needed to put a statewide data center moratorium on the ballot in 2027.
“Grassroots people who frankly have one hundredth the level of funds [of tech leaders] are battling these fights,” said Owens. “It’s really David versus Goliath, but the righteous people in this case, I believe, will prevail: the people who live in their communities.”
The post Revealed: Pro-AI Data Center Group Spending At Least $2.54M on TV Ads to Influence Ohio Election appeared first on DeSmog.
Survivors on Sacred Ground: Crested Caracaras Spotted at Historic Woodlawn Cemetery
Every Fraction of a Degree Counts, and So Does Every Acre of Habitat
Turning Global Climate Commitments into Action at COP31
State food chemical laws don’t create chaos. They make food safer for everyone.
More than a dozen states have now passed laws restricting certain chemicals from food. Most apply to food served in schools, and a few may apply to food sold in stores.
Companies have argued that differing state laws make food manufacturing and distribution systems less efficient – and that this “patchwork” of requirements could make food more expensive. Major industry groups have even backed a draft bill in Congress to block them.
But the industry argument doesn’t hold up.
What usually happens instead: When one state raises the bar for consumer safety by passing a new law saying what can and can’t be in products, companies often change their products nationwide, extending the new law’s benefits to everyone.
These are just a few examples of “patchwork” state laws that made consumer products safer for all of us: removing toxic flame retardants from furniture, bisphenol A, or BPA, from baby bottles and higher-risk ingredients from food.
How did California get toxic flame retardants out of furniture?Before 2013, most furniture sold in the U.S. contained toxic flame retardant chemicals in its upholstery foam. The foam helped furniture pass product safety tests.
But research linked these chemicals – also commonly used in baby products like strollers, car seats and nursing pillows – to multiple health risks, including cancer, hormone disruption and deficits in attention and learning in children, without providing meaningful fire safety.
As a result, California began updating its testing standards and phasing flame retardants out of products sold in the state.
The effort faced fierce industry opposition. Chemical corporations spent millions lobbying to keep the old standard in place. One such company, Chemtura, sued California to overturn the new rules. The company lost, and the new standards took full effect in 2015.
In 2020, Congress adopted these same standards as a federal requirement through the Safer Occupancy Furniture Flammability Act – helping all states switch to product safety tests that kept chemical flame retardants out of furniture.
How does state policy protect infants from BPA in baby bottles?In 2009, Minnesota became the first state to make baby bottles free of BPA, a synthetic estrogen linked to early puberty, impaired immune function and other developmental harms.
Ten more states followed with their own policies restricting BPA in children’s products. Most laws targeted baby bottles, sippy cups and infant formula containers.
Under pressure from state lawmakers and attorneys general, major manufacturers took BPA out of products nationwide, regardless of which states those items were sold in.
By 2012, so many manufacturers had already dropped BPA from baby bottles and sippy cups that the FDA formally ended its use in those products.
The Food and Drug Administration in 2013 also ended the use of BPA in formula packaging.
What has been the California Food Safety Act impact?The California Food Safety Act banned four food additives – Red Dye No. 3, brominated vegetable oil, potassium bromate and propylparaben – from food sold in the state starting in 2027.
Food companies pushed back. The Consumer Brands Association and other industry groups together opposed the bill. The National Confectioners Association called the legislation part of a “patchwork of inconsistent state requirements created by legislative fiat that will increase food costs.”
But by 2024, multiple states had introduced similar bans.
In early 2025, the FDA revoked authorization of Red 3 in food. That same year, major manufacturers, such as Kraft Heinz and General Mills, began announcing plans to reformulate products without artificial colors.
No company has announced planned price increases associated with the changes.
What would the FRESH Act do to state food chemical laws?The food industry’s “patchwork” argument isn’t just a talking point – it’s the basis of a draft bill.
The FRESH Act would block state bans or restrictions of food additives, or even mandatory warnings. The bill was proposed by Rep. Kat Cammack (R-Fla.).
If enacted, it would push groundbreaking state laws like California’s off the table – laws that have helped rid consumer products nationwide of chemicals like Red 3.
History is clear: When states act, companies change their products for everyone, for the better. The chaos predicted by food companies never actually occurs.
States aren’t the problem in our food safety system. Until the FDA adopts stricter regulations to help protect people from toxic chemicals, states are filling the gap.
What can you do?Tell your members of Congress to oppose any federal bill that strips states of the power to protect their residents from harmful food chemicals.
In the meantime, you can check what’s in your groceries using EWG’s Food Scores database, which provides ratings of more than 150,000 food products based on ingredients of concern, nutrition and processing.
Areas of Focus Food Food Chemicals Authors Sarah Reinhardt, MPH, RDN Scott Faber November 2, 2026When ‘After’ Means Alive
At first glance, it looks almost like an embrace.
One coral fragment is pale, its branching form pressed against a smaller, richly colored counterpart. Nine weeks later, the pale fragment has regained its color. Seen against the black background, the transformation is unmistakable. Something living has made contact with something struggling, and the struggle has changed course.
I keep returning to the place where they meet.
There is a scientific explanation for what happens there. There is also an emotional response that arrives before the explanation, before the species’ name, before any understanding of the experiment. We recognize vulnerability. We recognize proximity. We see what looks like help.
Giving Recovery a ShapeThe research behind this remarkable coral moment, led by Stanford doctoral student Danny Collins and captured in a series of photographs, concerns a particular kind of recovery. Bleached coral fragments placed in contact with healthy, genetically identical fragments fused tissues, allowing beneficial algae to move into the depleted coral. Recovery followed within weeks.
Photos © Danny Collins. Used with permission.“We thought that some transfer could take place, but we never would have expected it to be so fast, clear, and beautiful,” Collins wrote in an email.
The paired photographs released with the study give that discovery a shape, a before and after. We can locate it, follow it, see where it begins. The point of contact becomes the center of the story.
For someone unfamiliar with coral biology, it also offers a way into science. Collins, whose background includes visual and media studies alongside marine science, was thinking about that invitation from the start.
Collins holding coral fragments. © Dan Griffin GG Films, used with permission“I had a broad audience of all ages and backgrounds in my mind throughout this entire study,” he said. “I wanted everyone to be able to understand our study in just one image and have them say, ‘Wow, I get it.’”
The close view brings the coral into an intimate scale. Its textured surface becomes visible. The contrast between the fragments gives the eye somewhere to begin. The second photograph rewards the attention paid to the first.
When the Sequence ChangesFor those accustomed to environmental before-and-after photographs, this sequence can feel almost disorienting. We know the usual direction. The forest becomes a clearing. The glacier retreats. The reef loses its color. “Before” holds abundance; “after” records what has been taken away.
Here, “after” means recovery.
The reversal does not diminish the importance of documenting destruction. Such photographs provide evidence, preserve memory, and make damage harder to deny. I would never want conservation to surrender that work. But I worry about what happens when loss becomes the only future our images teach us to anticipate.
If every sequence ends with less life, where do we learn to picture the work of repair?
An image of recovery makes room for a different question. Instead of stopping at what happened to the coral, we begin to wonder what helped it. Attention moves toward a process, toward the conditions that made a different outcome possible. There is still damage in the frame, but there is also something to investigate.
The Beauty Survives ExplanationAnd then there is the metaphor, which is difficult to resist.
Healthy coral comes to the rescue. It melds with its bleached counterpart. Life appears to pass across a boundary. Anyone who has ever needed another person during illness, grief, or exhaustion may find something familiar in that arrangement. The photographs seem to offer a small, wordless account of being helped.
The fragments are genetically identical, and their fusion is no evidence of compassion. The embrace is something I see.
The healthy coral extends its polyps underwater. © Danny Collins, used with permissionBut Collins also finds meaning beyond the mechanism. “I find this represents the power and importance of contact, an idea that can be extended well beyond corals,” he said.
The apparent gesture has physical substance: Tissue connects, and beneficial algae move through it. The beauty survives explanation.
What One Coral Can PromiseA powerful photograph travels easily — and these generated headlines around the world. The qualifications attached to a scientific paper travel less reliably. These two panels offer a satisfying ending that the research itself cannot yet promise.
“I want people to recognize that these experiments were just done in the lab and we have not solved coral bleaching, the ocean is still getting warmer, but that this research opens a door to new possibilities for recovering corals that have already bleached,” Collins said.
Supplying a healthy genetic match for every bleached coral is not feasible at the scale that reefs require. The finding opens a research direction; making it useful in the ocean remains work ahead.
This coral does not owe us reassurance about the whole ocean. Its recovery is worth understanding without asking it to settle the fate of reefs.
Between Damaged and LostThe photographs also ask us to reconsider the boundary between damaged and lost. To an unfamiliar eye, the pale fragment may already look finished. Its recovery exposes the risk in that assumption. A living thing can be in profound trouble while still retaining capacities we have not learned how to support.
What can still be done, by whom, under what conditions, and with what prospect of success? Those questions remain worth asking after the dramatic injury, when the headlines have moved on.
There is human labor beyond the edges of the photographs, too. Someone maintained the experiment, observed the changes, made the images, examined the evidence, and worked with colleagues to understand it. The apparent simplicity of the two panels compresses a process that requires time, skill, and resources.
Tissues bridge between the two coral fragments. © Danny Collins, used with permissionA useful public response would follow that work outward. Who supports it? What would the next experiment need? How can people help sustain the institutions, environmental protections, and communities on which conservation depends? The photograph opens those questions; communication needs to carry them further.
Otherwise, even the most moving image risks becoming another brief encounter in an endless scroll.
An “After” Worth Working TowardThere is something else missing from these photographs: a picture of the coral before it bleached.
The sequence begins with injury already present. We never see an original, undamaged condition against which to measure everything that follows. We enter the story at a moment when something has gone wrong, and the question is what happens next.
That feels familiar. Much of conservation begins in places already altered, with populations already diminished and relationships already disrupted. People arrive with concern, skills, and resources long after the opportunity to prevent all harm has passed. They must decide what remains possible from here.
Collins’ own description of the research begins in that uncertain territory. “This all started from a simple experiment that has blossomed into a fascinating deep dive with surprises at every corner,” he told me.
The finished photograph can conceal that uncertainty. Placing two moments beside each other makes the passage between them look almost inevitable. But the researchers did not begin with the second image in hand. They had to ask a question whose answer they could not yet see.
Anyone considering whether to support conservation faces some version of that problem. The outcome is unavailable when commitment is needed. A restored habitat cannot be photographed in advance. The work asks people to invest attention, money, and effort in a future that remains contingent.
Here, at least, we can see that an intervention was followed by recovery. That does not tell us how the next experiment will end. It gives the next question a basis.
It also makes me think about what we demand of restoration. An imagined return to an untouched world can be a powerful aspiration, but it can leave every achievable improvement looking inadequate. Historical conditions matter: they help us understand what has been lost and resist accepting impoverishment as normal. Yet the distance from those conditions cannot be the only measure of whether work is worth doing.
A damaged place may have a future worth protecting even when its past cannot be fully recovered. Deciding what that future could support requires evidence, local knowledge, and difficult choices about priorities. There is no photograph that can make those choices for us.
But this one offers a useful starting position. The injury has already happened. Something remains alive. Someone decides it is worth finding out what might help.
The second panel exists because that question was pursued.
A Reason to StayAs an ocean conservationist, I want images like this to do more than provide a moment of relief. I want them to make people curious enough to stay, to learn the limits, to discover where their own abilities might be useful. Feeling something can be the beginning of participation if we make the next step visible and possible.
I return to the two panels and find the injury still there in the first. Nothing has been erased from the record. The second panel simply prevents the first from having the final word.
Republish this article for free! Read our reprint policy. Previously in The Revelator:Ghost Reefs of 2083: The Paleontology of Color (A Speculative ‘Fiction’)
The post When ‘After’ Means Alive appeared first on The Revelator.
Budgeting for a slow march to war when a “mad dash to net zero” is what we need to be safe
Budgeting for a slow march to war when a “mad dash to net zero” is what we need to be safe
Photo by flickr.com/photos/thomashawk/
John Healey’s first budget nudged and nurdled but certainly didn’t challenge 45 years of neoliberalism and chart the “new course” that Andy Burnham hinted at in September.
And, while there was a resounding statement about being “unshakably committed to net zero” the measures taken indicate a hollowing out of that commitment under the pressure to prepare for war.
In particular, it showed a willingness to bend the knee to Trump’s demands on the North Sea, with headlines announcing that Healey will veto new offshore wind projects “if they will not lower bills” at the same time as Treasury tax calculations factored in income from the development of Rosebank. As there are about half a dozen other fields waiting in the wings for this decision, this looks like an attempt to defy geology, economics and safety to appease the White House and its local attack dogs.
In the rest of the budget that was clear from what was not said as much as what was.
To end the upward pressure on energy pieces we need to end the war on Iran
The fact that the increases in energy bills that have already had a big impact on the cost of living – and are hovering over the future like a pyro-cumulonimbus cloud – has been caused by the US/Israeli attack on Iran was acknowledged. But this was taken as a given. Just one of those things that happens. Least of all was there any commitment by the UK government to oppose it, or step back from complicity in it; and “defensive” attacks on Iran will still be launched from Diego Garcia.
As a result of the war, Fossil Fuel companies are making colossal windfall profits. Shell’s have nearly doubled and BPs have quadrupled. This enables them to invest in more marginal oil and gas extraction; because the increased prices everyone is paying for them makes that potentially profitable, though a sign that the industry doubts its own future is that it is not rushing to do that. Increased emissions if they do. Increased damage. The banks that finance them -and arms companies – are also quids in from this war. A 100% tax on war profiteering would act as a disincentive to all this while raising billions to invest in the transition. Silence on that. Free pass.
Breaking with neoliberalism requires putting social needs above profitability. The chancellor appears to be as relaxed about these companies getting ”filthy rich” from war profiteering as Peter Mandelson was; and he’s not proposing to increase their taxation even though there is majority support for it.
The proposed Energy Wealth Fund from current rates of taxation on Fossil Fuels is a gesture in this direction so minimal as to constitute deflection more than commitment.
Clean energy is the solution
The recognition by the chancellor that the renewable energy already installed in the UK has massively cut the impact of fossil fuel prices rises is vital – especially in the face of the Fossil Opposition in Reform and the Conservative Party – who argue (with a straight face) that an 83% increase in wholesale gas prices since this time last year means that we need to use more of it to bring bills down – and that investing much, much more in the most expensive possible source of electricity generation – nuclear power – will do the same.
In 2020 gas set the price for electricity 90% of the time. It is now much more expensive, but sets it for just 60% of the time, and it’s coming down. That cuts bills. The chancellor’s stated ambition to “break the grip of gas on bills” is vital. But, how far do the measures in his budget rise to that challenge?
The decision to hold back on new renewable capacity that cannot easily be connected to the grid requires prioritising investment into grid upgrades to open up bottlenecks like the one between Scotland and England, which causes frustrating curtailment costs and unnecessary gas back up use. Without that investment, all this will do is slow up the growth of renewable capacity.
Approving Jackdaw, Rosebank and, by implication, the other fields that are queuing up for approval, the government will lock us into expensive fossil fuel dependence, and the planet wrecking emissions that go with them, and the costs of that, for longer than we need to. The phrase that we will “rely on oil and gas for decades to come” is designed to fudge the key question of how much; and avert the obvious point that the less we have to use the better it will be.
Bombs not Jobs
While the forced march of military expenditure increases is now being set at a slower pace than he was arguing for when he resigned as Defence Minister in the Summer – a 3.5% increase projected for 2035, not the 5% he saw as an imperative then – nevertheless, he’s still undermining security through climate action by diverting funds to war. And there remains the risk that the 10 year plan spending review will seek to step up the pace again. Meanwhile:
- £1 billion will be cut from the Warm Homes Fund “to help cover a shortfall in defence expenditure”. The WHF is set to provide loans of between £7500 and £35,000 for households to install solar panels, heat pumps and batteries; initially with £15 billion in funding and aiming to support 5 million households. Leaving aside GJA’s longstanding critique of this market led subsidy approach – which benefits those who can afford it, leads to work being done in penny packets by small firms which are not always competent or even honest, misses out on economies of scale and thereby gets a smaller bang for a buck – this cut will lead to over 330,000 households missing out. There’s also a threat that a further £4.7 billion will be “reallocated” from this scheme to pay for “Your First Home” scheme. That would cut a further 1.5 million households from benefitting from this. Higher bills, Higher emissions. A lower level of economic activity doing this work, so fewer jobs.
- The heat pump grant via the Boiler Upgrade Scheme will be cut by £800, leading to 100,000 fewer installations in the next 3 years. Again. Higher bills. Higher emissions, A lower level of economic activity. Fewer jobs.
Wider aspects of the transition are also being undermined.
- The continuing freeze on the fuel duty escalator will cost £4.3 billion by 2030. This continuing Fossil subsidy is presented as providing a relief for drivers but as Social Market Foundation Chief economist Gideon Salutin points out: “it does not work. Many savings are gobbled up by fuel retailers, who keep the price level and pocket the difference. Most of what’s left is taken by rich motorists who tend to drive more and own less fuel-efficient cars. Previous freezes have seen the richest tenth of earners save three times as much as the poorest tenth…. If government really wants to help hard-up drivers, it would support them into an EV, which are cheaper to operate than petrol cars, and support affordable transport services like buses and rail.”
- The welcome but minimal £100 million to cut the cost of public EV charging is 1/43rd of the fuel duty freeze cost. Charging 20% VAT on workplace charging will also slow the shift to EVs.
- There is to be no extension of the 0% VAT rating on “energy saving materials” including solar panels from next April – increasing costs, slowing the transition, increasing emissions, depressing jobs.
- At the same time, 10,000 “energy hungry” companies will get a 20-25% discount from next April, with back payments to cover this year comes with no conditional requirement to reduce energy or provide renewable on site supply.
- Data Centres difficult to connect to the grid that are considered “exceptionally strategic projects” will be allowed to generate their own power with gas or diesel generators even though the experience of the United States is that the surge in construction of gas-fired power plants to run AI data centres is “set to undo 15 years’ worth of greenhouse gas reductions from US electricity generation”.
- New planning powers will also be used to accelerate Data Centre grid connections; which begs the question, over what?
- Exempting brownfield development sites of <1.5 hectares from biodiversity net gain regulations is a bit like Donald Trump paving over the White House Rose Garden; but doing it again and again and again, all over the country.
Social Justice Measures?
- The £100 Council Tax rebate for households in bands A-D will do little to dent the impact of the sharp rise in the energy price cap; which is projected to be £470 above current levels by the middle of next year. This is in a context of household energy debt projected to total £7 billion by the end of the year.
- The VAT relief on electricity bills worth £45 a year is already in place, so won’t dent this any further.
- The cut in the gas standard charge is a small but progressive measure that will benefit lower income households, also by about £45 a year, and marginally reduce the price differential between gas and electricity per unit from 3.3 to 3; because the loss of the standing charge will be covered by an increase in charges per unit. So, those who use the least will benefit the most, so this is a small nudge towards electrification away from gas for heating and cooking. The electricity standing charge remains in place until next year, but if the same method is employed to get rid of it, it would make the price imbalance between gas and electricity worse.
- This is a marginal, and typically market led, gesture when it has been established that installing solar panels with batteries could cut energy costs for the poorest households by two thirds. But that would require a state led investment plan carried out as a social service, not a vehicle to generate business for micro firms, as it would not be affordable for the people who need it most, nor profitable for private companies to deliver. That is what a break with neoliberalism would actually look like.
The chancellor sticks with the mantra that “growth” will solve all problems, without reflecting on the problem that expenditure on war preparation – leaving aside more profound objections to it – is one of the least effective ways of generating any; because the kit you buy with it won’t do anyone any good – just harm if it is used. Investing in any other sector of the economy – health, education, transport, social housing and infrastructure construction – generates actual benefits as well as the economic activity that goes with it.
If you want a “growth sector” that will pull the rest of the economy into a healthier place, it’s the green sector; currently growing at 9% a year as the rest of the economy flatlines. So, if you want a healthier, livelier economy, green it!
The “breathing space” the Chancellor has given the government, before its course is set by the pending 10 year plan, should be used to push them in the right direction, because there is no breathing space in the rate at which climate breakdown is accelerating.
The GJA’s model motion is a useful way to take up the debate about the policies we need in union and party branches, and student unions too. Feel free to adapt it to your circumstances.
By Paul Atkin
Join the debate
Send us your contribution to the debate. We will contact you about using it here on our News & Debate page.
Name
Contribution
SubmitThe post Budgeting for a slow march to war when a “mad dash to net zero” is what we need to be safe first appeared on Greener Jobs Alliance.
AFSA at CBD COP17: The Negotiations Have Ended, but the Struggle for Biodiversity Justice Continues
The world cannot continue negotiating the future of biodiversity while the communities who sustain it struggle to protect their seeds, lands, knowledge and livelihoods. This was the conviction that guided the Alliance for Food Sovereignty in Africa (AFSA) throughout the 17th Conference of the Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD COP17) in Yerevan, Armenia. Over two intensive weeks, our six-member delegation stood alongside African farmers, Indigenous Peoples, local communities, youth movements and civil society allies to defend a simple but fundamental principle. Biodiversity justice must put people, rights and nature before corporate interests.
COP17 delivered the Yerevan Pathway and completed the first global review of progress under the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework. The findings were sobering. The world remains off track to meet its 2030 biodiversity targets, while inadequate financing, harmful subsidies and gaps in implementation continue to undermine progress. For AFSA, this reinforces a central concern. Global commitments mean little unless they bring meaningful change to the communities conserving biodiversity every day. We cannot continue financing the destruction of nature while promising to restore it.
Throughout the conference, AFSA carried Africa’s priorities into negotiation rooms, high-level panels, side events and public mobilisation spaces. We defended farmer-managed seed systems and the right of farmers to save, use, exchange and share their seeds. We championed agroecology as a practical pathway to biodiversity conservation and food systems transformation, consistent with Target 10 of the Global Biodiversity Framework. We challenged the promotion of false solutions, including approaches to synthetic biology that fail to adequately address equity, precaution, sovereignty and community rights. We called for fair and transparent benefit-sharing and a Cali Fund that genuinely serves the farmers and communities whose stewardship of genetic resources makes scientific and commercial innovation possible.
A major highlight of our engagement was AFSA’s side event on 24 October, titled “Digital Sequence Information (DSI): Understanding the Debate and Defining an African Civil Society Position.” Organised in collaboration with African civil society partners, the event brought the critical questions of equity, biodiversity sovereignty and community rights to the centre of the DSI debate. It provided a platform to examine how the growing use of digital genetic information affects Africa’s biological resources and the communities that have conserved them for generations. At the heart of the dialogue was a fundamental question. Who benefits when biodiversity becomes digital, and who has a voice in deciding how those benefits are shared? The event reinforced AFSA’s call for fair, transparent and accountable benefit-sharing arrangements, stronger protection of traditional knowledge and farmers’ rights, and coordinated African civil society advocacy to ensure that scientific innovation advances biodiversity justice rather than deepening existing inequalities.
Our delegation amplified these demands through strong interventions, strategic alliances and collective action. From the call to “Stop financing destruction!” to the pan-African campaign “Seed Is Life”, AFSA reaffirmed that Africa’s agricultural biodiversity is a living heritage, not simply a resource for commercial exploitation. Our engagement with the Just Transformations Network and other civil society allies strengthened solidarity across movements. As negotiations reached their final stages, we stood with young people inside the Blue Zone, raising our voices against false solutions and reminding world leaders of a truth too often forgotten. “You cannot eat money!”
We leave Yerevan with renewed solidarity, stronger alliances and a clear sense of the work ahead. Progress in global biodiversity governance must be judged not only by negotiated decisions, but by whose rights are protected, who controls resources, who benefits from their use and whether communities have the power to shape their own futures. AFSA will continue working with its members and partners to translate these demands into national policies, community action and sustained advocacy.
COP17 may have concluded, but our message remains uncompromising. No future in false solutions. Yes to real, rights-based solutions. Protect farmers’ seeds. Invest in agroecology. Uphold community sovereignty. Make biodiversity justice a reality.
Pages
The Fine Print I:
Disclaimer: The views expressed on this site are not the official position of the IWW (or even the IWW’s EUC) unless otherwise indicated and do not necessarily represent the views of anyone but the author’s, nor should it be assumed that any of these authors automatically support the IWW or endorse any of its positions.
Further: the inclusion of a link on our site (other than the link to the main IWW site) does not imply endorsement by or an alliance with the IWW. These sites have been chosen by our members due to their perceived relevance to the IWW EUC and are included here for informational purposes only. If you have any suggestions or comments on any of the links included (or not included) above, please contact us.
The Fine Print II:
Fair Use Notice: The material on this site is provided for educational and informational purposes. It may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. It is being made available in an effort to advance the understanding of scientific, environmental, economic, social justice and human rights issues etc.
It is believed that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have an interest in using the included information for research and educational purposes. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. The information on this site does not constitute legal or technical advice.




