You are here

News Feeds

Elevated demand for gas turbines could persist through 2035: Siemens Energy

Utility Dive - Tue, 11/17/2026 - 05:00

The U.S. midterms are not likely to slow turbine orders by data centers, company executives said, noting that turbine demand is also coming from diverse industries with long-term growth trajectories.

Canada’s methane policy is only as strong as Alberta’s

Pembina Institute News - Tue, 11/17/2026 - 03:29
With COP31 ongoing in Turkey, Canada’s status as a global leader on climate is under scrutiny. Oil and gas methane emissions are among the easier opportunities to reduce greenhouse gas emissions because of the value of the gas that is conserved...

Building coastal resilience for local communities in Honduras

Climate Change News - Tue, 11/17/2026 - 03:02

There is a remote corner of Honduras where tropical rainforests and vast lagoons are commonplace.

In the Gracias a Dios department, stretching across the country’s southeast coastline, the weather is hot and humid all year round. The region forms part of the Mosquito Coast and is known for its natural beauty, significant biodiversity and intricate waterways that almost touch the Atlantic Ocean.

The people who live here are few and far between, numbering around 100,000 across a huge landscape of almost 7,000 square miles. The Indigenous population has long built its life and culture from within this remote landscape, working with nature to serve their essential needs.

But it is this inaccessibility and close reliance on the natural environment which is now posing a serious challenge to the health and wellbeing of local people. As the climate crisis intensifies, people are being forced to find innovative solutions to maintain their way of life. 

“The Indigenous and Afro-descendant communities…live in a territory highly exposed to the effects of climate change,” said Kevin Santos, a project manager at the Comisión Acción Social Menonita (CASM), a non-profit Honduran organisation with offices across the country.

“Their location combined with limited connectivity, the fragility of the infrastructure, and a strong dependence on natural resources means that climate events have direct impacts on daily life and livelihoods,” he commented.

Indigenous people in the region have long relied on nature to sustain their way of life. (Image credit: CASM) Indigenous people in the region have long relied on nature to sustain their way of life. (Image credit: CASM) Giving people direct control

The threats these communities now face include flooding, hurricanes, coastal erosion, drought and rising sea levels.

“When an emergency occurs, difficulties with transport, communication and access to services can delay the response and increase the impacts. For communities, adaptation therefore means not only preparing for a climate event, but also strengthening their ability to anticipate, respond and recover,” said Santos.

To tackle this crisis, local people have developed a series of interventions to build resilience and protect their families.

Push for ocean roadmap that informs next global stocktake grows at COP31

The project is being implemented by CASM and developed under the Adaptation Fund’s locally led adaptation programme. The initiative gives local institutions the ability to implement climate solutions with direct control over their financing needs.

The project is now approaching the midpoint of its four-year, US$4-million grant programme to support the Indigenous people in the Juan Francisco Bulnes and Brus Laguna municipalities adapt to these ever-present climate risks. A large proportion of the financing is being directed towards building adaptation across four areas: disaster preparedness, resilient infrastructure, ecosystem restoration and sustainable agriculture. 

One tailored solution includes restoring mangroves and forests to act as natural barriers and reduce the impact of flooding and erosion. In addition, communities saw the need to combine both water and renewable electricity, with a plan to invest in solar systems to keep essential water systems running during extreme weather events.

Locally led priorities

Overall, the evolving plan has a target to reach 18,000 people, roughly the combined populations of both districts, with 60% of beneficiaries being women.

According to CASM, one of the main priorities identified by local people was to strengthen community-based early warning systems. The ability to have timely information when exposed to hurricanes and flooding makes all the difference in allowing people to prepare and evacuate. New emergency shelters are being created and personnel trained on how to run them.

The intervention calls for women to be directly involved in these contingency and risk management plans, alongside ensuring these plans are responsive to the different challenges men and women face in an emergency.

Early warning systems are saving lives in Central Asia

“Women often take on a significant share of responsibilities related to water, food, family care and household recovery. For this reason, a gender approach is a cross-cutting component of the programme,” added Santos. This forms part of a wider priority to strengthen community organisation and create spaces for people to effectively participate in managing their own adaptation actions.

To date, one of the learnings from the project has been the need to combine climate solutions. “Resilience requires an integrated approach rather than an isolated intervention,” said Santos. 

“A community may need a water system, but also energy to keep it operating; it may need an early warning system, but also communication and transport to respond to the warning. It may need protection from flooding, but also healthy ecosystems that reduce exposure,” he added.

Communities in Brus Laguna and Juan Francisco Bulnes are exposed to flooding and rising sea levels, among other climate threats. (Image credit: CASM) Communities in Brus Laguna and Juan Francisco Bulnes are exposed to flooding and rising sea levels, among other climate threats. (Image credit: CASM) Different continent, same challenges

Similar interventions are being pursued across the Atlantic Ocean in Côte d’Ivoire and Ghana. A regional programme implemented by UN-Habitat has successfully restored 248 hectares of mangrove ecosystems across both countries in a bid to reduce coastal vulnerability and improve shoreline stability.

A total of 21 communities dotted along the coast are involved in the project with 126,000 potential beneficiaries. Early warning systems have also been identified by communities as essential to reducing the impact of the rising sea levels and frequent storms. 

Furthermore, the project is preparing to build solar-powered irrigation systems to train farmers on climate-resilient agricultural techniques. 

Mouhamadou Diene, regional project coordinator at UN-Habitat, commented: “Some significant project solutions have been identified to improve the resilience of coastal communities in Ghana and Côte d’Ivoire…both countries share the Gulf of Guinea coastline and face interconnected coastal climate risks”.

In Guatemala, Indigenous women build climate resilience with old and new farming methods

Both the Latin American and African projects dovetail with the focus on ocean and coastal management at the UN climate conference underway in Antalya, Türkiye. Alongside coastal resilience, they support climate-proofed infrastructure, disaster risk reduction, nature-based solutions, water and food security – key themes also being negotiated at the conference.   

“Country and locally led adaptation solutions such as those in Honduras and the regional approach in Ghana and Cote d’Ivoire are having significant impacts in empowering vulnerable communities to build resilience to sea level rise and related climate risks,” said Mikko Ollikainen, head of the Adaptation Fund. “Scaling up successful adaptation projects is increasingly important as we see climate impacts becoming more intense and erratic,” he added.

Lessons on coastal resilience

People living in coastal regions are experiencing a barrage of climate pressures, and these aren’t restricted to isolated communities. An estimated 900 million people worldwide live in low-lying coastal zones and are threatened by extreme weather events, according to the UN.

As national governments seek to develop new policy interventions to tackle these risks, the experiences of people in places such as Gracias a Dios are illuminating. 

“Adaptation works better when solutions are based on local knowledge and priorities,” argued Santos. “Rather than centrally defining what each community needs, work with community organisations to identify risks, discuss alternatives, and develop proposals grounded in the local context,” he urged.

By doing so, researchers believe climate adaptation can be made more sustainable, combining local know-how with the technical information and resources to ensure solutions reach the people who need them the most.

Adam Wentworth is a freelance journalist based in Brighton, UK.

The post Building coastal resilience for local communities in Honduras appeared first on Climate Home News.

Categories: H. Green News

COP31: Erdoğan’ın Otoriter Yeşil Yıkamasına Karşı Direniş

Green European Journal - Tue, 11/17/2026 - 02:50

Türkiye, Antalya’da dünyanın en büyük iklim zirvesine ev sahipliği yapmaya hazırlanırken, resmi söylemler fosil yakıt bağımlılığını derinleştiren enerji politikalarının üzerini örtüyor. COP31, bir başka “yeşil boyama” gösterisine dönüşmüşse de Türkiye’deki taban hareketleri sömürüye dayalı otoriter baskı karşısında direnmeye, enerji demokrasisi ve ekolojik adalet için mücadeleye devam ediyor.

31. Birleşmiş Milletler İklim Değişikliği Konferansı (COP31), 9-20 Kasım tarihleri arasında Antalya’da düzenlenecek. “Uygulama COP’u” olarak tanıtılan zirvenin; emisyon azaltımı ve fosil yakıtların aşamalı olarak terk edilmesi için küresel bir uzlaşmaya zemin hazırlaması umuluyor.

Bu yılki iklim zirvesinin jeopolitik rekabetlerin ve gerilimlerin gölgesinde toplanmasından bağımsız olmayan şekilde hedeflerine ulaşması hayli muğlak. Zira bir taraftan temiz enerjinin küresel lider üreticisi konumundaki Çin güneş panellerinden rüzgâr türbinlerine, bataryalardan elektrikli araçlara kadar ürettiği yeşil teknolojilerine uygulanan Batılı gümrük vergilerine itiraz ediyor, diğer tarafta, Trump 2.0 yönetimindeki ABD, rotasını yeniden fosil yakıtlara çevirmiş bulunuyor. Petrol ve doğalgaz tedarik zincirlerindeki kırılmalarla sarsılan Avrupa Birliği ise artan iklim krizine rağmen küresel rekabet gücü gerekçesiyle yeşil politikalarını giderek daraltıyor.

Bu büyük resim içinde Türkiye ise enerji ihtiyacının yaklaşık üçte ikisini karşılayan fosil yakıtların neredeyse tamamını ithal eden bir ülke olarak COP31’e ev sahipliği yapmaya hazırlanıyor. Bu kapsamda zirvenin en dikkat çeken gündem maddelerinden biri, Türkiye’nin “35’e 35” önerisi. Bu öneri, bugün yaklaşık %20 seviyesinde olan küresel elektrik payını 2035 yılına kadar dünya enerji talebinin %35’ine çıkarmayı hedefleyen iddialı bir çağrı niteliğinde. Zira Türkiye, Cumhurbaşkanı Erdoğan döneminde Orta Doğu ve Avrupa arasında ana fosil yakıt transit merkezi olma yönündeki stratejik hedefini açıkça sürdürüyor. Bununla birlikte hem Çin ile madencilik, kritik mineraller, yenilenebilir ve nükleer enerji başlıklarında iş birliğini derinleştiriyor hem de Akdeniz’deki petrol ve doğalgaz arama faaliyetlerini artırarak Yunanistan ve AB ile bölgesel gerilimleri körüklüyor.

Bu ikilik, hükümet için COP31’in uzun süredir devam eden ekonomik krizin üzerini örtmek adına bulunmaz bir fırsat olduğunu düşündürüyor. Yani iklim diplomasisi, Erdoğan için ekolojik bir taahhüt değil; aksine, toplumsal muhalefetin susturulduğu bir ortamda yabancı sermaye akışını sağlamak ve uluslararası meşruiyeti tazelemek için pragmatik bir zemin sunuyor.

Yeşil Yıkamaya Devam

Esasen Türkiye, önceki ev sahipleri olan Mısır (COP27), BAE (COP28) ve Azerbaycan’ın (COP29) zirvelerini devasa enerji anlaşmaları için kullandığı, Brezilya’nın (COP30) ise zirvenin hemen öncesinde petrol ihalelerini sürdürdüğü gibi COP31’i ikili bir stratejiyle ele alıyor. Bu noktada küresel elektrifikasyon söylemi de hem derin politika çelişkilerini gizliyor hem de Türkiye’yi küresel temiz teknolojinin yeni adresi olarak pazarlıyor.

Bu durumun diğer bir dışavurumu hükümetin Çin ile batarya yatırımları için görüşürken Batılı aktörlere savunma bütçelerini iklim finansmanına kaydırma çağrısı yapmasında görülüyor. Bununla birlikte hükümet, yurt içinde “Demokrasi ve Özgürlük Adası” adıyla 1960 darbesinin simgesi olan ve belleğimizdeki imajını silmeye çalıştığı Yassıada’da devlet destekli “NextGenCOP30.5” gençlik zirvesini düzenlemek gibi geniş yankı uyandıran etkinliklere imza atıyor.

Öte yandan, hükümetin ikili bir strateji izlediği, kömür kullanımını aşamalı olarak sonlandırmak yerine 2035 yılına kadar emisyon artışını sürdüreceğini açıklamasından da anlaşılıyor. Kaldı ki yeni doğalgaz anlaşmalarını yürürlüğe koyan hükümet, yurt içindeki arama faaliyetleri doğrultusunda acele kamulaştırma kararnamelerini devreye sokmuş bulunuyor. Tüm bunlar COP31’in, emisyonları fiilen artıran ve fosil yakıt altyapısını besleyen hükümet için bir diğer “yeşil yıkama” hamlesi olduğunu teyit ediyor.

Nitekim 10 Ekim’de, Türk Petrol İşletmeleri Anonim Şirketi (TPAO) öncülüğünde yürütülen petrol ve doğalgaz arama çalışmalarını hızlandırmak amacıyla Antalya ve Akdeniz kıyıları genelinde acil arazi kamulaştırmalarına izin veren bir cumhurbaşkanlığı kararnamesinin yayınlanmasıyla bu çelişkiler zirveye çıkmış bulunuyor. Esasen Türkiye’nin bu kurumsal “yeşil boyama” pratiği, 2053 net sıfır hedefi kapsamındaki resmi taahhütlerine çoktan sirayet etmiş durumda. Zira devletin güncellenmiş Ulusal Katkı Beyanı (NDC), 2030 yılına kadar 41’lik bir azaltım vaadinin fosil yakıt tüketimine dair önlem alınmadığı senaryodaki projeksiyona dayanması emisyonların mevcut seviyenin üzerine çıkartılacağının taahhüdü anlamını taşıyor. Üstelik Ağustos ayında Türkiye’nin Emisyon Ticaret Sistemi’nin (ETS) devreye girmesiyle bu politika zemini daha da çetrefilli bir hal aldı. Çünkü söz konusu sistem, kirleticilere bağlayıcı emisyon sınırları getirmek yerine, ticarete konu edilebilen emisyon hakları sağlayarak endüstriyel kirliliğin meşrulaştırılmasına ve sürdürülmesine hizmet edebilir.

Bu bağlamda emisyonlarının 2035 yılına kadar %16 artması öngörülen Türkiye’de mutlak azaltım hedeflerinin belirsiz bir geleceğe ertelendiğini söylemek yanlış olmaz. Nitekim Avrupa Komisyonu’nun Küresel Atmosfer Araştırmaları Emisyon Veritabanı’nın (EDGAR) 2026 verileri, Türkiye’nin küresel emisyon sıralamasında iki basamak yükselerek dünyanın en büyük 14. sera gazı kirleticisi konumuna geldiğini ve küresel emisyonlardaki payını %1,13’e çıkardığını gösteriyor.

Netice itibarıyla hükümetin iklim diplomasisinin ardında, rejimin bekasına yönelik tanıdık bir hesap yatıyor. Tıpkı 2008 krizinin ardından inşaat ve enerji sektörlerindeki büyümenin siyasi hegemonyayı tahkim etmek için araçsallaştırıldığı gibi, hükümet bugün de COP31’in getireceği ESG fonlarını ve yeşil kredileri 2028 Cumhurbaşkanlığı seçim sürecinde ekonomik hareketliliği sağlaması için kritik birer can simidi olarak görüyor. Bu kaynaklar özellikle makro ekonomik krizin baskılarını yönetmek adına hayati likidite kaynaklarını teşkil ediyor. Zira %85’e ulaşarak zirveye çıkan ve %30 bandında katılaşan enflasyon ve Türk lirasının uğradığı %80’i aşkın değer kaybı hükümeti yeni rant ve sermaye arayışına mecbur bırakıyor.

Yenilenebilir Enerjilerin İşlevsizleştirilmesi

Öte yandan Türkiye Elektrik İletim A.Ş.’nin (TEİAŞ) ulusal şebeke verilerine bakıldığında, yenilenebilir enerjinin yaygınlaşmasıyla ilgili birçok sorunun kaynağında enerji sisteminin yapısı olduğu görülüyor. Bu açıdan, öncelikle %19’u ithal doğalgaz olmak üzere toplam kurulu gücün %38’ini oluşturan fosil yakıtlar en büyük paya sahipken geri kalan %62’ye tekabül eden “yenilenebilir enerji” diliminin %40’ını, nehir rejimlerini bozan, bölgesel su krizlerini derinleştiren ve yerelde can suyu bile bırakmadığı için toplumsal muhalefeti tetikleyen HES projelerinden oluştuğunu belirtelim. Kurulu gücün %21’i güneş, %15’i rüzgâr enerjisinden oluşuyor.

Ancak, bu tablo Türkiye’nin yenilenebilir enerji potansiyelini nasıl kullandığını anlatmıyor. Zira Ember Climate verileri üzerinden bir fiili üretim seviyelerine bakıldığında esas sorunun yapısal sınırlamalara dayandığı anlaşılıyor. Zira Ocak 2026’da güneş enerjisinin payı yalnızca %6 seviyesindeyken, yılın en yüksek güneşlenme potansiyeline sahip aylarından Haziran’da dahi güneşin toplam elektrik üretimindeki payı %16,5 ve rüzgârın payının da %13,5’te kaldığı görülüyor. Buna mukabil, benzer güneşlenme dinamiklerine sahip Portekiz ve İtalya gibi ülkeler, yaz aylarında aylık elektrik üretiminin %20 ila %30’unu düzenli olarak güneşten karşılıyor. Hatta İtalya’da güneşin payı yüksek üretim dönemlerinde toplam talebin %40’ını bile aşabiliyor. Öte yandan, Türkiye’nin güneş enerjisi potansiyelinin yalnızca üçte birine sahip olan Almanya altyapı kapasitesini ve şebeke esnekliğini verimli kullanarak yaz aylarındaki elektriğin %20’sinden fazlasını güneşten üretebiliyor.

Bu yapısal eksikliklerin giderilmesi, acil ve köklü bir rota değişiminin şart olduğuna işaret. Ne var ki, Türkiye’de 2053 net sıfır hedefleri kapsamında 2035’e kadar 120 GW güneş ve rüzgâr kapasitesini devreye sokması resmi olarak taahhüt edilmişse de , ortada hâlâ somut ve şeffaf bir yol haritası yok. Bugüne kadar bu hedeflere yaklaşılmadığı gibi mevcut güneş kapasitesi de kurumsal ve idari engeller yüzünden kısırdöngü içinde. Zira mevcut yasal çerçeve hane halklarını ve yerel toplulukları ürettikleri elektriği şebekeye geri beslemeye teşvik etmediği gibi küçük ölçekli projeler de bürokratik engeller, ağır ruhsatlandırma prosedürleri ve yetersiz şebeke kapasitesi gibi kronik sorunlarla boğuşmaya mahkûm ediliyor.

Bu sorunları daha da çetrefilli kılan asıl unsur, küçük ölçekli girişimlerin sistematik olarak engellenmesine karşın, arazi tahsislerinin ve mali teşviklerin doğrudan büyük sermaye gruplarına ve uluslararası ortaklıklara akıtılması. Nitekim 185 GW’lık devasa bir güneş enerjisi potansiyeline ve yılda 300 güneşli güne sahip olmasına rağmen Türkiye, Rusya ile nükleer enerji için kurulan ve şeffaflıktan uzak Akkuyu ortaklığında olduğu gibi kendi topraklarındaki enerji üretimini Suudi Arabistan’a açan hükümetlerarası anlaşma imzalamış bulunuyor.

Yurt içi söylemde hükümet bu uluslararası anlaşmaları, Türkiye’ye devasa tesisler kazandıracak ve “sıfır maliyetli” yatırımlar olarak pazarlıyor. Oysa bu anlaşmalar, Türkiye’yi kendi coğrafyasında üretilen enerjinin sahibi değil, dışarıdan gelen sermayeye bağımlı bir alıcı konumuna indirgiyor. Yani iktidar için Cumhurbaşkanlığı seçimine hazırlık sürecinde kurtarıcı işlevi gören bu projelerle hükümet, uzun vadede ülkeyi ağır bir ekonomik bağımlılık sarmalına sürüklüyor. Üstelik yenilenebilir enerji projeleri devletin zor aygıtları ve merkeziyetçi uygulamalarla yukarıdan aşağıya dayatıldığında, kırsalda ve kent çeperlerinde mülksüzleşme dalgasını tetikleyerek yereldeki toplumsal direnci kaçınılmaz olarak körüklüyor.

Nükleer Kumar

Türkiye’nin enerji politikasında kronikleşen dışa bağımlılık, hükümetin uzun süredir ısrarla sürdürdüğü nükleer projelerle daha da artmış bulunuyor. Üstelik hükümetin 2053 net sıfır stratejisi resmi olarak 20 GW’lık bir nükleer kapasite hedefini de beraberinde getirdi. Buna göre halihazırda inşa halindeki 4,8 GW’lık Akkuyu Nükleer Güç Santraline ek olarak Trakya’da 5,6 GW’lık, Sinop’ta 4,8 GW’lık birer projenin daha hayata geçirilmesi ve 4,8 GW’lık kısım için de Küçük Modüler Reaktörlerin (SMR) satın alınması öngörülüyor.

Oysa Akkuyu projesi bile tek başına bu nükleer ajandanın son derece ağır yapısal çıkmazlarla malul olduğunu göstermeye yeter. Zira Rusya ile imzalanan hükümetlerarası anlaşmanın üzerinden tam 16 yıl geçmesine rağmen, tek bir reaktör dahi henüz ticari işletmeye alınabilmiş, enerji üretimine katkıda bulunmuş değil. Bu süre ortalama yedi ila sekiz yıl arasında değişen küresel inşaat sürelerinin neredeyse iki katına tekabül ediyor. Öte yandan “Yap-Sahip Ol-İşlet” (BOO) finansman modeliyle hayata geçirilen Akkuyu NGS, iktidarın iddiasının aksine Rusya’ya olan enerji bağımlılığını da azaltmıyor. Tam tersine, ulusal egemenlik sahasındaki bir arazide yabancı bir devlete doğrudan mülkiyet ve işletme hakkı tanınmış olduğu için Türkiye’nin Rusya’ya stratejik bağımlılığını daha da derinleştiriyor. Üstelik yetkililerin “Akkuyu elektrik talebinin %10’unu karşılayacak” söylemi de bir istatistik illüzyonundan ibaret. Zira siyasal iktidarın 2035 yılına kadar elektrik tüketiminin 500 TWh’ye yaklaşacağı yönündeki söylemine göre Akkuyu’nun yıllık 35 TWh’lik tahmini üretiminin, toplam talebin ancak %7 ila %8’ini karşılayabileceği açık.

Bu yapısal uyumsuzluk, krizin derinleştiği ekolojik koşullarda daha da ağırlaşıyor: Çünkü Akkuyu nükleer santrali, küresel ortalamaya kıyasla %20 daha hızlı ısınan Akdeniz’den soğutma suyunu alacak şekilde tasarlandı. İklim krizine bağlı kuraklık nedeniyle soğutma suyunu denizden alan nükleer santraller için soğutma suyunun ısınması veya nehir kıyısındaki tesisler için ısınmaya bağlı olarak su seviyesinin düşmesi neticesinde zorunlu işletme kesintileri riskini tırmandırdığı artık herkesin malumu. Ne var ki Türkiye’de hükümet Akkuyu NGS için alınması gereken ekolojik tedbirleri bu yakıcı iklim gerçekliğine uyarlamak yerine projeye özel hukuki muafiyetler sağlıyor. Bunun en çarpıcı örneklerinden biri, Akkuyu NGS için yapılan yönetmelik değişikliğiyle daha önce öngörülen 35°C’lik sınırın fiilen ortadan kaldırılmasıdır.

Projenin atık yönetimi çerçevesi ise risk dağılımındaki yapısal eşitsizliğin en tehlikeli veçhesini yansıtıyor. Zira resmi söylemler kullanılmış nükleer yakıtın yurt içinde yönetileceğini iddia etse de mevcut hukuki düzenlemeler ve uluslararası pratikler Akkuyu NGS’nin VVER-1200 reaktörlerinden çıkan atığın yeniden işlenmek üzere Rusya’ya gönderileceğine işaret ediyor. Bunun temel nedenlerinden biri de Rusya federal yasalarına göre, yabancı radyoaktif atıkların Rusya topraklarında kalıcı olarak depolanmasının yasak olması. Bu açıdan pratikte plütonyum ve uranyum gibi stratejik malzemelerin Rusya’da ayrıştırılmasından sonra, geriye kalan en yüksek seviyeli radyoaktif atıkların Türkiye’ye iade edilmesinin hukuki bir zorunluluk olduğu öngörülebilir. Dolayısıyla bu durum bile Akkuyu NGS projesinin Rusya’ya endüstriyel ve askeri amaçlarla kullanabileceği değerli maddeleri mülkiyetine geçirmesini sağlarken Türkiye’ye bir milyon yıla kadar ölümcül tehlike saçacak olan yüksek seviyeli radyoaktif atıkların kalıcı yönetimini bırakan bir proje olduğunu yeterince açıklıyor.

Nükleer atık mirasının hükümeti kronik bir uzun vadeli bertaraf kriziyle yüzleşmeye mecbur bırakması bu uzun ömürlü izotopların yönetimi için Türkiye’nin nihayetinde derin jeolojik bir depolama tesisi (DİD) inşa etmesini gerektirecek. Bu ise yüz bin yıl boyunca güvenle izole etmek üzere tasarlanan, Finlandiya’daki Onkalo tesisine benzer şekilde milyarlarca avroluk devasa bir altyapı projesini başlatmak anlamına geliyor. Ne var ki, Türkiye’de radyoaktif atık tesisinin yer seçimi dahi merkezi ve otoriter bir idari yapı nedeniyle yukarıdan aşağıya yürütülüyor. Nitekim 2022 yılında Enerji ve Tabii Kaynaklar Bakanlığı’nın, başkent Ankara’nın yakınlarında, sismik açıdan nispeten sakin tarımsal bir bölge olan Polatlı’yı yerel halkla en ufak bir istişarede bulunmaksızın veya toplumsal rızayı aramaksızın radyoaktif atık tesisi için potansiyel bir adres olarak masaya yatırdığı basına yansıdı.

Çevresel ve stratejik risklerin yanı sıra Akkuyu NGS projesi, Türkiye’nin işgücü piyasası ve teknik kapasitesiyle de uyumlu değil. Zira resmi kaynaklar taşeron çalışanlarla istihdamın bir dönem 30 bin sınırına yaklaştığını öne sürmüşse de Ukrayna’daki savaşın yarattığı ekonomik kriz ve sarsıntılar nedeniyle inşaat aşamasında dahi bu sayı 10 bine gerilemiş bulunuyor. Santralın işletmeye geçmesiyle birlikte bu rakam daha da eriyecek; geriye yalnızca 4 bin civarında uzun vadeli operasyonel kadro kalacak. Üstelik Türkiye ile Rusya arasında imzalanan BOO anlaşmasının özel hükümleri teknoloji transferini açıkça kapsam dışı bıraktığından, yerel mühendisler ve teknik personel yalnızca alt-orta düzey destek görevleriyle sınırlandırılacak; bu da yabancı uzmanlığa olan yapısal bağımlılığı kalıcılaştıracak. Ancak kurumsal yetersizlik tesadüf değil; kökleri 12 Eylül askeri darbesi sonrasındaki idari tasfiyelere uzanıyor. Zira 1980 sonrasındaki neoliberal yapılanma sürecinde, Türkiye’nin kamusal nükleer araştırma hafızası ve yetişmiş bilim insanı kadrosu dağıtılarak ağır bir tahribata uğramış, sektör adeta vesayet altına alınmıştır.

Direniş ve Baskı

2018 ile 2025 yılları arasında Türkiye’de 22.855 madencilik ruhsatının verilmiş ve 13.342 ilk başvurunun alınmış olması tarım arazileriyle ekolojik açıdan hassas yaşam alanlarının sistematik olarak birer rant ve maden sahasına dönüştürüldüğünü sayılarla ortaya koyuyor. Sahada ise madencilik imtiyazlarının ve büyük ölçekli enerji projelerinin fütursuzca genişlemesi karşısında eş zamanlı olarak sivil toplum ve yerel ekoloji hareketleri üzerinde giderek tırmandırılan idari ve hukuki baskılar yürütülüyor. Merkezi iktidar, Çevresel Etki Değerlendirmesi (ÇED) süreçlerini birer formaliteye indirgeyerek, karar alma mekanizmalarına halkın katılımını fiilen kısıtlarken kamusal alandaki her türlü itirazı ve muhalefeti kriminalize ederek devlet destekli sermaye projelerine boyun eğdirilmesi için yerel direnişi sistematik bir şiddetle bastırıyor.

Bu açıdan son yıllarda COP ev sahibi ülkelerinin ortak paydasının, yalnızca yüksek karbon emisyonları değil; toplumsal muhalefetle her türlü diyalog mekanizmasını reddeden otoriter yönetimi kurumsallaştırmış rejimler olduğu netleşiyor. Nitekim Türkiye’de de ekolojik yıkım projelerine karşı yükselen halk hareketleri, özellikle 2016 darbe girişimi sonrasında ilan edilen ve kalıcılaştırılan olağanüstü hal rejiminden itibaren benzeri görülmemiş bir devlet şiddeti ve kuşatmasıyla karşı karşıya bulunuyor.

Bugün Türkiye’de çevre aktivizmi, dar çeperli kentli entelektüel tartışmalarının ötesinde; devlet korumasındaki madencilik ve enerji yağması kırsalın damarlarına kadar yayılarak doğrudan köylülerin, yerel toplulukların topraklarını, sularını ve yaşam alanlarını canla başla savunduğu meşru müdafaa hattına dönüşmüştür. İnsan Hakları İzleme Örgütü’nün (HRW) belgelediği üzere, rejim bu taban direnişini kırmak için yargı sopasını, keyfi gözaltı dalgalarını ve ağır idari para cezalarını sistematik bir sindirme aracı olarak kullanmaktan geri durmuyor.

Bu mücadelelerin başında 2019 yılından bu yana köylülerin kömür madeninin genişletilmesine karşı barikat kurduğu Muğla’daki Akbelen Ormanı direnişi geliyor. Siyasal iktidarın, özel şirketlerin maden arama ve kesim faaliyetlerini güvenceye almak üzere kolluk kuvvetlerini adeta şirketin özel güvenlik gücü gibi sahaya sürdüğü bu mücadelede, Anayasal haklarını kullanan şiddetsiz protestocular defalarca tazyikli su, göz yaşartıcı gaz ve copla hedef alınarak dağıtıldı. Bölge sakinleri ve hak savunucuları ise direniş alanlarının etrafında keyfi göz altılara, ağır idari para cezalarına ve aralıksız kimlik kontrollerine tabi tutuldu. Esasen bu durum, direniş odağını ablukaya alarak felç etmeyi ve toplumsal muhalefeti sönümlendirmeyi hedefleyen sistematik bir mekânsal gözetim ve sindirme stratejisidir.

Benzer bir mülksüzleştirme ve baskı dalgası, Perşembe Platosu’ndaki altın madenciliği projesine karşı yükselen direniş sırasında Karadeniz’de sergilendi. Ordu’nun Korgan ve Aybastı ilçeleri arasında uzanan bu yüksek rakımlı plato, yüzyıllardır hayvancılık ve geleneksel yaylacılıkla geçimini sağlayan yerel toplulukların ana yaşam alanıdır. Bölge yasal olarak koruma altındaki mera statüsüne sahip olmasına rağmen Çevre, Şehircilik ve İklim Değişikliği Bakanlığı, 2024 yılında kapalı kapılar ardında hiçbir kamusal rıza aramadan maden ruhsatını onayladı. Bölge halkı, şantiyedeki ilk sondaj çalışmalarının içme ve sulama suyu havzalarını doğrudan zehirlemesiyle projeden haberdar oldu. Haziran 2026’da mahkemece atanan bilirkişi heyeti de bu kaygıları resmen doğrulayarak; siyanürle liç yöntemiyle altın aranmasının yeraltı su rezervleri üzerinde telafisi imkânsız bir ekolojik yıkım yaratacağını açıkça raporladı. Ancak bu hukuki tescile ve devam eden davalara rağmen kolluk kuvvetleri, merasını ve suyunu savunan halkın barışçıl eylemlerini bir kez daha biber gazı, tazyikli su ve keyfi gözaltı dalgalarıyla bastırmaktan çekinmedi.

Benzer şiddet dalgası, devlet destekli bir lojistik limana hammadde sağlamak amacıyla Rize’nin İkizdere Vadisi’nde bir kireçtaşı ocağı açıldığında da tüm çıplaklığıyla gözler önüne serildi. Bölgedeki kadim çay bahçelerini, yaşlı ormanları ve hayati su kaynaklarını doğrudan kurutacak olan bu taş ocağı projesine karşı yükselen halk öfkesini kırmak için iktidar, “kamu düzeni” kisvesi altında acil kamulaştırma kararnameleri çıkardı ve ilçe genelinde olağanüstü hal seyrini aratmayan sirkülasyon kısıtlamaları dayattı. Jandarmanın ablukasına ve ağır idari cezalara rağmen, özellikle yöredeki kadınların militan öncülüğünde direnişi bayraklaştıran bölge sakinleri; yol kesme eylemleriyle iş makinelerine geçit vermedi, gövdelerini ağaçlara siper etti ve hukuki meşruiyet zeminini sonuna kadar savundu.

Otokratik “Yeşil Yıkama” ve Enerji Demokrasisi

Tüm bu örnekler; Türk devlet kurumları ile güvenlik aygıtının, sermaye çevrelerinin doğal kaynaklara ve yaşam alanlarına el koymasını güvence altına almak için nasıl organik ve eş güdümlü bir blok halinde hareket ettiğini ortaya koyan niteliktedir. Toplumla her türlü hakiki istişare mekanizmasını es geçen, yargı kararlarını ve bilimsel bilirkişi raporlarını yok sayan ve barışçıl protestoları sistematik bir şekilde kriminalize eden siyasal iktidar, halkın karar alma süreçlerine katılımını fiilen ortadan kaldırmakta. Sonuç olarak Türkiye’de “bölgesel kalkınma” ve “enerji güvenliği” retoriğinin devlet otoritesini arkasına alan bir sermaye gücünden ibaret olduğu ve yerel toplulukların toprakları, suları ve yüzyıllık geçim kaynaklarının sistematik bir mülksüzleştirme rejimiyle gasp edildiği açıktır.

Türkiye örneği açıkça ortaya koymaktadır ki, iç muhalefetin sistematik olarak ezildiği otokratik rejimlerde, uluslararası iklim zirveleri ev sahibi hükümetlere küresel sahnede “ilerici” bir imaj pazarlama ve siyasi denetimden tamamen arındırılmış steril bir ortamda yabancı sermaye avına çıkma imkânı sunmaktadır. Küresel sermaye çevreleri ve uluslararası yatırımcılar için bu otoriter idari model; toplumsal itirazların engellendiği, hukuki pürüzlerin “tek imza” ile çözüldüğü ve çevresel maliyetlerin görünmez kılındığı azami bir öngörülebilirlik alanı yaratmaktadır. Böylece mega enerji projeleri ve devasa altyapı sözleşmeleri, her türlü demokratik müzakere ve kamusal denetim mekanizmasından tamamen yalıtılarak güvence altına alınmaktadır.

Rejimin oyun alanının dışında bırakılan sivil toplum ise COP31’e karşı ortak ve kurucu bir ses çıkarmak üzere Halkların İklim Zirvesi (HİZ) gibi taban ağlarını inşa etmiştir. Bu ağlar tam da Akbelen, Perşembe Platosu ve İkizdere’de filizlenen yerel direnişleri kapsayarak ekoloji, emek ve insan hakları hareketleri arasında tarihsel bir dayanışma köprüsü kurmaktadır. Sermaye birikiminin doğayı ve insanı sömüren projelerine meydan okuyan, karar hakkını yerel topluluklara iade ederek “enerji demokrasisi” talebini yükselten bu ittifaklar; adil bir geçişe dair en hayati alternatif vizyonu şekillendirerek ekolojik adalet ile demokratik dönüşümün mümkün olabileceğine işaret ediyor.

Categories: H. Green News

Beyond the Race: China’s AI and the Choices Facing Europe 

Green European Journal - Tue, 11/17/2026 - 01:58

AI development is often framed as a two-player contest between the US and China over who can develop “superintelligence” first. Yet China’s moves suggest Beijing is focusing primarily on diffusion and global influence. Can Europe navigate this rivalry and actively engage with China while reducing its technological dependence on foreign superpowers?

This article will feature in the Green European Journal’s winter 2026 print edition Far West: Europe in the “Chinese Century”. Subscribe now and be among the first to receive a copy in December.

In recent years, China has firmly established itself as the leading global AI superpower alongside the US. Chinese open-weight models developed by companies including Alibaba, DeepSeek, Moonshot AI, and others are among the most downloaded in the world. Chinese AI labs are also quickly catching up with the leading US labs: according to some estimates, Chinese frontier capabilities are only three to six months behind the US, with the gap closing. In 2024, China also accounted for the largest share of AI patents granted worldwide,1 at 74.2 per cent, compared with 12.1 per cent for the US and 3 per cent for Europe.

These developments have sparked debate in the West, particularly in the US, about the trajectory and goals of China’s AI policy. One of the dominant narratives is that China is locked in an “AI race” with the US to develop so-called artificial general intelligence (AGI) or superintelligence first, and that whoever gets there first will command unprecedented power in the international order. For the US, losing this race could mean a decline in global influence and even the inability to protect its political and economic system.

Playing up the threat of China’s technological catch-up in frontier AI has enabled Silicon Valley to push back against regulation domestically. It has also prevented an informed and grounded debate on China’s AI strategy. But what if China is not pursuing the race towards AGI in quite the same way as the US? What if China is indeed in a race, but running on a different track, with the finish line further south?

The answer to these questions has implications for Europe. If we misunderstand China’s path and ambitions, we risk overlooking important developments in the global AI landscape and directing our policies towards the wrong priorities.

Building an ecosystem

A closer look at the Chinese Communist Party (CCP)’s actions and policies suggests that China is pursuing a strategy focused on building an AI ecosystem. It aims to create the economic, social, and political conditions for the widespread diffusion of Chinese AI, both domestically and internationally. To reach this goal, China doesn’t need to lead every technological breakthrough or be the first to develop the most advanced AI systems; rather, it needs to maximise technological diffusion and integration.

As political scientist Jeffrey Ding argues in his book Technology and the Rise of Great Powers,2 the country that benefits the most from a general-purpose technology is not the one that invents it, but the one that spreads and integrates it most widely across its economy. Ding links the rise of the British Empire to the diffusion of the steam engine, and the United States’ later overtaking of Britain as the dominant global power to its widespread adoption of electricity, which transformed production processes and strengthened its economy. China’s policies appear to regard AI as a general-purpose technology, and to follow much the same underlying logic.

Four pillars are central to China’s strategy: promoting the domestic diffusion of AI across traditional sectors; strengthening technological self-reliance along the AI value chain; betting on open-weight models for competitiveness and international diffusion; and expanding international cooperation on AI capacity-building and governance, particularly with countries in the Global South.

The government aims to integrate AI into as many sectors of China’s economy as possible

Diffusion over superintelligence

China’s focus on AI adoption does not mean that Chinese frontier labs don’t take AGI seriously or have no ambitions in that direction. DeepSeek founder Liang Wenfeng, for example, has explicitly stated that achieving AGI remains a key goal for the company. Moonshot AI founder Yang Zhilin has expressed similar ambitions. However, China’s political approach has been directed towards other priorities. AGI and superintelligence do not feature particularly prominently in the CCP’s vocabulary. In the 15th Five-Year Plan (2026-2030), for example, AGI is explicitly mentioned only once, as something to be explored alongside other fields of AI.

Instead, the government aims to integrate AI into as many sectors of China’s economy as possible, from manufacturing to agriculture, logistics, healthcare, education, public administration, and urban management. More recently, CCP policies have also placed greater emphasis on embodied intelligence and robotics, AI agents, and integrating AI into everyday products, from smartphones and computers to cars and household appliances. These objectives are being pursued under the AI Plus initiative, first introduced in 2024 and further developed in 2025, and again taken up in the latest Five-Year Plan.

There are signs that this strategy is paying off, at least in part. At this year’s World Artificial Intelligence Conference (WAIC) in Shanghai, more than 1100 companies showcased a vast range of ways AI technologies are being integrated across sectors. The conference is China’s flagship AI event and offers good insight into general developments in its AI economy.

Trivium China, a research and strategic advisory firm, also recently pointed out that while large parts of the Chinese economy are struggling, technology-related industries, including AI and semiconductors, have been performing exceptionally well.3 Of course, not all of this success can be attributed to government policies. Much of it is driven by private companies and entrepreneurs. Still, it suggests that China has created a policy environment in which AI diffusion can thrive.

Self-sufficiency across the stack

Chinese companies have faced increasing difficulties accessing foreign technologies essential to developing frontier AI. In October 2022, the Biden administration introduced export controls on advanced AI chips, including Nvidia’s A100 and H100, which are widely used to train frontier AI models. Restrictions were later extended to the equipment and software needed to manufacture advanced semiconductors. Although some restrictions have since been eased following Chinese retaliation and negotiations between Washington and Beijing, dependence on foreign technologies remains a strategic vulnerability for China.

Pursuing self-sufficiency across the AI stack, including rare earths, energy, chips, compute, data, models, and applications has therefore been a major strategic priority. This is not simply a response to US restrictions: it also reflects China’s broader ambition to strengthen its domestic economy and develop its own technological capabilities. At a Politburo study session in April 2025, Xi Jinping stressed the importance of technological self-reliance in AI, emphasising breakthroughs in advanced chips and foundational software, as well as the development of an independently controllable AI hardware and software system.4

Despite considerable progress, manufacturing the most advanced semiconductors at scale remains a major challenge for China.

A 2025 report by the Mercator Institute for China Studies shows that this ambition for self-reliance translates into different strategies and levels of government intervention depending on which layer of the AI stack it targets.5 Interestingly, some of the highest levels of innovation and development are happening in areas where the government intervenes the least. This is particularly the case in AI models and applications, where direct government intervention is comparatively limited. Chinese companies like DeepSeek, Moonshot AI, Zhipu AI, Tencent, and Alibaba have developed models that are now competing with those of leading US frontier labs. Here, the government’s role has largely been to support the wider ecosystem and help companies scale up through procurement or access to computing power.

In computing infrastructure, meanwhile, the government is investing heavily in the construction of data centres. Under its East Data, West Computing initiative, Chinese local governments, often in collaboration with private companies, are building large data centre clusters in the country’s western regions, where land and electricity are cheaper, to provide computing power for the AI industry (much of which is concentrated in eastern China).

In semiconductors, the picture looks very different. Here, China still faces some of its biggest technological bottlenecks, and government intervention has been extensive. The state-backed National Integrated Circuit Industry Investment Fund, known as the Big Fund, is a major source of financing for China’s domestic semiconductor industry. Its third phase was established in 2024 with a registered capital of 344 billion yuan (around 47.5 billion US dollars).

Companies such as Huawei and SMIC play a central role in developing domestic alternatives to foreign chips. But despite considerable progress, manufacturing the most advanced semiconductors at scale remains a major challenge for China.

Open weights to speed up diffusion

Unlike many leading US labs, most major Chinese frontier AI companies pursue an open-weight approach, which consists in making the underlying parameters of their AI models publicly available, allowing other developers to download, use, and adapt them to their own needs. However, the training data and the full development process are often not made publicly available, as is the case with open-source models. Chinese companies like DeepSeek and Alibaba also provide their models on internationally popular platforms such as Hugging Face, making them available to developers around the world.

This approach has two main benefits. First, open-weight (and occasionally open-source) models allow Chinese companies to tap into the international developer community, speeding up development and significantly reducing the costs of building and adapting AI models. According to a 2026 analysis by Hugging Face, Alibaba’s Qwen models have become one of the largest foundations in the open model ecosystem, recording more than two billion downloads in the first seven months of 2026. Other popular Chinese models also boast millions of downloads.6

Developers across the world now experiment with these models, adapt them for different applications, improve their efficiency, and identify or fix safety problems. In the case of Qwen alone, more than 151,000 derivative models had been uploaded to Hugging Face by August 2026. Many developers make their adaptations and improvements freely available, allowing others, including the original Chinese companies, to benefit from their work without hiring them directly. This gives Chinese companies a significant competitive advantage over American companies that keep their models closed.

The second key benefit is the international diffusion of Chinese AI and the development of applications built on its model ecosystem. Especially in the Global South, the costs of accessing and adapting AI models can be a major barrier. Chinese open-weight models can be downloaded, adapted to local languages and needs, and operated on infrastructure outside China. This flexibility makes them a more attractive, cheaper alternative to closed US models.

Even though much of this open-weight and open-source push has been driven by the private sector, the Chinese government actively supports it and has made it a priority in several policy documents. In the AI Plus initiative, for instance, the State Council explicitly calls for supporting open-source AI communities, making models, tools, and datasets more widely available, and developing globally accessible open ecosystems. The same document also calls for helping countries in the Global South develop their own AI capabilities. The 15th Five-Year Plan similarly encourages strengthening open-source systems.

Cooperation with the Global South

China’s ecosystem-building is not limited to the domestic level or the international diffusion of its open-weight models. The Chinese government is also actively building ties with governments worldwide, and particularly in the Global South, to help countries access, use, and build on Chinese AI technologies, and to collaborate on international AI governance.

The United Nations has been an important channel for this. In 2024, China initiated a UN resolution on international AI capacity-building, which was later adopted by consensus. At the UN’s first Global Dialogue on AI Governance in July 2026, China sent a ministerial-level delegation and actively promoted international cooperation on open-source AI, capacity-building, and governance.

The World Artificial Intelligence Cooperation Organization (WAICO) has been another important forum in this regard. Initiated by China, it was founded in July 2026 with 29 signatory countries, mostly from the Global South. The organisation has two main goals: first, capacity-building to improve access to AI technologies and services through policy exchange, technical cooperation, training, and joint research. Second, connecting members’ respective strengths and improving technology supply, furthering the joint construction of open-source ecosystems, and helping advance AI Plus initiatives in different countries.

Chinese diplomats are also using these forums to position China as an active defender of multilateralism, particularly as the current US administration is sceptical of, and actively undermines, attempts at international AI governance. This could become an important source of soft power, making it easier for Chinese AI technologies to spread internationally while strengthening the country’s position and influence in shaping how AI is governed around the world.

What does this mean for Europe?

China already is, and increasingly will be, a key AI player that Europe cannot ignore. Many European companies and developers are building on Chinese AI models, and they are likely to use them even more as these models become more competitive. For Europe, which is trying to become less dependent on American technologies and diversify its options, this trend could also open up new strategic opportunities.

One argument that often comes up in European debates is that Chinese technologies should not be used because they come from an authoritarian country, while US technologies are considered more democratic and therefore safer. The problem with this framing is that it doesn’t ask the most important questions that determine whether a technology is safe to use: is the model open or closed? Can we download it, run it on European infrastructure, and adapt it to our needs? Is it secure? Do we retain control over our data? Can we independently test the model and understand how it behaves?

When Chinese AI meets these conditions, Europe should not be so quick to dismiss it. Open-weight models, no matter where they are from, can offer European companies greater control over their systems than some of their closed alternatives.

Of course, these models still need to be used with caution. China has very different ideas about freedom of information from Europe, so models need to be tested, fine-tuned, and adapted for local use. They also need to be checked for security vulnerabilities. In October 2026, the Canadian AI company Cohere reported that an Alibaba Qwen model had unexpectedly attempted to send a probe file to an Alibaba Cloud server in Beijing during a security test.7 The attempt was blocked, and there is no established evidence that it was deliberate. Still, the incident shows why testing is essential. This is where European AI safety institutes could play an important role. Governments should help set them up and ensure they are equipped with the necessary resources and technical expertise to independently evaluate AI systems, identify potential risks, and help companies adapt them for safe use. This capacity would also be an important step towards European tech sovereignty.

Moreover, Europe should not build an AI strategy that assumes a continued supply of Chinese open-weight models. China is currently discussing a proposal by the Ministry of Commerce and the Ministry of Science and Technology to potentially introduce export controls on certain advanced AI technologies. While China is unlikely to completely change course on open-weight models, the proposal shows the risks of overreliance on Chinese AI.

Europe should therefore build on the options that currently exist, but it also needs to create the economic conditions for European AI companies to emerge and compete, so that it can rely on its own models in the future.

Open-weight models, no matter where they are from, can offer European companies greater control than some of their closed alternatives

Keeping options open also means that Europe must resist pressure from the US to become locked into its technological ecosystem. We cannot know who will lead in AI in 10 years’ time, and betting too heavily on continued US technological leadership would be risky. While Europe should seek to maintain good relations and preserve its partnerships with the US, it must also have credible alternatives that allow it to walk away from the negotiating table when necessary. Preserving that freedom of choice would give us more room to manoeuvre and greater control over our technological future.

China’s approach to AI diffusion also has important implications. Europe has already begun pursuing a similar approach through its Apply AI Strategy, but many traditional industries are struggling to integrate AI. They should pay closer attention to how their Chinese counterparts are using these technologies beyond frontier AI labs, and what can be learned from their experiences. If Chinese companies succeed in using AI to significantly improve productivity or develop whole ranges of new products, this could create another wave of competitive pressure on European industries. Europe needs to anticipate and prepare for this possibility.

Lastly, Europe should question the AI race rhetoric pushed by Silicon Valley and the Trump administration, and design policies that respond to what China is actually doing. Because worse than falling even further behind is spending billions trying to win a race we have fundamentally misunderstood.

  1. Sha Sajadieh et al (2026). Artificial Intelligence Index Report 2026. Stanford, CA: Stanford Institute for Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence (HAI). Available at https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.15708 ︎
  2. Jeffrey Ding (2025). Technology and the Rise of Great Powers: How Diffusion Shapes Economic Competition. Princeton: Princeton University Press. ︎
  3. Andrew Polk (2026). “Trivium China Podcast | China’s Growth Model Hits Another Reality Check”. Sinica Podcast. 20 June 2026. Available at https://bit.ly/4sKoWxo. ︎
  4. Xinhua News Agency (2025). “At the 20th Collective Study Session of the CCP Central Committee Politburo, Xi Jinping Stresses: Persist in Being Self-Reliant, Be Strongly Oriented Toward Applications, and Push the Orderly Development of Artificial Intelligence”. 26 April 2025. Translated by the Center for Security and Emerging Technology (CSET), Georgetown University, 28 April 2025. Available at https://bit.ly/4z1YWze ︎
  5. Wendy Chang, Rebecca Arcesati & Antonia Hmaidi (2025). “China’s drive toward self-reliance in artificial intelligence: from chips to large language models”. Mercator Institute for China Studies. 22 July 2025. Available at https://bit.ly/4sHax56 ︎
  6. Adina Yakefu, Apolinário from multimodal AI art & Irene Solaiman (2026). “State of Open Models: Summer 2026 Observations”. Hugging Face Blog. 14 August 2026. Available at https://bit.ly/4BOSvSA. ︎
  7. Cohere (2026). “Concerning behavior from a popular open-weight AI model”. Cohere Blog. 26 October 2026. Available at https://bit.ly/4k4UI68. ︎

Categories: H. Green News

Tribes push back as Congress moves to fast-track energy projects

Grist - Tue, 11/17/2026 - 01:45

After years of negotiation, Congress is on the cusp of passing a bipartisan “permitting reform” bill that would make it far easier to build power plants and electric transmission lines in the United States. The bill was negotiated by a bipartisan group of senators including Democrat Sheldon Whitehouse, a noted climate hawk, and Republican Mike Lee, an opponent of environmental regulation. It has picked up support from clean energy advocates because it would promote more transmission lines to carry renewable power to cities, speed up review for solar and wind projects, and stop presidents from cancelling offshore wind farms. It has also been endorsed by many conservative, business, and fossil fuel groups, who say it would cut down on environmental red tape and speed up natural gas pipelines.

The bill has divided the climate movement, separating groups focused on decarbonization from those focused on endangered species protection and environmental justice, but the most influential opposition has come from tribal nations. The bill would weaken a historic preservation law that tribes often use to protect cultural and religious sites from development, and numerous prominent Indigenous nations and organizations have said it harms tribal sovereignty.

While the bill cleared a procedural hurdle in the Senate last week, it remains unclear whether it will pass there or in the House. The negotiators who framed the bill say they believe they have the votes, but a number of Democrats in both chambers have opposed the bill. Hakeem Jeffries, the likely next Speaker of the House, has criticized what he called the bill’s “failure to adequately protect tribal sovereignty.” Nevada senator Catherine Cortez Masto, who voted to advance the bill, has said she won’t ultimately vote to pass it, saying she “cannot ignore the concerns” of tribes in her state.

“Projects affecting tribal governments before were already fast-tracked, but now this allows for a super fast track,” said John Bathke, a member of the Navajo Nation, a former historic preservation officer for the Quechan Tribe of the Fort Yuma Reservation, and now a professor of Indigenous studies at San Diego City College.

The 1966 National Historic Preservation Act, passed in the wake of nationwide urban renewal efforts that demolished many old buildings, requires the federal government to consider the effect of construction projects on historic and cultural properties. (Most intact objects or properties that are more than 50 years old and have some kind of historical, cultural, or religious significance qualify under the law.) When you’re building a solar farm or a transmission line, that is a big undertaking: The area of review can extend for as much as 5 miles away from the project itself, and major transmission lines can be hundreds of miles long. Even if a project is visible a few miles away when you’re standing in a historic area, that still counts as a potential effect.

While tribal nations have control over infrastructure projects on their reservations, many tribes have cultural, religious, and political claims over areas that are outside their reservation boundaries. The historic preservation law is one of the only tools they have to stop or alter construction projects that might desecrate sacred territories or religious sites. 

“Even though a lot of these projects aren’t on reservation land, it’s part of their traditional homeland, it’s part of their spiritual landscape,” said Bathke. “That land still belongs to them and they belong to that land.”

Tribal nations have used this law to limit energy projects that they say would harm their sacred territories. In perhaps the best-known example, the Quechan Tribe of the Fort Yuma Indian Reservation sued the federal government in 2010 over its approval of a 6,000-acre solar farm on federal land in California, one of the first such projects in the United States. The tribe argued that the project would destroy religious sites and buried remains and that the government had rubber-stamped it after just a few meetings. A court sided with the tribe and the solar developer nixed the project, moving to build on private farmland instead. (Bathke was the tribe’s historic preservation officer — the tribal official who helps with historic reviews — during the solar dispute.)

Supporters of clean energy development have long sought to reform the law. They argue that historic preservation review has become a far more sweeping and burdensome process than the authors of the law intended, and that clean energy projects are affected more than any other type of construction. The onus is heaviest for transmission lines — in some cases, the area under review can extend to hundreds of square miles, and entire rivers or valleys can be considered historic sites. Since transmission wires can be seen from miles away, it’s hard to eliminate all visual impacts associated with building them. 

“As written, [the historic preservation law] is a modest procedural check on hasty decisionmaking. … In practice, it has grown into a substantive burden on building infrastructure of all kinds,” write Ben Schifman and Aiden Mackenzie, two research analysts at the Institute for Progress, in a report on how the law affects energy development. The Institute for Progress has been a leading advocate for reforming the law and for the bipartisan permitting bill. 

To illustrate their argument, Schifman and Mackenzie cite the example of SunZia, an $11 billion transmission line that carries wind energy west from New Mexico to California. The project took two decades to complete. The line had to secure permits from multiple state power regulators, but it also had to undergo a historic review process that covered an area twice the size of Delaware. Among many other things, the government had to consider whether being able to see the transmission line in the distance would harm the historic characteristics of thousands of different sites across multiple states. 

While the government undertook this review, a coalition of tribes in the area protested the process. One of their main arguments centered on the San Pedro River Valley, a landform in Arizona that is sacred to the Apache, O’odham, Hopi, and Zuni peoples. The tribes wanted the government to declare the entire valley a historic zone, which could have required SunZia to reroute its wires. The government declined to give the valley that designation, arguing that the tribes had not identified the issue early enough in the review process. The Tohono O’odham and the San Carlos Apache tribes along with a group of environmental nonprofits then sued to stop the line. They failed to halt construction before the wires joined the grid, but the case is still ongoing, and a court could still force the developer to alter the project if the tribes win. 

Senators Martin Heinrich of New Mexico and Mike Lee of Utah listen during a hearing on reforming the National Historic Preservation Act. The two senators are part of a bipartisan group behind the permitting reform bill moving through Congress. Photo by Alex Wong / Getty Images

The initial version of the permitting bill limited the scope of the historic review process in several ways in an apparent attempt to avoid future SunZias. It made consultation with tribes effectively optional, allowing the federal government to move ahead with projects in cases where a tribe’s designated historic preservation official took too long to identify important sites. It outlined a definition for “traditional religious or cultural importance,” which had previously been open-ended under federal law. It narrowed the definition of a “visual” impact, requiring that such impacts “direct[ly]” and “significantly diminish” the historic value of a place; this standard is subjective, but it would likely exclude things like being able to see a wind turbine on the horizon. It also prohibited judges from halting construction work on projects if they find a flaw in a historic preservation analysis, as happened in the Quechan Tribe wind farm case; instead, judges could only order the federal government to redo its analysis as construction continued. 

These provisions provoked an immediate outcry from several tribal nations and Indigenous groups, who said it would threaten tribal sovereignty. A coalition of several major tribal groups, including the National Congress of American Indians, said that the bill was in “deep conflict with federal trust and treaty obligations” and that Senate negotiators were “proposing to facilitate the demolition of our heritage.”

Some lawmakers who support the bill expressed regret about their failure to incorporate Native interests.

 “We didn’t bring the tribes along on this … we could have done better on it in retrospect,” said Republican senator Alan Armstrong, who represents Oklahoma, in an interview with Punchbowl News.

Negotiators amended the bill earlier this month to address these concerns. The bill now makes tribal consultation mandatory throughout the historic review process, which isn’t the case under current law. It also prevents the government from taking over the historic review process when tribal officials are slow to respond. These changes are significant given that the Trump administration is already trying to weaken the historic review process through executive action. The administration’s rulemaking could limit the historic review process even if the permitting bill doesn’t pass. 

The tribes and tribal organizations that opposed the first version of the bill say these changes are nowhere near enough. Their primary areas of concern, including the limited definition of visual effects and the ban on injunctions, are still in the new version.

“While this amendment addresses select concerns, the authors ask Indian Country to be grateful Washington chose to take away fewer of our rights in the name of ‘progress,’” said Ira Matt, the head of the the National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers and a member of the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes. He also said the bill erodes “protections we have spent decades fighting to secure” and that those supporting it had demonstrated a “fundamental failure to understand and respect Tribal sovereignty.” 

The Kayenta Solar Plant in the Navajo Nation is the first tribally-built and owned solar facility in the United States. Tribes that support the permitting bill say it would help attract investment for energy projects on tribal lands. Jim West / UCG / Universal Images Group via Getty Images

It’s unlikely that lawmakers will strip the historic preservation section altogether. Many of the most suitable areas for clean energy development are on federal land in the west. In order to build enough clean energy to replace fossil fuels, developers will likely have to build projects that pass near tribal cultural sites. In that light, the bill’s historic preservation reform represents the biggest win for clean energy companies since the passage of the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act, which subsidized wind and solar construction and has since been largely repealed. 

Some tribal nations believe they themselves will benefit from the bill’s effort to speed up energy permitting. A few tribes have endorsed the bill, most of them tribes that have significant coal and oil resources. The Apsáalooke (Crow) tribe, whose reservation covers 2 million acres in Montana, told Senate negotiators last month that the bill could deliver “a predictable regulatory environment” and greater investment certainty” for “energy-producing tribes.” The tribe has significant coal reserves and has historically been a large coal producer, but its production has declined in recent years. The National Tribal Energy Association, which represents a number of fossil-fuel producing tribes, has also endorsed the bill. 

The bill will also strengthen the investment case for solar and wind on tribal lands, said Anthony Walters, a member of the Cherokee Nation and the vice president for government relations at the Alliance for Tribal Clean Energy, which helps tribes develop renewable energy. Walters says the main constraint that many tribes face is getting access to capital, and speedy environmental reviews and more transmission lines would make it easier for tribes to attract the money they need. 

Even so, he said the economic benefits of that development could never outweigh the potential destruction of sites that tribes hold sacred.

“The bill would help clean energy development projects across the board, so tribes would see the benefit of that,” he said. “But on the whole, right, we can’t do that at the expense of all the processes that tribes use to protect their interests. It’s a big trade-off.”

toolTips('.classtoolTips4','The process of reducing the emission of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases that drive climate change, most often by deprioritizing the use of fossil fuels like oil and gas in favor of renewable sources of energy.');

This story was originally published by Grist with the headline Tribes push back as Congress moves to fast-track energy projects on Nov 17, 2026.

Categories: H. Green News

COP31 Bulletin Day 8: EU backs electrification goal, as more TAFF roadmaps promised 

Climate Change News - Tue, 11/17/2026 - 01:29

Ministers are in the building and embarking on the tricky task of refining the mammoth draft cover text down to something that can be agreed upon by the end of the week. 

If the reactions heard so far at COP are anything to go by, this will be a big challenge. Few appear happy about its current form, with Europe’s climate commissioner dubbing it a “shopping list” on Tuesday and some large emerging economies rejecting the text outright. 

The headline political decision for COP31 should focus “on the gap that the world has in terms of delivery and in terms of implementation” to reach already agreed goals rather than straying into new territory, Wopke Hoekstra told reporters. 

According to the Earth Negotiations Bulletin, which unlike the media is allowed into the room, at a heads of delegation meeting on Monday evening, Like-Minded Developing Countries (LMDC) – a group that includes China, India and Saudi Arabia – said the draft crosses their red lines.

Particularly, they object to the inclusion of the 35×35 electrification target, the roadmap on transitioning away from fossil fuels and calls to rapidly reduce methane. The Arab Group and Russia went further, rejecting the draft text entirely over similar concerns. Even Türkiye’s ally Azerbaijan criticised the draft, ENB reports. 

The European Union also voiced doubts, saying it was not going in the right direction by including elements on finance, trade and carbon capture and storage. On the other hand, the text currently contains most of the EU’s key asks, including on responding to an overshoot of 1.5C and acknowledging the latest science. 

COP31 Bulletin Day 7: Incoming ministers set to battle over cover text

Negotiations on the cover decision resume in this afternoon. Other developments of note include concerns about the fate of the Climate Finance Work Programme (CFWP), with the poorest countries wanting it to continue for two more years and include a goal to triple adaptation finance. The EU and Switzerland have called for no text on this item, not wanting to take on new financial commitments.

NGOs under Climate Action Network International issued a letter calling on ministers and the COP31 presidency to ensure the CFWP addresses the developing countries’ needs for grant-based, highly concessional public finance for adaptation, loss and damage, emissions reductions and just transition. ”A weak or procedural result only, or worse, no text at all, would represent a failure and undermine the Paris Agreement’s finance architecture,” it said.

    Elsewhere, the EU announced it is backing the voluntary pledge to boost electrification to 35% of final energy use by 2035.

    “The world needs much quicker, much more radical electrification, and the more that is clean – and that is solar, wind, nuclear – the better it is,” said Hoekstra.

    However, the EU is not insisting that the COP recognise that the power to meet the 35×35 goal should be clean, with Ireland’s climate and environment minister Darragh O’Brien saying there was a need for “pragmatism” to help increase access to electricity in developing countries. 

    Tuesday is Oceans Day at COP31, with discussions and events due to focus on increasing cooperation between countries to protect oceans and including measures in national climate plans. There’s also likely to be a fresh push by some countries on the importance of climate science feeding into international policy and on driving forward the shift away from fossil fuels.

    Representatives of Denmark, Quebec, Germany, Vanuatu, Spain, Portugal, Finland, Ireland, Sweden, Tuvalu, the Marshall Islands and Luxembourg pose after a press conference on the transition away from fossil fuels at COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye, on 17 November 2026 (Photo: Chris McGrath/Getty Images) Representatives of Denmark, Quebec, Germany, Vanuatu, Spain, Portugal, Finland, Ireland, Sweden, Tuvalu, the Marshall Islands and Luxembourg pose after a press conference on the transition away from fossil fuels at COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye, on 17 November 2026 (Photo: Chris McGrath/Getty Images) Denmark unveils fossil fuel transition roadmap, with five more promised

    Denmark on Tuesday became the fifth country to unveil a national fossil fuel transition roadmap, while Spain, Portugal, Ireland, Luxembourg and the Pacific islands as a region have also committed to producing their own. 

    Danish climate and energy minister Samira Nawa told journalists the Nordic country is increasing its 2035 emissions reduction target to “at least” 85%, slightly up from its current goal of 82%. Denmark will also stop using coal power by 2028 and phase out oil and gas production by 2050. These two targets are not new and have existed for years.

    “Life is better without fossil fuels,” Nawa said. 

    Denmark accounts for a tiny share of global oil and gas production, but Nawa said its example should resonate with bigger producers. “If we can put an end date for oil and gas production in 2050 – and we have done that – then others can of course also do that,” she said.

    Portugal announced it would launch its fossil fuel transition roadmap on Wednesday, while an Irish one is expected by the end of this week. Vanuatu said Pacific island nations have started work on a regional roadmap and are hoping to have “something to show” in time for the next conference on transitioning away from fossil fuels due to take place in July 2027. Spain has not indicated a specific date. 

    Comment: COP31 outcome needs to prioritise transition away from fossil fuels

    Germany, France, the Netherlands and Finland have already published national roadmaps. None of the countries that have published or committed to one is a major oil and gas producer, but many are significant fossil fuel importers.

    Romain Ioualalen, a campaigner at Oil Change International, said producers should take from these announcements that their customers have understood their future is not in fossil fuels. “That’s why producing countries have everything to gain from doing their own roadmaps, because they need to prepare for what’s coming – a world where renewable energy is abundant and cheap, and fossil fuels decline,” he said.

    Brazil, one of the world’s largest and fastest-growing oil producers, is expected to publish its national roadmap next year.

    Ministers from Spain and Vanuatu also said they wanted COP31’s main political outcome, the cover decision, to refer to the voluntary global fossil fuel roadmap drawn up by Brazil’s COP30 presidency.

    The sprawling first draft of the cover decision, published on Monday, only “welcomes” that roadmap. It lists the roadmap in paragraph 140 among several voluntary initiatives and gives no indication of how work on it will continue after COP31.

    Ralph Regenvanu, Vanuatu’s climate minister, said the roadmap should be moved into the decision’s mitigation section with “a clear process to take it forward”.

    Arab states led by Saudi Arabia, the Like-Minded Developing Countries – which include India and China – and Russia have explicitly opposed the inclusion of voluntary roadmaps in the formal negotiated outcomes of the UN summit.

    Stop “negative messaging” about IPCC science, say small islands

    The chair of the Alliance of Small Island States group (AOSIS) accused certain countries on Tuesday of trying to drag out the timeline for the next reports by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and undermine the UN climate science agency.  

    Without naming the countries, AOSIS chair Ilana Seid told a press conference they were “not supportive of science” and accused them of spreading “negative messaging” about the IPCC, for example by saying that it is made up of “scientists from various countries who’ve been sent here to brainwash us”.

    Scientists vowed in October to keep working on the next flagship set of reports for the IPCC after a political dispute over the timeline for their release saw its latest session end without agreement. 

    The disagreement – which has persisted since early 2024 – turns on whether the three key parts of the AR7 assessment should all be published in time to feed into the UN’s next Global Stocktake of global climate action, which is due to be completed in late 2028. 

    Seid said the second Global Stocktake must “identify for us where collective progress is falling short, and what stronger action and support are needed to minimise the overshoot. To do that, the IPCC’s seventh assessment report must be ready in time to inform that assessment, she said, adding that any delay beyond that would be “unjustifiable” for AOSIS.

    Speaking alongside her, the chair of the Least Developed Countries (LDC) group, Adão Soares Barbosa, called on all governments to “respect the best available science, uphold the role of the IPCC and ensure that scientific evidence remains at the heart of our negotiation processes”.

    Opposition to the earlier publication has been led by bigger developing countries including India, Saudi Arabia, Kenya and China. EU Climate Commissioner Wopke Hoekstra said on Tuesday he had discussed the issue with his Chinese counterparts.

    He said he had told them it was important that the Stocktake has “the right information” from the IPCC, saying that message “resonates across the globe and also with our Chinese interlocutors”.

    Saudi Arabia’s COP31 delegation issued a statement saying its position on this issue “focuses on safeguarding scientific credibility, quality and inclusivity, rather than resisting scientific findings”. The issue should be debated at the IPCC, not at COP31, it added.

    Asked whether COP31 would reach agreement on this issue, Antigua’s Environment Minister Michael Joseph expressed optimism, saying there had been “very positive advancements” and “we are likely to get there”. But Seid cautioned there was still “a strong divergence of views”.

      COP31 set to boost ocean protection – marine geoengineering too?

      One aspect of the cover decision which is likely to prove relatively uncontroversial are its references to the importance of the ocean, which are pleasing campaigners.

      Asked how such words will actually protect marine ecosystems, David Ryfisch, senior manager at the Climate Policy Initiative, said the words will send a signal to politicians as well as to the private sector.

      “We will need the insurers, the institutional investors, banks, etc, to provide the financing, because a lot of funding will be necessary,” he told journalists on Oceans Day at COP31.

      Areas which need funding, he said, include sustainable fisheries, coastal protections and cleaning up the shipping industry. Standing alongside him, young Samoan activist Brianna Fruean spoke of a project she saw at the pre-COP in Fiji where the villagers of Naidiri have stopped fishing in an area of their waters and are re-planting coral that has been bleached.

      All the planters are volunteers though, she told Climate Home News, squeezing it in around their day jobs. With funding, they could be paid for their work and restore the reef much faster. The project began in 2009.

      At a separate event on Indian cooperation with small island developing states on ocean conservation, India’s environment minister Bhupender Yadav talked up his country’s mangrove restoration efforts.

      India’s environment minister Bhupender Yadav (left) speaks at an event on Indian cooperation with small island developing states on oceans on 17 November 2026 at COP31 (Photo: Joe Lo)

      A more controversial climate solution involving the seas is marine geoengineering, which means fiddling with the oceans so they store even more carbon dioxide than they already do.

      Some ocean advocates support this – or at least research into it. Kilaparti Ramakrishna, oceans and climate advisor at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, told Climate Home News in September that research should be conducted into ocean alkalinity enhancement and ocean iron fertilisation, where iron is put in the ocean so that algae grows on it and sucks up carbon.

      “Those are the kinds of things that make the ocean a hero in terms of solving the climate problem, but we should always be mindful that in solving one problem, we don’t create other problems,” he said.

      On Tuesday, however, Marine Lecerf, head of international policy at Ocean and Climate Platform, was wary about marine carbon removal techniques. “There are many uncertainties surrounding their effectiveness, their scalability, their durability – but even more importantly, their potential adverse impact on nature,” she said.

      There is wording in the cover text on carbon dioxide removal in general, which Lecerf opposes, saying the link between this and oceans has not and should not be made.

      Former Canadian environment minister Steven Guilbeault said the focus should instead be on ocean solutions that have already been proven to work. “We can perhaps another day talk about those technologies if we’re going to need them,” he said.

      At a press conference, Palau’s ambassador Ilana Seid said her Pacific country supported strong language on the protection of oceans but that Palau is concerned about marine carbon dioxide removal. “A lot of the science there is unproven and we are cautioning against that,” she said.

      Corals depicted during a WCS-Fiji Survey 2020 (Photo: Tom Vierus) COP31 “blue” initiatives aim to foster ocean cooperation beyond Antalya

      As Australia leads a push to include oceans in COP31’s main deal, Türkiye has launched its own call to action – urging countries to better protect the world’s oceans by using existing mechanisms.

      Based on several rounds of consultations with countries, the Antalya Ocean and Seas Compact identifies several scattered initiatives through which governments can work together, among them the UN Ocean and Climate Change Dialogue, and other UN treaties including the recent High Seas Treaty and the biodiversity convention.

      The Turkish declaration also endorses measures including “responsibly developed” offshore wind, sustainable fisheries, scientific monitoring capacity, as well as “electrification and emissions reductions in coastal activities”. 

      It says countries could cooperate after COP31 to turn these suggestions “into tangible benefits for the ocean and the communities”. It remains unclear whether other countries have endorsed the initiative, but negotiations have so far shown wide convergence on oceans.

      Kilaparti Ramakrishna, senior ocean policy advisor at Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, a non-profit marine research organisation, said that while the Turkish declaration helps highlight oceans at COP, countries must now “carry this leadership into the negotiated outcome” and make clear scientific and financial commitments on the issue.

      Push for ocean roadmap that informs next global stocktake grows at COP31

      A separate voluntary initiative led by France and Brazil – known as the Blue NDC Challenge – has launched an implementation taskforce to help its member countries meet their climate targets by reducing emissions and building resilience at sea.

      More than 20 academic and non-profit organisations will support the taskforce’s work, among them Blue Marine Foundation, Conservation International, the International Renewable Energy Agency and the Plymouth Marine Laboratory.

      Brazilian ambassador Carlos Márcio Cozendey, one of the co-chairs in the initiative, said the Blue NDC Challenge aims to build a coalition of countries “committed to placing the ocean at the centre of their national climate plans”. The coalition is currently composed of 27 members from Africa, Asia, the Americas, Caribbean, Europe and the Pacific region.

      Currently, almost all coastal countries have “blue targets” as part of their national climate plans – with measures like marine protected areas and sustainable fisheries – but more than half of them are conditional upon external funding.

      COP32 comes into focus as progress on adaptation finance slows in Antalya

      UN officials and African climate campaigners said on Tuesday adaptation finance must be a central priority of next year’s COP32 in Ethiopia, as they continued to push for a stronger outcome in Antalya and called for clearer messaging to help unlock greater investment.

      Speaking in Antalya, Marcos Neto, director of the UN Development Programme’s (UNDP) bureau for policy and programme support, said the adaptation conversation remained too “abstract”, noting that money only started flowing to mitigation when discussions came down to specific focus areas like renewables, grids and energy efficiency in buildings.

      “That’s the message in Ethiopia for COP32, we need to start breaking down what we mean by adaptation,” he said, adding that part of that should involve identifying areas that can attract private finance. 

      As developing countries push for stronger commitments on tripling adaptation finance, some representatives said they would rather defer decisions to COP32 than accept a weak outcome in Antalya.

      Kuda Manjonjo, just transition advisor at Power Shift Africa, a climate and energy think-tank, said “the cover decision is becoming a distraction from the actual negotiations” which should address adaptation finance, along with the just transition mechanism and the climate finance work programme. 

      He said having adaptation finance in the cover decision, as it was in the Global Mutirão Decision from last year’s COP30 in Brazil, ends up leaving countries unsure of “what was agreed and to what extent”.

      “Let’s just say the things that we need, but in the negotiation and not just speak about pledging or promising to do this,” he said, adding that as COP32 host, Ethiopia can maintain “a fundamental push to say that this [adaptation finance] will be a priority of the African COP”.

      Fred Njehu, Pan-African political strategist at Greenpeace Africa, urged the African Union and member states to adopt a strong position on adaptation and climate finance going into Addis Ababa.

      “We want that to be front and central of the agenda items to be discussed,” he said. “We want to ask our COP32 presidency to take that [as priority]”.

      With the negotiations midway in the second week, developing country groups are insisting on the baseline for the tripling to be $120 billion. One observer told Climate Home News the groups have agreed not to accept anything less than their demands and would rather continue discussions at COP32 if necessary.

      Egypt’s Mohamed Kamal, board member of Climate Action Network Arab World said “no outcome is better than a weak outcome from the African group”, adding that the group must have a clear action plan to ensure that its requirements at the baseline, especially on tripling adaptation, are pushed clearly as part of the outcome.

      The post COP31 Bulletin Day 8: EU backs electrification goal, as more TAFF roadmaps promised  appeared first on Climate Home News.

      Categories: H. Green News

      COP31 can’t deliver for islands without delivering for the ocean

      Climate Change News - Tue, 11/17/2026 - 01:24

      Dr Sivendra Michael is Fiji’s permanent secretary for environment and climate change.

      In Fiji, the ocean is our connection to one another, our source of food, our livelihood and an inheritance passed down through generations. It shapes where we live, how we travel and the traditions we carry forward.

      Our land may appear small on a world map, but our ocean territory stretches across approximately 1.3 million square kilometres – larger than France, Germany and the UK combined.

      For island nations across the Pacific, Caribbean and Indian Ocean, the ocean is not a distant environmental concern. It is the foundation of our communities and our economies. That is why the growing threats to the ocean concern us so deeply. The consequences of decades of pressure are becoming impossible to ignore.

      Warming hits coral reefs hard

      Consider what is happening to our coral reefs. The most extensive global bleaching event on record exposed more than 80% of the world’s coral reef area to high-level heat stress between 2023 and 2025.

      For island nations, the consequences extend far beyond the reefs themselves. A damaged reef can mean a coastline more exposed to storms, fewer fish for families who depend on them and lost income for communities already facing enormous economic pressures.

        The world is now on course to overshoot 1.5°C of warming, the temperature threshold island nations fought so hard to secure under the Paris Agreement. How far temperatures rise beyond that threshold, and whether and how quickly they can be brought back below it, will help determine whether our reefs have a chance to recover.

        For island nations, the stakes extend to whether communities can continue adapting or whether some of the places we call home become increasingly difficult to inhabit.

        We cannot afford to treat this as an inevitable loss. The future of our reefs, and the communities that depend on them, must not be determined by the world’s willingness to accept continued warming.

        Healthy ocean vital to keep warming in check

        As international climate negotiators today prepare to discuss oceans, island nations have three interconnected priorities they want to make clear: keeping the 1.5°C limit within reach, improving access to climate finance and ensuring that the ocean is recognised as central to tackling the climate crisis.

        We owe the ocean more than we acknowledge. For decades, it has absorbed most of the excess heat trapped by greenhouse gases and a substantial share of our carbon dioxide emissions, shielding the planet from far greater warming. But that protection has come at an enormous cost.

        Bleaching in American Samoa during February 2015. The same reefs will be exposed to raised temperatures again in the coming months. Source: Caitlin Seaview Survey Bleaching in American Samoa during February 2015. The same reefs will be exposed to raised temperatures again in the coming months. Source: Caitlin Seaview Survey

        The bleaching of our coral reefs is one of the most visible consequences of that burden, but the damage does not end there. Rising ocean temperatures are disrupting marine ecosystems. Increasing acidity makes it harder for corals and shell-forming organisms to build and maintain their skeletons and shells, while declining oxygen levels threaten marine life and the habitats on which fisheries depend. Continued warming will intensify these pressures.

        Governments must deliver deeper emissions reductions this decade, backed by credible plans for implementation. Limiting the extent and duration of any overshoot of 1.5°C must be a central measure of climate ambition.

        Climate solutions being put into practice

        That ambition must also extend to the ocean. We no longer need to make the case that the ocean is part of the climate solution. That case has been made. What we need now is action that reflects its importance.

        Coastal ecosystems such as mangroves and seagrass meadows store carbon while protecting shorelines and supporting marine biodiversity. Offshore renewable energy and cleaner maritime transport offer further opportunities to reduce dependence on fossil fuels.

        Pre-COP draws attention to Pacific’s climate plight and 1.5C goal

        Across the Pacific, island nations are already putting solutions into practice. In the Marshall Islands, the SV Juren Ae, a modern sailing cargo vessel, is reducing reliance on fossil fuels for inter-island transport. Its success offers a model for the Pacific Blue Shipping Partnership, a regional initiative co-led by Fiji and the Marshall Islands to transform maritime transport.

        For communities separated by vast stretches of ocean, reliable and affordable shipping is essential. Cleaner vessels offer an opportunity to reduce fuel consumption and emissions while improving transport services. With the right support, initiatives such as these can be expanded across the region.

        But putting solutions into practice requires finance.

        Island states struggle to access finance

        Island nations are already paying for the consequences of a crisis they have contributed little to creating. We are protecting coastlines, adapting infrastructure to rising seas and working to safeguard communities threatened by climate change. Yet too many of these efforts are held back, not by a lack of ideas or expertise, but by the difficulty of securing the finance needed to carry them forward.

        For small island governments, accessing international climate finance can become an exhausting exercise in navigating complex requirements, often with limited staff and resources to manage the process.

        Climate funds should align their application and accreditation procedures wherever possible, reducing unnecessary duplication. They should also make better use of existing national systems and capacities rather than requiring governments to establish new structures to satisfy different funding arrangements.

        Critically, support for countries already bearing the costs of climate change must not come at the expense of burdening them with greater debt.

        Pacific nations want higher emissions charges if shipping talks reopen

        The Pacific Blue Shipping Partnership illustrates what is at stake. Island nations have come together around a practical plan to transform maritime transport. Scaling up that ambition will require a financing system capable of supporting it. COP31 must deliver concrete progress on access to climate finance, particularly for small island developing states and least developed countries.

        Earlier this year, Fiji welcomed climate leaders to the Pacific for Pre-COP31, organised in partnership with Tuvalu and Australia. It brought international climate decision-makers to a region where the consequences of climate change, and the solutions being developed in response, could be seen firsthand.

        COP31 and beyond

        But the message from the Pacific should not stay in the Pacific.

        The world cannot continue to acknowledge the ocean’s importance in speeches while treating it as an afterthought in climate policy. That recognition must now shape national climate commitments, the Global Stocktake of climate plans in 2028 and the allocation of climate finance.

        The COP31 leadership has identified the ocean as a priority.

        The measure of the summit’s success will not be how prominently the ocean features in its discussions, but how firmly it is reflected in its outcomes.

        The post COP31 can’t deliver for islands without delivering for the ocean appeared first on Climate Home News.

        Categories: H. Green News

        Nitrates in drinking water are a ‘public health crisis,’ environmentalists warn

        Grist - Tue, 11/17/2026 - 01:15

        When the federal government set its limit on how much nitrate drinking water can safely contain, the primary concern was blue baby syndrome, a condition that deprives infants of oxygen. In the 51 years since then, research has associated exposure to the contaminant with cancer and other health problems, fueling calls for a stricter standard.

        On Monday, a coalition of national and local advocacy organizations including the Natural Resources Defense Council, Union of Concerned Scientists, Prairie Rivers Network, and 11 others filed a petition calling on the U.S Environmental Protection Agency to lower that threshold from 10 milligrams per liter to 1 mg/liter. In its petition, the coalition argued that “nitrates in drinking water are causing a public health crisis across the country.” 

        “One in three Americans — nearly 120 million people in this country — are currently being served water with dangerous levels of nitrate in it,” said Tyler Lobdell, a senior staff attorney at Food & Water Watch. That figure includes people served water with nitrate concentrations above 1 mg/L — one-tenth of the current federal standard.

        Nitrate pollution, much of it linked to fertilizer and manure runoff and leaching from agriculture, is a particular concern in farming regions, where contaminated groundwater can disproportionately impact rural, low-income, Latino, and farmworker communities. Studies have linked exposure with colorectal cancer, thyroid disease, and fetal abnormalities. A 2019 study estimated that up to 12,594 new cancer cases each year are attributable to nitrate in drinking water.

        “This change would reflect the best available, peer- reviewed science and would bring substantial health benefits to communities across the country,” according to the petition. 

        Climate change can exacerbate nitrate contamination as increasingly intense rainfall and flooding washes fertilizer and manure into waterways and groundwater. Drought can concentrate pollutants.

        In a statement to Grist, the EPA wrote that it would review the petition but noted that it completed its review of drinking water regulations, including the nitrate standard, in July, 2024. 

        “EPA conducted a robust evaluation of available studies and applicable data for nitrate to determine if any new information provided a basis to support a regulatory revision that would improve or strengthen public health protection,” the statement read. “Based on the agency’s review, EPA determined that the nitrate rule was not a candidate for revision at the time.”

        As part of the petition, the organizations commissioned the consulting firm One Water Econ to analyze the costs and benefits of adopting the proposed standard, especially in states most affected by nitrate contamination. 

        The 43-page report found that slashing the threshold isn’t cheap. The report estimates that adopting the 1mg/L benchmark would cost $94.5 billion over 50 years, which would cover everything from upgrading water treatment plants, maintenance, and replacing equipment. Despite the steep price tag, the analysis found that returns would significantly outweigh the investment, the benefits totaling $364 billion.  

        “People are paying with their health right now,” Lobdell said. “Costs are accruing right now in the real world, in the form of people losing their loved ones and  children being born with abnormalities.”

        The states with the largest impacted populations tend to cluster in the West and Midwest and account for 62 percent of the affected population, according to the analysis. Agricultural powerhouses like California, Texas, and Arizona topped that list, with traditional farming states like Iowa not far behind. 

        In Iowa, approximately 42 percent of residents are exposed to nitrate levels above 1 mg/L, according to the analysis. This summer, Des Moines-area residents faced water restrictions for the second year in a row amid high nitrate levels. Illinois faces a similar problem. Between 2021 and 2023, more than 2 million people were served drinking water that tested above 1 mg/l, said Robert Hirschfeld, the director of water policy at Prairie Rivers Network. 

        The current 10 mg/L threshold dates to 1975 and was formally adopted in 1991, based largely on the risk of blue baby syndrome. Advocates argue that the standard does not account for subsequent research associating nitrate exposure with other health problems.

        The EPA has twice tried to reassess the nitrate benchmark as part of its required periodic review of national drinking water standards. The Obama administration began that process in 2016, but the Trump administration paused it in 2019. The Biden administration restarted it in 2023, before the second Trump administration cut the effort short by eliminating the office responsible for the reviews.

        “We’ve done the EPA’s work for it,” Lobdell said.

        The petition asks the EPA to take two immediate steps: Adopt an interim benchmark for nitrate while it considers the new limit, and enforce other federal protections like the Clean Water Act and rein in industrial agriculture, which Lobdell said has been given “free pass to pollute.”

        For communities confronting nitrate contamination, the debate is ultimately about where regulators draw the line between what is legal and what is safe.

        This story was originally published by Grist with the headline Nitrates in drinking water are a ‘public health crisis,’ environmentalists warn on Nov 17, 2026.

        Categories: H. Green News

        Lessons from “The Man from Earth” for an age of collapse

        Resilience - Tue, 11/17/2026 - 00:00
        The protagonist can be seen as a metaphor for all of humanity, and not just one extraordinary person. He is a passenger and a living record of all he has experienced and adapted to.

        An exchange on Jeremy Lent’s essay ‘Toward an Ecocivilization’

        Resilience - Tue, 11/17/2026 - 00:00
        The transgression of planetary boundaries requires us to rethink not only our strategies, but also our assumptions about human agency, our political economy, and the priorities from which our responses emerge.

        The woman turning Dal Lake’s weeds into sustainable handicrafts in Kashmir

        Resilience - Tue, 11/17/2026 - 00:00
        Every day before the sun rises over Dal Lake, often called the jewel in Kashmir’s crown, Simran Irshad heads towards the water with a singular mission: to clear its choking weeds.

        World goes over climate cliff

        Ecologist - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 23:00
        World goes over climate cliff Channel News brendan 17th November 2026 Teaser Media
        Categories: H. Green News

        Opinion: France Did E-Bike Subsidies Right — and America Can, Too

        Streetsblog USA - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 21:03

        American cities are currently running the world’s most expensive experiment in moving nobody. We hand out free parking — minimum requirements that force developers to build it, meters priced below cost, curb space given away at rates no economist would defend — and then we act surprised when people drive. Every free parking space is a subsidy, and it is a subsidy for the behavior we say we want less of.

        France, by contrast, spent nearly a decade subsidizing the opposite behavior — and the results should be a required reading in every city hall on this side of the Atlantic.

        From 2017 until February 2025, France ran a national bonus vélo — a direct purchase subsidy for e-bicycles. The most generous rates were aimed at the communities where they do the most good: low-income households. That was especially true the trade-in category, where scrapping an old car in favor of an e-bike earned the largest checks: historically up to €3,000 for any e-bike, with up to €1,000 more in low-emission zones.

        Read that again, because it’s what makes the program so exciting. The state didn’t just make e-bikes cheaper. It paid its citizens to downgrade their cars. It treated the car-to-bike swap as a public benefit worth purchasing, the way other governments treat insulation or solar panels.

        Of course, France is not alone in paying people to ride. Denver’s 2026 rebate is $675, or $900 with Colorado’s tax credit; Colorado relaunched an income-qualified statewide rebate this August. But these are purchase discounts, not the car-for-bike trade France paid for.

        Recommended STEAL THIS IDEA: Denver Offering Rebates on E-Bike Purchases Eve Kessler April 26, 2022

        Sadly, France’s national program ended in February 2025. But the experiment did not end, because the cities kept it alive: Paris, Lyon, Marseille, Toulouse and other French metros continue to pay e-bike purchase subsidies today, tuned to their own budgets and residents.

        Local cargo-bike aid, meanwhile, still runs up to €600 in Paris and up to €900 in Lyon, albeit far below the old national bonus of up to €2,000. France retreated from the national check to the local check — and in doing so handed the idea, ready-made and road-tested, to anyone willing to run it.

        Now look at what virtually all American cities subsidize instead — even if they have an e-bike credit to offset it.

        America builds parking structures at $30,000 to $60,000 per structured space, and then charges less than the debt service for drivers to use them. We mandate parking minimums that add invisible costs to every apartment, every grocery store, every small business. We spend billions widening roads so that the subsidized parking spaces can be reached faster.

        And when someone proposes spending a few hundred dollars to help a nurse buy an e-bike, the objection is often the same: we can’t afford it.

        We can’t afford a check for $800, but we can afford a garage for $40,000 a stall. That is not a budget constraint. That is a value statement, printed in concrete.

        Recommended Study: Removing Parking Minimums Leads to More Affordable Housing Susan D. Daggett October 22, 2025

        The case for copying France is not just sentimental. It is arithmetic. An e-bike subsidy is the cheapest per-person mode shift a city can buy — a fraction of the cost of one structured parking space — and it produces exactly the outcomes cities claim to want: less congestion, fewer emissions, healthier residents, curb space freed for the uses that actually generate city life.

        Parking subsidies produce cars. E-bike checks produce riders. If a subsidy’s job is to change behavior in ways that benefit society, only one of these programs is doing its job.

        There is also an equity case for e-bike subsidies, and it cuts in the direction U.S. policy usually forgets. The households most likely to be trapped by car dependency — low-income workers facing long commutes on transit-poor routes — are precisely the households France’s program targeted for the most assistance. A flat parking subsidy, by contrast, flows to whoever already owns a car.

        France’s structure — income-tiered, trade-in-weighted, cargo-bike-generous — is an object session in good policy. Pay the most to the people for whom the switch is hardest, because when you do, ever euro will go further to take cars off the road.

        So here is the ask — and it is deliberately municipal because that is where American action actually happens. City councils: fund an e-bike purchase rebate next budget cycle, income-tiered, with a car-scrappage bonus at the top. Take the money from the parking structure line item — the one that was going to produce a garage full of empty stalls.

        And when the inevitable objection arrives about “giving free bikes to people,” answer it with the only honest reply available: we already give free storage to cars, at scale, forever, and nobody calls that a giveaway because it has always been there.

        France proved that e-bike subsidy moves people. Its national retreat proved the program needs local champions. The blueprint is public, the price is small, and the parking lots are not going to delete themselves.

        London’s Car-Free Oxford Offers Lessons for One of America’s Most Iconic Streets

        Streetsblog USA - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 21:02

        Mayor Mamdani should take a page out of London’s successful pedestrianization of Oxford Street, and banish cars from Fifth Avenue in Midtown and other shopping hubs as the holiday season rounds the corner, advocates said.

        The British capital saw surges in foot traffic, spending and international visitors after the city removed cars from the globally famous retail corridor last month.

        “The numbers are in: footfall *and* spending are up on Oxford Street,” London Mayor Sadiq Khan posted on Bluesky on Nov. 9. In the larger West End area, spending increased by 13 percent in the first six days of the conversion.

        The numbers are in: footfall *and* spending are up on Oxford Street.

        — Mayor of London, Sadiq Khan (@london.gov.uk) 2026-11-09T08:17:51.248Z

        Three weeks ago, city transportation officials in the Big Smoke banned buses, taxis and even bikes from a roughly 0.6-mile stretch of Oxford Street. The intervention was a decade in the making and six years late under Khan’s mayoralty, and aimed at improving street safety, cutting pollution and revitalizing ailing businesses on the strip.

        Livable streets advocates on our side of the pond immediately seized on the promising data to bolster the case for pedestrianizing Fifth Avenue, Manhattan’s dominant shopping artery and the city’s closest equivalent to Oxford Street. The idea dates back to 2017, when ex-Mayor Bloomberg’s former DOT Commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan proposed pedestrianizing three of the strip’s five lanes for 25 blocks south of Central Park, while leaving the remaining two lanes for buses.

        But business titans along the ritzy row have foiled successive efforts by both mayors Bill de Blasio and Eric Adams to reclaim space from cars. Mamdani now has a chance to stand up to the monied interests and follow London’s lead, advocates said. “New York, it’s time to pedestrianize Fifth Avenue,” said Doug Gordon, a co-host of the War on Cars podcast.

        In recent years, the city has closed the corridor to traffic on some December weekends to make room for holiday shopping crowds. But former Mayor Eric Adams scaled those events back, despite a 6.6-percent bump in spending during the car-free days.

        Recommended

        City Scales Back Hugely Popular Fifth Ave. Holiday Open Street Despite Sales Boosts
        Kevin Duggan

        December 4, 2024

        One street safety advocate said the upcoming holiday season provides an opportunity for Mamdani to go bigger than his predecessors and set the tone for pedestrian-first shopping streets throughout the Big Apple.

        “I’m optimistic that the numbers [on Oxford Street] will continue to remain pretty high and it’s something that New York should be taking very seriously,” said Samir Lavingia, the second vice chair of Manhattan Community Board 5, who noted he’s not speaking on behalf of the board. “I would love to see him lead with something visionary in Midtown,”

        Lavingia suggested that Mamdani could start with an entire month of a car-free Fifth Avenue, and later bring the conversion to other busy shopping areas, like SoHo or Williamsburg. “That would be a good way to kick it off,” he said. “For people to change their behavior, it needs to be multiple days in a row.”

        Two mayors have attempted to redesign Fifth Avenue, starting with de Blasio’s busway in 2020, which would have banned through-traffic for private vehicles between 57th and 34th Streets.

        After big business fat cats pushed back against the idea of banning through-traffic, de Blasio watered down his proposal to allow through-traffic for private vehicles. But even the diluted plan never made it out of the planning phase before he left office.

        Recommended

        Memo to Mamdani: Fifth Ave. Belongs to the People — Not the Ultra-Wealthy and Gridlock
        Samir Lavingia

        November 21, 2025

        The Eric Adams administration at first proposed a different plan with bus and protected bike lanes, before ditching the cycle path and releasing a $350 million overhaul called the “Future of Fifth.”

        The plan would have widened sidewalks while preserving the majority of the roadbed for private cars. It would have also slowed bus commutes by cutting the dedicated bus lanes from two to one. The proposal received strong support from the Fifth Avenue Association, an influential group representing businesses and institutions along the corridor like the Trump Organization, St. Patrick’s Cathedral and Bergdorf Goodman.

        London rerouted buses away from Oxford Street ahead of its pedestrianization. Relocating buses away from Fifth Avenue could be a challenge, since its double-wide bus lanes serve as a key south-bound surface transit artery connecting to all other boroughs, and nearby Madison Avenue serves the same function for buses heading north.

        Lavingia said if Mamdani wanted to move buses elsewhere, he could work with the state-run MTA to look at alternatives in its upcoming borough-wide bus network redesign. “It’s an opportunity for the mayor to say, ‘look, I would love to see the buses off of Fifth Avenue to pedestrianize it,” he said.

        View this post on Instagram

        The Adams administration wanted to start construction in 2028, but it’s unclear if Mamdani’s Department of Transportation still plans to move forward with the redesign. A DOT rep declined to specify the agency’s plans for Fifth Avenue, and instead cited Commissioner Mike Flynn’s Vision Zero Reimagined platform that called for more pedestrian-focused designs in the city.

        “The Mamdani administration will be developing the city’s first-ever pedestrian-priority and pedestrian-only districts and we look forward to sharing more soon,” said Vin Barone. A spokesperson for the Fifth Avenue Association said it was still too early to measure success on Oxford Street, but its CEO emphasized the pressing need for more sidewalk space.

        “Everyone can see Fifth Avenue pedestrians deserve wider, more attractive and sustainable sidewalks,” its CEO, Madelyn Wils, told Streetsblog. “We have studied many global examples that prove the value of investing in streetscape projects that increase the quality of conditions for pedestrians.”

        Tuesday’s Headlines Wonder About the Blue Wave

        Streetsblog USA - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 21:01
        • The recent election is not likely to change the transportation status quo unless transit and street safety advocates put enormous pressure on Democrats. According to Smart Growth America’s Beth Osborne, history shows that Democrats are unlikely to pass a progressive surface transportation funding bill if left to their own devices.
        • A new report from the Brookings Institute suggests that state-owned roads in urban areas are ripe for transit-oriented development.
        • None of the 99 largest public transportation systems in the U.S. are easy to access for people with disabilities, according to a University of Michigan study.
        • Austin officials are hopeful that a new Democratic administration in Texas will mean less conflict with the state over Project Connect (Austin Current). In related news, the Houston Chronicle (paywall) says Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa should end Texas’ war on cities.
        • A new bill in the Texas legislature would instruct the state DOT to explore high-speed rail connecting San Antonio, Austin, Waco and Dallas. (San Antonio Current)
        • Texas A&M-Fort Worth’s location between two downtown transit stations helps with recruitment and economic development. (Report)
        • The newly formed Northern Illinois Transit Authority, which united three Chicago-area transit agencies, is seeking passage of a $5 billion budget. (Evanston Now)
        • California Gov. Gavin Newsom awarded Caltrain $750 million for an extension into downtown San Francisco. (SFist)
        • Nithya Raman’s support for density, housing and transit led Governing to call her “L.A.’s Urbanist in Chief.”
        • The Post and Courier editorial board urges Charleston not to wait for someone to get hurt or killed before making streets safer.
        • Broward County, Florida received a $164 million federal grant for light rail. (Sun Sentinel; paywall)
        • Kalamazoo approved funding for two road diet projects. (WWMT)
        • A Philadelphia man spent 36 hours riding on all of SEPTA’s 22 trains to spark conversation about long-term funding for the transit agency. (NBC 10)

        Revealed: Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia are largest CO2 exporters of all time

        The Carbon Brief - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 21:00
        Print article Share

        Russia, Saudi Arabia and COP31 co-president Australia are the largest exporters of carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions in history, reveals Carbon Brief analysis.

        Since 1850, the three nations – and other major fossil-fuel exporters – have exported hundreds of billions of tonnes of CO2 in the form of gas, oil and coal that has been burned in other countries.

        Carbon Brief’s analysis of extraction-based CO2 emissions is based on figures compiled by Robbie Andrew, a senior researcher at Norwegian climate institute CICERO.

        It shows that Australia is responsible for more than twice as much global warming when including emissions from its fossil-fuel exports, while Saudi Arabia has caused more than four times as much.

        Australia has been under pressure for continuing to expand its fossil-fuel production ahead of the UN climate summit in Antalya, where it is co-president with host nation Turkey.

        .cb-membership-banner.alignfull {
        box-sizing: border-box;
        width: var(--width--responsive--container, calc(100% - 32px));
        margin: clamp(24px, 4vw, 48px) auto;
        padding: 20px clamp(16px, 4vw, 56px);
        border-radius: 5px;
        background: var(--color--brand-1, #152d42);
        color: #f3f3f3;
        }

        .cb-membership-banner__inner {
        display: flex;
        align-items: center;
        gap: clamp(16px, 3vw, 40px);
        max-width: var(--width--l, 1400px);
        margin-inline: auto;
        }

        .cb-membership-banner__image {
        position: relative;
        flex: none;
        width: 104px;
        }

        .cb-membership-banner__image img {
        display: block;
        width: 100%;
        height: auto;
        max-height: 100px;
        object-fit: contain;
        }

        /* Crop the transparent border around the current CB+ logo. */
        .cb-membership-banner__image--logo {
        aspect-ratio: 1279 / 1208;
        overflow: hidden;
        }

        .cb-membership-banner__image--logo img {
        position: absolute;
        top: 50%;
        left: 50%;
        width: 230%;
        height: auto;
        max-width: none;
        max-height: none;
        transform: translate(-48.65%, -49.17%);
        }

        .cb-membership-banner__copy {
        flex: 1;
        min-width: 0;
        }

        .cb-membership-banner .cb-membership-banner__label {
        display: inline-block;
        margin: 0 0 5px;
        padding-top: 4px;
        border-top: 2px solid currentColor;
        color: inherit;
        font: 700 13px / 1.2 "PT Sans", sans-serif;
        text-transform: uppercase;
        }

        .cb-membership-banner .cb-membership-banner__title {
        margin: 0;
        color: inherit;
        font: 700 clamp(24px, 2.8vw, 38px) / 1.1 "PT Sans Narrow", sans-serif;
        }

        .cb-membership-banner .cb-membership-banner__cta {
        display: inline-flex;
        flex: none;
        align-items: center;
        justify-content: center;
        box-sizing: border-box;
        min-height: 44px;
        padding: 10px 18px;
        border-radius: 4px;
        background: #89d9f8;
        color: #152d42;
        font: 700 16px / 1.2 "PT Sans", sans-serif;
        text-decoration: none;
        }

        .cb-membership-banner .cb-membership-banner__cta:hover {
        background: #b0e7fb;
        }

        .cb-membership-banner .cb-membership-banner__cta:focus-visible {
        outline: 2px solid #fff;
        outline-offset: 3px;
        }

        @media (max-width: 680px) {
        .cb-membership-banner.alignfull {
        padding-block: 16px;
        }

        .cb-membership-banner__inner {
        display: grid;
        grid-template-columns: minmax(0, 1fr);
        gap: 10px 14px;
        justify-items: start;
        }

        .cb-membership-banner__inner:has(.cb-membership-banner__image) {
        grid-template-columns: 64px minmax(0, 1fr);
        }

        .cb-membership-banner__image {
        grid-row: span 2;
        width: 64px;
        align-self: start;
        }
        }
        .cb-membership-banner.alignfull { box-sizing: border-box; width: var(--width--responsive--container, calc(100% - 32px)); margin: clamp(24px, 4vw, 48px) auto; padding: 20px clamp(16px, 4vw, 56px); border-radius: 5px; background: var(--color--brand-1, #152d42); color: #f3f3f3; } .cb-membership-banner__inner { display: flex; align-items: center; gap: clamp(16px, 3vw, 40px); max-width: var(--width--l, 1400px); margin-inline: auto; } .cb-membership-banner__image { position: relative; flex: none; width: 104px; } .cb-membership-banner__image img { display: block; width: 100%; height: auto; max-height: 100px; object-fit: contain; } /* Crop the transparent border around the current CB+ logo. */ .cb-membership-banner__image--logo { aspect-ratio: 1279 / 1208; overflow: hidden; } .cb-membership-banner__image--logo img { position: absolute; top: 50%; left: 50%; width: 230%; height: auto; max-width: none; max-height: none; transform: translate(-48.65%, -49.17%); } .cb-membership-banner__copy { flex: 1; min-width: 0; } .cb-membership-banner .cb-membership-banner__label { display: inline-block; margin: 0 0 5px; padding-top: 4px; border-top: 2px solid currentColor; color: inherit; font: 700 13px / 1.2 "PT Sans", sans-serif; text-transform: uppercase; } .cb-membership-banner .cb-membership-banner__title { margin: 0; color: inherit; font: 700 clamp(24px, 2.8vw, 38px) / 1.1 "PT Sans Narrow", sans-serif; } .cb-membership-banner .cb-membership-banner__cta { display: inline-flex; flex: none; align-items: center; justify-content: center; box-sizing: border-box; min-height: 44px; padding: 10px 18px; border-radius: 4px; background: #89d9f8; color: #152d42; font: 700 16px / 1.2 "PT Sans", sans-serif; text-decoration: none; } .cb-membership-banner .cb-membership-banner__cta:hover { background: #b0e7fb; } .cb-membership-banner .cb-membership-banner__cta:focus-visible { outline: 2px solid #fff; outline-offset: 3px; } @media (max-width: 680px) { .cb-membership-banner.alignfull { padding-block: 16px; } .cb-membership-banner__inner { display: grid; grid-template-columns: minmax(0, 1fr); gap: 10px 14px; justify-items: start; } .cb-membership-banner__inner:has(.cb-membership-banner__image) { grid-template-columns: 64px minmax(0, 1fr); } .cb-membership-banner__image { grid-row: span 2; width: 64px; align-self: start; } }

        Membership

        Support award-winning climate journalism Join CB+

        In contrast, nations that are heavily reliant on energy imports – such as Japan or Germany – are responsible for far lower shares of planet-warming emissions, if responsibility passes to fossil-fuel producers.

        There are many different ways to assign historical responsibility for current global warming.

        Carbon Brief has previously published analysis based on territorial emissions, the consumption of imported goods, according to colonial rule or based on historical emissions per capita.

        Historical responsibility

        This year is expected to be around 1.5C hotter than pre-industrial temperatures. Next year is forecast to be the hottest on record, at around 1.7C of warming.

        This year-to-year variation is due to natural variability, such as El Niño. However, approximately 100% of global warming to date is the result of human-caused greenhouse gas emissions.

        The burning of fossil fuels since the industrial revolution is the largest contributor to this.

        Since there is a direct link between each tonne of CO2 and each fraction of a degree of warming, historical fossil-fuel emissions can be tied to responsibility for current climate change.

        This is typically calculated on the basis of historical territorial CO2 emissions, according to where in the world the fossil fuels are burned. It is also possible to assign historical responsibility on a “consumption” basis, according to where goods are used.

        Historical emissions are often counted by country, but this puts the focus on populous nations. Alternatively, responsibility can be assigned per capita, based on today’s populations.

        A less-familiar way to look at the question of historical responsibility is to consider where fossil fuels are extracted. This puts the spotlight on major fossil-fuel exporters.

        The figure below shows that Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia are the largest CO2 exporters of all time, based on emissions from exported fossil fuels since 1850.

        (The allocation is based on extraction taking place within current national borders. Emissions under the former USSR, Czechoslovakia and Yugoslavia are allocated among constituent countries, based on their share of emissions at the time of separation.)

        Other major CO2 exporters, based on their overseas sales of fossil fuels since 1850, include Venezuela, Iran, Norway, the United Arab Emirates and Canada.

        Between them, these major coal, oil and gas producers have exported hundreds of billions of tonnes of CO2 over the past 175 years, according to Carbon Brief’s analysis.

        Extraction-based accounting

        The analysis shows that overall, the US and China retain the largest responsibility for historical warming under extraction-based accounting, despite having been net CO2 importers since 1850.

        The US has large resources of coal, oil and gas, but was nevertheless a major oil importer until after the shale revolution in the early 2000s.

        China remains a major oil and gas importer, describing itself as “rich in coal, lacking oil and gas”.

        Russia remains in third place, as shown in the figure below, despite gaining responsibility for an extra 69bn tonnes of CO2 from exported fossil fuels.

        The UK becomes the fourth-largest historical emitter, climbing above Germany due to the latter’s reliance on fossil-fuel imports.

        Saudi Arabia becomes responsible for the world’s fifth-largest share of historical warming when including its fossil-fuel exports, which increase its cumulative emissions more than fourfold.

        Australia also climbs up the rankings, becoming one of the top-ten largest emitters when including its fossil-fuel exports. This more than doubles its share of historical emissions.

        Nations that drop down the rankings under extraction-based accounting, due to their reliance on fossil-fuel imports, include Germany, India, France and COP31 host Turkey.

        Japan is a particularly notable example, as it is almost completely reliant on fossil-fuel imports. The nation is the sixth-largest emitter on a territorial basis and the 34th-largest on an extraction basis.

        Per-capita accounting

        When considering population sizes, major fossil-fuel exporters have the highest extraction-based CO2 emissions since 1850, as shown in the figure below.

        Small nations that export large amounts of oil and gas are particularly prominent on this list, including Brunei, Kuwait, Qatar, Norway and Trinidad and Tobago.

        Andrew tells Carbon Brief that while the extraction-based accounting offers an alternative perspective on historical responsibility for warming, it also raises complex questions. He explains: 

        “At the end of the day, it’s not solely the responsibility of extracting countries that fuels are combusted; it’s joint responsibility between extractors, producers and consumers.”

        He adds that responsibility for past decisions is shared by many actors. For example, he notes that oil production in the Middle East was historically “developed by and for western powers”.

        var gform;gform||(document.addEventListener("gform_main_scripts_loaded",function(){gform.scriptsLoaded=!0}),document.addEventListener("gform/theme/scripts_loaded",function(){gform.themeScriptsLoaded=!0}),window.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded",function(){gform.domLoaded=!0}),gform={domLoaded:!1,scriptsLoaded:!1,themeScriptsLoaded:!1,isFormEditor:()=>"function"==typeof InitializeEditor,callIfLoaded:function(o){return!(!gform.domLoaded||!gform.scriptsLoaded||!gform.themeScriptsLoaded&&!gform.isFormEditor()||(gform.isFormEditor()&&console.warn("The use of gform.initializeOnLoaded() is deprecated in the form editor context and will be removed in Gravity Forms 3.1."),o(),0))},initializeOnLoaded:function(o){gform.callIfLoaded(o)||(document.addEventListener("gform_main_scripts_loaded",()=>{gform.scriptsLoaded=!0,gform.callIfLoaded(o)}),document.addEventListener("gform/theme/scripts_loaded",()=>{gform.themeScriptsLoaded=!0,gform.callIfLoaded(o)}),window.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded",()=>{gform.domLoaded=!0,gform.callIfLoaded(o)}))},hooks:{action:{},filter:{}},addAction:function(o,r,e,t){gform.addHook("action",o,r,e,t)},addFilter:function(o,r,e,t){gform.addHook("filter",o,r,e,t)},doAction:function(o){gform.doHook("action",o,arguments)},applyFilters:function(o){return gform.doHook("filter",o,arguments)},removeAction:function(o,r){gform.removeHook("action",o,r)},removeFilter:function(o,r,e){gform.removeHook("filter",o,r,e)},addHook:function(o,r,e,t,n){null==gform.hooks[o][r]&&(gform.hooks[o][r]=[]);var d=gform.hooks[o][r];null==n&&(n=r+"_"+d.length),gform.hooks[o][r].push({tag:n,callable:e,priority:t=null==t?10:t})},doHook:function(r,o,e){var t;if(e=Array.prototype.slice.call(e,1),null!=gform.hooks[r][o]&&((o=gform.hooks[r][o]).sort(function(o,r){return o.priority-r.priority}),o.forEach(function(o){"function"!=typeof(t=o.callable)&&(t=window[t]),"action"==r?t.apply(null,e):e[0]=t.apply(null,e)})),"filter"==r)return e[0]},removeHook:function(o,r,t,n){var e;null!=gform.hooks[o][r]&&(e=(e=gform.hooks[o][r]).filter(function(o,r,e){return!!(null!=n&&n!=o.tag||null!=t&&t!=o.priority)}),gform.hooks[o][r]=e)}}); #gform_wrapper_7[data-form-index="0"].gform-theme,[data-parent-form="7_0"]{--gf-color-primary: #204ce5;--gf-color-primary-rgb: 32, 76, 229;--gf-color-primary-contrast: #fff;--gf-color-primary-contrast-rgb: 255, 255, 255;--gf-color-primary-darker: #001AB3;--gf-color-primary-lighter: #527EFF;--gf-color-secondary: #fff;--gf-color-secondary-rgb: 255, 255, 255;--gf-color-secondary-contrast: #112337;--gf-color-secondary-contrast-rgb: 17, 35, 55;--gf-color-secondary-darker: #F5F5F5;--gf-color-secondary-lighter: #FFFFFF;--gf-color-out-ctrl-light: rgba(17, 35, 55, 0.1);--gf-color-out-ctrl-light-rgb: 17, 35, 55;--gf-color-out-ctrl-light-darker: rgba(104, 110, 119, 0.35);--gf-color-out-ctrl-light-lighter: #F5F5F5;--gf-color-out-ctrl-dark: #585e6a;--gf-color-out-ctrl-dark-rgb: 88, 94, 106;--gf-color-out-ctrl-dark-darker: #112337;--gf-color-out-ctrl-dark-lighter: rgba(17, 35, 55, 0.65);--gf-color-in-ctrl: #fff;--gf-color-in-ctrl-rgb: 255, 255, 255;--gf-color-in-ctrl-contrast: #112337;--gf-color-in-ctrl-contrast-rgb: 17, 35, 55;--gf-color-in-ctrl-darker: #F5F5F5;--gf-color-in-ctrl-lighter: #FFFFFF;--gf-color-in-ctrl-primary: #204ce5;--gf-color-in-ctrl-primary-rgb: 32, 76, 229;--gf-color-in-ctrl-primary-contrast: #fff;--gf-color-in-ctrl-primary-contrast-rgb: 255, 255, 255;--gf-color-in-ctrl-primary-darker: #001AB3;--gf-color-in-ctrl-primary-lighter: #527EFF;--gf-color-in-ctrl-light: rgba(17, 35, 55, 0.1);--gf-color-in-ctrl-light-rgb: 17, 35, 55;--gf-color-in-ctrl-light-darker: rgba(104, 110, 119, 0.35);--gf-color-in-ctrl-light-lighter: #F5F5F5;--gf-color-in-ctrl-dark: #585e6a;--gf-color-in-ctrl-dark-rgb: 88, 94, 106;--gf-color-in-ctrl-dark-darker: #112337;--gf-color-in-ctrl-dark-lighter: rgba(17, 35, 55, 0.65);--gf-radius: 3px;--gf-font-size-secondary: 14px;--gf-font-size-tertiary: 13px;--gf-icon-ctrl-number: url("data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg width='8' height='14' viewBox='0 0 8 14' fill='none' xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%3E%3Cpath fill-rule='evenodd' clip-rule='evenodd' d='M4 0C4.26522 5.96046e-08 4.51957 0.105357 4.70711 0.292893L7.70711 3.29289C8.09763 3.68342 8.09763 4.31658 7.70711 4.70711C7.31658 5.09763 6.68342 5.09763 6.29289 4.70711L4 2.41421L1.70711 4.70711C1.31658 5.09763 0.683417 5.09763 0.292893 4.70711C-0.0976311 4.31658 -0.097631 3.68342 0.292893 3.29289L3.29289 0.292893C3.48043 0.105357 3.73478 0 4 0ZM0.292893 9.29289C0.683417 8.90237 1.31658 8.90237 1.70711 9.29289L4 11.5858L6.29289 9.29289C6.68342 8.90237 7.31658 8.90237 7.70711 9.29289C8.09763 9.68342 8.09763 10.3166 7.70711 10.7071L4.70711 13.7071C4.31658 14.0976 3.68342 14.0976 3.29289 13.7071L0.292893 10.7071C-0.0976311 10.3166 -0.0976311 9.68342 0.292893 9.29289Z' fill='rgba(17, 35, 55, 0.65)'/%3E%3C/svg%3E");--gf-icon-ctrl-select: url("data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg width='10' height='6' viewBox='0 0 10 6' fill='none' xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%3E%3Cpath fill-rule='evenodd' clip-rule='evenodd' d='M0.292893 0.292893C0.683417 -0.097631 1.31658 -0.097631 1.70711 0.292893L5 3.58579L8.29289 0.292893C8.68342 -0.0976311 9.31658 -0.0976311 9.70711 0.292893C10.0976 0.683417 10.0976 1.31658 9.70711 1.70711L5.70711 5.70711C5.31658 6.09763 4.68342 6.09763 4.29289 5.70711L0.292893 1.70711C-0.0976311 1.31658 -0.0976311 0.683418 0.292893 0.292893Z' fill='rgba(17, 35, 55, 0.65)'/%3E%3C/svg%3E");--gf-icon-ctrl-search: url("data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg width='640' height='640' xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%3E%3Cpath d='M256 128c-70.692 0-128 57.308-128 128 0 70.691 57.308 128 128 128 70.691 0 128-57.309 128-128 0-70.692-57.309-128-128-128zM64 256c0-106.039 85.961-192 192-192s192 85.961 192 192c0 41.466-13.146 79.863-35.498 111.248l154.125 154.125c12.496 12.496 12.496 32.758 0 45.254s-32.758 12.496-45.254 0L367.248 412.502C335.862 434.854 297.467 448 256 448c-106.039 0-192-85.962-192-192z' fill='rgba(17, 35, 55, 0.65)'/%3E%3C/svg%3E");--gf-label-space-y-secondary: var(--gf-label-space-y-md-secondary);--gf-ctrl-border-color: #686e77;--gf-ctrl-size: var(--gf-ctrl-size-md);--gf-ctrl-label-color-primary: #112337;--gf-ctrl-label-color-secondary: #112337;--gf-ctrl-choice-size: var(--gf-ctrl-choice-size-md);--gf-ctrl-checkbox-check-size: var(--gf-ctrl-checkbox-check-size-md);--gf-ctrl-radio-check-size: var(--gf-ctrl-radio-check-size-md);--gf-ctrl-btn-font-size: var(--gf-ctrl-btn-font-size-md);--gf-ctrl-btn-padding-x: var(--gf-ctrl-btn-padding-x-md);--gf-ctrl-btn-size: var(--gf-ctrl-btn-size-md);--gf-ctrl-btn-border-color-secondary: #686e77;--gf-ctrl-file-btn-bg-color-hover: #EBEBEB;--gf-field-img-choice-size: var(--gf-field-img-choice-size-md);--gf-field-img-choice-card-space: var(--gf-field-img-choice-card-space-md);--gf-field-img-choice-check-ind-size: var(--gf-field-img-choice-check-ind-size-md);--gf-field-img-choice-check-ind-icon-size: var(--gf-field-img-choice-check-ind-icon-size-md);--gf-field-pg-steps-number-color: rgba(17, 35, 55, 0.8);}

        X/TwitterThis field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

        Free weekly newsletter

        .preheader p{ margin-top: 0; font-family: 'PT Sans', sans-serif; font-weight: var(--type--3--font-weight--bold); color: var(--button--color); font-size: var(--button--font-size, inherit); } .newsletter-inline{ display: flex; border: solid 1px #333333; padding: 1em; background: #ffffff; } .inline-email{ display:inline-block; margin-right:1em; margin-top:0 !important; margin-bottom:0.5em; } #field_submit{ display:inline-block; margin-top:0 !important; } .gform_wrapper .gfield+.gfield{ margin-top:0 } Email gform.initializeOnLoaded( function() {gformInitSpinner( 7, 'http://www.carbonbrief.org/wp-content/plugins/gravityforms/images/spinner.svg', false );jQuery('#gform_ajax_frame_7').on('load',function(){var contents = jQuery(this).contents().find('*').html();var is_postback = contents.indexOf('GF_AJAX_POSTBACK') >= 0;if(!is_postback){return;}var form_content = jQuery(this).contents().find('#gform_wrapper_7');var is_confirmation = jQuery(this).contents().find('#gform_confirmation_wrapper_7').length > 0;var is_redirect = contents.indexOf('gformRedirect(){') >= 0;var is_form = form_content.length > 0 && ! is_redirect && ! is_confirmation;var mt = parseInt(jQuery('html').css('margin-top'), 10) + parseInt(jQuery('body').css('margin-top'), 10) + 100;if(is_form){jQuery('#gform_wrapper_7').html(form_content.html());if(form_content.hasClass('gform_validation_error')){jQuery('#gform_wrapper_7').addClass('gform_validation_error');} else {jQuery('#gform_wrapper_7').removeClass('gform_validation_error');}setTimeout( function() { /* delay the scroll by 50 milliseconds to fix a bug in chrome */ jQuery(document).scrollTop(jQuery('#gform_wrapper_7').offset().top - mt); }, 50 );if(window['gformInitDatepicker']) {gformInitDatepicker();}if(window['gformInitPriceFields']) {gformInitPriceFields();}var current_page = jQuery('#gform_source_page_number_7').val();gformInitSpinner( 7, 'http://www.carbonbrief.org/wp-content/plugins/gravityforms/images/spinner.svg', false );jQuery(document).trigger('gform_page_loaded', [7, current_page]);window['gf_submitting_7'] = false;}else if(!is_redirect){var confirmation_content = jQuery(this).contents().find('.GF_AJAX_POSTBACK').html();if(!confirmation_content){confirmation_content = contents;}jQuery('#gform_wrapper_7').replaceWith(confirmation_content);jQuery(document).scrollTop(jQuery('#gf_7').offset().top - mt);jQuery(document).trigger('gform_confirmation_loaded', [7]);window['gf_submitting_7'] = false;wp.a11y.speak(jQuery('#gform_confirmation_message_7').text());}else{jQuery('#gform_7').append(contents);if(window['gformRedirect']) {gformRedirect();}}jQuery(document).trigger("gform_pre_post_render", [{ formId: "7", currentPage: "current_page", abort: function() { this.preventDefault(); } }]); if (event && event.defaultPrevented) { return; } const gformWrapperDiv = document.getElementById( "gform_wrapper_7" ); if ( gformWrapperDiv ) { const visibilitySpan = document.createElement( "span" ); visibilitySpan.id = "gform_visibility_test_7"; gformWrapperDiv.insertAdjacentElement( "afterend", visibilitySpan ); } const visibilityTestDiv = document.getElementById( "gform_visibility_test_7" ); let postRenderFired = false; function triggerPostRender() { if ( postRenderFired ) { return; } postRenderFired = true; gform.core.triggerPostRenderEvents( 7, current_page ); if ( visibilityTestDiv ) { visibilityTestDiv.parentNode.removeChild( visibilityTestDiv ); } } function debounce( func, wait, immediate ) { var timeout; return function() { var context = this, args = arguments; var later = function() { timeout = null; if ( !immediate ) func.apply( context, args ); }; var callNow = immediate && !timeout; clearTimeout( timeout ); timeout = setTimeout( later, wait ); if ( callNow ) func.apply( context, args ); }; } const debouncedTriggerPostRender = debounce( function() { triggerPostRender(); }, 200 ); if ( visibilityTestDiv && visibilityTestDiv.offsetParent === null ) { const observer = new MutationObserver( ( mutations ) => { mutations.forEach( ( mutation ) => { if ( mutation.type === 'attributes' && visibilityTestDiv.offsetParent !== null ) { debouncedTriggerPostRender(); observer.disconnect(); } }); }); observer.observe( document.body, { attributes: true, childList: false, subtree: true, attributeFilter: [ 'style', 'class' ], }); } else { triggerPostRender(); } } );} ); About the data

        National emissions under extraction-based accounting come from a dataset developed by Robbie Andrew and covering the period from 1850-2025.

        Emissions are allocated to the country that extracted the relevant fossil fuels, regardless of where the coal, oil or gas was burned.

        The allocation is based on current national borders. Emissions that took place within the former USSR, Czechoslovakia and Yugoslavia are allocated among their present-day constituent countries, based on the relative shares of emissions at the time of separation.

        Andrew notes that the dataset is a draft release, based on available data.

        Population data for 2025 is taken from the UN Population Fund.

        RELATED COP31: How Ed Miliband answered Carbon Brief readers’ questions 12.11.2026 COP31 Antalya Analysis: Climate-finance pledges fall 70% as countries meet at COP31  11.11.2026 COP31 Antalya Analysis: Which countries have sent the most delegates to COP31? 10.11.2026 COP31 Antalya Analysis: Fossil-fuel CO2 emissions set to dip in 2026 as Iran conflict hits oil use 10.11.2026 Carbon budgets

        The post Revealed: Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia are largest CO2 exporters of all time appeared first on Carbon Brief.

        Categories: I. Climate Science

        Minerals for the planet or for war and AI? COP31 must make clear what we prioritise

        Climate Change News - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 20:00

        Elisa Morgera is the UN Special Rapporteur on Climate Change and Human Rights.

        For years, governments and international financial institutions have justified the mining boom by arguing that the energy transition cannot happen without critical minerals.  

        Increasingly, however, they are securing those minerals for something else: weapons and artificial intelligence (AI).

        At COP31, governments must make clear what a sustainable and fair energy transition requires and reject demand for minerals that fuels war and other climate-harming uses. 

        Independent research shows that mineral demand is increasingly driven by AI and militarisation. Yet, both undermine climate action.

        Major armed conflicts are linked to fossil fuel expansion, generate emissions that are unaccounted for under the Paris Agreement, and deliver record profits to fossil fuel and petrochemical companies through price spikes and disrupted access to fuel and food. 

        Meanwhile, AI infrastructure risks undoing the progress of the renewable energy transition by driving fossil fuel expansion to meet data centres’ vast new energy demand.  

          UN Secretary-General António Guterres and the head of UN Climate Change Simon Stiell have both warned of the climate harm of unchecked, fossil fuel-powered AI and data centre growth. 

          In addition, AI equipment and infrastructure require huge amounts of copper – one of the minerals most in demand for the energy transition. A recent academic study found that copper makes up roughly 82-83% of the mineral mass in data centres. 

          None of this demand serves the energy transition. Instead, the climate case for mining is being used to legitimise uses that undermine a sustainable future.

          Mining still relies heavily on fossil fuels and often harms the environment, so it must be limited to extracting the resources strictly necessary for the energy transition. Otherwise, states breach their binding obligations to protect the environment and human rights, as the International Court of Justice (ICJ) has made clear. 

          National security is the new mining fast track 

          Campaigners have long warned that when minerals become a matter of national security, governments are more tempted to deregulate and fast-track mining projects. Communities pay the price.  

          Extraction without adequate consultation is a global pattern linked to killings of land and environmental defenders. More than half of transition mineral projects are located on or near Indigenous lands, and allegations of abuses linked to mining transition minerals surged 73% in 2025 alone. 

          Security and climate are not separate problems. Both are rooted in the fossil fuel-based global economy, now joined by the unchecked growth of AI and data centres.  

          Who should benefit from minerals? 

          Not every demand for minerals can or should be met. Minerals are finite and must be used to address the worsening climate crisis as a priority.

          The COP31 presidency’s push for electrification will have significant implications for mineral demand. At the same time, electrification doesn’t necessarily help to phase out fossil fuels. Governments must be clear about how minerals are being used and prioritise uses that genuinely advance the energy transition.

          • Climate action comes first: Mineral demand for the wind and solar projects that power communities and essential public services such as local food systems should be met first. Priority uses should include community-led wind and solar projects and renewable power for public transport.
          • No support for climate-harming activities: Mineral demand projections for the energy transition should exclude the military-industrial complex and data centres, and governments should reconsider public spending on militarisation. Mineral demand for electrification should also be scrutinised to avoid deepening fossil fuel dependence.
          • Cut demand before expanding supply: High-consuming countries should use less primary material through efficiency, longer-lasting products and by reducing car dependence, rather than exporting waste and harm to the Global South. 
          • Prioritise energy needs: Those without access to energy must be served first. Overproduction and overconsumption must be curbed, otherwise the transition will neither mitigate climate change nor reduce poverty. 
          • No mining without consent: No project should receive financing or permits without the Free, Prior and Informed Consent of Indigenous Peoples and genuine consultations with affected communities. 
          • No-go zones: States should establish no-go mining zones in ecologically sensitive areas, on land and at sea, and ensure that mining does not cause significant harm to biodiversity.
          What can COP31 do? 

          Last year, governments agreed to develop a Just Transition Mechanism, but explicit provisions on transition mineral governance were dropped. At COP31, negotiators are reconsidering the issue. I urge negotiators in Antalya to: 

          • Reflect states’ obligations underpinning the ICJ Advisory Opinion and the UN Secretary-General’s Critical Energy Transition Minerals Panel principles in the Just Transition Work Programme. 
          • Keep mineral demand for the military and digital infrastructure separate from demand that serves climate protection.
          • Require traceability and end-use disclosure, so it is publicly known whether a mineral ends up in a battery, a missile or a data centre. 
          • Respect the human rights of Indigenous Peoples, peasants and environmental human rights defenders, including the right to say no, protection from reprisals and access to remedy. 

          At COP31, transition minerals should be unequivocally linked to everyone’s human right to a safe climate and a healthy environment. 

          The post Minerals for the planet or for war and AI? COP31 must make clear what we prioritise appeared first on Climate Home News.

          Categories: H. Green News

          Think Tanks on The Hill: In Conversation with Senators Cardozo and Dasko

          Centre for Future Work - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 15:30

          A fascinating initiative has been launched by Senators Andrew Cardozo and Donna Dasko to showcase the contributions Canadian think tanks make to research and policy development in Canada. Called ‘Think Tanks on The Hill,’ the program invites various think tanks to share their approaches to research, advocacy, and the key challenges facing Canada’s economy and society.

          The Centre for Future Work was proud to participate in the second instalment of the project, along with representatives from the C.D. Howe Institute, the Canada West Foundation, and the Shorefast Institute.

          In this recording of their exchange, Centre Director Jim Stanford highlights how Canada is pivoting in response to the threats from U.S. President Donald Trump, the challenges of national policy-making in a country with so much regional diversity, and the opportunities of building a sovereign, inclusive, sustainable, and capable Canadian economy.

          The post Think Tanks on The Hill: In Conversation with Senators Cardozo and Dasko appeared first on Centre for Future Work.

          Categories: A2. Green Unionism

          Thomas Frank on How the Elites Used Creativity and Innovation to Con America

          Green and Red Podcast - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 15:27
          Politics and culture are used by the Ruling Class to subvert working class movements and secure consent from the masses along with state violence and economic dominance. These Gramscian methods…
          Categories: B4. Radical Ecology

          Pages

          The Fine Print I:

          Disclaimer: The views expressed on this site are not the official position of the IWW (or even the IWW’s EUC) unless otherwise indicated and do not necessarily represent the views of anyone but the author’s, nor should it be assumed that any of these authors automatically support the IWW or endorse any of its positions.

          Further: the inclusion of a link on our site (other than the link to the main IWW site) does not imply endorsement by or an alliance with the IWW. These sites have been chosen by our members due to their perceived relevance to the IWW EUC and are included here for informational purposes only. If you have any suggestions or comments on any of the links included (or not included) above, please contact us.

          The Fine Print II:

          Fair Use Notice: The material on this site is provided for educational and informational purposes. It may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. It is being made available in an effort to advance the understanding of scientific, environmental, economic, social justice and human rights issues etc.

          It is believed that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have an interest in using the included information for research and educational purposes. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. The information on this site does not constitute legal or technical advice.