You are here

News Feeds

Director of Strategic Communications and Marketing

Greenbelt Alliance - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 15:27
Overview

Job Location: Oakland, hybrid – 2 days required in office
Position Start Date: January 2027
Job Classification: Full-time, Salaried, Exempt
Annual Salary: $110-120K
Reporting To: Executive Director

Apply About this Opportunity

Are you a strategic thinker and compelling communicator? Excited to lead the Marketing and Communications team and set the narrative strategy for a longstanding environmental nonprofit with energizing, complex work at the intersection of climate, housing, land use, and planning? Greenbelt Alliance is hiring a Director of Strategic Communications and Marketing to guide and elevate our messaging, communications, marketing, and public relations to amplify our critical mission and advance equitable climate resilience for communities across the region. This position will report to the Executive Director and be a member of the Leadership Team.

This senior leadership role requires the ability to navigate, resource, execute, and delegate marketing and communications to support programmatic projects and institutional efforts. We are seeking a leader with a vision and ability to execute and adapt content for different audiences and demonstrate a deep understanding of our work to drive thought leadership in our communications. This is an opportunity to lead exciting local and statewide work that shifts narratives around climate and housing.

YOU’LL BE A GREAT FIT FOR THE ROLE IF YOU BRING:

  • Experience engaging audiences and translating complex ideas into compelling stories that inspire action.
  • Excellent verbal, visual, and written communication skills, with the ability to articulate ideas clearly and effectively to diverse audiences.
  • Team leadership with a proven track record of guiding teams to achieve results through mentorship, priority-setting, creativity, and collaboration.
  • A data-driven approach to communications; owning and analyzing metrics, establishing growth strategies, and amplifying impact.
  • A passion for supporting organizational excellence in our mission to ensure the Bay Area’s lands and communities are resilient to a changing climate.

Key Activities 

  • Develop and execute integrated communications strategies and campaigns that advance our mission and connect our work to Bay Area residents, government agencies, nonprofit partners, and donors.
  • Lead brand strategy and messaging, ensuring our voice, identity, and key messages are clear, consistent, and compelling across all communications.
  • Oversee content development and multi-channel execution, translating complex environmental, climate, housing, and land use topics into accessible content for several formats including digital ads, social media, email newsletters, print materials, and media outreach.
  • Lead advocacy and policy communications, including coalition messaging, campaign support, and rapid response and crisis communications.
  • Ensure communications are accessible, multilingual, and culturally relevant, centering equity in how stories are told and who tells them.
  • Lead media relations, including writing press releases, pitching stories, supporting staff in writing op-eds, and preparing spokespeople for interviews.
  • Lead Marketing and Communications team; providing leadership, supervision, and support for three staff members. Manage annual work plans and provide guidance, direction, and professional development to set project priorities, manage cross-departmental coordination, and foster a culture of accountability, empowerment, care, and shared success.
  • Oversee Marketing and Communications departmental budget and hold responsibility for effective use of funds to advance communications goals in collaboration with Executive Director and Director of Finance and Operations. 
  • Lead marketing strategy implementation, including optimizing online presence through targeted campaigns, SEO/SEM/GEO, email, SMS, and overseeing social media engagement. Manage CRM database and integrations.
  • Manage website strategy and oversee website updates and maintenance, including content creation, design updates, and functionality.
  • Serve as the marketing liaison with the Development team and collaborate closely across Program, Operations, and the Executive Team to ensure alignment and integration of organizational initiatives. 
  • Manage communications consultants, providing strategic direction and developing and deploying scopes of work for landmark projects; serve as communications consultant lead to external agencies on fee-for-service projects.

Desired Qualifications

NOTE: We do not expect any single candidate to have extensive expertise/experience in all of these areas, but will prioritize candidates with demonstrated success in the following:

  • 5+ years of communications experience, including 3+ years in a director-level role leading strategy in a nonprofit, advocacy, or public-interest setting.
  • Demonstrated ability to translate complex policy and technical topics into clear, persuasive stories that engage audiences and inspire action.
  • Proven track record developing brand and messaging strategy and running multi-channel campaigns, with strong writing and editing skills across formats from short-form digital content to long-form reports.
  • Experience in team management, with a strong ability to project manage, set annual team goals, and provide direction and decision-making.
  • Ability to set strategy, outline project direction, and execute certain tasks while delegating and empowering team members to grow in these aspects over time.
  • Knowledge of land use, climate change, adaptation or environmental advocacy.
  • Experience with policy or advocacy communications and with reaching diverse, multilingual audiences.
  • Advanced experience using any of the following software: Google Suite, Asana, Slack, Salesforce, Mailchimp, Zoom, and Classy.
Benefits

  • 100% Employer-Paid Health Insurance, Dental Insurance, and Vision Insurance policies. Life insurance policy also provided.
  • 50% Employer-Paid Insurance policies for dependents.
  • Generous Paid Time-Off package, including Vacation Days, Sick Days, and Floating Holidays. As many as 14 paid holidays off, including Winter Break.
  • Professional development and training opportunities.
How to Apply

Applications for this position will be considered on a rolling basis; however, priority consideration will be given to applications submitted by 12/11/2026 Please allow several weeks for a response as we are reviewing applications. Be sure to attach both a cover letter and professional resume as PDF documents to your application.

Apply

WORK AUTHORIZATION

At this time, Greenbelt Alliance is unable to offer assistance to noncitizens or nonresidents in obtaining employer-sponsored work visas. All employees must have existing authorization from the federal government to work lawfully in the United States of America. Authorization would include US citizenship, US permanent residency (“green card”), or any other type of unexpired work authorization visa issued by the federal government.

EQUAL EMPLOYMENT STATEMENT

Greenbelt Alliance is an equal opportunity employer that does not discriminate on the basis of race, religion, disability, sex, gender expression, nationality, ethnicity, sexual orientation, or any other category. We strongly encourage people of color, LGBTQIA+ persons, people of different levels of physical ability, people with diverse national and class origins, and all qualified persons to apply for this position. Learn more about our nondiscrimination policy here.

Greenbelt Alliance encourages candidates of all abilities to apply to this position! In case you may require any kind of special accommodation in order to complete the application or hiring process, please contact us at accessibility@greenbelt.org.

ABOUT GREENBELT ALLIANCE

Greenbelt Alliance’s mission is to educate, advocate, and collaborate to ensure the Bay Area’s lands and communities are resilient to a changing climate. Greenbelt Alliance has stewarded the region’s beautiful natural landscapes while promoting the growth needed for thriving communities for nearly 70 years. We focus on innovative policy solutions and accelerating local and regional collaboration to plan and invest in resilient communities. Learn more at greenbelt.org.

The post Director of Strategic Communications and Marketing appeared first on Greenbelt Alliance.

Categories: G2. Local Greens

NC WARN Blasts Regulators for Duke Energy Gift — Statement from Executive Director Jim Warren

NC WARN - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 14:21

Statement from Executive Director Jim Warren:

The NC Utilities Commission once again rubber stamped Duke Energy’s plans to expand fossil fuels to power A.I. data centers and spend hundreds of millions of customer dollars to study failure-prone experimental nuclear power plants while limiting renewables. This cements the massive corporation’s spot as one of the world’s worst climate polluters. The regulators will again let Duke Energy continue with frequent rate increases and wrecking the planet. 

###

Now in its 38th year, NC WARN is building people power in the climate and energy justice movement to persuade or require Charlotte-based Duke Energy – one of the world’s largest climate polluters – to make a quick transition to renewable, affordable power generation and energy efficiency in order to avert climate tipping points and ongoing rate hikes. 

The post NC WARN Blasts Regulators for Duke Energy Gift — Statement from Executive Director Jim Warren appeared first on NC WARN.

Categories: G2. Local Greens

The fix is still in

Skeptical Science - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 13:16

This is a re-post from The Climate Brink by Andrew Dessler

This is a re-post of something I wrote in early Sept. of 2025. I’m reposting it because I have heard from an author of the DOE report that they have a revised report that “responds” to criticisms of the original report. This post describes what they should do if they want their response to be considered legitimate science.

If they just release a new report and simply say, “Here it is, we’ve responded to the criticism,” their response will be considered a sham by the scientific community. As described here, there is an accepted way to respond to criticism in peer review and they need to follow them.

Of course, they won’t do that because the DOE report is not a scientific document and the authors don’t care at all about engaging with the scientific community. Rather, the report is fossil-fuel propaganda.

Here it is, from Sept. 2025:

My last post described our 450-page response to the DOE Climate Working Group report. This DOE report seems designed to muddy the waters about climate science — it’s a new iteration of the Merchants of Doubt. We found the report used selective misquoting of the scientific literature (cherry picking), omission of contrary results from the scientific literature, and simple errors due to a lack of understanding of the science to reach its conclusions. Further commentary of the process is in this post.

A reporter asked me for a comment on a post on Dr. Judy Curry’s blog about our review of the DOE Climate Working Group report. In her post, she said:

Let me first say, wow, this is generous and far better than I expected. Only referring to me as “unhinged” once is a W and I’ll take it. Near the end of her post, she wrote:

underline added by me

When I read the underlined portion (added by me), I said to myself, “so that’s how they’re going to do it.” Yes, the fix is in — everyone should understand that this is a show trial for climate science and the inevitable outcome of this “debate” will be that climate science is found to be too uncertain to justify climate policy. And now I think I know how they’ll do it.

Let me walk you through it, starting with an explanation of how peer review works.

how does peer review work?

Peer review is a system of quality control designed to ensure the rigor of research and it’s one of the bedrocks of science. This process begins after individual research groups conduct their analyses and write up their findings in a manuscript.

The authors submit their manuscript to a scholarly journal. The manuscript is then assigned to one of the journal’s editors, who are typically established experts in the field. The editor first assesses the paper for its suitability for the journal. If it meets the basic criteria, the editor then sends the paper out to a few independent experts in the same field. These are the “peers” in peer review.

These peer reviewers critically evaluate the manuscript, scrutinizing its methodology, the validity of its data, the soundness of its conclusions, and its overall contribution to the field. They then send detailed comments and recommendations back to the editor.

The editor evaluates these comments and sends anonymized versions to the authors. The authors are then required to revise their paper, addressing the concerns and suggestions raised by the peer reviewers.

A crucial aspect of this process is that the ultimate authority to publish rests with the editor. Therefore, the authors must convince the editor that they have made the appropriate and necessary changes to their work. The paper can go back and forth over several revision cycles between the authors, the editor, and the peer reviewers.

This rigorous back-and-forth is a robust process. I can’t tell you how many times, when working with a student, I’ll tell them “That argument will never make it through peer review” as an indicator that we need to shore up that part of the work.

Eventually, the editor is satisfied that the authors have fixed the issues and the manuscript is accepted for publication. Or the editor decides that the paper does not meet the standard for publication and the paper is rejected.

While peer review does not eliminate all subpar work from being published, it absolutely compels authors to write better, clearer, and more scientifically defensible papers than would occur in its absence.

you need an editor to handle the process

The editor’s role as a neutral arbiter is essential to the peer-review system. A process where reviews were sent directly back to authors, with instructions to “incorporate the good comments” would be disastrously ineffective.

Peer review is absolutely brutal. Receiving negative peer-review feedback after you’ve invested months of work into a manuscript can be a heart-rending and upsetting experience. The natural human tendency is to dismiss negative critiques (“the reviewers are idiots”) and ignore comments that require substantial revision.

This is why the editor is so important. To get the paper published, the authors understand that they have to address these criticisms head on. They cannot just blow them off because they’re upset — they must make cogent arguments that convince the editor that they have responded reasonably to the reviewers, regardless of how distasteful that is.

To demonstrate this, journals typically require authors to submit a point-by-point response that explains how each reviewer’s comment was addressed, often supplemented by a revised manuscript with tracked changes so the editor can see exactly where the changes were made.

scientific assessments are no different

The need for an impartial editor to ensure peer review is properly handled is also a requirement for scientific assessments. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has formalized this by appointing a “Review Editor” to each chapter. These editors play the same role as journal editors: they are auditors of the review process.

Their main responsibility is to take the complete record of comments from expert and government reviewers and verify that the author teams have responded to every single one, either by revising the text or by providing a transparent and scientifically valid reason for not doing so. This structured process guarantees that criticism is not simply dismissed by angry authors.

There are comprehensive descriptions of the duties of review editors (REs). Here’s the guidance for REs from the last IPCC report:

the job of the review editor (RE) in the IPCC process the DOE report

When I saw Dr. Curry’s comment that “I wouldn’t change any of the conclusions of the DOE report in response” to our comments, I suddenly realized that the DOE is not going to appoint a review editor.

They’re going to simply send the comments to the DOE authors and leave it up those authors whether and how to address comments. This is a recipe for a review process that is an unscientific sham and it would demonstrate in no uncertain terms that the DOE is uninterested in legitimate scientific debate.

The good news is that the solution is simple: they just need to appoint an unbiased, expert review editor for each chapter and design a process like that followed by the IPCC. That review editor would track every comment and ensure that a reasonable effort has been made to respond and publicly post that.

Luckily, there are thousands of climate scientists out there, so it should not be a problem to find a half dozen or so who are unbiased.

Perhaps I’m reading too much into that Curry quote. Maybe in a few days the DOE will announce the details of a credible review process, including the appointment of expert and unbiased review editors. Maybe pigs will fly. Maybe I’ll win the 2025 AL Cy Young Award [update: I did not win it]. Who knows which of these equally likely things will occur.

Other stuff, late 2026

The Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists has been kicking ass on the DOE Climate Working Group report. Here are two stories worth reading.

Categories: I. Climate Science

Most polluting coal project in NSW’s pipeline referred to IPC over community opposition

Lock the Gate Alliance - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 13:08

A proposal to expand a coal mine in north-west NSW has been referred to the Independent Planning Commission (IPC) NSW for decision after attracting a significant number of community objections over its potential to impact local farming, groundwater, climate and threatened wildlife. 

Categories: G2. Local Greens

Dirty Dozen™ food chemicals: Sodium nitrite

Environmental Working Group - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 12:58
Dirty Dozen™ food chemicals: Sodium nitrite rcoleman November 16, 2026 EWG’s recommendation

Avoid or limit cured meats and fish containing sodium nitrite.

Sodium nitrite is a synthetic preservative that is added to processed meats and that can lead to the formation of cancer-causing compounds in the body. The International Agency for Research on Cancer, the World Health Organization’s cancer arm, classifies nitrite as probably carcinogenic to humans under certain conditions. 

Studies have linked dietary nitrite from processed meats to increased risk of certain cancers. 

What is sodium nitrite?

Sodium nitrite is a synthetic preservative and curing agent added to processed meats to prevent the growth of Clostridium botulinum, the bacterium that causes botulism. It also helps maintain the pink color and characteristic flavor of cured meats. It is sometimes used along with sodium nitrate, which is converted to nitrite by bacteria in slower curing processes.

What about naturally occurring nitrates and nitrites?

Nitrates and nitrites occur naturally in many vegetables, including spinach, beets and broccoli. These vegetables also contain vitamin C and other antioxidants that counteract the potential harms of those additives, helping prevent the formation of potentially harmful compounds in the body.

The effects of these compounds in processed meat are different. When sodium nitrite is added to meat, it can react with other compounds during processing, cooking and digestion in ways that promote the formation of potentially carcinogenic substances.

Which foods contain sodium nitrite?

Sodium nitrite is most commonly found in deli meats, bacon, hot dogs and sausage. 

Look for sodium nitrite in the ingredient list, usually on the back of the package below the Nutrition Facts panel.

How is sodium nitrite regulated?

The Food and Drug Administration permits sodium nitrite in certain food uses, including some cured fish products and home meat-curing preparations. 

The Agriculture Department sets maximum levels for its use in commercial cured meat and poultry products. Neither agency permits nitrite in baby or toddler foods.

The European Food Safety Authority has set an acceptable daily intake of 0.07 milligrams of nitrite per kilogram of body weight per day. A 2017 EFSA analysis estimated that most people get less than that from food sources alone – but children at the highest exposure levels may exceed it. 

Synthetic sodium nitrite is not permitted in certified USDA Organic processed meat. Celery powder, naturally high in nitrate, is allowed as an additive in organic foods. It’s commonly used in processed meats labeled uncured or “nitrite and nitrate free.” 

During processing, bacterial cultures convert the nitrate in celery powder into nitrite, which serves the same curing function as directly added sodium nitrite. There is no evidence showing celery powder is safer than synthetic sodium nitrite.

Under California’s 2025 Real Food, Healthy Kids Act, sodium nitrite is among the synthetic additives that can qualify a food as ultra-processed.

What does the science say about sodium nitrite?

The primary cause for concern about sodium nitrite is its role in forming N-nitrosamines, compounds that can develop when nitrite reacts with other substances in meat during processing, cooking and digestion. Some N-nitrosamines are known carcinogens that can form in the stomach.

IARC classifies ingested nitrite as probably carcinogenic to humans (Group 2A) under conditions that lead to N-nitroso compound formation. Its classification is based on limited human evidence linking these exposures to stomach cancer. A 2026 prospective study of more than 105,000 people found that higher intake of sodium nitrite from food additives was associated with a 32% higher risk of prostate cancer. 

Several earlier studies have linked dietary nitrite – primarily from cured meats – to stomach cancer, especially among people with lower vitamin C intake. A 2023 assessment by the EFSA, the European safety agency, concluded dietary exposure to N-nitrosamines raises a health concern, with meat and meat products as the main source.

Nitrate-contaminated drinking water can pose a risk of methemoglobinemia, a condition in which red blood cells lose their ability to carry oxygen effectively. In severe cases, it can lead to tissue damage. This is most likely to affect infants when formula is prepared with water containing nitrate that is converted to nitrite in the body. Methemoglobinemia from typical consumption of commercially cured meats is unlikely in adults.

Some animal studies suggest sodium nitrite can cross the placenta and may affect offspring survival and growth, though long-term human data on these reproductive effects remain limited.

Find out more

Learn more about recommendations relating to sodium nitrite – and the full EWG Dirty Dozen™ list of food chemicals – on EWG’s research page.

EWG’s Food Scores provides ratings for more than 150,000 foods and drinks based on nutrition, ingredients and processing concerns, and flags unhealthy ultra-processed foods to help you identify alternatives.

EWG’s Skin Deep®  cosmetic database helps to identify harmful chemicals in personal care and beauty products. EWG Verified® products meet the strictest criteria for transparency and health.

And the Healthy Living™ app lets you take these tools with you on the go.

Areas of Focus Food & Water Food Toxic Chemicals Food Chemicals Authors Sarah Reinhardt, MPH, RDN November 16, 2026
Categories: G1. Progressive Green

EPA Awards $13.9M for Project to Simultaneously Save Flooding Freeway and Restore Critical Wetland in San Francisco Bay

Audubon Society - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 12:54
(Tiburon, CA) In partnership with Audubon California, local governments, transportation agencies, and restoration practitioners, the Association of Bay Area Governments has been awarded funding by...
Categories: G3. Big Green

November Newsletter: Stopping BAAJA, ending immunity, breaking climate silence.

Stop the Money Pipeline - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 12:49

Following last week’s election results a new era of political possibility is upon us. But with climate tipping points fast approaching, Big Tech’s hard lurch to the right ongoing, and MAGA already regrouping, what happens from here could not be more critical. 

As the newly-empowered Democrats prepare for power, here are 3 things Stop the Money Pipeline will be focused on in this new political era.

1. Stopping the Dirty Data Center Deal: Before the new Congress is even seated, we need to stop the energy permitting legislation, known as the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, that is being fast-tracked through this lame duck Congress.  The precise causes of the election results are still being debated, but one thing is clear: this election was an absolute repudiation of Big Tech’s dystopian vision for our future.. 

In Georgia, Ohio, Michigan, Texas (where Governor-elect Hinojosa appeared in a campaign ad shooting Flock cameras), and elsewhere opposition to data centers, AI, and Big Tech, helped propel Democrats to power. Out of 40 data center ballot initiatives across the country, opponents of data centers won 39. 

The Dirty Data Center Deal needs to be stopped not only because it would lock in more gas-powered data centers, but because it would just be a terrible political move.

After this week’s election, Democrats should be siding with the supermajority of people opposed to data centers, not voting for a bill championed by Big Tech that will superfire data center construction even more.

2. Ending Immunity: Perhaps my favorite video released on election night was one from the Democratic Oversight Committee, celebrating Ranking Member Representative Robert Garcia’s two-word warning to the Trump Administration: Lawyer Up.

From Elon Musk eviscerating government agencies charged with regulating his companies to the Trump family making billions through tungsten mines in Kazakhstan and shadowy crypto schemes, the scale of corruption over the last two years has been truly unprecedented.  

And now that they have the gavel, Democrats need to not only ensure accountability for such corruption, but use the power of Congress to educate the American public about how Trump and Musk enriched themselves to the tune of billions over the last two years, as everyday Americans struggled to pay for groceries and gas. 

 3. Making Climate a Top Priority Again: Over the last two years, as Trump has spent billions fighting clean energy, the media, the corporate world, and even deep blue states, such as California and New York, have also rolled back climate commitments. In this, they have been significantly aided by centrists who’ve championed deprioritizing climate as a political issue.

Yet in 2026 alone, climate-driven heatwaves killed at least 50,000 Europeans and a single climate disaster in Nepal probably killed more than 6,000. As we approach climate tipping points, we absolutely need to make the climate crisis a top-tier priority political issue once again.

This shouldn’t be hard. Global heating is making everything from groceries to owning a home more expensive, and nearly two-thirds of voters support a transition to 100% renewables by 2050.

And at a time when Americans are sick and tired of corporate influence over politicians, Big Oil just donated $182 million in the midterms to elect their favored politicians.

Our job as we head into this new political era is clear: we must build a movement powerful enough to end immunity for billionaires and win transformational climate policy that also makes life more affordable for everyday people. But first, we need to stop the Dirty Data Center Deal. 

For ways to get plugged in right away, check out the news and updates from across the Stop the Money Pipeline Network below. 

In Solidarity
– Alec Connon, Stop the Money Pipeline, coalition director

 

News & Updates from the Coalition

– Stopping the Dirty Data Center Deal

If you haven’t yet urged Members of Congress to oppose BAAJA, (aka: the Dirty Data Center Deal), join nearly 6,000 STMP supporters and email your Member of Congress.

And once you have sent your email, use this tool to call them, too. Calls are more impactful than emails and this tool makes it so it should take you less than five minutes. (You can also check out whether your Senator has taken a position on BAAJA here. If they haven’t, or voted yes to advance it in yesterday’s initial vote, it’s critical that they hear from you.)

– Stop the Money Pipeline 2.0

After finishing up a coalition recommitment process, we’re excited to announce that there are 108 organizations that are now formally a part of the Stop the Money Pipeline Network. Our partners range from frontline environmental justice groups to global NGOs, but we all have one thing in common: a commitment to end the fossil fuel industry and defeat far-right authoritarianism.

We’ll get our website updated in the coming weeks, but for now you can view the full list of our Stop the Money Pipeline Network Partners here. 

To get involved with one of our local partners, check out our STMP Local Partner Map.  

 – Investigate Musk, Investigate DOGE

This month, we had a huge breakthrough in the Investigate DOGE campaign – and not only because of the election results. 

On October 23rd, The Washington Post published a bombshell piece announcing that Senator Blumenthal, the Ranking Member on the Senate Subcommittee on Investigations, “intends to investigate Musk and DOGE.”

Not only that, but the Post credited our campaign with pushing the Democrats towards real accountability on Elon: “Activist group Investigate DOGE has channeled the spirit of the Tesla Takedown movement, which staged anti-Musk demonstrations outside Tesla showrooms, calling for Musk and DOGE alumni to face congressional scrutiny.”

Check out the piece here, and our video explainer here. 

 – Protecting our right to protest oil & gas pipelines

Sigh. In addition to BAAJA, there’s another piece of bad legislation in Congress that needs to be stopped: pipeline “safety” legislation currently being considered would expose people to 20 years in federal prison for participating in protests that slow down or temporarily halt the construction of an oil or gas pipeline.

The Water Protectors protecting their homelands at Standing Rock from the Dakota Access pipeline? If this bill passes, nonviolent activists engaging in these types of protests in the future would be subjected to serious felony charges.

Email Senator Cantwell―the Democrats lead negotiator on the final text of the bill―and urge her to protect our right to nonviolent protests. To learn more, check out our video explainer here. 

– Insurers are blowing the whistles

Last month, insurance insiders blew the whistle on how the insurance industry is responding to the climate crisis.

In a bombshell memo and a Guardian op-ed, senior leaders at major insurance companies revealed how the insurance industry is responding to the climate crisis: First, they’re raising prices, making insurance unaffordable for many, especially low-income and marginalized people. Second, they’re reducing what policies cover–we’ve already seen this in states like California, Louisiana, and Florida. And finally, they’re “simply withdrawing” from entire communities, leaving people without protection and forced to foot the entire bill after a disaster. 

Contact your State Insurance Commissioner to demand they regulate Big Insurance’s ability to pass the costs of the climate crisis onto the rest of us.

 – State-level solutions to the climate & insurance crisis

Last month, Big Oil tried to move its “legal immunity bill” through the House of Representatives. Thankfully, after thousands of you contacted your Members of Congress to demand they stop the bill, the legislation stalled before the House went out on recess.

But we need to be vigilant. We expect Big Oil’s puppets in Congress to try and move the legislation forward again in the lame duck session after the midterms. So if your Members of Congress haven’t heard from you on this yet, make sure they do. 

And on that note, it seems appropriate to close with the words of the United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres when he addressed world leaders in New York last month: polluters must pay.

The next learning session is on Monday, Sept 14th at 1PT/4ET. RSVP here.

 – State-level solutions to the climate & insurance crisis

Unlike other financial institutions, major insurance companies are regulated at the state level. That means, if we can pass legislation in key states we can 1) stop insurance companies from passing the costs of climate change onto the rest of us; and 2) end the insurance industry’s bankrolling of new fossil fuel projects.

In 2027, we’ll be focused on passing legislation in three states to achieve this.

In Connecticut, we’re supporting the Insuring Connecticut’s Future campaign, campaigning to pass legislation that would force major insurance companies and Big Oil to pay their fair share for the state’s climate resiliency. If you’re in Connecticut, join the campaign welcome call on Thursday, December 3rd. 

In Oregon, we’re doing the same thing. If you’re in Oregon, you can plug in by joining the Insuring Oregon’s Future Launch Call on December 3rd.  

In New York, we’ll be doing everything we can to pass the Insure our Communities Act, the strongest anti-oil and gas insurance bill in the country. If you’re in New York, complete our community survey – we’d love to talk.

 – Aligning your money with your values #1: Insurance

Our partners at Green America have launched an updated version of their Climate-Smart Insurance Directory 

State Farm, Liberty Mutual, Allstate, Travelers, Chubb, and Geico/Berkshire Hathaway: these companies are investing in and insuring new fossil fuel projects even as they pass the costs of the climate crisis onto the rest of us.

Fortunately, there are better options. Find one of 180 climate-friendly insure companies here. If you have questions or have already made the switch, you can contact Cathy Becker at Green American: cbecker@greenamerica.org 

  – Aligning your money with your values #2: Investments

Our partner Third Act is hosting a training series on how you can align your money with your values. In recent months, they’ve covered banking and insurance.

Next up, they are sharing how you can ensure that your investment is supporting, and not undermining, the climate transition. Join the session on December 14th at 1PT/4ET. 

And to close out our newsletter this month, here, again, is the new Democratic Oversight Committee’s two-word warning to Trump and his corrupt cronies like Elon Musk.

The post November Newsletter: Stopping BAAJA, ending immunity, breaking climate silence. appeared first on Stop the Money Pipeline.

Categories: G1. Progressive Green

How India’s Cockroach movement maintains nonviolent discipline

Waging Nonviolence - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 12:37

This article How India’s Cockroach movement maintains nonviolent discipline was originally published by Waging Nonviolence.

On Nov. 7, the eve of Diwali, the Hindu festival of lights, the leaders of the Cockroach Janta Party, or CJP, including founder Abhijeet Dipke, were not at home. They were marching in Kochi, a port city in the southern state of Kerala, nearly 1,300 miles from Delhi. 

The march echoed the two demands the movement had been shouting in Delhi’s streets since the first week of October: Scrap the nationwide recheck of voter rolls that began in June 2025, and sack the chief election commissioner, Gyanesh Kumar. 

The Cockroach movement came into being in May of this year and won its first victory in July, pushing India’s education minister out of office over a leaked national medical entrance exam. The open question then was whether a movement with no one leader and no office would still be around after winning its first fight. It is, and while it still has no office, it has picked a much bigger fight. Not an exam this time, but the vote itself.

The Election Commission, which runs India’s elections, is rechecking every one of India’s nearly one billion voters. In the name of clearing the rolls of the dead, the duplicated, people who have moved and what its June 2025 order called “foreign illegal immigrants,” it has purged more than 130 million voters. In Delhi alone, the cleanup has knocked 4.76 million people, nearly a third of the city’s electorate, off the voter list. 

#newsletter-block_d669adadd8d38d6e65c376094470b5a9 { background: #ECECEC; color: #000000; } #newsletter-block_d669adadd8d38d6e65c376094470b5a9 #mc_embed_signup_front input#mce-EMAIL { border-color:#000000 !important; color: #000000 !important; } Sign Up for our Newsletter

Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party, or BJP, strongly backs the recheck, saying that it’s necessary to strike undocumented migrants from neighboring Bangladesh, particularly Muslims, who have slipped onto the rolls. Amit Shah, Modi’s home minister and most powerful lieutenant, has defended the recheck as a way to “detect, delete, deport” what he calls infiltrators. But critics charge that the rolls are being manipulated to benefit the BJP. They say the recheck shifts the burden of proof onto voters, and that the people least likely to have the required documents are the ones being dropped. 

Human Rights Watch found that the purge has disproportionately affected women, the poor and Muslims; in one area of West Bengal that is nine percent Muslim, more than 92 percent of those deleted were Muslim. Opposition leaders have called the recheck a backdoor version of the National Register of Citizens, a citizenship list the BJP promised in 2019 to extend across India.

Presiding over it all is Kumar, whose commission both referees India’s elections and runs the recheck. He was handpicked by Modi in February 2025 under a new law giving Modi more power over the selection, in a decision announced late at night over the written dissent of opposition leader Rahul Gandhi.

In late September, the national daily The Indian Express reported that two of the election commission’s three members, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, had objected on record at least 14 times in 10 months to decisions and orders tied to the recheck that they say were issued in the commission’s name without their knowledge. (In an official statement, the commission maintained that all of its decisions on the recheck were unanimous.) 

Previous Coverage
  • What India’s Cockroach Party won — and what’s next
  • The Cockroach movement, which had been pressuring the government since July over broken promises, responded by calling Kumar the biggest threat to India’s democracy and giving him 48 hours to resign.

    When Kumar ignored the movement’s deadline, it took to the streets of Delhi and other cities on Oct. 2, the birthday of Mahatma Gandhi, who led India’s nonviolent struggle for independence.

    Unlike most Indian police forces, Delhi’s police do not answer to the city’s elected government but to the federal Home Ministry, run by Shah. It answered the protests the way it did in July, only harder. On Oct. 10 police detained more than 2,000 people in Delhi, opposition leaders and journalists among them, while about 600 were detained in Mumbai, India’s financial capital, and mobile internet went dark in the heart of Delhi.

    Two days later, Jantar Mantar — a square just a short walk from Parliament that has been Delhi’s main protest site for decades and was occupied by the movement for five weeks this summer — was struck off the list of places where protest is allowed. Two of the movement’s leaders, Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka, walked into Jantar Mantar with the national flag the next day and were arrested. They were jailed for a week for breaking a peace bond and still face criminal charges. 

    Through all of this, the protests have stayed nonviolent and they have spread well beyond Delhi. In Kochi, hundreds of people marched behind the actor and activist Prakash Raj under the banner “Jantar Mantar @ Kochi.”

    I spoke with Ratna Singh, who leads the CJP’s legal team, over a series of WhatsApp voice calls in early November, about how the movement holds its nonviolent line under this much pressure, and what comes next.

    Ratna Singh (left) and Saurav Das (right) exit court proceedings on Aug. 18, 2026 in Delhi. (Ishant Chauhan/Hindustan Times via Getty Images)

    This interview was conducted in Hindi and has been translated and edited for length and clarity.

    Your movement started over an exam. Now it’s about the vote. Who are you really fighting, the Election Commission or Modi?

    It’s the same fight. We can’t question how an election is run without questioning the government that runs it. Let’s stop pretending these are separate things.

    The BJP’s attitude is, “You voted, now shut up and obey.” That’s democratic tyranny. Citizens have every right to check the rolls, expose manipulation and ask for complete transparency.

    What really gets me is how state media treats the BJP as if it were the nation. The government cannot claim to speak for the entire country. Modi is the prime minister, but Indian democracy belongs to its citizens.

    People came out in October because they’d had enough of that arrogance. We’re not begging for crumbs. We want accountability, and we’ll take it.

    The crackdown came fast. How do you get people ready for that, and keep them nonviolent when the police move in?

    We brief everyone before every march: no panic, no retaliation. When police charge or bring out detention buses, our instruction is to sit down on the pavement immediately. Sitting down takes away their excuse to claim we were rushing them or inciting a riot.

    It forces the police to physically carry people away one by one, which slows them down and exposes their aggression on camera. Nonviolence here isn’t passive; it’s an active tactic to strip the state of its excuses.

    The state’s favorite trick is to change the story. People are out there over stolen elections, and suddenly the debate is about unlawful assembly and traffic permits. That’s deliberate. It keeps the government away from real scrutiny.

    I tell people to remain disciplined and understand their legal rights. That does not mean they should stop questioning the authorities. We can remain peaceful while continuing to challenge the government.

    There’s no single leader. So, who keeps the discipline?

    Indian politics is sick with hero worship, and the BJP is the worst case. Everything revolves around the cult of Modi: the propaganda, the policy, the state machinery. That’s not strength. That’s a single point of failure. We’re not going to build another political god. 

    A real movement runs on shared anger and a clear strategy, not on waiting for one boss to give orders. The movement depends on people understanding its objectives and taking responsibility for their actions. We don’t need one person making every decision.

    In large, leaderless crowds, how do you stop someone from throwing stones or provoking violence?

    The state’s oldest trick is sending in provocateurs to throw a stone, turn a march violent and justify a crackdown. We deploy trained marshals and experienced volunteers across the crowd. The moment someone starts acting aggressively or picks up a projectile, our volunteers immediately surround that person, isolate them and calm the crowd down. We make it clear: Anyone inciting violence is working for the regime, not the movement.

    Mobile internet was shut down in central Delhi during the protests. How do you coordinate when you’re offline?

    You can’t rely solely on WhatsApp or social media when you’re fighting a state that controls the kill switch. We operate on a decentralized structure. We use pre-agreed physical contact points, runner systems and offline mesh networks to pass instructions.

    Small local teams know their primary and secondary assembly spots in advance. If the internet goes dark, the plan doesn’t change. Everyone knows where to be and what their role is.

    Critics say you’re being provocative on purpose. Are you?

    Absolutely. That’s the whole point of resistance. If you’re not threatening the status quo, you’re just putting on a show for the regime.

    “Provocative” is what people in power call you when they’re losing their grip on citizens. They want polite dissent with no teeth, petitions they can drop straight in the bin.

    But there’s a huge line between physical violence and hard political confrontation. And the BJP built its empire on ruthless political violence. It has no right to lecture its victims about manners. If asking questions provokes them, it just shows how long they’ve been coddled.

    The government says the mass detentions were just routine law and order.

    That’s a pathetic, cowardly excuse. The minute the state’s legitimacy is questioned, it hides behind police batons and calls it public safety.

    Look at the double standard. The BJP can shut down whole cities for its own rallies, and that’s national pride. Ordinary citizens gather to question the government, and suddenly they’re a national security threat.

    If our accusations are false, why hide the data and the sources? If the system isn’t rigged, prove it. Sending in police boots to crush dissent isn’t governance. It’s state terror. And attacking Modi is a democratic duty, not treason.

    Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka spent a week in Tihar jail over a peace bond, and they’re still facing charges. What’s the point of all this legal pressure?

    It’s judicial harassment. The repeated summonses and legal cases put enormous pressure on activists and their families. Even when a protest is peaceful, people have to spend time and money dealing with these cases. We believe the legal process is being used to discourage people from continuing the movement.

    How does your legal team handle thousands of detentions in a single day?

    It’s a war of attrition. We have a network of volunteer lawyers stationed across different police stations and magistrate courts in the city. As soon as a detention bus leaves, our ground volunteers send the vehicle number and station location through our backup channels.

    Lawyers arrive before the buses to monitor treatment, track names and draft bail bonds on the spot. They want to wear us down with paperwork and legal costs, but our legal network works 24/7 to make sure no activist is left behind.

    Jantar Mantar is now closed to protest. What does that say about Modi’s government?

    This blows apart Modi’s whole international act. He travels the world selling India as the “Mother of Democracy,” and at home he runs a police state that chokes basic speech.

    Jantar Mantar was set aside for people to protest, not for parades the state approves of. When they use red tape to outlaw political opposition, that’s not regulation. That’s totalitarian control.

    If the state only allows protests that pose no risk to it, democracy is already dead. What’s left is a show.

    What has kept people coming back for four months, with all this pressure?

    The core crime hasn’t gone away.

    The BJP survives on short attention spans. Every 72 hours there’s a new crisis or another distraction pitting Hindus against Muslims to flood the news, and then they wait for people to forget.

    But electoral fraud and captured institutions don’t disappear just because the TV channels move on. 

    Women have been at the front of these protests. What does that change?

    It wrecks the BJP’s gender washing. They use women as props in their campaign ads. Real empowerment is women on the street standing up to state power.

    When a woman stands up and calls out Modi’s regime, that’s direct political action. You can’t praise women as obedient voters in your speeches and then send riot police after them the moment they turn against you.

    #support-block_51d1e4f21195506ee81eb84efa35627f { background: #000000; color: #ffffff; } Support Us

    Waging Nonviolence depends on reader support. Make a donation today!

    Donate

    What did the recent gathering in Kochi show you?

    It kills the regime’s line that this is a tantrum by Delhi elites.

    Electoral corruption is a national disease. The BJP badly wants every protest to look local, because a united, nationwide resistance threatens its grip on power.

    Kochi shows it’s crossing state lines. Modi’s government can’t contain this as a local disturbance anymore. The anger is spreading, and the state can’t arrest an entire country.

    People have until Nov. 25 to file objections and corrections to the recheck, and the final list comes out on Dec. 22. If millions are still missing, is that the end of it?

    Right now, it’s maximum pressure through Nov. 25 and Dec. 22. We won’t let the state use those dates as a blanket to smother the questions about the rolls.

    Will the CJP run for office in the 2027 state elections or the 2029 general election?

    It’s a real strategic option. But turning into just another party is a trap. If we end up copying the BJP’s centralization, its high handedness, its autocratic habits, then the whole struggle has failed.

    The Modi regime isn’t invincible. Its dominance is an illusion kept alive by fear. But empty slogans against Modi won’t do it. You need an aggressive alternative that takes apart the power structure.

    The people are sovereign, not Narendra Modi. The BJP has no divine right to rule. If we get on the ballot, it’ll be to smash this culture of unchecked power, not to swap one dictator for another. We’re not here to cause a temporary disturbance. We’re here to bring the political establishment to its knees.

    This article How India’s Cockroach movement maintains nonviolent discipline was originally published by Waging Nonviolence.

    Categories: B4. Radical Ecology

    THE SHELL LEAKS FILES — 16 NOVEMBER 2026

    Royal Dutch Shell Plc .com - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 12:08
    THE SHELL LEAKS FILES — 16 NOVEMBER 2026

    Archive reference: SLF-2007-120

    The Sakhalin Papers CX: The $100 Billion Projection — What Russia Was Promised in 2012 and What the Documentary Record Reveals

    In March 2012, Sakhalin Energy predicted that Russia would receive more than $100 billion over the lifetime of Sakhalin II. By the end of 2022, the operator was reporting cumulative receipts of approximately $40.2 billion, including more than $13 billion attributed to Sakhalin Oblast. But the ownership changes following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, a special government dividend arrangement and subsequent compensation payments have made the financial record increasingly complicated. An independent examination of original Shell-era sustainability reports, an authenticated Shell SEC filing, contemporaneous Russian reporting and a 2025 Accounts Chamber assessment reveals what the figures establish — and why the original $100 billion forecast cannot yet be given a definitive verdict.

    AN INDEPENDENT DOCUMENTARY INVESTIGATION

    By the Donovan–Shell Archive

    Researched and drafted with assistance from ChatGPT. Based on original Sakhalin Energy reports, authenticated Shell corporate filings, contemporary Russian and international reporting, and published Russian state-audit findings.

    Publication date: 16 November 2026

    Collection: The Sakhalin Papers — Shell, Gazprom and Russia

    Previous instalment: SLF-2007-119 — The Sakhalin Budget Test: How Shell’s $24.5 Billion Cost Recovery Led to a Regional Revenue Windfall

    INTRODUCTION: THE $100 BILLION QUESTION

    On 30 March 2012, Sakhalin Energy issued one of the most ambitious financial projections in the history of Sakhalin II.

    The company announced that it had recovered approximately $24.5 billion in project expenditure.

    Under the production-sharing arrangements, that milestone triggered a new stage in the distribution of profits from the offshore oil and gas development.

    Russia and Sakhalin Oblast would begin receiving their respective shares of profit production.

    The development was significant.

    Shell had originally controlled Sakhalin Energy.

    The project’s enormous construction costs had contributed to a confrontation with the Russian authorities.

    Gazprom had subsequently acquired majority control.

    But by March 2012, with Shell still a substantial minority shareholder, the operator was reporting that the project had reached its critical cost-recovery threshold.

    The announcement included an extraordinary prediction.

    Sakhalin Energy expected the Russian side to receive more than $100 billion over the project’s lifetime.

    That figure was not a payment already made.

    It was not a guaranteed sum.

    Nor was it a legally established minimum entitlement.

    It was a forward-looking corporate projection, published against the background of expectations concerning production, energy prices, operating expenditure and the contractual allocation of revenues.

    The distinction matters.

    Fourteen years have passed since that announcement.

    During that period, Sakhalin II has generated substantial public receipts.

    Original corporate reports show that Russia’s cumulative revenues from the project rose from approximately $3 billion at the end of 2011 to more than $20.8 billion by the end of 2016.

    By the end of 2019, the figure had reached approximately $28.5 billion.

    By the end of 2021, it was approximately $33.06 billion.

    And a report published in April 2023 placed cumulative Russian-side receipts at approximately $40.2 billion through the end of 2022.

    That represents a substantial financial contribution.

    But there is a complication.

    Shell lost significant influence over Sakhalin II in April 2022.

    Russia subsequently transferred the project’s operations to a replacement Russian company.

    And in 2025, the Russian Accounts Chamber disclosed information concerning a special compensation payment that included amounts connected with unpaid dividends on a government-held preference share.

    That development introduces an additional issue into the calculation of Russian state revenues.

    It also raises questions about how subsequent payments should be reconciled with the earlier financial record.

    The documentary task is therefore more demanding than comparing $40.2 billion with $100 billion.

    What did the original forecast include? How much has actually been received? Which payments belong to the same accounting categories? And can the public record establish whether the project remains on course to meet the original lifetime projection?

    The evidence provides substantial answers to the first three questions.

    The fourth remains unresolved.

    PART ONE: WHAT SAKHALIN ENERGY ACTUALLY SAID IN 2012 1. The original announcement

    The most important source is Sakhalin Energy’s announcement of 30 March 2012.

    Its contents were reproduced contemporaneously by Energyland and Offshore Energy.

    The company reported that profit-production sharing had begun.

    It explained that the relevant cost-recovery threshold had been reached after approximately $24.5 billion in capital and operating expenditure had been recovered.

    The amount included the project’s first and second development phases.

    Chief Executive Andrey Galaev welcomed the transition, attributing it to favourable market conditions and improvements in operational performance.

    The announcement also contained a forecast for 2012.

    Using an assumed oil price of $100 per barrel, Sakhalin Energy expected the Russian side to receive approximately $500 million in profit production during that year.

    Royalties and profits tax would be additional.

    This is an important distinction.

    The $500 million projection concerned a particular category of receipts during a particular year.

    The $100 billion projection concerned expected total Russian-side revenues over the project’s lifetime.

    They were different forecasts with different scopes.

    The announcement also stated that Russia had received approximately $3 billion from the project during the period from 1995 through 2011.

    That historical figure provides the starting point for assessing subsequent performance.

    But the announcement did not publish the detailed economic model underlying the $100 billion estimate.

    It did not provide a year-by-year schedule of expected receipts.

    It did not identify a definitive project-completion date for the forecast.

    And it did not disclose the complete assumptions concerning future oil and LNG prices, additional investment, operating costs or fiscal adjustments.

    Consequently, the forecast can be compared with subsequent reported receipts.

    It cannot be independently reconstructed in full from the original announcement.

    Contemporaneous sources: Energyland — Start of Production Sharing Under Sakhalin II, 30 March 2012 and Offshore Energy — Russia: Production Sharing Under Sakhalin-2 Project Starts, 30 March 2012.

    energyland.info+1

     

    2. A projection is not a contractual guarantee

    The distinction between a forecast and a guarantee should be established at the outset.

    The production-sharing agreement governed the parties’ economic entitlements.

    It provided a framework for recovering expenditure and distributing production.

    The operator’s $100 billion statement was a forecast concerning the revenues that might result from those arrangements.

    It was not itself an amendment to the agreement.

    Nor did its publication establish an independent legal obligation to deliver precisely that amount.

    The difference matters when considering whether the eventual outcome should be described as success or failure.

    If the project ultimately generates less than the original projection, that would not automatically establish a contractual breach.

    Similarly, a forecast might be exceeded without proving that every earlier commercial decision was sound.

    The relevant legal obligations and the accuracy of the original forecast are separate questions.

    The $100 billion figure is evidence of what Sakhalin Energy expected in March 2012. It is not proof of what the Russian state was guaranteed to receive.

    PART TWO: THE ORIGINAL SHELL-ERA FINANCIAL RECORD 3. By 2016, cumulative receipts exceeded $20.8 billion

    Sakhalin Energy’s Sustainable Development Report 2016 provides an important documentary checkpoint.

    The report was published while Shell remained a substantial shareholder.

    It stated that cumulative payments to the Russian side had exceeded $20.8 billion by the end of 2016.

    Approximately $8 billion was attributed to Sakhalin Oblast.

    These figures are particularly useful because they come from an original corporate publication.

    They were not reconstructed retrospectively by journalists.

    The report also distinguished between royalties, profit production, profits tax and other mandatory payments.

    This is essential to understanding the financial arrangement.

    A royalty could be paid in hydrocarbons.

    A profit-production entitlement represented another contractual form of revenue.

    Corporate profits tax was a separate obligation.

    And certain tax payments related to the financial performance of a preceding year.

    The operator therefore recorded multiple types of economic benefit.

    The $20.8 billion cumulative figure was not simply the Russian government’s share of company profits.

    It was a broader measure of payments and benefits reported by the operator.

    Nor should the approximately $8 billion attributed to Sakhalin Oblast be added to the $20.8 billion.

    The regional amount was included in the larger Russian-side total.

    The report establishes that substantial public revenues were being generated.

    It does not independently validate the assumptions behind the original $100 billion forecast.

    Primary corporate source: Sakhalin Energy — Sustainable Development Report 2016, pages 60–61 (PDF).

    sakhalinenergy.ru

     

    4. The 2019 report contains a more detailed financial trail

    An important additional source is Sakhalin Energy’s Sustainable Development Report 2019.

    This report was also published during Shell’s involvement.

    Its section on economic impact management provides detailed cumulative and annual figures.

    By the end of 2019, the company reported that the Russian side had received approximately $28.5 billion since the project’s beginning.

    Approximately $10.3 billion was attributed to Sakhalin Oblast.

    The report also identified approximately $3.3 billion allocated to the Russian side during 2019.

    That year’s figure included several distinct elements.

    Royalties were valued at approximately $384 million.

    The Russian side’s share of profit production amounted to approximately $512 million.

    The report also recorded profits-tax payments of approximately $1.7 billion relating to the 2018 fiscal year.

    And it identified another payment that deserves particular attention.

    Dividends associated with the special R-share amounted to approximately $707 million in 2019.

    This was a government-related preference-share arrangement.

    It was not the same as Shell’s ordinary shareholder dividend.

    Nor was it identical to profit-production sharing.

    That distinction becomes important when examining later changes to the project’s operating structure.

    The R-share would reappear in Russian state-audit findings concerning payments after Shell’s withdrawal.

    Primary corporate source: Sakhalin Energy — Sustainable Development Report 2019, pages 100–101 (PDF).

    sakhalinenergy.ru

     

    PART THREE: THE 2020 AND 2021 RECORD 5. The 2020 report records more than $30.9 billion

    Sakhalin Energy’s Sustainable Development Report 2020 provides another contemporaneous checkpoint.

    It stated that cumulative receipts by the Russian side had exceeded $30.9 billion.

    Approximately $10.8 billion was attributed to Sakhalin Oblast.

    The operator’s annual financial table recorded approximately $2.462 billion in payments to the Russian side during 2020.

    That was lower than the $3.328 billion recorded for 2019.

    The difference demonstrates that annual payments could vary substantially even while the project’s cumulative contribution continued to increase.

    The report also identified a profit-production payment of approximately $272 million during 2020.

    Dividends on the R-share were reported at approximately $339 million.

    The figures again establish that the Russian-side total consisted of several different financial categories.

    They also demonstrate why a single annual figure should not be confused with the amount received from profit production alone.

    Primary corporate source: Sakhalin Energy — Sustainable Development Report 2020, pages 130–131 (PDF).

    sakhalinenergy.ru

     

    6. The final complete reporting year before Shell’s withdrawal

    The Sustainable Development Report 2021 provides a particularly important historical reference.

    It was the final complete annual reporting period before Shell announced its withdrawal from Russia.

    The operator reported cumulative Russian-side receipts of $33.06 billion by the end of 2021.

    Approximately $11.34 billion was attributed to Sakhalin Oblast.

    The company’s annual payments to the Russian side during 2021 amounted to approximately $2.139 billion.

    The operator also reported approximately $489.3 million as the Russian side’s share of profit production.

    The report identified approximately $992 million in profits tax paid in respect of the 2020 financial year.

    These figures are important because they establish what the operator was reporting before the subsequent ownership and management changes.

    They also provide a useful baseline for separating Shell’s historical involvement from later developments.

    By the end of 2021, Sakhalin II had reportedly generated more than $33 billion in cumulative Russian-side receipts.

    That was approximately one-third of the amount forecast in 2012.

    But the project had not reached the end of its contractual life.

    The passage of time alone does not establish whether the lifetime projection was being achieved at the rate originally expected.

    Without the original forecast model, it is impossible to determine whether $33.06 billion by the end of 2021 was above or below the amount projected for that particular date.

    Primary corporate source: Sakhalin Energy — Sustainable Development Report 2021, Economic Impact Management, pages 136–137 (Russian-language PDF).

    sakhalinenergy.ru

     

    PART FOUR: THE $40.2 BILLION CHECKPOINT 7. April 2023: A remarkable new cumulative figure

    On 3 April 2023, Russian energy publication InfoTEK reported a further set of Sakhalin II financial results.

    The figures were attributed to the project’s operator.

    According to the report, cumulative payments to the Russian side had reached approximately $40.2 billion by the end of 2022.

    More than $13 billion was attributed to Sakhalin Oblast.

    The article also reported that the operator had transferred approximately $7.1 billion to the Russian side during 2022.

    That was described as a record annual amount.

    The figures are consistent with the separate reporting of the 2022 annual payments by Finmarket, which identified approximately $7.109 billion in cash and in-kind payments.

    The cumulative total is especially significant.

    It provides a further historical checkpoint against the $100 billion projection.

    By the end of 2022, the operator was reporting that cumulative Russian-side receipts had reached approximately 40% of the amount forecast for the project’s entire lifetime.

    But this comparison must not be misunderstood.

    It does not establish that the remaining 60% was overdue.

    Nor does it mean that the project had failed to meet 60% of its obligations.

    The original forecast concerned the entire remaining lifetime of the development.

    The publicly examined 2012 announcement did not provide an independently verifiable timetable for receiving each portion.

    The correct conclusion is narrower.

    By the end of 2022, approximately $40.2 billion in cumulative Russian-side receipts was being reported against an original lifetime forecast exceeding $100 billion. The available documents do not establish whether that represented the originally expected rate of progress.

    Contemporaneous sources: InfoTEK — Sakhalin II Generated Record Payments to Russia in 2022, 3 April 2023 and Finmarket — Russian Budget Receipts from Sakhalin II Rose 3.3 Times in 2022, 3 April 2023.

    Отраслевой портал ИнфоТЭК+1

     

    8. Why 2022 was exceptional

    The 2022 financial disclosures are particularly interesting.

    According to Finmarket, the operator reported approximately $7.109 billion in payments to the Russian side during 2022.

    That compared with approximately $2.139 billion during 2021.

    The 2022 figure included royalties valued at more than $1.3 billion.

    The Russian side’s share of profit production exceeded $1.1 billion.

    The report also described substantial profits-tax payments, including payments concerning the preceding financial year and advance payments relating to 2022.

    Sakhalin Oblast received approximately $1.677 billion.

    That compared with approximately $525 million in the preceding year.

    These figures show that 2022 was not merely another ordinary reporting period.

    Russian-side receipts increased substantially.

    The operator also benefited from exceptional LNG market conditions.

    Contemporaneous reporting of its financial results described revenue of approximately $9.608 billion and net income of approximately $4 billion for 2022.

    But the relationship between higher commercial revenues and specific government payments must not be oversimplified.

    The financial totals included different categories of receipts and tax-payment periods.

    Some payments were affected by income earned in earlier periods.

    The precise timing and classification of each payment therefore remain important.

    Contemporaneous sources: Finmarket — Sakhalin II’s 2022 Payments and Kommersant — Sakhalin II Operator’s 2022 Financial Results, 3 April 2023.

    ИА “Финмаркет”+1

     

    PART FIVE: THE SHELL WITHDRAWAL BOUNDARY 9. An authenticated Shell SEC filing changes the interpretation

    The financial record cannot be examined responsibly without accounting for Shell’s departure.

    On 28 February 2022, Shell announced its intention to withdraw from its Russian equity partnerships following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

    The subsequent changes are documented in Shell’s original filings with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission.

    An authenticated Shell plc interim financial report for the period ended 30 June 2022 provides precise details.

    Shell stated that its Sakhalin II investment had been accounted for as an associate through 31 March 2022.

    The company reported an impairment charge of approximately $1.614 billion relating to Sakhalin II.

    It also stated that it had lost significant influence over the investment from 1 April 2022.

    The loss of influence followed the resignation of Shell’s executive directors and the withdrawal of managerial and technical staff.

    Shell subsequently changed the accounting treatment of its investment.

    The report also addressed the Russian presidential decree of 30 June 2022 concerning the transfer of Sakhalin Energy’s assets and licences to a newly created Russian company.

    By 30 June 2022, Shell reported that the carrying value of its Sakhalin II investment was zero.

    These are authenticated corporate disclosures.

    They establish a critical chronological boundary.

    The 2022 annual Russian-side receipts cannot simply be attributed in their entirety to decisions made under Shell’s continuing management.

    The year included periods before and after Shell lost significant influence.

    The subsequent replacement of the operating company introduced further changes.

    The distinction is essential for a documentary archive examining Shell’s historical responsibility.

    Authenticated corporate source: Shell plc — SEC Filing, Interim Financial Report for the Six Months Ended 30 June 2022.

    SEC

     

    PART SIX: THE MORE RECENT FINANCIAL RECORD 10. The new operator continued generating substantial revenues

    The subsequent Russian operator continued the Sakhalin II development.

    Production and LNG exports remained substantial.

    Its 2024 non-financial report recorded revenue of approximately 637.3 billion roubles.

    That compared with approximately 585.3 billion roubles for 2023.

    The company’s 2024 LNG shipments totalled approximately 10.2 million tonnes.

    These figures demonstrate continuing commercial operations.

    But there is an important distinction.

    The operating company’s commercial revenue is not the same as the Russian state’s receipts under the production-sharing agreement.

    The 637.3 billion rouble figure concerns the operator’s reported revenue.

    It does not establish that the Russian government received that amount.

    Nor can it be added directly to the earlier cumulative Russian-side receipts.

    The latter included royalties, profit production, taxes and other defined payments.

    The accounting categories are different.

    Similarly, converting the operator’s 2024 revenue into US dollars would not produce a reliable update to the $100 billion forecast.

    It would merely convert a different financial measurement into the same currency.

    The original corporate disclosures must therefore remain the basis for any comparison.

    Primary source: Sakhalin Energy — Non-Financial ESG Report 2024 (PDF).

    sakhalinenergy.ru

     

    11. A significant development reported by Russia’s Accounts Chamber

    A more revealing development was reported on 8 August 2025.

    Interfax published findings attributed to Russia’s Accounts Chamber following its examination of federal budget implementation.

    The report concerned revenues administered by Russia’s Ministry of Energy during 2024.

    It stated that receipts from production-sharing arrangements had exceeded the amounts originally forecast.

    The examination covered three projects: Sakhalin I, Sakhalin II and the Kharyaga field.

    Consequently, the overall figures could not be attributed to Sakhalin II alone.

    But the Accounts Chamber’s explanation included an important finding specifically concerning Sakhalin Energy.

    It reported that revenue had declined compared with 2023 largely because of a reduction in a special compensation payment made by the replacement Sakhalin II operator.

    The compensation mechanism had been established under an agreement dated 24 March 2023.

    According to the Accounts Chamber’s reported findings, the payment included amounts associated with earlier unpaid dividends on the special R-share.

    This is a significant documentary development.

    It connects the later Russian fiscal arrangements with a category of payments specifically identified in Sakhalin Energy’s Shell-era reports.

    In 2019, the operator had reported approximately $707 million in R-share dividends.

    In 2020, it reported approximately $339 million.

    The later Accounts Chamber findings indicate that a compensation arrangement concerning the replacement operator included amounts related to unpaid historical R-share dividends.

    The detailed terms of the 2023 compensation agreement have not been independently authenticated for this instalment.

    Nevertheless, the official audit reporting provides evidence that the revenue mechanisms continued to evolve.

    And that matters directly to the $100 billion projection.

    A proper lifetime reconciliation must account for the treatment of special government-share dividends and subsequent compensation payments, not merely royalties and profits tax.

    Contemporaneous source: Interfax — Accounts Chamber Findings on Production-Sharing Revenues, 8 August 2025.

    Interfax.ru

     

    PART SEVEN: WHAT THE FIGURES ACTUALLY ESTABLISH 12. A chronological documentary comparison

    The original reports provide a useful sequence of cumulative figures.

    At the end of 2011, the operator reported that the Russian side had received approximately $3 billion since 1995. This figure appeared in the March 2012 announcement.

    At the end of 2016, cumulative Russian-side receipts exceeded $20.8 billion, including approximately $8 billion attributed to Sakhalin Oblast.

    At the end of 2019, the company reported approximately $28.5 billion in cumulative Russian-side receipts, including approximately $10.3 billion attributed to Sakhalin Oblast.

    At the end of 2020, the figure exceeded $30.9 billion, including approximately $10.8 billion for Sakhalin Oblast.

    At the end of 2021, the operator reported approximately $33.06 billion, including approximately $11.34 billion attributed to Sakhalin Oblast.

    At the end of 2022, contemporaneous reporting of the replacement operator’s disclosures placed cumulative Russian-side receipts at approximately $40.2 billion, with more than $13 billion attributed to Sakhalin Oblast.

    These figures demonstrate substantial growth in reported cumulative receipts.

    They also show that the final reporting checkpoint came after the changes in Shell’s involvement and the operating structure.

    The figures are therefore not a single uninterrupted series produced under identical corporate governance arrangements.

    The common historical thread is the continuing Sakhalin II project and its production-sharing framework.

    The available evidence is sufficient to establish the reported cumulative position through 2022.

    It is not sufficient to produce a fully independently reconciled cumulative figure through 2025.

    More recent corporate disclosures exist.

    But the records examined for this instalment do not provide a complete verified reconciliation of all subsequent Russian-side receipts using the same definitions.

    The 2025 Accounts Chamber reporting provides important evidence of continuing fiscal payments.

    It does not itself supply a complete replacement for the earlier lifetime cumulative series.

    It would therefore be inappropriate to invent an updated total by adding unlike financial categories or extrapolating from operating-company revenue.

    EDITORIAL ANALYSIS 13. Was the $100 billion forecast realistic?

    The documentary evidence does not permit a definitive answer.

    The original projection was made in March 2012.

    At that time, the operator expected substantial future revenues from oil and LNG production.

    Its announcement referred to favourable market conditions.

    It also used an oil-price assumption of $100 per barrel for the separate 2012 profit-production estimate.

    But the published announcement did not identify the full price assumptions underlying the lifetime forecast.

    The project subsequently experienced changing energy-market conditions.

    Oil and LNG prices fluctuated.

    The operating company made additional investments.

    The ownership structure changed.

    And Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022 created an entirely different political and commercial environment.

    A reliable assessment would need the original model and comparable actual receipts.

    Without that information, the original projection cannot simply be declared achieved, missed or invalid.

    The fact that cumulative receipts reached approximately $40.2 billion by the end of 2022 is important.

    But it does not establish whether the project was on schedule to generate $100 billion over its entire life.

    That would require knowing what the original model expected by the end of 2022.

    The correct historical finding is that the operator published an ambitious lifetime forecast, subsequent public receipts were substantial, and the available evidence does not permit a definitive assessment of the forecast’s ultimate accuracy.

    14. A fundamental distinction between the Russian state and Shell’s shareholders

    Another potential misunderstanding must be avoided.

    The Russian-side revenues reported by Sakhalin Energy were not Shell’s own revenues.

    They concerned payments and entitlements associated with the Russian party under the production-sharing arrangements.

    Shell held an equity interest in the operating company.

    That interest gave Shell rights and obligations as an investor.

    But the Russian state received royalties, profit production, taxes and other payments under distinct arrangements.

    Consequently, the $100 billion forecast should not be understood as a forecast of Shell’s profits.

    Nor should the company’s $1.614 billion impairment in 2022 be subtracted from the Russian state’s cumulative receipts.

    That impairment concerned Shell’s accounting for its investment.

    The two figures belong to different entities and financial categories.

    The same principle applies to Gazprom’s subsequent acquisition of the former Shell interest.

    The acquisition price and the project’s cumulative public payments are separate matters.

    Combining them would produce a misleading result.

    15. The R-share deserves closer investigation

    One of the most important findings from the present documentary review concerns the special R-share.

    The Shell-era reports describe dividends paid on that share.

    The later Accounts Chamber findings refer to a compensation mechanism incorporating unpaid R-share dividends from earlier periods.

    This creates a clear line of further investigation.

    It is necessary to establish who held the special share, what rights it conveyed, how the dividends were calculated and how the replacement operator’s compensation arrangements affected the Russian side’s receipts.

    The March 2023 compensation agreement is particularly relevant.

    The published Accounts Chamber findings indicate that payments made under that agreement affected subsequent federal revenues.

    But the available reporting does not establish every detail of the compensation calculation.

    Nor does it establish precisely how the replacement payments were classified in the same terms as the original corporate financial reports.

    Those questions should be resolved before attempting to extend the historical revenue series through later years.

    The issue is not merely a technical accounting distinction.

    It concerns how revenue entitlements established under the earlier operating arrangements were treated after the change in corporate structure.

    That is directly relevant to the integrity of the historical record.

    16. The importance of not confusing forecasts with audited outcomes

    The documentary evidence also illustrates a wider corporate-accountability issue.

    Major energy projects frequently generate impressive forecasts.

    Those forecasts may influence public perceptions, government expectations and shareholder assessments.

    They can become part of the justification for large capital investments and complex long-term agreements.

    But forecasts depend upon assumptions.

    Their credibility cannot be assessed solely by the size of the projected number.

    The relevant questions concern the underlying methodology.

    What commodity prices were assumed?

    What production volumes were expected?

    What additional capital expenditure was anticipated?

    What operating costs were projected?

    What fiscal entitlements were included?

    And what period did the forecast cover?

    For Sakhalin II, the original $100 billion projection was made after the project had reached a major financial milestone.

    The operator had substantial operating experience.

    It had established LNG exports.

    And the contractual arrangements were entering a new stage.

    Those circumstances gave the forecast commercial significance.

    But the publicly reproduced announcement does not supply the detailed model required to verify it independently.

    The absence of that model does not establish that it was unreasonable.

    It establishes the limit of public scrutiny.

    DOCUMENTARY FINDINGS

    The investigation establishes that Sakhalin Energy announced the beginning of profit-production sharing on 30 March 2012 after reporting the recovery of approximately $24.5 billion in project expenditure.

    The company stated that the Russian side had received approximately $3 billion during the period from 1995 through 2011.

    It also forecast lifetime Russian-side revenues exceeding $100 billion.

    The latter figure was a corporate projection, not a guaranteed contractual payment.

    Original Shell-era sustainability reports documented substantial increases in cumulative Russian-side receipts.

    Those reports recorded approximately $28.5 billion by the end of 2019, more than $30.9 billion by the end of 2020, and approximately $33.06 billion by the end of 2021.

    The 2019 and 2020 reports separately identified dividends associated with the special R-share.

    The 2021 report provided the final complete annual financial checkpoint before Shell’s announced withdrawal.

    An authenticated Shell SEC filing confirms that Shell lost significant influence over Sakhalin II from 1 April 2022.

    The filing also records an impairment charge of approximately $1.614 billion relating to Shell’s investment.

    Contemporaneous reporting published in April 2023 attributed cumulative Russian-side receipts of approximately $40.2 billion through the end of 2022 to the project operator.

    The operator also reported record annual payments of approximately $7.109 billion for 2022.

    Those annual payments covered a period involving substantial changes to the project’s ownership and operating arrangements.

    The 2024 replacement operator continued reporting significant commercial revenues and LNG production.

    But operating-company revenue is not identical to the Russian state’s receipts under the production-sharing agreement.

    In August 2025, Interfax reported findings attributed to Russia’s Accounts Chamber concerning federal revenues from production-sharing projects.

    The findings included a special compensation-payment arrangement associated with Sakhalin II and earlier unpaid R-share dividends.

    The detailed underlying 2023 compensation agreement has not been independently authenticated in full.

    The available records therefore establish a substantial history of Russian-side payments.

    They do not establish a complete independently reconciled lifetime total through 2025.

    Nor do they permit a definitive conclusion concerning the ultimate accuracy of the original $100 billion projection.

    No finding of deliberate financial misrepresentation, fraudulent forecasting or contractual breach is advanced.

    CONCLUSION: FORTY BILLION DOLLARS — AND AN UNANSWERED FORECAST

    Sakhalin II’s financial history provides an unusual opportunity to examine the relationship between corporate projections and subsequent results.

    In March 2012, the operator announced that the project had recovered approximately $24.5 billion in capital and operating expenditure.

    Profit-production sharing had begun.

    Russia and Sakhalin Oblast were expected to receive substantial additional economic benefits.

    And the company forecast that total Russian-side revenues would exceed $100 billion over the project’s lifetime.

    That forecast was remarkable in scale.

    The subsequent record demonstrates that significant payments followed.

    The operator’s original reports document cumulative receipts exceeding $20.8 billion by the end of 2016.

    The figure reached approximately $28.5 billion by the end of 2019.

    It exceeded $30.9 billion by the end of 2020.

    And it stood at approximately $33.06 billion by the end of 2021.

    The replacement operator’s disclosures subsequently placed the cumulative amount at approximately $40.2 billion through the end of 2022.

    Those figures cannot responsibly be dismissed.

    They establish that Sakhalin II generated substantial public revenues.

    The project also supplied natural gas to Russian consumers, supported domestic employment and generated extensive procurement activity.

    The financial benefits were significant.

    But the question raised by the original $100 billion forecast remains unresolved.

    The published 2012 announcement did not provide a sufficiently detailed model to establish the expected timing of each component of the projected receipts.

    Without that model, there is no reliable basis for declaring that the project was ahead of or behind its original lifetime forecast.

    The events of 2022 introduce additional complications.

    Shell lost significant influence.

    Russia established a replacement operator.

    And the subsequent financial arrangements included mechanisms that require careful reconciliation with the earlier reporting categories.

    The special R-share is particularly important.

    The Shell-era reports identify dividends paid on that share.

    The Russian Accounts Chamber’s later findings refer to a compensation arrangement concerning unpaid historical R-share dividends.

    That development indicates that the financial relationship between the project and the Russian side continued to evolve after Shell’s withdrawal.

    The documentary conclusion must therefore be precise.

    By the end of 2022, Sakhalin II was reporting cumulative Russian-side receipts of approximately $40.2 billion against a lifetime forecast exceeding $100 billion. The original prediction remains an important historical benchmark, but the available evidence does not establish whether it will ultimately be achieved.

    That is not an accusation against Shell.

    Nor is it an endorsement of the original projection.

    It is a distinction between documented results and expectations.

    The original reports show substantial revenues.

    The authenticated Shell filing establishes when Shell lost significant influence.

    The subsequent Russian reporting establishes further payments and changes in the relevant financial arrangements.

    What remains necessary is a consistent, independently reproducible reconciliation extending across the change in operators.

    Such a reconciliation would need to account for royalties, profit production, taxes, R-share dividends, compensation payments and other defined entitlements.

    It would also need to distinguish Russian federal receipts from the amounts allocated to Sakhalin Oblast.

    Until those matters are resolved, an updated lifetime total cannot responsibly be constructed merely by adding unrelated figures.

    For the Donovan–Shell Archive, the significance extends beyond the amount involved.

    A corporate forecast should remain identifiable as a forecast.

    A payment should be supported by evidence of the amount and the recipient.

    An audited result should be distinguished from a company-reported figure.

    And a later change in ownership should not obscure responsibility for earlier decisions.

    The $100 billion projection remains part of the historical record. The documented receipts are substantial. But the final accounting of that forecast has yet to be established from the evidence examined.

    The Sakhalin Papers continue.

    PRINCIPAL DOCUMENTARY SOURCES

    Sakhalin Energy — 30 March 2012. Original company announcement reproduced contemporaneously by Energyland, identifying the $24.5 billion cost-recovery milestone, the approximately $3 billion historical receipts and the lifetime forecast exceeding $100 billion. Read the contemporaneous announcement.

    Sakhalin Energy — Sustainable Development Report 2016. Original Shell-era corporate report, particularly pages 60–61, detailing cumulative receipts, regional allocations and the components of Russian-side revenues. Read the 2016 report (PDF).

    Sakhalin Energy — Sustainable Development Report 2019. Original report, pages 100–101, identifying cumulative payments, annual financial results and R-share dividends. Read the 2019 report (PDF).

    Sakhalin Energy — Sustainable Development Report 2020. Original company report, pages 130–131, documenting cumulative receipts exceeding $30.9 billion and the annual payments made in 2020. Read the 2020 report (PDF).

    Sakhalin Energy — Sustainable Development Report 2021. Original company report in Russian, pages 136–137, recording cumulative payments of approximately $33.06 billion and the financial position before Shell’s withdrawal. Read the 2021 report (PDF).

    Shell plc — SEC filing, July 2022. Authenticated interim financial report documenting Shell’s impairment of its Sakhalin II investment, loss of significant influence and the consequences of Russia’s changes to the operating arrangements. Read the original SEC filing.

    Finmarket — 3 April 2023. Contemporaneous reporting of Sakhalin Energy’s 2022 payments to the Russian side, including the breakdown of royalties, profit production and profits tax. Read the Finmarket report.

    InfoTEK — 3 April 2023. Contemporary reporting of the operator’s cumulative Russian-side receipts of approximately $40.2 billion through the end of 2022. Read the InfoTEK report.

    Sakhalin Energy — Non-Financial ESG Report 2024. Original report from the replacement operator, providing the later corporate and operational context. Read the 2024 report (PDF).

    Interfax — 8 August 2025. Reporting of Russian Accounts Chamber findings concerning production-sharing revenues and the Sakhalin II compensation-payment mechanism. Read the Accounts Chamber report coverage.

    Donovan–Shell Archive — 15 November 2026. The preceding instalment examining Sakhalin II’s cost recovery and the subsequent dependence of Sakhalin Oblast upon project revenues. Read SLF-2007-119.

    DOCUMENTARY DISCLAIMER

    This investigation examines the financial projections and subsequently reported Russian-side receipts associated with Sakhalin II.

    It relies upon original Sakhalin Energy corporate publications, authenticated Shell filings with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission, contemporaneous news reports and published findings attributed to Russia’s Accounts Chamber.

    The March 2012 lifetime revenue projection is attributed to Sakhalin Energy.

    It is identified as a forward-looking forecast rather than a guaranteed contractual entitlement.

    The underlying economic model has not been independently obtained.

    The cumulative financial figures published for 2016, 2019, 2020 and 2021 are attributed to the operator’s original corporate reports.

    They have not been independently reconciled against every underlying government receipt, contractual calculation or accounting record.

    The cumulative figure of approximately $40.2 billion through 2022 is attributed to contemporary reporting of the operator’s disclosures.

    The investigation distinguishes tax payments, royalties, profit-production entitlements, special-share dividends and compensation payments.

    It does not assume that every financial figure expressed in the same currency measures the same economic category.

    The 2022 annual total spans a period of major ownership and management changes.

    The investigation does not attribute every payment during that year to Shell’s continuing management.

    Shell’s loss of significant influence from 1 April 2022 is established from its original SEC filing.

    The impairment of Shell’s investment is treated separately from payments received by the Russian side.

    The subsequent revenues and operating results of the replacement Russian operator are not automatically attributed to Shell.

    The 2025 Russian Accounts Chamber findings are reported through Interfax.

    The full text of the March 2023 compensation agreement and its supporting payment calculations has not been independently authenticated.

    The Accounts Chamber’s reporting concerned multiple production-sharing projects.

    Its aggregate fiscal figures are not treated as amounts received solely from Sakhalin II.

    No relevant court judgment establishing deliberate financial misrepresentation or a breach of the specific obligations examined has been authenticated for this instalment.

    The absence of an independently verified lifetime reconciliation does not establish that the underlying records do not exist.

    The analysis does not allege that Shell falsified the 2012 forecast or that Sakhalin Energy deliberately misrepresented government receipts.

    Shell plc, former Sakhalin Energy executives, the current operator, Gazprom, Russian government authorities and other interested parties are invited to submit original documents, factual corrections and other relevant evidence for consideration and fair reporting.

    The website’s general disclaimer also applies.

    NEXT IN THE SHELL LEAKS FILES SLF-2007-121 — THE SAKHALIN PAPERS CXI The R-Share Dividend Trail — How a Special Government Share Became a New Russian Compensation Payment

    The Sakhalin Energy Sustainability Report for 2019 contains a financial disclosure that deserves closer examination.

    The operator reported dividends of approximately $707 million associated with the project’s special R-share.

    The following year, the amount was approximately $339 million.

    These payments were separate from ordinary shareholder distributions, royalties and profit production.

    They formed part of the financial benefits associated with the Russian side’s participation in Sakhalin II.

    But the project’s operating arrangements subsequently changed dramatically.

    Shell withdrew its management and technical personnel in 2022.

    Russia established a replacement operating company.

    And the old ownership structure was replaced.

    Then came a significant development.

    In August 2025, Interfax reported Russian Accounts Chamber findings describing a compensation-payment arrangement established in March 2023.

    According to the reported findings, the arrangement included amounts associated with earlier unpaid R-share dividends.

    The next investigation will examine the documentary history of that special share.

    It will trace the references contained in original Shell-era corporate reports and compare them with the Russian state’s subsequent compensation mechanism.

    It will distinguish ordinary shareholder dividends from the financial entitlements associated with the Russian side.

    And it will examine what the surviving records establish about the treatment of historical payment obligations following the creation of the replacement operator.

    No assumption will be made that unpaid amounts resulted from misconduct.

    Nor will a compensation arrangement be treated as evidence of fraud merely because it replaced or adjusted an earlier mechanism.

    The documentary objective will be to understand how the arrangements worked, how they changed and how the resulting payments were accounted for.

    The central question: when Russia replaced the original Sakhalin II operator, what happened to the government’s special R-share dividend rights — and how did those rights become part of a new compensation-payment system?

    The investigation will follow the original corporate disclosures and the subsequent Russian state-audit findings, identifying the evidence that is available and the documents still needed.

    The Sakhalin Papers continue.

    THE SHELL LEAKS FILES — 16 NOVEMBER 2026 was first posted on November 16, 2026 at 9:08 pm.
    ©2018 "Royal Dutch Shell Plc .com". Use of this feed is for personal non-commercial use only. If you are not reading this article in your feed reader, then the site is guilty of copyright infringement. Please contact me at john@shellnews.net

    CMMC nurses to hold community town hall meeting

    National Nurses United - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 11:00
    Nurses at Central Maine Medical Center (CMMC) will hold a town hall meeting on Tuesday evening, Nov. 17, in Lewiston, Maine, to update residents in the Lewiston-Auburn area on their fight to protect patients and save the hospital in the face of severe opposition from Prime Healthcare.
    Categories: C4. Radical Labor

    Legendary Skolt Sámi Teacher, Knowledge Holder Satu Moshnikoff Has Gone Home

    Snowchange Cooperative - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 10:57
    Satu in 2011

    Satu Moshnikoff, Snowchange affiliate and a person of knowledge from the Skolt Sámi community of Sevettijärvi, has passed on.

    Satu Moshnikoff (b. 1940) has passed on. Snowchange joins family and community in mourning. Counselor of Education, teacher, Elder, person of knowledge Satu was instrumental in the community life of Sevettijärvi from early on. Saturday worked from 1970s as teacher at the Sevetti school. Together with her husband, Elder Jouni Moshnikoff, they developed the Skolt Sámi linguistic basis of grammar, dictionaries, teaching materials and many other educational assets that led the Skolt Sámi language to be rescued and revitalized.

    Satu participated in the salmon fishing and reindeer herding life as a member of the community. The Moshnikoffs spent substantial amount of their summers at Njauddam river, significant Atlantic Salmon river in Finland. Between 2009 and 2013 Satu worked with us to co-develop the river collaborative management plan, ensuring the participation and view of women as knowledge holders.

    Snowchange and Satu as well as Jouni until his death in 2012 worked on an all-encompassing biocultural push for revitalization of Sámi ways of knowing, governance, nature protection, restoration and cultural re-awakenings. Monumental achievements of the past twenty years have included for example the Eastern Sámi Atlas, documentation of climate and extreme events in the community, salmon and other fish data, gendered ways of knowing, Skolt Sámi plant lore and use of traditional materials, sacred sites, food and reindeer culture and many other aspects of Skolt traditions.

    For these and many more efforts Satu took a lead on led to international and domestic recognitions. Satu was chosen Skolt Sámi of the Year, Counselor of Education and other awards and recognitions reflected the numerous books, educational materials, linguistic and grammatical works that Satu and her family produced over the years. Central to all of the work was a guiding principle – through hard work the language, culture and therefore unique and priceless Skolt Sámi way of life will come back and revitalize.

    We join in mourning and remember Satus and familys work and vision for decades to come.

    Categories: E1. Indigenous

    Arctic Refuge Oil Push Puts Polar Bears at Risk as Seismic Testing Advances

    Alaska Wilderness League - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 10:45

    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
    Date: November 16, 2026
    Contact: Anja Semanco | anja@alaskawild.org | 724-967-2777 

     

    Arctic Refuge Oil Push Puts Polar Bears at Risk as Seismic Testing Advances

    New federal proposal would allow harassment of polar bears during seismic exploration across the Refuge’s Coastal Plain despite repeated failures to attract major oil and gas investors 

    WASHINGTON, D.C. — The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service today published a proposal that would allow the Alaska Industrial Development and Export Authority (AIDEA) to conduct seismic exploration in the Coastal Plain of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, opening the door to another round of industrial activity in one of the most ecologically important landscapes on the planet. 

    The Incidental Harassment Authorization (IHA) would allow harmful impacts to polar bears to occur because of the proposed seismic activities during the winter of 2026-2027. Occurring on designated critical denning habitat for polar bears, the proposed activity would include aircraft flights, thumper trucks, support vehicles, and mobile camps for up to nearly 400 workers during critical denning season. 

    The proposal comes despite repeated evidence that commercial oil and gas companies have little appetite for development in the Arctic Refuge. The 2025 federal lease sale attracted zero bids. The most recent sale, in June 2026, generated just $3.7 million in winning bids across five of the 58 tracts offered, with no major oil companies participating. Instead, the only bidders were AIDEA, a state-backed development corporation, and a small Alaska-based company. 

    “The oil and gas industry has repeatedly looked at the Arctic Refuge and decided the financial risks aren’t worth it. Not even major oil companies want to drill here because they understand the extraordinary costs, risks, and uncertainty involved,” said Kristen Miller, executive director at Alaska Wilderness League. “Yet this administration is determined to sacrifice one of the most important wildlife habitats on the planet to keep an oil development obsession alive. The Arctic Refuge is essential habitat for polar bears and other iconic Arctic wildlife, and no amount of political pressure or taxpayer money spent will make drilling here worth the cost. Polar bears and this extraordinary place they call home should not have to pay the price for the myth of profits.” 

    The Fish and Wildlife Service’s proposed authorization acknowledges the potential for significant disturbance to polar bears from seismic operations, aircraft overflights, and industrial activity near maternal dens. The agency’s analysis estimates that the proposed activities could result in 10 instances of Level B harassment and two instances of Level A harassment. Its modeling also identifies the possibility of lethal impacts to cubs if disturbance causes a mother to abandon her den. 

    Polar bears are already confronting the consequences of a rapidly warming Arctic and shrinking sea ice. Industrial activity in their critical habitat adds unnecessary pressure to a species whose survival is increasingly impacted by climate change, and are listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act. 

    The proposal is another step toward industrializing the Arctic Refuge’s Coastal Plain, a globally significant landscape that supports polar bears, the Porcupine Caribou herd, migratory birds, and the subsistence traditions and ways of life of Indigenous communities. 

    ### 

     

    Categories: G2. Local Greens

    Santa Paula Hospital and Ventura County Medical Center Nurses and Healthcare Professionals to Hold Save Santa Paula Hospital Town Hall

    National Nurses United - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 10:00
    Nurses and health care professionals at Santa Paula Hospital (SPH) and Ventura County Medical Center in the county of Ventura, California will hold a town hall on Thursday, Nov. 19 for community members, fellow union siblings, and patients to demand the Ventura County Board of Supervisors reverse its decision to eliminate emergency and acute-care services at Santa Paula Hospital.
    Categories: C4. Radical Labor

    The American Polycrisis and the Emergency Green New Deal

    Labor Network for Sustainability - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 08:43

    By Jeremy Brecher,
    Senior Strategic Advisor, LNS Co-Founder

    Listen to the audio version >>

    The 2026 midterm elections represented a resounding repudiation of Donald Trump. But they also reflected something even more momentous: the American Polycrisis. The American Polycrisis helps explain the unprecedented rejection of the status quo by the midterm electorate. It also presents a sobering panorama of what a Green New Deal 2.0 will need to overcome.

    No Kings Protest down Main Street in downtown Brattleboro, Vermont. Photo credit: Artaxerxes, Wikipedia Commons, CC BY 4.0.

    Polycrisis is a term that has primarily been applied to the world order. But the U.S. is in an American Polycrisis as well. The elements of each interact, and a Green New Deal 2.0 will have to take account of both.

    We face the derangement, indeed the deliberate dismemberment, of the sinews of society which we depend on for our daily life and wellbeing — like food, shelter, healthcare, security, a safe and healthy environment, and other essentials. We face something like the post-Soviet era in Russia, often referred to as the “Yeltsin era,” where government let the necessities of life deteriorate while its oligarchs scrambled for wealth and power. The results included hyperinflation and severe economic hardship; constitutional crisis and struggles between the president and parliament; a surge in organized crime and corruption; and an unprecedented decline in life expectancy. These resulted from an on-going degeneration of Russian society that nobody intended; the deliberate “shock therapy” imposed by Western powers; and the effort of Yeltsin’s government to sabotage, dismember, and loot the social body.

    As so often with crises of a part or subsystem within a higher-level whole, the American Polycrisis is not just a reflection of the global Polycrisis; it has its own characteristics and dynamics. It interacts with the global Polycrisis, but it can’t be understood as simply one aspect or subset of it.

    Why analyze the American Polycrisis? We need to understand the actual situation we are in today. We need to understand the dire conditions we will be facing even after the Trump administration has been disempowered. And we need to see what the Emergency Green New Deal and the Green New Deal 2.0 will have to rectify.

    The first in this new series of commentaries on the Green New Deal 2.0 laid out the dynamics of the global Polycrisis that a Green New Deal 2.0 will need to survive and quell. The second lays out the broad transformations needed to adapt a future Green New Deal to a changed world order. But right now we face the American Polycrisis – and that requires an Emergency Green New Deal.

    The Lived American Polycrisis

    Vibrant Sunset Over a Silhouette of Buildings. Photo credit by Chayanitc, Envato.

    Here are some elements of the American Polycrisis that directly impact the everyday lives of everyday people:

    • Climate:
      Global warming is causing extreme heat, rising sea levels, severe droughts, and intensified storms. 2026 was the hottest summer ever recorded in the U.S. AnAP/NORDC poll found that 90% of Americans said extreme heat has impacted their lives.
    • Energy:
      81 percent of Americans in anAP/NORDC poll said extreme heat over the past year has affected their electricity bills.  Residential energy rates jumped 3 percent between April 2025 and April 2026.
    • Food:
      48 million people experience food insecurity in the U.S. More than 50 million turned to food banks and pantries for help. According to the Department of Agriculture, five years ago the average cost of groceriesfor a family of two working adults and two children ranged between $613 and $1,500 per month. By 2025, such a family was spending between $1,000 and $1,600 per month at the grocery store. Five million people have lost SNAP food assistance in the past year.
    • Housing:
      According to Harvard’s “State of the Nation’s Housing” report, since 2020, home prices have increased by 54%. 24% of homeowners are “cost-burdened,” spending more than 30% of income on housing. 49% of renters are cost-burdened.
    • Healthcare:
      S. life expectancy is ranked 55th in the world, behind Panama and just ahead of Cuba, four years lower than the average of comparable wealthy nations. A quarter of Americans say they are “very” worried about affording health care costs for themselves and their families. Nearly half of adults in the U.S. say it is difficult to afford health care costs. Five million people lost health insurance in the first six months of 2026 and 15 million more people are at risk of losing Medicaid coverage in 2027. Cuts in government health programs and the scientifically illiterate views of government health officials are leading to epidemics of preventable diseases like measles.
    • Education:
      According to a 2025 report, “The public education system in the United States is on the verge of systemic collapse” with “catastrophic consequences for future generations and the stability of American society.” There are more than four hundred thousand teacher vacancies reported nationwide; that number is expected to double within the next five years. Twelfth-grade U.S. reading scores have droppedto the lowest level since 2005. The Trump administration has conducted a sustained attack on American colleges and universities.
    • Transportation:
      Transit agencies face massive deficits, forcing severe route cuts, reduced frequency, or complete shutdowns. Surging diesel costs have forced multiple trucking and logistics carriers into bankruptcy protection. Since the start of the Iran war, the cost to drive 100 miles in a gas car rose from $11.23 to $16.69 – three times as much as an electric vehicle.
    • Economic Insecurity:
      Contingent workers, including temporary staff, contractors, and project-based consultants, comprise nearly 40% of the U.S. workforce. Nearly 43%of U.S. college graduates aged 22 to 27 are underemployed, defined as working jobs that do not require the degree they earned. The Boston Consulting Group estimates that more than half of the jobs in the United States will be “reshaped” by artificial intelligence over the next two to three years, though far fewer will be replaced entirely.
    • Affordability:
      A 2026 Harris Poll found that 95% of Americans believe we are in an affordability crisis. 50% struggle to afford necessities like gas and groceries. In a 2025 poll by the American Family Survey, seven in 10 Americans said raising children is unaffordable.
    • Work Degradation:
      Ninety percent of American workers are not represented by unions – it’s 94% in the private sector. The introduction of AI threatens both the number of jobs and their quality. As one Amazon worker wrote:

    “When I’m in the Amazon truck, every movement I make is tracked with technology and evaluated by an AI program. Readouts at the end of every shift show how each of my deliveries compared to the timing prescribed by Amazon’s algorithmic standard. Employers everywhere are seeking to imitate the behemoth’s labor model of exploitation, job instability, and — terrifyingly — the deployment of AI technologies to discipline and disempower workers. This workplace dystopia is being perfected at Amazon, then exported to other employers — in factories, grocery stores, hospitals, restaurants, hotels, construction sites, laboratories, and offices.”

    • Environmental Degradation:
      In addition to climate change, the debasement of American land, air, and water is taking a myriad of forms, including biodiversity loss, plastic pollution, deforestation, air pollution, overfishing, and many others. Environmental catastrophes are being aggravated by the deliberate policies of the Trump administration.
    • Public Safety:
      Agencies like FEMA and NOAA designed to help communities stricken by wildfires, floods, and other disasters are being dismantled. Ordinary people are not safe on the street or even in their homes, schools, and workplaces in the face of attacks by ICE and other agencies of governmental repression.
    The Structural American Polycrisis

    Oil Pump and Wind Turbines at Sunset. Photo credit: perutskyy, Envato.

    There are deeper structural aspects of the American Polycrisis that lie behind what is experienced in everyday life:

    • Uncontrolled Climate Destruction:
      Trump and his administration deny the reality of climate change. They are actively promoting the fossil fuel extraction and burning that accelerate climate change. In 2025, US greenhouse gas emissions increased by 2.4%, reversing the decreases of the prior two years.
    • Fossil Fuel Island:
      Donald Trump and the US government are doing everything possible to shut down fossil free energy and to expand U.S. dependence on fossil fuels. As a result, Americans are being marooned on what two energy experts call a fossil fuel “energy island” as the rest of the world turns to an “electric world order.”
    • Governance:
      The U.S. faces autocracy, kleptocracy, corruption of elections, and degradation of the rule of law. According to the International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance (International Idea), key indicators of democracy in the U.S. have fallen to their lowest levels in 50 years. In 2025, “the global challenges to democracy and the difficulty in stemming its erosion were both exemplified and compounded by political developments in the United States.” President Donald Trump “quickly amassed power in the executive branch and wielded it to further a narrow set of personal goals and pursue retaliation against perceived enemies.” The results have been “far-reaching, undermining the rule of law.”
    • Inequality:
      The wealth of the top 12 US billionaires quadrupled between 2020 and 2026. The share of the nation’s economic output going to wages and benefits is now the lowest since the Bureau of Labor Statistics began measuring it in 1947; the share of profits in the nation’s income is the highest since 1950. In 2024 the income share of the richest 1% of households reached 20%, more than double their mid-70s share. In 1989 the share of wealth of the top 0.1% of households was an already extreme 7%; by 2026 it nearly doubled to 13%. Meanwhile, the wealth share of the bottom 90% shrank from 55% in 1989 to 36% in 2026.
    • Unregulated Finance:
      From 1946 to 1959 the financial sector received thirty cents for every dollar of savings it transferred to finance economic activity in the real (nonfinancial) sector. In the 2000s, it received $1.74 –nearly six times as much.
    • Debt:
      In July 2026, the S. national debt reached$39.7 trillion, putting the debt over 100 percent of gross domestic product for the first time since World War II. It is running a $2 trillion annual deficit. This October interest rates on U.S. government bonds reached the highest level since 2002.
    • Unlimited Destructive Power of Elites:
      The rise of hyperscale data centers has dramatized the extent to which uncontrolled billionaires are able to reshape American life and American communities at will, regardless of the wishes of residents.
    • Hyper-Militarism and Hyper-Imperialism:
      The U.S continues to produce soaring military budgets and illegal wars of aggression around the world. These aggravate many other aspects of the American Polycrisis, ranging from affordability to economic instability. They are also unsustainable failures. The huge U.S. military deployment in the Middle East has been unable to defeat Iran or even the Houthi; the U.S. has been unable to defend many of its bases in the Middle East and has been forced to evacuate them. Meanwhile, the U.S. has depleted its stockpiles of many kinds of weapons.
    • Gutting of Science
      The Trump administration has been conducting a “war on science.” The result was described by Stephen Cohen of Columbia University: “The scientific illiterates in the Executive Branch of the American government continue to dismantle our scientific enterprise. They have orchestrated a series of attacks on scientists and their laboratories, implemented through funding cuts, grant interruptions, and immigration restrictions. Scientists are gravitating to Canada, Europe, and China, and we are rapidly losing the depth of our innovative and essential scientific community.”

    These lived and structural aspects of the American Polycrisis interact with widely observed trends in values and norms that make them harder to solve. Unleashed social divisiveness, such as racism, sexism, homophobia, and xenophobia, contribute to marginalization and a loss of social solidarity. A “might makes right” ethic undermines social responsibility and legitimates the glorification of cruelty. Lack of accountability to the people erodes the belief in the legitimacy of government and other institutions.

    The elements of the American Polycrisis interact with and aggravate each other. For example, concentration of wealth gives the wealthy more opportunity to skew politics toward their interests via tax, regulation, and other policies, which in turn aggravates inequality and the loss of institutional legitimacy. Unregulated finance aggravates the unsupportable cost of housing.   Unrestrained militarism and imperialism and the resulting wars lead to energy and financial crises.

    The American Polycrisis also interacts with the global Polycrisis. U.S carbon emissions aggravate global warming; conversely, the rise in global temperatures causes floods, droughts, forest fires, heatwaves, and other effects in the U.S., which also harm health and erode public budgets. The soaring U.S. national debt puts the global economy at risk, while the chaotic interactions of the global economy threaten the economic stability of the U.S.

    There is a great deal we don’t know about what the world will look like after the extrusion of Trump from power. We can’t assume a post-Trump era will be one in which a progressive coalition can impose its plans via government, or even that status quo “normalcy” can be restored. Long-lasting retrogression is possible: The fall of Rome was followed by the Dark Ages; Yeltsin was followed, not by democratization, but by Putin.

    Although the American Polycrisis presents a long-term challenge that the Green New Deal 2.0 aims to answer, as a matter of survival it must be addressed on a “first aid” basis by an Emergency Green New Deal.

    The next commentaries in this series will explore the Emergency Green New Deal.

    Get “Strike!” via EmailGet “Strike!” via Substack DONATE ONLINE

    The post The American Polycrisis and the Emergency Green New Deal first appeared on Labor Network for Sustainability.

    Pilots and Pivots: How to Serve While Prioritizing Your Community 

    RAFI-USA - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 08:30

    “All we do is pivot,” said Clara Coffey, Executive Director of Casting Bread Free Market and Cafe. She stands at the front of FaithBridge UMC, in front of over 20 people who work locally in food security. In the wake of the damage Hurricane Helene brought to Blowing Rock, NC, she shares the many challenges Casting Bread faced, and how piloting new ideas and pivoting from “the way we’ve always done it” was crucial to keeping their pantry running and their community fed.

    The post Pilots and Pivots: How to Serve While Prioritizing Your Community  appeared first on RAFI.

    Categories: A3. Agroecology

    NRG to sell 4.9 GW of gas plants to LS Power for $4B

    Utility Dive - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 08:21

    NRG Energy CEO Robert Gaudette said the sale values one 1.2-GW Texas gas plant at $1,400/kW, while NRG is “developing 1.5 GW of new natural gas generation in Texas” for just above $1,000/kW.

    Countries take up industry push to loosen UN carbon market rules at COP31

    Climate Change News - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 08:16

    Dozens of countries – from big emerging economies to the world’s poorest nations – are calling for the UN’s new carbon market to reassess climate integrity rules, in a push that campaigners and researchers have blamed on industry lobbying. 

    At COP31 talks on the Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism (PACM) this weekend, the Like-Minded Developing Countries – a group that includes Saudi Arabia, India and China – the Least Developed Countries (LDCs) and landlocked developing countries raised concerns about the requirements project developers must meet, according to sources familiar with the closed-door discussions.

    They warned about the cumulative weight of those requirements developed under Article 6 of the Paris Agreement as barriers to implementation. Several countries, including Singapore and some Latin American states, said rules must keep projects financially viable, while South Korea asked for proportionate requirements, the sources said.

    Their demands closely track arguments from carbon market industry groups, which claim PACM’s conservative approach to counting emission reductions is so strict that few projects will ever come to fruition.

    Industry and NGOs lobby to weaken UN carbon credit rules in “coordinated” push

    In a letter published ahead of COP31, the lobby groups asked governments to “raise implementation concerns” and to request that the Supervisory Body – the UN body that oversees the market – assess the “combined impact” of its rules on the feasibility of projects.

    The letter was signed by the International Emissions Trading Association (IETA), a business group whose members include fossil fuel giants Shell, BP, Saudi Aramco and Chevron, along with the Project Developer Forum and the Wildlife Conservation Society, which develops forest conservation programmes.

    Draft text reflects industry demands

    Those demands are reflected in the first draft of the COP31 decision on the mechanism, published late on Saturday. To guard against over-crediting, PACM’s rules deliberately err on the side of issuing fewer credits when emissions cuts from projects are uncertain.

    The document asks the Supervisory Body to look at how these cautious assumptions add up across its rules and what that means for the number of credits, project costs and prices. The aim, it says, is to avoid “excessive compounding of conservative adjustments”. 

    Other parts of the draft tell the body not to make its rules too cautious or too rigid. That includes efforts to guard against the risk that carbon captured by a project is later released. Most of these passages add that environmental integrity must be maintained.

    Risk of another ‘failure’

    “Weakening the rules is not climate ambition – it is a license to pollute,” said Erika Lennon, a senior attorney at the Center for International Environmental Law (CIEL). “As we are on the brink of permanently breaching 1.5C, we cannot afford to turn the carbon market into another loophole for polluters,” she added. 

    Axel Michaelowa, research director at Perspectives Climate Research, said that if attempts to weaken the rules succeed, it could lead to another failure of an international carbon market. Demand for credits rests on trust, he said, and the slightest doubt over integrity erodes buyers’ willingness to pay.

    Calls to revise requirements “must be supported by scientific evidence, not unsupported claims of under-crediting – especially when these assumptions come from private actors whose revenues depend on the volume of transacted credits rather than real mitigation outcomes,” Michaelowa said.

    The EU, Switzerland and Senegal are among a handful of countries pushing back against demands to re-assess the market rules, according to the sources, and are opposing requests to weigh up the profitability of projects or to lower standards.

    Burn company enumerator Teresia Wanjiru checks moisture on firewood at a client’s house using clean cookstoves in Kachoroba village of Kiambu county, Kenya, August 16, 2023. REUTERS/Monicah Mwangi Burn company enumerator Teresia Wanjiru checks moisture on firewood at a client’s house using clean cookstoves in Kachoroba village of Kiambu county, Kenya, August 16, 2023. REUTERS/Monicah Mwangi Cookstove credits in focus

    At the centre of the fight are new methodologies for projects that aim to cut emissions by distributing cleaner cookstoves – one of the carbon market’s most popular credit types and also one of its most criticised for overstating climate benefits. A 2024 study in Nature Sustainability found cookstove projects had been over-credited roughly tenfold.

    Under the rules adopted by the Supervisory Body in October, cookstove project developers are required to set aside part of their credits in a buffer pool, in case the forests they claim to save later burn or are cleared.

    The body rejected an exemption from this requirement sought by developers, corporate buyers, some conservation groups and the UN Environment Programme, in what critics called a coordinated lobbying campaign, as reported by Climate Home News.

    Industry groups and some countries have seized on the cookstove methodologies to warn against excessively stringent requirements, which they say undercount emission reductions and deter developers. The LDCs told negotiators that developers had found some approved methodologies, including on clean cooking, difficult to apply.

    Industry group calls for revisions

    Industry representatives attacked the Supervisory Body’s approach in interventions that sources in the room described as very aggressive.

    In a subsequent Linkedin post, IETA’s Andrea Bonzanni accused the regulator of following an unscientific approach that would deliver systematic under-crediting. He called on environmental integrity standards to be amended and rulebooks to be revised. 

    The mechanism “has had a false start”, he said, but countries in Antalya have a chance to agree on clear guidance that puts it back on track. “Unless the mechanism becomes workable across countries and activity types, its impact on the atmosphere risks remaining marginal,” he added. 

    IETA did not respond to a request for comment.

      Campaigners and researchers have pushed back on the claims. Arguing there is currently no evidence of under-crediting in the UN market, they stressed that more credits do not necessarily mean more emissions reductions if the rules underpinning them are not grounded on science. 

      “Having a Paris Agreement carbon crediting mechanism that cheats the atmosphere completely misses the point,” said Isa Mulder, a policy expert at Carbon Market Watch. “Countries should not allow Article 6 to become just another dangerous distraction from real, urgent climate action.”

      The draft of the rules is an early version and will be negotiated during the COP31 summit’s final days. Under the Paris Agreement rules, the Supervisory Body must follow guidance that governments give through COP decisions. 

      The post Countries take up industry push to loosen UN carbon market rules at COP31 appeared first on Climate Home News.

      Categories: H. Green News

      Groups petition EPA to lower drinking water limit For carcinogenic nitrates

      Environmental Working Group - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 08:14
      Groups petition EPA to lower drinking water limit For carcinogenic nitrates Anthony Lacey November 16, 2026

      WASHINGTON – Today, a coalition of public health and environmental organizations filed a petition calling on the Environmental Protection Agency to lower the federal safety threshold for nitrates in drinking water to 1 milligram per liter.

      The current threshold of 10 mg/L was first adopted in 1975 and the EPA has never updated it since. Public health research in the intervening 51 years clearly shows that nitrate-contaminated drinking water at levels far below the current standard is associated with increased risk of cancer, birth defects, and more.

      The coalition that filed the petition includes the Environmental Working Group, Alliance for the Great Lakes and Prairie Rivers Network, Environmental Law & Policy Center, Food & Water Watch, the Natural Resources Defense Council and the Union of Concerned Scientists.

      Unchecked factory farming and chemical fertilizer pollution are the nation’s primary sources of waterway nitrate contamination. Today roughly 1 in 3 Americans — nearly 120 million people — are exposed to dangerous nitrate levels in their tap water. 

      The petition filing comes as the Trump EPA has apparently abandoned a re-assessment of nitrate’s toxicity and eliminated the offices responsible for conducting such assessments, scuttling years of work done under prior administrations.

      The following are statements from representatives of coalition members:

      Anne Schechinger, senior director, agriculture and climate research at EWG

      “The science on the threats of nitrate exposure has advanced, but our public health protective standards have not. We now know that even low-level exposure can have serious health consequences, yet federal policy continues to rely on an outdated threshold that fails to protect millions of people. The EPA must urgently update the drinking water standard for nitrate.”

      Tarah Heinzen, legal director at Food & Water Watch

      “Nitrates are poisoning America and Trump’s EPA is asleep at the wheel. Unfettered industrial agriculture pollution is pumping these toxic chemicals into the water we drink, and hardly anything is being done about it. The science is clear: Current regulations are not protecting our health. EPA must lower the safe drinking water limit for nitrates and start holding the polluters responsible accountable.

      “Under the Safe Drinking Water Act, EPA has a responsibility to update safety thresholds as public health research evolves. Today’s petition outlines the research establishing nitrate health risks, presents a comprehensive cost-benefit analysis, and provides a roadmap for EPA to address this problem at the source and at the tap.

      “Tens of millions of people from California to Delaware are exposed to particularly high nitrate levels because of pollution from industrial agriculture. For example, 46% of Iowans are exposed to nitrate levels over 1mg/L. With more factory farms and chemical fertilizer use than any other state, Iowa has the nation’s highest surface water nitrate contamination and fastest rising cancer rates. This summer, more than 600,000 Des Moines area residents faced a second consecutive year of water restrictions, while nitrate removal systems ran a record 193 days.”

      Dr. Stacy Woods, research director at Union of Concerned Scientists

      “The U.S. is facing a quiet public health crisis. Since EPA set the nitrate drinking water standard decades ago, scientific research has revealed links between lower levels of nitrate and cancer, adverse birth outcomes, and other serious health effects. The need for action is urgent, because nitrate levels linked to increased health risks have been reported in water systems serving tens of millions of people across the country.”

      Nancy Stoner, senior attorney at the Environmental Law & Policy Center

      “EPA is using a report from 1962 to set the nitrate drinking water standard – 64 year-old information. It completely fails to consider the cancer risk associated with drinking nitrate-contaminated water. It is way past time for EPA to set a new standard to protect public health.”   

      Angela Blatt, senior agriculture policy manager at the Alliance for the Great Lakes 

      “Communities across the Great Lakes region are already paying the price for nitrate contamination, whether through costly drinking water treatment or higher nitrate levels in the water coming from their taps. Lowering the federal nitrate standard to 1 mg/L is an important step toward protecting public health, but treatment alone cannot be the answer. We also have to address the problem at its source by preventing excess fertilizer and manure from contaminating our water. Pollution that starts upstream creates real costs downstream, and stronger action is needed to stop shifting those costs onto communities and drinking water systems.”

      J.P. Rose, director of soil health at the Natural Resources Defense Council

      “For decades EPA has given industrial agriculture a free pass to pollute, and now one in three Americans is drinking water with dangerous levels of nitrates. Tackling agricultural pollution at the source and improving treatment will help ensure all Americans have access to safe drinking water.”

      Robert Hirschfeld, director of water policy at Prairie Rivers Network

      “Illinois, like much of the Corn Belt, has a nitrate problem driven largely by fertilizer runoff from farm fields. Research increasingly links nitrate to colorectal cancer and other health risks at levels far below today’s legal limit. That limit is based on decades-old science and gives Illinois families a false sense of security about our tap water. We need a nitrate limit that reflects the best available science.”

      Demand for stricter nitrate regulation is growing. Earlier this year, 83 groups called on EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin and Health & Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to take emergency action to protect drinking water from industrial agriculture’s nitrate pollution. 

      Advocates and communities in five states – Iowa, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Oregon and Washington – also have filed petitions for EPA emergency action to protect private well users from this same contamination.

      ###

      The Environmental Working Group is a nonprofit, non-partisan organization that empowers people to live healthier lives in a healthier environment. Through research, advocacy and unique education tools, EWG drives consumer choice and civic action. Visit www.ewg.org for more information.

      Areas of Focus Water Farming & Agriculture Midwest Current regulations leave 1 in 3 Americans at risk of cancer, birth defects and more Press Contact Alex Formuzis alex@ewg.org (202) 667-6982 November 16, 2026
      Categories: G1. Progressive Green

      Media Advisory: SUWA to Announce Next Step in the Fight to Restore Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante – 11.16.26

      Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 08:11

      November 16, 2026 – FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

      Media Advisory: SUWA to Announce Next Step in the Fight to Restore Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante – 11.16.26

      Contacts:
      Grant Stevens, Communications Director, Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance (SUWA); (319) 427-0260; grant@suwa.org

      WHAT: The Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance (SUWA) will publicly announce its next steps to restore Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monuments, which were cut by 90% in July. 

      WHEN: Tuesday, November 17, 2026, 11:00 a.m. MT

      WHERE: Utah State Capitol Rotunda, 350 N. State St., Salt Lake City

      EVENING EVENT: Media are also welcome at SUWA’s public launch celebration that evening from 6 to 8 p.m. at Red Butte Garden’s Orangerie, 300 Wakara Way. Remarks are around 7 p.m., with interview opportunities with SUWA staff and supporters. 

      Please RSVP to Grant Stevens (grant@suwa.org or 319-427-0260). 

      ###

      The Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance (SUWA) is a nonprofit organization with members and supporters from around the country dedicated to protecting America’s redrock wilderness. From offices in Moab, Salt Lake City, and Washington, DC, our team of professionals defends the redrock, organizes support for America’s Red Rock Wilderness Act, and stewards a world-renowned landscape. Learn more at www.suwa.org.

      The post Media Advisory: SUWA to Announce Next Step in the Fight to Restore Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante – 11.16.26 appeared first on Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance.

      Categories: G2. Local Greens

      Draft cover decision silent on key climate finance issues

      Demand Climate Justice - Mon, 11/16/2026 - 08:02

      For Immediate Release

      16 November, 2026

      Reacting to today’s draft cover text, Rachitaa Gupta, Global Coordinator, Global Campaign to Demand Climate Justice, said:

      “The draft cover decision skirts around the issue of climate finance without holding developed countries accountable for their obligations. The devastating floods in Nepal have shown us that Global South countries urgently need climate finance for adaptation and loss and damage. Yet Global North countries are still using every means and process possible inside COP31 to block progress on climate finance provision to the Global South. 

      On the Climate Finance Work Programme, developed countries said today they need a “no text option” and want a procedural closure, which is totally unacceptable. The cover text only “recalls” the CFWP but stays shamefully silent on its operationalisation. 

      At the same time, the draft cover text focuses mostly on adaptation finance for the Small Island Developing States and Least Developed Countries, without acknowledging the needs of the rest of the developing countries and the Global South, condemning millions if not billions of peoples in the Global South to more devastating impacts of the climate crisis induced disasters.”

      For Media Enquiries and Interview Requests:

      DCJ Comms Team at COP31

      Juliah Kibochi & Sidharth Pandey

      sidharth.dcj@gmail.com
      juliah.dcj@gmail.com
      dcj.comms@demandclimatejustice.org

      Website: https://demandclimatejustice.org

      The post Draft cover decision silent on key climate finance issues appeared first on Global Campaign to Demand Climate Justice.

      Categories: G1. Progressive Green

      Pages

      The Fine Print I:

      Disclaimer: The views expressed on this site are not the official position of the IWW (or even the IWW’s EUC) unless otherwise indicated and do not necessarily represent the views of anyone but the author’s, nor should it be assumed that any of these authors automatically support the IWW or endorse any of its positions.

      Further: the inclusion of a link on our site (other than the link to the main IWW site) does not imply endorsement by or an alliance with the IWW. These sites have been chosen by our members due to their perceived relevance to the IWW EUC and are included here for informational purposes only. If you have any suggestions or comments on any of the links included (or not included) above, please contact us.

      The Fine Print II:

      Fair Use Notice: The material on this site is provided for educational and informational purposes. It may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. It is being made available in an effort to advance the understanding of scientific, environmental, economic, social justice and human rights issues etc.

      It is believed that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have an interest in using the included information for research and educational purposes. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. The information on this site does not constitute legal or technical advice.